rubric edits from Jason Sun

eval_cases/paraview/main_cases.yaml

@@ -416,18 +416,19 @@
         5) Set the viewpoint parameters as: [600, 0, 0] to position; [0, 0, 0] to focal point; [0, -1, 0] to camera up direction
         6) White background
         7) Visualization image resolution is 1024x1024
-        8) Save the visualization image as a png file "chameleon_isosurface/results/{agent_mode}/chameleon_isosurface.png"
-        9) (Option 1) Save the paraview state as "chameleon_isosurface/results/{agent_mode}/chameleon_isosurface.pvsm" if you are using ParaView as the visualization tool
-        10) (Option 2) Save the cxx code script as "chameleon_isosurface/results/{agent_mode}/chameleon_isosurface.cxx" if you are using VTK as the visualization tool
+        8) Don't show color/scalar bar or coordinate axes.
+        9) Save the visualization image as a png file "chameleon_isosurface/results/{agent_mode}/chameleon_isosurface.png"
+        10) (Option 1) Save the paraview state as "chameleon_isosurface/results/{agent_mode}/chameleon_isosurface.pvsm" if you are using ParaView as the visualization tool
+        11) (Option 2) Save the cxx code script as "chameleon_isosurface/results/{agent_mode}/chameleon_isosurface.cxx" if you are using VTK as the visualization tool
         You should only choose one of Option 1 or Option 2 to save your work. Do not save any other files, and always save the visualization image.
   assert:
     - type: llm-rubric
       subtype: vision
       value: |
-          1. Overall Visualization Goal: Does the result present a good isosurface rendering compared to groundtruth?
-          
+          1. Does the result present 2 isosurfaces, one showing the inner part of the chameleon and one showing the outer part of the chameleon?
+
           2. Is the skin of the Chameleon object of green color?
-          
+
           3. Is the bone of the Chameleon object of white color?
 
 
@@ -445,9 +446,10 @@
         3) Set the color transfer function to assign a warm red color [0.71, 0.02, 0.15] to the highest value, a cool color [0.23, 0.29, 0.75] to the lowest value, and a grey color[0.87, 0.87, 0.87] to the midrange value
         4) Set the viewpoint parameters as: [0, 450, 0] to position; [0, 0, -15] to focal point; [0, 0, -1] to camera up direction
         5) Visualization image resolution is 1024x1024. White background. Shade turned off. Volume rendering ray casting sample distance is 0.1
-        6) Save the visualization image as a png file "argon-bubble/results/{agent_mode}/argon-bubble.png"
-        7) (Option 1) Save the paraview state as "argon-bubble/results/{agent_mode}/argon-bubble.pvsm" if you are using ParaView as the visualization tool
-        8) (Option 2) Save the cxx code script as "argon-bubble/results/{agent_mode}/argon-bubble.cxx" if you are using VTK as the visualization tool
+        6) Don't show color/scalar bar or coordinate axes.
+        7) Save the visualization image as a png file "argon-bubble/results/{agent_mode}/argon-bubble.png"
+        8) (Option 1) Save the paraview state as "argon-bubble/results/{agent_mode}/argon-bubble.pvsm" if you are using ParaView as the visualization tool
+        9) (Option 2) Save the cxx code script as "argon-bubble/results/{agent_mode}/argon-bubble.cxx" if you are using VTK as the visualization tool
         You should only choose one of Option 1 or Option 2 to save your work. Do not save any other files, and always save the visualization image.
   assert:
     - type: llm-rubric
@@ -474,9 +476,10 @@
         5) Set the viewpoint parameters as: [420, 420, -550] to position; [128, 128, 150] to focal point; [-1, -1, 1] to camera up direction
         6) Turn on the shade and set the ambient, diffuse and specular as 1.0
         7) White background. Volume rendering ray casting sample distance is 0.1
-        8) Save the visualization image as a png file "richtmyer/results/{agent_mode}/richtmyer.png"
-        9) (Option 1) Save the paraview state as "richtmyer/results/{agent_mode}/richtmyer.pvsm" if you are using ParaView as the visualization tool
-        10) (Option 2) Save the cxx code script as "richtmyer/results/{agent_mode}/richtmyer.cxx" if you are using VTK as the visualization tool
+        8) Don't show color/scalar bar or coordinate axes.
+        9) Save the visualization image as a png file "richtmyer/results/{agent_mode}/richtmyer.png"
+        10) (Option 1) Save the paraview state as "richtmyer/results/{agent_mode}/richtmyer.pvsm" if you are using ParaView as the visualization tool
+        11) (Option 2) Save the cxx code script as "richtmyer/results/{agent_mode}/richtmyer.cxx" if you are using VTK as the visualization tool
         You should only choose one of Option 1 or Option 2 to save your work. Do not save any other files, and always save the visualization image.
   assert:
     - type: llm-rubric
@@ -484,9 +487,9 @@
       value: |
           1. Does the visualization show a clear surface with peaks and valleys?
 
-          2. Are the peaks highlighted with the color yellow?
+          2. Are the peaks highlighted with the reddish color?
 
-          3. Are the valleys highlighted with the color blue?
+          3. Are the valleys highlighted with the bluish color?
 
 
 # 15. Rayleigh-Taylor Instability (Miranda)
@@ -503,9 +506,10 @@
         5) Volume rendering ray casting sample distance is 0.1
         6) White background
         7) Visualization image resolution is 1024x1024
-        8) Save the visualization image as a png file "miranda/results/{agent_mode}/miranda.png"
-        9) (Option 1) Save the paraview state as "miranda/results/{agent_mode}/miranda.pvsm" if you are using ParaView as the visualization tool
-        10) (Option 2) Save the cxx code script as "miranda/results/{agent_mode}/miranda.cxx" if you are using VTK as the visualization tool
+        8) Don't show color/scalar bar or coordinate axes.
+        9) Save the visualization image as a png file "miranda/results/{agent_mode}/miranda.png"
+        10) (Option 1) Save the paraview state as "miranda/results/{agent_mode}/miranda.pvsm" if you are using ParaView as the visualization tool
+        11) (Option 2) Save the cxx code script as "miranda/results/{agent_mode}/miranda.cxx" if you are using VTK as the visualization tool
         You should only choose one of Option 1 or Option 2 to save your work. Do not save any other files, and always save the visualization image.
   assert:
     - type: llm-rubric
@@ -532,9 +536,10 @@
         5) Volume rendering ray casting sample distance is 0.1
         6) White background
         7) Visualization image resolution is 1024x1024
-        8) Save the visualization image as a png file "rotstrat/results/{agent_mode}/rotstrat.png"
-        9) (Option 1) Save the paraview state as "rotstrat/results/{agent_mode}/rotstrat.pvsm" if you are using ParaView as the visualization tool
-        10) (Option 2) Save the cxx code script as "rotstrat/results/{agent_mode}/rotstrat.cxx" if you are using VTK as the visualization tool
+        8) Don't show color/scalar bar or coordinate axes.
+        9) Save the visualization image as a png file "rotstrat/results/{agent_mode}/rotstrat.png"
+        10) (Option 1) Save the paraview state as "rotstrat/results/{agent_mode}/rotstrat.pvsm" if you are using ParaView as the visualization tool
+        11) (Option 2) Save the cxx code script as "rotstrat/results/{agent_mode}/rotstrat.cxx" if you are using VTK as the visualization tool
         You should only choose one of Option 1 or Option 2 to save your work. Do not save any other files, and always save the visualization image.
   assert:
     - type: llm-rubric
@@ -542,9 +547,9 @@
       value: |
           1. Does the visualization image clearly show the shape of turbulence compared to ground truth?
 
-          2. Does the blueish region show areas with low opacity?
+          2. Does the visualization show the shape of a vortex in the upper right part of the image?
 
-          3. Does the reddish region show areas with high opacity?
+          3. Does the visualization show the shape of a vortex in the bottom left corner of the image?
 
 
 # Vector Field Cases

main/argon-bubble/task_description.txt

@@ -6,6 +6,7 @@ Generate a visualization image of the Argon Bubble scalar field dataset with the
 3) Set the color transfer function to assign a warm red color [0.71, 0.02, 0.15] to the highest value, a cool color [0.23, 0.29, 0.75] to the lowest value, and a grey color[0.87, 0.87, 0.87] to the midrange value
 4) Set the viewpoint parameters as: [0, 450, 0] to position; [0, 0, -15] to focal point; [0, 0, -1] to camera up direction
 5) Visualization image resolution is 1024x1024. White background. Shade turned off. Volume rendering ray casting sample distance is 0.1
-6) Save the visualization image as a png file "argon-bubble/results/{agent_mode}/argon-bubble.png"
-7) (Option 1) Save the paraview state as "argon-bubble/results/{agent_mode}/argon-bubble.pvsm" if you are using ParaView as the visualization tool
-8) (Option 2) Save the cxx code script as "argon-bubble/results/{agent_mode}/argon-bubble.cxx" if you are using VTK as the visualization tool
+6) Don't show color/scalar bar or coordinate axes.
+7) Save the visualization image as a png file "argon-bubble/results/{agent_mode}/argon-bubble.png"
+8) (Option 1) Save the paraview state as "argon-bubble/results/{agent_mode}/argon-bubble.pvsm" if you are using ParaView as the visualization tool
+9) (Option 2) Save the cxx code script as "argon-bubble/results/{agent_mode}/argon-bubble.cxx" if you are using VTK as the visualization tool

main/chameleon_isosurface/task_description.txt

@@ -8,6 +8,7 @@ Generate a visualization image of 2 isosurfaces of the Chameleon scalar field da
 5) Set the viewpoint parameters as: [600, 0, 0] to position; [0, 0, 0] to focal point; [0, -1, 0] to camera up direction
 6) White background
 7) Visualization image resolution is 1024x1024
-8) Save the visualization image as a png file "chameleon_isosurface/results/{agent_mode}/chameleon_isosurface.png"
-9) (Option 1) Save the paraview state as "chameleon_isosurface/results/{agent_mode}/chameleon_isosurface.pvsm" if you are using ParaView as the visualization tool
-10) (Option 2) Save the cxx code script as "chameleon_isosurface/results/{agent_mode}/chameleon_isosurface.cxx" if you are using VTK as the visualization tool
+8) Don't show color/scalar bar or coordinate axes.
+9) Save the visualization image as a png file "chameleon_isosurface/results/{agent_mode}/chameleon_isosurface.png"
+10) (Option 1) Save the paraview state as "chameleon_isosurface/results/{agent_mode}/chameleon_isosurface.pvsm" if you are using ParaView as the visualization tool
+11) (Option 2) Save the cxx code script as "chameleon_isosurface/results/{agent_mode}/chameleon_isosurface.cxx" if you are using VTK as the visualization tool

main/chameleon_isosurface/visualization_goals.txt

@@ -1,4 +1,4 @@
-1. Overall Visualization Goal: Does the result present a good isosurface rendering compared to groundtruth?
+1. Does the result present 2 isosurfaces, one showing the inner part of the chameleon and one showing the outer part of the chameleon?
 
 2. Is the skin of the Chameleon object of green color?
 

main/miranda/task_description.txt

@@ -8,6 +8,7 @@ Generate a visualization image of the Rayleigh-Taylor Instability dataset, a tim
 5) Volume rendering ray casting sample distance is 0.1
 6) White background
 7) Visualization image resolution is 1024x1024
-8) Save the visualization image as a png file "miranda/results/{agent_mode}/miranda.png"
-9) (Option 1) Save the paraview state as "miranda/results/{agent_mode}/miranda.pvsm" if you are using ParaView as the visualization tool
-10) (Option 2) Save the cxx code script as "miranda/results/{agent_mode}/miranda.cxx" if you are using VTK as the visualization tool
+8) Don't show color/scalar bar or coordinate axes.
+9) Save the visualization image as a png file "miranda/results/{agent_mode}/miranda.png"
+10) (Option 1) Save the paraview state as "miranda/results/{agent_mode}/miranda.pvsm" if you are using ParaView as the visualization tool
+11) (Option 2) Save the cxx code script as "miranda/results/{agent_mode}/miranda.cxx" if you are using VTK as the visualization tool

main/richtmyer/task_description.txt

@@ -8,6 +8,7 @@ Generate a visualization image of the Richtmyer dataset, Entropy field (timestep
 5) Set the viewpoint parameters as: [420, 420, -550] to position; [128, 128, 150] to focal point; [-1, -1, 1] to camera up direction
 6) Turn on the shade and set the ambient, diffuse and specular as 1.0
 7) White background. Volume rendering ray casting sample distance is 0.1
-8) Save the visualization image as a png file "richtmyer/results/{agent_mode}/richtmyer.png"
-9) (Option 1) Save the paraview state as "richtmyer/results/{agent_mode}/richtmyer.pvsm" if you are using ParaView as the visualization tool
-10) (Option 2) Save the cxx code script as "richtmyer/results/{agent_mode}/richtmyer.cxx" if you are using VTK as the visualization tool
+8) Don't show color/scalar bar or coordinate axes.
+9) Save the visualization image as a png file "richtmyer/results/{agent_mode}/richtmyer.png"
+10) (Option 1) Save the paraview state as "richtmyer/results/{agent_mode}/richtmyer.pvsm" if you are using ParaView as the visualization tool
+11) (Option 2) Save the cxx code script as "richtmyer/results/{agent_mode}/richtmyer.cxx" if you are using VTK as the visualization tool

main/richtmyer/visualization_goals.txt

@@ -1,5 +1,5 @@
 1. Does the visualization show a clear surface with peaks and valleys?
 
-2. Are the peaks highlighted with the color yellow?
+2. Are the peaks highlighted with the reddish color?
 
-3. Are the valleys highlighted with the color blue?
+3. Are the valleys highlighted with the bluish color?

main/rotstrat/task_description.txt

@@ -8,6 +8,7 @@ Generate a visualization image of the Rotstrat dataset, temperature field of a d
 5) Volume rendering ray casting sample distance is 0.1
 6) White background
 7) Visualization image resolution is 1024x1024
-8) Save the visualization image as a png file "rotstrat/results/{agent_mode}/rotstrat.png"
-9) (Option 1) Save the paraview state as "rotstrat/results/{agent_mode}/rotstrat.pvsm" if you are using ParaView as the visualization tool
-10) (Option 2) Save the cxx code script as "rotstrat/results/{agent_mode}/rotstrat.cxx" if you are using VTK as the visualization tool
+8) Don't show color/scalar bar or coordinate axes.
+9) Save the visualization image as a png file "rotstrat/results/{agent_mode}/rotstrat.png"
+10) (Option 1) Save the paraview state as "rotstrat/results/{agent_mode}/rotstrat.pvsm" if you are using ParaView as the visualization tool
+11) (Option 2) Save the cxx code script as "rotstrat/results/{agent_mode}/rotstrat.cxx" if you are using VTK as the visualization tool

main/rotstrat/visualization_goals.txt

@@ -1,5 +1,5 @@
 1. Does the visualization image clearly show the shape of turbulence compared to ground truth?
 
-2. Does the blueish region show areas with low opacity?
+2. Does the visualization show the shape of a vortex in the upper right part of the image?
 
-3. Does the reddish region show areas with high opacity?
+3. Does the visualization show the shape of a vortex in the bottom left corner of the image?