library(tidyverse) library(scales) library(ggrepel) library(RColorBrewer) library(optparse) option_list <- list( make_option(c("-c", "--core"), type = "character", default = "core", help = "Directory containing the Google Sheets downloads.", metavar = "character" ), make_option(c("-o", "--output"), type = "character", default = ".", help = "Output directory.", metavar = "character" ) ) # Parse command line arguments opt_parser <- OptionParser(option_list = option_list) opt <- parse_args(opt_parser) # Check if required arguments are provided if (is.null(opt$core)) { stop("Error: Sheets directory (-s, --sheets) is required") } if (is.null(opt$output)) { stop("Error: Output directory (-o, --output) is required") } core_dir <- opt$core output_dir <- opt$output # Load the CSV source files. ################ ## Core datasets ################ model_hierarchy <- c( "model_family", "model_version", "model_variant", "model_subvariant", "model_base" ) core_models <- read_csv(str_glue("{core_dir}/models.csv")) |> mutate( model_base = if_else(model_is_base == TRUE, "base", NA_character_), model_old_id = model_id, ) |> unite( col = "model_id", all_of(model_hierarchy), sep = "_", remove = FALSE, na.rm = TRUE # this skips fields that are NA. ) |> mutate( model_id = str_to_lower(model_id), model_id = str_replace_all(model_id, fixed("."), "_") ) core_highlights <- core_models |> # Filter here to exclude base models. # filter(model_is_base == FALSE) |> inner_join(read_csv(str_glue("{core_dir}/highlights.csv")), by = join_by(model_old_id == model_id)) |> select( model_id, benchmark_id, prescribed_competency, prescribed_category, model_is_base, model_published_at, model_access, organization_name, organization_sector, organization_domain, all_of(model_hierarchy), ) |> group_by( benchmark_id, model_id, ) |> summarise( # Get unique, non-NA competencies, and combine them with ' && ' prescribed_competency = paste(unique(na.omit(prescribed_competency)), collapse = " && "), # Get unique, non-NA categories, and combine them with ' && ' prescribed_category = paste(unique(na.omit(prescribed_category)), collapse = " && "), model_published_at = first(model_published_at), model_access = first(na.omit(model_access)), organization_name = first(na.omit(organization_name)), organization_sector = first(na.omit(organization_sector)), organization_domain = first(na.omit(organization_domain)), .groups = "keep" ) |> ungroup() core_models <- core_highlights |> group_by(model_id) |> mutate(model_published_at = min(model_published_at)) |> ungroup() |> select( model_id, model_published_at, model_access, organization_name, organization_sector, organization_domain, ) |> distinct() core_benchmarks <- core_highlights |> left_join(read_csv(str_glue("{core_dir}/benchmarks.csv")), by = "benchmark_id") |> select( benchmark_id, benchmark_name, benchmark_full_name, paper_id, paper_href, paper_published_at, ) |> distinct() core_highlights <- core_highlights |> select( model_id, benchmark_id, prescribed_competency, prescribed_category, ) |> distinct() core_categories <- read_csv(str_glue("{core_dir}/categories.csv")) core_categorizations <- read_csv(str_glue("{core_dir}/categorizations.csv")) |> left_join(core_categories, by = "benchmark_category") core_affiliations <- read_csv(str_glue("{core_dir}/affiliations.csv")) core_knowledge_subjects <- read_csv(str_glue("{core_dir}/knowledge-subjects.csv")) ########### ## Rankings ########### rankings_overall <- core_highlights |> left_join(core_models, by = "model_id") |> select(benchmark_id, model_id, organization_name) |> # Calculate the totals of all models and publishers. mutate( total_publishers = n_distinct(organization_name), total_models = n_distinct(model_id) ) |> summarise( n_publishers = n_distinct(organization_name), n_models = n_distinct(model_id), # Carry the totals forward (they are the same for every row, so first() works) total_publishers = first(total_publishers), total_models = first(total_models), .by = benchmark_id ) |> mutate( score = sqrt(n_publishers * n_models), rank = dense_rank(desc(score)), p_publishers = n_publishers / total_publishers, p_models = n_models / total_models, ) |> select(-total_publishers, -total_models) |> select(benchmark_id, rank, ends_with("publishers"), ends_with("models"), score) rankings_access <- core_highlights |> left_join(core_models, by = "model_id") |> select(benchmark_id, model_id, model_access, organization_name) |> # Calculate the totals of all models and publishers grouped by model_access. mutate( total_models = n_distinct(model_id), .by = model_access ) |> summarise( n_publishers = n_distinct(organization_name), n_models = n_distinct(model_id), # Carry the totals forward (they are the same for every row, so first() works) total_models = first(total_models), .by = c(benchmark_id, model_access) ) |> group_by(model_access) |> mutate( score = sqrt(n_publishers * n_models), rank = dense_rank(desc(score)), p_models = n_models / total_models, ) |> ungroup() |> select(-total_models) |> pivot_wider( id_cols = benchmark_id, names_from = model_access, values_from = c(rank, n_models, p_models, score), names_glue = "{.value}_{str_to_lower(str_replace_all(model_access, ' ', '_'))}" ) |> select(benchmark_id, ends_with("closed"), ends_with("open-weight"), ends_with("open-source")) rankings_domain <- core_highlights |> left_join(core_models, by = "model_id") |> select(benchmark_id, model_id, organization_domain, organization_name) |> # Calculate the totals of all models and publishers grouped by organization_domain. mutate( total_publishers = n_distinct(organization_name), .by = organization_domain ) |> summarise( n_publishers = n_distinct(organization_name), n_models = n_distinct(model_id), # Carry the totals forward (they are the same for every row, so first() works) total_publishers = first(total_publishers), .by = c(benchmark_id, organization_domain) ) |> group_by(organization_domain) |> mutate( score = sqrt(n_publishers * n_models), rank = dense_rank(desc(score)), p_publishers = n_publishers / total_publishers, ) |> ungroup() |> select(-total_publishers) |> pivot_wider( id_cols = benchmark_id, names_from = organization_domain, values_from = c(rank, n_publishers, p_publishers, score), names_glue = "{.value}_{str_to_lower(str_replace_all(organization_domain, ' ', '_'))}" ) |> select(benchmark_id, ends_with("west"), ends_with("china")) rankings <- rankings_overall |> left_join(rankings_domain, by = "benchmark_id") |> left_join(rankings_access, by = "benchmark_id") |> select( benchmark_id, rank, ends_with("models"), ends_with("publishers"), ends_with("publishers_west"), ends_with("publishers_china"), ends_with("models_closed"), ends_with("models_open-weight"), ends_with("models_open-source"), starts_with("rank_"), contains("score"), ) |> arrange(rank) |> write_csv(str_glue("{output_dir}/derived/rankings.csv"), na = "") ## Top 15 Most Popular Benchmarks: Table 4 rankings_top_15 <- rankings |> slice_min(order_by = rank, n = 15, with_ties = TRUE) |> write_csv(str_glue("{output_dir}/derived/rankings-top-15.csv"), na = "") ############## # Affiliations ############## benchmark_creators <- core_affiliations |> inner_join(core_benchmarks, by = "paper_id", relationship = "many-to-many") ## Affiliation of Benchmark Creators: Table 1 affiliations_overall <- benchmark_creators |> count(organization_sector) |> mutate(p = n / sum(n)) affiliations_west <- benchmark_creators |> filter(organization_domain == "west") |> count(organization_sector) |> mutate(p = n / sum(n)) affiliations_china <- benchmark_creators |> filter(organization_domain == "china") |> count(organization_sector) |> mutate(p = n / sum(n)) affiliations_overall_2025 <- benchmark_creators |> filter(year(paper_published_at) == "2025") |> count(organization_sector) |> mutate(p = n / sum(n)) affiliations_west_2025 <- benchmark_creators |> filter(year(paper_published_at) == "2025" & organization_domain == "west") |> count(organization_sector) |> mutate(p = n / sum(n)) affiliations_china_2025 <- benchmark_creators |> filter(year(paper_published_at) == "2025" & organization_domain == "china") |> count(organization_sector) |> mutate(p = n / sum(n)) # We join the separate affiliation tibbles into a single data structure # containing all columns joined on the organization_sector column. list( overall = affiliations_overall, overall_2025 = affiliations_overall_2025, west = affiliations_west, west_2025 = affiliations_west_2025, china = affiliations_china, china_2025 = affiliations_china_2025 ) |> # imap iterates over the list (.x is the tibble, .y is the list name) imap(~ rename_with(.x, function(col) paste0(col, "_", .y), c(n, p))) |> # reduce sequentially joins all tibbles in the list reduce(~ full_join(.x, .y, by = "organization_sector")) |> write_csv(str_glue("{output_dir}/derived/affiliations-benchmark-creators.csv"), na = "") ## Multiple affiliations of benchmark authors: Table 2 n_benchmark_creators <- benchmark_creators |> distinct(author_name, paper_id) |> nrow() n_benchmark_creators_multiple <- benchmark_creators |> add_count(author_name, paper_id) |> filter(n >= 2) |> distinct(author_name, paper_id) |> nrow() tibble( n_benchmark_creators = n_benchmark_creators, n_benchmark_creators_multiple = n_benchmark_creators_multiple, p_benchmark_creators_multiple = n_benchmark_creators_multiple / n_benchmark_creators ) |> write_csv(str_glue("{output_dir}/derived/benchmark-creators.csv"), na = "") benchmark_creators |> # Only proceed with authors that appear more than once. add_count(author_name, paper_id) |> filter(n >= 2) |> # Create combined sector labels. Make sure the sectors are always appearing in # the same order. group_by(author_name, paper_id) |> arrange(organization_sector, .by_group = TRUE) |> summarize( combination = paste(unique(organization_sector), collapse = " & "), .groups = "drop", ) |> # Count the combination labels and produce final output. count(combination) |> mutate(p = n / sum(n)) |> arrange(desc(p)) |> write_csv(str_glue("{output_dir}/derived/affiliations-benchmark-creators-multiple.csv"), na = "") # Affiliations per benchmark benchmark_affiliations <- benchmark_creators |> group_by(benchmark_id) |> count(organization_sector) |> mutate(p = n / sum(n)) |> ungroup() |> select(-n) |> write_csv(str_glue("{output_dir}/derived/affiliations-benchmark.csv"), na = "") benchmark_affiliations |> pivot_wider( names_from = organization_sector, values_from = p, names_glue = "{.value}_{organization_sector}", ) |> relocate(`p_NA`, .after = last_col()) |> write_csv(str_glue("{output_dir}/derived/affiliations-benchmark-wide.csv"), na = "") ############## # Competencies ############## ## Evaluated Competencies in the Top 15 Benchmarks: Table 3 top_15_categories <- rankings_top_15 |> left_join(core_categorizations, by = "benchmark_id") evaluated_competencies <- top_15_categories |> count(benchmark_category) |> mutate(p = n / sum(n)) evaluated_meta_competencies <- top_15_categories |> count(benchmark_meta_category) |> mutate(p = n / sum(n)) top_15_categories |> left_join(core_benchmarks, by = "benchmark_id") |> group_by(benchmark_category) |> arrange(benchmark_name, .by_group = TRUE) |> summarize( benchmarks = paste(unique(benchmark_name), collapse = ", "), .groups = "drop", ) |> left_join(evaluated_competencies, by = "benchmark_category") |> arrange(desc(p)) |> write_csv(str_glue("{output_dir}/derived/evaluated-competencies.csv"), na = "") top_15_categories |> left_join(core_benchmarks, by = "benchmark_id") |> group_by(benchmark_meta_category) |> arrange(benchmark_name, .by_group = TRUE) |> summarize( benchmarks = paste(unique(benchmark_name), collapse = ", "), .groups = "drop", ) |> left_join(evaluated_meta_competencies, by = "benchmark_meta_category") |> arrange(desc(p)) |> write_csv(str_glue("{output_dir}/derived/evaluated-meta-categories.csv"), na = "") ## Yearly breakdown of benchmark competencies: Table 5 core_categorizations |> left_join(core_benchmarks, by = "benchmark_id") |> mutate(year = year(paper_published_at)) |> count(benchmark_meta_category, benchmark_category, year) |> group_by(benchmark_category) |> mutate(p = n / sum(n)) |> pivot_wider( names_from = year, values_from = c(n, p), names_glue = "{.value}_{year}", names_sort = TRUE ) |> arrange(benchmark_meta_category, benchmark_category) |> write_csv(str_glue("{output_dir}/derived/evaluated-competencies-by-year.csv"), na = "") ## Prescribed competencies by model publishers within "Coding" benchmarks: Figure 1 prescribed_competencies_coding <- core_highlights |> left_join(rankings, by = "benchmark_id") |> inner_join(core_categorizations, by = "benchmark_id", relationship = "many-to-many") |> left_join(core_benchmarks, by = "benchmark_id") |> filter(benchmark_category == "Coding") |> select(benchmark_id, benchmark_name, model_id, prescribed_category, rank) |> write_csv(str_glue("{output_dir}/derived/prescribed-competencies-coding.csv"), na = "") ## Prescribed competencies by model publishes for the LiveCodeBench benchmark: RQ2 prescribed_competencies_coding |> filter(benchmark_id == "lcb") |> count(prescribed_category) |> distinct(prescribed_category, n) |> mutate(p = n / sum(n)) |> write_csv(str_glue("{output_dir}/derived/prescribed-competencies-lcb.csv"), na = "") top_15_coding_benchmarks <- prescribed_competencies_coding |> distinct(benchmark_name, rank) |> slice_min(order_by = rank, n = 5, with_ties = FALSE) |> pull(benchmark_name) prescribed_competencies_coding |> filter(!is.na(prescribed_category)) |> filter(benchmark_name %in% top_15_coding_benchmarks) |> mutate(prescribed_category = factor(prescribed_category)) |> mutate(benchmark_name = fct_reorder(benchmark_name, rank, .desc = TRUE)) |> count(benchmark_name, prescribed_category) |> complete(benchmark_name, prescribed_category) |> ggplot(aes(x = prescribed_category, y = benchmark_name)) + geom_tile( data = \(x) filter(x, is.na(n)), fill = "grey95", color = "white", linewidth = 0.5 ) + geom_tile( data = \(x) filter(x, !is.na(n)), aes(fill = n), color = "white", linewidth = 0.5 ) + geom_text( data = \(x) filter(x, !is.na(n)), aes(label = n, color = n > max(n, na.rm = TRUE) / 2), size = 4, show.legend = FALSE ) + scale_color_manual(values = c("black", "white")) + scale_fill_viridis_c(option = "plasma", name = "Number of\nHighlights", direction = -1) + labs( x = "Prescribed Category", y = NULL, title = "Prescribed Competencies by Model Publisher", subtitle = "Within Top 5 Coding Benchmarks", caption = 'From: "Unsteady Metrics and Benchmarking Cultures of AI Model Builders", submitted to FAccT 2026' ) + theme_minimal() + theme( axis.text.x = element_text(angle = 45, hjust = 1), panel.grid = element_blank() ) + coord_fixed(ratio = 1) ggsave( filename = str_glue("{output_dir}/figures/prescribed-competencies-coding.png"), width = 10, height = 6, dpi = 300, bg = "white" ) ## Prescribed competencies by model publishers within top 15 "Reasoning and knowledge" benchmarks: Figure 4 prescribed_competencies_reasoning_knowledge <- rankings |> slice_min(order_by = rank, n = 15, with_ties = TRUE) |> inner_join(core_highlights, by = "benchmark_id") |> filter(rank <= 15) |> inner_join(core_categorizations, by = "benchmark_id", relationship = "many-to-many") |> left_join(core_benchmarks, by = "benchmark_id") |> filter(benchmark_category == "Reasoning and knowledge") |> select(benchmark_id, benchmark_name, model_id, prescribed_category, rank) |> write_csv(str_glue("{output_dir}/derived/prescribed-competencies-reasoning-knowledge.csv"), na = "") prescribed_competencies_reasoning_knowledge |> filter(!is.na(prescribed_category)) |> # For consistency, we remove MMMLU from the graph, since it is also missing in # other tables/figures mentioning the Top 5 "Reasoning and knowledge" # benchmarks. See footnote in paper. filter(benchmark_id != "mmmlu") |> mutate(prescribed_category = factor(prescribed_category)) |> mutate(benchmark_name = fct_reorder(benchmark_name, rank, .desc = TRUE)) |> count(benchmark_name, prescribed_category) |> complete(benchmark_name, prescribed_category) |> ggplot(aes(x = prescribed_category, y = benchmark_name, fill = n)) + geom_tile( data = \(x) filter(x, is.na(n)), fill = "grey95", color = "white", linewidth = 0.5 ) + geom_tile( data = \(x) filter(x, !is.na(n)), aes(fill = n), color = "white", linewidth = 0.5 ) + geom_text( data = \(x) filter(x, !is.na(n)), aes(label = n, color = n > max(n, na.rm = TRUE) / 2), size = 4, show.legend = FALSE ) + scale_color_manual(values = c("black", "white")) + scale_fill_viridis_c(option = "plasma", name = "Number of\nHighlights", direction = -1) + labs( x = "Prescribed Category", y = NULL, title = "Prescribed Competencies by Model Builders", subtitle = "Within Reasoning and Knowledge Category of the Top 15 Benchmarks", caption = 'From: "Unsteady Metrics and Benchmarking Cultures of AI Model Builders", submitted to FAccT 2026', ) + theme_minimal() + theme( axis.text.x = element_text(angle = 45, hjust = 1), panel.grid = element_blank() # Removes default gridlines behind tiles ) + coord_fixed(ratio = 1) ggsave( filename = str_glue("{output_dir}/figures/prescribed-competencies-reasoning-knowledge.png"), width = 10, height = 6, dpi = 300, bg = "white" ) # Percentage of Unique Models for top 15 Reasoning and knowledge reasoning_and_knowledge_benchmark_ids <- prescribed_competencies_reasoning_knowledge |> distinct(benchmark_id) |> pull(benchmark_id) core_highlights |> summarize( n = n_distinct(model_id[benchmark_id %in% reasoning_and_knowledge_benchmark_ids]), p = (n / n_distinct(model_id)) ) |> write_csv(str_glue("{output_dir}/derived/reasoning-knowledge-unique-models.csv"), na = "") ##################### ## Benchmark Adoption ##################### ## Yearly releases of becnhmarks by year: RQ4 core_benchmarks |> mutate(year = year(paper_published_at)) |> count(year) |> mutate(p = n / sum(n)) |> distinct(year, n, p) |> arrange(year) |> write_csv(str_glue("{output_dir}/derived/benchmark-releases-by-year.csv"), na = "") ## Adoption of benchmarks released in 2025: Figure 2 highlights_2025 <- core_highlights |> left_join(core_benchmarks, by = "benchmark_id") |> filter(year(paper_published_at) == "2025") |> left_join(core_models, by = "model_id") |> # Calculate the 'T-Zero' relative time # This normalizes all benchmarks to start at Month 0 mutate(months_since_release = interval(paper_published_at, model_published_at) %/% months(1)) |> # Filter out observations that happened before official pub filter(months_since_release >= 0) |> group_by(benchmark_id, benchmark_name, months_since_release) |> summarise(monthly_count = n(), .groups = "drop_last") |> # Calculate cumulative sum for the S-Curve mutate(cumulative_popularity = cumsum(monthly_count)) |> # Calculate Velocity (Growth rate) # This shows how many new 'mentions' happen per month mutate(velocity = cumulative_popularity - lag(cumulative_popularity, default = 0)) |> write_csv(str_glue("{output_dir}/derived/highlights-2025.csv"), na = "") top_highlights_2025 <- highlights_2025 |> group_by(benchmark_name) |> summarize(max_pop = max(cumulative_popularity)) |> slice_max(max_pop, n = 5) |> pull(benchmark_name) other_highlights_2025 <- c("ARC-AGI-2", "Tau2-bench", "Creative Writing") highlight_palette <- setNames( c(viridis::plasma(5), "#D3D3D3"), # 5 colors + light grey c(top_highlights_2025, "Other") ) highlights_2025_label_data <- highlights_2025 |> group_by(benchmark_name) |> filter(months_since_release == max(months_since_release)) highlights_2025_label_data_filtered <- highlights_2025_label_data |> filter(benchmark_name %in% top_highlights_2025) highlights_2025_other_label_data_filtered <- highlights_2025_label_data |> filter(benchmark_name %in% other_highlights_2025) highlights_2025_plot_data <- highlights_2025 |> mutate(highlight_color = case_when( benchmark_name %in% top_highlights_2025 ~ benchmark_name, benchmark_name %in% other_highlights_2025 ~ "Secondary", TRUE ~ "Other" )) ggplot( highlights_2025_plot_data, aes( x = months_since_release, y = cumulative_popularity, group = benchmark_name, color = highlight_color, ) ) + # Draw the grey lines first, then the colored lines on top geom_line(data = filter(highlights_2025_plot_data, highlight_color == "Other"), size = 0.7, alpha = 0.6) + geom_line(data = filter(highlights_2025_plot_data, highlight_color == "Secondary"), size = 1.2, alpha = 0.6) + geom_line(data = filter(highlights_2025_plot_data, highlight_color != "Other"), size = 1.2, alpha = 1) + # Apply our custom palette scale_color_manual(values = highlight_palette) + geom_text_repel( data = highlights_2025_label_data_filtered, aes(label = benchmark_name, x = months_since_release, y = cumulative_popularity), inherit.aes = FALSE, hjust = 0, nudge_x = 0.5, direction = "y", segment.color = "grey" ) + geom_text_repel( data = highlights_2025_other_label_data_filtered, aes(label = benchmark_name, x = months_since_release, y = cumulative_popularity), inherit.aes = FALSE, hjust = 0, nudge_x = 0.5, direction = "y", segment.color = "grey" ) + scale_x_continuous(expand = expansion(mult = c(0.05, 0.3))) + theme_minimal() + theme(legend.position = "none") + labs( x = "Months Since Release", y = "Cumulative Highlights", title = "Adoption of Benchmarks Released in 2025", caption = 'From: "Unsteady Metrics and Benchmarking Cultures of AI Model Builders", submitted to FAccT 2026', ) ggsave( filename = str_glue("{output_dir}/figures/highlights-2025.png"), width = 10, height = 6, dpi = 300, bg = "white" ) ## Highlights of selected competencies by model builders: Figure 3 category_names <- c( "Coding", "Math", "Reasoning and knowledge", "Strategic planning", "Tool orchestration" ) highlighted_competencies <- core_categorizations |> left_join(core_highlights, by = "benchmark_id", relationship = "many-to-many") |> left_join(core_benchmarks, by = "benchmark_id") |> left_join(core_models, by = "model_id") |> mutate(month = floor_date(model_published_at, "month")) |> count(month, benchmark_meta_category, benchmark_category) |> write_csv(str_glue("{output_dir}/derived/highlighted-competencies-by-month.csv"), na = "") highlighted_competencies |> filter(benchmark_category %in% category_names) |> ggplot(aes(x = month, y = n, color = benchmark_category)) + geom_line(alpha = 0.5) + geom_point(alpha = 0.5) + geom_smooth(method = "lm", se = FALSE, size = 1.2) + scale_color_viridis_d(option = "plasma") + scale_fill_viridis_d(option = "plasma") + scale_x_date(date_labels = "%b %Y", date_breaks = "1 month") + labs( x = "Month of Model Publication", y = "Number of Highlights", color = "Assigned Competency", title = "Highlights of Selected Competencies by Model Builders", caption = 'From: "Unsteady Metrics and Benchmarking Cultures of AI Model Builders", submitted to FAccT 2026' ) + guides(color = guide_legend(ncol = 1)) + theme_minimal() + theme(axis.text.x = element_text(angle = 45, hjust = 1)) ggsave( filename = str_glue("{output_dir}/figures/highlighted-competencies-by-month.png"), width = 10, height = 6, dpi = 300, bg = "white" ) # Highlighted competencies: Figure 5 (Appendix) palette_families <- c( "Blues", "Reds", "Greens", "Purples", "Oranges", "Greys", "YlGn", "BuPu" ) highlighted_competencies_custom_colors <- highlighted_competencies |> distinct(benchmark_meta_category, benchmark_category) |> arrange(benchmark_meta_category, benchmark_category) |> group_by(benchmark_meta_category) |> mutate( pal_name = palette_families[cur_group_id()], color = colorRampPalette(brewer.pal(max(3, n()), pal_name[1]))(n()) ) |> ungroup() |> select(benchmark_category, color) |> deframe() highlighted_competencies |> # Crucial: Order the factors so the legend naturally groups the meta-categories together arrange(benchmark_meta_category, benchmark_category) |> mutate(benchmark_category = fct_inorder(benchmark_category)) |> ggplot(aes(x = month, y = n, color = benchmark_category, fill = benchmark_category)) + geom_line(alpha = 0.5) + geom_point(alpha = 0.5) + geom_smooth(method = "lm", se = FALSE, linewidth = 1.2) + facet_wrap(~benchmark_meta_category, scales = "free_y") + scale_color_manual(values = highlighted_competencies_custom_colors) + scale_fill_manual(values = highlighted_competencies_custom_colors) + scale_x_date(date_labels = "%b %Y", date_breaks = "3 month") + labs( x = "Month of Model Publication", y = "Number of Highlights", color = "Assigned Competency", fill = "Assigned Competency", title = "Highlights of Competencies by Model Builders", caption = 'From: "Unsteady Metrics and Benchmarking Cultures of AI Model Builders", submitted to FAccT 2026' ) + guides(color = guide_legend( ncol = 5, byrow = TRUE, title.position = "top", override.aes = list(linewidth = 2) )) + theme_minimal() + theme( axis.text.x = element_text(angle = 45, hjust = 1), legend.position = "bottom", legend.text = element_text(size = 8), legend.key.width = unit(1, "cm"), legend.box.margin = margin(t = 10) ) ggsave( filename = str_glue("{output_dir}/figures/highlighted-competencies-by-month-facets.png"), width = 10, height = 10, dpi = 300, bg = "white" ) ## Distribution of benchmark adoption: Table 6 rankings |> select(starts_with("n_")) |> pivot_longer( cols = everything(), names_to = "column_name", values_to = "highlights" ) |> filter(!is.na(highlights)) |> mutate(column_name = str_remove(column_name, "^n_")) |> count(column_name, highlights) |> group_by(column_name) |> mutate(p = (n / sum(n))) |> ungroup() |> pivot_wider( names_from = column_name, values_from = c(n, p), names_vary = "slowest" ) |> select( highlights, ends_with("_publishers"), ends_with("_publishers_west"), ends_with("_publishers_china"), ends_with("_models"), ends_with("_models_closed"), ends_with("_models_open-weight"), ends_with("_models_open-source"), ) |> arrange(highlights) |> write_csv(str_glue("{output_dir}/derived/benchmark-adoption.csv"), na = "") ################################### ## Knowledge and reasoning subjects ################################### ## Distribution of subjects covered in "Reasoning and Knowledge" benchmarks: Table 8 core_knowledge_subjects |> count(field, wt = n, sort = TRUE) |> mutate(p = n / sum(n)) |> write_csv(str_glue("{output_dir}/derived/subjects-covered.csv"), na = "") ## Breakdown of Science Questions by discipline: Table 9 core_knowledge_subjects |> filter(!is.na(science_discipline)) |> count(science_discipline, wt = n, sort = TRUE) |> mutate(p = n / sum(n)) |> write_csv(str_glue("{output_dir}/derived/science-subjects-covered.csv"), na = "")