File size: 5,920 Bytes
8a1c7c6 0b2af11 8a1c7c6 | 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 70 | {
"task_id": "consumerfinance_010",
"domain": "CFPB_REPORTS",
"autonomy_type": "ordered table",
"oracle_output_cardinality": 2,
"instruction": "I want to clearly sort out the CFPB's 2020 Debt Collection Rules, including proposal sources, delayed effective date arrangements, final effective dates, and the accompanying quick-reference PDF information on the implementation page. Follow the steps below. First, confirm when each of the two 2020 Debt Collection Rule final rules was issued. Then separately confirm the following for each wave: 1. The issue date of this final rule; 2. Which proposal(s) it developed from, and the public comment deadline for each proposal; 3. Whether the 2021 proposed rule on delaying the effective date covers this wave, and the comment deadline for that proposal; 4. The actual final effective date; 5. Which quick-reference PDF corresponds to this wave on the implementation page; 6. The first heading in the PDF body after skipping the introductory paragraph.",
"start_url": "https://www.consumerfinance.gov/rules-policy/final-rules/",
"output_format": "Output a single-line string with results sorted by final-rule issue date in ascending order. Identify each wave by its final rule issue month (YYYY-MM). Use the following format: <wave>|<final-rule-date>|<proposal-chain>|<proposal-comment-closes>|<delay-proposal-applied>|<delay-proposal-comments-close>|<controlling-effective-date>|<quick-reference-pdf>|<summary-heading>",
"oracle_answer": "2020-10|2020-10-30|2019-05-07 main|2019-09-18|YES|2021-05-19|2021-11-30|Executive summary of the October 2020 final rule|Coverage and Definitions,2020-12|2020-12-18|2019-05-07 main+2020-02-21 supplemental|2019-09-18+2020-08-04|YES|2021-05-19|2021-11-30|Executive summary of the December 2020 final rule|Validation Information Requirements and Disclosures",
"metadata": {
"State-Gated Retrieval": [
"Must process the two 2020 Debt Collection Practices (Regulation F) final rules separately, not merge them into one.",
"For each wave, separately confirm: issue date, corresponding proposal chain and public comment deadlines, whether the 2021 delayed-effective-date proposed rule covers it and its deadline, final effective date, corresponding implementation quick-reference PDF, and the first heading after the introduction in that PDF.",
"The detail page, proposal chain, and summary PDF for the October wave and the December wave must each be independently verified."
],
"dependency_type": "Data + Control",
"intra_chain": true,
"inter_chain": true,
"data_dependency": [
"final-rules index pages and rule-development pages yield the two 2020 Regulation F final-rule waves and their proposal branches",
"each final-rule detail page, delayed-effective-date proposal page, and implementation quick-reference PDF yields the wave-specific dates, linked proposals, comment deadlines, and first summary heading",
"final rows are produced only after the October and December waves are traced separately end to end"
],
"control_dependency": [
"two same-title final rules force correction from name-based collapsing to issue-date branching",
"proposal-chain validation must be done per wave; otherwise the later December chain contaminates the October row",
"implementation PDFs must be matched back to the correct wave rather than accepting the latest quick-reference page"
],
"freeze": {
"historical_window": "the 2020-10 and 2020-12 Debt Collection Rule final-rule waves, their linked 2020 proposal pages, the 2021 delayed-effective-date proposal, and the current implementation-page quick-reference PDFs"
},
"answer_type": "multi-row ordered table"
},
"rubric": {
"inclusion_conditions": [
"Must process the two 2020 Debt Collection Practices (Regulation F) final rules separately, not merge them into one.",
"For each wave, separately confirm: issue date, corresponding proposal chain and public comment deadlines, whether the 2021 delayed-effective-date proposed rule covers it and its deadline, final effective date, corresponding implementation quick-reference PDF, and the first heading after the introduction in that PDF.",
"The detail page, proposal chain, and summary PDF for the October wave and the December wave must each be independently verified."
],
"exclusion_conditions": [
"Exclude results that merge the two identically named 2020 final rules into one.",
"Exclude results that project the December wave's proposal chain or executive-summary heading onto the October wave.",
"Exclude results that do not independently verify each final-rule detail page and its corresponding PDF."
],
"normalization": {
"field_separator": "|",
"record_separator": ",",
"schema": [
"wave",
"final-rule-date",
"proposal-chain",
"proposal-comment-closes",
"delay-proposal-applied",
"delay-proposal-comments-close",
"controlling-effective-date",
"quick-reference-pdf",
"summary-heading"
],
"wave": "wave is the final-rule issue month in YYYY-MM",
"date_format": "all standalone date fields use YYYY-MM-DD",
"proposal_chain": "canonical chain joins proposal milestones with `+`, using pieces such as `2019-05-07 main` or `2020-02-21 supplemental` in chronological order",
"proposal_comment_closes": "join multiple comment-close dates with `+` in the same order as proposal_chain",
"delay_proposal_applied": "emit `YES` when a delay proposal is part of the chain; otherwise emit `NO`",
"quick_reference_pdf": "use the displayed quick-reference PDF title, not the filename",
"summary_heading": "use the first substantive heading from the final-rule PDF",
"sorting_or_selection": "final-rule-date ascending"
}
}
}
|