syn-pdfQA/01.1_Input_Files_Non_PDF/research articles/2510.23080v1.tex

\documentclass[twocolumn,english,aps,prd,reprint,floatfix,notitlepage,footinbib,preprintnumbers,superscriptaddress,altaffilletter]{revtex4-2}

\usepackage{amsmath,amssymb,amsfonts}
\usepackage{hyperref,breakurl,cleveref,url}
\usepackage{color}

\usepackage{graphicx}
\usepackage[export]{adjustbox}

%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
% AUTHORS' MACROS BEGIN HERE
% 

%%%%%%%%%%_ LEVEL 0 _%%%%%%%%%%

%%%%% Math Packages %%%%%
\usepackage{accents,mathrsfs,mathtools}

%%%%% Formatting %%%%%
\renewcommand{\paragraph}[1]{%
	\textit{#1}.---%
}

\def\skip{\vskip1.5pt}
\newcommand\trick[1]{}
%\protect\trick.

\usepackage{enumitem}
\setlist[enumerate]{
	label={},
	leftmargin=2em,
	itemsep=2pt,
	topsep= 2pt,
	partopsep=0pt,
	parsep=0pt,
}

%%%%% Referencing %%%%%
\let\oldeqref\eqref
\renewcommand{\eqref}[1]{Eq.\,\smash{\oldeqref{#1}}}
\newcommand{\eqrefs}[2]{Eqs.\,\smash{\oldeqref{#1}} and \smash{\oldeqref{#2}}}

\newcommand{\rcite}[1]{Ref.\,\cite{#1}}
\newcommand{\rrcite}[1]{Refs.\,\cite{#1}}

\newcommand{\fref}[1]{Fig.\,\ref{#1}}

\newcommand{\App}[1]{Appendix~\ref{#1}}

\def\JHK{{J.-H.\,K. }}

%%%%%%%%%%_ LEVEL 1 _%%%%%%%%%%

%%%%% MathOperators %%%%%
\def\Re{{\operatorname{Re}}}
\def\Im{{\operatorname{Im}}}
\DeclareMathOperator{\sinc}{sinc}
\DeclareMathOperator{\sinhc}{sinhc}
\DeclareMathOperator{\Exp}{Exp}
\DeclareMathOperator{\diag}{diag}

%%%%% Abbreviations, spacings %%%%%
\def\mem{\hspace{0.1em}}
\def\hem{\hspace{0.05em}}
\def\nem{\hspace{-0.1em}}
\def\hnem{\hspace{-0.05em}}
\def\hhem{\hspace{0.025em}}
\def\hhnem{\hspace{-0.025em}}
\def\hhhem{\hspace{0.0125em}}
\def\hhhnem{\hspace{-0.0125em}}
\def\ssnem{\hspace{-0.031em}}
\def\blank{{\,\,\,\,\,}}

%%%%% Abbreviations, implies %%%%%
\def\qiq{{\quad\implies\quad}}
\def\iq{{{\implies}\quad}}

%%%%% Symbols, greek %%%%%
\def\a{\alpha}
\def\b{\beta}
\def\c{{\gamma}}
\def\d{{\delta}}
\def\e{\epsilon}
\def\ve{\varepsilon}
\def\m{\mu}
\def\n{\nu}
\def\r{\rho}
\def\s{\sigma}
\def\k{\kappa}
\def\l{\lambda}
\def\t{\tau}

%%%%% Symbols, barred greek %%%%%
\def\bpsi{\bar{\psi}}

%%%%% Symbols, alphabetical %%%%%
\def\bQ{\bar{Q}}

%%%%% Symbols, spacings adjusted %%%%%
\def\mtimes{{\mem\times\mem}}
\def\mdot{{\mem\cdot\mem}}

%%%%%%%%%%_ LEVEL 2 _%%%%%%%%%%

%%%%% Macros, Big Brackets %%%%%

\newcommand{\BB}[1]{\Big(\,{#1}\,\Big)}
\newcommand{\bb}[1]{\bigg(\,{#1}\,\bigg)}
\newcommand{\bigbig}[1]{\big(\mem{#1}\mem\big)}
\newcommand{\pr}[1]{(\mem{#1}\mem)}

\newcommand{\bbsq}[1]{\bigg[\,{#1}\,\bigg]}

%%%%% Indices %%%%%
\def\da{{\dot{\a}}}
\def\db{{\dot{\b}}}
\def\dc{{\dot{\c}}}
\def\dd{{\dot{\d}}}

%%%%% Spinors %%%%%
% \def\tdo{\widetilde{o}}
% \def\ti{\widetilde{\iota}}
\def\tdo{\tilde{o}}
\def\ti{\tilde{\iota}}

\newcommand{\wrap}[1]{{\smash{#1}\vphantom{\beta}}}

%%%%% Spinor brackets %%%%%
\def\lsq{{
		\kern-0.037em
		\adjustbox{scale=0.919,valign=c}{$
			{
				\adjustbox{raise=-0.0855em}{$\lfloor$}
				\llap{\reflectbox{\rotatebox[origin=c]{180}{$\lfloor$}}}
			}
			$}
		\kern-0.04em
}}
\def\rsq{{
		\kern-0.04em
		\adjustbox{scale=0.919,valign=c}{$
			{
				\rlap{\reflectbox{\rotatebox[origin=c]{180}{$\rfloor$}}} 
				\adjustbox{raise=-0.0855em}{$\rfloor$}
			}
			$}
		\kern-0.037em
}}

%%%%% This paper %%%%%
\def\vex{\vec{x}}
\def\vea{\vec{a}}

\def\txi{{\protect\tilde{\xi}}}
\def\tzeta{{\protect\tilde{\zeta}}}
\def\tpi{{\protect\tilde{\pi}}}

\def\tz{{\tilde{z}}}

\def\tm{{\tilde{m}}}
\def\tZ{\smash{\tilde{Z}}}

\def\tchi{\tilde{\chi}}
\def\te{\tilde{\epsilon}}

\def\tell{\smash{\tilde{\ell}}}
\def\trho{\smash{\tilde{\rho}}}
\def\ttheta{\smash{\tilde{\theta}}}
\def\teta{\smash{\tilde{\eta}}}

\def\rstar{{r}}
\def\rprol{{\tilde{r}}}

\def\zag{}
\def\zig{}

\def\tQ{{\smash{\widetilde{Q}}}}
\def\tM{{\smash{\widetilde{M}}}}

\usepackage{hyphenat}
\hyphenation{Schwarz-schild}

\usepackage{lipsum}









\usepackage{simpler-wick}

\newcommand{\Jac}[1]{\mathrm{Jac}\hem\big(\hem{#1}\hem\big)}

%\def\lb{\{\nem\{}
%\def\rb{\}\nem\}}
\def\lb{\{\kern-0.15em\{}
\def\rb{\}\kern-0.15em\}}

\newcommand{\pb}[2]{\{\hem{#1},{#2}\hem\}}
\newcommand{\dpb}[2]{\lb\hem{#1},{#2}\hem\rb}
\newcommand{\tpb}[2]{\{\nem\lb\hem{#1},{#2}\hem\rb\nem\}}

\newcommand{\comm}[2]{[\hem{#1},{#2}\hem]}

\def\R{\mathbb{R}}
\def\g{\mathfrak{g}}
\def\su{\mathfrak{su}}
\def\diff{\mathfrak{diff}}
\def\SU{\mathrm{SU}}
\def\GL{\mathrm{GL}}

\def\Nc{{N_\text{c}}}

\def\tphi{\tilde{\phi}}

\def\P{\mathcal{P}}
\def\Aflat{\mathbb{A}}
\def\A{\mathcal{A}}

\def\can{{\text{can}}}
\def\cov{{\adjustbox{raise=-0.06em,scale=0.85}{${}_\nabla$}}}

\def\YM{{\text{YM}}}

\def\O{\mathcal{O}}
\def\N{\mathcal{N}}

\def\M{\mathcal{M}}


%%%%% Symbols, spacings adjusted %%%%%
 \def\mwedge{{\mem\wedge\mem\hhem}}
\def\swedge{{\mem{\wedge}\,}}
% \def\edge{{\hhhem\mem\wedge\mem}}
\def\mtimes{{\mem\times\mem}}
\def\mdot{{\mem\cdot\mem}}
\def\mt{{\mem\times}}
\def\md{{\mem\cdot}}

\def\modot{{\mem\odot\mem}}
\def\mtensor{{\mem\otimes\mem}}
\def\mplus{{\mem+\mem}}
\def\mcdots{{\mem\cdots\mem}}
\def\mminus{{\mem-\mem}}

\def\mlra{{\mem\leftrightarrow\mem}}

\def\tensor\otimes

\def\bplus{{\,+\,}}


%%%%% TikZ %%%%%
\usepackage{tikz}
\usetikzlibrary{calc} % to use relative coordinates
\usetikzlibrary{shapes.geometric} % to draw regular polygons
\usetikzlibrary{positioning} % to use right=of 
\usetikzlibrary{fit} % for fit size
\usepackage[a]{esvect} % arrow styling %f
\tikzset{empty/.style = {inner sep = 0pt, outer sep = 0, minimum size = 0}}
\tikzset{b/.style = {inner sep = 2pt, outer sep = 4pt, minimum size = 12pt}}
\tikzset{w/.style = {inner sep = 1pt, outer sep = 2pt, minimum size = 12pt, anchor = west}}
\usepackage[export]{adjustbox}
\tikzset{every node/.style = {inner sep = 0pt, outer sep = 0, minimum size = 0}}
%\tikzset{every path/.style = {draw, line width = 1.2pt}}

\tikzset{dot/.style = {circle, draw=black, fill=black, inner sep=0pt, outer sep=0pt, minimum size=2.5pt, line width=1.2pt}}

\definecolor{lgray}{RGB}{150,150,150}
\tikzset{
	dprop/.style = {
		draw, line width=0.8pt,
		dotted, 
		line cap=round,
		dash pattern=on 0pt off 2.53pt,
		color=lgray
	}
}

\tikzset{l/.style = {draw, line width = 1.2pt}}

\tikzset{s/.style = {inner sep = 2.5pt, outer sep =2.5pt, minimum size = 1pt, font = \small}}


%%%%% Formatting, colored texts %%%%%
% 
\newcommand{\hla}[1]{{\color[RGB]{0,110,160}{}#1}}
\newcommand{\hlb}[1]{{\color[RGB]{0,40,210}{}#1}}
%\newcommand{\hlc}[1]{{\color[RGB]{0,150,190}{}#1}}
\newcommand{\hlc}[1]{{\color[RGB]{0,145,225}{}#1}}

%\newcommand{\hld}[1]{{\color[RGB]{135,125,40}{}#1}}
\newcommand{\hld}[1]{{\color[RGB]{130,100,40}{}#1}}

%\newcommand{\hlg}[1]{{\color[RGB]{10,175,25}{}#1}}
\newcommand{\hlg}[1]{{\color[RGB]{2,145,15}{}#1}}
\newcommand{\hlG}[1]{{\color[RGB]{10,110,10}{}#1}}

\newcommand{\hlx}[1]{{\color[RGB]{220,10,10}{}#1}}
\newcommand{\hly}[1]{{\color[RGB]{220,100,0}{}#1}}
\newcommand{\hlz}[1]{{\color[RGB]{195,145,0}{}#1}}
                             
                            
\definecolor{guides}{RGB}{143,153,173}

\newcommand{\cont}[4]{{\color{guides}\small%
	\text{\quad\, from \quad}
		\bigg\{
		\begin{aligned}[c]
			#1 &\text{---} #2
			\\[-0.4\baselineskip]
			#3 &\text{---} #4
		\end{aligned} 
		\bigg\}
	\,,
}}
\newcommand{\contd}[4]{{\color{guides}\small%
	\text{\quad\, from \quad} 
		\bigg\{
		\begin{aligned}[c]
			#1 &\text{---} #2
			\\[-0.4\baselineskip]
			#3 &\text{---} #4
		\end{aligned} 
		\bigg\}
}}

\newcommand{\contx}[4]{
\times 2
{\color{guides}\small%
	\text{\quad\, from \quad}
		\bigg\{
		\begin{aligned}[c]
			#1 &\text{---} #2
			\\[-0.4\baselineskip]
			#3 &\text{---} #4
		\end{aligned} 
		\bigg\}
	\text{\,,\,\,}
		\bigg\{
		\begin{aligned}[c]
			#3 &\text{---} #4
			\\[-0.4\baselineskip]
			#1 &\text{---} #2
		\end{aligned} 
		\bigg\}
	\,,
}}
\newcommand{\contxd}[4]{
\times 2
{\color{guides}\small%
	\text{\quad\, from \quad}
		\bigg\{
		\begin{aligned}[c]
			#1 &\text{---} #2
			\\[-0.4\baselineskip]
			#3 &\text{---} #4
		\end{aligned} 
		\bigg\}
	\text{\,,\,\,}
		\bigg\{
		\begin{aligned}[c]
			#3 &\text{---} #4
			\\[-0.4\baselineskip]
			#1 &\text{---} #2
		\end{aligned} 
		\bigg\}
}}

\newcommand{\conty}[4]{
\times 2
{\color{guides}\small%
	\text{\quad\, from \quad}
		\bigg\{
		\begin{aligned}[c]
			#1 &\text{---} #2
			\\[-0.4\baselineskip]
			#3 &\text{---} #4
		\end{aligned} 
		\bigg\}
	\text{\,,\,\,}
		\bigg\{
		\begin{aligned}[c]
			#2 &\text{---} #1
			\\[-0.4\baselineskip]
			#4 &\text{---} #3
		\end{aligned} 
		\bigg\}
	\,,
}}
\newcommand{\contyd}[4]{
\times 2
{\color{guides}\small%
	\text{\quad\, from \quad}
		\bigg\{
		\begin{aligned}[c]
			#1 &\text{---} #2
			\\[-0.4\baselineskip]
			#3 &\text{---} #4
		\end{aligned} 
		\bigg\}
	\text{\,,\,\,}
		\bigg\{
		\begin{aligned}[c]
			#2 &\text{---} #1
			\\[-0.4\baselineskip]
			#4 &\text{---} #3
		\end{aligned} 
		\bigg\}
}}

\newcommand{\contxy}[4]{
\times 4
{\color{guides}\small%
	\text{\quad\, from \quad}
		\bigg\{
		\begin{aligned}[c]
			#1 &\text{---} #2
			\\[-0.4\baselineskip]
			#3 &\text{---} #4
		\end{aligned} 
		\bigg\}
	\text{\,,\,\,}
		\bigg\{
		\begin{aligned}[c]
			#2 &\text{---} #1
			\\[-0.4\baselineskip]
			#4 &\text{---} #3
		\end{aligned} 
		\bigg\}
	\text{\,,\,\,}
		\bigg\{
		\begin{aligned}[c]
			#3 &\text{---} #4
			\\[-0.4\baselineskip]
			#1 &\text{---} #2
		\end{aligned} 
		\bigg\}
	\text{\,,\,\,}
		\bigg\{
		\begin{aligned}[c]
			#4 &\text{---} #3
			\\[-0.4\baselineskip]
			#2 &\text{---} #1
		\end{aligned} 
		\bigg\}
	\,,
}}
\newcommand{\contxyd}[4]{
\times 4
{\color{guides}\small%
	\text{\quad\, from \quad}
		\bigg\{
		\begin{aligned}[c]
			#1 &\text{---} #2
			\\[-0.4\baselineskip]
			#3 &\text{---} #4
		\end{aligned} 
		\bigg\}
	\text{\,,\,\,}
		\bigg\{
		\begin{aligned}[c]
			#2 &\text{---} #1
			\\[-0.4\baselineskip]
			#4 &\text{---} #3
		\end{aligned} 
		\bigg\}
	\text{\,,\,\,}
		\bigg\{
		\begin{aligned}[c]
			#3 &\text{---} #4
			\\[-0.4\baselineskip]
			#1 &\text{---} #2
		\end{aligned} 
		\bigg\}
	\text{\,,\,\,}
		\bigg\{
		\begin{aligned}[c]
			#4 &\text{---} #3
			\\[-0.4\baselineskip]
			#2 &\text{---} #1
		\end{aligned} 
		\bigg\}
}}


%%%%% Symbols, vectors %%%%%  

%\definecolor{spacegray}{RGB}{20,20,75}
%\newcommand{\csg}[1]{{\color{spacegray}#1}}
%                           
%\def\X{\csg{\mathbf{X}}}
%\def\P{\csg{\mathbf{P}}}
%
%\def\Ph{\csg{\mathbf{\Phi}}}
%\def\tPh{\csg{\tilde{\mathbf{\Phi}}}}
%
%\def\Ps{\csg{\mathbf{\Psi}}}
%\def\tPs{\csg{\tilde{\mathbf{\Psi}}}}
%
%\def\E{\csg{\mathbf{E}}}

\def\X{\mathbf{X}}
\def\P{\mathbf{P}}

\def\Th{\mathbf{\Theta}}
\def\bTh{\bar{\mathbf{\Theta}}}

\def\Ph{\mathbf{\Phi}}
\def\tPh{\tilde{\mathbf{\Phi}}}

\def\Ps{\mathbf{\Psi}}
\def\bPs{\bar{\mathbf{\Psi}}}
\def\tPs{\tilde{\mathbf{\Psi}}}

\def\E{\mathbf{E}}


\def\Ric{{\mathrm{Ric}}}



%\definecolor{LRarrows}{RGB}{41,40,160}
%\newcommand{\LA}[1]{{
%	\accentset{\footnotesize\color{LRarrows}\xleftarrow{}}{#1}
%}}
%\newcommand{\RA}[1]{{
%	\accentset{\footnotesize\color{LRarrows}\xrightarrow{}}{#1}
%}}

\newcommand{\LA}[1]{{\smash{
	\accentset{\footnotesize\blacktriangleleft}{#1}
}}}
\newcommand{\RA}[1]{{\smash{
	\accentset{\footnotesize\blacktriangleright}{#1}
}}}

\def\LPs{\LA{\mathbf{\Psi}}}
\def\LbPs{\LA{\bar{\mathbf{\Psi}}}}
\def\RPs{\RA{\mathbf{\Psi}}}
\def\RbPs{\RA{\bar{\mathbf{\Psi}}}}

\def\LTh{\LA{\mathbf{\Theta}}}
\def\LbTh{\LA{\bar{\mathbf{\Theta}}}}
\def\RTh{\RA{\mathbf{\Theta}}}
\def\RbTh{\RA{\bar{\mathbf{\Theta}}}}

\newcommand{\la}[1]{{\smash{
	\accentset{\adjustbox{scale=0.45}{$\scriptsize\blacktriangleleft$}}{#1}
}}}
\newcommand{\ra}[1]{{\smash{
	\accentset{\adjustbox{scale=0.45}{$\scriptsize\blacktriangleright$}}{#1}
}}}

\def\lPs{\la{\mathbf{\Psi}}}
\def\lbPs{\la{\bar{\mathbf{\Psi}}}}
\def\rPs{\ra{\mathbf{\Psi}}}
\def\rbPs{\ra{\bar{\mathbf{\Psi}}}}

\def\lTh{\la{\mathbf{\Theta}}}
\def\lbTh{\la{\bar{\mathbf{\Theta}}}}
\def\rTh{\ra{\mathbf{\Theta}}}
\def\rbTh{\ra{\bar{\mathbf{\Theta}}}}


\usepackage{makecell}


\newcommand{\para}[1]{\noindent\textbf{#1.}|}


\def\mflat{\mathbb{M}}
\def\V{\mathbb{V}}

\def\btheta{\bar{\theta}}

\def\ps{\mathcal{P}}

\def\YM{{\text{YM}}}
\def\BI{{\text{BI}}}
\def\Grav{{\text{Grav}}}


\newcommand{\normal}[1]{{{:}\mem{#1}\mem{:}}}




\def\ta{{\smash{\tilde{a}}}{}}
\def\tb{{\smash{\tilde{b}}}{}}
\def\tc{{\smash{\tilde{c}}}{}}
\def\td{{\smash{\tilde{d}}}{}}
\def\te{{\smash{\tilde{e}}}{}}
\def\tf{{\smash{\tilde{f}}}{}}

\def\R{\mathbb{R}}
\def\C{\mathbb{C}}

\def\so{\mathfrak{so}}

\def\g{\mathfrak{g}}  
\def\tg{\tilde{\mathfrak{g}}}

\def\diff{\mathfrak{diff}}  
\def\sdiff{\mathfrak{sdiff}}  
            
\def\tphi{\widetilde{\phi}}          

\def\Nc{{N_\text{c}}}

%\def\mathe{e}
\def\mathe{{\scalebox{1.01}[1]{$\mathrm{e}$}}}

% 
% AUTHORS' MACROS END HERE
%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%

\begin{document}
	
	\title{
%		Field Equations from Particle Phase Spaces
		Double Copy and the Double Poisson Bracket
	}
	
	\author{Joon-Hwi Kim}
	\affiliation{Walter Burke Institute for Theoretical Physics, California Institute of Technology, Pasadena, CA 91125, USA}
	
	\begin{abstract}
		We derive 
		first-order and second-order
		field equations 
		from ambitwistor spaces as phase spaces of massless particles.
%
		In particular,
		the second-order field equations
		of Yang-Mills theory and general relativity
		are formulated
		in a unified form $\dpb{H}{H}_\cov = 0$,
		whose left-hand side
		describes a doubling of Poisson bracket
		in a covariant sense.
%		
		This structure
		originates from a one-loop diagram
		encoded in gauge-covariant, associative operator products
		on the ambitwistor worldlines.
%
		A conjecture arises that
		the kinematic algebra might manifest 
		as the Poisson algebra
		of ambitwistor space.
	\end{abstract}
	
	\preprint{CALT-TH 2025-005}
	
	% \date{\today}
	
	\bibliographystyle{utphys-modified}
	
	\renewcommand*{\bibfont}{\fontsize{8}{8.5}\selectfont}
	\setlength{\bibsep}{1pt}
	
	\maketitle
	
	\input{body.tex}
	
	\medskip
	\noindent\textit{Acknowledgements.}|%
		The author is grateful to
			Clifford Cheung,
			Toby Saunders-A'Court,
		and
			Sonja Klisch
		for discussions.
	%	
		The author would like to thank
			Lionel Mason
		for insightful discussions
		during the
		conference ``The Mathematics behind Scattering Amplitudes'' held in August 2024;
	%	
		the author thanks the Galileo Galilei
		Institute for Theoretical Physics, Florence for hospitality. 
	%
		The author is grateful to
			Sebastian Mizera
		for encouraging comments
		and
			Julio Parra-Martinez
		for bringing the history of Feynman brackets to his attention.
	%
		The author thanks
		the attendees of California Amplitudes Meeting 2023 on March 18\textsuperscript{th} for 
		comments on the idea of approaching double copy via Feynman brackets,
		presented in the talk \cite{caamps23spt}.
	%
		J.-H.K. is supported by the Department of Energy (Grant {No.}~DE-SC0011632) and by the Walter Burke Institute for Theoretical Physics.
	% 	
	
	\newpage
	\appendix
	\onecolumngrid
	\input{app.tex}
	
%	\phantom{.}
%	\newpage
%	\newpage
%	\input{supp.tex}

	\twocolumngrid
	\bibliography{references.bib}
	
\end{document}