License Compatibility
#1
by goodnight399 - opened
Hi, I’d like to report a potential license incompatibility inNeko3000lora-trained-xl-livebeanroise. According to the model information, this model was built by adapting RunDiffusion/Juggernaut-XI-v11, which is licensed under CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0.
However, the adapter-based model Neko3000lora-trained-xl-livebeanroise is currently released under the OpenRAIL++ License, which may be incompatible with the source model’s restrictions — particularly the “No Derivatives” clause in the CC-BY-NC-ND-4.0 license.
⚠️ License Conflicts:
CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0:
• BY: Attribution required
• NC: Non-commercial use only
• ND: No Derivatives – prohibits sharing modified, transformed, or adapted versions
OpenRAIL++:
• Allows sharing, modifying, and adapting the model
• Enables downstream reuse and redistribution
• Often used for responsible AI distribution, including research and commercial contexts (with conditions)
Conflict:
→ CC-BY-NC-ND explicitly forbids the **distribution of derivative works**
→ An adapter-based model is considered a derivative under most interpretations
→ Releasing the adapted model under OpenRAIL++ contradicts the ND clause and may breach the original license
Let me know if I misunderstood anything — happy to help clarify further!
Thanks for your attention!