| { |
| "task_id": "comptox_004", |
| "domain": "COMPTOX_CHEMEXPO", |
| "autonomy_type": "ordered table", |
| "oracle_output_cardinality": 5, |
| "instruction": "In ChemExpo, for the five substances Di(2-Ethylhexyl) Phthalate, Melamine, Phthalic Acid, Tris(2-Ethylhexyl) Phosphate, and Triphenyl Phosphates Tert-Butylated, check whether their historical labels align with their current uses. Follow the steps below. First, restrict the scope to these five substances. For each substance, collect three sets of baseline assessment data. The first set is the \"material contact\" score: check for the presence of the following five label categories, scoring 1 point for each category hit: Indirect additives food contact (10/2018); Europe, Food contact items; Food contact items, Japan; any keyword containing \"Toys and children's products\"; and any keyword containing \"artificial_saliva\" or \"artificial_sweat\". The second set is the \"production source\" score: check for the presence of the following two label categories, scoring 1 point for each category hit: \"drinking_water, Europe, manufacturing, plastic_additive\" and \"Europe, plastic_additive\". The third set is the regulatory profile for specific dates: separately count the total hits for the four exact keywords Indirect additives food contact (10/2018), OEHHA Proposition 65 (3/2019), WA Children's Safe Product Act (4/2020), and OEHHA Proposition 65 (1/2023), and record the earliest and latest year-month among all hits. After obtaining these three sets of data, determine the historical side by comparing scores: if the material contact score is strictly greater than the production source score, select a historically recommended kind in the order Article → Formulation → Occupation; otherwise, select in the order Occupation → Article → Formulation. After determining the kind, drill down along the subcategory with the most products at each level until no further subdivision is possible; if there is a tie at the same level, choose the one with the smaller PUC ID. Separately, independently identify the current dominant category for the same substance, ignoring historical clues: directly find the path with the most products among all use categories, drilling down to the terminal level using the same tie-breaking rule (smaller PUC ID). Finally, compare the two results: if the current dominant kind is Article or Formulation and the historical side is material, mark ALIGNED; if the current dominant kind is Occupation and the historical side is source, also mark ALIGNED; otherwise, mark MISALIGNED.", |
| "start_url": "https://comptox.epa.gov/chemexpo/", |
| "output_format": "Output MISALIGNED records first; within the same group, sort by datedHits descending; if datedHits are equal, sort by currentProducts descending. Format: <DTXSID>|<materialHits>|<sourceHits>|<datedHits>|<earliest>|<latest>|<historySide>|<recommendedKind>|<recommendedGeneral>|<recommendedTerminal>|<recommendedLevel>|<recommendedProducts>|<currentKind>|<currentGeneral>|<currentTerminal>|<currentLevel>|<currentProducts>|<status>. Separate records with commas. If datedHits is 0, write NA for both earliest and latest.", |
| "oracle_answer": "DTXSID6020802|4|2|1|2018-10|2018-10|material|Article|Furniture and furnishings|Furniture and furnishings|general|15|Occupation|Raw materials|fireproof coatings|type|24|MISALIGNED,DTXSID8021484|3|1|1|2018-10|2018-10|material|Occupation|Laboratory supplies|Laboratory supplies|general|8|Occupation|Laboratory supplies|Laboratory supplies|general|8|MISALIGNED,DTXSID5020607|5|2|4|2018-10|2023-01|material|Article|Construction and building materials|flooring|family|1|Formulation|Home maintenance|paint|type|112|ALIGNED,DTXSID0021414|5|0|1|2018-10|2018-10|material|Article|Construction and building materials|Construction and building materials|general|3|Article|Construction and building materials|Construction and building materials|general|3|ALIGNED,DTXSID20872645|0|1|0|NA|NA|source|Occupation|Industrial products|hydraulic fluid|family|5|Occupation|Industrial products|hydraulic fluid|family|5|ALIGNED", |
| "metadata": { |
| "State-Gated Retrieval": [ |
| "Operate only on the five specified substances, and first compute materialHits, sourceHits, and datedHits from the keyword-set block.", |
| "The historically recommended category must be derived independently from these historical signals; the current dominant category must be derived separately from the current use path.", |
| "Finally, compare only whether the historically recommended category and the current dominant category align at the coarse side level, and mark ALIGNED or MISALIGNED accordingly." |
| ], |
| "dependency_type": "Data + Control", |
| "intra_chain": true, |
| "inter_chain": true, |
| "data_dependency": [ |
| "each chemical page yields materialHits, sourceHits, datedHits, and the historical recommendation side implied by the keyword set", |
| "an independent current PUC category path yields the current dominant category, path labels, and classification counts for the same chemical", |
| "final rows are produced only after the historical recommendation and current dominant category are computed independently and then compared at the coarse side level" |
| ], |
| "control_dependency": [ |
| "the historical recommendation must be determined from the keyword-set evidence rather than from the current largest category", |
| "historical recommendation must be computed from the keyword-set evidence before alignment is judged", |
| "ALIGNED / MISALIGNED status is valid only after the historical and current category directions have been derived independently and then compared" |
| ], |
| "freeze": { |
| "historical_window": "current ChemExpo chemical pages and PUC category paths for the five named substances, using the specified historical keyword-set evidence through 2023-01" |
| }, |
| "answer_type": "multi-row ordered table" |
| }, |
| "rubric": { |
| "inclusion_conditions": [ |
| "Operate only on the five specified substances, and first compute materialHits, sourceHits, and datedHits from the keyword-set block.", |
| "The historically recommended category must be derived independently from these historical signals; the current dominant category must be derived separately from the current use path.", |
| "Finally, compare only whether the historically recommended category and the current dominant category align at the coarse side level, and mark ALIGNED or MISALIGNED accordingly." |
| ], |
| "exclusion_conditions": [ |
| "Exclude results that simply take the current largest category and treat it as the historically recommended category.", |
| "Exclude results that default to ALIGNED without independently deriving the historically recommended category.", |
| "Exclude results that fail to compute the historical and current paths separately, instead mixing signals in a single path." |
| ], |
| "normalization": { |
| "field_separator": "|", |
| "record_separator": ",", |
| "schema": [ |
| "DTXSID", |
| "materialHits", |
| "sourceHits", |
| "datedHits", |
| "earliest", |
| "latest", |
| "historySide", |
| "recommendedKind", |
| "recommendedGeneral", |
| "recommendedTerminal", |
| "recommendedLevel", |
| "recommendedProducts", |
| "currentKind", |
| "currentGeneral", |
| "currentTerminal", |
| "currentLevel", |
| "currentProducts", |
| "status" |
| ], |
| "dated_hits": "count only the exact dated keyword strings defined in the source rubric", |
| "date_format": "YYYY-MM; if datedHits is 0, earliest and latest are both `NA`", |
| "historySide": "emit the lower-case historical winner `material` or `source`", |
| "recommended_fields": "these fields describe the historically suggested path", |
| "current_fields": "these fields describe the current dominant path", |
| "kind": "the kind fields use the canonical labels Article, Formulation, or Occupation", |
| "level": "the level fields use the canonical labels general, family, or type", |
| "status": "emit `ALIGNED` or `MISALIGNED` exactly", |
| "sorting_or_selection": { |
| "primary": "status with MISALIGNED before ALIGNED", |
| "secondary": "datedHits descending", |
| "tertiary": "currentProducts descending", |
| "quaternary": "DTXSID ascending" |
| } |
| } |
| } |
| } |
|
|
