Beemer Claude Opus 4.7 commited on
Commit
107dffb
Β·
1 Parent(s): 8027fd6

Add 17 more leading SCC/FCA/FC decisions

Browse files

Ingest 17 of the 18 curated leading decisions on immigration, customs
and Charter law: Chiarelli, Chieu, Medovarski, Mugesera, Harkat,
Nemeth, Mavi, Pham, Chan, Jacques, Martineau (SCC); Poshteh, Hinzman,
Thamotharem, Toussaint, Rahaman (FCA); Almrei (FC). Sahin (1994) is
not on the Lexum Federal Court database and was dropped.

The case-law corpus grows from 72 to 89 decisions (3,341 -> 4,308
chunks); the whole corpus is now 15,045 chunks.

94-question eval: Hit@1 0.67, Hit@3 0.82, Hit@5 0.89, MRR 0.76.
Hit@5 dips 0.02 from the pre-expansion 0.91 -- two FB collective-
agreement questions now lose to labour-board case law on labour
queries, an artifact of the richer corpus.

Removes the now-obsolete pending-cases.md.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 <noreply@anthropic.com>

canlex/caselaw.py CHANGED
@@ -119,6 +119,39 @@ CASES = [
119
  {"court": "scc", "id": 1023, "short": "Ward",
120
  "topic": "The refugee definition; a particular social group; the "
121
  "availability of state protection"},
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
122
 
123
  # --- Federal Court of Appeal ---
124
  {"court": "fca", "id": 143136, "short": "Huruglica",
@@ -169,6 +202,21 @@ CASES = [
169
  {"court": "fca", "id": 419470, "short": "Hociung",
170
  "topic": "Whether gold coins are currency or monetary instruments that "
171
  "must be reported on import under the PCMLTFA cross-border regime"},
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
172
 
173
  # --- Federal Court ---
174
  {"court": "fc", "id": 64594, "short": "Goburdhun",
@@ -183,6 +231,9 @@ CASES = [
183
  {"court": "fc", "id": 56900, "short": "Nguyen",
184
  "topic": "Customs Act; judicial review of the amount set for a penalty "
185
  "or ascertained forfeiture"},
 
 
 
186
 
187
  # --- Federal courts: PCMLTFA cross-border currency forfeiture ---
188
  {"court": "fca", "id": 36092, "short": "Sellathurai",
 
119
  {"court": "scc", "id": 1023, "short": "Ward",
120
  "topic": "The refugee definition; a particular social group; the "
121
  "availability of state protection"},
122
+ {"court": "scc", "id": 855, "short": "Chiarelli",
123
+ "topic": "Charter s. 7 fundamental justice and the deportation of "
124
+ "permanent residents for serious criminality"},
125
+ {"court": "scc", "id": 1940, "short": "Chieu",
126
+ "topic": "Immigration Appeal Division appeals from a removal order; "
127
+ "foreign hardship is a relevant consideration"},
128
+ {"court": "scc", "id": 2284, "short": "Medovarski",
129
+ "topic": "The objectives of IRPA; a non-citizen has no Charter s. 7 "
130
+ "right to remain in Canada"},
131
+ {"court": "scc", "id": 2273, "short": "Mugesera",
132
+ "topic": "Inadmissibility for crimes against humanity; incitement to "
133
+ "genocide and the elements of the offence"},
134
+ {"court": "scc", "id": 13643, "short": "Harkat",
135
+ "topic": "Constitutionality of the IRPA security-certificate regime and "
136
+ "the special advocate scheme"},
137
+ {"court": "scc", "id": 7899, "short": "NΓ©meth",
138
+ "topic": "Extradition and the refugee principle of non-refoulement; the "
139
+ "Minister's duty when surrendering a protected person"},
140
+ {"court": "scc", "id": 7944, "short": "Mavi",
141
+ "topic": "Sponsorship-undertaking debt; the procedural fairness owed "
142
+ "before the Crown enforces a sponsorship debt"},
143
+ {"court": "scc", "id": 12904, "short": "Pham",
144
+ "topic": "Collateral immigration consequences as a factor in fixing a "
145
+ "criminal sentence"},
146
+ {"court": "scc", "id": 1299, "short": "Chan",
147
+ "topic": "Refugee protection; membership in a particular social group "
148
+ "and a well-founded fear of persecution"},
149
+ {"court": "scc", "id": 1425, "short": "Jacques",
150
+ "topic": "Border searches; reasonable suspicion for a vehicle stop near "
151
+ "the border under the Customs Act"},
152
+ {"court": "scc", "id": 2198, "short": "Martineau",
153
+ "topic": "Whether an ascertained-forfeiture proceeding under the Customs "
154
+ "Act is penal and engages the right against self-incrimination"},
155
 
156
  # --- Federal Court of Appeal ---
157
  {"court": "fca", "id": 143136, "short": "Huruglica",
 
202
  {"court": "fca", "id": 419470, "short": "Hociung",
203
  "topic": "Whether gold coins are currency or monetary instruments that "
204
  "must be reported on import under the PCMLTFA cross-border regime"},
205
+ {"court": "fca", "id": 32333, "short": "Poshteh",
206
+ "topic": "Inadmissibility for membership in a terrorist organization "
207
+ "under IRPA s. 34(1)(f); relevance of the claimant's age"},
208
+ {"court": "fca", "id": 35576, "short": "Hinzman",
209
+ "topic": "Refugee and humanitarian and compassionate claims by United "
210
+ "States military deserters"},
211
+ {"court": "fca", "id": 35611, "short": "Thamotharem",
212
+ "topic": "Refugee Protection Division hearing procedure; order of "
213
+ "questioning and fettering of discretion by guidelines"},
214
+ {"court": "fca", "id": 37227, "short": "Toussaint",
215
+ "topic": "Access to the Interim Federal Health Program for an indigent "
216
+ "applicant without immigration status"},
217
+ {"court": "fca", "id": 31447, "short": "Rahaman",
218
+ "topic": "Refugee claims and the meaning of a 'no credible basis' "
219
+ "finding under IRPA"},
220
 
221
  # --- Federal Court ---
222
  {"court": "fc", "id": 64594, "short": "Goburdhun",
 
231
  {"court": "fc", "id": 56900, "short": "Nguyen",
232
  "topic": "Customs Act; judicial review of the amount set for a penalty "
233
  "or ascertained forfeiture"},
234
+ {"court": "fc", "id": 57473, "short": "Almrei",
235
+ "topic": "Reasonableness of an IRPA security certificate after "
236
+ "Charkaoui; the test on re-determination"},
237
 
238
  # --- Federal courts: PCMLTFA cross-border currency forfeiture ---
239
  {"court": "fca", "id": 36092, "short": "Sellathurai",
data/processed/caselaw.json CHANGED
The diff for this file is too large to render. See raw diff
 
pending-cases.md DELETED
@@ -1,59 +0,0 @@
1
- # Leading cases to add when the Lexum block clears
2
-
3
- **Status (2026-05-21):** Phase 4 (FPSLREB/CIRB) and this case-law expansion are
4
- both blocked. `canlex.caselaw` fetches return **HTTP 403** from the Lexum
5
- decision hosts β€” two full ingest attempts, every FPSLREB/CIRB decision failed.
6
- A single-shot probe of the same URLs returns 200, so the block is intermittent
7
- or specific to the fetch pattern (likely the `?iframe=true` decision endpoint).
8
-
9
- **To ingest when the block clears:** for each case below, open the decision on
10
- its court's `decisions.*.gc.ca` site, take the numeric **item id** from the
11
- `.../item/{id}/index.do` URL, and add an entry to `CASES` in
12
- `canlex/caselaw.py` (`{"court": ..., "id": ..., "short": ..., "topic": ...}`),
13
- then re-run `py -m canlex.caselaw` β†’ `py -m canlex.embed` β†’ redeploy. Verify the
14
- citation against the page (these are from memory). Cases already in the corpus
15
- are excluded.
16
-
17
- ## Supreme Court of Canada (court: "scc")
18
- - **Chiarelli** β€” Canada (MEI) v Chiarelli, [1992] 1 SCR 711 β€” s. 7 fundamental
19
- justice and the deportation of permanent residents; the constitutional
20
- baseline for non-citizens.
21
- - **Chieu** β€” Chieu v Canada (MCI), 2002 SCC 3 β€” Immigration Appeal Division
22
- removal-order appeals; foreign hardship is a relevant consideration.
23
- - **Medovarski** β€” Medovarski v Canada (MCI), 2005 SCC 51 β€” IRPA's objectives;
24
- no Charter s. 7 right for a non-citizen to remain in Canada.
25
- - **Mugesera** β€” Mugesera v Canada (MCI), 2005 SCC 40 β€” inadmissibility for
26
- crimes against humanity; incitement to genocide.
27
- - **Harkat** β€” Canada (Citizenship and Immigration) v Harkat, 2014 SCC 37 β€”
28
- constitutionality of the security-certificate regime and special advocates.
29
- - **NΓ©meth** β€” NΓ©meth v Canada (Justice), 2010 SCC 56 β€” extradition and the
30
- refugee principle of non-refoulement.
31
- - **Mavi** β€” Canada (AG) v Mavi, 2011 SCC 30 β€” sponsorship-undertaking debt and
32
- the duty of procedural fairness in enforcing it.
33
- - **Pham** β€” R v Pham, 2013 SCC 15 β€” collateral immigration consequences as a
34
- factor in criminal sentencing.
35
- - **Chan** β€” Chan v Canada (MEI), [1995] 3 SCR 593 β€” refugee protection; a
36
- particular social group and well-founded fear (verify the citation).
37
- - **Jacques** β€” R v Jacques, [1996] 3 SCR 312 β€” border searches; a vehicle stop
38
- near the border and customs officers' powers.
39
- - **Martineau** β€” Martineau v MNR, 2004 SCC 81 β€” whether an ascertained-
40
- forfeiture notice under the Customs Act is a penal proceeding.
41
-
42
- ## Federal Court of Appeal (court: "fca")
43
- - **Poshteh** β€” Poshteh v Canada (MCI), 2005 FCA 85 β€” membership in a terrorist
44
- organization for inadmissibility; relevance of the claimant's age.
45
- - **Hinzman** β€” Hinzman v Canada (MCI), 2007 FCA 171 β€” refugee and H&C claims by
46
- US military deserters.
47
- - **Thamotharem** β€” Canada (MCI) v Thamotharem, 2007 FCA 198 β€” Refugee
48
- Protection Division hearing procedure; order of questioning; fettering by
49
- guidelines.
50
- - **Toussaint** β€” Toussaint v Canada (AG), 2011 FCA 213 β€” interim federal health
51
- coverage and access for indigent applicants.
52
- - **Rahaman** β€” Rahaman v Canada (MCI), 2002 FCA 89 β€” refugee claims and the "no
53
- credible basis" finding.
54
-
55
- ## Federal Court (court: "fc")
56
- - **Almrei (Re)** β€” Almrei (Re), 2009 FC 1263 β€” reasonableness of a security
57
- certificate after Charkaoui.
58
- - **Sahin** β€” Sahin v Canada (MCI), [1995] 1 FC 214 β€” the foundational factors
59
- for the length of immigration detention.