{ "task_id": "consumerfinance_011", "domain": "CFPB_REPORTS", "autonomy_type": "ordered table", "oracle_output_cardinality": 2, "instruction": "On the CFPB Enforcement Actions page, identify administrative enforcement actions filed in 2024 and subsequently closed, separately for the product categories Credit Cards and Deposits. Then extract the corresponding clause information linking the terminating order to the original Consent Order. Specifically, first restrict the search to administrative enforcement actions on the CFPB Enforcement Actions page whose initial filing date falls between 2024-01-01 and 2024-12-31. Then filter separately for the two product categories: Credit Cards and Deposits. For each category, retain only cases that simultaneously meet the following conditions: the case page shows the case has been closed, with a status of Expired, Terminated, or Vacated; the case page provides all four of these document types: Consent Order, Stipulation, Order Terminating the Consent Order, and Press Release; the page lists exactly one product category, and that single category is the one you are currently targeting. That is, if you are searching for Credit Cards, the page must list only that item and no other categories; the same requirement applies when searching for Deposits. After filtering, each product category may still have more than one case. For each category, retain only the case with the latest initial filing date; if multiple cases share the same filing date, select the one with the smaller docket number. Next, open the Order Terminating the Consent Order for the selected case and record the following three pieces of information: the termination date on this document; the passage in the document that states the legal authority for terminating the consent order, i.e., the termination authority, recording only the original text of its first occurrence; the PDF physical page number where this termination authority first appears. Also, within the text of this terminating order, find the first explicit reference to a paragraph number from the original Consent Order; if it reads \"Paragraphs X and Y,\" take only X. Then, return to the original Consent Order document for this case, locate the referenced paragraph, and record the section heading under which it falls.", "start_url": "https://www.consumerfinance.gov/enforcement/actions/", "output_format": "Finally, output a single-line string in alphabetical order by product name: ||||||p||. If a product has no qualifying case, output: |NONE", "oracle_answer": "Credit Cards|Apple Inc.|2024-CFPB-0012|2024-10-23|2025-09-22|12 U.S.C. § 5563(b)(3)|p1|83|ADMINISTRATIVE PROVISIONS,Deposits|Navy Federal Credit Union|2024-CFPB-0014|2024-11-07|2025-07-01|12 U.S.C. § 5563(b)(3)|p1|106|ADMINISTRATIVE PROVISIONS", "metadata": { "State-Gated Retrieval": [ "Consider only administrative enforcement actions with an Initial filing date in 2024, and search separately in the Credit Cards and Deposits categories.", "Cases must have a status of Expired, Terminated, or Vacated, and the page must simultaneously provide a Consent Order, Stipulation, Order Terminating the Consent Order, and Press Release, and the Products field must correspond one-to-one with the target category.", "Finally, for each category retain only the most recent qualifying case determined by Initial filing date, and compile the corresponding clause information linking the terminating order to the original Consent Order." ], "dependency_type": "Data + Control", "intra_chain": true, "inter_chain": true, "data_dependency": [ "enforcement-action list pages yield 2024 candidate actions by product branch", "each action detail page and linked Consent Order / Stipulation / Order Terminating the Consent Order / Press Release documents yield status, initial filing date, single-product validity, and clause references", "final rows are selected only after per-product comparison on Initial filing date and document-stack validation" ], "control_dependency": [ "\"latest\" must be determined by Initial filing date rather than termination date", "product filters on the list page are insufficient until the action detail page confirms a single matching product", "clause extraction in the terminating order must stay aligned with the original Consent Order rather than a superficially similar section" ], "freeze": { "historical_window": "administrative enforcement actions with Initial filing date from 2024-01-01 through 2024-12-31; current action status and currently linked Consent Order / Stipulation / terminating-order / Press Release documents" }, "answer_type": "multi-row ordered table" }, "rubric": { "inclusion_conditions": [ "Consider only administrative enforcement actions with an Initial filing date in 2024, and search separately in the Credit Cards and Deposits categories.", "Cases must have a status of Expired, Terminated, or Vacated, and the page must simultaneously provide a Consent Order, Stipulation, Order Terminating the Consent Order, and Press Release, and the Products field must correspond one-to-one with the target category.", "Finally, for each category retain only the most recent qualifying case determined by Initial filing date, and compile the corresponding clause information linking the terminating order to the original Consent Order." ], "exclusion_conditions": [ "Exclude results that use termination date instead of Initial filing date to determine \"latest.\"", "Exclude cases with an incomplete document stack or where Products is not a single target category.", "Exclude cases where the required clause correspondence between the terminating order and the original Consent Order cannot be established." ], "normalization": { "field_separator": "|", "record_separator": ",", "schema": [ "Product", "Respondent", "Docket", "InitialFilingDate", "TerminationDate", "TerminationAuthority", "TermAuthorityPage", "ReferencedParagraph", "ConsentSectionHeading" ], "product_order": "alphabetical by Product name", "fallback_row": "if a product has no qualifying case, emit `|NONE`", "date_format": "InitialFilingDate and TerminationDate use YYYY-MM-DD", "termination_authority": "use the canonical statute string extracted from the termination order", "page_fields": "TermAuthorityPage uses the canonical `pN` form", "ReferencedParagraph": "emit the paragraph number as a plain numeric string", "ConsentSectionHeading": "emit the uppercase heading of the consent-order section containing the referenced paragraph" } } }