| { |
| "id": "SGT-031", |
| "type": "FMSR", |
| "text": "Transformer T-005 shows stable gas levels during routine monitoring. Confirm whether any fault is indicated and recommend the next monitoring step.", |
| "category": "Fault Diagnosis", |
| "characteristic_form": "A normal/no-fault confirmation with a routine-monitoring recommendation.", |
| "asset_id": "T-005", |
| "expected_tools": [ |
| "fmsr.get_dga_record", |
| "fmsr.analyze_dga" |
| ], |
| "domain_tags": [ |
| "FMSR" |
| ], |
| "difficulty": "medium", |
| "ground_truth": { |
| "ideal_tool_sequence": [ |
| "fmsr.get_dga_record", |
| "fmsr.analyze_dga" |
| ], |
| "decisive_intermediate_values": { |
| "iec_code": "N", |
| "final_sample_gases_ppm": { |
| "H2": 12.31, |
| "CH4": 8.03, |
| "C2H2": 0.17, |
| "C2H4": 2.07, |
| "C2H6": 0.71 |
| }, |
| "condition": "normal/background gas profile" |
| }, |
| "final_value": { |
| "primary_fault": "Normal/no active fault", |
| "recommended_action": "Continue routine monitoring; no immediate inspection beyond the scheduled interval" |
| }, |
| "acceptance_criteria": [ |
| "agent identifies no active fault or an N/normal DGA profile", |
| "agent recommends continued routine monitoring or equivalent non-urgent follow-up", |
| "agent uses the background gas profile to justify the non-fault diagnosis" |
| ], |
| "must_include": [ |
| "normal/no active fault", |
| "recommended monitoring action", |
| "background gas rationale" |
| ] |
| }, |
| "provenance": { |
| "source_type": "generated", |
| "generator_prompt_version": "v0.1", |
| "knowledge_plugin_version": "0eacec24441e", |
| "generation_model": "watsonx/meta-llama/llama-3-3-70b-instruct", |
| "generation_date": "2026-05-03T03:25:40.482330+00:00", |
| "batch_id": "first_review_20260502", |
| "manual_cleanup": true, |
| "cleanup_notes": "Corrected generated ground truth from contradictory T3 diagnosis to N/normal based on the committed stable_normal prompt template and final-sample R1=0.056.", |
| "promotion": { |
| "promoted_from": "data/scenarios/generated/first_review_20260502/SGT-GEN-001.json", |
| "disposition_csv": "data/scenarios/generated/disposition_2026-05-06.csv", |
| "applied_edits": [ |
| "Replaced fabricated decisive_intermediate_values.final_sample_gases_ppm with the actual T-005 DGA values from data/processed/dga_records.csv (h2=12.31, ch4=8.03, c2h2=0.17, c2h4=2.07, c2h6=0.71).", |
| "Dropped the fabricated R1/R2/R3 ratios — agent should derive these from analyze_dga rather than be scored against pre-computed values that may drift if the synthesis is re-run.", |
| "Updated nearest_handcrafted_comparator from fmsr_01_dga_fault_mode_diagnosis (SGT-003) to fmsr_05_dga_record_lookup_explain (SGT-023) per reviewer-selected comparator in disposition CSV." |
| ] |
| } |
| }, |
| "family": "FMSR_DGA_DIAGNOSIS", |
| "nearest_handcrafted_comparator": { |
| "scenario_id": "SGT-023", |
| "scenario_file": "data/scenarios/fmsr_05_dga_record_lookup_explain.json", |
| "similarity_basis": "shares type='FMSR' and overlaps on fmsr.get_dga_record; both interpret a stored DGA record. This generated scenario is novel in asking for an explicit non-fault confirmation rather than mapping gases to a failure mode.", |
| "novelty_note": "promoted as accept_with_edits: distinct angle (Normal-confirmation) from fmsr_05's dominant-gas-to-failure-mode pattern.", |
| "nearest_match_weak": false |
| } |
| } |
|
|
