| { |
| "task_id": "arxiv_002", |
| "domain": "ARXIV", |
| "autonomy_type": "ordered table", |
| "oracle_output_cardinality": 10, |
| "instruction": "I am compiling a reading list of 2022 research on reasoning prompts for large language models. I want to find arXiv papers whose first version was submitted in 2022 and that explicitly focus on chain-of-thought or self-consistency reasoning methods. Start with arXiv records first submitted in 2022. First, check whether the title or abstract explicitly contains clues related to chain-of-thought or self-consistency. Then, retain only papers whose primary category is Computation and Language; do not include records that are only cross-listed from other primary categories. Next, verify that these papers actually had a version update in 2023, and confirm that the current arXiv record's comments field clearly indicates subsequent publication information. Finally, output a table sorted in ascending order by the date of each paper's earliest 2023 version update, with columns: arXiv ID, cue family, cue location, v1 submitted, first 2023 version, date of that version, primary category, publication clue. If no qualifying items exist, output NONE.", |
| "start_url": "https://arxiv.org/search/advanced", |
| "output_format": "Finally, output a table sorted in ascending order by the date of each paper's earliest 2023 version update, with columns: arXiv ID, cue family, cue location, v1 submitted, first 2023 version, date of that version, primary category, publication clue. If no qualifying items exist, output NONE.", |
| "oracle_answer": "arXiv ID|cue family|cue location|v1 submitted|first 2023 version|date of that version|primary category|publication clue\n2210.01240|Chain-of-thought|Title + Abstract|2022-10-03|v2|2023-01-25|cs.CL|Published as a conference paper at ICLR 2023\n2205.11916|Chain-of-thought|Abstract-only|2022-05-24|v4|2023-01-29|cs.CL|Accepted to NeurIPS2022\n2203.11171|Self-consistency; Chain-of-thought|Title + Abstract|2022-03-21|v4|2023-03-07|cs.CL|Published at ICLR 2023; camera ready version at ICLR 2023\n2210.03629|Chain-of-thought|Abstract-only|2022-10-06|v3|2023-03-10|cs.CL|v3 is the ICLR camera ready version\n2210.03350|Chain-of-thought|Abstract-only|2022-10-07|v2|2023-05-23|cs.CL|To appear at Findings of EMNLP 2023\n2212.10001|Chain-of-thought|Title + Abstract|2022-12-20|v2|2023-06-01|cs.CL|ACL-23 Camera Ready\n2212.08061|Chain-of-thought|Abstract-only|2022-12-15|v2|2023-06-04|cs.CL|ACL 2023 Main Conference\n2212.10071|Chain-of-thought|Abstract-only|2022-12-20|v2|2023-06-13|cs.CL|ACL 2023 camera-ready\n2212.10509|Chain-of-thought|Title + Abstract|2022-12-20|v2|2023-06-23|cs.CL|ACL'23 Camera Ready\n2211.12588|Chain-of-thought; Self-consistency|Abstract-only|2022-11-22|v4|2023-10-23|cs.CL|Published at TMLR 2023", |
| "metadata": { |
| "State-Gated Retrieval": [ |
| "Only include arXiv papers whose v1 was submitted in 2022.", |
| "The title or abstract must explicitly contain clues related to chain-of-thought or self-consistency.", |
| "The current primary category must be cs.CL; do not include records that are only cross-listed from other primary categories.", |
| "Must have had a version update in 2023, and the current comments field must clearly indicate subsequent publication information." |
| ], |
| "dependency_type": "Data + Control", |
| "intra_chain": true, |
| "inter_chain": true, |
| "data_dependency": [ |
| "root searches yield candidate arXiv IDs", |
| "each candidate abstract page yields primary category, v1 date, first 2023 version, comments/publication clue", |
| "answer rows are produced only after deduplication and detail-page validation" |
| ], |
| "control_dependency": [ |
| "searches must cover both Title and Abstract fields because valid rows can appear only in the abstract", |
| "cross-listed hits whose primary category is not cs.CL must be excluded, and the primary category must be validated on the abstract page", |
| "topic-matched hits must be validated against a current Comments publication clue before they can be accepted", |
| "2023 candidates must be identified by original submission year and full version-history checks, rather than by latest-date proxies" |
| ], |
| "freeze": { |
| "historical_window": "v1 submitted in 2022; version-history event in 2023" |
| }, |
| "answer_type": "multi-row ordered table" |
| }, |
| "rubric": { |
| "inclusion_conditions": [ |
| "Only include arXiv papers whose v1 was submitted in 2022.", |
| "The title or abstract must explicitly contain clues related to chain-of-thought or self-consistency.", |
| "The current primary category must be cs.CL; do not include records that are only cross-listed from other primary categories.", |
| "Must have had a version update in 2023, and the current comments field must clearly indicate subsequent publication information." |
| ], |
| "exclusion_conditions": [ |
| "Exclude records whose current primary category is not cs.CL, even if they appear in relevant search results.", |
| "Exclude records that contain only vague abbreviations or weakly related hints, but whose title and abstract lack explicit CoT/self-consistency semantics.", |
| "Exclude records that have no 2023 version update, or whose current record lacks a direct publication clue." |
| ], |
| "normalization": { |
| "field_separator": "|", |
| "record_separator": "\n", |
| "header_row": "required literal first row shown in the oracle", |
| "schema": [ |
| "arXiv ID", |
| "cue family", |
| "cue location", |
| "v1 submitted", |
| "first 2023 version", |
| "date of that version", |
| "primary category", |
| "publication clue" |
| ], |
| "dedup_key": "bare arXiv ID without version suffix", |
| "date_format": "YYYY-MM-DD", |
| "cue_family": [ |
| "Chain-of-thought", |
| "Self-consistency" |
| ], |
| "cue_location": { |
| "Title": "qualifying cue appears only in the title", |
| "Abstract-only": "qualifying cue appears only in the abstract", |
| "Title + Abstract": "qualifying cue appears in both title and abstract, or title carries only a generic cue while the abstract carries the specific family name" |
| }, |
| "publication_clue": { |
| "source": "Comments field only", |
| "extraction": "keep the shortest phrase that still preserves the current publication-status clue" |
| }, |
| "sorting_or_selection": { |
| "primary": "date of the earliest 2023 version ascending", |
| "secondary": "arXiv ID ascending" |
| }, |
| "stop_condition": [ |
| "all corrected result pages are exhausted", |
| "all unique candidate IDs are opened to abstract-page depth", |
| "for every surviving candidate, the current browse context, Comments field, and full Submission history are checked before emitting the final ordered table" |
| ] |
| } |
| } |
| } |
|
|
