{
  "task_id": "arxiv_002",
  "domain": "ARXIV",
  "autonomy_type": "ordered table",
  "oracle_output_cardinality": 10,
  "instruction": "I am compiling a reading list of 2022 research on reasoning prompts for large language models. I want to find arXiv papers whose first version was submitted in 2022 and that explicitly focus on chain-of-thought or self-consistency reasoning methods. Start with arXiv records first submitted in 2022. First, check whether the title or abstract explicitly contains clues related to chain-of-thought or self-consistency. Then, retain only papers whose primary category is Computation and Language; do not include records that are only cross-listed from other primary categories. Next, verify that these papers actually had a version update in 2023, and confirm that the current arXiv record's comments field clearly indicates subsequent publication information. Finally, output a table sorted in ascending order by the date of each paper's earliest 2023 version update, with columns: arXiv ID, cue family, cue location, v1 submitted, first 2023 version, date of that version, primary category, publication clue. If no qualifying items exist, output NONE.",
  "start_url": "https://arxiv.org/search/advanced",
  "output_format": "Finally, output a table sorted in ascending order by the date of each paper's earliest 2023 version update, with columns: arXiv ID, cue family, cue location, v1 submitted, first 2023 version, date of that version, primary category, publication clue. If no qualifying items exist, output NONE.",
  "oracle_answer": "arXiv ID|cue family|cue location|v1 submitted|first 2023 version|date of that version|primary category|publication clue\n2210.01240|Chain-of-thought|Title + Abstract|2022-10-03|v2|2023-01-25|cs.CL|Published as a conference paper at ICLR 2023\n2205.11916|Chain-of-thought|Abstract-only|2022-05-24|v4|2023-01-29|cs.CL|Accepted to NeurIPS2022\n2203.11171|Self-consistency; Chain-of-thought|Title + Abstract|2022-03-21|v4|2023-03-07|cs.CL|Published at ICLR 2023; camera ready version at ICLR 2023\n2210.03629|Chain-of-thought|Abstract-only|2022-10-06|v3|2023-03-10|cs.CL|v3 is the ICLR camera ready version\n2210.03350|Chain-of-thought|Abstract-only|2022-10-07|v2|2023-05-23|cs.CL|To appear at Findings of EMNLP 2023\n2212.10001|Chain-of-thought|Title + Abstract|2022-12-20|v2|2023-06-01|cs.CL|ACL-23 Camera Ready\n2212.08061|Chain-of-thought|Abstract-only|2022-12-15|v2|2023-06-04|cs.CL|ACL 2023 Main Conference\n2212.10071|Chain-of-thought|Abstract-only|2022-12-20|v2|2023-06-13|cs.CL|ACL 2023 camera-ready\n2212.10509|Chain-of-thought|Title + Abstract|2022-12-20|v2|2023-06-23|cs.CL|ACL'23 Camera Ready\n2211.12588|Chain-of-thought; Self-consistency|Abstract-only|2022-11-22|v4|2023-10-23|cs.CL|Published at TMLR 2023",
  "metadata": {
    "State-Gated Retrieval": [
      "Only include arXiv papers whose v1 was submitted in 2022.",
      "The title or abstract must explicitly contain clues related to chain-of-thought or self-consistency.",
      "The current primary category must be cs.CL; do not include records that are only cross-listed from other primary categories.",
      "Must have had a version update in 2023, and the current comments field must clearly indicate subsequent publication information."
    ],
    "dependency_type": "Data + Control",
    "intra_chain": true,
    "inter_chain": true,
    "data_dependency": [
      "root searches yield candidate arXiv IDs",
      "each candidate abstract page yields primary category, v1 date, first 2023 version, comments/publication clue",
      "answer rows are produced only after deduplication and detail-page validation"
    ],
    "control_dependency": [
      "searches must cover both Title and Abstract fields because valid rows can appear only in the abstract",
      "cross-listed hits whose primary category is not cs.CL must be excluded, and the primary category must be validated on the abstract page",
      "topic-matched hits must be validated against a current Comments publication clue before they can be accepted",
      "2023 candidates must be identified by original submission year and full version-history checks, rather than by latest-date proxies"
    ],
    "freeze": {
      "historical_window": "v1 submitted in 2022; version-history event in 2023"
    },
    "answer_type": "multi-row ordered table"
  },
  "rubric": {
    "inclusion_conditions": [
      "Only include arXiv papers whose v1 was submitted in 2022.",
      "The title or abstract must explicitly contain clues related to chain-of-thought or self-consistency.",
      "The current primary category must be cs.CL; do not include records that are only cross-listed from other primary categories.",
      "Must have had a version update in 2023, and the current comments field must clearly indicate subsequent publication information."
    ],
    "exclusion_conditions": [
      "Exclude records whose current primary category is not cs.CL, even if they appear in relevant search results.",
      "Exclude records that contain only vague abbreviations or weakly related hints, but whose title and abstract lack explicit CoT/self-consistency semantics.",
      "Exclude records that have no 2023 version update, or whose current record lacks a direct publication clue."
    ],
    "normalization": {
      "field_separator": "|",
      "record_separator": "\n",
      "header_row": "required literal first row shown in the oracle",
      "schema": [
        "arXiv ID",
        "cue family",
        "cue location",
        "v1 submitted",
        "first 2023 version",
        "date of that version",
        "primary category",
        "publication clue"
      ],
      "dedup_key": "bare arXiv ID without version suffix",
      "date_format": "YYYY-MM-DD",
      "cue_family": [
        "Chain-of-thought",
        "Self-consistency"
      ],
      "cue_location": {
        "Title": "qualifying cue appears only in the title",
        "Abstract-only": "qualifying cue appears only in the abstract",
        "Title + Abstract": "qualifying cue appears in both title and abstract, or title carries only a generic cue while the abstract carries the specific family name"
      },
      "publication_clue": {
        "source": "Comments field only",
        "extraction": "keep the shortest phrase that still preserves the current publication-status clue"
      },
      "sorting_or_selection": {
        "primary": "date of the earliest 2023 version ascending",
        "secondary": "arXiv ID ascending"
      },
      "stop_condition": [
        "all corrected result pages are exhausted",
        "all unique candidate IDs are opened to abstract-page depth",
        "for every surviving candidate, the current browse context, Comments field, and full Submission history are checked before emitting the final ordered table"
      ]
    }
  }
}