ggfox00000's picture
Upload ICSI full mirror (75 wav + ICSI NXT + ICSIplus contrib + MRT)
e0cf8ff verified
<?xml version="1.0" encoding="iso-8859-1"?>
<!DOCTYPE Meeting SYSTEM "http://www.icsi.berkeley.edu/Speech/mr/Meeting1.dtd">
<Meeting Session="Bed005" DateTimeStamp="2001-03-12-1500" Version="2" VersionDate="Jan 7 2004">
<Preamble>
<Notes>
PZM4 was out of its styrofoam holder.
me010 did not read digits.
Channel 2 (mn015) has a lot of distortion.
Meeting actually ends at 1 hour 3 minutes, i.e., at 16:03
rather than 16:11.
</Notes>
<Channels>
<Channel Name="chan0" Mic="c1" Transmission="w1" Gain="9" AudioFile="chan0.sph"/>
<Channel Name="chan1" Mic="s1" Transmission="w1" Gain="9" AudioFile="chan1.sph"/>
<Channel Name="chan2" Mic="s1" Transmission="w1" Gain="9" AudioFile="chan2.sph"/>
<Channel Name="chan3" Mic="s1" Transmission="w1" Gain="9" AudioFile="chan3.sph"/>
<Channel Name="chan4" Mic="s1" Transmission="w1" Gain="9" AudioFile="chan4.sph"/>
<Channel Name="chan5" Mic="c1" Transmission="w1" Gain="9" AudioFile="chan5.sph"/>
<Channel Name="chan6" Mic="c2" Transmission="u1" Gain="9" AudioFile="chan6.sph"/>
<Channel Name="chan7" Mic="c2" Transmission="u1" Gain="9" AudioFile="chan7.sph"/>
<Channel Name="chanC" Mic="u3" Transmission="j1" Gain="12" AudioFile="chanC.sph"/>
<Channel Name="chanD" Mic="u3" Transmission="j1" Gain="12" AudioFile="chanD.sph"/>
<Channel Name="chanE" Mic="c2" Transmission="u1" Gain="9" AudioFile="chanE.sph"/>
<Channel Name="chanF" Mic="c2" Transmission="u1" Gain="9" AudioFile="chanF.sph"/>
</Channels>
<Participants DB="icsi1.spk">
<Participant Name="me003" Channel="chan0"/>
<Participant Name="me010" Channel="chan1"/>
<Participant Name="mn015" Channel="chan2"/>
<Participant Name="me012" Channel="chan3"/>
<Participant Name="fe004" Channel="chan4"/>
<Participant Name="mn036" Channel="chan5"/>
</Participants>
</Preamble>
<Transcript StartTime="0.0" EndTime="3962.16">
<Segment StartTime="10.737" EndTime="12.430" Participant="me003">
Yeah, I think I got my mike on.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="10.800" EndTime="11.525" Participant="mn015">
<VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="12.410" EndTime="13.520" Participant="fe004">
<VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="13.261" EndTime="15.016" Participant="mn015">
<VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="14.108" EndTime="15.300" Participant="me003">
O_K.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="16.261" EndTime="17.266" Participant="mn015">
<NonVocalSound Description="mike noise"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="16.980" EndTime="18.727" Participant="me003">
Let's see.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="17.309" EndTime="20.100" Participant="mn015">
<VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="17.672" EndTime="139.987" CloseMic="false">
<Comment Description="digits task"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="18.727" EndTime="24.014" Participant="me003" DigitTask="true">
three eight eight, seven one, four six two seven <Comment Description="Digits"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="19.796" EndTime="21.470" Participant="fe004">
<VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="20.656" EndTime="40.352" Participant="mn015">
<VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="24.304" EndTime="29.910" Participant="me003" DigitTask="true">
six nine two, six four O_, nine seven nine <Comment Description="Digits"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="24.690" EndTime="25.480" Participant="fe004">
<VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="30.160" EndTime="37.940" Participant="me003" DigitTask="true">
two one, one six, zero two, three zero, nine six <Comment Description="Digits"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="38.370" EndTime="43.188" Participant="me003" DigitTask="true">
eight six one, six four, eight nine three six <Comment Description="Digits"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="40.761" EndTime="42.529" Participant="mn015">
<VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="43.214" EndTime="45.041" Participant="mn015">
<VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="43.479" EndTime="48.527" Participant="me003" DigitTask="true">
four O_ eight, five six nine, eight eight zero <Comment Description="Digits"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="47.359" EndTime="90.459" Participant="mn015">
<VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="49.100" EndTime="56.605" Participant="me003" DigitTask="true">
zero seven, four two, eight two, four four, nine one <Comment Description="Digits"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="54.030" EndTime="54.072" Participant="fe004">
<VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="54.072" EndTime="54.398" Participant="fe004">
<VocalSound Description="sniff"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="56.882" EndTime="64.001" Participant="me003" DigitTask="true">
five, four one five, seven seven, one one nine, seven <Comment Description="Digits"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="64.426" EndTime="69.280" Participant="me003" DigitTask="true">
four eight seven, nine three, four two four zero. <Comment Description="Digits"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="70.029" EndTime="72.102" Participant="me010">
O_K. Ami, do yours then we'll <Uncertain> open it </Uncertain> and I think it'll be enough.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="80.928" EndTime="84.040" Participant="me003">
Mmm - Doesn't, uh - It should be the other way. Yeah, now it's on.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="83.435" EndTime="84.739" Participant="mn036">
Right. O_K.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="85.876" EndTime="91.455" Participant="mn036" DigitTask="true">
One five six, seven four one, five six four <Comment Description="Digits"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="91.759" EndTime="98.578" Participant="mn036" DigitTask="true">
zero five one, four five three, nine two zero five <Comment Description="Digits"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="92.492" EndTime="98.138" Participant="mn015">
<VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="98.138" EndTime="114.187" Participant="mn015">
<NonVocalSound Description="mike noise"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="98.874" EndTime="104.353" Participant="mn036" DigitTask="true">
one three three eight, zero, two five zero <Comment Description="Digits"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="103.410" EndTime="105.678" Participant="fe004">
<VocalSound Description="breath-laugh"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="104.860" EndTime="109.461" Participant="mn036" DigitTask="true">
eight zero three six, nine, two eight nine <Comment Description="Digits"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="109.937" EndTime="115.731" Participant="mn036" DigitTask="true">
six seven one, one nine, eight one nine nine <Comment Description="Digits"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="114.187" EndTime="145.172" Participant="mn015">
<VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="116.150" EndTime="123.998" Participant="mn036" DigitTask="true">
eight, five zero eight, nine eight, four five five, eight <Comment Description="Digits"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="120.770" EndTime="121.830" Participant="fe004">
<VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="124.150" EndTime="126.310" Participant="fe004">
<VocalSound Description="clears throat"/> <VocalSound Description="sniff"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="124.320" EndTime="130.932" Participant="mn036" DigitTask="true">
three zero seven, seven eight four, eight one seven <Comment Description="Digits"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="126.310" EndTime="129.767" Participant="fe004">
<VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="131.296" EndTime="137.560" Participant="mn036" DigitTask="true">
zero eight three nine, eight, three eight three. <Comment Description="Digits"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="139.987" EndTime="142.485" CloseMic="false">
<Comment Description="start of non-digits part of meeting"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="140.080" EndTime="141.760" Participant="me010">
O_K. So, we all switched on?
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="142.230" EndTime="146.460" Participant="me003">
<VocalSound Description="breath-laugh"/> We are <Emphasis> all </Emphasis> switched on, yeah. <VocalSound Description="laugh"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="144.460" EndTime="145.570" Participant="fe004">
<VocalSound Description="breath-laugh"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="144.510" EndTime="153.300" Participant="me010">
Alright. Anyway. So, uh, before we get started with the, uh, <Emphasis> technical </Emphasis> part, I just want to review what I <Emphasis> think </Emphasis> is happening with the -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="145.010" EndTime="146.201" Participant="mn036">
We are all switched on.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="145.172" EndTime="147.015" Participant="mn015">
<VocalSound Description="breath-laugh"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="151.319" EndTime="157.381" Participant="mn015">
<VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="152.355" EndTime="155.247" Participant="me012">
<NonVocalSound Description="mike noise"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="153.300" EndTime="155.470" Participant="me010">
<Emphasis> our </Emphasis> data collection. <VocalSound Description="mouth"/> So -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="155.644" EndTime="158.121" Participant="me010">
<VocalSound Description="mouth"/> Uh, probably after today, <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="158.121" EndTime="164.536" Participant="me010">
that shouldn't come up in this meeting. Th- this - this is s- <Pronounce> should </Pronounce> be im- it isn't - There's another thing going on of gathering data, <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="158.380" EndTime="159.970" Participant="mn036">
<VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="160.209" EndTime="163.674" Participant="mn015">
<NonVocalSound Description="mike noise"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="164.536" EndTime="167.598" Participant="me010">
and that's pretty much independent of this. <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="166.680" EndTime="168.154" Participant="mn036">
<VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="167.598" EndTime="171.773" Participant="me010">
But, uh, I just want to make sure we're all together on this. <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="171.773" EndTime="175.590" Participant="me010">
What we think is gonna happen is that,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="175.590" EndTime="180.304" Participant="me010">
uh, in <Emphasis> parallel </Emphasis> starting about now <VocalSound Description="breath"/> we're gonna get Fey <VocalSound Description="mouth"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="180.304" EndTime="181.654" Participant="me010">
to,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="181.654" EndTime="190.601" Participant="me010">
where you're working with me and Robert, draft a note that we're gonna send out to various CogSci c- and other classes saying, "here's an opportunity to be a subject. <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="188.560" EndTime="189.310" Participant="fe004">
<VocalSound Description="sniff"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="190.601" EndTime="192.406" Participant="me010">
Contact Fey." <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="192.406" EndTime="199.296" Participant="me010">
And then there'll be a certain number of um, hours during the week which she will be available and we'll bring in
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="192.620" EndTime="193.340" Participant="fe004">
<VocalSound Description="sniff"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="199.296" EndTime="200.906" Participant="me010">
people. Uh, roughly how many, Robert?
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="201.231" EndTime="201.904" Participant="me010">
We d- Do we know?
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="201.302" EndTime="204.190" Participant="mn015">
<VocalSound Description="mouth"/> Um, fifty was <Uncertain> our </Uncertain> - sort of our first -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="202.912" EndTime="210.265" Participant="me010">
O_K. So, we're looking for a total of fifty people, <VocalSound Description="breath"/> not necessarily by <Emphasis> any </Emphasis> means all students but we'll s- we'll start with - with that.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="210.265" EndTime="214.402" Participant="me010">
<VocalSound Description="breath"/> In <Emphasis> parallel </Emphasis> with that, we're gonna need to actually do the <Emphasis> script. </Emphasis>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="214.546" EndTime="215.020" Participant="fe004">
<VocalSound Description="sniff"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="214.630" EndTime="215.074" Participant="me010">
<VocalSound Description="mouth"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="215.074" EndTime="219.242" Participant="me010">
And, so, I guess there's a plan to have a meeting Friday afternoon
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="219.692" EndTime="227.697" Participant="me010">
Uh, with - uh, Jane, and maybe Liz and <Emphasis> whoever, </Emphasis> on actually getting the script worked out.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="219.995" EndTime="226.977" Participant="me012">
<NonVocalSound Description="mike noise"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="225.990" EndTime="226.740" Participant="fe004">
<VocalSound Description="sniff"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="227.697" EndTime="230.063" Participant="me010">
But what I'd <Emphasis> like </Emphasis> to do, if it's O_<Emphasis> K, </Emphasis> <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="230.063" EndTime="230.981" Participant="me010">
is to s-
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="230.981" EndTime="235.342" Participant="me010">
to, as I say, start the recruiting in parallel and possibly start running subjects next week.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="235.342" EndTime="240.848" Participant="me010">
The week after that's Spring Break, and maybe we'll look for them - some subjects next door or <Pause/> i-
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="238.980" EndTime="239.746" Participant="mn015">
<Uncertain> Yeah </Uncertain>.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="240.412" EndTime="243.430" Participant="mn015">
Yeah. Also, <Emphasis> Fey </Emphasis> will not be here during spring break. So.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="242.530" EndTime="244.915" Participant="me010">
Oh, O_K, then we won't do it. O_K. So that's easy.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="245.140" EndTime="247.210" Participant="me010">
<VocalSound Description="inbreath"/> Um.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="245.951" EndTime="251.904" Participant="mn015">
<NonVocalSound Description="mike noise"/> <Comment Description="takes mike off, background coughing"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="247.000" EndTime="248.680" CloseMic="false">
<VocalSound Description="[mn015] coughs in background, off close-mike"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="249.340" EndTime="250.950" Participant="me010">
So, is - Is <Emphasis> that </Emphasis>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="251.192" EndTime="252.460" Participant="me010">
make sense to everybody?
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="251.904" EndTime="256.321" Participant="mn015">
Yeah. Also, um, F- <VocalSound Description="breath"/> both Fey and I will, um, <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="256.321" EndTime="257.822" Participant="mn015">
do something of which I may, eh -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="257.822" EndTime="265.371" Participant="mn015">
kindly ask you to - to do the same thing, which is we gonna check out our <Emphasis> social </Emphasis> infrastructures for possible subjects. Meaning, <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="265.371" EndTime="270.140" Participant="mn015">
um, kid children's gymnastic classes, pre-school parents and so forth. <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="270.140" EndTime="272.623" Participant="mn015">
They also sometimes have flexible schedules. <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="272.623" EndTime="279.734" Participant="mn015">
So, if you happen to be sort of in a non-student social setting, and you know people who may be interested in being subjects - <Comment Description="abandoned as clear"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="279.734" EndTime="284.406" Participant="mn015">
We also considered using the Berkeley High School and their teachers, maybe, <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="284.406" EndTime="286.490" Participant="mn015">
and get <Emphasis> them </Emphasis> interested in
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="286.370" EndTime="287.430" Participant="me010">
That's a good idea.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="286.490" EndTime="288.284" Participant="mn015">
stuff. <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="288.284" EndTime="289.875" Participant="mn015">
And, um. <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="289.875" EndTime="292.460" Participant="mn015">
So that's as far as our brainstorming was concerned.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="292.314" EndTime="294.160" Participant="me010">
Oh, yeah. The <Emphasis> high </Emphasis> school's a <Emphasis> great </Emphasis> idea.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="293.545" EndTime="294.910" Participant="fe004">
<VocalSound Description="swallowing"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="296.333" EndTime="296.778" Participant="mn015">
<VocalSound Description="inbreath"/> <Comment Description="as if to speak"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="298.409" EndTime="299.517" Participant="mn015">
So.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="299.517" EndTime="305.223" Participant="mn015">
<VocalSound Description="breath"/> But I - I will just make a first draft of the, uh, <Emphasis> note, </Emphasis> the "write-up" note, send it to you and Fey and then -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="305.560" EndTime="307.930" Participant="me010">
<VocalSound Description="mouth"/> And why don't you also copy Jane on it?
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="310.352" EndTime="311.883" Participant="mn015">
And, um,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="311.883" EndTime="318.420" Participant="mn015">
Are we - Have we concurred that, uh, these - these forms are sufficient for us, and necessary? <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="318.420" EndTime="320.729" Participant="me010">
Uh, th- I think they're <Emphasis> necessary. </Emphasis>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="320.729" EndTime="322.320" Participant="me010">
<VocalSound Description="inbreath"/> This - The <Emphasis> permission </Emphasis> form.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="321.808" EndTime="323.663" Participant="mn015">
Mmm. Nuh.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="322.320" EndTime="326.980" Participant="me010">
Uh, there <Emphasis> has </Emphasis> to <Emphasis> be </Emphasis> one, and I think we're just gonna use it as it is, and <Pause/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="325.949" EndTime="326.886" Participant="mn015">
N_.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="326.980" EndTime="327.885" Participant="me010">
Um <Pause/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="327.885" EndTime="329.020" Participant="me010">
<VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="328.342" EndTime="329.195" Participant="mn015">
You happy with that?
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="329.020" EndTime="331.030" Participant="me010">
Well, yeah. There's one tricky part
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="331.397" EndTime="332.725" Participant="me010">
about,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="332.725" EndTime="335.394" Participant="me010">
um, they have the right <Pause/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="336.116" EndTime="337.766" Participant="me010">
um <Pause/> <Comment Description="shuffling papers"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="337.766" EndTime="343.834" Participant="me010">
I- The last paragraph <Comment Description="colon"/> "if you agree to participate you have the opportunity to have anything excised which you would prefer not to have included in the data set."
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="344.330" EndTime="348.119" Participant="me010">
O_K? <VocalSound Description="breath"/> Now <Emphasis> that, </Emphasis> we- had to be included for this
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="348.119" EndTime="354.515" Participant="me010">
<Emphasis> other </Emphasis> one which might have, uh, meetings, you know, <Emphasis> about </Emphasis> something. In this case, it doesn't <Emphasis> really </Emphasis> make sense.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="348.880" EndTime="349.884" Participant="mn015">
Mm-hmm.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="355.346" EndTime="358.504" Participant="me010">
Um, so what I'd <Emphasis> like </Emphasis> to do
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="358.504" EndTime="362.167" Participant="me010">
is <Emphasis> also </Emphasis> have <Emphasis> our </Emphasis> subjects sign a waiver
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="362.167" EndTime="364.418" Participant="me010">
saying "I don't want to see the final transcript".
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="364.117" EndTime="365.132" Participant="mn015">
Mm-hmm.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="364.707" EndTime="370.690" Participant="me010">
And if they <Emphasis> don't </Emphasis> - If they say "no, I'm not willing to <Emphasis> sign </Emphasis> that", then we'll <Emphasis> show </Emphasis> them the final transcript. But, um.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="370.430" EndTime="372.080" Participant="mn015">
<Uncertain> Yep </Uncertain>. Makes sense.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="371.008" EndTime="371.255" Participant="me010">
<VocalSound Description="mouth"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="371.864" EndTime="374.000" Participant="me010">
That, uh -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="374.000" EndTime="376.320" Participant="me010">
<Uncertain> yeah </Uncertain>, so we <Emphasis> might </Emphasis> actually, um <Pause/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="377.525" EndTime="380.849" Participant="me010">
S- i- <Emphasis> Jane </Emphasis> may say that, "you know, you can't <Emphasis> do </Emphasis> this", uh,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="380.849" EndTime="385.322" Participant="me010">
"on the same form, we need a <Emphasis> separate </Emphasis> form." But anyway. I'd - I'd - I'd like to,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="385.322" EndTime="393.310" Participant="me010">
e- e- um, add an- a little thi- eh - a thing for them to initial, saying "nah, do- I don't want to see the final transcript." But other than that, that's one's been approved,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="387.821" EndTime="388.708" Participant="mn015">
Mm-hmm.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="393.803" EndTime="395.799" Participant="me010">
this really <Emphasis> is </Emphasis> the same project,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="396.543" EndTime="399.160" Participant="me010">
uh, rec- you know. And so forth. So I think we just go with it.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="398.155" EndTime="398.805" Participant="mn015">
<Uncertain> Yeah </Uncertain>.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="399.332" EndTime="400.098" Participant="mn015">
<Uncertain> Yeah </Uncertain>.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="407.077" EndTime="407.720" Participant="mn015">
O_K.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="408.230" EndTime="409.620" Participant="mn015">
So much for the data, <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="411.220" EndTime="413.726" Participant="mn015">
except that with Munich everything is fine now.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="413.726" EndTime="418.834" Participant="mn015">
They're gonna <VocalSound Description="breath"/> transcribe. They're also gonna translate the, uh, German data from the
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="418.834" EndTime="421.916" Participant="mn015">
T_V and cinema stuff for Andreas. So.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="421.916" EndTime="424.600" Participant="mn015">
They're - <Emphasis> they </Emphasis> all seem to be happy now, <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="424.600" EndTime="426.197" Participant="mn015">
with that. <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="427.241" EndTime="428.260" Participant="mn015">
<VocalSound Description="mouth"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="428.260" EndTime="432.440" Participant="mn015">
So. <VocalSound Description="breath"/> <Uncertain> w- c- </Uncertain> sh- should we move on to the technical sides? <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="431.564" EndTime="432.216" Participant="me010">
Yep.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="432.440" EndTime="436.350" Participant="mn015">
Well I guess the good - <Emphasis> good </Emphasis> news of <Emphasis> last </Emphasis> week was the <Emphasis> parser. </Emphasis>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="433.920" EndTime="434.722" Participant="fe004">
<VocalSound Description="sniff"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="437.245" EndTime="438.744" Participant="mn015">
So, um <Pause/> <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="438.744" EndTime="441.250" Participant="mn015">
Bhaskara and I started working on the - <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="441.250" EndTime="445.720" Participant="mn015">
the parser. Then Bhaskara went to class and once he came back, um, <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="446.230" EndTime="448.061" Participant="mn015">
it was finished. <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="447.350" EndTime="450.370" Participant="fe004">
<VocalSound Description="laugh"/> <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="447.704" EndTime="449.102" Participant="me012">
<VocalSound Description="laugh-breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="448.061" EndTime="450.391" Participant="mn015">
So. <VocalSound Description="laugh"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="450.391" EndTime="454.490" Participant="mn015">
It, uh - I didn't measure it, but it was about an hour and ten minutes.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="454.253" EndTime="455.780" Participant="me012">
Yep. Something like that.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="454.922" EndTime="460.930" Participant="mn015">
And, um - and now it's - We have a complete English parser that does everything the German parser does.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="459.310" EndTime="460.080" Participant="fe004">
<VocalSound Description="cough in background"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="461.175" EndTime="463.160" Participant="me010">
Which is <VocalSound Description="laugh"/> not a <Emphasis> lot. </Emphasis> But - <Pause/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="461.691" EndTime="464.232" Participant="me012">
That's the, uh, point. <VocalSound Description="laugh"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="461.975" EndTime="463.600" Participant="mn015">
<VocalSound Description="laugh"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="462.040" EndTime="462.740" Participant="me003">
<VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="462.890" EndTime="464.045" Participant="mn036">
<VocalSound Description="breath-laugh"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="463.600" EndTime="466.394" Participant="mn015">
The - uh, <Emphasis> that's </Emphasis> not a <Emphasis> lot. </Emphasis> <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="463.634" EndTime="464.920" Participant="me010">
<VocalSound Description="breath"/> O_K.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="464.232" EndTime="464.964" Participant="me012">
Yes.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="465.606" EndTime="466.973" Participant="me010">
Right. <VocalSound Description="inbreath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="466.387" EndTime="467.181" Participant="fe004">
<VocalSound Description="inbreath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="466.394" EndTime="467.410" Participant="mn015">
And um. <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="467.181" EndTime="470.430" Participant="fe004">
What did you end up having to do? I mean, wha- Was there anything <Pause/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="469.524" EndTime="471.520" Participant="mn015">
Well, if you, eh -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="470.506" EndTime="471.520" Participant="me012">
We'll show you.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="470.650" EndTime="472.670" Participant="fe004">
interesting about it at all? or are we gonna see that?
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="471.361" EndTime="472.600" Participant="me010">
Yeah, we can <Emphasis> show </Emphasis> us, right?
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="472.241" EndTime="473.619" Participant="mn015">
Well, w- w-
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="473.619" EndTime="481.489" Participant="mn015">
We d- The first we did is we - we tried to - to do - change the - the <Foreign Language="de" Description="&quot;run&quot;"> "laufen" </Foreign> into "run", <VocalSound Description="breath"/> or "running", <VocalSound Description="breath"/> or "runs". <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="479.952" EndTime="480.642" Participant="me010">
Yep.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="481.137" EndTime="481.886" Participant="fe004">
Mm-hmm.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="481.489" EndTime="485.352" Participant="mn015">
And we noticed that whatever we tried to do, it no effect. <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="485.190" EndTime="486.298" Participant="fe004">
O_K.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="485.352" EndTime="487.249" Participant="mn015">
And we were puzzled. <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="486.868" EndTime="487.525" Participant="fe004">
Mm-hmm.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="487.249" EndTime="490.697" Participant="mn015">
And, uh, the <Emphasis> reason </Emphasis> was that the parser i- c-
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="490.697" EndTime="493.305" Participant="mn015">
completely ignores the verb. <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="493.059" EndTime="496.170" Participant="fe004">
Hmm. <VocalSound Description="laugh"/> Interesting parser property. <Comment Description="while laughing"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="493.305" EndTime="495.430" Participant="mn015">
So <Emphasis> this </Emphasis> sentence -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="495.793" EndTime="498.122" Participant="me012">
<VocalSound Description="laugh-breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="495.980" EndTime="496.713" Participant="me003">
<VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="496.170" EndTime="497.603" Participant="mn015">
sentence is -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="496.570" EndTime="498.002" Participant="fe004">
<VocalSound Description="laugh"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="497.603" EndTime="500.160" Participant="mn015">
<Emphasis> parses </Emphasis> the p- the same output, <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="498.002" EndTime="499.190" Participant="fe004">
<VocalSound Description="inbreath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="498.743" EndTime="499.621" Participant="me012">
<NonVocalSound Description="mike noise"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="500.300" EndTime="504.090" Participant="mn015">
um, even if you leave out, um,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="500.355" EndTime="501.990" Participant="fe004">
<Emphasis> I </Emphasis> see. Yeah. <Comment Description="last word whispered"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="504.430" EndTime="509.931" Participant="mn015">
all - all of <Emphasis> this. </Emphasis> So it's basically feature film and T_V.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="509.280" EndTime="512.810" Participant="fe004">
Today <Pause/> O_K. And the - t- and the time, right?
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="509.931" EndTime="511.400" Participant="mn015">
That's what you need. <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="511.400" EndTime="519.920" Participant="mn015">
If - if you'd add - add Today and Evening, it'll add Time or not. So it - i- it <Emphasis> does </Emphasis> look at that. But all the rest is p- simply frosting on the cake, <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="515.260" EndTime="516.100" Participant="fe004">
O_K.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="519.920" EndTime="521.826" Participant="mn015">
and it's optional for that parser.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="520.134" EndTime="521.252" Participant="fe004">
True.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="521.826" EndTime="523.400" Participant="mn015">
<VocalSound Description="breath"/> And -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="522.294" EndTime="526.180" Participant="me010">
So, you can sho- You - you - Are - are you gonna show us the little templates? <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="523.309" EndTime="524.001" Participant="fe004">
<VocalSound Description="inbreath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="524.001" EndTime="524.966" Participant="fe004">
S-
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="524.612" EndTime="526.026" Participant="mn015">
<VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="526.410" EndTime="529.169" Participant="mn015">
Yeah. We ar- we can sh- er - I can show you the templates. <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="528.382" EndTime="530.800" Participant="fe004">
<Uncertain> "The former end g-" </Uncertain> <Comment Description="apparently reading"/> Oh, I see. Uh-huh.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="529.169" EndTime="532.350" Participant="mn015">
I - I also have it <Emphasis> running </Emphasis> here, so if I <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="532.526" EndTime="533.680" Participant="mn015">
do <Emphasis> this </Emphasis> now,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="534.445" EndTime="536.709" Participant="mn015">
um, <VocalSound Description="breath"/> you can see that
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="536.709" EndTime="542.262" Participant="mn015">
it parsed the wonderful English sentence, "Which films are on the cinema today <Pause/> evening?" <Comment Description="while smiling"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="542.197" EndTime="544.920" Participant="me010">
<VocalSound Description="laugh"/> Well, that sounds - <VocalSound Description="laugh"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="542.200" EndTime="544.720" Participant="fe004">
<VocalSound Description="laugh"/> <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="542.262" EndTime="543.850" Participant="mn015">
But, um. <VocalSound Description="laugh"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="543.960" EndTime="546.325" Participant="mn015">
Uh do- don't worry about it. It could be
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="545.501" EndTime="546.468" Participant="me010">
No i- <VocalSound Description="laugh"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="546.325" EndTime="550.126" Participant="mn015">
"<Emphasis> this </Emphasis> evening, which - which films are on the cinema", or "running in the cinema, which -"
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="548.148" EndTime="549.759" Participant="me012">
<VocalSound Description="laugh-breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="549.913" EndTime="550.927" Participant="fe004">
O_K.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="550.126" EndTime="551.595" Participant="mn015">
uh, "today evening", uh i-
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="551.595" EndTime="554.330" Participant="mn015">
"Is anything happening in the cinema this evening?"
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="554.039" EndTime="556.420" Participant="fe004">
O_K. <Emphasis> Key </Emphasis> words, e- basically.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="556.090" EndTime="556.393" Participant="mn015">
<VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="556.302" EndTime="557.035" Participant="me010">
<Emphasis> Well </Emphasis> <Pause/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="556.393" EndTime="561.050" Participant="mn015">
Ge- elaborate, or, more or less, <VocalSound Description="breath"/> uh - <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="557.872" EndTime="559.089" Participant="me010">
<NonVocalSound Description="mike noise"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="559.710" EndTime="561.655" Participant="me010">
Actually, it's a <Emphasis> little </Emphasis> tricky,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="562.169" EndTime="563.593" Participant="me010">
in that there's some
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="563.593" EndTime="569.560" Participant="me010">
allowable German orders which aren't allowable English orders and so forth. And it <Emphasis> is </Emphasis> order-based. So it - it -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="569.126" EndTime="570.255" Participant="me012">
<NonVocalSound Description="mike noise"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="569.968" EndTime="570.454" Participant="me010">
Isn't it?
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="570.255" EndTime="570.902" Participant="me012">
No.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="570.448" EndTime="571.084" Participant="mn015">
No.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="571.419" EndTime="573.346" Participant="me010">
<Emphasis> Oh. </Emphasis> So it - it doe- I- it - These -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="573.346" EndTime="576.350" Participant="me010">
u- these optional elements, it's - it's actually a <Emphasis> set, </Emphasis> not a <Emphasis> sequence? </Emphasis>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="573.410" EndTime="574.752" Participant="mn015">
It is not - <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="576.350" EndTime="579.410" Participant="mn015">
Yeah. We were - I was afraid that, um - <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="577.542" EndTime="578.946" Participant="me012">
<NonVocalSound Description="mike noise"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="578.280" EndTime="581.663" Participant="me010">
Oh! <VocalSound Description="laugh"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="580.020" EndTime="583.040" Participant="fe004">
So it really <Emphasis> is </Emphasis> key word matching, basically. <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="581.663" EndTime="582.549" Participant="me010">
<Emphasis> Really </Emphasis> a se-
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="581.960" EndTime="583.720" Participant="mn015">
<VocalSound Description="breath"/> Um. <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="582.375" EndTime="583.982" Participant="mn036">
e- yeah. <Uncertain> Mm-hmm. </Uncertain>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="583.882" EndTime="585.010" Participant="me010">
Oh, <Emphasis> wow. </Emphasis>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="587.290" EndTime="593.132" Participant="mn015">
Um, I mean, these sentences are just silly. I mean, uh, d- these were not the ones we - we actually <Emphasis> did </Emphasis> it. <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="587.783" EndTime="588.713" Participant="fe004">
<Emphasis> Hmm. </Emphasis>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="593.132" EndTime="597.810" Participant="mn015">
Um. What's an idiomatic of phrasing this? Which films are <Pause/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="596.782" EndTime="599.100" Participant="me012">
<Uncertain NumSyllables="1"> @@ </Uncertain> <Comment Description="uncodeable vocal sound"/> Are pl- <Emphasis> playing </Emphasis> at the cinema? <Comment Description="completing [mn015]'s utterance"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="597.810" EndTime="599.890" Participant="mn015">
showing? playing?
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="599.100" EndTime="599.723" Participant="me012">
Yeah.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="599.890" EndTime="607.508" Participant="mn015">
<NonVocalSound Description="keyboard typing in background"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="603.720" EndTime="604.540" Participant="fe004">
Tonight?
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="604.891" EndTime="605.650" Participant="fe004">
<VocalSound Description="laugh"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="605.505" EndTime="607.751" Participant="me012">
I changed that file, actually, where it's on my account.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="605.590" EndTime="609.850" Participant="mn036">
Actually, you would say, "which films are <Emphasis> on </Emphasis> tonight?"
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="605.650" EndTime="606.920" Participant="fe004">
This - this evening?
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="607.751" EndTime="610.580" Participant="me012">
You want to get it? Or - is - di- was it easy to get it?
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="611.171" EndTime="613.010" Participant="mn015">
Um. I have no net here.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="612.664" EndTime="613.600" Participant="me012">
Oh, O_K.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="613.207" EndTime="614.348" Participant="me010">
Do I? <Comment Description="whispered, offering"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="614.161" EndTime="615.305" Participant="me003">
<VocalSound Description="mouth"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="614.348" EndTime="615.074" Participant="me010">
<NonVocalSound Description="mike noise"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="616.840" EndTime="621.116" Participant="mn015">
O_K. So. Wonderful parse, same thing. <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="621.116" EndTime="622.160" Participant="mn015">
Um. <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="623.180" EndTime="624.275" Participant="me010">
Right. <VocalSound Description="breath-laugh"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="623.612" EndTime="624.419" Participant="mn015">
<VocalSound Description="mouth"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="624.419" EndTime="629.870" Participant="mn015">
Except that we d- w- we don't have this, uh, time information here now, which is,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="630.480" EndTime="632.713" Participant="mn015">
um - <Pause/> <Comment Description="distracted by laptop"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="634.790" EndTime="635.884" Participant="mn015">
Oh. This - are the reserve.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="635.884" EndTime="636.921" Participant="mn015">
<Emphasis> Anyways. </Emphasis> <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="636.921" EndTime="637.248" Participant="mn015">
So.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="637.248" EndTime="638.295" Participant="mn015">
<NonVocalSound Description="mike noise"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="638.295" EndTime="639.575" Participant="mn015">
Um.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="639.575" EndTime="643.490" Participant="mn015">
These are the - sort of the ten different sentence types
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="640.683" EndTime="643.713" Participant="me012">
<NonVocalSound Description="mike noise"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="643.490" EndTime="645.600" Participant="mn015">
that the uh - <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="645.600" EndTime="650.155" Participant="mn015">
the parser was able to do. And it still <Emphasis> is, </Emphasis> now in English. <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="649.599" EndTime="650.389" Participant="fe004">
Mm-hmm.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="649.638" EndTime="650.663" Participant="me010">
Yeah. <Comment Description="with aspirated glottal stop"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="650.155" EndTime="652.140" Participant="mn015">
And, um - Sorry. <Comment Description="probably referring to PowerPoint visual"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="652.752" EndTime="654.150" Participant="mn015">
And, um
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="655.083" EndTime="659.550" Participant="mn015">
you have already to make it a little bit more elaborate, right?
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="659.004" EndTime="661.910" Participant="me012">
Yeah, I mean I changed those sentences to make it, uh,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="662.526" EndTime="664.054" Participant="me012">
more, uh, idiomatic.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="664.054" EndTime="665.090" Participant="me012">
And, of course, you can have i-
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="665.090" EndTime="667.912" Participant="me012">
<Emphasis> many </Emphasis> variations in those sentences, they will still parse fine.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="668.286" EndTime="671.550" Participant="me012">
So, in a sense it's pretty broad. <VocalSound Description="laugh"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="669.507" EndTime="671.480" Participant="mn015">
<VocalSound Description="breath-laugh"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="669.734" EndTime="670.784" Participant="fe004">
<VocalSound Description="breath-laugh"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="671.380" EndTime="672.346" Participant="me010">
O_K.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="671.480" EndTime="672.652" Participant="mn015">
<Uncertain> O_K. </Uncertain>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="672.652" EndTime="675.970" Participant="mn015">
So, if you want to <Emphasis> look </Emphasis> at the templates, <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="675.124" EndTime="675.961" Participant="me012">
<NonVocalSound Description="mike noise"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="675.990" EndTime="676.740" Participant="mn015">
<VocalSound Description="clears throat"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="677.437" EndTime="680.120" Participant="mn015">
they're conveniently located in a file, "template".
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="681.168" EndTime="682.415" Participant="mn015">
Um, <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="682.415" EndTime="685.715" Participant="mn015">
and <Emphasis> this </Emphasis> is what I had to do. I had to change, <Uncertain NumSyllables="6"> @@ </Uncertain> <Comment Description="uncodeable vocal sounds"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="685.715" EndTime="690.550" Participant="mn015">
<Foreign Language="de"> "Spielfilm" </Foreign> to "film", uh, <Foreign Language="de"> "Film" </Foreign> to "movie", cinem- <Foreign Language="de"> "Kino" </Foreign> to "cinema" -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="691.443" EndTime="696.090" Participant="mn015">
to- "today" - heu- <Foreign Language="de"> "heute" </Foreign> to "today", evening - <Foreign Language="de"> "Abend" </Foreign> to "evening"
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="692.403" EndTime="693.200" Participant="fe004">
Huh.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="693.200" EndTime="694.362" Participant="fe004">
<VocalSound Description="laugh"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="695.326" EndTime="696.140" Participant="me010">
<VocalSound Description="laugh"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="696.360" EndTime="697.138" Participant="me012">
<VocalSound Description="inbreath"/> <Comment Description="as if to speak"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="696.497" EndTime="697.903" Participant="me010">
Capitalized as well <Pause/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="697.652" EndTime="698.967" Participant="me012">
<VocalSound Description="inbreath"/> <Comment Description="as if to speak"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="697.779" EndTime="698.670" Participant="me003">
Hmm.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="697.952" EndTime="700.440" Participant="mn015">
And, um. <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="699.076" EndTime="700.201" Participant="fe004">
<VocalSound Description="breath-laugh"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="699.236" EndTime="700.097" Participant="me010">
<VocalSound Description="inbreath"/> Y- i- <Comment Description="as if to speak"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="699.240" EndTime="700.625" Participant="me012">
One thing I was wondering, was,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="700.625" EndTime="703.723" Participant="me012">
those functions there, are those things that modify the M_-three-L_ basically?
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="701.490" EndTime="706.100" Participant="mn036">
<VocalSound Description="breath"/> <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="703.811" EndTime="704.859" Participant="mn015">
Yep.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="704.128" EndTime="704.885" Participant="me012">
O_K.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="705.536" EndTime="709.521" Participant="mn015">
And that's - that's the next step, but we'll get to that in a second. <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="707.545" EndTime="708.461" Participant="me010">
<VocalSound Description="inbreath"/> p- <Comment Description="as if to speak"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="709.521" EndTime="711.950" Participant="mn015">
And so <Emphasis> this </Emphasis> means, um,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="709.761" EndTime="711.155" Participant="me010">
<VocalSound Description="mouth"/> Oh. <VocalSound Description="outbreath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="712.659" EndTime="716.228" Participant="mn015">
"this" and "see" are not optional.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="716.228" EndTime="721.910" Participant="mn015">
"Want I like" is all <Emphasis> maybe </Emphasis> in there, but may also <Emphasis> not </Emphasis> be in there. <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="721.040" EndTime="725.356" Participant="me010">
So - so, the <Emphasis> point </Emphasis> is, if it says "<Emphasis> this </Emphasis>" and "<Emphasis> see </Emphasis>", it also will work in "<Emphasis> see </Emphasis>" and "<Emphasis> this </Emphasis>"?
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="721.644" EndTime="722.534" Participant="fe004">
S-
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="725.941" EndTime="727.029" Participant="me010">
In the other order?
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="726.062" EndTime="726.553" Participant="mn015">
Yeah.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="727.029" EndTime="728.457" Participant="me010">
with those two key words?
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="727.100" EndTime="728.250" Participant="mn015">
Should we try it?
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="733.318" EndTime="734.764" Participant="me010">
"This is the one I want to see"
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="735.289" EndTime="736.029" Participant="me010">
or whatever.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="737.286" EndTime="738.010" Participant="mn015">
O_K.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="738.010" EndTime="739.723" Participant="mn015">
"Action watch", <VocalSound Description="inbreath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="739.192" EndTime="739.542" Participant="me012">
Hmm.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="739.723" EndTime="742.757" Participant="mn015">
whatever. <Pronounce Pronunciation="&quot;nnnothing&quot;"> Nothing </Pronounce> was specialfi- specified. <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="742.757" EndTime="747.380" Participant="mn015">
<Emphasis> except </Emphasis> that it has some references to audio-visual media here. <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="744.116" EndTime="745.260" Participant="me012">
A_V medium. <Comment Description="completing [mn015]'s sentence"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="746.226" EndTime="747.258" Participant="me012">
<NonVocalSound Description="mike noise"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="747.258" EndTime="747.677" Participant="me012">
Yeah.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="747.603" EndTime="751.660" Participant="mn015">
Where it gets <Emphasis> that </Emphasis> from - <Comment Description="rising"/> It's correct, but I don't know where it gets it from.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="750.930" EndTime="751.700" Participant="me012">
"<Emphasis> See </Emphasis>".
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="751.869" EndTime="753.480" Participant="mn015">
Oh, "<Emphasis> see </Emphasis>". Yeah.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="753.147" EndTime="754.886" Participant="me012">
I mean it's sort of - <Comment Description="abandons as clear"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="753.480" EndTime="755.290" Participant="mn015">
Yeah. Yep. O_K. <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="755.290" EndTime="758.980" Participant="mn015">
And "see this" <Comment Description="rising intonation"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="759.554" EndTime="761.240" Participant="mn015">
is exactly the same thing. <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="761.161" EndTime="762.544" Participant="me012">
<NonVocalSound Description="mike noise"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="761.600" EndTime="763.160" Participant="me010">
O_K, so it <Emphasis> is </Emphasis> set-based. Alright.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="763.160" EndTime="764.248" Participant="me012">
One thing I was wondering was,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="764.248" EndTime="764.506" Participant="me012">
<VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="764.506" EndTime="766.475" Participant="me012">
those percentage signs, right? <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="766.475" EndTime="767.596" Participant="me012">
So, I mean,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="767.274" EndTime="767.957" Participant="mn015">
<VocalSound Description="inbreath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="767.596" EndTime="770.320" Participant="me012">
why do we even <Emphasis> have </Emphasis> them? Because - if you didn't have them - <Comment Description="abandoned as clear"/> <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="768.631" EndTime="769.228" Participant="mn015">
Yep.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="769.920" EndTime="773.320" Participant="mn015">
<VocalSound Description="laugh-cough"/> Uh, I'll <Emphasis> tell </Emphasis> you why. Because it gives a - you a <Emphasis> score. </Emphasis>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="773.225" EndTime="773.865" Participant="fe004">
Mm-hmm.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="773.683" EndTime="774.727" Participant="me012">
Oh.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="774.161" EndTime="777.385" Participant="mn015">
And the value of the score is, v- <Emphasis> I </Emphasis> assume,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="777.385" EndTime="782.460" Participant="mn015">
<Emphasis> I </Emphasis> guess, the more of these optional things that are actually in there, the higher the r- score <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="780.455" EndTime="781.022" Participant="me012">
O_K.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="780.840" EndTime="781.744" Participant="mn036">
Right.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="781.042" EndTime="782.135" Participant="fe004">
It's a match.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="781.236" EndTime="782.700" Participant="me012">
So <Emphasis> that's </Emphasis> the main purpose. Alright.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="782.700" EndTime="783.810" Participant="mn015">
it is.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="783.439" EndTime="784.190" Participant="fe004">
Mm-hmm.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="784.742" EndTime="785.268" Participant="me010">
O_K.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="787.601" EndTime="788.399" Participant="me012">
<VocalSound Description="laugh-breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="789.220" EndTime="793.030" Participant="mn015">
So we - we shouldn't belittle it <Emphasis> too </Emphasis> much. It's <Emphasis> doing </Emphasis> something,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="790.255" EndTime="791.671" Participant="me012">
<NonVocalSound Description="mike noise"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="793.291" EndTime="794.234" Participant="fe004">
<VocalSound Description="sniff"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="793.720" EndTime="794.780" Participant="mn015">
<Emphasis> some </Emphasis> things,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="794.740" EndTime="795.585" Participant="me012">
<VocalSound Description="inbreath"/> <Comment Description="as if to speak"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="795.170" EndTime="796.590" Participant="mn015">
and it's very flexible.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="797.084" EndTime="798.993" Participant="mn036">
<VocalSound Description="inbreath"/> <Comment Description="as if to speak"/> <VocalSound Description="outbreath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="797.089" EndTime="798.400" Participant="mn015">
I've just tried to
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="797.218" EndTime="798.630" Participant="fe004">
Mm-hmm. <VocalSound Description="laugh"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="798.630" EndTime="799.040" Participant="fe004">
<VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="798.993" EndTime="800.897" Participant="mn036">
Right. <VocalSound Description="inbreath"/> <Comment Description="as if to speak"/> <VocalSound Description="outbreath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="799.040" EndTime="799.645" Participant="mn015">
be nice.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="799.197" EndTime="801.900" Participant="me010">
<VocalSound Description="mouth"/> <VocalSound Description="inbreath"/> No, no. Fine. Yeah, yeah, yeah, flexible it <Emphasis> is. </Emphasis>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="799.645" EndTime="801.086" Participant="mn015">
<VocalSound Description="laugh-breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="799.723" EndTime="800.802" Participant="fe004">
<Uncertain> Right </Uncertain> - Yeah. <VocalSound Description="laugh"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="800.897" EndTime="801.580" Participant="mn036">
But - <VocalSound Description="inbreath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="801.187" EndTime="801.891" Participant="mn015">
<VocalSound Description="clears throat"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="801.891" EndTime="803.450" Participant="mn015">
<VocalSound Description="cough"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="804.650" EndTime="805.628" Participant="mn015">
O_K. <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="805.362" EndTime="806.316" Participant="me012">
<NonVocalSound Description="click"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="805.628" EndTime="812.409" Participant="mn015">
Um, let's hope that the generation will not be more difficult, even though the generator is a <Emphasis> little </Emphasis> bit more complex.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="812.994" EndTime="814.700" Participant="mn015">
Uh but we'll -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="814.700" EndTime="815.463" Participant="mn015">
Mmm,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="815.463" EndTime="820.755" Participant="mn015">
that means we may need two hours and twenty minutes rather than an hour ten minutes, <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="819.411" EndTime="821.118" Participant="me010">
<VocalSound Description="breath"/> Alright.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="819.497" EndTime="820.184" Participant="me012">
<VocalSound Description="breath-laugh"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="820.184" EndTime="821.011" Participant="me012">
Right.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="820.755" EndTime="821.560" Participant="mn015">
I hope.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="822.740" EndTime="828.565" Participant="mn015">
And the next thing I would <Emphasis> like </Emphasis> to be able to do, and it seems like this would not be too difficult <Emphasis> either, </Emphasis> is <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="828.565" EndTime="834.602" Participant="mn015">
to say, "O_K let's now pretend we <Pronounce> actually </Pronounce> wanted to not only change the - <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="834.602" EndTime="842.977" Participant="mn015">
the <Emphasis> mapping </Emphasis> of - of, uh, words to the M_-three-L_ but we also wanted to change - add a new sentence type and and make up some - some new M_-three-L_ - s-"
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="840.972" EndTime="841.488" Participant="me010">
<VocalSound Description="mouth"/> Yep.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="841.734" EndTime="842.149" Participant="me010">
So-
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="842.149" EndTime="842.508" Participant="me010">
<VocalSound Description="mouth"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="842.508" EndTime="844.996" Participant="me010">
That'd be <Emphasis> great. </Emphasis> It would be a good exercise to just see <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="842.977" EndTime="843.750" Participant="mn015">
See th- <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="844.996" EndTime="846.430" Participant="me010">
whether one can get that to <Emphasis> run. </Emphasis>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="846.240" EndTime="847.090" Participant="mn015">
Mm-hmm. <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="847.090" EndTime="847.382" Participant="mn015">
Yep.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="849.010" EndTime="850.070" Participant="mn015">
And, um, <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="850.140" EndTime="852.352" Participant="me012">
So, that's - Fine, yeah. <Comment Description="last two words whispered"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="851.050" EndTime="852.410" Participant="mn015">
that's - shouldn't be too tough.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="852.352" EndTime="856.530" Participant="me012">
Yeah, so where are those - those functions "Action", "Goodbye", and so on, right? Are they actually, um, <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="856.790" EndTime="860.689" Participant="me012">
Are they going to be called? Um, are they present in the code for the parser?
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="861.760" EndTime="865.911" Participant="mn015">
Yeah. I think what it does, it i- i- it does something sort of fancy. It loads
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="865.911" EndTime="866.940" Participant="mn015">
um - <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="867.250" EndTime="870.142" Participant="mn015">
It has these style sheets and also the, um,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="871.230" EndTime="872.480" Participant="mn015">
schemata. <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="872.510" EndTime="875.470" Participant="mn015">
So what it probably does, is it takes the, uh,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="877.631" EndTime="877.780" Participant="mn015">
<VocalSound Description="mouth"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="877.780" EndTime="878.740" Participant="mn015">
um - <Pause/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="880.702" EndTime="884.670" Participant="mn015">
Is this where it is? This is already the X_M_L stuff? <Comment Description="to self"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="887.579" EndTime="892.810" Participant="mn015">
This is where it takes its own, um, syntax,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="894.248" EndTime="896.777" Participant="mn015">
and converts it somehow. <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="896.777" EndTime="898.068" Participant="mn015">
Um. <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="898.068" EndTime="899.530" Participant="mn015">
Where is the uh -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="902.052" EndTime="903.871" Participant="mn015">
<VocalSound Description="tongue taps"/> <Comment Description="vocal gesture, searching in progress"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="904.883" EndTime="905.810" Participant="me012">
What are you looking for?
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="905.980" EndTime="906.342" Participant="mn015">
<VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="906.342" EndTime="913.100" Participant="mn015">
Um, where it actually produces the - the X_M_L out of the, uh, parsed <Pause/> stuff.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="910.754" EndTime="911.592" Participant="me012">
Oh, O_K. <Comment Description="whispered"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="914.019" EndTime="914.621" Participant="mn015">
<VocalSound Description="tongue taps"/> <Comment Description="vocal gesture, searching in progress"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="918.810" EndTime="920.992" Participant="mn015">
No, this is not it. <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="920.992" EndTime="922.790" Participant="mn015">
Uh. I can't find it now. <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="928.197" EndTime="931.688" Participant="mn015">
You mean, where the - where the act- how the action "Goodbye"
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="931.688" EndTime="933.830" Participant="mn015">
maps into something -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="933.817" EndTime="934.596" Participant="me012">
Yeah. <Comment Description="whispered"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="935.150" EndTime="937.160" Participant="me003">
Yeah, where are those constructors defined?
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="935.835" EndTime="936.442" Participant="me012">
Oh.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="937.379" EndTime="938.785" Participant="me012">
No, that's not it. <Comment Description="quietly"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="937.413" EndTime="938.380" Participant="mn015">
Nope.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="949.480" EndTime="950.166" Participant="mn015">
Yeah. <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="950.166" EndTime="951.650" Participant="mn015">
This is sort of what happens.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="951.650" EndTime="955.495" Participant="mn015">
This is what you would need to - to change - to get the, uh, X_M_L changed. <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="955.495" EndTime="958.020" Participant="mn015">
So when it encounts- encounters "Day", <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="956.657" EndTime="958.360" Participant="me012">
<NonVocalSound Description="mike noise"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="958.430" EndTime="959.780" Participant="mn015">
it will, uh, <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="964.820" EndTime="968.840" Participant="mn015">
activate those h- classes in the - in the X_M_L stuff <Pause/> <Comment Description="with a quasi-questioning tone"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="968.951" EndTime="970.128" Participant="me012">
<NonVocalSound Description="mike noise"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="969.376" EndTime="970.680" Participant="mn015">
But, um - <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="971.560" EndTime="974.770" Participant="mn015">
I <Emphasis> saw </Emphasis> those actions - uh, the "Goodbye" stuff somewhere.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="974.770" EndTime="977.335" Participant="mn015">
Hmm, hmm, hmm, hmm, hmm. <Comment Description="vocal gesture, denoting thinking"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="977.460" EndTime="978.450" Participant="me003">
Grep for it?
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="979.697" EndTime="980.110" Participant="mn015">
<Uncertain> Yeah </Uncertain>.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="980.110" EndTime="980.878" Participant="mn015">
Let's do that.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="998.121" EndTime="998.900" Participant="mn015">
<Emphasis> Oh. </Emphasis>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1000.140" EndTime="1000.862" CloseMic="false">
<NonVocalSound Description="computer beep"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1003.977" EndTime="1005.295" Participant="me003">
<VocalSound Description="breath-laugh"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1008.608" EndTime="1009.055" Participant="me012">
Mmm.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1009.055" EndTime="1010.720" Participant="me012">
M_-three-L_ dot D_T_D?
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1010.684" EndTime="1011.480" Participant="mn015">
Yep.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1025.180" EndTime="1026.018" Participant="me012">
That's just a <Pause/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1026.464" EndTime="1028.041" Participant="me012">
specification for the X_M_L
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1027.900" EndTime="1028.590" Participant="mn015">
Yep.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1028.041" EndTime="1029.008" Participant="me012">
format.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1040.210" EndTime="1041.670" Participant="mn015">
Well, we'll find that out.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1061.385" EndTime="1062.184" Participant="mn015">
<VocalSound Description="inbreath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1062.184" EndTime="1068.410" Participant="mn015">
So whatever - n- this does - I mean this is, basically, looks l- to me like a function call, right? <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1068.058" EndTime="1068.830" Participant="me010">
Hmm? Oh, yeah.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1068.830" EndTime="1070.528" Participant="mn015">
And, um - <VocalSound Description="breath"/> <VocalSound Description="mouth"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1070.528" EndTime="1074.416" Participant="mn015">
So, whenever it - it encounters "Goodbye",
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1074.416" EndTime="1076.930" Participant="mn015">
which we can make it do in a second, here <Pause/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1077.410" EndTime="1079.974" Participant="me003">
That function automatically generates an initialized
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1079.974" EndTime="1081.770" Participant="me003">
X_M_L structure?
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1081.548" EndTime="1084.901" Participant="me012">
I think each of those functions act on the current X_M_L structure, and
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1081.683" EndTime="1083.136" Participant="mn015">
<VocalSound Description="mouth"/> I- <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1084.901" EndTime="1086.997" Participant="me012">
change it in some way, for example, by adding a -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1087.810" EndTime="1089.115" Participant="me010">
<VocalSound Description="inbreath"/> y-
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1088.005" EndTime="1089.640" Participant="me012">
a l- a <Emphasis> field </Emphasis> to it, or something.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1089.115" EndTime="1091.565" Participant="me010">
Yeah. They also seem to affect <Emphasis> state, </Emphasis> cause some of them -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1089.256" EndTime="1090.082" Participant="mn015">
Mm-hmm.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1091.565" EndTime="1092.891" Participant="me010">
there were <Emphasis> other </Emphasis> actions
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1093.220" EndTime="1093.950" Participant="me012">
Right.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1093.700" EndTime="1099.690" Participant="me010">
uh, that - that s- seemed to step - state variables somewhere, like the n- s- "<Emphasis> Discourse </Emphasis> Status Confirm". <Comment Description="rising intonation"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1095.540" EndTime="1096.730" Participant="mn015">
<VocalSound Description="cough"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1099.690" EndTime="1100.708" Participant="mn015">
Yep. <VocalSound Description="sniff"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1100.140" EndTime="1104.430" Participant="me010">
O_K. So that's going to be a call on the discourse and <VocalSound Description="breath"/> confirm that it's -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1100.708" EndTime="1100.825" Participant="mn015">
<VocalSound Description="mouth"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1104.329" EndTime="1105.655" Participant="mn015">
W- we- Mm-hmm <Pause/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1104.430" EndTime="1109.047" Participant="me012">
Oh, you mean that's not going to actually <Emphasis> modify </Emphasis> the tree, but it's going to <Emphasis> change </Emphasis> the event. <Emphasis> Oh. </Emphasis> <Emphasis> Oh. </Emphasis>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1106.110" EndTime="1109.800" Participant="me010">
I think that's right. I think it's actually - That <Emphasis> looks </Emphasis> like it's state modification.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1106.308" EndTime="1107.014" Participant="mn015">
e- <Comment Description="squeaky vocal sound"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1107.860" EndTime="1108.890" Participant="mn015">
<VocalSound Description="sniff"/> e- mmm <Pause/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1108.890" EndTime="1111.083" Participant="mn015">
<VocalSound Description="breath"/> Um, well i-
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1111.007" EndTime="1112.982" Participant="me012">
When there's a feature.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1111.083" EndTime="1113.576" Participant="mn015">
There is a feature called "Discourse-Status", <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1113.185" EndTime="1113.670" Participant="me010">
Yeah.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1113.576" EndTime="1115.670" Participant="mn015">
And so whenever I just say, "Write",
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1116.180" EndTime="1118.680" Participant="mn015">
it will - it will put this in here. <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1118.240" EndTime="1120.484" Participant="me010">
Oh, so it always just - Is it - So it -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1120.484" EndTime="1123.260" Participant="me010">
Well, go <Emphasis> back, </Emphasis> then, cuz it may be that <Emphasis> all </Emphasis> those th- things,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1120.817" EndTime="1121.464" Participant="mn015">
h-
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1123.260" EndTime="1125.325" Participant="me010">
while they <Emphasis> look </Emphasis> like function calls, are just
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1125.325" EndTime="1128.935" Participant="me010">
a way of adding exactly that to the X_M_L.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1128.587" EndTime="1129.472" Participant="mn015">
Yep.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1129.873" EndTime="1131.089" Participant="me010">
Uh-huh!
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1131.485" EndTime="1133.937" Participant="me012">
<NonVocalSound Description="mike noise"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1132.035" EndTime="1133.271" Participant="me010">
I'm not - I'm not <Emphasis> sure. </Emphasis>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1132.110" EndTime="1133.220" Participant="mn015">
So, this -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1133.271" EndTime="1134.900" Participant="me010">
e- I'm not sure - e- that -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1135.250" EndTime="1137.443" Participant="mn015">
Um - well, we - we'll see, when we say,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1137.443" EndTime="1138.380" Participant="mn015">
let's <Emphasis> test </Emphasis> something, <Comment Description="embedded"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1138.380" EndTime="1139.261" Participant="mn015">
"Goodbye",
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1138.393" EndTime="1140.660" Participant="me012">
<NonVocalSound Description="mike noise"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1139.261" EndTime="1147.080" Participant="mn015">
causes it to c- to create basically an "Action Goodbye-End-Action". <VocalSound Description="breath"/> Which is a means of telling the system to shut down.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1144.296" EndTime="1144.982" Participant="me010">
Right.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1146.588" EndTime="1147.153" Participant="me010">
Right.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1147.660" EndTime="1150.451" Participant="mn015">
Now, if we know that "Write"
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1150.451" EndTime="1154.372" Participant="mn015">
produces a "Feature Discourse-Status Confirm Discourse-Status".
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1154.372" EndTime="1156.217" Participant="mn015">
So if I now say "Write,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1156.217" EndTime="1157.510" Participant="mn015">
Goodbye,"
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1159.035" EndTime="1160.532" Participant="mn015">
it should do that. <Comment Description="showing actions on a computer in the meeting"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1160.532" EndTime="1162.430" Participant="mn015">
It sho- it creates <Emphasis> this, </Emphasis>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1161.543" EndTime="1162.510" Participant="me012">
Mm-hmm.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1162.347" EndTime="1163.465" Participant="me010">
Right.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1162.430" EndTime="1164.580" Participant="mn015">
"Confirm Goodbye". <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1164.138" EndTime="1165.313" Participant="me012">
<Uncertain> Right there. </Uncertain> <Comment Description="whispered"/> <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1164.654" EndTime="1165.183" Participant="me010">
Yep.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1165.313" EndTime="1170.122" Participant="me012">
But there <Emphasis> is </Emphasis> some kind of function call, because how does it know to put Goodbye in Content, but, uh, Confirm in Features?
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1170.122" EndTime="1171.059" Participant="me012">
So-
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1170.490" EndTime="1173.050" Participant="mn015">
Oh. It d- it - n- That's because -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1171.822" EndTime="1174.641" Participant="me012">
So, it's not just that it's adding that field. It's <Pause/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1174.037" EndTime="1174.684" Participant="me010">
Right.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1174.641" EndTime="1175.655" Participant="me012">
O_K.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1174.684" EndTime="1176.020" Participant="me010">
Absolutely. Good point.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1176.020" EndTime="1179.275" Participant="me010">
It's - it's - the - It's under what sub-type you're doing it. Yeah.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1178.226" EndTime="1179.473" Participant="mn015">
Mm-hmm. <Uncertain> Yeah </Uncertain>.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1184.299" EndTime="1186.200" Participant="me003">
<Uncertain> It's </Uncertain> <Emphasis> mystery </Emphasis> functions.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1186.041" EndTime="1186.790" Participant="me012">
<VocalSound Description="breath-laugh"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1186.550" EndTime="1187.928" Participant="fe004">
<NonVocalSound Description="mike noise"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1186.790" EndTime="1189.505" Participant="me012">
Well, they're <Emphasis> defined </Emphasis> somewhere, presumably.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1186.980" EndTime="1189.850" Participant="mn015">
Well, sometimes it m- Sometimes, i-
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1188.630" EndTime="1191.398" Participant="me003">
<VocalSound Description="laugh"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1189.690" EndTime="1190.360" Participant="fe004">
<VocalSound Description="breath-laugh"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1190.269" EndTime="1192.186" Participant="me012">
<VocalSound Description="laugh"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1190.409" EndTime="1194.700" Participant="me010">
Yeah, each is - S- so that's funny. You bury the s- the state in the function <Pause/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1190.590" EndTime="1191.460" Participant="mn015">
When it - <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1190.917" EndTime="1195.718" Participant="fe004">
<NonVocalSound Description="mike noise"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1195.393" EndTime="1197.049" Participant="me010">
Alright. Uh <Pause/> <Uncertain NumSyllables="1"> @@ </Uncertain>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1196.190" EndTime="1196.960" Participant="mn015">
it - <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1196.220" EndTime="1199.940" Participant="me003">
Well, it just automatically initializes things that are common, right? So it's just a shorthand.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1197.755" EndTime="1199.677" Participant="me012">
<NonVocalSound Description="mike noise"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1200.186" EndTime="1201.176" Participant="me010">
Yeah.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1201.017" EndTime="1203.960" Participant="mn015">
For example - Oh, this is German. Sorry.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1204.451" EndTime="1205.101" Participant="mn015">
e-
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1205.286" EndTime="1207.411" Participant="me012">
<VocalSound Description="laugh"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1211.490" EndTime="1215.960" Participant="mn015">
So, now, <Emphasis> this, </Emphasis> it cannot do anymore. Nothing comes out of here.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1215.970" EndTime="1218.970" Participant="me003">
A "not a number" is a value. Awesome. <VocalSound Description="laugh"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1217.410" EndTime="1220.841" Participant="mn015">
<VocalSound Description="breath"/> <VocalSound Description="several coughs"/> <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1218.062" EndTime="1220.048" Participant="me012">
<VocalSound Description="laugh"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1218.970" EndTime="1220.630" Participant="fe004">
<VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1222.300" EndTime="1223.300" Participant="mn015">
So, it
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1224.100" EndTime="1228.675" Participant="mn015">
doesn't speak German anymore, but it does speak English. <VocalSound Description="breath"/> And there is, here,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1228.675" EndTime="1230.201" Participant="mn015">
a reference -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1231.241" EndTime="1236.690" Participant="mn015">
So, this tells us that whatever is - has the I_D "<Emphasis> zero </Emphasis>" is referenced here -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1231.453" EndTime="1233.420" Participant="me012">
<NonVocalSound Description="mike noise"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1236.960" EndTime="1241.670" Participant="mn015">
by <Uncertain NumSyllables="1"> @@ </Uncertain> <Comment Description="uncodeable vocal sound"/> the restriction <Uncertain> seed </Uncertain> and this is exa- "I want -"
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1238.494" EndTime="1239.680" Participant="fe004">
<VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1241.670" EndTime="1242.916" Participant="mn015">
What was the sentence? <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1243.444" EndTime="1244.490" Participant="me010">
"I want two seats here."
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1244.361" EndTime="1246.160" Participant="mn015">
"need two seats here." <Uncertain> Nuh </Uncertain>.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1248.050" EndTime="1251.950" Participant="mn015">
"And where is it playing?" There should also be a reference to something, maybe.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1252.832" EndTime="1253.350" Participant="mn015">
<VocalSound Description="mouth"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1253.350" EndTime="1255.250" Participant="mn015">
Our d- This is re- um <Pause/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1256.661" EndTime="1257.116" Participant="me003">
<VocalSound Description="mouth"/> <VocalSound Description="inbreath"/> <Comment Description="as if to speak"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1257.174" EndTime="1257.696" Participant="mn015">
<Uncertain> Mmm </Uncertain>. <VocalSound Description="mouth"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1257.696" EndTime="1265.290" Participant="mn015">
Here, we change - and so, we - Here we add something to the Discourse-Status, that the user wants to change something that was sort of done before <Pause/> <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1258.391" EndTime="1258.706" Participant="me010">
<VocalSound Description="sniff"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1258.625" EndTime="1260.120" Participant="fe004">
<VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1259.666" EndTime="1260.943" Participant="me010">
<NonVocalSound Description="mike noise"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1264.140" EndTime="1265.230" Participant="fe004">
<VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1265.690" EndTime="1266.890" Participant="mn015">
And, uh -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1266.200" EndTime="1267.260" Participant="fe004">
<VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1267.670" EndTime="1271.240" Participant="mn015">
and that, whatever is being changed has something to do with the cinema.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1268.280" EndTime="1269.110" Participant="fe004">
<VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1271.510" EndTime="1275.510" Participant="me003">
So then, whatever takes this M_-three-L_ is what actually changes the state, not the -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1274.314" EndTime="1276.416" CloseMic="false">
<VocalSound Description="[mn015] coughs in background, off close-mike"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1275.777" EndTime="1276.153" Participant="me010">
<VocalSound Description="mouth"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1276.190" EndTime="1277.189" Participant="me003">
Yeah, O_K.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1276.386" EndTime="1277.590" Participant="fe004">
<VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1276.520" EndTime="1278.900" Participant="me010">
No, right, the Discourse Maintainer, yeah.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1277.985" EndTime="1278.991" Participant="me003">
Yeah.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1278.497" EndTime="1285.728" Participant="mn015">
<NonVocalSound Description="mike noise"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1278.652" EndTime="1279.690" Participant="fe004">
<VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1279.890" EndTime="1282.962" Participant="me010">
<Emphasis> I </Emphasis> see. And it - and it runs around looking for Discourse Status
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1282.962" EndTime="1283.974" Participant="me010">
tags,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1284.750" EndTime="1287.336" Participant="me010">
and doing whatever it does with them.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1287.336" EndTime="1290.080" Participant="me010">
And other people <Emphasis> ignore </Emphasis> those tags. <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1290.180" EndTime="1291.460" Participant="fe004">
<VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1290.312" EndTime="1291.166" Participant="me010">
<VocalSound Description="mouth"/> Alright.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1295.250" EndTime="1297.406" Participant="me010">
So, yeah. I definitely think it's - <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1296.190" EndTime="1296.960" Participant="fe004">
<VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1297.406" EndTime="1298.732" Participant="me010">
It's worth
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1299.179" EndTime="1302.098" Participant="me010">
the exercise of trying to
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1302.098" EndTime="1303.750" Participant="me010">
actually add something
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1303.750" EndTime="1305.170" Participant="me010">
that isn't there.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1305.382" EndTime="1306.401" Participant="mn015">
Hmm?
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1306.033" EndTime="1307.670" Participant="me010">
Uh <Pause/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1306.490" EndTime="1310.650" Participant="fe004">
<VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1307.784" EndTime="1310.600" Participant="mn015">
Sort of <Emphasis> get </Emphasis> a complete understanding of the whole thing. <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1307.844" EndTime="1308.448" Participant="me010">
Disc-
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1309.236" EndTime="1313.764" Participant="me010">
Yeah, <Uncertain> a kid </Uncertain> understanding what's going on. <VocalSound Description="breath"/> Then the <Emphasis> next </Emphasis> thing we talked about is actually, <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1313.764" EndTime="1316.731" Participant="me010">
um, figuring out how to add our own
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1316.731" EndTime="1318.450" Participant="me010">
<Emphasis> tags, </Emphasis> and stuff like that.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1318.178" EndTime="1318.784" Participant="mn015">
O_K.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1319.760" EndTime="1320.723" Participant="mn015">
Point number <Emphasis> two. </Emphasis>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1320.723" EndTime="1324.974" Participant="mn015">
I got the, uh, M_-three-L_ for the routes today.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1324.974" EndTime="1326.514" Participant="mn015">
Uh, so I got some more.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1326.514" EndTime="1330.020" Participant="mn015">
This is sort of the uh, <VocalSound Description="breath"/> um, <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1337.330" EndTime="1338.145" Participant="mn015">
<NonVocalSound Description="computer beep in background"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1339.310" EndTime="1341.850" Participant="mn015">
Hmm. Interesting. It's just going <Emphasis> up, </Emphasis> it's not going
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1343.092" EndTime="1344.110" Participant="mn015">
back <Emphasis> down. </Emphasis> <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1351.550" EndTime="1359.210" Participant="mn015">
So, this is - um, what I got today is <VocalSound Description="breath"/> the - the new <VocalSound Description="breath"/> um <VocalSound Description="breath"/> M_-three-L_ for
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1360.187" EndTime="1364.234" Participant="mn015">
um, <VocalSound Description="breath"/> <VocalSound Description="mouth"/> the Maps, <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1362.800" EndTime="1363.925" Participant="me010">
<VocalSound Description="mouth"/> Yep.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1364.234" EndTime="1369.877" Participant="mn015">
uh, and with some examples - So, this is the X_M_L and this is sort of what it will look like later on,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1364.450" EndTime="1366.570" Participant="fe004">
<VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1369.877" EndTime="1372.640" Participant="mn015">
even though it - you can't see it on - on this resolution. <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1372.860" EndTime="1377.550" Participant="mn015">
And this is what it - sort of is the - the structure of Map requests,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1377.550" EndTime="1378.720" Participant="mn015">
um <Pause/> <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1379.800" EndTime="1381.370" Participant="mn015">
also not very interesting, <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1381.680" EndTime="1386.023" Participant="mn015">
and here is the <Emphasis> more </Emphasis> interesting stuff for us, is the routes,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1386.530" EndTime="1388.219" Participant="mn015">
route elements, <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1388.219" EndTime="1393.059" Participant="mn015">
and, again, as we thought it's really simple. This is sort of the, uh, <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1393.562" EndTime="1393.920" Participant="mn015">
<VocalSound Description="mouth"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1393.920" EndTime="1397.967" Participant="mn015">
um, <VocalSound Description="breath"/> parameters. We have
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1397.967" EndTime="1398.175" Participant="mn015">
<Uncertain NumSyllables="1"> @@ </Uncertain> <Comment Description="uncodeable vocal fragment"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1398.175" EndTime="1401.456" Participant="mn015">
simple "<Emphasis> from </Emphasis> objects" and "<Emphasis> to </Emphasis> objects" and so forth,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1401.456" EndTime="1403.121" Participant="mn015">
points of interest along the way - <Comment Description="list"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1403.785" EndTime="1405.849" Participant="mn015">
And, um,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1405.849" EndTime="1409.664" Participant="mn015">
I asked them whether or not we could, um -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1405.910" EndTime="1406.780" Participant="fe004">
<VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1409.664" EndTime="1411.698" Participant="mn015">
First of all, I was little bit -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1410.910" EndTime="1411.820" Participant="fe004">
<VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1412.168" EndTime="1418.509" Participant="mn015">
It seemed to me that this m- way of doing it is sort of a stack- a step backwards from the way we've done it before. t- <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1413.252" EndTime="1414.754" Participant="fe004">
<VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1418.509" EndTime="1421.040" Participant="mn015">
It seems to me that some notions were missing.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1421.390" EndTime="1423.017" Participant="mn015">
So these are - these are -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1421.471" EndTime="1422.190" Participant="me010">
<VocalSound Description="inbreath"/> S- <Comment Description="abandoned utterance"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1422.190" EndTime="1425.080" Participant="me010">
So these are - these are your friends back at E_M_L. <Comment Description="statement syntax plus falling intonation serving as a question"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1422.941" EndTime="1423.840" Participant="me003">
<VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1424.591" EndTime="1426.598" Participant="mn015">
Yep. Who are doing this.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1425.257" EndTime="1439.986" Participant="me012">
<NonVocalSound Description="mike noise"/> <Comment Description="adjusting mike"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1425.440" EndTime="1427.642" Participant="me010">
So this is not a <Emphasis> complicated </Emphasis> negotiation.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1427.642" EndTime="1430.310" Participant="me010">
There's - there's not <Emphasis> seven </Emphasis> committees, or anything, right? <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1427.650" EndTime="1428.720" Participant="mn015">
No. <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1429.453" EndTime="1433.340" Participant="mn015">
No, this is very straightforward. <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1432.015" EndTime="1433.763" Participant="me010">
<Emphasis> Great. </Emphasis> So this is just trying to -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1433.763" EndTime="1435.983" Participant="me010">
It's a <Emphasis> design </Emphasis> thing, not a <Emphasis> political </Emphasis> thing.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1435.630" EndTime="1437.110" Participant="mn015">
Yeah. <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1435.983" EndTime="1438.767" Participant="me010">
Once we've - eh - We can just sort of agree on what oughta be done.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1438.932" EndTime="1441.244" Participant="mn015">
<VocalSound Description="mouth"/> Exactly. <VocalSound Description="breath"/> And, um -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1439.190" EndTime="1439.713" Participant="me010">
Good.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1442.063" EndTime="1443.750" Participant="mn015">
And, uh - <Pause/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1443.750" EndTime="1444.836" Participant="mn015">
However, the, uh -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1445.287" EndTime="1450.532" Participant="mn015">
e- So that you understand, it is <Emphasis> really </Emphasis> simple. Uh - You - you have a <Emphasis> route, </Emphasis> and you cut it up in different pieces.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1448.959" EndTime="1453.089" Participant="me012">
<NonVocalSound Description="mike noise"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1450.532" EndTime="1451.986" Participant="mn015">
And every -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1451.986" EndTime="1454.762" Participant="mn015">
every <Emphasis> element </Emphasis> of that e- r- r- f- of that -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1453.089" EndTime="1455.626" Participant="me012">
<VocalSound Description="yawn"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1454.762" EndTime="1457.080" Participant="mn015">
Every <Emphasis> segment </Emphasis> we call a "route element".
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1457.575" EndTime="1461.064" Participant="mn015">
And so, from A_ to B_ we cut up in three different steps,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1461.064" EndTime="1468.033" Participant="mn015">
and every step has a "<Emphasis> from </Emphasis> object" where you <Emphasis> start, </Emphasis> a "<Emphasis> to </Emphasis> object" where y- where <Pause/> you sort of <Emphasis> end, </Emphasis> and some points of interest along the way.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1461.350" EndTime="1462.250" Participant="fe004">
<VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1468.843" EndTime="1476.150" Participant="mn015">
What w- I was sort of missing here, and uh, maybe it was just me being too stupid, is, <VocalSound Description="breath"/> I didn't sort of get the - the notion of the global goal
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1476.150" EndTime="1480.829" Participant="mn015">
of the whole route. Really, s- was not straightforward visibly for me. <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1480.829" EndTime="1482.509" Participant="mn015">
And some <Emphasis> other </Emphasis> stuff. And I <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1482.509" EndTime="1489.530" Participant="mn015">
suggested that they should n- be - k- uh, kind enough to do s- <Emphasis> two </Emphasis> things for us, is one, um, <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1490.202" EndTime="1498.276" Participant="mn015">
<VocalSound Description="mouth"/> Also allocating, uh, some tags for our Action Schema Enter-Vista-Approach, <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1495.747" EndTime="1497.004" Participant="fe004">
<VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1497.004" EndTime="1497.340" Participant="fe004">
<NonVocalSound Description="mike noise"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1498.276" EndTime="1498.750" Participant="mn015">
and -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1498.750" EndTime="1502.955" Participant="mn015">
<NonVocalSound Description="mike noise"/> <VocalSound Description="cough"/> <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1499.740" EndTime="1501.070" Participant="fe004">
<VocalSound Description="cough in background"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1502.955" EndTime="1504.822" Participant="mn015">
And also,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1504.822" EndTime="1507.519" Participant="mn015">
um, since <Emphasis> you </Emphasis> had suggested that -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1507.519" EndTime="1515.539" Participant="mn015">
that, um, we figure out if we ever, for a <Emphasis> demo </Emphasis> reason, wanted to shortcut directly to the g- G_I_S and the Planner, <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1515.539" EndTime="1516.476" Participant="mn015">
of how we can do it.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1516.476" EndTime="1526.234" Participant="mn015">
Now, what's the state of the art of getting to <Emphasis> entrances, </Emphasis> um, what's the syntax for that, how get- getting to <VocalSound Description="breath"/> <Emphasis> vista </Emphasis> points and calculating those on the spot. <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1523.571" EndTime="1526.811" Participant="me012">
<NonVocalSound Description="mike noise"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1526.234" EndTime="1528.911" Participant="mn015">
And the <Emphasis> Approach </Emphasis> mode, anyhow, is the default.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1528.528" EndTime="1529.920" Participant="fe004">
<VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1528.911" EndTime="1536.520" Participant="mn015">
That's all they do it these days. Wherever you'll find a route planner it n- does nothing but get to the closest point where the street network is <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1531.253" EndTime="1531.866" Participant="me010">
Mm-hmm.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1532.070" EndTime="1532.930" Participant="fe004">
<NonVocalSound Description="mike noise"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1536.520" EndTime="1539.155" Participant="mn015">
at minimal distance to the geometric center. <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1539.155" EndTime="1540.060" Participant="mn015">
<Uncertain NumSyllables="1"> @@ </Uncertain>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1540.490" EndTime="1544.976" Participant="fe004">
<VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1541.290" EndTime="1542.030" Participant="mn015">
So.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1542.070" EndTime="1549.055" Participant="me010">
<VocalSound Description="breath"/> So, well, let - Now, this is <Emphasis> important. </Emphasis> Let, uh - I want a- a- Again, outside of m- almost <Emphasis> managerial </Emphasis> point, <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1549.055" EndTime="1550.270" Participant="me010">
um -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1550.270" EndTime="1554.142" Participant="me010">
<VocalSound Description="mouth"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1554.142" EndTime="1557.280" Participant="me010">
You're in the midst of this, so you know better. But it seems to me it's <Emphasis> probably </Emphasis>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1557.280" EndTime="1558.933" Participant="me010">
a good idea to
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1558.933" EndTime="1562.338" Participant="me010">
li- uh - <Emphasis> minimize </Emphasis> the number of
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1562.338" EndTime="1564.110" Participant="me010">
uh, <Emphasis> change </Emphasis> requests we make of them.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1564.110" EndTime="1568.120" Participant="me010">
<VocalSound Description="breath"/> So it seemed to me, what we ought to do is get <Emphasis> our </Emphasis> story together.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1568.740" EndTime="1572.782" Participant="me010">
O_K? And think about it some, <Emphasis> internally, </Emphasis> before
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1572.101" EndTime="1574.926" Participant="mn015">
<NonVocalSound Description="mike noise"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1572.782" EndTime="1574.526" Participant="me010">
asking them to make <Emphasis> changes. </Emphasis>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1574.926" EndTime="1575.461" Participant="mn015">
Mm-hmm.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1575.780" EndTime="1581.206" Participant="me010">
Oh. Does this - does this make sense to you guys? It - I mean you're - you're doing the - the interaction but it seemed to me that <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1581.206" EndTime="1584.175" Participant="me010">
what we <Emphasis> ought </Emphasis> to do is come up with a -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1582.465" EndTime="1584.191" Participant="me012">
<NonVocalSound Description="mike noise"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1584.590" EndTime="1588.420" Participant="me010">
uh, something where you, um - <Pause/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1590.025" EndTime="1593.870" Participant="me010">
And I - I don't know who's mok- working most closely on it. <Emphasis> Probably </Emphasis> Johno.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1590.548" EndTime="1596.659" Participant="fe004">
<NonVocalSound Description="mike noise"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1593.940" EndTime="1594.826" Participant="me010">
O_K. <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1594.826" EndTime="1596.910" Participant="me010">
Uh, take what they have,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1598.290" EndTime="1602.132" Participant="me010">
send it to everybody saying "this is what they have, this is what we think we should add",
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1602.132" EndTime="1606.897" Participant="me010">
O_K? <Comment Description="embedded"/> and then have a d- a - an iteration within <Emphasis> our </Emphasis> group saying "Hmm, well -"
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1606.897" EndTime="1610.000" Participant="me010">
O_K? And get <Emphasis> our </Emphasis> best idea of what we should add.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1609.820" EndTime="1610.490" Participant="mn015">
Mm-hmm.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1610.449" EndTime="1611.815" Participant="me010">
And <Emphasis> then </Emphasis> go back to them.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1612.673" EndTime="1615.130" Participant="me010">
Is i- or, I don't know does this make sense to you? Or <Pause/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1615.130" EndTime="1617.803" Participant="mn015">
Yeah. <VocalSound Description="breath"/> Especially if we want - <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1617.803" EndTime="1623.640" Participant="mn015">
Sort of, what I - <Emphasis> my </Emphasis> feeling was eh- we - we sort of reserved something that has a r- eh-
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1623.640" EndTime="1628.058" Participant="mn015">
an O_K label. That's - th- that was my th- first sort of step. <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1626.955" EndTime="1627.860" Participant="me010">
Mm-hmm.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1628.058" EndTime="1629.127" Participant="mn015">
I- w-
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1629.127" EndTime="1631.236" Participant="mn015">
No matter <Emphasis> how </Emphasis> we want to call it, <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1631.236" EndTime="1642.430" Participant="mn015">
this is sort of our playground. And if we get something in there that is a structure <Emphasis> elaborate </Emphasis> and - and - and - and - and <Emphasis> complex </Emphasis> enough to - to - to maybe enable a whole <Emphasis> simulation, </Emphasis>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1633.031" EndTime="1633.685" Participant="me010">
Right.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1642.283" EndTime="1643.100" Participant="me010">
Right.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1642.738" EndTime="1643.633" Participant="mn015">
one of these days,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1643.633" EndTime="1646.520" Participant="mn015">
that would be - u- the - the perfect goal. <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1644.281" EndTime="1648.784" Participant="me010">
<VocalSound Description="breath"/> That's right. So. So, Yeah. The problem isn't the <Emphasis> short </Emphasis> ra- range optimization.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1648.784" EndTime="1655.860" Participant="me010">
It's the sort of - o- one or two <Emphasis> year </Emphasis> kind of thing. O_K. What are the thl- <Emphasis> class </Emphasis> of things we think we might try to <Emphasis> do </Emphasis> in a year or two? <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1655.860" EndTime="1659.814" Participant="me010">
How - how would we try to <Emphasis> characterize </Emphasis> those and what do we want to request <Emphasis> now </Emphasis> <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1659.814" EndTime="1662.554" Participant="me010">
that's leave enough space to <Emphasis> do </Emphasis> all that stuff?
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1661.540" EndTime="1662.430" Participant="mn015">
Mm-hmm. Yep.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1662.554" EndTime="1664.520" Participant="me010">
Right. And that re- that requires some thought.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1665.205" EndTime="1666.102" Participant="mn015">
Yep.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1666.534" EndTime="1669.717" Participant="me010">
And - so that sounds like a <Emphasis> great </Emphasis> thing to do <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1669.717" EndTime="1672.438" Participant="me010">
as the priority item
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1672.438" EndTime="1674.576" Participant="me010">
um, as soon as we can do it.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1674.355" EndTime="1675.242" Participant="mn015">
Yep.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1675.456" EndTime="1678.843" Participant="me010">
So y- so you guys will <VocalSound Description="breath"/> send to the rest of us
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1679.338" EndTime="1680.264" Participant="me010">
um <Pause/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1680.686" EndTime="1682.990" Participant="me010">
<VocalSound Description="mouth"/> a version of
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1681.536" EndTime="1689.273" Participant="me012">
<NonVocalSound Description="papers rustling in background"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1682.422" EndTime="1688.458" Participant="fe004">
<NonVocalSound Description="papers rustling in background"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1683.330" EndTime="1685.501" Participant="me010">
um, <Emphasis> this, </Emphasis>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1684.760" EndTime="1685.430" Participant="me003">
<VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1685.501" EndTime="1688.381" Participant="me010">
and - the - uh, <Emphasis> description </Emphasis> -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1687.540" EndTime="1690.220" Participant="me003">
With sugge- yeah, suggested improvements and - <Comment Description="connecting to [me010]'s utterance"/> <Comment Description="abandoned as clear"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1689.680" EndTime="1692.737" Participant="me010">
Well b- Yeah. So, the - the - uh - Not everyone
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1692.737" EndTime="1695.001" Participant="me010">
uh, reads German, so if you'd
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1695.001" EndTime="1696.693" Participant="me010">
um <VocalSound Description="mouth"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1696.190" EndTime="1697.020" Participant="me003">
Mmm.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1697.520" EndTime="1700.900" Participant="me010">
tu- uh, tur- change the description to, uh,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1700.860" EndTime="1701.586" Participant="me003">
<VocalSound Description="breath-laugh"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1701.340" EndTime="1701.985" Participant="me010">
English
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1701.586" EndTime="1702.490" Participant="me003">
O_K.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1701.985" EndTime="1705.111" Participant="me010">
and, um,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1703.463" EndTime="1704.465" Participant="me012">
<NonVocalSound Description="clank of drinking glass in background"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1706.458" EndTime="1710.580" Participant="me010">
Then - then, yeah. Then, with some sug- s- suggestions about where - where do we go from here?
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1706.770" EndTime="1708.190" Participant="me003">
<VocalSound Description="laugh"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1711.407" EndTime="1714.400" Participant="me010">
Uh, this - and this, of course, was just the <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1711.560" EndTime="1712.320" Participant="me003">
O_K.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1714.988" EndTime="1719.513" Participant="me010">
<VocalSound Description="mouth"/> <Emphasis> action </Emphasis> end. Uh, at some point we're going to have to worry about the <Emphasis> language </Emphasis> end. But for the moment just <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1719.230" EndTime="1720.153" Participant="mn015">
<VocalSound Description="mouth"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1719.513" EndTime="1724.490" Participant="me010">
uh, t- for this class of - of <Emphasis> things, </Emphasis> we might want to try to encompass.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1725.357" EndTime="1727.220" Participant="me010">
And - <Pause/> <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1727.180" EndTime="1729.170" Participant="me003">
Then the scope of this is beyond <Pause/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1729.340" EndTime="1732.240" Participant="me003">
Approach and Vis- or Vista. Yeah, yeah.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1730.782" EndTime="1733.896" Participant="me010">
Oh, yeah, yeah yeah yeah. This is - this is everything that - that,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1733.896" EndTime="1735.312" Participant="me010">
um, <Pause/> <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1735.312" EndTime="1737.039" Participant="me010">
you know, um <Pause/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1735.810" EndTime="1736.800" Participant="me003">
Yeah, yeah.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1737.039" EndTime="1739.070" Participant="me010">
we might want to do in the next couple years.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1740.564" EndTime="1741.727" Participant="mn015">
Hmm?
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1740.770" EndTime="1742.500" Participant="me003">
So what would - O_K.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1740.954" EndTime="1743.742" Participant="me012">
<NonVocalSound Description="mike noise"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1742.094" EndTime="1742.948" Participant="mn015">
<NonVocalSound Description="fabric whishing against mike"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1744.406" EndTime="1746.845" Participant="me010">
We don't - I mean, that's an <Emphasis> issue. </Emphasis> We don't <Emphasis> know </Emphasis> what, entirely.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1744.788" EndTime="1748.133" Participant="mn015">
<NonVocalSound Description="computer beeping in background"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1746.662" EndTime="1748.510" Participant="me003">
Uh, yeah. but I'm just -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1751.270" EndTime="1752.959" Participant="me003">
But the - Yeah, O_K. So I just -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1752.959" EndTime="1754.080" Participant="me003">
this
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1754.090" EndTime="1757.494" Participant="me003">
X_M_L stuff <Emphasis> here </Emphasis> just has to do with Source-Path-Goal type stuff,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1757.494" EndTime="1758.493" Participant="me003">
in terms of
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1758.493" EndTime="1760.766" Participant="me003">
traveling through Heidelberg.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1758.755" EndTime="1759.500" Participant="mn015">
Hmm.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1760.277" EndTime="1761.330" Participant="me010">
<VocalSound Description="mouth"/> Right.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1760.766" EndTime="1763.310" Participant="me003">
Or travel, specifically.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1763.530" EndTime="1766.170" Participant="me003">
So, but <Uncertain> this O- </Uncertain> Is the domain greater than <Emphasis> that? </Emphasis>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1765.690" EndTime="1769.371" Participant="me010">
<VocalSound Description="breath"/> No. I think - I think the i- the idea is <Pause/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1766.047" EndTime="1767.853" Participant="me012">
<NonVocalSound Description="mike noise"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1766.770" EndTime="1767.750" Participant="me003">
O_K.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1768.053" EndTime="1778.854" Participant="mn015">
<NonVocalSound Description="mike noise"/> <VocalSound Description="cough in background"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1769.538" EndTime="1770.916" Participant="me010">
that -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1772.320" EndTime="1775.870" Participant="me010">
Oh. It's <Emphasis> beyond </Emphasis> Source-Path-Goal, but I think we don't need to get beyond it <Uncertain NumSyllables="3"> @@ </Uncertain> <Comment Description="uncodeable vocal sounds"/> -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1776.220" EndTime="1779.860" Participant="me010">
tourists in Heidelberg. <VocalSound Description="breath"/> It seems to me we can get <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1777.080" EndTime="1778.010" Participant="me003">
O_K. <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1779.759" EndTime="1782.733" Participant="mn015">
<NonVocalSound Description="mike noise"/> <Comment Description="replacing mike"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1779.950" EndTime="1783.557" Participant="me010">
all the complexity we want in actions and in language
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1783.557" EndTime="1786.916" Participant="me010">
without going outside of tourists in Heidelberg.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1786.916" EndTime="1788.136" Participant="me010">
O_K? <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1788.136" EndTime="1791.149" Participant="me010">
But you know, i- depending on what people are interested in,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1791.149" EndTime="1795.084" Participant="me010">
one could have, <VocalSound Description="breath"/> uh, <Emphasis> tours, </Emphasis> one could have <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1795.084" EndTime="1802.264" Participant="me010">
um, explanations of <Emphasis> why </Emphasis> something is - is, you know, why - <Emphasis> why </Emphasis> was this done, or - I mean, no - there's <Emphasis> no </Emphasis> end
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1802.264" EndTime="1805.399" Participant="me010">
to the complexity you can build into the -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1805.399" EndTime="1805.603" Participant="me010">
<VocalSound Description="mouth"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1805.603" EndTime="1807.780" Participant="me010">
uh, what a tourist in Heidelberg might
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1807.830" EndTime="1808.540" Participant="me003">
Mmm.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1808.210" EndTime="1809.144" Participant="me010">
ask. <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1809.144" EndTime="1812.653" Participant="me010">
So, at least - unless somebody else wants t- to suggest <Emphasis> otherwise </Emphasis> I think <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1812.653" EndTime="1814.400" Participant="me010">
the <Emphasis> general </Emphasis> domain
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1814.757" EndTime="1816.919" Participant="me010">
we don't have t- to
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1816.919" EndTime="1818.831" Participant="me010">
uh, <Emphasis> broaden. </Emphasis>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1818.831" EndTime="1821.020" Participant="me010">
That is, <Emphasis> tourists </Emphasis> in Heidelberg.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1823.387" EndTime="1828.514" Participant="me010">
And if there's something somebody comes up with that <Emphasis> can't </Emphasis> be done that way, then, <Emphasis> sure. </Emphasis> W- we'll - we'll look at that, but <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1828.514" EndTime="1830.220" Participant="me010">
uh <Pause/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1831.629" EndTime="1833.434" Participant="me010">
I'd be s- I- I'd be surprised at -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1833.863" EndTime="1835.160" Participant="me010">
if there's any - <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1836.051" EndTime="1838.537" Participant="me010">
<Emphasis> important </Emphasis> issue that - that - <Comment Description="abandoned as clear"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1838.537" EndTime="1840.729" Participant="me010">
And, um -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1838.890" EndTime="1841.219" Participant="mn015">
<VocalSound Description="mouth"/> <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1841.219" EndTime="1843.390" Participant="mn015">
<VocalSound Description="breath"/> <NonVocalSound Description="mike noise"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1841.334" EndTime="1843.640" Participant="me010">
I mean if - if you want to <Pause/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1843.753" EndTime="1847.514" Participant="me010">
uh, push us into reference problems, that would be great.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1847.240" EndTime="1848.350" Participant="mn036">
O_K.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1847.959" EndTime="1851.825" Participant="me010">
O_K, so this is - his specialty is - reference,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1850.202" EndTime="1851.289" Participant="mn015">
Mm-hmm.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1851.825" EndTime="1855.758" Participant="me010">
and - you know, what - what <Emphasis> are </Emphasis> these things referring to? Not <Emphasis> only </Emphasis> <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1855.758" EndTime="1858.668" Participant="me010">
anaphora, but, uh, more generally the,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1858.668" EndTime="1859.636" Participant="me010">
uh -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1859.636" EndTime="1861.704" Participant="me010">
this <Emphasis> whole </Emphasis> issue of,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1861.704" EndTime="1866.320" Participant="me010">
uh, <Emphasis> referring </Emphasis> expressions, and, what is it that they're actually
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1866.320" EndTime="1868.145" Participant="me010">
<Emphasis> dealing </Emphasis> with in the world?
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1867.468" EndTime="1868.122" Participant="mn015">
Mm-hmm.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1868.145" EndTime="1873.310" Participant="me010">
And, again, this is li- in the databa- this is also <Emphasis> pretty </Emphasis> well formed because there is an ontology,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1873.964" EndTime="1877.555" Participant="me010">
and the database, and stuff. So it isn't like, <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1877.555" EndTime="1882.230" Participant="me010">
um, you know, the Evening Star or stuff like that. I- i- it -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1880.570" EndTime="1882.230" Participant="mn036">
Right.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1882.230" EndTime="1884.001" Participant="me010">
<Emphasis> All </Emphasis> the entities
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1884.001" EndTime="1889.645" Participant="me010">
<Emphasis> do </Emphasis> have concrete reference. Although th- the <VocalSound Description="breath"/> To get at them from a language may not be trivial.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1885.680" EndTime="1886.506" Participant="mn036">
Right.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1889.260" EndTime="1890.740" Participant="mn036">
Right. <VocalSound Description="inbreath"/> <Comment Description="as if to speak"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1889.645" EndTime="1890.491" Participant="me010">
There aren't
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1890.491" EndTime="1892.850" Participant="me010">
really <Emphasis> deep </Emphasis> mysteries about
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1891.570" EndTime="1892.240" Participant="fe004">
<VocalSound Description="cough"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1892.850" EndTime="1897.080" Participant="me010">
um, what w- what things the system <Emphasis> knows </Emphasis> about.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1896.534" EndTime="1901.090" Participant="mn036">
<Uncertain> Right. </Uncertain> And you have both proper names and descriptions and y- and you can <Emphasis> ask </Emphasis> for it.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1899.148" EndTime="1899.315" Participant="me010">
<VocalSound Description="mouth"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1899.470" EndTime="1902.690" Participant="me010">
<Emphasis> All </Emphasis> those things. Yeah. You have proper names, and descriptions.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1900.565" EndTime="1901.388" Participant="mn015">
Mm-hmm.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1902.090" EndTime="1903.710" Participant="mn036">
Right. O_K.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1902.708" EndTime="1903.475" Participant="mn015">
Nuh.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1902.960" EndTime="1907.200" Participant="me010">
<Emphasis> And </Emphasis> a l- and a lot - and - and anaphora, and pronouns, and <Pause/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1905.310" EndTime="1906.850" Participant="mn036">
Right.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1906.930" EndTime="1907.830" Participant="mn036">
Right.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1907.470" EndTime="1908.550" Participant="me010">
all those things.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1908.920" EndTime="1915.378" Participant="mn015">
<VocalSound Description="mouth"/> <Uncertain> Now </Uncertain>, we hav- the - the whole - Unfortunately, the whole database is, uh, <VocalSound Description="breath"/> in <Emphasis> German. </Emphasis>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1912.041" EndTime="1914.240" Participant="me012">
<NonVocalSound Description="mike noise"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1915.620" EndTime="1920.930" Participant="mn015">
We have just commissioned someone to translate some bits of it, I_E the e-
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1921.090" EndTime="1928.829" Participant="mn015">
the shortest k- the - the more general descriptions of all the objects and, um, persons and events. So, it's a relational database with persons, events, <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1928.829" EndTime="1931.014" Participant="mn015">
and, um, objects. <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1931.014" EndTime="1933.460" Participant="mn015">
<VocalSound Description="mouth"/> And it's - it's quite, um, <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1932.725" EndTime="1933.380" Participant="me010">
<NonVocalSound Description="mike noise"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1933.460" EndTime="1940.275" Participant="mn015">
there. But <Uncertain> did y- </Uncertain> I - uh - I think <Uncertain> there </Uncertain> will be great because the reference problem really is not trivial, even if you have such a g-
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1940.275" EndTime="1941.804" Participant="mn015">
well-defined world.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1941.050" EndTime="1942.490" Participant="me010">
He knows. <VocalSound Description="laugh"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1941.804" EndTime="1946.950" Participant="mn015">
<VocalSound Description="laugh"/> <Uncertain> Ah- he- </Uncertain> you are not, uh, throwing uh, uh, carrying owls to Athens. <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1946.267" EndTime="1950.520" Participant="me003">
Could you give me an example of a reference problem? <Uncertain> so - so l- I can </Uncertain> make it more concrete?
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1948.236" EndTime="1948.930" Participant="mn015">
Well -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1948.930" EndTime="1951.399" Participant="mn015">
<VocalSound Description="breath"/> How do I get to the Powder-Tower?
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1951.849" EndTime="1960.571" Participant="mn015">
We sort of t- think that <Emphasis> our </Emphasis> bit in this problem is interesting, but, just to get from <Emphasis> Powder-Tower </Emphasis> to an object I- I_D in a database
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1955.999" EndTime="1956.880" Participant="fe004">
<VocalSound Description="clears throat"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1961.054" EndTime="1963.600" Participant="mn015">
is <Emphasis> also </Emphasis> not really trivial. <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1962.470" EndTime="1963.220" Participant="fe004">
<NonVocalSound Description="mike noise"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1965.356" EndTime="1977.530" Participant="mn036">
Or - or if you take something even <Emphasis> more </Emphasis> scary, um, "how do I get to the third building <Emphasis> after </Emphasis> the Tower? the Ple- Powder-Tower?" Uh, you need some mechanism <Uncertain> for </Uncertain> <Pause/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1973.580" EndTime="1974.300" Participant="me003">
Mmm. <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1975.159" EndTime="1975.693" Participant="me010">
Yeah.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1975.825" EndTime="1978.550" Participant="me010">
Or, you know, the church across from City Hall, or -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1978.580" EndTime="1981.620" Participant="me003">
Or the re- the restaurant where they wear <Foreign Language="de"> lederhosen? </Foreign> Or is that -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1978.594" EndTime="1979.350" Participant="mn015">
Or the- <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1978.734" EndTime="1979.384" Participant="mn036">
Right.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1980.599" EndTime="1982.043" Participant="me010">
Yeah, that would be fine.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1980.866" EndTime="1985.672" Participant="fe004">
<VocalSound Description="laugh"/> Uniquely.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1981.290" EndTime="1982.180" Participant="mn036">
Right.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1981.770" EndTime="1983.649" Participant="me003">
O_K. <VocalSound Description="laugh"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1982.043" EndTime="1982.850" Participant="me010">
Yeah.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1982.115" EndTime="1987.077" Participant="mn015">
O- or - or tower, or <Emphasis> this </Emphasis> tower, or <Emphasis> that </Emphasis> building, or - <Comment Description="list"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1982.390" EndTime="1983.270" Participant="mn036">
Right.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1986.958" EndTime="1993.282" Participant="me012">
<NonVocalSound Description="mike noise"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1987.077" EndTime="1987.450" Participant="mn015">
hmm? <Comment Description="meaning &quot;right?&quot;"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1987.920" EndTime="1988.810" Participant="me003">
O_K.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1989.930" EndTime="1992.270" Participant="me010">
<VocalSound Description="mouth"/> Or you can say "how -" you know, "how do I get <Emphasis> back? </Emphasis>"
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1990.180" EndTime="1991.130" Participant="me003">
Trying to -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1992.490" EndTime="1993.470" Participant="me003">
Yeah, yeah.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1993.220" EndTime="1994.140" Participant="me010">
O_K.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="1998.848" EndTime="2002.771" Participant="me010">
<VocalSound Description="inbreath"/> And, <Emphasis> again, </Emphasis> it's just a question of <Emphasis> which </Emphasis> of these things,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2002.771" EndTime="2005.943" Participant="me010">
uh, people want to <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2005.943" EndTime="2008.160" Participant="me010">
dive <Emphasis> into. </Emphasis> What,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2008.503" EndTime="2011.623" Participant="me010">
uh, I think <Emphasis> I'm </Emphasis> gonna try to do, <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2011.623" EndTime="2014.279" Participant="me010">
and I guess, pwww! <Comment Description="vocal gesture during a speculation"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2014.279" EndTime="2016.578" Participant="me010">
let's say that by the end of spring break,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2016.829" EndTime="2019.259" Participant="me010">
I'll try to come up with some <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2019.259" EndTime="2022.040" Participant="me010">
<Emphasis> general </Emphasis> story about,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2022.366" EndTime="2028.580" Participant="me010">
um, construction grammar, and what constructions we'd use and how all this might
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2028.580" EndTime="2032.832" Participant="me010">
fit together. There's this whole <Emphasis> framework </Emphasis> problem that I'm feeling really uncomfortable about. <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2032.832" EndTime="2035.560" Participant="me010">
And I haven't had a chance to <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2036.340" EndTime="2038.785" Participant="me010">
think about it seriously. But I - I want to -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2039.150" EndTime="2041.547" Participant="me010">
I want to do that <Emphasis> early, </Emphasis> rather than <Emphasis> late. </Emphasis>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2041.810" EndTime="2044.045" Participant="me010">
And you and I will probably have to talk about this some.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2044.103" EndTime="2045.429" Participant="mn015">
<VocalSound Description="inbreath"/> u- u- u- u-
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2045.349" EndTime="2046.312" Participant="me010">
<VocalSound Description="inbreath"/> <Comment Description="as if to speak"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2045.429" EndTime="2047.220" Participant="mn015">
That's what strikes me, that we sort of -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2047.250" EndTime="2048.713" Participant="mn015">
the de- g- uh, <Emphasis> small </Emphasis> -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2048.713" EndTime="2056.490" Participant="mn015">
Something, uh, maybe we should address one of these days, is to - <VocalSound Description="breath"/> That <Emphasis> most </Emphasis> of the work people actually always do is look at some statements,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2056.490" EndTime="2061.022" Participant="mn015">
and - and analyze <Emphasis> those. </Emphasis> <VocalSound Description="breath"/> Whether it's abstracts or newspapers and stuff like this. <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2060.425" EndTime="2061.604" Participant="me010">
Hmm. <VocalSound Description="mouth"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2061.022" EndTime="2066.590" Participant="mn015">
But the whole - i- is it - is it really <Emphasis> relevant </Emphasis> that we are dealing mostly with, sort of, <Emphasis> questions? </Emphasis>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2067.190" EndTime="2070.945" Participant="me010">
<VocalSound Description="mouth"/> Oh, <Emphasis> yeah? </Emphasis> Well, I mean <Emphasis> yeah, </Emphasis> I- d-
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2067.590" EndTime="2068.750" Participant="mn015">
Uh, you know -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2069.680" EndTime="2075.720" Participant="mn015">
And this is - It seems to me that we should maybe at least spend a session or - or brainstorm a little bit about whether that l-
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2076.030" EndTime="2078.439" Participant="mn015">
this is <Emphasis> special </Emphasis> case in that sense.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2078.022" EndTime="2078.905" Participant="me012">
Mm-hmm.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2079.314" EndTime="2080.790" Participant="mn015">
Um, <VocalSound Description="long closed-mouth outbreath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2080.790" EndTime="2081.650" Participant="mn015">
I don't know. <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2084.248" EndTime="2088.920" Participant="mn015">
You know - Did we ever find m- metaphorical use in - in questions in - in that sense, really?
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2088.960" EndTime="2089.750" Participant="me010">
Yeah.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2090.228" EndTime="2091.594" Participant="me012">
<VocalSound Description="mouth"/> <Uncertain NumSyllables="3"> @@ </Uncertain> <Comment Description="uncodeable vocal fragments"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2090.790" EndTime="2091.650" Participant="me010">
You will.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2090.986" EndTime="2092.766" Participant="mn015">
And how soon, I <Uncertain> don't know </Uncertain>.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2091.997" EndTime="2092.820" Participant="me010">
Oh, yeah.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2094.870" EndTime="2096.188" Participant="me010">
I mean, uh, we could take
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2096.188" EndTime="2099.082" Participant="me010">
all the standard metaphor examples and make question
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2099.082" EndTime="2100.400" Participant="me010">
versions of them.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2101.709" EndTime="2102.738" Participant="me010">
O_K.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2102.224" EndTime="2103.660" Participant="mn036">
<Uncertain> Muh- </Uncertain>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2102.374" EndTime="2104.670" Participant="mn015">
"<Emphasis> Who </Emphasis> got kicked out of France?" Nuh.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2103.660" EndTime="2110.240" Participant="me010">
Yeah, or, you know. "Wh- why is he - why is he pushing for promotion?" or, "who's pushing proof-" er, just pick - pick any of them and just <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2104.280" EndTime="2105.400" Participant="mn036">
Right.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2106.713" EndTime="2107.210" Participant="mn015">
Nuh.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2109.817" EndTime="2110.464" Participant="mn015">
Mm-hmm.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2110.240" EndTime="2111.248" Participant="me010">
do the - eh -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2111.202" EndTime="2113.549" Participant="mn015">
<VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2111.248" EndTime="2113.195" Participant="me010">
So I don't - I don't think, <VocalSound Description="mouth"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2113.195" EndTime="2114.679" Participant="me010">
uh, it's at <Emphasis> all </Emphasis>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2113.549" EndTime="2131.909" Participant="mn015">
<VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2115.068" EndTime="2116.054" Participant="me010">
<Emphasis> difficult </Emphasis> -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2116.850" EndTime="2121.855" Participant="me010">
Uh, to convert them to question forms that <Emphasis> really </Emphasis> exist and people say all the <Emphasis> time, </Emphasis>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2121.855" EndTime="2124.190" Participant="me010">
<VocalSound Description="breath"/> um -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2125.760" EndTime="2130.133" Participant="me010">
And - sort of - we don't know how to handle them, <Emphasis> too. </Emphasis> Right? I mean, it's -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2130.133" EndTime="2130.830" Participant="me010">
I d-
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2131.060" EndTime="2131.864" Participant="me010">
It -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2131.864" EndTime="2134.011" Participant="me010">
We <Emphasis> don't </Emphasis> know how to handle the <Emphasis> declarative </Emphasis> forms,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2131.909" EndTime="2136.547" Participant="mn015">
<NonVocalSound Description="mike noise"/> <VocalSound Description="cough in background"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2132.080" EndTime="2135.080" Participant="fe004">
<VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2134.454" EndTime="2134.693" Participant="me010">
<Uncertain NumSyllables="1"> @@ </Uncertain> <Comment Description="uncodeable vocal fragment"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2134.927" EndTime="2135.721" Participant="me010">
<Emphasis> really, </Emphasis>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2135.721" EndTime="2139.517" Participant="me010">
and, then, the interrogative forms, ah-oh. <Comment Description="vocal gesture"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2138.109" EndTime="2140.054" Participant="mn015">
<VocalSound Description="cough in background"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2139.969" EndTime="2140.622" Participant="me010">
Uh.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2140.411" EndTime="2145.497" Participant="mn015">
<NonVocalSound Description="mike noise"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2140.891" EndTime="2141.781" Participant="me012">
Ooo! <Comment Description="interjection, possibly with empathy for painful-sounding cough"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2141.457" EndTime="2143.115" Participant="me010">
Yeah. Nancy, it looked like you were s-
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2142.610" EndTime="2144.599" Participant="fe004">
<VocalSound Description="breath"/> Oh. it's just that - that the goals
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2144.599" EndTime="2149.980" Participant="fe004">
are g- very different to cases - So we <Emphasis> had </Emphasis> this problem last year when we first <Emphasis> thought </Emphasis> about this domain, actually, was that <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2149.224" EndTime="2150.012" Participant="me012">
<NonVocalSound Description="mike noise"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2150.020" EndTime="2156.220" Participant="fe004">
<Emphasis> most </Emphasis> of the things we talked about are our story understanding. Uh, we're gonna have a short discourse and <VocalSound Description="breath"/> the person talking is trying to,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2152.533" EndTime="2153.115" Participant="me010">
Right.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2154.030" EndTime="2158.086" Participant="me012">
<NonVocalSound Description="mike noise"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2156.300" EndTime="2160.290" Participant="fe004">
I don't know, give you a statement and tell you something. And here, <VocalSound Description="breath"/> it's th- <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2158.378" EndTime="2160.910" Participant="mn015">
Help you create a mental model, blah-blah-blah. <Comment Description="completing [fe004]'s utterance"/> Yeah.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2160.880" EndTime="2168.106" Participant="fe004">
Yea- eh - y- <Emphasis> Yeah, </Emphasis> I <Emphasis> guess </Emphasis> so. And then here, y- you are j- uh, the person is getting information and they or may not be following some larger plan, <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2161.574" EndTime="2162.199" Participant="me010">
Yes.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2168.106" EndTime="2171.048" Participant="fe004">
you know, that we have to recognize or, you know, infer.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2171.048" EndTime="2174.720" Participant="fe004">
And th- th- the - their discourse patterns probably <NonVocalSound Description="mike noise"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2174.860" EndTime="2176.509" Participant="fe004">
don't follo- follow quite as many
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2176.509" EndTime="2179.310" Participant="fe004">
<VocalSound Description="breath"/> logical connec- <VocalSound Description="breath"/> Yeah.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2176.760" EndTime="2180.455" Participant="me010">
<VocalSound Description="breath"/> Right. No, I think that's one of things that's interesting, is - is in this sort of
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2178.139" EndTime="2180.755" Participant="mn015">
<NonVocalSound Description="mike noise"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2179.310" EndTime="2182.136" Participant="fe004">
<VocalSound Description="breath"/> <NonVocalSound Description="mike noise"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2180.722" EndTime="2186.278" Participant="me010">
over-<Emphasis> arching </Emphasis> story we - we worked it out for th- as you <Emphasis> say, </Emphasis> this - the storytelling scenario.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2182.136" EndTime="2183.147" Participant="fe004">
<VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2183.147" EndTime="2183.578" Participant="fe004">
Mm-hmm.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2183.578" EndTime="2186.093" Participant="fe004">
<VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2186.093" EndTime="2187.094" Participant="fe004">
Mm-hmm.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2186.278" EndTime="2188.510" Participant="me010">
And I think it's really worth thinking <Emphasis> through </Emphasis> <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2187.094" EndTime="2189.436" Participant="fe004">
<VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2188.795" EndTime="2188.879" Participant="me010">
<VocalSound Description="mouth"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2189.167" EndTime="2191.792" Participant="me010">
what it looks like. What is the simspec mean, et cetera.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2189.436" EndTime="2190.900" Participant="fe004">
Mm-hmm. M-
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2191.762" EndTime="2199.829" Participant="fe004">
Right. Cuz for a while we were thinking, "well, how can we <Emphasis> change </Emphasis> the, <VocalSound Description="breath"/> um, data to sort of illicit tha- <VocalSound Description="laugh"/> illicit, um, actions that are <Emphasis> more </Emphasis> like what we are used to?" <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2192.201" EndTime="2192.789" Participant="me010">
<VocalSound Description="mouth"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2194.270" EndTime="2204.342" Participant="me012">
<NonVocalSound Description="mike noise"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2199.829" EndTime="2203.390" Participant="fe004">
But obviously we would rather, you know, try to figure out what's - what's, you know -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2201.639" EndTime="2205.714" Participant="me010">
Well, I don't know. I mean, maybe - maybe that's what we'll do is - is s- u- e-
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2205.714" EndTime="2211.870" Participant="me010">
We can do anything we want with it. I mean, once we have fulfilled these requirements,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2206.635" EndTime="2207.743" Participant="fe004">
Yep. Mmm - Mm-hmm.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2210.712" EndTime="2212.153" Participant="fe004">
<VocalSound Description="breath"/> Mm-hmm. <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2212.460" EndTime="2215.062" Participant="me010">
O_K, and the one for next
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2215.062" EndTime="2216.956" Participant="me010">
uh, <Emphasis> summer </Emphasis> is just
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2215.457" EndTime="2216.780" Participant="fe004">
<VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2216.956" EndTime="2219.034" Participant="me010">
<Emphasis> half </Emphasis> done and then the <Emphasis> other </Emphasis> half is this,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2217.416" EndTime="2219.290" Participant="fe004">
<VocalSound Description="breath"/> Mm-hmm.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2219.034" EndTime="2220.170" Participant="me010">
um,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2220.170" EndTime="2222.461" Participant="me010">
"generation thing" which we think isn't much different.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2222.461" EndTime="2223.881" Participant="me010">
So once <Emphasis> that's </Emphasis> done,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2223.881" EndTime="2225.783" Participant="me010">
then <Emphasis> all </Emphasis> the rest of it is,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2225.783" EndTime="2226.907" Participant="me010">
uh, sort of,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2226.862" EndTime="2229.741" Participant="me012">
<NonVocalSound Description="mike noise"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2226.907" EndTime="2228.654" Participant="me010">
you know, what <Emphasis> we </Emphasis> want to do for the <Emphasis> research. </Emphasis>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2229.204" EndTime="2233.147" Participant="me010">
And we can - w- we can do all <Emphasis> sorts </Emphasis> of things that don't fit into their
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2233.606" EndTime="2234.685" Participant="me010">
framework at <Emphasis> all. </Emphasis>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2235.456" EndTime="2237.312" Participant="mn036">
<VocalSound Description="inbreath"/> <Comment Description="as if to speak"/> <VocalSound Description="outbreath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2235.594" EndTime="2238.472" Participant="me010">
Th- there's <Emphasis> no </Emphasis> reason why we're c- we're constrained to <Emphasis> do </Emphasis> that.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2235.687" EndTime="2237.000" Participant="fe004">
Mm-hmm.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2238.472" EndTime="2241.002" Participant="me010">
<Emphasis> If </Emphasis> we can <Emphasis> use </Emphasis> all the, uh,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2241.002" EndTime="2242.405" Participant="me010">
<Emphasis> execution </Emphasis> engines,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2241.173" EndTime="2246.869" Participant="me012">
<NonVocalSound Description="mike noise"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2242.405" EndTime="2243.310" Participant="me010">
then we can,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2243.476" EndTime="2243.556" Participant="me010">
<VocalSound Description="mouth"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2243.556" EndTime="2245.080" Participant="me010">
you know, <Emphasis> really </Emphasis>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2244.903" EndTime="2246.439" Participant="fe004">
<VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2245.080" EndTime="2245.174" Participant="me010">
<NonVocalSound Description="mike noise"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2245.427" EndTime="2247.037" Participant="me010">
<Emphasis> try </Emphasis> things that
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2246.439" EndTime="2247.762" Participant="fe004">
Mm-hmm.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2247.386" EndTime="2251.114" Participant="me010">
would be too - too much pain to do <Emphasis> ourselves. </Emphasis> But there's no <Emphasis> obligation </Emphasis> on any of this. <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2251.114" EndTime="2254.878" Participant="me010">
So, if we want to turn it into u- understan- standing <Emphasis> stories </Emphasis> about Heidelberg,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2255.283" EndTime="2255.957" Participant="me010">
<Emphasis> we </Emphasis> can do that.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2256.993" EndTime="2258.650" Participant="me010">
I mean, that would just be a t- a- um -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2259.581" EndTime="2261.657" Participant="mn036">
<VocalSound Description="inbreath"/> <Comment Description="as if to speak"/> <VocalSound Description="outbreath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2259.679" EndTime="2261.248" Participant="mn015">
Or, as a matter of fact, we <Emphasis> need </Emphasis> - <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2260.314" EndTime="2260.600" Participant="me010">
<VocalSound Description="mouth"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2261.248" EndTime="2266.225" Participant="mn015">
and if we if we'r- eh - take a <Emphasis> ten </Emphasis> year perspective, we <Emphasis> need </Emphasis> to do that, <VocalSound Description="breath"/> because <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2266.225" EndTime="2266.949" Participant="mn015">
w-
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2266.949" EndTime="2274.204" Participant="mn015">
e- w- a- Assuming we <Emphasis> have </Emphasis> this, um, we- we- ta- in that case we <Pronounce> actually </Pronounce> <Emphasis> do </Emphasis> have these wonderful stories, and historical anecdotes, and
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2270.284" EndTime="2270.802" Participant="me010">
Yeah.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2273.847" EndTime="2274.400" Participant="fe004">
Mmm.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2274.204" EndTime="2276.769" Participant="mn015">
knights jumping out of windows, and-and-and - <Comment Description="meaning &quot;and so forth&quot;, iterative as intensifier"/> <Comment Description="abandoned list"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2276.769" EndTime="2280.084" Participant="mn015">
<Emphasis> tons </Emphasis> of stuff. <VocalSound Description="breath"/> So, th- the database is huge, <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2280.084" EndTime="2283.090" Participant="mn015">
and if we want to answer a <Emphasis> question </Emphasis> on that,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2283.478" EndTime="2287.240" Participant="mn015">
we actually have to go one step before that, and <Emphasis> understand </Emphasis> that.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2287.159" EndTime="2288.034" Participant="fe004">
Mm-hmm.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2287.618" EndTime="2291.980" Participant="mn015">
In order to e- do <Emphasis> sensible </Emphasis> information extraction. And so, <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2288.668" EndTime="2289.632" Participant="fe004">
Yeah.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2290.043" EndTime="2290.765" Participant="fe004">
Mm-hmm.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2290.809" EndTime="2291.000" Participant="me010">
<VocalSound Description="mouth"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2291.320" EndTime="2292.220" Participant="me010">
You <Emphasis> might, </Emphasis> yeah.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2291.889" EndTime="2293.551" Participant="mn036">
<Uncertain> Mwa- Mm-hmm. </Uncertain> <Comment Description="whispered"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2292.220" EndTime="2300.417" Participant="mn015">
um, this has been a - a - a <Emphasis> Deep </Emphasis> Map <Emphasis> research </Emphasis> issue that was - is - is part of the unresolved, and to-do's, and something for the future, is <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2300.417" EndTime="2301.458" Participant="mn015">
how can we sort of
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2301.458" EndTime="2306.930" Participant="mn015">
<Emphasis> run </Emphasis> our our <Emphasis> text, </Emphasis> our <Emphasis> content, </Emphasis> through a <Emphasis> machine </Emphasis> <VocalSound Description="breath"/> that will enable <Emphasis> us, </Emphasis> later, to
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2305.225" EndTime="2305.918" Participant="fe004">
Mm-hmm.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2306.120" EndTime="2309.756" Participant="me012">
<NonVocalSound Description="mike noise"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2307.333" EndTime="2310.400" Participant="mn015">
retrieve or answer e- questions more sensibly?
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2308.220" EndTime="2308.943" Participant="fe004">
Mmm.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2309.642" EndTime="2310.209" Participant="me010">
<VocalSound Description="mouth"/> <VocalSound Description="inbreath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2310.209" EndTime="2310.578" Participant="me010">
Right. <Comment Description="whispered"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2310.525" EndTime="2311.031" Participant="mn036">
<VocalSound Description="inbreath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2310.578" EndTime="2310.737" Participant="me010">
<VocalSound Description="inbreath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2310.737" EndTime="2311.461" Participant="me010">
Anyway. S-
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2310.905" EndTime="2314.509" Participant="me012">
<NonVocalSound Description="mike noise"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2311.031" EndTime="2314.370" Participant="mn036">
So, uh - So, uh, I was just going to ask, um, <VocalSound Description="breath"/> so,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2311.461" EndTime="2311.850" Participant="me010">
Who's going?
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2314.740" EndTime="2323.120" Participant="mn036">
what is the - the basic thing that - that you are, um, obligated to do, um, uh, by the summer before w- uh y- c- we can move -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2319.800" EndTime="2320.610" Participant="me010">
Ah!
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2320.846" EndTime="2321.343" Participant="me010">
<VocalSound Description="mouth"/> <VocalSound Description="inbreath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2321.788" EndTime="2324.970" Participant="me010">
O_K. So - eh - Yeah. So, what <Emphasis> happened </Emphasis> is,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2324.970" EndTime="2327.630" Participant="me010">
there's this, eh, uh - Robert was describing
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2327.630" EndTime="2330.638" Participant="me010">
the - There's two packages there's a,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2330.638" EndTime="2333.557" Participant="me010">
uh, quote parser, there's a particular <Emphasis> piece </Emphasis>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2333.557" EndTime="2333.658" Participant="me010">
<VocalSound Description="mouth"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2333.658" EndTime="2336.499" Participant="me010">
of this <Emphasis> big </Emphasis> system, which, in <Emphasis> German, </Emphasis>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2336.499" EndTime="2340.518" Participant="me010">
uh, takes these t- sentence templates and produces X_M_L structures.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2338.049" EndTime="2342.310" Participant="fe004">
<NonVocalSound Description="mike noise"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2340.000" EndTime="2341.450" Participant="mn036">
Right.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2340.518" EndTime="2345.499" Participant="me010">
And <Emphasis> one </Emphasis> of our jobs was to make the <Emphasis> English </Emphasis> equivalent of <Emphasis> that. </Emphasis>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2345.070" EndTime="2346.420" Participant="mn036">
<VocalSound Description="mouth"/> Right.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2345.715" EndTime="2348.410" Participant="me010">
<Emphasis> That, </Emphasis> these guys did in a - in a day.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2346.870" EndTime="2349.120" Participant="mn036">
Right.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2348.586" EndTime="2348.752" Participant="me010">
<VocalSound Description="mouth"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2348.752" EndTime="2352.385" Participant="me010">
The <Emphasis> other </Emphasis> thing is, at the <Emphasis> other </Emphasis> end, <Emphasis> roughly </Emphasis> at the same level,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2352.385" EndTime="2354.094" Participant="me010">
there's something that takes,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2354.094" EndTime="2356.169" Participant="me010">
uh, X_M_<Emphasis> L </Emphasis> structures,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2356.169" EndTime="2359.356" Participant="me010">
produces an <Emphasis> output </Emphasis> X_M_L structure which is
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2359.356" EndTime="2361.415" Participant="me010">
instructions for the <Emphasis> generator. </Emphasis>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2360.920" EndTime="2361.980" Participant="mn036">
Right.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2361.536" EndTime="2361.939" Participant="me010">
<VocalSound Description="mouth"/> <VocalSound Description="inbreath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2361.939" EndTime="2366.502" Participant="me010">
O_K? And then there's a language <Emphasis> generator, </Emphasis> and then after that a s- a synthesizer that
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2366.502" EndTime="2369.944" Participant="me010">
goes from an X_M_L structure to,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2369.944" EndTime="2372.236" Participant="me010">
uh, <Emphasis> language </Emphasis> generation, to
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2372.236" EndTime="2375.030" Participant="me010">
actual specifications for a <Emphasis> synthesizer. </Emphasis>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2374.550" EndTime="2375.840" Participant="mn036">
Right.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2375.030" EndTime="2378.005" Participant="me010">
Eh, but again, there's <Emphasis> one </Emphasis> module in which there's <Emphasis> one </Emphasis>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2378.005" EndTime="2378.746" Participant="me010">
piece
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2378.746" EndTime="2378.921" Participant="me010">
<VocalSound Description="mouth"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2378.921" EndTime="2382.519" Participant="me010">
that we have to convert to English.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2382.085" EndTime="2382.700" Participant="mn036">
Right.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2382.700" EndTime="2383.440" Participant="mn036">
Got it. <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2383.307" EndTime="2383.760" Participant="me010">
Is that -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2385.163" EndTime="2387.221" Participant="me010">
<VocalSound Description="mouth"/> O_K. And that - But as I say, this is -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2387.890" EndTime="2389.780" Participant="me010">
<Emphasis> all </Emphasis> <Emphasis> along </Emphasis> was viewed as a kind of -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2389.780" EndTime="2390.110" Participant="me010">
<VocalSound Description="mouth"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2390.282" EndTime="2392.027" Participant="me010">
a m- a minor thing,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2392.027" EndTime="2394.010" Participant="me010">
<Emphasis> necessary, </Emphasis> but - but not -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2393.540" EndTime="2396.630" Participant="mn036">
Right. Right. That's great!
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2394.338" EndTime="2394.720" Participant="me010">
O_K?
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2394.720" EndTime="2397.819" Participant="me010">
And much more <Emphasis> interesting </Emphasis> is the fact that,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2397.819" EndTime="2401.155" Participant="me010">
<VocalSound Description="mouth"/> as part of <Emphasis> doing </Emphasis> this, we - we are,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2401.155" EndTime="2404.299" Participant="me010">
you know, inheriting this system that does all <Emphasis> sort- </Emphasis> of these other
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2404.030" EndTime="2405.250" Participant="mn036">
Right.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2404.779" EndTime="2405.075" Participant="me010">
<VocalSound Description="mouth"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2405.258" EndTime="2406.090" Participant="me010">
things.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2406.090" EndTime="2408.650" Participant="me010">
Not <Emphasis> precisely </Emphasis> what we want, and that's -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2409.267" EndTime="2409.673" Participant="me010">
<VocalSound Description="mouth"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2410.044" EndTime="2411.545" Participant="me010">
that's wh- where it -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2411.545" EndTime="2415.431" Participant="me010">
it gets difficult. And I - I don't pretend to understand yet what I think
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2416.094" EndTime="2417.141" Participant="me010">
we really ought to do.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2421.146" EndTime="2421.718" Participant="mn015">
O_K.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2422.790" EndTime="2424.432" Participant="mn015">
So, e- enough of that,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2424.432" EndTime="2426.210" Participant="mn015">
but I, uh, um,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2426.470" EndTime="2428.014" Participant="mn015">
mmm,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2428.014" EndTime="2431.240" Participant="mn015">
the e- sort of, Johno and I will take up that
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2431.240" EndTime="2432.530" Participant="mn015">
responsibility,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2432.312" EndTime="2435.008" Participant="me010">
<VocalSound Description="mouth"/> <VocalSound Description="inbreath-outbreath"/> <Comment Description="as if to speak"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2433.055" EndTime="2436.609" Participant="mn015">
and, um, get a first draft of <Emphasis> that. </Emphasis> <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2436.609" EndTime="2442.180" Participant="mn015">
Now, we have um just, I think <Emphasis> two </Emphasis> more <Emphasis> short </Emphasis> things.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2441.798" EndTime="2442.300" Participant="me010">
O_K.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2443.220" EndTime="2444.130" Participant="mn015">
Um,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2444.457" EndTime="2448.966" Participant="mn015">
y- you guys sort of started fighting, uh, on the Bayes-net
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2448.610" EndTime="2452.058" Participant="fe004">
<VocalSound Description="laugh"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2448.966" EndTime="2451.560" Participant="mn015">
"Noisy-OR" front? <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2449.221" EndTime="2449.950" Participant="me012">
Hmm.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2450.372" EndTime="2451.370" Participant="me012">
<VocalSound Description="laugh"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2451.370" EndTime="2453.197" Participant="me012">
Yeah, I thought I should, um,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2453.197" EndTime="2455.924" Participant="me012">
talk a little bit about <Emphasis> that, </Emphasis> because that might be a good, uh,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2455.924" EndTime="2459.970" Participant="me012">
sort of architecture to have, in general for, uh, problems with, <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2458.035" EndTime="2458.435" Participant="me010">
<VocalSound Description="mouth"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2458.435" EndTime="2458.932" Participant="me010">
Good!
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2458.932" EndTime="2459.673" Participant="me010">
O_K.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2460.180" EndTime="2462.280" Participant="me012">
you know, multiple inputs to a node.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2461.546" EndTime="2462.161" Participant="me010">
Good.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2462.161" EndTime="2464.446" Participant="me010">
And what's the <Emphasis> other </Emphasis> one? so that - just we know what the d- agenda is?
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2463.852" EndTime="2467.130" Participant="mn015">
Um, the <Emphasis> Wu </Emphasis> paper, I think maybe -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2465.780" EndTime="2472.343" Participant="me010">
<VocalSound Description="breath"/> Oh, yeah. I've got a couple <Emphasis> new </Emphasis> Wu papers as well. Uh, so I - I've been in contact with Wu, so, <Emphasis> probably </Emphasis> let's
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2469.780" EndTime="2471.420" Participant="mn015">
<VocalSound Description="cough"/> <VocalSound Description="cough"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2472.760" EndTime="2475.077" Participant="me010">
put that off till I - I - till I understand better,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2475.077" EndTime="2475.558" Participant="me010">
<VocalSound Description="mouth"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2475.558" EndTime="2481.127" Participant="me010">
uh, what he's doing. It's just a <Emphasis> little </Emphasis> embarrassing cause all this was in his thesis and I was on his thesis committee,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2479.957" EndTime="2480.916" Participant="fe004">
<VocalSound Description="breath-laugh"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2480.575" EndTime="2482.346" Participant="mn036">
<VocalSound Description="laugh"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2481.127" EndTime="2484.553" Participant="me010">
and, so, <VocalSound Description="laugh"/> I r- really <Emphasis> knew </Emphasis> this at one time.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2481.660" EndTime="2482.630" Participant="me003">
<VocalSound Description="laugh"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2482.346" EndTime="2484.201" Participant="mn036">
<Pronounce> Ugh. </Pronounce> <Comment Description="interjection"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2484.553" EndTime="2485.732" Participant="me010">
But, I - I -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2484.671" EndTime="2485.422" Participant="fe004">
<VocalSound Description="cough-laugh"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2485.732" EndTime="2489.703" Participant="me010">
<Uncertain> It's not only uh </Uncertain> Is - Part of what I haven't figured out yet is - is how all this goes together.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2489.703" EndTime="2491.233" Participant="me010">
So I'll dig up some more
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2491.233" EndTime="2492.596" Participant="me010">
stuff from Dekai.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2493.080" EndTime="2495.720" Participant="me010">
And - so why don't we just do the, uh -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2495.830" EndTime="2500.550" Participant="me012">
O_K. So - <VocalSound Description="breath"/> should I - Is there a white board here that I can use?
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2501.083" EndTime="2502.320" Participant="me010">
Yeah. You could -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2501.090" EndTime="2502.180" Participant="me012">
Uh -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2501.660" EndTime="2502.560" Participant="fe004">
Yeah. <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2502.320" EndTime="2504.000" Participant="me012">
Or shall I just use this?
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2502.320" EndTime="2503.174" Participant="me010">
<Uncertain> squealing sound? </Uncertain>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2503.358" EndTime="2504.948" Participant="me010">
It's <Emphasis> probably </Emphasis> just as easy. I-
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2504.370" EndTime="2505.130" Participant="mn036">
Yeah.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2504.870" EndTime="2505.637" Participant="me012">
Yeah.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2505.510" EndTime="2507.280" Participant="me003">
You can put the microphone in your pocket.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2507.270" EndTime="2508.120" Participant="me012">
Hey! <Comment Description="in response to another person's comment"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2507.970" EndTime="2508.790" Participant="me003">
<VocalSound Description="laugh"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2508.818" EndTime="2509.630" Participant="fe004">
<VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2511.920" EndTime="2514.560" Participant="me003">
I was envying you and your pocket cause I don't have one. <VocalSound Description="breath-laugh"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2513.865" EndTime="2515.885" Participant="mn036">
<VocalSound Description="laugh"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2514.130" EndTime="2514.997" Participant="fe004">
<VocalSound Description="laugh"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2514.997" EndTime="2516.580" Participant="fe004">
It was a quick one, <Uncertain> huh </Uncertain>?
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2515.490" EndTime="2518.050" Participant="me010">
That's why they invented "pocket T_'s".
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2516.580" EndTime="2517.340" Participant="fe004">
<NonVocalSound Description="mike noise"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2517.340" EndTime="2519.451" Participant="fe004">
They have clips! <VocalSound Description="breath"/> Huh.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2517.650" EndTime="2518.840" Participant="me003">
exactly <VocalSound Description="laugh"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2519.100" EndTime="2522.400" Participant="me012">
Yeah. So, um - <VocalSound Description="breath"/> Recall that, uh,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2522.090" EndTime="2525.150" Participant="fe004">
<VocalSound Description="breath"/> <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2523.130" EndTime="2525.528" Participant="me003">
<VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2524.210" EndTime="2525.572" Participant="me012">
we want to have
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2525.572" EndTime="2528.431" Participant="me012">
this kind of structure in our Bayes-nets. <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2526.306" EndTime="2527.486" Participant="me003">
<VocalSound Description="breath-laugh"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2528.431" EndTime="2534.000" Participant="me012">
Namely, that, um - <VocalSound Description="breath"/> <VocalSound Description="mouth"/> You have these nodes that have several bands, right? So -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2534.000" EndTime="2535.980" Participant="me012">
<Uncertain> Does </Uncertain> I mean, they sort of - <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2536.690" EndTime="2543.230" Participant="me012">
the typical example is that, um, these are all a bunch of cues for something, and this is a certain effect that we'd like to conclude.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2543.300" EndTime="2544.138" Participant="me012">
So, uh - <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2544.138" EndTime="2549.147" Participant="me012">
Like, let's just look at the case when, um, this is actually the - the final action, right? So this is like, uh, <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2550.119" EndTime="2550.588" Participant="me012">
you know,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2550.895" EndTime="2552.108" Participant="mn015">
<VocalSound Description="mouth"/> Y-
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2551.029" EndTime="2553.620" Participant="me012">
touch, or - Sorry. Uh <Pause/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2552.589" EndTime="2553.709" Participant="mn015">
E_- <Pronounce Pronunciation="&quot;ee-fuh&quot;"> EVA </Pronounce>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2553.709" EndTime="2556.356" Participant="mn015">
<VocalSound Description="laugh"/> <Uncertain NumSyllables="3"> @@ </Uncertain> <VocalSound Description="laugh"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2554.260" EndTime="2556.724" Participant="me012">
Yeah, E_- <VocalSound Description="while laughing"/> <Emphasis> E_V_A </Emphasis>, right?
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2556.370" EndTime="2556.977" Participant="mn015">
Yeah.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2556.724" EndTime="2559.636" Participant="me012">
Enter, V- View, Approach, right? <VocalSound Description="breath"/> <NonVocalSound Description="mike noises"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2558.190" EndTime="2561.150" Participant="mn036">
W- what was this? It - i- i- i- ehhh, <Comment Description="vocal gesture of hindrance"/> i- ehhh. <Comment Description="vocal gesture of hindrance"/> <VocalSound Description="laugh"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2559.636" EndTime="2561.180" Participant="me012">
So, this is -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2559.912" EndTime="2561.371" Participant="me010">
Wri- write it out for- for -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2561.470" EndTime="2563.030" Participant="me012">
Yeah. Enter,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2561.540" EndTime="2563.211" Participant="mn036">
I mean - <VocalSound Description="breath-laugh"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2563.040" EndTime="2563.830" Participant="me012">
View,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2564.040" EndTime="2565.410" Participant="me012">
Approach.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2564.350" EndTime="2565.700" Participant="mn036">
O_K. Right.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2565.710" EndTime="2566.375" Participant="me012">
Right.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2566.740" EndTime="2571.750" Participant="me012">
So, I mean, we'd like to - take all these various cues, right? So this one might be, say, uh - <VocalSound Description="mouth"/> <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2566.821" EndTime="2568.089" Participant="mn015">
<VocalSound Description="laugh-breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2568.440" EndTime="2572.825" Participant="mn036">
Like the army. Yeah. <VocalSound Description="laugh"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2569.467" EndTime="2574.039" Participant="fe004">
New terminology? <VocalSound Description="laugh"/> I haven't heard that before. <VocalSound Description="breath-laugh"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2570.491" EndTime="2571.335" Participant="mn015">
<VocalSound Description="laugh-breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2571.830" EndTime="2574.090" Participant="me012">
Well, let me pick a random one and say, uh -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2571.845" EndTime="2572.728" Participant="mn015">
Hmm?
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2571.877" EndTime="2573.132" Participant="me010">
<NonVocalSound Description="mike noise"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2573.386" EndTime="2575.072" Participant="mn015">
<VocalSound Description="laugh"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2574.039" EndTime="2575.089" Participant="fe004">
<VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2574.090" EndTime="2575.384" Participant="me012">
I don't know, it could be, like - <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2575.384" EndTime="2580.261" Participant="me012">
This isn't the way it really is, but let me say - that, suppose someone mentioned, uh,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2580.261" EndTime="2581.694" Participant="me012">
admission fees <Pause/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2581.694" EndTime="2583.107" Participant="me012">
<VocalSound Description="sucking on lower lip"/> <Comment Description="vocal gesture, while thinking"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2583.440" EndTime="2585.900" Participant="me012">
Ah, it takes too long. Try - let me just say "Landmark".
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2585.500" EndTime="2586.820" Participant="fe004">
<VocalSound Description="laugh"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2585.900" EndTime="2587.401" Participant="me012">
If the thing is a landmark,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2587.401" EndTime="2592.554" Participant="me012">
you know, <VocalSound Description="breath"/> um - then there's another thing that says if - <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2592.554" EndTime="2593.966" Participant="me012">
um - <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2593.966" EndTime="2596.776" Participant="me012">
if it's <Emphasis> closed </Emphasis> or not, at the moment.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2597.493" EndTime="2603.929" Participant="me012">
Alright, so you have nodes. <VocalSound Description="breath"/> Right? And the, uh, problem that we were having was that, you know, given N_nodes, there's "two to the N" <Pause/> <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2603.929" EndTime="2610.522" Participant="me012">
Given N_nodes, and furthermore, the fact that there's three things here, we need to specify "three times", uh, "two to the N" probabilities. <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2610.522" EndTime="2617.412" Participant="me012">
Right? That's assuming these are all binary, which f- they may not be. For example, they could be "time of day", in which case we could, uh, say, you know, "Morning,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2617.412" EndTime="2620.427" Participant="me012">
afternoon, evening, night". So, this could be more <Pause/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2618.938" EndTime="2622.232" Participant="fe004">
<VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2620.860" EndTime="2622.373" Participant="me012">
So, it's a <Emphasis> lot, </Emphasis> anyway. <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2622.373" EndTime="2626.556" Participant="me012">
And, that's a lot of probabilities to put here, which is kind of a pain. So <Pause/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2626.556" EndTime="2629.324" Participant="me012">
Noisy-ORs are a way to, uh, <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2629.324" EndTime="2630.454" Participant="me012">
sort of deal with this.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2630.987" EndTime="2632.310" Participant="me012">
Um <Pause/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2632.847" EndTime="2634.332" Participant="me012">
Where should I put this? <Comment Description="quietly"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2633.135" EndTime="2633.521" Participant="me010">
<VocalSound Description="mouth"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2634.251" EndTime="2637.070" Participant="me010">
<VocalSound Description="long outbreath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2634.332" EndTime="2636.930" Participant="me012">
So, the idea is that, um, <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2640.100" EndTime="2648.170" Participant="me012">
Let's call these, uh, C_one, C_two, C_three, and C_four, and E_, for Cause and Effect, I guess.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2652.830" EndTime="2655.850" Participant="me012">
The idea is to have these intermediate nodes. <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2658.530" EndTime="2658.990" Participant="me012">
Right.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2659.050" EndTime="2659.754" Participant="me012">
<VocalSound Description="mouth"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2659.754" EndTime="2661.104" Participant="me012">
<NonVocalSound Description="mike noise"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2661.104" EndTime="2667.560" Participant="me012">
Well, actually, the idea, first of all, is that each of these things has a - quote-unquote <Emphasis> distinguished </Emphasis> state, which means that this is
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2667.560" EndTime="2670.198" Participant="me012">
<VocalSound Description="mouth"/> the state in which we don't <Pronounce> really </Pronounce> know anything about it. So - right? <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2670.198" EndTime="2674.320" Participant="me012">
So, for example, if we don't really know <VocalSound Description="breath"/> if the thing is a landmark or not,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2674.644" EndTime="2680.358" Participant="me012">
Or, i- if that just doesn't seem relevant, then that would be th- sort of the Disting- the Distinguish state. It's a really, you know, <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2680.358" EndTime="2683.080" Participant="me012">
if there is something for the person talking about the admission fee,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2683.320" EndTime="2686.225" Participant="me012">
you know, if they didn't talk about it, that would be the Distinguish state. <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2686.111" EndTime="2689.320" Participant="mn015">
<VocalSound Description="mouth"/> S- so, this is a fanciful way of saying "default"?
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2686.225" EndTime="2687.779" Participant="me012">
So - <VocalSound Description="outbreath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2689.320" EndTime="2692.430" Participant="me012">
Yeah, yeah. That's just what they - the word they used in that paper. <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2689.944" EndTime="2690.614" Participant="mn015">
O_K.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2691.067" EndTime="2691.586" Participant="mn015">
Mm-hmm.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2692.430" EndTime="2698.770" Participant="me012">
So, the idea is that, um, <VocalSound Description="breath"/> you have these intermediate nodes, right? E_one, E_two, E_three and E_four?
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2696.712" EndTime="2697.179" Participant="me010">
<VocalSound Description="mouth"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2697.746" EndTime="2700.383" Participant="me010">
So, this is the Heckerman paper you're working with? Good.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2699.470" EndTime="2700.095" Participant="me012">
Yeah.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2700.972" EndTime="2701.879" Participant="me012">
So <Pause/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2702.356" EndTime="2704.097" Participant="me012">
The idea is that, each of these E_I -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2704.491" EndTime="2706.044" Participant="me012">
is - <VocalSound Description="mouth"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2706.044" EndTime="2708.170" Participant="me012">
represents <Emphasis> what </Emphasis> this would be -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2708.170" EndTime="2710.485" Participant="me012">
if <Emphasis> all </Emphasis> the other ones were in the distinguish state. Right? <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2710.485" EndTime="2714.330" Participant="me012">
So, for example, suppose that the person - I mean, suppose the thing that they talked about is a landmark. <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2714.330" EndTime="2716.865" Participant="me012">
But none of the other - <VocalSound Description="breath"/> sort of cues really apply.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2717.836" EndTime="2719.990" Participant="me012">
Then, <VocalSound Description="cough"/> this would be - <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2720.327" EndTime="2724.839" Participant="me012">
W- The <VocalSound Description="breath"/> this would just represent the probability distribution of this,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2724.839" EndTime="2728.221" Participant="me012">
assuming that this cue is turned on and the other ones just didn't apply? <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2728.221" EndTime="2733.903" Participant="me012">
So, you know, if it is a landmark, and no- none of the other things really ap- applicable, then - this would represent the <Pronounce> probability distribution. </Pronounce> So maybe in this case - <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2734.530" EndTime="2739.744" Participant="me012">
Maybe we just t- k- Maybe we decide that, <Emphasis> if </Emphasis> the thing's a landmark and we don't know anything else, then we're gonna conclude that, um - <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2740.125" EndTime="2745.500" Participant="me012">
They want to view it with <Pronounce> probability, </Pronounce> you know, point four. <Comment Description="number"/> They want to enter it with <Pronounce> probability, </Pronounce> uh -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2747.023" EndTime="2751.089" Participant="me012">
with <Pronounce> probability </Pronounce> point five <Comment Description="number"/> and they want to approach it probability point one, say -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2751.626" EndTime="2754.302" Participant="me012">
Right? So we come up with these l- little tables for each of those <Pause/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2755.024" EndTime="2756.211" Participant="me012">
O_K. <NonVocalSound Description="mike noise"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2756.211" EndTime="2759.071" Participant="me012">
And the final thing is that, um - <VocalSound Description="breath"/> <VocalSound Description="mouth"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2759.071" EndTime="2761.475" Participant="me012">
this is a deterministic function of these, <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2761.475" EndTime="2763.979" Participant="me012">
so we don't <Pronounce> need </Pronounce> to specify any probabilities.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2763.979" EndTime="2766.791" Participant="me012">
We just have to, um, say what function this is, right?
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2763.997" EndTime="2776.720" Participant="mn015">
<NonVocalSound Description="mike noise"/> <VocalSound Description="cough in background"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2766.791" EndTime="2768.808" Participant="me012">
So we can let this be, um -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2768.808" EndTime="2771.810" Participant="me012">
<VocalSound Description="breath"/> G_ of E_one comma E_two.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2771.810" EndTime="2773.720" Participant="me012">
E_three, E_four.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2773.825" EndTime="2774.368" Participant="me012">
Right?
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2774.645" EndTime="2777.390" Participant="me012">
and our example G_ would be, um, <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2777.390" EndTime="2778.950" Participant="me012">
a majority vote?
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2780.093" EndTime="2780.828" Participant="me012">
Right?
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2780.828" EndTime="2781.951" Participant="me012">
<NonVocalSound Description="mike noise"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2781.878" EndTime="2784.532" Participant="me010">
Well. O_K, so th- so the <Emphasis> important </Emphasis> point -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2786.230" EndTime="2787.618" Participant="me010">
is -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2788.070" EndTime="2790.198" Participant="me010">
W- <Emphasis> not </Emphasis> what the G_ function is.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2790.198" EndTime="2791.779" Participant="me010">
The important point is -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2790.360" EndTime="2791.478" Participant="fe004">
<VocalSound Description="sniff"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2790.754" EndTime="2797.161" Participant="mn015">
<NonVocalSound Description="mike noise"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2791.478" EndTime="2794.201" Participant="fe004">
<VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2791.779" EndTime="2792.965" Participant="me010">
that -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2792.988" EndTime="2794.358" Participant="me010">
Um -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2794.358" EndTime="2802.512" Participant="me010">
There is a - a - a general kind of idea of shortcutting the full C_P_T. Th- c- the full conditional probability table - with <Emphasis> some </Emphasis> function.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2802.512" EndTime="2803.127" Participant="me010">
<VocalSound Description="mouth"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2803.127" EndTime="2813.043" Participant="me010">
O_K? Which y- w- you choose appropriately for each case. So, depending on <VocalSound Description="breath"/> what your situation is, <Uncertain> there are </Uncertain> different functions which are most appropriate.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2813.043" EndTime="2814.610" Participant="me010">
And -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2814.610" EndTime="2822.280" Participant="me010">
So I gave - eh - Bhaskara a copy of this, eh - sort of "ninety-two" <Comment Description="year of publication"/> paper. D- and <Emphasis> you </Emphasis> got one, Robert. I don't know who else has seen it.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2819.294" EndTime="2819.837" Participant="me012">
Mm-hmm.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2822.138" EndTime="2825.806" Participant="me012">
There's - I mean - yeah. it's Heckerman and Breese.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2824.333" EndTime="2825.260" Participant="me010">
It's short.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2826.072" EndTime="2826.718" Participant="me010">
It's short.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2826.674" EndTime="2827.207" Participant="me012">
Yeah.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2827.250" EndTime="2830.800" Participant="me010">
So, I- u- w- Um, yo- uh - you - Have <Emphasis> you </Emphasis> read it yet?
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2828.224" EndTime="2829.372" Participant="me012">
<NonVocalSound Description="mike noise"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2830.800" EndTime="2832.651" Participant="me012">
Uh, you can - Yeah, you should take a look at it, I guess.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2831.978" EndTime="2835.280" Participant="me010">
O_K, so you should take a look. Nancy, I'm sure you read it at some point in life.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2832.320" EndTime="2833.220" Participant="me003">
O_K <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2832.651" EndTime="2833.283" Participant="me012">
<NonVocalSound Description="mike noise"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2834.130" EndTime="2835.830" Participant="fe004">
I - yeah. I - I think so, yeah.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2835.830" EndTime="2836.684" Participant="me010">
O_K. <VocalSound Description="inbreath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2836.323" EndTime="2837.186" Participant="fe004">
<Uncertain> Yeah, </Uncertain> <Uncertain NumSyllables="1"> @@ </Uncertain>.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2836.741" EndTime="2842.317" Participant="me010">
And - so, you other guys can decide how interested - <Emphasis> Anyway. </Emphasis> So the paper isn't th- isn't real hard. <VocalSound Description="breath"/> And -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2839.364" EndTime="2840.179" Participant="mn036">
O_K.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2842.667" EndTime="2843.180" Participant="me010">
<VocalSound Description="mouth"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2843.180" EndTime="2844.535" Participant="me010">
Uh -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2844.535" EndTime="2846.548" Participant="me010">
One of the questions <Uncertain> just come at </Uncertain> Bhaskara is,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2846.548" EndTime="2849.482" Participant="me010">
"How much of this does JavaBayes support?"
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2849.559" EndTime="2851.237" Participant="me012">
Yeah, it's a good question. Um <Pause/> <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2851.733" EndTime="2852.130" Participant="me012">
<NonVocalSound Description="mike noise"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2852.130" EndTime="2856.563" Participant="me012">
The - so what we want, is basically JavaBayes to support deterministic, uh, functions. <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2856.170" EndTime="2857.150" Participant="me010">
Right.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2856.563" EndTime="2866.080" Participant="me012">
And, um - <VocalSound Description="breath"/> In a sense it sup- we can make it supported by, um, <VocalSound Description="breath"/> manually, uh, entering, you know, probabilities that are one and zeros, right? <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2864.947" EndTime="2869.317" Participant="me010">
Right. So the little handout that - The little thing that <Emphasis> I </Emphasis> sent - I sent a message saying,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2869.317" EndTime="2872.088" Participant="me010">
uh, here is a way to take -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2872.088" EndTime="2877.475" Participant="me010">
One thing you could do, which is kind of s- in a way, stupid, is take this deterministic function,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2877.475" EndTime="2879.580" Participant="me010">
and use it to build the C_P_T.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2880.344" EndTime="2882.666" Participant="me010">
So, if Ba- JavaBayes won't do it <Emphasis> for </Emphasis> you,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2881.468" EndTime="2882.207" Participant="mn015">
Mmm.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2882.666" EndTime="2887.020" Participant="me010">
that you can convert all that into what the C_P_T would be.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2887.300" EndTime="2893.028" Participant="me010">
Um - and, what <Emphasis> I </Emphasis> sent out about a week ago, was an idea of how to <Emphasis> do </Emphasis> that,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2891.716" EndTime="2897.716" Participant="mn015">
<NonVocalSound Description="mike noise"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2893.028" EndTime="2894.341" Participant="me010">
for,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2894.341" EndTime="2903.240" Participant="me010">
um, evidence combination. So one of - one function that you <Emphasis> could </Emphasis> use as your "G_ function" is an e- e- Evidence-Combining. So you just take <VocalSound Description="breath"/> the -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2903.240" EndTime="2906.897" Participant="me010">
uh, if each of th- if each of the ones has its own
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2906.897" EndTime="2910.086" Participant="me010">
little table like that, <VocalSound Description="breath"/> then you could take the,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2910.086" EndTime="2917.472" Participant="me010">
uh, strength of each of those, times its little table, and you'd add up the total evidence for "V_", "E_", and "A_".
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2914.646" EndTime="2915.638" Participant="me012">
Mmm. <Comment Description="doubtfully"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2917.402" EndTime="2919.518" Participant="me012">
I don't think you can do this, because - <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2918.426" EndTime="2919.294" Participant="fe004">
Mm-hmm.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2919.207" EndTime="2920.165" Participant="me010">
<VocalSound Description="mouth"/> <Pronounce Pronunciation="ending with an aspirated glottal stop"> Yep. </Pronounce>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2919.518" EndTime="2921.300" Participant="me012">
G_ is a function from <Pause/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2924.940" EndTime="2925.523" Participant="me012">
that <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2926.117" EndTime="2927.090" Participant="me012">
to that. <Comment Description="pointing out two things"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2926.814" EndTime="2927.668" Participant="me010">
<VocalSound Description="mouth"/> Right.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2928.100" EndTime="2930.550" Participant="me012">
Right? So there's no numbers. There's just -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2928.530" EndTime="2929.689" Participant="me010">
<NonVocalSound Description="mike noise"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2931.620" EndTime="2935.210" Participant="me012">
quadruplets of - well, N_duplets of, uh, E_Vs.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2933.086" EndTime="2933.725" Participant="me010">
I- i- i-
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2934.020" EndTime="2935.405" Participant="me010">
No, no - But I'm saying is - There -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2935.739" EndTime="2936.198" Participant="me010">
<VocalSound Description="mouth"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2937.008" EndTime="2944.041" Participant="me010">
<VocalSound Description="mouth"/> There is a w- I mean, if y- if - if you decide what's - what is appropriate, is probablistic evidence combination, you can write a function
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2944.590" EndTime="2947.285" Participant="me010">
that does it. It's a <Uncertain> pui- it's </Uncertain> actually one of the examples he's got in there.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2947.865" EndTime="2951.959" Participant="me010">
But, <Emphasis> anyway, </Emphasis> s- skipping - skipping the question of <Emphasis> exactly </Emphasis> which functions -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2952.285" EndTime="2953.591" Participant="me010">
<Uncertain> now is it </Uncertain> clear
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2953.591" EndTime="2956.902" Participant="me010">
that you might like to be able to
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2956.902" EndTime="2958.356" Participant="me010">
shortcut
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2958.356" EndTime="2961.710" Participant="me010">
the whole conditional probability table.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2962.595" EndTime="2970.520" Participant="mn015">
I mean, in some - it seems very plausible in some sense, where we <Emphasis> will </Emphasis> be likely to <Emphasis> not </Emphasis> be - <Emphasis> observe </Emphasis> some of the stuff.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2970.790" EndTime="2973.270" Participant="mn015">
Cuz we don't have the a- access to the information.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2971.600" EndTime="2972.031" Participant="me012">
<NonVocalSound Description="bang in background, of something being dropped"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2972.031" EndTime="2972.925" Participant="me012">
Oops, <Comment Description="interjection"/> sorry. <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2973.397" EndTime="2976.700" Participant="me010">
Right. That's one of the problems, is, W- Is - is, Where would th- Where would it all come from?
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2974.790" EndTime="2975.277" Participant="mn015">
Yeah.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2976.485" EndTime="2977.350" Participant="mn015">
So.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2976.700" EndTime="2979.860" Participant="me012">
Is - Oh, right. W- would not be ab- able to observe <Pause/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2977.001" EndTime="2977.594" Participant="fe004">
Mmm.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2980.200" EndTime="2981.000" Participant="me012">
What?
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2980.805" EndTime="2986.970" Participant="mn015">
I- if it's a - a - a discar- Discourse Initial Phrase, we will have <Emphasis> nothing </Emphasis> in the discourse history.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2984.369" EndTime="2985.065" Participant="me010">
<VocalSound Description="mouth"/> <VocalSound Description="inbreath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2988.156" EndTime="2988.602" Participant="me010">
<VocalSound Description="inbreath"/> <Comment Description="as if to speak"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2988.230" EndTime="2991.490" Participant="mn015">
So, if - if we ever want to wonder what was mention-
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2988.780" EndTime="2989.980" Participant="me012">
<VocalSound Description="inbreath"/> Oh - <Comment Description="under his breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2989.980" EndTime="2994.455" Participant="me012">
Oh. A- are you saying that we'll not be able to observe certain nodes? That's fine. That is sort of orthogonal thing.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2990.559" EndTime="2991.844" Participant="me010">
<VocalSound Description="inbreath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2991.844" EndTime="2992.659" Participant="me010">
<VocalSound Description="outbreath"/> <Comment Description="possible vocal gesture"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2993.220" EndTime="2995.609" Participant="me010">
Yeah, so there's - there's <Emphasis> two </Emphasis> separate things, Robert.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2995.609" EndTime="2999.125" Participant="me010">
The f- the - the - the Bayes-nets in general are quite good
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="2999.125" EndTime="3004.485" Participant="me010">
at saying, "if you have no current information about this variable just take the prior for that."
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3004.844" EndTime="3006.611" Participant="me010">
O_K? Th- that's what they're <Emphasis> real </Emphasis> good at.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3006.611" EndTime="3008.841" Participant="me010">
So, if you don't have any information about the discourse,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3008.841" EndTime="3011.742" Participant="me010">
you just use your priors of - of whatever -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3011.742" EndTime="3014.324" Participant="me010">
eh- the - discourse -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3014.324" EndTime="3015.808" Participant="me010">
uh,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3015.808" EndTime="3021.082" Participant="me010">
eh, basically whatever w- it's - Probabilistically, whatever it would be. And it's - it's sort of not a <Emphasis> great </Emphasis> estimate, but -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3019.047" EndTime="3019.774" Participant="mn015">
Mm-hmm.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3021.082" EndTime="3023.097" Participant="me010">
it's the best one you have, <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3023.097" EndTime="3027.734" Participant="me010">
and, so forth. So that, they're good at. But the other problem is, how do you fill in all these numbers?
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3027.895" EndTime="3029.260" Participant="fe004">
Mm-hmm. Yeah.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3027.949" EndTime="3029.299" Participant="me010">
And I think <Emphasis> that's </Emphasis> the one he was getting at.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3028.694" EndTime="3031.293" Participant="me012">
Yeah. So, specifically in this case you have to - f-
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3031.293" EndTime="3037.044" Participant="me012">
have this many numbers, whereas in this case you just have to have three for this, three for this, three for this. Right? <VocalSound Description="breath"/> So you have to have just
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3036.001" EndTime="3037.130" Participant="mn015">
Mm-hmm.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3037.044" EndTime="3038.020" Participant="me012">
three N_?
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3038.560" EndTime="3040.770" Participant="me012">
So, this is much smaller than that. <NonVocalSound Description="mike noise"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3041.830" EndTime="3042.752" Participant="me012">
<NonVocalSound Description="mike noise"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3041.940" EndTime="3043.850" Participant="me003">
Asymptotically. <VocalSound Description="laugh"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3042.903" EndTime="3043.406" Participant="fe004">
Mm-hmm.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3043.810" EndTime="3045.240" Participant="me012">
Yeah. <Comment Description="while laughing"/> Right.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3043.850" EndTime="3045.530" Participant="me003">
<VocalSound Description="laugh"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3044.001" EndTime="3046.163" Participant="me010">
Well, pretty quickly.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3045.530" EndTime="3047.360" Participant="me003">
U- yeah, yeah. <VocalSound Description="laugh"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3045.740" EndTime="3050.710" Participant="fe004">
So, you don't need da- data enough to cover - uh, nearly as much stuff.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3046.163" EndTime="3047.050" Participant="me010">
I mean -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3046.451" EndTime="3048.726" Participant="mn036">
<VocalSound Description="breath-laugh"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3046.870" EndTime="3047.630" Participant="me012">
I don't know.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3048.370" EndTime="3051.576" Participant="me003">
So, really, i- What a - A Noisy-OR seems to kind of <Pause/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3051.006" EndTime="3051.954" Participant="me010">
<VocalSound Description="inbreath"/> <Comment Description="as if to speak"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3051.576" EndTime="3054.320" Participant="me003">
"neural-net-acize" these Bayes-nets?
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3052.387" EndTime="3053.041" Participant="me010">
<VocalSound Description="mouth"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3053.041" EndTime="3057.153" Participant="me010">
Eh - well- to- some- No, no. So, "Noisy-OR" is a funny
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3055.430" EndTime="3058.200" Participant="fe004">
<NonVocalSound Description="mike noise"/> <VocalSound Description="laugh"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3057.153" EndTime="3059.088" Participant="me010">
way of referring to this, because
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3059.088" EndTime="3059.383" Participant="me010">
<VocalSound Description="mouth"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3059.756" EndTime="3062.011" Participant="me010">
the Noisy-OR is only one instance.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3061.810" EndTime="3063.890" Participant="me012">
Yeah. This isn't a Noisy-OR anymore.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3062.856" EndTime="3065.520" Participant="me010">
That one actually <Emphasis> isn't </Emphasis> a Noisy-OR. So we'll have to think of <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3065.120" EndTime="3066.050" Participant="me003">
Yeah.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3065.520" EndTime="3066.970" Participant="me010">
of a way t- t-
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3066.970" EndTime="3070.967" Participant="me012">
it's a Noisy-arg-max or a Noisy-whatever. <Comment Description="last two words while laughing"/> <VocalSound Description="breath-laugh"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3068.644" EndTime="3070.806" Participant="me010">
Yeah, whatever. Yeah. <VocalSound Description="breath"/> So -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3068.888" EndTime="3070.875" Participant="fe004">
<VocalSound Description="laugh"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3070.806" EndTime="3071.212" Participant="me010">
Eh - <Comment Description="a drawn-out squeal-type sound"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3071.212" EndTime="3072.440" Participant="me010">
Um <Pause/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3072.680" EndTime="3079.090" Participant="me003">
Well, my point was more that we just - eh - With the neural net, right, eh, things come in, you have a function that combines them and - <Comment Description="abandoned as clear"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3079.110" EndTime="3084.520" Participant="me010">
Yeah, it - it - Tha- that's true. It is a- is also more neural-net-like, although - <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3084.590" EndTime="3086.614" Participant="me010">
Uh, it isn't <Emphasis> necessarily </Emphasis> sum -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3086.614" EndTime="3089.548" Participant="me010">
uh, s- you know, <Emphasis> sum </Emphasis> of weights or anything like that.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3088.770" EndTime="3090.050" Participant="me003">
Right. <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3089.548" EndTime="3090.885" Participant="me010">
I mean i- You could have, <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3090.885" EndTime="3092.739" Participant="me010">
uh, like the Noisy-OR function,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3093.105" EndTime="3097.380" Participant="me010">
really <Emphasis> is </Emphasis> one that's essentially says, uh, take the max.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3097.650" EndTime="3098.670" Participant="me012">
Well, the "OR".
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3099.175" EndTime="3099.871" Participant="me010">
<Uncertain> Same. </Uncertain>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3099.800" EndTime="3101.750" Participant="me012">
Right. I guess you're right. Yeah.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3102.826" EndTime="3104.409" Participant="me010">
Uh <Pause/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3104.409" EndTime="3105.719" Participant="me010">
But anyway. So -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3107.470" EndTime="3110.224" Participant="me010">
And, I thi- I think that's the <Emphasis> standard </Emphasis> way people
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3110.224" EndTime="3112.568" Participant="me010">
get around the -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3112.568" EndTime="3113.623" Participant="me010">
uh <Pause/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3113.623" EndTime="3120.490" Participant="me010">
There are a couple other ones. There are ways of breaking this up into s- to - to subnets and stuff like that. But, um <Pause/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3121.671" EndTime="3122.760" Participant="me010">
The <Pause/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3121.727" EndTime="3126.305" Participant="mn015">
<NonVocalSound Description="mike noise"/> <VocalSound Description="cough in background"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3123.820" EndTime="3128.130" Participant="me010">
I think we definitely - I think it's a great idea tha- to - to pursue that.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3127.597" EndTime="3130.500" Participant="mn015">
<NonVocalSound Description="mike noise"/> <VocalSound Description="cough in background"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3129.127" EndTime="3130.252" Participant="me012">
Yep. So <Pause/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3130.500" EndTime="3133.184" Participant="mn015">
Wha- still sort of leaves one question.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3133.184" EndTime="3143.509" Participant="mn015">
It - I mean you - you can always uh - see easily that - that I'm not grasping <Emphasis> everything </Emphasis> correctly, but <VocalSound Description="breath"/> what seemed attractive to <Emphasis> me </Emphasis> in im- uh in the last discussion we had, was <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3143.509" EndTime="3146.020" Participant="mn015">
that we find out a means of -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3146.650" EndTime="3149.814" Participant="mn015">
of getting these point four, point five, point one,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3149.814" EndTime="3151.776" Participant="mn015">
of C_four,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3151.776" EndTime="3158.338" Participant="mn015">
<Emphasis> not </Emphasis> because, you know, A_ is a Landmark or not, but we - we - we label this whatever object type, <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3158.338" EndTime="3160.436" Participant="mn015">
and if it's a garden,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3160.436" EndTime="3171.080" Participant="mn015">
it's point three, point four, point two. If it's a castle, it's point eight, point one, point one. If it's, <VocalSound Description="breath"/> uh, a town hall, it's point two, point three, point five. <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3166.382" EndTime="3166.974" Participant="me010">
<VocalSound Description="mouth"/> Right.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3171.080" EndTime="3172.268" Participant="mn015">
And so forth. <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3172.268" EndTime="3174.250" Participant="mn015">
And we don't want to write this down -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3174.650" EndTime="3177.160" Participant="mn015">
<Emphasis> necessarily </Emphasis> every time for something but, uh -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3177.310" EndTime="3179.650" Participant="me012">
It'll be students - <Uncertain> Where else would it </Uncertain> be stored? That's the question.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3177.330" EndTime="3178.300" Participant="mn015">
<Uncertain> let's see. </Uncertain>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3179.650" EndTime="3185.140" Participant="mn015">
Well, in the beginning, we'll write up a flat file. We know we have twenty object types and we'll write it down in a flat file.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3181.666" EndTime="3181.987" Participant="me010">
Oh.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3182.552" EndTime="3183.080" Participant="me010">
Yeah.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3183.080" EndTime="3184.405" Participant="me010">
No. So, i- is-
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3184.809" EndTime="3188.379" Participant="me010">
Well, let me say something, guys, cuz there's not - There's a pretty point about this we might as well get in right now.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3187.865" EndTime="3188.378" Participant="me012">
Mm-hmm.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3188.379" EndTime="3189.319" Participant="me010">
Which is -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3189.319" EndTime="3192.614" Participant="me010">
The hierarchy that s- comes with the ontology
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3192.614" EndTime="3196.264" Participant="me010">
is <Emphasis> just </Emphasis> what you want for this. So that -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3196.720" EndTime="3201.023" Participant="me010">
<VocalSound Description="mouth"/> Uh, <Emphasis> if </Emphasis> you know about it - let's say, a <Emphasis> particular </Emphasis> town hall - <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3201.023" EndTime="3203.502" Participant="me010">
that, it's one that is a monument, <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3203.502" EndTime="3205.147" Participant="me010">
then, that would be stored <Emphasis> there. </Emphasis> <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3205.147" EndTime="3207.980" Participant="me010">
If you <Emphasis> don't, </Emphasis> you look up the hierarchy,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3208.213" EndTime="3212.187" Participant="me010">
Eh - so, you - you - you may or - So, then you'd have this little vector of,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3212.187" EndTime="3221.409" Participant="me010">
um, you know, <Emphasis> Approach </Emphasis> Mode or <Emphasis> E_V_A </Emphasis> Mode. Let's - O_K, so we have <VocalSound Description="breath"/> the E_V_A vector for - for various kinds of landmarks. <VocalSound Description="breath"/> If you know it for a <Emphasis> specific </Emphasis> landmark you put it there.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3218.021" EndTime="3219.944" Participant="fe004">
<VocalSound Description="laugh-breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3221.409" EndTime="3226.040" Participant="me010">
If you <Emphasis> don't, </Emphasis> you just go up the hierarchy to the first place you find one.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3225.769" EndTime="3226.150" Participant="me012">
O_K.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3226.580" EndTime="3228.480" Participant="me012">
So, is the idea to put it in the ontology?
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3228.016" EndTime="3229.060" Participant="me010">
Absolutely.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3228.838" EndTime="3229.438" Participant="me012">
O_K.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3229.570" EndTime="3237.270" Participant="me010">
Uh, or, link to - or - but - but in any case - i- View it logically as being in the ontology. It's part of what you <Emphasis> know </Emphasis> about -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3237.378" EndTime="3240.280" Participant="me010">
a - an <Emphasis> object, </Emphasis> <VocalSound Description="breath"/> is its E_V_A vector.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3240.680" EndTime="3242.640" Participant="me012">
O_K. <Uncertain> Mm-hmm. </Uncertain>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3241.400" EndTime="3245.950" Participant="me010">
And, if yo- As I say, if you know about a specific <Pronounce> object, </Pronounce> you put it there. This is part of what Dekai was doing.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3246.292" EndTime="3247.506" Participant="me010">
So, when we get to Wu,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3247.698" EndTime="3248.402" Participant="me012">
Right.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3248.120" EndTime="3250.612" Participant="me010">
The- e- We'll see w- what he says about that.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3250.612" EndTime="3252.213" Participant="me010">
And, then if you -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3252.213" EndTime="3259.640" Participant="me010">
If it isn't there, it's higher, and if you don't know anything except that it's a b- it's - it's a - building, then up at the highest thing, you have the pr- what amounts to a prior.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3259.640" EndTime="3261.690" Participant="me010">
If you don't know anything <Emphasis> else </Emphasis> about a building, <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3261.730" EndTime="3268.590" Participant="me010">
uh, you just take whatever your crude approximation is up at <Emphasis> that </Emphasis> level, which might be <Emphasis> equal, </Emphasis> or <Emphasis> whatever </Emphasis> it is.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3264.055" EndTime="3264.870" Participant="me012">
Right.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3267.451" EndTime="3267.926" Participant="me012">
Yeah.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3268.875" EndTime="3272.482" Participant="me010">
<VocalSound Description="mouth"/> So, that's a very pretty relationship between
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3272.482" EndTime="3275.150" Participant="me010">
these local vectors and the ontology.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3275.150" EndTime="3277.482" Participant="me010">
And it seems to me the <Emphasis> obvious </Emphasis> thing to do, unless
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3277.482" EndTime="3277.849" Participant="me010">
<VocalSound Description="mouth"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3278.058" EndTime="3280.146" Participant="me010">
we find a reason to do something <Emphasis> different. </Emphasis>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3281.681" EndTime="3282.111" Participant="me012">
<Uncertain> Yeah. </Uncertain>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3282.494" EndTime="3284.380" Participant="me010">
Does this make sense to <Emphasis> you? </Emphasis> Bhask- ?
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3282.660" EndTime="3283.450" Participant="me012">
So -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3283.710" EndTime="3284.641" Participant="me012">
Yeah.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3284.641" EndTime="3288.821" Participant="me012">
So, we are - but we - we're not doing the ontology, so we have to get to whoever is doing the - u- ultimately,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3288.012" EndTime="3288.426" Participant="me010">
<VocalSound Description="vocal squeak"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3288.626" EndTime="3291.772" Participant="me010">
Indeed. So, that's another thing we're gonna need to do, is - is, to,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3288.821" EndTime="3290.190" Participant="me012">
we have to get them to -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3292.192" EndTime="3292.960" Participant="me010">
<Emphasis> either </Emphasis> -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3293.482" EndTime="3299.920" Participant="me010">
<VocalSound Description="mouth"/> We're gonna need <Emphasis> some </Emphasis> way to either get a p- <Emphasis> tag </Emphasis> in the ontology, or add <Emphasis> fields, </Emphasis> or - <Comment Description="list"/> <Comment Description="&quot;or -&quot; used as &quot;and so on&quot;"/> <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3299.920" EndTime="3307.070" Participant="me010">
<Emphasis> some </Emphasis> way to associate - Or, w- It may be that all we can do is, um, some of our own hash tables that it - <Comment Description="list"/> <Comment Description="&quot;or -&quot; used as &quot;and so on&quot;"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3307.830" EndTime="3311.220" Participant="me010">
Th- the - th- you know, there's <Emphasis> always </Emphasis> a way to <Emphasis> do </Emphasis> that. It's a just a question of - <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3311.220" EndTime="3311.367" Participant="me010">
i- <Comment Description="vocal fragment"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3311.360" EndTime="3315.930" Participant="me003">
Yeah, hash on object name to, you know, uh, the probabilities or whatever.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3312.746" EndTime="3313.450" Participant="me010">
th-
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3313.450" EndTime="3314.240" Participant="me010">
Yeah.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3315.033" EndTime="3315.414" Participant="me010">
e-
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3315.414" EndTime="3317.243" Participant="me010">
Right. And, so,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3317.243" EndTime="3317.362" Participant="me010">
i- <Comment Description="vocal fragment"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3317.362" EndTime="3318.410" Participant="me010">
uh -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3317.610" EndTime="3320.937" Participant="mn015">
But it's, uh - <VocalSound Description="clears throat"/> Well, it strikes me as a <Uncertain> What For- </Uncertain>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3320.937" EndTime="3322.730" Participant="mn015">
If we <Emphasis> get </Emphasis> the mechanism,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3323.383" EndTime="3326.583" Participant="mn015">
that will be sort of the <Emphasis> wonderful </Emphasis> part. And then, <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3323.836" EndTime="3324.478" Participant="me010">
<VocalSound Description="mouth"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3326.583" EndTime="3330.170" Participant="mn015">
how to make it <Emphasis> work </Emphasis> is - is the <Emphasis> second </Emphasis> part, in the sense that -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3330.630" EndTime="3333.664" Participant="mn015">
I mean, m- the guy who was doing the ontology -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3333.664" EndTime="3337.910" Participant="mn015">
eh, eh, s- ap- apologized that i- it will take him another through -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3337.910" EndTime="3342.021" Participant="mn015">
two to three days because they're having really trouble getting the upper level
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3342.021" EndTime="3343.117" Participant="mn015">
straight, and
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3343.117" EndTime="3345.892" Participant="mn015">
right now. <VocalSound Description="breath"/> The reason is, <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3345.892" EndTime="3349.841" Participant="mn015">
given the <Uncertain> craw bet </Uncertain> uh, the - the - the <Emphasis> projects </Emphasis>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3349.841" EndTime="3354.088" Participant="mn015">
that <Emphasis> all </Emphasis> carry their own <Emphasis> taxonomy </Emphasis> and, on <Uncertain> all </Uncertain> <Emphasis> history, </Emphasis> <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3354.088" EndTime="3362.420" Participant="mn015">
they're really trying to build one top level ontology ft- that covers all the E_M_L projects, and that's, uh, uh, sort of a tough cookie, a little bit tougher than they <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3362.420" EndTime="3365.442" Participant="mn015">
figured. I could have <Emphasis> told </Emphasis> them s- so. Uh. <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3362.450" EndTime="3364.430" Participant="me003">
<VocalSound Description="laugh-breath"/> <VocalSound Description="laugh-breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3364.396" EndTime="3365.730" Participant="me010">
Right. Yeah.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3365.442" EndTime="3375.320" Participant="mn015">
But, nevertheless, it's going to be there by n- by, uh, <Emphasis> next </Emphasis> Monday and I will show you what's - what some examples <VocalSound Description="breath"/> <Emphasis> from </Emphasis> that for towers, and stuff. <Comment Description="rising intonation"/> <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3365.560" EndTime="3366.230" Participant="me003">
<VocalSound Description="laugh-breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3375.470" EndTime="3376.720" Participant="mn015">
And, um,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3377.990" EndTime="3384.927" Participant="mn015">
what I don't think is <Emphasis> ever </Emphasis> going to be in the <Emphasis> ontology, </Emphasis> is sort of, you know, the likelihood of, eh, people <Emphasis> entering </Emphasis> r-
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3384.927" EndTime="3388.189" Participant="mn015">
town halls, and <Emphasis> looking </Emphasis> at town halls, and <Emphasis> approaching </Emphasis> town halls, <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3388.189" EndTime="3392.651" Participant="mn015">
especially since we are b- dealing with a <Emphasis> case-based, </Emphasis> not an <Emphasis> instance-based </Emphasis> ontology. <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3392.651" EndTime="3398.256" Participant="mn015">
So, there will be <Emphasis> nothing </Emphasis> on - on <Emphasis> that </Emphasis> town hall, or on the <Emphasis> Berkeley </Emphasis> town hall, or on the <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3398.256" EndTime="3401.302" Participant="mn015">
<Emphasis> Heidelberg </Emphasis> town hall, it'll just be information on town halls. <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3401.154" EndTime="3405.680" Participant="me010">
Well, they - they - they - How ar- What are they gonna <Emphasis> do </Emphasis> with instances? I mean, you - y-
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3401.302" EndTime="3402.230" Participant="mn015">
But what -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3404.350" EndTime="3406.373" Participant="mn015">
Well, that's - Hhh. <Comment Description="vocal gesture"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3406.373" EndTime="3410.910" Participant="mn015">
That's - that's al- different question. I mean, th- the - first, they had to make a <Emphasis> design </Emphasis> question, <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3410.910" EndTime="3416.400" Participant="mn015">
"do we take ontologies that <Emphasis> have </Emphasis> instances? or just one that does <Emphasis> not, </Emphasis> that just has the types?" <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3416.110" EndTime="3416.930" Participant="me010">
O_K.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3416.960" EndTime="3421.019" Participant="mn015">
And, so, since the d- decision was on <Emphasis> types, </Emphasis> on a d- simply type-based, <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3421.019" EndTime="3423.052" Participant="mn015">
we now have to hook it up to <Emphasis> instances. </Emphasis>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3423.052" EndTime="3425.364" Participant="mn015">
I mean this is
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3425.364" EndTime="3426.240" Participant="mn015">
one -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3425.630" EndTime="3428.174" Participant="me010">
But what i- What <Pronounce> is </Pronounce> <Emphasis> SmartKom </Emphasis> gonna do about that?
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3429.094" EndTime="3431.790" Participant="me010">
Cuz, they have instances <Emphasis> all </Emphasis> the <Emphasis> time. </Emphasis> <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3432.280" EndTime="3435.992" Participant="mn015">
Yeah, but the ontology is really not a SmartKom
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3435.992" EndTime="3436.929" Participant="mn015">
thing,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3436.929" EndTime="3440.320" Participant="mn015">
in - in and of itself. That's more something that <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3440.320" EndTime="3441.562" Participant="mn015">
<Emphasis> I </Emphasis> kicked loose
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3441.920" EndTime="3444.982" Participant="mn015">
in - in E_M_L. So it's a completely E_M_L
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3445.398" EndTime="3446.200" Participant="mn015">
thing. <Comment Description="rising intonation"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3445.821" EndTime="3446.350" Participant="me010">
But -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3446.350" EndTime="3448.650" Participant="me010">
Uh - uh - <Emphasis> SmartKom's </Emphasis> gonna <Emphasis> need </Emphasis> an ontology. <Comment Description="rise-fall-rise contradiction contour"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3448.650" EndTime="3451.540" Participant="mn015">
Yes, u- a w- a lot of people are aware of that.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3451.710" EndTime="3455.260" Participant="me010">
I <Emphasis> understand, </Emphasis> <VocalSound Description="cough-laugh"/> but is anybody <Emphasis> doing </Emphasis> anything about it? <VocalSound Description="cough-laugh"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3452.560" EndTime="3455.222" Participant="mn015">
<VocalSound Description="laugh"/> <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3453.455" EndTime="3454.563" Participant="fe004">
<VocalSound Description="laugh-breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3455.160" EndTime="3456.240" Participant="fe004">
<VocalSound Description="breath-laugh"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3455.222" EndTime="3456.530" Participant="mn015">
Um -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3456.631" EndTime="3459.950" Participant="me010">
O_K. It's <Uncertain> a </Uncertain> political problem. We won't worry about it. <VocalSound Description="laugh"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3457.940" EndTime="3459.440" Participant="mn015">
<VocalSound Description="clears throat"/> <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3459.440" EndTime="3462.232" Participant="mn015">
No, but - th- the r- eh - I th- I <Emphasis> still </Emphasis> think that
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3460.644" EndTime="3461.994" Participant="me010">
<VocalSound Description="outbreath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3462.232" EndTime="3464.474" Participant="mn015">
there is <Emphasis> enough </Emphasis> information in there. <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3464.474" EndTime="3470.219" Participant="mn015">
For example, whether - O_K. So, th- it will know about the twenty object types there are in the world.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3470.219" EndTime="3472.890" Participant="mn015">
Let's assume there are only <Emphasis> twenty </Emphasis> object types in this world.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3470.295" EndTime="3472.618" Participant="fe004">
<VocalSound Description="breath-laugh"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3473.596" EndTime="3478.135" Participant="mn015">
And it will know if <Emphasis> any </Emphasis> of those have <Emphasis> institutional </Emphasis> meanings.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3473.660" EndTime="3477.058" Participant="fe004">
<VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3478.135" EndTime="3483.790" Participant="mn015">
So, in a sense, "I" used as Institutions for some s- in some sense or the other. <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3484.090" EndTime="3485.358" Participant="mn015">
Which makes them -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3485.358" EndTime="3486.340" Participant="mn015">
<Emphasis> enterable. </Emphasis>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3486.340" EndTime="3487.910" Participant="mn015">
Right? In a sense. You know.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3486.909" EndTime="3487.930" Participant="me010">
<VocalSound Description="mouth"/> Yeah.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3487.930" EndTime="3491.747" Participant="me010">
<Emphasis> Anyway. </Emphasis> So we <Emphasis> may </Emphasis> have to - This is with the whole thing, <Comment Description="embedded"/> we may have to build another data stru- <Comment Description="abandoned utterance"/> <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3488.632" EndTime="3489.183" Participant="mn015">
<Uncertain> Yep. </Uncertain>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3490.233" EndTime="3490.786" Participant="mn015">
Yep.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3491.747" EndTime="3493.553" Participant="me010">
<Emphasis> Conceptually, </Emphasis> we know what should be done.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3494.170" EndTime="3498.214" Participant="me010">
When we <Emphasis> see </Emphasis> what people have <Emphasis> done, </Emphasis> it may turn out that the <Emphasis> easiest </Emphasis> thing to do <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3498.214" EndTime="3501.123" Participant="me010">
is to build a - a separate thing that - that
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3501.123" EndTime="3502.067" Participant="me010">
just pools i- i-
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3501.794" EndTime="3507.991" Participant="mn015">
<NonVocalSound Description="mike noise"/> <VocalSound Description="cough in background"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3502.430" EndTime="3504.628" Participant="me010">
Like, i- i- it - it <Emphasis> may </Emphasis> be,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3504.628" EndTime="3505.458" Participant="me010">
that,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3505.458" EndTime="3508.113" Participant="me010">
the - the instance - w- That we have to build our own
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3508.113" EndTime="3509.752" Participant="me010">
instance, uh,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3509.150" EndTime="3511.830" Participant="me012">
Yeah, it's - Right, we can just assume -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3509.752" EndTime="3510.656" Participant="me010">
things, that,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3510.656" EndTime="3516.936" Participant="me010">
with their <Emphasis> types, </Emphasis> and then it goes off to the ontology once you have its type. So we build a little <Emphasis> data </Emphasis> structure <Pause/> <VocalSound Description="breath"/> And so what we would do in <Emphasis> that </Emphasis> case,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3512.320" EndTime="3516.579" Participant="mn015">
<NonVocalSound Description="mike noise"/> <VocalSound Description="cough in background"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3515.713" EndTime="3516.459" Participant="mn036">
<VocalSound Description="breath-laugh"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3516.936" EndTime="3520.103" Participant="me010">
is, in our instance gadget have
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3518.205" EndTime="3521.648" Participant="mn015">
<NonVocalSound Description="mike noise"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3520.547" EndTime="3522.391" Participant="me010">
<VocalSound Description="mouth"/> our E_V_As. <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3522.391" EndTime="3528.945" Participant="me010">
And if we- d- there <Emphasis> isn't </Emphasis> one we'd get the <Emphasis> type </Emphasis> and then have the E_V_As for the <Emphasis> type. </Emphasis> So we'd have our own little, <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3528.945" EndTime="3531.229" Participant="me010">
uh, E_V_A <Emphasis> tree. </Emphasis>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3531.152" EndTime="3532.592" Participant="me012">
Yeah. Right.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3531.635" EndTime="3532.945" Participant="me010">
And then, for other,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3533.104" EndTime="3540.074" Participant="me010">
uh, vectors that we need. So, we'd have our own little <VocalSound Description="breath"/> things so that whenever we needed one, we'd just use the ontology to get the type, <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3534.731" EndTime="3535.533" Participant="me012">
Mm-hmm. <Comment Description="very quietly"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3539.712" EndTime="3540.256" Participant="me012">
Mm-hmm.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3540.074" EndTime="3543.567" Participant="me010">
and then would hash or whatever we do to say, "ah! If it's that type of thing,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3543.567" EndTime="3546.230" Participant="me010">
and we want its E_V_A vector, pppt-pppt! <Comment Description="vocal gesture, computer spitting out two bits of information"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3546.230" EndTime="3547.232" Participant="me010">
it's <Emphasis> that. </Emphasis>"
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3547.232" EndTime="3551.528" Participant="me010">
So, I- I think we can handle that. And then - But, the <Emphasis> combination </Emphasis> functions,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3552.010" EndTime="3554.960" Participant="me010">
and whether we can put those in Java Bayes, and all that sort of stuff,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3555.599" EndTime="3558.240" Participant="me010">
is, uh - is the <Emphasis> bigger </Emphasis> deal.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3558.420" EndTime="3558.960" Participant="me012">
Yeah.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3558.917" EndTime="3560.844" Participant="me010">
I think <Emphasis> that's </Emphasis> where we have to get technically clever.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3561.860" EndTime="3563.300" Participant="me012">
Um -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3562.350" EndTime="3565.319" Participant="me003">
We could just steal the <Emphasis> classes </Emphasis> in <Emphasis> JavaBayes </Emphasis> and then
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3565.319" EndTime="3567.370" Participant="me003">
<Emphasis> interface </Emphasis> to them with our own <Emphasis> code. </Emphasis>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3567.370" EndTime="3569.560" Participant="me010">
Well, <Uncertain> I me- ye </Uncertain> <NonVocalSound Description="mike noise"/> <Uncertain> eh, yeah, the - </Uncertain>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3568.158" EndTime="3571.620" Participant="me012">
That requires understanding the classes in JavaBayes, I guess.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3570.230" EndTime="3572.630" Participant="me010">
Yeah, I mean, it's, uh, e- e- e- e- e- <Emphasis> cute. </Emphasis>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3572.830" EndTime="3573.746" Participant="me010">
<VocalSound Description="laugh"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3573.746" EndTime="3574.977" Participant="me010">
I mean, you've been around enough to -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3574.977" EndTime="3575.321" Participant="me010">
I mean -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3575.321" EndTime="3576.401" Participant="me010">
Just?
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3576.530" EndTime="3578.370" Participant="me003">
Well, it depends on -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3576.890" EndTime="3581.730" Participant="me010">
I mean, there's this <Emphasis> huge </Emphasis> package which - which may or may not be consistent and - <Comment Description="list"/> you know. <Comment Description="very reduced articulation of &quot;you know&quot;"/> <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3577.830" EndTime="3578.710" Participant="fe004">
<VocalSound Description="breath-laugh"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3582.570" EndTime="3583.910" Participant="me010">
But, <Emphasis> yeah, </Emphasis> we could look at it.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3584.310" EndTime="3585.910" Participant="me003">
Well, I was j- O_K. Yeah. <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3585.457" EndTime="3585.904" Participant="me010">
Yeah.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3586.520" EndTime="3587.324" Participant="me010">
It's b- It -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3588.849" EndTime="3594.715" Participant="me010">
<VocalSound Description="mouth"/> It's an <Emphasis> inter- </Emphasis> <Emphasis> sort </Emphasis> of a kind of a - it - The thing is, it's kind of an interpreter and i- i- it expects its data structures to
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3594.715" EndTime="3596.876" Participant="me010">
be in a given form, and if you say, "hey, we're gonna <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3595.220" EndTime="3601.775" Participant="fe004">
<VocalSound Description="yawn"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3596.876" EndTime="3599.690" Participant="me010">
make a <Emphasis> different </Emphasis> kind of <Emphasis> data </Emphasis> structure to stick in there -" <Comment Description="abandoned utterance"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3600.350" EndTime="3602.193" Participant="me003">
Well, no, but that just means there's a <Emphasis> protocol, </Emphasis>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3602.193" EndTime="3603.820" Participant="me003">
right? That you could -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3603.820" EndTime="3609.417" Participant="me010">
It may or may not. I don't know. That's the question is "to what extent does it allow us to put in these <Emphasis> G_ </Emphasis> functions?"
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3606.032" EndTime="3607.048" Participant="fe004">
<VocalSound Description="breath-cough"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3610.460" EndTime="3611.730" Participant="me010">
And I don't know.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3612.158" EndTime="3614.287" Participant="me003">
Well, no, but - I mean - What I <Uncertain> uh the </Uncertain> -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3614.287" EndTime="3620.622" Participant="me003">
So you could have four different Bayes-nets that you're running, and then run your own - write your own function that would take the output of those four,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3620.622" EndTime="3623.090" Participant="me003">
and make your own "G_ function", is what I was saying.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3621.837" EndTime="3625.460" Participant="me010">
Yeah, that's <Emphasis> fine </Emphasis> if it's - if it comes only at the <Emphasis> end. </Emphasis> But suppose you want it <Emphasis> embedded? </Emphasis>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3626.002" EndTime="3629.800" Participant="me003">
Well, then you'd have to break all of your Bayes-nets into smaller Bayes-nets, with all the -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3630.170" EndTime="3632.740" Participant="me010">
Oh, <Emphasis> that </Emphasis> - Yeah, that's a <Emphasis> truly </Emphasis> horrible way to do d- it. One would <Emphasis> hope </Emphasis> -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3632.664" EndTime="3634.270" Participant="me003">
Yeah, but I'm just -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3632.674" EndTime="3633.467" Participant="mn015">
Mm-hmm.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3633.420" EndTime="3634.527" Participant="me010">
Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, <Uncertain> you bet </Uncertain>.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3634.838" EndTime="3639.007" Participant="me010">
But, at <Emphasis> that </Emphasis> point you may say, "hey, Java Bayes isn't the only package in town. Let's see if there's
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3638.200" EndTime="3639.210" Participant="fe004">
<VocalSound Description="breath-laugh"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3639.375" EndTime="3642.370" Participant="me010">
<Emphasis> another </Emphasis> package that's, eh, more <Emphasis> civilized </Emphasis> about this."
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3642.009" EndTime="3642.921" Participant="me012">
<Uncertain NumSyllables="2"> @@ </Uncertain>. <Comment Description="whispered to self"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3645.170" EndTime="3646.171" Participant="me010">
Now, <Emphasis> Srini </Emphasis>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3645.445" EndTime="3646.262" Participant="me012">
Mmm. <NonVocalSound Description="mike noise"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3646.495" EndTime="3648.016" Participant="me010">
is worth talking to on this,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3648.016" EndTime="3649.541" Participant="me010">
cuz <Emphasis> he </Emphasis>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3649.541" EndTime="3651.434" Participant="me010">
said that <Emphasis> he </Emphasis> actually <Emphasis> did </Emphasis>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3652.200" EndTime="3654.779" Participant="me010">
hack some combining functions into JavaBayes.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3654.524" EndTime="3655.059" Participant="me012">
Ah!
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3654.779" EndTime="3658.199" Participant="me010">
But he doesn't remember - at least when I talked to him, he didn't remember <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3658.199" EndTime="3662.996" Participant="me010">
whether it was an e- an <Emphasis> easy </Emphasis> thing, a <Emphasis> natural </Emphasis> thing, or whether he had to do some violence to it to make it work.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3662.540" EndTime="3663.340" Participant="me003">
<VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3662.733" EndTime="3663.766" Participant="me012">
<VocalSound Description="laugh"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3663.549" EndTime="3665.662" Participant="me010">
Uh. But he <Emphasis> did </Emphasis> <Emphasis> do </Emphasis> it.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3665.526" EndTime="3666.470" Participant="me012">
<VocalSound Description="inbreath"/> Yeah. <Comment Description="whispered to self"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3666.470" EndTime="3675.540" Participant="me012">
I don't see why the, uh, combining f- functions have to be directly hacked into JavaBayes. I mean, they're used to create tables so we can just make our own little functions that create tables in X_M_L.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3668.370" EndTime="3670.484" Participant="fe004">
<VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3674.070" EndTime="3677.224" Participant="me010">
Well, I say that's <Emphasis> one </Emphasis> way to <Emphasis> do </Emphasis> it, is - is to just <Emphasis> convert </Emphasis> it
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3677.420" EndTime="3679.832" Participant="me010">
int- into a - into a C_P_<Emphasis> T </Emphasis> that <Uncertain> you zip </Uncertain> -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3679.832" EndTime="3682.930" Participant="me010">
It's <Emphasis> blown </Emphasis> up, and is a - it's, uh - it's <Emphasis> huge, </Emphasis> but - <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3683.190" EndTime="3685.230" Participant="me010">
it doesn't require any
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3684.260" EndTime="3685.061" Participant="me012">
Mm-hmm.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3685.230" EndTime="3686.990" Participant="me010">
data fitting or complication.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3686.459" EndTime="3686.941" Participant="me012">
Yeah.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3686.941" EndTime="3690.967" Participant="me012">
I don't think - I mean, the fact that it blown u- blows up is a <Emphasis> huge </Emphasis> issue in the sense that -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3690.967" EndTime="3693.836" Participant="me012">
I mean, O_K. So say it blows up, right? So there's, like,
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3693.836" EndTime="3694.499" Participant="me012">
<Uncertain> the </Uncertain>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3694.499" EndTime="3698.780" Participant="me012">
you know, ten, f- ten, fifteen, uh, things. It's gonna be like, two to the -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3698.780" EndTime="3700.800" Participant="me012">
<Emphasis> that, </Emphasis> which isn't so bad.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3700.675" EndTime="3702.915" Participant="me010">
I- I understand. I'm just saying tha- that w-
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3702.915" EndTime="3704.090" Participant="me010">
That was wi- that was my note.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3704.494" EndTime="3706.328" Participant="me010">
The little note I sent said that.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3706.446" EndTime="3707.046" Participant="me012">
Mm-hmm.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3706.850" EndTime="3708.709" Participant="me010">
It said, "Here's the way you'd take
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3708.709" EndTime="3711.636" Participant="me010">
the logical f- G_ function and turn it into a C_P_T."
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3711.581" EndTime="3712.163" Participant="me012">
Mm-hmm.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3712.452" EndTime="3714.807" Participant="me010">
I mean that - the Max- the Evidence-Combining function.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3715.715" EndTime="3717.860" Participant="me010">
So we could do that. And maybe that's what we'll <Emphasis> do. </Emphasis>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3718.790" EndTime="3719.336" Participant="me010">
<VocalSound Description="mouth"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3719.336" EndTime="3721.160" Participant="me010">
But, um <Pause/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3722.180" EndTime="3722.595" Participant="me010">
don't know.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3725.157" EndTime="3729.452" Participant="me010">
So, I will, e- <VocalSound Description="inbreath"/> e- <Emphasis> before </Emphasis> next week, uh, <Uncertain NumSyllables="1"> @@ </Uncertain> <Comment Description="uncodeable vocal fragment"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3729.452" EndTime="3732.789" Participant="me010">
p- <Pronounce> push </Pronounce> - push some more on - on this stuff that Dekai Wu did, <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3732.789" EndTime="3734.476" Participant="me010">
and try to <Emphasis> understand </Emphasis> it.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3734.934" EndTime="3739.460" Participant="me010">
Uh, you'll make a couple of more copies of the Heckerman paper to give
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3738.538" EndTime="3739.600" Participant="me012">
p- Sure.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3739.050" EndTime="3741.370" Participant="mn036">
Yeah, I - I would like a copy, <Uncertain> y- y- yeah </Uncertain>.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3739.460" EndTime="3740.265" Participant="me010">
to people?
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3740.910" EndTime="3741.690" Participant="me012">
O_K.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3741.140" EndTime="3741.886" Participant="me010">
O_K.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3742.371" EndTime="3743.835" Participant="mn036">
<VocalSound Description="mouth"/> O_K.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3742.900" EndTime="3744.690" Participant="me010">
And, um <Pause/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3748.064" EndTime="3748.917" Participant="me010">
<VocalSound Description="mouth"/> I think -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3748.470" EndTime="3751.899" Participant="mn015">
O_K. And I- I'll - I'll think s- through this, uh, <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3751.899" EndTime="3760.510" Participant="mn015">
eh - getting EVA <Pronounce> vectors </Pronounce> dynamically out of ontologies one more time because I s- I - I - I'm not quite sure whether we all think of the same thing or not, here. <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3760.502" EndTime="3762.037" Participant="me010">
<VocalSound Description="mouth"/> Well, you and I should talk about it.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3760.901" EndTime="3762.260" Participant="mn015">
Yeah, uh-huh.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3765.671" EndTime="3766.725" Participant="mn015">
O_K.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3766.730" EndTime="3768.468" Participant="me010">
Alright, great! <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3768.468" EndTime="3771.378" Participant="me010">
And, Robert, thank you for <VocalSound Description="breath"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3771.378" EndTime="3773.150" Participant="me010">
coming in
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3772.570" EndTime="3773.590" Participant="mn015">
<VocalSound Description="clears throat"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3773.488" EndTime="3775.810" Participant="me010">
under - He - <Emphasis> he's </Emphasis> been <Emphasis> sick, </Emphasis> Robert. <Comment Description="Robert's been sick"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3776.035" EndTime="3776.940" Participant="mn015">
<VocalSound Description="mouth"/> <Foreign Language="de" Description="meaning &quot;and&quot;"> <Emphasis> Und. </Emphasis> </Foreign>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3777.418" EndTime="3778.495" Participant="fe004">
Mm-hmm.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3777.760" EndTime="3782.110" Participant="me003">
I was thinking maybe we should just cough into the microphone and see if they can't - th- see if they can <Emphasis> handle </Emphasis> it. <Comment Description="metacomment, about the recording situation"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3781.861" EndTime="3783.786" Participant="me012">
<VocalSound Description="laugh"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3782.470" EndTime="3783.810" Participant="fe004">
<VocalSound Description="laugh"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3783.960" EndTime="3785.270" Participant="me003">
<VocalSound Description="laugh"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3785.068" EndTime="3786.088" Participant="me012">
<VocalSound Description="laugh"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3787.391" EndTime="3788.057" CloseMic="false">
<Comment Description="end of meeting, [me010]'s mike turned off"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3787.902" EndTime="3789.194" Participant="me012">
<NonVocalSound Description="computer keyboard typing in background"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3790.409" EndTime="3791.141" Participant="me012">
Yep.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3791.200" EndTime="3791.554" Participant="fe004">
Sure.
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3791.554" EndTime="3793.050" Participant="fe004">
<NonVocalSound Description="mike noise"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3796.435" EndTime="3809.548" Participant="me012">
<NonVocalSound Description="background noise"/> <NonVocalSound Description="mike noise"/>
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3813.983" EndTime="3816.280" Participant="mn015">
Um - is this, uh -
</Segment>
<Segment StartTime="3826.805" EndTime="3836.439" Participant="me012">
<NonVocalSound Description="mike noise"/> <Comment Description="removing mike"/>
</Segment>
</Transcript>
</Meeting>