| Year,Award Ceremony,Category,Nominee,Result | |
| 2000,Tony Award,Best Original Score,Elton John and Tim Rice,Won | |
| 2000,Tony Award,Best Actress in a Musical,Heather Headley,Won | |
| 2000,Tony Award,Best Scenic Design,Bob Crowley,Won | |
| 2000,Tony Award,Best Costume Design,Bob Crowley,Nominated | |
| 2000,Tony Award,Best Lighting Design,Natasha Katz,Won | |
| 2000,Drama Desk Award,Outstanding Actress in a Musical,Heather Headley,Won | |
| 2000,Grammy Award,Best Musical Show Album,Elton John and Tim Rice,Won | |
| 2000,John Kraaijkamp Musical Award,Best Musical,Walt Disney Theatrical,Won | |
| 2000,John Kraaijkamp Musical Award,Best Performance by a Leading Actress,Antje Monteiro,Nominated | |
| 2000,John Kraaijkamp Musical Award,Best Performance by a Leading Actor,Bastiaan Ragas,Won | |
| 2000,John Kraaijkamp Musical Award,Most Promising Male Talent,Marlon David Henry,Nominated | |
| 2000,John Kraaijkamp Musical Award,Award for Best Translation,Martine Bijl,Won | |
| 2000,"National Broadway Theatre Awards (now called ""Touring Broadway Awards"")",Best Musical,Best Musical,Won | |
| 2000,"National Broadway Theatre Awards (now called ""Touring Broadway Awards"")",Best Score,Elton John and Tim Rice,Nominated | |
| 2000,"National Broadway Theatre Awards (now called ""Touring Broadway Awards"")",Best Song in a Musical,"""I Know The Truth""",Nominated | |
| 2000,"National Broadway Theatre Awards (now called ""Touring Broadway Awards"")",Best Actor in a Musical,Patrick Cassidy,Won | |
| 2000,"National Broadway Theatre Awards (now called ""Touring Broadway Awards"")",Best Actress in a Musical,Simone,Nominated | |
| 2000,"National Broadway Theatre Awards (now called ""Touring Broadway Awards"")",Best Actress in a Musical,Kelli Fournier,Nominated | |
| 2000,"National Broadway Theatre Awards (now called ""Touring Broadway Awards"")",Best Direction,Elton John,Won | |
| 2000,"National Broadway Theatre Awards (now called ""Touring Broadway Awards"")",Best Visual Presentation,Bob Crowley (Scenic Design) and Natasha Katz (Lighting),Won | |
| 2000,"National Broadway Theatre Awards (now called ""Touring Broadway Awards"")",Best Costumes,Bob Crowley,Nominated | |
| 2000,Clarence Derwent Award,Most Promising Female,Sherie Rene Scott,Won | |
| 2000,Outer Critics Circle Awards,Outstanding Actress In A Musical,Heather Headley,Nominated | |