query_id string | query_text string | positive_document_ids list | negative_document_ids list | answer null | source string | relevances list |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
test-health-hpehwadvoee-con01a | Self-preservation is our primary moral duty Many people, especially those who belong to religious groups believe that we have a duty to preserve our own lives. They would argue that suicide is never justified, even if the reasons might appear to be good. It is impossible to sacrifice your life for others, because you ... | [
"test-health-hpehwadvoee-con01b"
] | [
"test-health-dhpelhbass-con02a",
"test-health-hpehwadvoee-pro03a",
"test-philosophy-elhbrd-pro02a",
"test-philosophy-elkosmj-pro01a",
"test-philosophy-elhbrd-con01a",
"test-health-dhpelhbass-pro01a",
"training-environment-aelmmhbahr-pro02a",
"training-law-cplghrhwrgo-pro01a",
"test-health-hpehwadvoe... | null | beir-bm25top100 | [
1
] |
test-health-dhghwapgd-pro02a | Allowing production of generic drugs saves lives, particularly in the developing world Many developing countries are fraught with terrible disease. Much of Africa and Asia are devastated by malaria, and in many parts of Africa AIDS is a horrendous scourge, infecting large percentages of many countries populations. For... | [
"test-health-dhghwapgd-pro02b"
] | [
"test-health-dhghwapgd-pro03a",
"test-health-dhghwapgd-con04a",
"test-health-dhghwapgd-pro04a",
"test-health-dhghwapgd-con03a",
"training-science-cidfiphwa-pro01a",
"test-health-dhghwapgd-con01a",
"test-health-dhghwapgd-pro01a",
"test-health-dhghwapgd-con02a",
"test-society-asfhwapg-con02b",
"test... | null | beir-bm25top100 | [
1
] |
test-health-dhghwapgd-pro05a | You cannot own an idea, and thus cannot hold patents, especially to vital drugs An individual's idea, so long as it rests solely in his mind or is kept safely hidden, belongs to him. When he disseminates it to everyone and makes it public, it becomes part of the public domain, and belongs to anyone who can use it. If ... | [
"test-health-dhghwapgd-pro05b"
] | [
"training-science-cidfiphwa-pro05a",
"test-culture-ascidfakhba-pro01a",
"test-health-dhghwapgd-con03b",
"training-science-cidfiphwa-con02b",
"test-health-dhghwapgd-con03a",
"training-science-cidfiphwa-con02a",
"test-health-dhghwapgd-con02a",
"test-health-dhghwapgd-pro03a",
"training-science-cidfiphw... | null | beir-bm25top100 | [
1
] |
test-health-dhghwapgd-pro01a | The current patent system is unjust and creates perverse incentives that benefit large pharmaceutical companies at the expense of ordinary citizens The current drug patent regime is largely designed to benefit and shield the profits of large pharmaceutical companies. This is due to the fact that most of the laws on dr... | [
"test-health-dhghwapgd-pro01b"
] | [
"test-health-dhghwapgd-con04a",
"training-science-cidfiphwa-pro01a",
"test-health-dhghwapgd-pro04a",
"test-health-dhghwapgd-pro03a",
"test-health-dhghwapgd-con03a",
"test-health-dhghwapgd-con02a",
"test-society-asfhwapg-con02b",
"test-health-dhghwapgd-pro02a",
"test-health-dhghwapgd-con02b",
"test... | null | beir-bm25top100 | [
1
] |
test-health-dhghwapgd-pro03a | Production of generic drugs reduce medical costs by allowing increased production and the development of superior production methods, increasing market efficiency The sale of generic drugs invariably reduces costs to consumers. This is due to two reasons. It may be the case that an individual or firm with a patent, es... | [
"test-health-dhghwapgd-pro03b"
] | [
"test-health-dhghwapgd-con02a",
"test-health-dhghwapgd-pro02a",
"test-health-dhghwapgd-pro04a",
"training-science-cidfiphwa-pro01a",
"test-health-dhghwapgd-con04a",
"test-health-dhghwapgd-con03a",
"test-health-dhghwapgd-pro01a",
"test-health-dhghwapgd-con04b",
"test-health-dhghwapgd-pro05a",
"test... | null | beir-bm25top100 | [
1
] |
test-health-dhghwapgd-pro04a | When generic drugs are legalized firms and individuals no longer feel the incentive to misallocate resources to the race to patent new drugs and to monitor existing patents, or to spend resources stealing from one another Patent regimes cause firms to inefficiently allocate resources. One such inefficiency arises from... | [
"test-health-dhghwapgd-pro04b"
] | [
"training-science-cidfiphwa-pro03a",
"training-science-cidfiphwa-pro05b",
"test-health-dhghwapgd-con03a",
"test-health-dhghwapgd-con04a",
"test-health-dhghwapgd-pro03a",
"test-health-dhghwapgd-pro01a",
"test-health-dhghwapgd-pro02a",
"test-health-dhghwapgd-con02a",
"test-health-dhghwapgd-con02b",
... | null | beir-bm25top100 | [
1
] |
test-health-dhghwapgd-con02a | Patent rights allow firms to more readily release their products and methods into the public domain, particularly through licensing Without patent protection, innovative and enterprising firms lacking the capacity to market successfully or efficiently produce new drugs might develop new drugs and never release them, s... | [
"test-health-dhghwapgd-con02b"
] | [
"training-science-cidfiphwa-con05a",
"test-health-dhghwapgd-con04a",
"test-health-dhghwapgd-pro03a",
"test-health-dhghwapgd-con03a",
"test-health-dhghwapgd-pro04a",
"test-health-dhghwapgd-pro05a",
"test-health-dhghwapgd-pro01a",
"training-science-cidfiphwa-con03a",
"test-health-dhghwapgd-pro02a",
... | null | beir-bm25top100 | [
1
] |
test-health-dhghwapgd-con04a | Robust drug patent laws incentivize investment of time and money in developing new products When a real chance of profit exists in the development of a new product or drug, people and firms put the effort into developing and creating them. The incentive to profit drives a great deal of people's intellectual endeavors.... | [
"test-health-dhghwapgd-con04b"
] | [
"training-science-cidfiphwa-con03a",
"test-health-dhghwapgd-pro04a",
"test-health-dhghwapgd-con03a",
"test-health-dhghwapgd-pro01a",
"test-health-dhghwapgd-con02a",
"test-health-dhghwapgd-pro03b",
"test-health-dhghwapgd-pro02a",
"test-society-asfhwapg-con02b",
"test-health-dhghwapgd-pro03a",
"trai... | null | beir-bm25top100 | [
1
] |
test-health-dhghwapgd-con03a | The product of a firm's intellectual endeavor is the property of that firm, and it deserves to profit from it When a firm directs individuals to mix their labor with its capital or other resources, part of that firm's identity inheres in the product that arises from the effort. This is the origin of, and fundamental p... | [
"test-health-dhghwapgd-con03b"
] | [
"training-science-cidfiphwa-con02a",
"test-health-dhghwapgd-pro04a",
"training-digital-freedoms-iphwclcp-con01a",
"test-health-dhghwapgd-con04a",
"test-health-dhghwapgd-pro05a",
"training-science-cidfiphwa-con03a",
"training-science-cidfiphwa-pro01a",
"test-health-dhghwapgd-con04b",
"test-health-dhg... | null | beir-bm25top100 | [
1
] |
test-health-dhghwapgd-con01a | Generic drugs often prove to be less effective than their brand name counterparts, and can even be dangerous Generic drugs are meant to retain a substantial degree of bioequivalence with their brand name predecessors. Yet, even under strict testing laws in this regard, generic drugs have on several cases been shown to... | [
"test-health-dhghwapgd-con01b"
] | [
"test-health-dhghwapgd-pro04a",
"test-health-dhghwapgd-pro02a",
"test-health-dhghwapgd-pro03a",
"test-education-egscphsrdt-pro01b",
"test-health-dhghwapgd-con04a",
"test-health-dhghwapgd-con03a",
"test-health-dhiacihwph-con02a",
"training-health-bhhghwapc-con03a",
"test-health-dhghwapgd-con02a",
"... | null | beir-bm25top100 | [
1
] |
test-health-dhghhbampt-pro02a | Although there are many accounts of the efficacy of alternative cancer treatments, not one has been demonstrated to work in a clinical trial The National Centre for Conventional and Alternative Medicines has spent over $2.5bn on research since 1992. The Dutch government funded research between 1996 and 2003. Alternati... | [
"test-health-dhghhbampt-pro02b"
] | [
"test-health-dhghhbampt-pro03a",
"test-health-dhghhbampt-pro01b",
"test-health-dhghhbampt-pro01a",
"test-health-dhghhbampt-pro03b",
"test-health-dhghhbampt-con01b",
"test-health-dhghhbampt-con02a",
"test-health-dhghhbampt-con03a",
"test-health-dhghhbampt-con03b",
"test-health-dhghhbampt-con01a",
"... | null | beir-bm25top100 | [
1
] |
test-health-dhghhbampt-pro01a | Many alternative remedies, such as homeopathy, offer nothing but a false hope and can discourage patients from consulting a doctor with what may be serious symptoms There are good reasons why new therapies are tested in scientific trials first, rather than just released on the public that it might work. The first is t... | [
"test-health-dhghhbampt-pro01b"
] | [
"test-health-dhghhbampt-pro03a",
"test-health-dhghhbampt-pro02a",
"test-health-dhghhbampt-pro03b",
"test-health-dhghhbampt-con03a",
"test-health-dhghhbampt-con03b",
"test-health-dhghhbampt-con01b",
"test-health-dhghhbampt-con02b",
"test-health-dhghhbampt-pro02b",
"test-health-dhghhbampt-con01a",
"... | null | beir-bm25top100 | [
1
] |
test-health-dhghhbampt-pro03a | Overwhelmingly alternative therapies are used in conjunction with established remedies - oddly the latter tends not to get the credit for the miracle cure Thankfully only 4.4% of the 60million or so Americans who say they use alternative therapies rely on them exclusively. It is odd that in the cases of anecdotal acco... | [
"test-health-dhghhbampt-pro03b"
] | [
"test-health-dhghhbampt-pro01a",
"test-health-dhghhbampt-pro01b",
"test-health-dhghhbampt-pro02a",
"test-health-dhghhbampt-pro02b",
"test-health-dhghhbampt-con03a",
"test-health-dhghhbampt-con03b",
"test-health-dhghhbampt-con02b",
"test-health-dhghhbampt-con01a",
"test-health-dhghhbampt-con01b",
"... | null | beir-bm25top100 | [
1
] |
test-health-dhghhbampt-con02a | The pharmaceutical and medical industries are worth billions of dollars annually. They have an interest in ignoring the efficacy of remedies that are, for the most part, free or considerably cheaper It’s understandable that the medical establishment has an interest in ignoring treatments that are freely available. Pha... | [
"test-health-dhghhbampt-con02b"
] | [
"test-health-dhghwapgd-con04a",
"training-health-dhgamvs-con03a",
"test-health-dhghwapgd-pro02a",
"training-international-gsciidfi-pro02a",
"test-health-dhghwapgd-pro01a",
"training-health-bhhghwapc-pro04a",
"training-health-bhhghwapc-pro04b",
"test-health-dhiacihwph-con01a",
"test-society-asfhwapg-... | null | beir-bm25top100 | [
1
] |
test-health-dhghhbampt-con03a | Alternative medical practitioners tend to spend more time with their patients and get a better understanding of them as a whole, as a result they are more likely to treat the person than the symptom Modern medicine tends to treat an individual symptom without putting it in the context of the whole person and so will o... | [
"test-health-dhghhbampt-con03b"
] | [
"test-health-dhghhbampt-pro01a",
"test-health-dhghhbampt-pro01b",
"validation-society-fyhwscdcj-con02a",
"test-health-dhghhbampt-pro03a",
"training-education-eghhwmvc-pro01a",
"test-health-dhghhbampt-pro03b",
"test-digital-freedoms-phwnaccpdt-pro03a",
"training-health-bhhghwapc-pro03a",
"training-he... | null | beir-bm25top100 | [
1
] |
test-health-dhghhbampt-con01a | A huge number of fully accepted medical practices started being seen as something a bit off the wall, it’s wrong to deny sick people access to a treatment that may be mainstream in 20 years There is a fine line between what is considered alternative and what is thought of as mainstream. Techniques do move across that ... | [
"test-health-dhghhbampt-con01b"
] | [
"training-health-hpessghwgt-pro02a",
"test-health-dhghhbampt-pro03a",
"training-health-bhhghwapc-pro02a",
"training-health-ahghtrpcas-pro02a",
"test-health-dhghhbampt-pro02a",
"training-health-hpessghwgt-con01a",
"test-law-phwmfri-pro03a",
"test-health-dhghhbampt-con02a",
"test-health-dhghhbampt-pro... | null | beir-bm25top100 | [
1
] |
test-health-dhpelhbass-pro02a | Those who are in the late stages of a terminal disease have a horrific future agead of them The gradual decline of their body, the failure of their organs and the need for artificial support. In some cases, the illness will slowly destroy their minds, the essence of themselves; even if this is not the case, the huge a... | [
"test-health-dhpelhbass-pro02b"
] | [
"test-health-dhpelhbass-con02b",
"test-health-dhpelhbass-con01b",
"test-health-dhpelhbass-pro01b",
"test-health-dhpelhbass-con02a",
"test-health-dhpelhbass-pro01a",
"test-health-dhpelhbass-pro03a",
"test-health-dhpelhbass-con01a",
"test-philosophy-elhbrd-pro01a",
"test-health-hpehwadvoee-pro04a",
... | null | beir-bm25top100 | [
1
] |
test-health-dhpelhbass-pro01a | Every human being has a right to life Perhaps the most basic and fundamental of all our rights. However, with every right comes a choice. The right to speech does not remove the option to remain silent; the right to vote brings with it the right to abstain. In the same way, the right to choose to die is implicit in th... | [
"test-health-dhpelhbass-pro01b"
] | [
"test-health-dhpelhbass-con01b",
"test-philosophy-elhbrd-pro01a",
"test-health-dhpelhbass-con03a",
"test-health-dhpelhbass-con02a",
"test-philosophy-elhbrd-con04a",
"test-philosophy-elhbrd-pro03a",
"test-philosophy-elhbrd-pro02a",
"test-health-dhpelhbass-con04a",
"test-health-dhpelhbass-con01a",
"... | null | beir-bm25top100 | [
1
] |
test-health-dhpelhbass-pro03a | Suicide is a lonely, desperate act, carried out in secrecy and often as a cry for help The impact on the family who remain can be catastrophic. Often because they were unaware of how their loved one was feeling. Suicide cases such as Megan Meier, an American teenager who committed suicide by hanging herself in 2006, [... | [
"test-health-dhpelhbass-pro03b"
] | [
"test-health-dhpelhbass-pro01a",
"test-health-dhpelhbass-pro01b",
"test-health-dhpelhbass-con02a",
"test-health-dhpelhbass-con01a",
"test-health-dhpelhbass-pro02a",
"test-health-dhpelhbass-con01b",
"test-philosophy-elhbrd-con04a",
"test-law-lgplhbssbco-pro02b",
"test-health-dhpelhbass-con02b",
"te... | null | beir-bm25top100 | [
1
] |
test-health-dhpelhbass-con02a | If someone is threatening to kill themselves it is your moral duty to try to stop them Those who commit suicide are not evil, and those who attempt to take their own lives are not prosecuted. However, it is your moral duty to try and prevent people from committing suicide. You would not, for example, simply ignore a m... | [
"test-health-dhpelhbass-con02b"
] | [
"test-law-lgplhbssbco-con02a",
"test-health-dhpelhbass-pro01b",
"test-health-dhpelhbass-pro01a",
"test-law-lgplhbssbco-pro03a",
"test-health-dhpelhbass-con01b",
"test-health-dhpelhbass-pro03a",
"test-law-lgplhbssbco-pro02b",
"test-health-dhpelhbass-pro02a",
"test-health-dhpelhbass-con03a",
"test-h... | null | beir-bm25top100 | [
1
] |
test-health-dhpelhbass-con04a | It would have a damaging effect on society Some people who do not agree with voluntary euthanasia argue that if it was legalised, it would damage the moral and social foundation of society by removing the traditional principle that man should not kill, and reduce the respect for human life. It might also be the case t... | [
"test-health-dhpelhbass-con04b"
] | [
"test-health-dhpelhbass-con01a",
"test-health-dhpelhbass-con03a",
"test-philosophy-elhbrd-con04a",
"test-health-dhpelhbass-pro01a",
"test-health-dhpelhbass-pro03a",
"test-philosophy-elhbrd-pro02a",
"test-health-dhpelhbass-con01b",
"test-health-hpehwadvoee-pro04a",
"test-health-dhpelhbass-con02a",
... | null | beir-bm25top100 | [
1
] |
test-health-dhpelhbass-con03a | Only God can give and take away life Life is Sacred so no one has the right to take a life, this includes ones own. As a result both suicide and assisted suicide are wrong. There are many passages within the bible that speak of the idea that God has appointed a time for all to die, 'Hebrews 9:27, “And as it is appoint... | [
"test-health-dhpelhbass-con03b"
] | [
"test-health-dhpelhbass-pro01a",
"test-philosophy-elhbrd-pro01a",
"test-health-dhpelhbass-con04a",
"training-science-gsehbehdc-con01b",
"test-health-dhpelhbass-con02a",
"test-health-dhpelhbass-con01a",
"test-philosophy-elhbrd-con01a",
"test-philosophy-elhbrd-con04a",
"test-health-dhpelhbass-con01b",... | null | beir-bm25top100 | [
1
] |
test-health-dhpelhbass-con01a | It is vital that a doctor's role not be confused The guiding principle of medical ethics is to do no harm: a physician must not be involved in deliberately harming their patient. Without this principle, the medical profession would lose a great deal of trust; and admitting that killing is an acceptable part of a docto... | [
"test-health-dhpelhbass-con01b"
] | [
"test-philosophy-elhbrd-con04a",
"test-health-dhpelhbass-pro01b",
"test-health-dhpelhbass-con04a",
"test-health-dhpelhbass-con04b",
"validation-philosophy-ehbidachsb-pro01a",
"test-health-dhpelhbass-pro03a",
"test-health-dhpelhbass-pro01a",
"test-health-dhpelhbass-pro02a",
"test-health-hpehwadvoee-c... | null | beir-bm25top100 | [
1
] |
test-sport-aastshsrqsar-pro02a | Broadening participation The talent pool in South African rugby is not as racially diverse as one would expect from the “Rainbow Nation” – some commentators have argued that England and France produce more top level black players than South Africa [1] . This is because top level players are a result of development fro... | [
"test-sport-aastshsrqsar-pro02b"
] | [
"test-sport-aastshsrqsar-pro01a",
"test-sport-aastshsrqsar-con04a",
"test-sport-aastshsrqsar-con03a",
"test-sport-aastshsrqsar-con02a",
"test-sport-aastshsrqsar-pro03a",
"test-sport-aastshsrqsar-con01a",
"test-sport-aastshsrqsar-pro01b",
"test-sport-aastshsrqsar-pro03b",
"test-sport-aastshsrqsar-con... | null | beir-bm25top100 | [
1
] |
test-sport-aastshsrqsar-pro01a | Radical action needed for racial equality in South Africa It is plain for all to see how unrepresentative rugby union in South Africa is. While there is not necessarily a deliberate policy of racism, it is very easy for biases to creep in. Across the division where the quotas will come in only about 6% of players are ... | [
"test-sport-aastshsrqsar-pro01b"
] | [
"test-sport-aastshsrqsar-con04a",
"test-sport-aastshsrqsar-con01a",
"test-sport-aastshsrqsar-pro02a",
"test-sport-aastshsrqsar-con03a",
"test-sport-aastshsrqsar-pro03a",
"test-sport-aastshsrqsar-con02a",
"test-sport-aastshsrqsar-con01b",
"test-sport-aastshsrqsar-con04b",
"test-sport-aastshsrqsar-con... | null | beir-bm25top100 | [
1
] |
test-sport-aastshsrqsar-pro03a | Most South Africans support quotas In 2006, the South African Social Attitudes Survey revealed that most South Africans (56%) support a quota system [1] . This support remained roughly the same over a four year period. Sport should reflect the will of the population of the country, if the population wants quotas then ... | [
"test-sport-aastshsrqsar-pro03b"
] | [
"test-sport-aastshsrqsar-pro01a",
"test-sport-aastshsrqsar-pro02a",
"test-sport-aastshsrqsar-con04a",
"test-sport-aastshsrqsar-con03a",
"test-sport-aastshsrqsar-con02a",
"test-sport-aastshsrqsar-con01a",
"test-sport-aastshsrqsar-pro01b",
"test-sport-aastshsrqsar-con03b",
"test-sport-aastshsrqsar-con... | null | beir-bm25top100 | [
1
] |
test-sport-aastshsrqsar-con02a | IRB rules Racial quotas are a breach of the views of the world governing body of Rugby Union, the International Rugby Board [1] . If this were found to be the case then it would have a large negative impact on South African rugby. An IRB intervention would lead to at least interference by the governing body, which wo... | [
"test-sport-aastshsrqsar-con02b"
] | [
"test-sport-aastshsrqsar-pro02a",
"test-sport-aastshsrqsar-con04a",
"test-sport-aastshsrqsar-pro01a",
"test-sport-aastshsrqsar-pro03a",
"test-sport-aastshsrqsar-con03a",
"test-sport-aastshsrqsar-pro01b",
"test-sport-aastshsrqsar-pro03b",
"test-sport-aastshsrqsar-con01a",
"test-sport-aastshsrqsar-con... | null | beir-bm25top100 | [
1
] |
test-sport-aastshsrqsar-con04a | Racial quotas don’t develop new players The quota system could lead to moving players from the regional teams who generally have less non-white players pilfering them from other unions, rather “Home growing” them [1] . Former Springboks coach Peter de Villiers, the first non-white person in that role, has described q... | [
"test-sport-aastshsrqsar-con04b"
] | [
"test-sport-aastshsrqsar-con01a",
"test-sport-aastshsrqsar-pro01a",
"test-sport-aastshsrqsar-pro02a",
"test-sport-aastshsrqsar-con03a",
"test-sport-aastshsrqsar-pro03a",
"test-sport-aastshsrqsar-con02a",
"test-sport-aastshsrqsar-pro01b",
"test-sport-aastshsrqsar-pro03b",
"test-sport-aastshsrqsar-con... | null | beir-bm25top100 | [
1
] |
test-sport-aastshsrqsar-con03a | Quotas can drive players away. Policies of racial quotas can have the effect of driving players abroad. Such policies have had similar affects in cricket. Kevin Pietersen stated that racial quotas in domestic competition, requiring four non-white players per team, were a key reason for his decision to leave South Afri... | [
"test-sport-aastshsrqsar-con03b"
] | [
"test-sport-aastshsrqsar-con04a",
"test-sport-aastshsrqsar-pro01a",
"test-sport-aastshsrqsar-pro02a",
"test-sport-aastshsrqsar-con01a",
"test-sport-aastshsrqsar-pro03a",
"test-sport-aastshsrqsar-con02a",
"test-sport-aastshsrqsar-pro01b",
"test-sport-aastshsrqsar-con01b",
"test-sport-aastshsrqsar-con... | null | beir-bm25top100 | [
1
] |
test-sport-aastshsrqsar-con01a | Meritocracy It is a value of sport in general that it should be outside the sphere of social ills like racial, religious and political tensions. Sport should be based on merit only; those who play best get onto the team. Racial quotas will lead to any non-white player in a team in a competition where quotas are being... | [
"test-sport-aastshsrqsar-con01b"
] | [
"test-sport-aastshsrqsar-con04a",
"test-sport-aastshsrqsar-pro01a",
"test-sport-aastshsrqsar-pro02a",
"test-sport-aastshsrqsar-con03a",
"test-sport-aastshsrqsar-pro01b",
"test-sport-aastshsrqsar-pro03a",
"test-sport-aastshsrqsar-con02a",
"test-sport-aastshsrqsar-con02b",
"test-sport-aastshsrqsar-pro... | null | beir-bm25top100 | [
1
] |
test-sport-otshwbe2uuyt-pro02a | Boycotting Euro 2012 will highlight Ukraine’s backsliding on human rights European leaders must take a stand on human rights in their own back yard if they are to be taken seriously on the issue anywhere in the world. There are numerous human rights abuses in Ukraine; migrants "risk abusive treatment and arbitrary det... | [
"test-sport-otshwbe2uuyt-pro02b"
] | [
"test-sport-otshwbe2uuyt-pro01a",
"test-sport-otshwbe2uuyt-con02a",
"test-sport-otshwbe2uuyt-pro03a",
"test-sport-otshwbe2uuyt-con04a",
"test-sport-otshwbe2uuyt-con01a",
"test-sport-otshwbe2uuyt-con03a",
"test-international-emephsate-con02a",
"test-international-emephsate-con02b",
"test-sport-otshwb... | null | beir-bm25top100 | [
1
] |
test-sport-otshwbe2uuyt-pro01a | Europe must not give approval to this regime. Viktor Yanukovych fairly came to power in 2010 however since then he has set about attacking the country’s fragile democracy. There are numerous cases showing this democratic decline. For example changes to the constitution that occurred after the Orange revolution have be... | [] | [
"test-sport-otshwbe2uuyt-pro02a",
"test-sport-otshwbe2uuyt-con05a",
"test-international-emephsate-con02a",
"test-sport-otshwbe2uuyt-con03a",
"test-international-emephsate-con02b",
"test-sport-otshwbe2uuyt-con02a",
"training-politics-oamepdgtwh-con01a",
"test-politics-cdmaggpdgdf-con04a",
"test-sport... | null | beir-bm25top100 | [] |
test-sport-otshwbe2uuyt-pro03a | Boycotting Euro 2012 is proportional Diplomacy is necessary with any regime almost no matter how oppressive they are however that does not show approval of a regime to the world in the way that high profile visits and events can. Just as the Beijing Olympics were the People’s Republic of China’s coming out party so Eu... | [
"test-sport-otshwbe2uuyt-pro03b"
] | [
"test-sport-otshwbe2uuyt-con03a",
"test-sport-otshwbe2uuyt-con02a",
"test-sport-otshwbe2uuyt-con04a",
"test-sport-otshwbe2uuyt-pro02b",
"test-sport-otshwbe2uuyt-con01a",
"test-sport-otshwbe2uuyt-pro02a",
"test-sport-otshwbe2uuyt-con04b",
"test-sport-otshwbe2uuyt-con05b",
"test-sport-otshwbe2uuyt-pro... | null | beir-bm25top100 | [
1
] |
test-sport-otshwbe2uuyt-con02a | A boycott won’t help resolve the issues at question European leaders need to consider whether their methods are likely to achieve the result they want. What Europe’s leaders want is first of all Yulia Timoshenko released and secondly improvements in Ukrainian human rights. Timoshenko is unlikely to be released as she ... | [
"test-sport-otshwbe2uuyt-con02b"
] | [
"test-sport-otshwbe2uuyt-con03a",
"test-sport-otshwbe2uuyt-con04a",
"test-sport-otshwbe2uuyt-pro03a",
"test-sport-otshwbe2uuyt-con01a",
"test-sport-otshwbe2uuyt-pro02b",
"test-sport-otshwbe2uuyt-pro02a",
"test-sport-otshwbe2uuyt-con05b",
"test-sport-otshwbe2uuyt-pro01a",
"test-sport-otshwbe2uuyt-con... | null | beir-bm25top100 | [
1
] |
test-sport-otshwbe2uuyt-con05a | Europe needs to prevent Russian influence in Ukraine If Europe shuns Ukraine then Yanukovych has an obvious alternative he can turn to; Russia. Putin, the newly re-elected President of Russia, is holding out the option of a customs union with Ukraine which Yanukovych despite initially rejecting [1] is now showing more... | [
"test-sport-otshwbe2uuyt-con05b"
] | [
"test-sport-otshwbe2uuyt-con03a",
"test-sport-otshwbe2uuyt-pro01a",
"training-international-ehbesefe-pro04a",
"training-international-epdhwenmga-pro01a",
"test-sport-otshwbe2uuyt-pro03a",
"training-international-egilpwhbrh-pro04a",
"training-international-egilpwhbrh-con03a",
"training-international-ep... | null | beir-bm25top100 | [
1
] |
test-sport-otshwbe2uuyt-con04a | Boycotts did not take place for the 2008 Olympics despite the far worst human rights background It would be hypocritical for European leaders to boycott the Euro 2012 finals because of Ukraine’s recent human rights record. It an absurd overreaction when the focus is on the poor treatment of one woman, Timoshenko. Coun... | [
"test-sport-otshwbe2uuyt-con04b"
] | [
"test-sport-otshwbe2uuyt-con02a",
"test-sport-otshwbe2uuyt-pro03a",
"test-sport-otshwbe2uuyt-con03a",
"test-sport-ybfgsohbhog-pro03b",
"test-sport-otshwbe2uuyt-con01a",
"test-sport-otshwbe2uuyt-pro02b",
"test-sport-otshwbe2uuyt-pro02a",
"test-sport-otshwbe2uuyt-con05a",
"test-sport-otshwbe2uuyt-pro0... | null | beir-bm25top100 | [
1
] |
test-sport-otshwbe2uuyt-con03a | The boycott would affect Poland and the Ukrainian people as well as Yanukovych A boycott of Euro 2012 even if it was meant to be limited to Ukraine would negatively impact on the whole tournament. Polish Prime Minister Donald Tust argued "It is in Poland's undisputed interest to hold the games in Poland and Ukraine wi... | [
"test-sport-otshwbe2uuyt-con03b"
] | [
"test-sport-otshwbe2uuyt-con02a",
"test-sport-otshwbe2uuyt-pro03a",
"test-sport-otshwbe2uuyt-con05b",
"test-sport-otshwbe2uuyt-con01a",
"test-sport-otshwbe2uuyt-con04a",
"test-sport-otshwbe2uuyt-con05a",
"test-sport-otshwbe2uuyt-pro01a",
"test-sport-otshwbe2uuyt-pro02a",
"test-sport-otshwbe2uuyt-pro... | null | beir-bm25top100 | [
1
] |
test-sport-otshwbe2uuyt-con01a | This is a sports event not a political event Sport and politics are separate and should be kept separate. This is the position of the organisers “Uefa has no position and will not take any regarding the political situation in Ukraine, and will not interfere with internal government matters.” [1] Euro 2012 is a footbal... | [
"test-sport-otshwbe2uuyt-con01b"
] | [
"test-sport-otshwbe2uuyt-con03a",
"test-sport-otshwbe2uuyt-pro03a",
"test-sport-otshwbe2uuyt-con04a",
"test-sport-otshwbe2uuyt-con02a",
"test-sport-otshwbe2uuyt-pro02a",
"test-sport-otshwbe2uuyt-con04b",
"test-sport-otshwbe2uuyt-pro02b",
"test-sport-otshwbe2uuyt-pro03b",
"test-sport-otshwbe2uuyt-con... | null | beir-bm25top100 | [
1
] |
test-sport-ybfgsohbhog-pro02a | Hosting stimulates regeneration in local areas Hosting stimulates regeneration. The IOC is enthusiastic about bids that will leave a lasting impact and have looked favourably on cities that locate their Olympic Villages and stadia in deprived areas in need of regeneration. The 1992 Barcelona Olympics were used as a me... | [
"test-sport-ybfgsohbhog-pro02b"
] | [
"test-sport-ybfgsohbhog-con01a",
"test-sport-ybfgsohbhog-pro03a",
"test-sport-ybfgsohbhog-con03a",
"test-sport-ybfgsohbhog-pro04b",
"test-sport-ybfgsohbhog-con03b",
"test-sport-ybfgsohbhog-con02a",
"validation-free-speech-debate-fchbcuilre-con03a",
"test-sport-ybfgsohbhog-pro01b",
"test-sport-ybfgso... | null | beir-bm25top100 | [
1
] |
test-sport-ybfgsohbhog-pro01a | Hosting creates a 'feel-good' factor Hosting creates a 'feel-good factor'. It is hard to put a price on the buzz that surrounds international sporting events. Think of Paris during the World Football Cup in 1998 or Sydney during the 2002 Olympics. Even sporting success abroad can unite a nation (for example the Englan... | [
"test-sport-ybfgsohbhog-pro01b"
] | [
"test-sport-ybfgsohbhog-pro04a",
"test-sport-ybfgsohbhog-con03a",
"test-sport-ybfgsohbhog-con01a",
"test-sport-ybfgsohbhog-con01b",
"test-sport-ybfgsohbhog-pro02a",
"test-sport-ybfgsohbhog-pro04b",
"test-sport-ybfgsohbhog-pro03a",
"test-sport-ybfgsohbhog-con02b",
"test-sport-ybfgsohbhog-pro02b",
"... | null | beir-bm25top100 | [
1
] |
test-sport-ybfgsohbhog-pro03a | COUNTERPOINT Any large expenditure in one area will stimulate regeneration. Considering that the cost of hosting the London 2012 Olympics is predicted at £2.375 billion, expected to rise far higher, regeneration is the least that can be expected as a le The Olympics are a showcase. Hosting the Olympics can be a way of... | [
"test-sport-ybfgsohbhog-pro03b"
] | [
"test-sport-ybfgsohbhog-pro02b",
"test-sport-ybfgsohbhog-con01a",
"test-sport-ybfgsohbhog-pro02a",
"test-sport-ybfgsohbhog-con03a",
"test-sport-ybfgsohbhog-pro04a",
"test-sport-ybfgsohbhog-con03b",
"test-sport-otshwbe2uuyt-con02a",
"test-sport-ybfgsohbhog-pro01b",
"validation-free-speech-debate-fchb... | null | beir-bm25top100 | [
1
] |
test-sport-ybfgsohbhog-pro04a | Hosting has wide-reaching economic benefits Hosting creates an economic boost. Whilst none of the Olympics of recent times have made an immediate profit, the cost of the regeneration and improved infrastructure means that this is not a big problem as long as the losses are not huge. The Olympics showcases the host nat... | [
"test-sport-ybfgsohbhog-pro04b"
] | [
"test-sport-ybfgsohbhog-con03a",
"test-sport-ybfgsohbhog-pro01a",
"test-sport-ybfgsohbhog-con01a",
"test-sport-ybfgsohbhog-pro03a",
"test-sport-ybfgsohbhog-pro02a",
"test-sport-ybfgsohbhog-con03b",
"test-sport-ybfgsohbhog-pro01b",
"validation-free-speech-debate-fchbcuilre-con03a",
"test-sport-ybfgso... | null | beir-bm25top100 | [
1
] |
test-sport-ybfgsohbhog-con02a | The bidding process is too long, tying up funds and land The bidding process takes too long. Bidding officially takes only two years (unless a city fails to make the shortlist), but most cities spend nearly a decade working on their bids. Obviously the bidding process costs money but it also ties up the land needed fo... | [
"test-sport-ybfgsohbhog-con02b"
] | [
"test-sport-ybfgsohbhog-pro02a",
"test-sport-ybfgsohbhog-con03a",
"test-sport-ybfgsohbhog-con01a",
"training-sport-tshwm2fwcw-con01a",
"test-sport-ybfgsohbhog-pro03a",
"test-sport-ybfgsohbhog-pro01a",
"validation-free-speech-debate-fchbcuilre-con03a",
"test-sport-ybfgsohbhog-pro01b",
"training-econo... | null | beir-bm25top100 | [
1
] |
test-sport-ybfgsohbhog-con03a | Hosting is very expensive Hosting is very expensive. In recent times the Olympics have never made a direct profit. The bidding process alone for 2012 will cost each bidding city around £20m and whichever is selected will expect to pay at least £6.5bn (Paris). With increased security fears Athens spent $1.5bn on securi... | [
"test-sport-ybfgsohbhog-con03b"
] | [
"test-sport-ybfgsohbhog-pro02a",
"test-sport-ybfgsohbhog-con01a",
"test-sport-ybfgsohbhog-pro03a",
"test-sport-ybfgsohbhog-pro04a",
"test-sport-ybfgsohbhog-pro02b",
"test-sport-ybfgsohbhog-pro04b",
"test-sport-ybfgsohbhog-pro01a",
"training-economy-epsosghbsas-con02a",
"test-sport-ybfgsohbhog-con02a... | null | beir-bm25top100 | [
1
] |
test-sport-ybfgsohbhog-con01a | Hosting only affects one city In large countries like the United States or China, the benefits of the Olympics are almost entirely focused on the host city. Even in smaller countries, the benefits of a event played outside the host city or a training camp are negligible. Capital cities are often chosen (after failed b... | [
"test-sport-ybfgsohbhog-con01b"
] | [
"test-sport-ybfgsohbhog-pro02b",
"test-sport-ybfgsohbhog-pro02a",
"test-sport-ybfgsohbhog-con03b",
"test-sport-ybfgsohbhog-pro01b",
"test-sport-ybfgsohbhog-pro03a",
"test-sport-ybfgsohbhog-pro04b",
"test-sport-ybfgsohbhog-con03a",
"test-sport-ybfgsohbhog-pro01a",
"validation-free-speech-debate-fchbc... | null | beir-bm25top100 | [
1
] |
test-sport-tshbmlbscac-pro02a | Collisions are a part of the game. First, collisions are part of the tradition of baseball. They have been part of the game for a very long time. Fans, players, and managers all expect home plate hits to occur from time to time. “Some things are part of the game. There’s not a whole lot you can do,” said Red Sox catch... | [
"test-sport-tshbmlbscac-pro02b"
] | [
"test-sport-tshbmlbscac-con01a",
"test-sport-tshbmlbscac-pro03a",
"test-sport-tshbmlbscac-pro04a",
"test-sport-tshbmlbscac-con04a",
"test-sport-tshbmlbscac-con04b",
"test-sport-tshbmlbscac-con01b",
"test-sport-tshbmlbscac-con02b",
"test-sport-tshbmlbscac-con02a",
"test-sport-tshbmlbscac-pro03b",
"... | null | beir-bm25top100 | [
1
] |
test-sport-tshbmlbscac-pro01a | Collisions are exciting and fun to watch. Baseball is a form of entertainment, and few plays are as entertaining as bang-bang plays (a close call on whether the runner is thrown out) at the plate. As a sport that’s often criticized for being too slow and boring—“baseball has no clock,” the saying goes [1] —it’s import... | [
"test-sport-tshbmlbscac-pro01b"
] | [
"test-sport-tshbmlbscac-con03a",
"test-sport-tshbmlbscac-con01a",
"test-sport-tshbmlbscac-pro02a",
"test-sport-tshbmlbscac-pro02b",
"test-sport-tshbmlbscac-pro03a",
"test-sport-tshbmlbscac-pro04a",
"test-sport-tshbmlbscac-con01b",
"test-sport-tshbmlbscac-con02a",
"test-sport-tshbmlbscac-pro03b",
"... | null | beir-bm25top100 | [
1
] |
test-sport-tshbmlbscac-pro03a | Collisions are not as dangerous as they’re feared to be. Some hits lead to injury, but the vast majority do not. One commentator challenged proponents of a rule change “to name as many as five MLB catchers in the last 30 years who have had their careers ended or shortened as a result of a home plate collision. Persona... | [
"test-sport-tshbmlbscac-pro03b"
] | [
"test-sport-tshbmlbscac-pro02a",
"test-sport-tshbmlbscac-con01a",
"test-sport-tshbmlbscac-con01b",
"test-sport-tshbmlbscac-pro04a",
"test-sport-tshbmlbscac-pro02b",
"test-sport-tshbmlbscac-con04a",
"test-sport-tshbmlbscac-pro01a",
"test-sport-tshbmlbscac-con04b",
"test-sport-tshbmlbscac-pro01b",
"... | null | beir-bm25top100 | [
1
] |
test-sport-tshbmlbscac-pro04a | Without collisions, either the catcher or the runner would have an enormous and unfair advantage. There are two often-discussed ways to change the rules: require the runner to slide, just as they must do when attempting to reach other bases; or disallow catchers to block runners’ paths. Each results in an imbalance be... | [
"test-sport-tshbmlbscac-pro04b"
] | [
"test-sport-tshbmlbscac-con03a",
"test-sport-tshbmlbscac-con01a",
"test-sport-tshbmlbscac-pro02a",
"test-sport-tshbmlbscac-pro02b",
"test-sport-tshbmlbscac-pro01a",
"test-sport-tshbmlbscac-pro03a",
"test-sport-tshbmlbscac-con01b",
"test-sport-tshbmlbscac-pro03b",
"test-sport-tshbmlbscac-con04b",
"... | null | beir-bm25top100 | [
1
] |
test-sport-tshbmlbscac-con02a | Collisions are an example of violence that has no place in baseball. Baseball is not a contact sport. It is not a sport that is supposed to rely on violence. This is one commentator’s point: “if you want to watch violent collisions, you can watch [American] football. Or hockey. Or MMA. There’s no reason baseball needs... | [
"test-sport-tshbmlbscac-con02b"
] | [
"test-sport-tshbmlbscac-pro02a",
"test-sport-tshbmlbscac-pro01a",
"test-sport-tshbmlbscac-con03a",
"test-sport-tshbmlbscac-pro01b",
"test-sport-tshbmlbscac-pro03a",
"test-sport-tshbmlbscac-con01a",
"test-sport-tshbmlbscac-pro02b",
"test-sport-tshbmlbscac-pro04a",
"test-sport-tshbmlbscac-con03b",
"... | null | beir-bm25top100 | [
1
] |
test-sport-tshbmlbscac-con04a | Collisions heighten antagonisms. When someone gets hurt in a collision at the plate, the injured player’s teammates are more likely to hold a grudge—and to try to get even. There are numerous opportunities to do that, whether by aiming a pitch at that player, or by seeking another opportunity to hurt him. When Posey w... | [
"test-sport-tshbmlbscac-con04b"
] | [
"test-sport-tshbmlbscac-pro02a",
"test-sport-tshbmlbscac-con01a",
"test-sport-tshbmlbscac-pro03a",
"test-sport-tshbmlbscac-pro02b",
"test-sport-tshbmlbscac-con01b",
"test-sport-tshbmlbscac-pro03b",
"test-sport-tshbmlbscac-pro01a",
"test-sport-tshbmlbscac-pro04a",
"training-sport-tshbirsbumlb-pro03a"... | null | beir-bm25top100 | [
1
] |
test-sport-tshbmlbscac-con03a | Collisions are unnecessary. Baseball doesn’t need collisions. By requiring the runner to slide, just as they must do when attempting to reach other bases, or disallowing catchers to block runners’ paths, or—best of all—requiring both those steps, baseball can eliminate collisions. Unlike in football or rugby, hits at... | [
"test-sport-tshbmlbscac-con03b"
] | [
"test-sport-tshbmlbscac-pro04a",
"test-sport-tshbmlbscac-pro01a",
"test-sport-tshbmlbscac-pro02b",
"test-sport-tshbmlbscac-con01a",
"test-sport-tshbmlbscac-pro02a",
"test-sport-tshbmlbscac-con02a",
"test-sport-tshbmlbscac-con01b",
"test-sport-tshbmlbscac-pro03b",
"test-sport-tshbmlbscac-pro03a",
"... | null | beir-bm25top100 | [
1
] |
test-sport-tshbmlbscac-con01a | Collisions are dangerous and lead to injury. Ray Fosse and Buster Posey (mentioned above in the Introduction) are just two examples of players who suffered major injuries in crashes at home plate. Texas Rangers star Josh Hamilton, reigning Most Valuable Player of the American League, broke his arm when he collided wit... | [
"test-sport-tshbmlbscac-con01b"
] | [
"test-sport-tshbmlbscac-pro02a",
"test-sport-tshbmlbscac-con04b",
"test-sport-tshbmlbscac-pro03a",
"test-sport-tshbmlbscac-pro04a",
"test-sport-tshbmlbscac-pro03b",
"test-sport-tshbmlbscac-con04a",
"test-sport-tshbmlbscac-pro02b",
"test-sport-tshbmlbscac-pro01a",
"test-sport-tshbmlbscac-pro01b",
"... | null | beir-bm25top100 | [
1
] |
test-free-speech-debate-magghbcrg-pro02a | Radio is cheap to produce and easily accessible. Community radio relies on the power of its ideas and the thirst for those ideas among its audience. It accepts the notion that it is the exchange of information and views, freely given and received, that is more important than the ideas themselves. It doesn’t require m... | [
"test-free-speech-debate-magghbcrg-pro02b"
] | [
"test-free-speech-debate-magghbcrg-con01a",
"test-free-speech-debate-magghbcrg-pro03a",
"test-free-speech-debate-magghbcrg-con02a",
"test-free-speech-debate-magghbcrg-con03a",
"test-free-speech-debate-magghbcrg-pro01a",
"test-free-speech-debate-magghbcrg-con03b",
"test-free-speech-debate-magghbcrg-pro01... | null | beir-bm25top100 | [
1
] |
test-free-speech-debate-magghbcrg-pro01a | Community radio gives voices to the people rather than imposing those of the powerful. The events of the Arab Spring (and previous events such as the revolutions of 1989) have shown that effective means of communicating are vital. In a country where people have heard only one perspective, anything that can break the m... | [
"test-free-speech-debate-magghbcrg-pro01b"
] | [
"test-free-speech-debate-magghbcrg-pro03a",
"test-free-speech-debate-magghbcrg-con01a",
"test-free-speech-debate-magghbcrg-con03a",
"test-free-speech-debate-magghbcrg-pro02a",
"test-free-speech-debate-magghbcrg-con02a",
"test-free-speech-debate-magghbcrg-con03b",
"test-free-speech-debate-magghbcrg-con01... | null | beir-bm25top100 | [
1
] |
test-free-speech-debate-magghbcrg-pro03a | Community radio evens the playing field against state and corporate broadcasters. Autocracy has, at its root, the premise that only one perspective, or group of perspectives is legitimate. Certain assumptions are unquestionable, certain rules inviolable and, more often than not, certain voices unchallengeable. It’s a... | [
"test-free-speech-debate-magghbcrg-pro03b"
] | [
"test-free-speech-debate-magghbcrg-pro01a",
"test-free-speech-debate-magghbcrg-pro02a",
"test-free-speech-debate-magghbcrg-con01a",
"test-free-speech-debate-magghbcrg-con02a",
"test-free-speech-debate-magghbcrg-con03a",
"test-free-speech-debate-magghbcrg-con03b",
"test-free-speech-debate-magghbcrg-con01... | null | beir-bm25top100 | [
1
] |
test-free-speech-debate-magghbcrg-con02a | Radio is yesterday’s technology. Proposition is right to point out the role that has traditionally been filled by relatively small scale radio – providing a relatively cheap method of getting in touch with anybody willing to listen. However, that has, effectively, been rendered redundant by Internet technology. The po... | [
"test-free-speech-debate-magghbcrg-con02b"
] | [
"test-free-speech-debate-magghbcrg-con01a",
"test-free-speech-debate-magghbcrg-pro03a",
"test-free-speech-debate-magghbcrg-pro02a",
"test-free-speech-debate-magghbcrg-con03a",
"test-science-cpisydfphwj-pro03b",
"test-society-cpisydfphwj-pro03b",
"test-free-speech-debate-magghbcrg-pro01a",
"test-scienc... | null | beir-bm25top100 | [
1
] |
test-free-speech-debate-magghbcrg-con03a | Community radio is just a platform, there is nothing innately democratic about it. To associate a medium with a particular virtue is missing the point. Radio has been used for atrocity and tyranny (Rwanda would be an obvious example) just as much as the promotion and development of democracy. Equally the suggestion th... | [
"test-free-speech-debate-magghbcrg-con03b"
] | [
"test-free-speech-debate-magghbcrg-con01a",
"test-free-speech-debate-magghbcrg-pro01a",
"test-free-speech-debate-magghbcrg-pro03a",
"test-free-speech-debate-magghbcrg-con02a",
"test-free-speech-debate-magghbcrg-pro02a",
"test-free-speech-debate-magghbcrg-con01b",
"test-free-speech-debate-magghbcrg-pro01... | null | beir-bm25top100 | [
1
] |
test-free-speech-debate-magghbcrg-con01a | Community radio just gives a megaphone to extremists. Experience suggests that the airwaves, unregulated, tend to attract pedagogues seeking followers more than democrats seeking the views of others. Particularly in areas of high sectarian divisions, technologies that propagate the views of every mullah with a mic are... | [
"test-free-speech-debate-magghbcrg-con01b"
] | [
"test-free-speech-debate-magghbcrg-pro02a",
"test-free-speech-debate-magghbcrg-pro01a",
"test-free-speech-debate-magghbcrg-con03a",
"test-free-speech-debate-magghbcrg-con02a",
"test-free-speech-debate-magghbcrg-pro03a",
"test-free-speech-debate-magghbcrg-pro02b",
"test-free-speech-debate-magghbcrg-pro01... | null | beir-bm25top100 | [
1
] |
test-free-speech-debate-nshbbsbfb-pro02a | Many people find the views expressed by much of the church offensive, those views are given airtime, a public service broadcaster should provide a level playing field for ideas. The role of a public service broadcaster, especially one of the stature of the BBC, is to provide a portal for ideas from all perspectives. T... | [
"test-free-speech-debate-nshbbsbfb-pro02b"
] | [
"test-free-speech-debate-nshbbsbfb-pro04a",
"test-free-speech-debate-nshbbsbfb-pro03a",
"test-free-speech-debate-nshbbsbfb-pro01a",
"test-free-speech-debate-nshbbsbfb-con01a",
"test-free-speech-debate-ldhwprhs-pro01a",
"validation-free-speech-debate-nshwcb-con01a",
"test-free-speech-debate-nshbbsbfb-con... | null | beir-bm25top100 | [
1
] |
test-free-speech-debate-nshbbsbfb-pro01a | This was a piece of art, advertised and described as such, those likely to be offended were quite welcome not to watch it. The allegation made by those who objected to the airing of this show was that it was blasphemous. There were also objections to the graphic nature of the language and sexual reference. It seems st... | [
"test-free-speech-debate-nshbbsbfb-pro01b"
] | [
"test-free-speech-debate-nshbbsbfb-con03a",
"test-culture-thbcsbptwhht-pro01a",
"test-culture-thbcsbptwhht-pro02a",
"test-culture-thbcsbptwhht-con03a",
"test-culture-thbcsbptwhht-pro03a",
"test-culture-thbcsbptwhht-con01a",
"test-free-speech-debate-nshbbsbfb-con02a",
"test-free-speech-debate-nshbbsbfb... | null | beir-bm25top100 | [
1
] |
test-free-speech-debate-nshbbsbfb-pro03a | There is a duty for a broadcaster that is not dependent on either commercial or state funding to give a platform to controversial works of art. The BBC is in an unusual position, simply because of its funding structure, to promote new or challenging works of art. The licence fee means that it is freed of many of the p... | [
"test-free-speech-debate-nshbbsbfb-pro03b"
] | [
"test-free-speech-debate-nshbbsbfb-pro01a",
"test-free-speech-debate-nshbbsbfb-con03b",
"test-free-speech-debate-nshbbsbfb-con02a",
"test-free-speech-debate-nshbbsbfb-pro02a",
"test-free-speech-debate-nshbbsbfb-pro02b",
"test-free-speech-debate-nshbbsbfb-con01a",
"test-free-speech-debate-nshbbsbfb-con03... | null | beir-bm25top100 | [
1
] |
test-free-speech-debate-nshbbsbfb-pro04a | It is simply impractical for a major international broadcaster to hand out powers of veto to small sectional interests. The BBC would quickly be left with a content either devoid of interest or of content were it to allow such a veto to become normative. Especially were it, as appears to be the case here, to offer suc... | [] | [
"test-free-speech-debate-nshbbsbfb-pro01a",
"test-free-speech-debate-nshbbsbfb-pro02a",
"test-free-speech-debate-nshbbsbfb-con03a",
"test-free-speech-debate-nshbbsbfb-con03b",
"test-free-speech-debate-nshbbsbfb-con01a",
"test-free-speech-debate-nshbbsbfb-pro03a",
"training-free-speech-debate-nvhbfemir-p... | null | beir-bm25top100 | [] |
test-free-speech-debate-nshbbsbfb-con02a | Tens of thousands of licence fee payers objected to this, ultimately they are the BBC’s key stakeholder and that view is worthy of respect. As an institution, the BBC may like to position itself as a global media brand but that doesn’t alter the fact that it is funded by, and chartered to serve, the British population... | [
"test-free-speech-debate-nshbbsbfb-con02b"
] | [
"test-free-speech-debate-nshbbsbfb-pro02b",
"test-free-speech-debate-nshbbsbfb-pro01a",
"test-free-speech-debate-nshbbsbfb-pro03a",
"test-free-speech-debate-nshbbsbfb-pro03b",
"test-free-speech-debate-nshbbsbfb-con03a",
"test-free-speech-debate-nshbbsbfb-con01a",
"test-free-speech-debate-nshbbsbfb-con03... | null | beir-bm25top100 | [
1
] |
test-free-speech-debate-nshbbsbfb-con03a | Why should those who foot the bill have chunks of airtime from which they are, effectively, excluded. How can it be okay for a broadcaster, funded by a compulsory levy on anyone who owns a television, to willingly produce programmes they know will cause offence to that consumer? The charge of blasphemy is far more th... | [
"test-free-speech-debate-nshbbsbfb-con03b"
] | [
"test-free-speech-debate-nshbbsbfb-pro01a",
"test-free-speech-debate-nshbbsbfb-pro04a",
"test-free-speech-debate-nshbbsbfb-con01a",
"test-free-speech-debate-nshbbsbfb-pro03b",
"test-free-speech-debate-nshbbsbfb-pro01b",
"test-free-speech-debate-nshbbsbfb-con02a",
"training-culture-cgmmcthbrt-con03a",
... | null | beir-bm25top100 | [
1
] |
test-free-speech-debate-nshbbsbfb-con01a | If this work had been an attack on Mohammed it would never have been broadcast, the BBC is applying double standards. A week before the broadcast of the opera, protest by Sikhs in Birmingham about the play Bezthi by the Birmingham Rep, brought the show to a close. Like many organisations, the BBC panics when it believ... | [
"test-free-speech-debate-nshbbsbfb-con01b"
] | [
"test-free-speech-debate-nshbbsbfb-con03a",
"test-free-speech-debate-nshbbsbfb-pro01a",
"test-free-speech-debate-nshbbsbfb-con02a",
"test-free-speech-debate-nshbbsbfb-pro02b",
"test-free-speech-debate-nshbcsbawc-pro02a",
"test-free-speech-debate-nshbbsbfb-pro02a",
"test-free-speech-debate-nshbbsbfb-pro0... | null | beir-bm25top100 | [
1
] |
test-free-speech-debate-fsaphgiap-pro02a | The people are interested in the health of their leader The health of the leader of the state is an issue that the people and the media inevitably want to know about. There will always be a lot of interest in it. Occasionally this can be played by the administration as with Kissinger saying he was ill and using time t... | [
"test-free-speech-debate-fsaphgiap-pro02b"
] | [
"test-free-speech-debate-fsaphgiap-pro01a",
"test-free-speech-debate-fsaphgiap-pro04a",
"test-free-speech-debate-fsaphgiap-con01a",
"test-free-speech-debate-fsaphgiap-pro03b",
"test-politics-cdfsaphgiap-pro03b",
"test-politics-cdfsaphgiap-pro02b",
"training-digital-freedoms-phbplpfsbop-pro03a",
"train... | null | beir-bm25top100 | [
1
] |
test-free-speech-debate-fsaphgiap-pro01a | The head of state/government must be accountable to the people Secrecy in relation to the leader’s health shows a distrust or distain of the electorate. Not being open about health issues almost invariably means that the administration is lying to those who elected them, those who they are accountable to. A couple of ... | [] | [
"test-free-speech-debate-fsaphgiap-pro02a",
"test-free-speech-debate-fsaphgiap-pro04a",
"test-free-speech-debate-fsaphgiap-pro03b",
"test-politics-cdfsaphgiap-pro03b",
"training-politics-pgghwbnap-pro04a",
"training-education-eghhwmvc-pro02b",
"test-politics-lghwdecm-pro02a",
"training-health-bhhgwtny... | null | beir-bm25top100 | [] |
test-free-speech-debate-fsaphgiap-pro03a | Transparency allows citizens to choose for a healthy leader as to ensure proper functioning The health and fitness of a leader is a vital issue when choosing a leader; the electorate deserves to know if they are likely to serve out their term. When health conditions are hidden from the people they may mistakenly elect... | [
"test-free-speech-debate-fsaphgiap-pro03b"
] | [
"validation-politics-glvhwetleb-con01a",
"validation-politics-glvhwetleb-pro03a",
"test-politics-cdfsaphgiap-pro03b",
"test-free-speech-debate-fsaphgiap-con01a",
"validation-politics-glvhwetleb-con03a",
"test-free-speech-debate-fsaphgiap-con01b",
"test-politics-cdfsaphgiap-con01b",
"validation-politic... | null | beir-bm25top100 | [
1
] |
test-free-speech-debate-fsaphgiap-pro04a | A lack of transparency can endanger the leader A person is most likely to survive when they have an accident, a heart attack, or some other condition if they get prompt treatment and doctors are aware of any underlying conditions. Mills may well have lived, or lived longer if there had been more transparency about his... | [] | [
"test-free-speech-debate-fsaphgiap-pro02a",
"test-politics-cdmaggpdgdf-con05a",
"training-health-bhhghwapc-pro02a",
"test-law-cplgpshwdp-pro01a",
"test-politics-cdmaggpdgdf-pro05b",
"training-environment-achbessbp-con02a",
"training-philosophy-epwhbuabaha-pro01b",
"test-free-speech-debate-radhbsshr-pr... | null | beir-bm25top100 | [] |
test-free-speech-debate-fsaphgiap-con02a | Rivals could misuse the opportunity While the leader suffers from an illness, rivals can use the opportunity to ease the leader out of office. A period of illness is a period of vulnerability in which the government is less able to respond to external and internal threats. Not telling the public about the leader's hea... | [
"test-free-speech-debate-fsaphgiap-con02b"
] | [
"test-free-speech-debate-fsaphgiap-con01a",
"test-politics-cdfsaphgiap-con02b",
"training-international-alcphbgbsnl-pro01a",
"validation-politics-glvhwetleb-pro01a",
"test-free-speech-debate-fsaphgiap-con03b",
"test-politics-cdfsaphgiap-con03b",
"validation-politics-glvhwetleb-con03a",
"validation-law... | null | beir-bm25top100 | [
1
] |
test-free-speech-debate-fsaphgiap-con04a | Damages diplomacy to be too open Diplomacy can be very personal; diplomatic initiatives are often the result of a single person, and the individual leader is necessary to conclude negotiations. Transparency about a leader's health may therefore prevent deals being done; Nixon went to China despite Mao's ill heath mean... | [
"test-free-speech-debate-fsaphgiap-con04b"
] | [
"test-politics-cdfsaphgiap-con04b",
"test-free-speech-debate-fsaphgiap-pro02a",
"test-free-speech-debate-fsaphgiap-con03a",
"test-politics-cdmaggpdgdf-con03a",
"training-international-ahwvys-pro01a",
"test-culture-thbcsbptwhht-con03a",
"test-free-speech-debate-fsaphgiap-con01a",
"training-society-gfyh... | null | beir-bm25top100 | [
1
] |
test-free-speech-debate-fsaphgiap-con03a | Markets like stability Business and the markets prize political stability. Clearly when the leader of a country is ill this stability is damaged but the damage can be mitigated by being transparent. The markets will want to know how ill the leader is, and that the succession is secure so that they know what the future... | [
"test-free-speech-debate-fsaphgiap-con03b"
] | [
"validation-politics-glvhwetleb-con03a",
"test-free-speech-debate-fsaphgiap-con01a",
"test-politics-oepghbrnsl-con03b",
"test-politics-cdmaggpdgdf-con04a",
"training-economy-epsfhwpusss-con02a",
"test-free-speech-debate-fsaphgiap-con04a",
"test-free-speech-debate-yfsdfkhbwu-pro02a",
"test-internationa... | null | beir-bm25top100 | [
1
] |
test-free-speech-debate-fsaphgiap-con01a | Denial of privacy to the leaders The leaders of states deserve privacy in exactly the same way as anyone else. Just like their citizens leaders want and deserve privacy and it would be unfair for everyone to know about their health. Leaders may suffer from diseases such AIDS/HIV or embarrassing illnesses which could d... | [
"test-free-speech-debate-fsaphgiap-con01b"
] | [
"test-politics-cdfsaphgiap-con01b",
"test-free-speech-debate-fsaphgiap-con02a",
"test-free-speech-debate-fsaphgiap-pro03a",
"test-free-speech-debate-fsaphgiap-pro02a",
"test-free-speech-debate-fsaphgiap-con03a",
"test-free-speech-debate-fsaphgiap-con02b",
"test-politics-cdfsaphgiap-con02b",
"test-free... | null | beir-bm25top100 | [
1
] |
test-free-speech-debate-yfsdfkhbwu-pro02a | A bargaining chip In much the same way that material investment in countries can be used as a bargaining chip to secure improvements in areas of legislation, so cultural investment can be used to secure rights associated with related fields of endeavour. Free speech is merely the most obvious. It is reasonable for a w... | [
"test-free-speech-debate-yfsdfkhbwu-pro02b"
] | [
"test-free-speech-debate-yfsdfkhbwu-pro03a",
"test-free-speech-debate-yfsdfkhbwu-pro01a",
"test-free-speech-debate-yfsdfkhbwu-con01a",
"test-free-speech-debate-yfsdfkhbwu-con02a",
"test-education-ufsdfkhbwu-pro03b",
"test-free-speech-debate-yfsdfkhbwu-pro03b",
"training-free-speech-debate-fchbnhampi-con... | null | beir-bm25top100 | [
1
] |
test-free-speech-debate-yfsdfkhbwu-pro01a | The academic tradition of the West The growth of universities as beacons of free speech has been a fundamental part of their history in the West; notably during the renaissance, reformation and enlightenment. The democratisation of that process with the expansion of the university sector in recent decades is merely th... | [
"test-free-speech-debate-yfsdfkhbwu-pro01b"
] | [
"test-free-speech-debate-yfsdfkhbwu-pro02a",
"test-free-speech-debate-yfsdfkhbwu-con03a",
"test-free-speech-debate-yfsdfkhbwu-con02a",
"test-free-speech-debate-yfsdfkhbwu-pro03a",
"test-education-ufsdfkhbwu-pro03b",
"test-free-speech-debate-yfsdfkhbwu-con01a",
"test-free-speech-debate-yfsdfkhbwu-pro03b"... | null | beir-bm25top100 | [
1
] |
test-free-speech-debate-yfsdfkhbwu-pro03a | Maintaining the value of the degree Employers and others expect certain degrees to mean certain things; they are more than just an expensive badge. In the case of elite western universities part of what that means is a critical approach to the world and the willingness to challenge ideas, regardless of the authority t... | [
"test-free-speech-debate-yfsdfkhbwu-pro03b"
] | [
"test-free-speech-debate-yfsdfkhbwu-pro02a",
"test-free-speech-debate-yfsdfkhbwu-con03a",
"test-education-ufsdfkhbwu-pro03b",
"test-free-speech-debate-yfsdfkhbwu-pro01a",
"test-free-speech-debate-yfsdfkhbwu-con01a",
"test-free-speech-debate-yfsdfkhbwu-con02a",
"training-culture-aeuhbdcaal-pro01a",
"tr... | null | beir-bm25top100 | [
1
] |
test-free-speech-debate-yfsdfkhbwu-con02a | ‘Separation of town and gown’ There are two parties involved in this interaction, the state and the university. To pretend that is an entirely one way process is to ignore reality. Contrary to the belief of many Senior Common Rooms, states do not exist for the convenience of universities. Indeed universities quite hap... | [] | [
"test-free-speech-debate-yfsdfkhbwu-con03a",
"test-education-udfakusma-con03b",
"test-education-ughbuesbf-pro01a",
"test-education-udfakusma-pro02a",
"test-education-pteuhwfphe-con03a",
"test-free-speech-debate-yfsdfkhbwu-pro02a",
"test-education-udfakusma-pro04a",
"test-free-speech-debate-yfsdfkhbwu-... | null | beir-bm25top100 | [] |
test-free-speech-debate-yfsdfkhbwu-con03a | Universities should exchange ideas not impose them Of all possible institutions, for a university to suggest that it is not open to defending its ideas rather than insisting that they be artificially imported seems counter-intuitive. As Asian and European intellectual traditions increasingly interact as a result of ec... | [] | [
"test-free-speech-debate-yfsdfkhbwu-pro03a",
"test-free-speech-debate-yfsdfkhbwu-con02a",
"test-free-speech-debate-yfsdfkhbwu-pro01a",
"test-education-udfakusma-con03a",
"training-education-udfakhwst-pro01a",
"test-education-udfakusma-con03b",
"test-free-speech-debate-yfsdfkhbwu-con01a",
"training-edu... | null | beir-bm25top100 | [] |
test-free-speech-debate-yfsdfkhbwu-con01a | Argument One: Contact leads to the dissemination of values There is certainly some evidence to suggest the view that trade with a country can benefit human rights as increased wealth provides many with more choice and better standards of living. [i] Certainly that argument has been made by governments and multi-nation... | [] | [
"training-international-ghbssbupd-con03a",
"training-international-seighweo-con01b",
"training-international-gsciidfi-con01a",
"test-politics-cdmaggpdgdf-con04a",
"test-free-speech-debate-ldhwbmclg-con03a",
"test-free-speech-debate-yfsdfkhbwu-pro03a",
"test-culture-tlhrilsfhwr-pro02a",
"test-philosoph... | null | beir-bm25top100 | [] |
test-free-speech-debate-ldhwbmclg-pro02a | Hate speech The enforcement of the laws proposed in this article will be fraught, complex and difficult. However, the difficulty of administering a law is never a good argument for refusing to enforce it. The censorship of the written word ended in England with the Lady Chatterley and Oz obscenity trials, but this li... | [
"test-free-speech-debate-ldhwbmclg-pro02b"
] | [
"test-free-speech-debate-ldhwbmclg-pro01a",
"test-free-speech-debate-ldhwbmclg-con03a",
"test-free-speech-debate-ldhwbmclg-pro03a",
"test-free-speech-debate-ldhwbmclg-con03b",
"test-free-speech-debate-ldhwbmclg-pro01b",
"test-free-speech-debate-ldhwprhs-pro02a",
"test-free-speech-debate-ldhwbmclg-con02b... | null | beir-bm25top100 | [
1
] |
test-free-speech-debate-ldhwbmclg-pro01a | Classification, not censorship We should expect fans of an art form that is subjected to public criticism and vilification to leap to its defence. Some of these aficionados- whether the medium in question is cinema, fine art or pop music- make the case for the value of their favourite mode of expression by overstating... | [
"test-free-speech-debate-ldhwbmclg-pro01b"
] | [
"test-free-speech-debate-ldhwbmclg-pro03a",
"test-free-speech-debate-ldhwbmclg-con03a",
"test-free-speech-debate-ldhwbmclg-con02a",
"test-free-speech-debate-ldhwbmclg-pro02a",
"test-free-speech-debate-ldhwbmclg-con01a",
"test-free-speech-debate-ldhwbmclg-pro02b",
"test-free-speech-debate-ldhwbmclg-con02... | null | beir-bm25top100 | [
1
] |
test-free-speech-debate-ldhwbmclg-pro03a | Defending hip hop artists’ right to free speech The intervention of the state is necessary in order to ensure that aggressive forms of hip hop remain accessible only to adults, especially in neighbourhoods and home environments that are not part of a cohesive, caring community. Some degree of public control over the c... | [
"test-free-speech-debate-ldhwbmclg-pro03b"
] | [
"test-free-speech-debate-ldhwbmclg-pro01a",
"test-free-speech-debate-ldhwbmclg-con01b",
"test-free-speech-debate-ldhwbmclg-con03a",
"test-free-speech-debate-ldhwbmclg-pro01b",
"test-free-speech-debate-ldhwbmclg-pro02a",
"test-free-speech-debate-ldhwbmclg-pro02b",
"test-free-speech-debate-ldhwbmclg-con01... | null | beir-bm25top100 | [
1
] |
test-free-speech-debate-ldhwbmclg-con02a | A ban will be ineffective A new legal prohibition on any type of behaviour or conduct can only be set up by investing large amounts of political capital in order to transform vague proposals into a legislative document and then into a fully-fledged law. This expense can only be justified if the ban is effective – if i... | [
"test-free-speech-debate-ldhwbmclg-con02b"
] | [
"test-free-speech-debate-ldhwbmclg-pro01a",
"test-free-speech-debate-ldhwbmclg-con01a",
"test-free-speech-debate-ldhwbmclg-pro03a",
"test-free-speech-debate-ldhwbmclg-con03a",
"test-free-speech-debate-ldhwbmclg-pro02b",
"test-free-speech-debate-ldhwbmclg-con03b",
"test-free-speech-debate-ldhwbmclg-pro01... | null | beir-bm25top100 | [
1
] |
test-free-speech-debate-ldhwbmclg-con03a | A ban will further marginalise young members of impoverished communities Hip hop is an extremely diverse musical genre. Surprisingly, this diversity has evolved from highly minimal series of musical principles. At its most basic, raping consists of nothing more than rhyming verses that are delivered to a beat. This si... | [
"test-free-speech-debate-ldhwbmclg-con03b"
] | [
"test-free-speech-debate-ldhwbmclg-pro01a",
"test-free-speech-debate-ldhwbmclg-pro03a",
"test-free-speech-debate-ldhwbmclg-pro01b",
"test-free-speech-debate-ldhwbmclg-pro02a",
"test-free-speech-debate-ldhwbmclg-pro02b",
"test-free-speech-debate-ldhwbmclg-con01a",
"test-free-speech-debate-ldhwbmclg-con01... | null | beir-bm25top100 | [
1
] |
test-free-speech-debate-ldhwbmclg-con01a | Violent imagery can serve different purposes. Calls for a ban on music that references or glorifies violence are frequently based on an overly simplistic understanding of contemporary and popular musical genres. It is instructive that the loudest voices of protest raised against violent content in hip hop and rock mus... | [
"test-free-speech-debate-ldhwbmclg-con01b"
] | [
"test-free-speech-debate-ldhwbmclg-pro02b",
"test-free-speech-debate-ldhwbmclg-pro01a",
"test-free-speech-debate-ldhwbmclg-con03a",
"test-free-speech-debate-ldhwbmclg-pro03a",
"test-free-speech-debate-ldhwbmclg-con02a",
"test-free-speech-debate-ldhwbmclg-pro01b",
"test-free-speech-debate-ldhwbmclg-con02... | null | beir-bm25top100 | [
1
] |
test-free-speech-debate-ldhwprhs-pro02a | Because religion promotes certainty of belief, divinely inspired hatred is easy to use to justify and promote violent actions and discriminatory practices. Free speech must come second when there is the potential for that speech to cause harm. The mantra of “With God on our side” has been used, and continues to be use... | [
"test-free-speech-debate-ldhwprhs-pro02b"
] | [
"validation-free-speech-debate-nshwcb-pro01a",
"test-free-speech-debate-ldhwprhs-pro01a",
"test-free-speech-debate-ldhwbmclg-pro02a",
"validation-free-speech-debate-nshwcb-pro02a",
"validation-free-speech-debate-bphwpbsas-pro02a",
"test-free-speech-debate-ldhwprhs-con02a",
"training-culture-amcghbmgvaw-... | null | beir-bm25top100 | [
1
] |
test-free-speech-debate-ldhwprhs-pro01a | Religion simply justifies reactionary views which many find offensive. There is no reason for vitriol to be tolerated just because it presents a mask of religion. Views on issues such as abortion, women, and what constitutes an acceptable family expressed by those who are extremely religious are simply bigoted views w... | [
"test-free-speech-debate-ldhwprhs-pro01b"
] | [
"test-free-speech-debate-ldhwprhs-pro03a",
"training-free-speech-debate-nvhbfemir-pro01a",
"test-free-speech-debate-nshbbsbfb-pro02a",
"test-international-bldimehbn-pro02b",
"test-free-speech-debate-ldhwprhs-con01a",
"test-free-speech-debate-ldhwprhs-con03a",
"validation-free-speech-debate-nshwcb-con02a... | null | beir-bm25top100 | [
1
] |
test-free-speech-debate-ldhwprhs-pro03a | Ill-informed prejudice has no place in society. The veneer of religion has been used to justify hatred, prejudice and division and should be confronted. Homophobia is the last respectable prejudice [1] and should be tackled with the same passion and force that others have been, and continue to be, confronted. If the s... | [
"test-free-speech-debate-ldhwprhs-pro03b"
] | [
"test-free-speech-debate-ldhwprhs-pro01a",
"training-free-speech-debate-nvhbfemir-pro01a",
"training-religion-fmshbrdmhg-pro01a",
"test-religion-frghbbgi-pro04a",
"test-free-speech-debate-ldhwprhs-pro02a",
"training-religion-fmshbrdmhg-pro01b",
"training-free-speech-debate-ldigrrg-pro03b",
"test-free-... | null | beir-bm25top100 | [
1
] |
test-free-speech-debate-ldhwprhs-con02a | There is no right not to be offended, enforcing what is acceptable to be thought or said places far too much power in the hands of the state. It is impossible to ensure that nobody is ever offended and it is questionable as to whether it is even desirable [1] . There is simply no way of protecting against offence. The... | [] | [
"training-free-speech-debate-esdbphwlfsr-con02b",
"validation-free-speech-debate-bphwpbsas-con03a",
"training-free-speech-debate-nvhbfemir-con01a",
"training-health-sshwnasso-pro01a",
"test-law-cppshbcjsfm-pro01a",
"test-law-cplgpshwdp-pro01a",
"test-law-cppshbcjsfm-pro02a",
"test-free-speech-debate-n... | null | beir-bm25top100 | [] |
test-free-speech-debate-ldhwprhs-con03a | Silencing views that are considered offensive is self-defeating and would be detrimental to those attempting to advance gay rights. If freedom of speech is to mean anything then it needs to be a principle that is universally applied. Unless speech represents a direct and immediate threat to public safety then it shoul... | [] | [
"test-free-speech-debate-ldhwprhs-pro01a",
"test-free-speech-debate-ldhwprhs-con02a",
"validation-society-gihbsosbcg-pro01a",
"test-free-speech-debate-radhbsshr-pro02a",
"test-international-bldimehbn-pro02a",
"test-free-speech-debate-ldhwprhs-con01a",
"test-law-sdiflhrdffe-con02b",
"training-free-spee... | null | beir-bm25top100 | [] |
test-free-speech-debate-ldhwprhs-con01a | Regardless of the views expressed, freedom of speech means that all opinions should be heard. Allowing politicians to regulate what it is acceptable to say – or think – is not something that has a happy history. This isn’t the result of a purely intellectual construct but one of altruistic self-interest; once people s... | [] | [
"test-free-speech-debate-ldhwbmclg-con03a",
"test-free-speech-debate-nshbcsbawc-pro04a",
"training-free-speech-debate-nvhbfemir-pro01a",
"test-philosophy-elhbrd-pro01a",
"validation-free-speech-debate-bphwpbsas-con03a",
"training-health-ahwba-con01a",
"training-free-speech-debate-nvhbfemir-con01a",
"t... | null | beir-bm25top100 | [] |
test-free-speech-debate-radhbsshr-pro02a | Pluralism and Political Interference The removal of ‘The Spear’ from the Goodman Gallery and the City Press also hints at a threat to pluralism, especially when one considers the political nature of the campaign to have such images removed. While Jacob Zuma attempted to have the image banned in a personal capacity, t... | [
"test-free-speech-debate-radhbsshr-pro02b"
] | [
"test-free-speech-debate-radhbsshr-pro03a",
"test-free-speech-debate-radhbsshr-pro01a",
"test-free-speech-debate-radhbsshr-con02a",
"test-free-speech-debate-radhbsshr-pro01b",
"test-free-speech-debate-radhbsshr-con01b",
"test-free-speech-debate-radhbsshr-con03a",
"test-free-speech-debate-radhbsshr-con01... | null | beir-bm25top100 | [
1
] |
test-free-speech-debate-radhbsshr-pro01a | Artistic Freedom A core principle of art is that it should be free from any form of inhibition, as the particular artwork is an expression of the particular views and ideals of the artist. The subject matter in many instances is their own choice; therefore they have the right to say what they want about the subject ma... | [
"test-free-speech-debate-radhbsshr-pro01b"
] | [
"test-free-speech-debate-radhbsshr-pro03a",
"test-free-speech-debate-radhbsshr-pro02a",
"test-free-speech-debate-radhbsshr-pro03b",
"test-free-speech-debate-radhbsshr-con01b",
"test-free-speech-debate-radhbsshr-con03a",
"test-free-speech-debate-radhbsshr-con02a",
"test-free-speech-debate-radhbsshr-pro02... | null | beir-bm25top100 | [
1
] |
test-free-speech-debate-radhbsshr-pro03a | Racialised Opposition Some critics of ‘The Spear’ have criticised the artwork on the grounds that it ‘dehumanises’ black people in general [1] and President Zuma in particular and criticises him based upon his personal life rather than policy, using vulgar means to do it. This line of opposition is part of a dog-whist... | [
"test-free-speech-debate-radhbsshr-pro03b"
] | [
"test-free-speech-debate-radhbsshr-pro01a",
"test-free-speech-debate-radhbsshr-pro02a",
"test-free-speech-debate-radhbsshr-pro02b",
"test-free-speech-debate-radhbsshr-con02a",
"test-free-speech-debate-radhbsshr-con01b",
"test-free-speech-debate-radhbsshr-con02b",
"test-free-speech-debate-radhbsshr-pro01... | null | beir-bm25top100 | [
1
] |
test-free-speech-debate-radhbsshr-con02a | Infantilisation and Prejudice Those who dismiss the reaction to ‘The Spear’ forget the historical context which may trigger the sorts of responses seen to the artwork. [1] South Africa’s past problems can be seen to derive from the gross caricaturing of Black people and Black Men in particular as lascivious, overtly ... | [
"test-free-speech-debate-radhbsshr-con02b"
] | [
"test-free-speech-debate-radhbsshr-pro03a",
"test-free-speech-debate-radhbsshr-pro03b",
"test-free-speech-debate-radhbsshr-pro01a",
"test-free-speech-debate-radhbsshr-pro02a",
"test-free-speech-debate-radhbsshr-pro02b",
"test-free-speech-debate-radhbsshr-pro01b",
"validation-free-speech-debate-nshwcb-co... | null | beir-bm25top100 | [
1
] |
test-free-speech-debate-radhbsshr-con04a | Masculinity The problem with leaving the painting, the spear, up is that to many young men President Zuma symbolises what excessive wealth can ‘buy’ you. He is the figure head of the nation, the pinnacle of capitalism and masculinity, of which the penis and sex are instrumental in this image. By leaving the painting u... | [
"test-free-speech-debate-radhbsshr-con04b"
] | [
"test-free-speech-debate-radhbsshr-pro01b",
"test-free-speech-debate-radhbsshr-pro01a",
"test-free-speech-debate-radhbsshr-con01a",
"test-culture-mmctghwbsa-pro01a",
"test-free-speech-debate-radhbsshr-con03a",
"test-free-speech-debate-ldhwbmclg-pro01a",
"training-culture-amcghbmgvaw-con03a",
"training... | null | beir-bm25top100 | [
1
] |
test-free-speech-debate-radhbsshr-con03a | Public Decency Freedom of Speech is something that is highly valued, particularly in a country such as South Africa, where it was in short supply for a large part of its history, but surely for such speech to be worthwhile, it has to be able to convey a message that actually enriches the public domain. Such messages c... | [
"test-free-speech-debate-radhbsshr-con03b"
] | [
"test-free-speech-debate-radhbsshr-con01a",
"test-free-speech-debate-radhbsshr-pro02a",
"test-free-speech-debate-radhbsshr-pro03a",
"test-free-speech-debate-radhbsshr-pro01a",
"test-free-speech-debate-radhbsshr-pro01b",
"test-free-speech-debate-radhbsshr-pro02b",
"test-free-speech-debate-radhbsshr-con02... | null | beir-bm25top100 | [
1
] |
test-free-speech-debate-radhbsshr-con01a | Defamation While South African Law does allow for freedom of speech, and the constitution is one of the most liberal in the world for protecting such freedoms, it must be measured against the need for responsibility in the use of such freedoms to prevent offence. Whatever one believes about ‘The Spear’ it is clear th... | [
"test-free-speech-debate-radhbsshr-con01b"
] | [
"test-free-speech-debate-radhbsshr-con03a",
"test-free-speech-debate-radhbsshr-pro02b",
"test-free-speech-debate-radhbsshr-pro03a",
"test-free-speech-debate-radhbsshr-pro01b",
"test-free-speech-debate-radhbsshr-pro01a",
"test-free-speech-debate-radhbsshr-pro02a",
"test-free-speech-debate-radhbsshr-con03... | null | beir-bm25top100 | [
1
] |
test-free-speech-debate-fchbjaj-pro02a | Governments have always struggled with the idea of press investigation and freedom of information, claiming Assange is not a journalist is simply a stunt. We know that most governments struggle with the idea of not having control over information and are suspicious of the media. In a pre-Internet age working with a ha... | [
"test-free-speech-debate-fchbjaj-pro02b"
] | [
"test-free-speech-debate-fchbjaj-pro01a",
"test-free-speech-debate-fchbjaj-pro03a",
"test-free-speech-debate-fchbjaj-con03b",
"test-free-speech-debate-fchbjaj-con02a",
"test-free-speech-debate-fchbjaj-con01b",
"test-free-speech-debate-fchbjaj-con03a",
"test-free-speech-debate-fchbjaj-con01a",
"test-fr... | null | beir-bm25top100 | [
1
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.