datamatters24 commited on
Commit
8dd51ae
·
verified ·
1 Parent(s): 593f67e

Remove stale FP-Stalker backfill claims (block is fully populated)

Browse files
Files changed (1) hide show
  1. cano_paper_v2.md +17 -12
cano_paper_v2.md CHANGED
@@ -195,9 +195,6 @@ model-agnostic perturbations. Gaussian provides little additional transfer
195
  protection (1.04x). C&W's transfer reduction is negative
196
  (anti-protective on small synthetics) -- its ratio is reported as n/a.
197
 
198
- > **Note.** Transfer numbers are from the utility-metric subset; the FP-Stalker
199
- > block does not yet have transfer values computed -- backfill planned.
200
-
201
  ## 3.3 Noise Utility Metrics
202
 
203
  **Table 3.** Per-strategy noise-quality metrics (n = 5,924 in-scope rows).
@@ -253,10 +250,13 @@ concentration on importance-ranked rather than variance-ranked features.
253
  | `synth_50u_20s` | 50 | 0.003 | 0.514 | 0.356 | n/a | n/a |
254
  | `synth_5u_30s` | 5 | -0.006 | 0.208 | 0.072 | n/a | n/a |
255
 
256
- > **Note.** "n/a" means a strategy was not evaluated on that dataset
257
- > (backfill planned). FP-Stalker (Vastel et al. [10]) is the closest dataset
258
- > to deployment conditions; on it, CANO closes most of the gap to Gaussian
259
- > (0.276 vs 0.340).
 
 
 
260
 
261
  ## 3.6 Statistical Significance
262
 
@@ -311,14 +311,19 @@ adversaries.
311
  (HTillmann; BrFAST extended) are the next integration.
312
  - 9 synthetic features with artificial importance concentration.
313
  - `cybersec_intrusion` (2 users) excluded from aggregates.
314
- - Utility metrics on 5,924-row subset; backfill re-run planned.
 
 
315
  - RL at 50 users; architectural changes needed for scaling.
316
- - Transfer numbers not yet computed for the FP-Stalker block.
 
317
 
318
  ## 4.3 Future Work
319
 
320
- 1. Backfill transfer-attack and noise-utility metrics for the FP-Stalker block.
321
- 2. Extend utility-metric coverage across all historical evaluation runs.
 
 
322
  3. Formal DP guarantees for CANO's allocation mechanism.
323
  4. Larger RL training (1,000+ users); online policy updates in deployment.
324
  5. Theoretical analysis of conditions under which feature-weighted noise
@@ -385,5 +390,5 @@ generalizes better under realistic conditions.
385
 
386
  ---
387
 
388
- *Generated: 2026-04-26 03:41:25*
389
  *Data source: 19 merged `eval_*.jsonl` files (68,885 raw configs, 54,281 in-scope after excluding `cybersec_intrusion`).*
 
195
  protection (1.04x). C&W's transfer reduction is negative
196
  (anti-protective on small synthetics) -- its ratio is reported as n/a.
197
 
 
 
 
198
  ## 3.3 Noise Utility Metrics
199
 
200
  **Table 3.** Per-strategy noise-quality metrics (n = 5,924 in-scope rows).
 
250
  | `synth_50u_20s` | 50 | 0.003 | 0.514 | 0.356 | n/a | n/a |
251
  | `synth_5u_30s` | 5 | -0.006 | 0.208 | 0.072 | n/a | n/a |
252
 
253
+ > **Note.** "n/a" cells in Table 5 mark configurations where a strategy was
254
+ > not run on a particular dataset; this primarily affects Laplace and PGD on
255
+ > the smaller synthetic variants and on `keystroke_cmu_51users`, which were
256
+ > added to the strategy roster after those datasets had already been
257
+ > evaluated. FP-Stalker (Vastel et al. [10]) is the closest dataset to
258
+ > deployment conditions and is fully populated across all six strategies; on
259
+ > it, CANO closes most of the gap to Gaussian (0.276 vs 0.340).
260
 
261
  ## 3.6 Statistical Significance
262
 
 
311
  (HTillmann; BrFAST extended) are the next integration.
312
  - 9 synthetic features with artificial importance concentration.
313
  - `cybersec_intrusion` (2 users) excluded from aggregates.
314
+ - Utility metrics (sparsity, KL, deviation, sensitivity) cover the 5,924-row
315
+ subset of runs from 2026-04-05 onward; older synthetic-only runs predate the
316
+ instrumentation and contribute only adaptive accuracy_reduction.
317
  - RL at 50 users; architectural changes needed for scaling.
318
+ - Laplace and PGD were not run on the older small-synthetic variants
319
+ (`overlap_*`, `synth_NuMs` family) -- visible as `n/a` cells in Table 5.
320
 
321
  ## 4.3 Future Work
322
 
323
+ 1. Extend utility-metric coverage across the older synthetic runs (the
324
+ ~50,000 rows that predate the noise-quality instrumentation).
325
+ 2. Fill the remaining `n/a` cells in Table 5 by running Laplace and PGD on
326
+ the small-synthetic variants and on `keystroke_cmu_51users`.
327
  3. Formal DP guarantees for CANO's allocation mechanism.
328
  4. Larger RL training (1,000+ users); online policy updates in deployment.
329
  5. Theoretical analysis of conditions under which feature-weighted noise
 
390
 
391
  ---
392
 
393
+ *Generated: 2026-04-26 03:47:41*
394
  *Data source: 19 merged `eval_*.jsonl` files (68,885 raw configs, 54,281 in-scope after excluding `cybersec_intrusion`).*