| { |
| "task_id": "comptox_013", |
| "domain": "COMPTOX_CHEMEXPO", |
| "autonomy_type": "ordered table", |
| "oracle_output_cardinality": 5, |
| "instruction": "在 ChemExpo 中，我们需要针对 Di(2-Ethylhexyl) Phthalate、Melamine、Phthalic Acid、Tris(2-Ethylhexyl) Phosphate 和 Triphenyl Phosphates Tert-Butylated 这五个物质，核对它们的历史标签与当前实际用途是否一致请按下面的步骤来查。先把范围限定在这五个物质：Di(2-Ethylhexyl) Phthalate、Melamine、Phthalic Acid、Tris(2-Ethylhexyl) Phosphate、Triphenyl Phosphates Tert-Butylated。首先，为每个物质收集三组基础评估数据。第一组为‘成品接触’得分：检查是否出现 Indirect additives food contact (10/2018)、Europe, Food contact items、Food contact items, Japan、含 Toys and children's products 字样的关键词，以及含 artificial_saliva 或 artificial_sweat 字样的关键词，这五类标签每命中一类记 1 分。第二组为‘生产来源’得分：检查是否出现 drinking_water, Europe, manufacturing, plastic_additive 与 Europe, plastic_additive 这两类标签，每命中一类也记 1 分。第三组为特定日期的监管概况：单独核查 Indirect additives food contact (10/2018)、OEHHA Proposition 65 (3/2019)、WA Children's Safe Product Act (4/2020)、OEHHA Proposition 65 (1/2023) 这四个关键词的命中总数，并记录所有命中项跨越的最早及最晚年月。有了这三组数据之后，看哪边分数高来决定历史方向：如果成品接触那边的分数严格大于生产来源那边，就按 Article → Formulation → Occupation 的顺序，为它选出一个历史线索推荐的类别；否则按 Occupation → Article → Formulation 的顺序来选。确定了类别之后，沿着产品数最多的下一级分类一路往下走，直到不能再细分；如果同一层有并列，就取 PUC ID 更小的。与此同时，再另外找出这个物质当前的主导类别，不看历史线索，直接在所有用途分类里找产品数最多的那条线，同样一路往下走到不能再细分；同层并列也取 PUC ID 更小的。最后把这两个结果放在一起比对：如果当前主导类别是 Article 或 Formulation，而历史线索判断也指向成品接触这一边，就记 ALIGNED；如果当前主导类别是 Occupation，而历史线索判断也指向生产来源那一边，也记 ALIGNED；其余情况都记 MISALIGNED。", |
| "start_url": "https://comptox.epa.gov/chemexpo/", |
| "output_format": "输出时先把 MISALIGNED 的排在前面；同一组里再按带日期命中数从高到低排；命中数也相同的，再按当前主导类别的产品数从高到低排。格式如下：<DTXSID>|<materialHits>|<sourceHits>|<datedHits>|<earliest>|<latest>|<historySide>|<recommendedKind>|<recommendedGeneral>|<recommendedTerminal>|<recommendedLevel>|<recommendedProducts>|<currentKind>|<currentGeneral>|<currentTerminal>|<currentLevel>|<currentProducts>|<status>结果之间用英文逗号分隔；如果带日期命中数为 0，则 earliest 和 latest 都写 NA。", |
| "oracle_answer": "DTXSID6020802|4|2|1|2018-10|2018-10|material|Article|Furniture and furnishings|Furniture and furnishings|general|15|Occupation|Raw materials|fireproof coatings|type|24|MISALIGNED,DTXSID8021484|3|1|1|2018-10|2018-10|material|Occupation|Laboratory supplies|Laboratory supplies|general|8|Occupation|Laboratory supplies|Laboratory supplies|general|8|MISALIGNED,DTXSID5020607|5|2|4|2018-10|2023-01|material|Article|Construction and building materials|flooring|family|1|Formulation|Home maintenance|paint|type|112|ALIGNED,DTXSID0021414|5|0|1|2018-10|2018-10|material|Article|Construction and building materials|Construction and building materials|general|3|Article|Construction and building materials|Construction and building materials|general|3|ALIGNED,DTXSID20872645|0|1|0|NA|NA|source|Occupation|Industrial products|hydraulic fluid|family|5|Occupation|Industrial products|hydraulic fluid|family|5|ALIGNED", |
| "metadata": { |
| "State-Gated Retrieval": [ |
| "只在题目指定的五个物质上工作，并先根据 keyword-set 区块计算 materialHits、sourceHits 与 datedHits。", |
| "历史推荐类别必须由这些历史信号独立推出；当前主导类别则需要单独从当前用途路径中求出。", |
| "最终只比较历史推荐类别与当前主导类别所在的大类方向是否一致，并据此标记 ALIGNED 或 MISALIGNED。" |
| ], |
| "dependency_type": "Data + Control", |
| "intra_chain": true, |
| "inter_chain": true, |
| "data_dependency": [ |
| "each chemical page yields materialHits, sourceHits, datedHits, and the historical recommendation side implied by the keyword set", |
| "independent current PUC drilldown yields the current dominant category, path labels, and classification counts for the same chemical", |
| "final rows are produced only after the historical recommendation and current dominant category are computed independently and then compared at the coarse side level" |
| ], |
| "control_dependency": [ |
| "the historical recommendation must be determined from the keyword-set evidence rather than from the current largest category", |
| "historical recommendation must be computed from the keyword-set evidence before alignment is judged", |
| "ALIGNED / MISALIGNED status is valid only after the historical and current category directions have been derived independently and then compared" |
| ], |
| "freeze": { |
| "historical_window": "current ChemExpo chemical pages and PUC drilldowns for the five named substances, using the specified historical keyword-set evidence through 2023-01" |
| }, |
| "answer_type": "multi-row ordered table" |
| }, |
| "rubric": { |
| "inclusion_conditions": [ |
| "只在题目指定的五个物质上工作，并先根据 keyword-set 区块计算 materialHits、sourceHits 与 datedHits。", |
| "历史推荐类别必须由这些历史信号独立推出；当前主导类别则需要单独从当前用途路径中求出。", |
| "最终只比较历史推荐类别与当前主导类别所在的大类方向是否一致，并据此标记 ALIGNED 或 MISALIGNED。" |
| ], |
| "exclusion_conditions": [ |
| "排除只看当前最大类别、直接把它当成历史推荐类别的结果。", |
| "排除在没有独立求出历史推荐类别的情况下默认一律 ALIGNED 的结果。", |
| "排除未把历史与当前两条链路分开计算、而是在同一路线里混读信号的结果。" |
| ], |
| "normalization": { |
| "field_separator": "|", |
| "record_separator": ",", |
| "schema": [ |
| "DTXSID", |
| "materialHits", |
| "sourceHits", |
| "datedHits", |
| "earliest", |
| "latest", |
| "historySide", |
| "recommendedKind", |
| "recommendedGeneral", |
| "recommendedTerminal", |
| "recommendedLevel", |
| "recommendedProducts", |
| "currentKind", |
| "currentGeneral", |
| "currentTerminal", |
| "currentLevel", |
| "currentProducts", |
| "status" |
| ], |
| "dated_hits": "count only the exact dated keyword strings defined in the source rubric", |
| "date_format": "YYYY-MM; if datedHits is 0, earliest and latest are both `NA`", |
| "historySide": "emit the lower-case historical winner `material` or `source`", |
| "recommended_fields": "these fields describe the historically suggested path", |
| "current_fields": "these fields describe the current dominant path", |
| "kind": "the kind fields use the canonical labels Article, Formulation, or Occupation", |
| "level": "the level fields use the canonical labels general, family, or type", |
| "status": "emit `ALIGNED` or `MISALIGNED` exactly", |
| "sorting_or_selection": { |
| "primary": "status with MISALIGNED before ALIGNED", |
| "secondary": "datedHits descending", |
| "tertiary": "currentProducts descending", |
| "quaternary": "DTXSID ascending" |
| } |
| } |
| } |
| } |
|
|
