diff --git "a/ablation_v4_results/ablation_v4_mpnn_augmented.json" "b/ablation_v4_results/ablation_v4_mpnn_augmented.json" new file mode 100644--- /dev/null +++ "b/ablation_v4_results/ablation_v4_mpnn_augmented.json" @@ -0,0 +1,12113 @@ +{ + "variant": "mpnn_augmented", + "config": { + "name": "MPNN-augmented", + "model_type": "mpnn", + "aggregation": "sum", + "edge_norm": false, + "edge_augment": true, + "train_domains": [ + "diffusion", + "advection" + ], + "epochs": 1000, + "matrices_per_epoch": 16, + "num_layers": 8, + "embed_dim": 16, + "hidden_dim": 32, + "num_context_pairs": 5, + "training_grid_sizes": [ + 16, + 24, + 32 + ], + "eval_grid_sizes": [ + 16, + 24, + 32, + 48, + 64 + ], + "batch_size": 128, + "learning_rate": 0.001, + "gmres_restart": 30, + "gmres_max_iters": 300, + "gmres_rtol": 1e-06, + "num_test_matrices": 50, + "seeds": [ + 42, + 123, + 456, + 789, + 1337 + ], + "eval_domains": [ + "diffusion", + "advection", + "graph_laplacian" + ] + }, + "seeds": [ + { + "seed": 42, + "models": [ + { + "name": "No Preconditioner", + "param_count": 0, + "train_time": 0.0, + "train_history": [], + "best_loss": null, + "best_epoch": null, + "eval": { + "diffusion_16": { + "iterations": [ + 92, + 92, + 89, + 70, + 80, + 86, + 97, + 94, + 87, + 102, + 99, + 79, + 90, + 102, + 87, + 85, + 85, + 117, + 96, + 84, + 79, + 83, + 82, + 85, + 72, + 82, + 88, + 85, + 84, + 87, + 79, + 90, + 94, + 96, + 103, + 86, + 85, + 93, + 120, + 73, + 75, + 94, + 67, + 90, + 69, + 85, + 99, + 72, + 77, + 88 + ], + "converged": [ + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 8.849466608178487e-07, + 9.038157360916802e-07, + 9.831751473519103e-07, + 9.842022519533538e-07, + 9.232250361971954e-07, + 9.002261828778202e-07, + 9.9813588356472e-07, + 9.170099375220525e-07, + 9.265688578811523e-07, + 9.146902867227488e-07, + 9.505956099760592e-07, + 9.181001926961287e-07, + 9.58149083752407e-07, + 9.117652475283652e-07, + 9.219373199635413e-07, + 8.751072682992054e-07, + 9.551646274943965e-07, + 9.771465702551275e-07, + 9.7281864384397e-07, + 9.992570297644205e-07, + 9.045304062608205e-07, + 9.475831643560432e-07, + 9.210528513060686e-07, + 9.766666673515225e-07, + 8.596233047722296e-07, + 9.382540061165044e-07, + 9.76266907644767e-07, + 9.923978776479618e-07, + 9.205848099073365e-07, + 8.356487961880503e-07, + 9.890016734894256e-07, + 8.946018926454138e-07, + 9.1356517336525e-07, + 9.872635207177978e-07, + 9.462878589061932e-07, + 9.472505027105415e-07, + 9.08992835409336e-07, + 9.241868163353711e-07, + 9.974144806451077e-07, + 7.745399911052034e-07, + 9.822184752306027e-07, + 8.831538500216185e-07, + 9.362275258935101e-07, + 9.655818043504687e-07, + 9.075506859276581e-07, + 8.613473143148737e-07, + 9.843657326104486e-07, + 9.522806746350867e-07, + 9.177558487662283e-07, + 9.592506251799735e-07 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 0.34591162000015174, + 0.3479038550003679, + 0.48794467899915617, + 0.3482731789999889, + 0.3943986059994131, + 0.4895585780004694, + 0.495726348000062, + 0.36754294200000004, + 0.3279243690003568, + 0.3741305019993888, + 0.3735167819995695, + 0.28694016899953567, + 0.34875920899958146, + 0.3841060520007886, + 0.3250785589998486, + 0.3173400820005554, + 0.32790017099978286, + 0.44284000100014964, + 0.3586422540001877, + 0.3149444439995932, + 0.28511756799980503, + 0.3059220289997029, + 0.309949752000648, + 0.31439695299923187, + 0.25630398700013757, + 0.3180742699996699, + 0.33310007300042344, + 0.31374895099997957, + 0.31353715600016585, + 0.3412711629998739, + 0.2834582819996285, + 0.35067688199978875, + 0.36742550099916116, + 0.3505908469996939, + 0.3749143169998206, + 0.33531313100047555, + 0.41072389999953884, + 0.5078424559997075, + 0.6355926520000139, + 0.4096032120005475, + 0.34539816200049245, + 0.35501607799960766, + 0.2578081359997668, + 0.3437233610002295, + 0.2516090400004032, + 0.312889042000279, + 0.3766557979997742, + 0.2606381389996386, + 0.2746163820002039, + 0.3472044560003269 + ], + "output_norm_ratios": [] + }, + "diffusion_24": { + "iterations": [ + 137, + 141, + 122, + 127, + 172, + 161, + 103, + 123, + 146, + 136, + 154, + 155, + 134, + 127, + 135, + 166, + 155, + 143, + 123, + 146, + 138, + 139, + 144, + 158, + 118, + 162, + 130, + 121, + 135, + 137, + 134, + 140, + 206, + 107, + 134, + 125, + 132, + 123, + 140, + 156, + 117, + 157, + 135, + 135, + 146, + 137, + 131, + 129, + 139, + 153 + ], + "converged": [ + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 9.544699185647606e-07, + 9.587760189134982e-07, + 9.331194249118201e-07, + 8.987310911056011e-07, + 9.569743007590225e-07, + 9.587001850582422e-07, + 8.937690010941312e-07, + 9.428459537290264e-07, + 9.663232300607155e-07, + 9.189597599153805e-07, + 9.758391652249088e-07, + 9.629947528669966e-07, + 8.935495125494931e-07, + 9.613569550885038e-07, + 9.59517894940616e-07, + 9.424429006301574e-07, + 9.468678541412646e-07, + 9.565570754670376e-07, + 9.516499292535886e-07, + 9.605463623671881e-07, + 9.624713553908928e-07, + 9.35991390131557e-07, + 9.645157770531545e-07, + 9.695084974775614e-07, + 9.716499844565535e-07, + 9.614341110780335e-07, + 9.511843022634717e-07, + 9.347356498185206e-07, + 9.952564848203143e-07, + 9.71672060316992e-07, + 9.71343486901874e-07, + 9.383308551412407e-07, + 9.874554705523514e-07, + 9.422247296854364e-07, + 9.25947803325315e-07, + 9.972116175838567e-07, + 9.360052246484835e-07, + 9.813527371882484e-07, + 9.543434766913437e-07, + 9.95432806842629e-07, + 9.262851824017934e-07, + 9.830222875631986e-07, + 9.403096961703958e-07, + 9.094173723846004e-07, + 9.86545070819402e-07, + 9.087473501387556e-07, + 9.091229260975543e-07, + 9.972543682398116e-07, + 9.448154105431053e-07, + 9.897309928081217e-07 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 0.5270948110000973, + 0.5278176699994219, + 0.4847190690006755, + 0.47731846300030156, + 0.6660628690005979, + 0.6112130889996479, + 0.3942850789999284, + 0.4760940039996058, + 0.568495860999974, + 0.5132639910007128, + 0.764986633999797, + 0.8284993679999388, + 0.7684278260003339, + 0.48112334799952805, + 0.5171096009999019, + 0.6251380319999953, + 0.6096753819992955, + 0.5463585369998327, + 0.4944665269995312, + 0.5728050739999162, + 0.5368662620003306, + 0.5175610900005267, + 0.5669849629994133, + 0.6563385459994606, + 0.4576392679991841, + 0.6259625780003262, + 0.4851390250005352, + 0.4888952799992694, + 0.49858073299947137, + 0.5276162040008785, + 0.49724385700028506, + 0.6840969269997004, + 1.1343827460004832, + 0.5801511249992473, + 0.5088938600001711, + 0.4703519319991756, + 0.5034428510007274, + 0.49472798999886436, + 0.5327562029997353, + 0.5913385849999031, + 0.45570021500134317, + 0.596270515001379, + 0.5097702750008466, + 0.5061475599995902, + 0.5630006970004615, + 0.5303230450008414, + 0.5004646239995054, + 0.48447289900104806, + 0.5266874760000064, + 0.5903300760001002 + ], + "output_norm_ratios": [] + }, + "diffusion_32": { + "iterations": [ + 226, + 255, + 178, + 197, + 234, + 246, + 241, + 235, + 225, + 185, + 193, + 209, + 171, + 184, + 253, + 292, + 184, + 246, + 186, + 184, + 218, + 202, + 183, + 174, + 204, + 194, + 177, + 228, + 209, + 266, + 188, + 194, + 181, + 199, + 217, + 185, + 271, + 142, + 190, + 226, + 193, + 186, + 219, + 300, + 183, + 204, + 238, + 174, + 211, + 192 + ], + "converged": [ + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + false, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 9.509238585060975e-07, + 9.804556082977805e-07, + 9.278299122138735e-07, + 9.925427461448639e-07, + 9.858301045499623e-07, + 9.83732013168549e-07, + 9.863785218190011e-07, + 9.879729160698793e-07, + 9.770578104203928e-07, + 9.903120436673868e-07, + 9.23215198145418e-07, + 9.803393343463326e-07, + 9.38101242974112e-07, + 9.682420384775732e-07, + 9.69845544773826e-07, + 9.671426824923816e-07, + 9.242855485997784e-07, + 9.821196794783623e-07, + 9.59628446322292e-07, + 9.930834909302778e-07, + 9.461239316817652e-07, + 9.749725917104618e-07, + 9.91136442716531e-07, + 9.442335265798881e-07, + 9.397935731153459e-07, + 9.692160128208779e-07, + 9.60405281729227e-07, + 9.768611769018325e-07, + 9.78676156558373e-07, + 9.95219897027808e-07, + 9.37763691740265e-07, + 9.831006208028516e-07, + 9.783485361970232e-07, + 9.464097709507154e-07, + 9.781615772615721e-07, + 9.871735176339006e-07, + 9.891009599831183e-07, + 9.776491868791917e-07, + 9.746787598974872e-07, + 9.67083832132172e-07, + 9.671324114401248e-07, + 9.802268256184325e-07, + 9.551856290138135e-07, + 1.579759935793942e-06, + 9.793042680954916e-07, + 9.540002924185311e-07, + 9.741934866979418e-07, + 9.929807611109584e-07, + 9.912283842755438e-07, + 9.408735990853426e-07 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 0.9174042180002289, + 0.993314007000663, + 0.7083709800008364, + 0.7687824290005665, + 0.9668667640016793, + 0.957021132000591, + 0.9563273650001065, + 0.9261664469995594, + 0.879164010999375, + 0.7362770250001631, + 0.7567261800013512, + 0.9844701919992076, + 0.9018645189989911, + 0.9506595610000659, + 0.9804721719992813, + 1.1444074239989277, + 0.7265300710005249, + 0.9697047720001137, + 0.7350119769998855, + 0.7245949820007809, + 0.8621763090013701, + 0.7866530219998822, + 0.7219582050001918, + 0.6740382509997289, + 0.8076909060000617, + 0.8647534430001542, + 0.9713043560004735, + 1.1367105250010354, + 0.8345208299997466, + 1.0546354950001842, + 0.7222197869996307, + 0.7600506300004781, + 0.7398271259989997, + 0.7798095529997227, + 0.8385448589997395, + 0.7322846690003644, + 1.0789225569988048, + 0.561164918999566, + 0.7277439439985756, + 1.0079986529999587, + 1.0386046540006646, + 0.9683960749989637, + 0.8588107160012441, + 1.1990289989989833, + 0.7260123880005267, + 0.8011374990001059, + 0.9428908840000076, + 0.6736641630013764, + 0.8423415929992188, + 0.7457002949995513 + ], + "output_norm_ratios": [] + }, + "diffusion_48": { + "iterations": [ + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 294, + 300, + 300 + ], + "converged": [ + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + true, + false, + false + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 1.385447213049806e-05, + 3.151994416594569e-05, + 8.841948559928044e-06, + 2.4825783353843242e-05, + 1.7357921023544727e-05, + 1.1972341614399512e-05, + 1.1392500423572879e-05, + 3.482395964994861e-06, + 5.995483441140289e-05, + 7.705356299366643e-06, + 1.1511282088116479e-05, + 0.00016855578682802317, + 4.176808570672182e-06, + 1.1903355873714857e-05, + 7.23588542187335e-05, + 9.21149314455258e-06, + 4.784817779489888e-06, + 2.9439216745243973e-05, + 1.0794759500581623e-05, + 9.407864733298095e-05, + 3.1002275798108055e-06, + 1.2578867091944991e-06, + 7.46027522259469e-06, + 7.358368762219615e-06, + 8.130888881877959e-06, + 1.7344788791409175e-05, + 4.424185749003934e-06, + 2.844900477468073e-06, + 6.4740391968522766e-06, + 9.768345552634111e-06, + 1.017533919043851e-05, + 3.646987444763962e-05, + 3.8596956677929646e-05, + 2.991814841003178e-05, + 6.655341464443871e-06, + 3.837960695458244e-05, + 2.539600248912184e-06, + 1.3040010414351172e-05, + 6.951318716209864e-06, + 0.00030606125367295704, + 7.299507856878473e-06, + 1.0539558257331696e-05, + 8.155540504443843e-05, + 9.917395713943111e-06, + 6.824639858609423e-06, + 1.0444771356166444e-05, + 7.990340932224202e-06, + 9.8489885142439e-07, + 3.0201412854668707e-05, + 1.7187369568931633e-05 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 1.6968713909991493, + 1.2056906210000307, + 1.2068118229999527, + 1.215420720000111, + 1.1959654279999086, + 1.1983156140013307, + 1.198072528000921, + 1.2040114259998518, + 1.206474814998728, + 1.6034493650004151, + 1.4434794040007546, + 1.201696071000697, + 1.2104990869993344, + 1.200498216001506, + 1.2004460589996597, + 1.2259891650010104, + 1.2034861229985836, + 1.2046389810002438, + 1.4087851040003443, + 1.711567667000054, + 1.2184559100005572, + 1.1961588880003546, + 1.2002192180007114, + 1.2321904149994225, + 1.206334037000488, + 1.1959006500001124, + 1.2156962570006726, + 1.205150687999776, + 1.6739827640012663, + 1.3661280050000641, + 1.2005967260010948, + 1.2015275710000424, + 1.198596774998805, + 1.195680621000065, + 1.2055468920007115, + 1.227779859000293, + 1.1994559450013185, + 1.4673390649986686, + 1.581639907999488, + 1.2095912109998608, + 1.2019308540002385, + 1.2130657069992594, + 1.2354715840010613, + 1.2282247690000077, + 1.1996857770009228, + 1.2041300390010292, + 1.2861470199986798, + 1.6971940089988493, + 1.2659738910006126, + 1.2040625659992656 + ], + "output_norm_ratios": [] + }, + "diffusion_64": { + "iterations": [ + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300 + ], + "converged": [ + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 0.00013664502134414397, + 0.0004197877290502607, + 0.00017329090124761968, + 5.76975532349097e-06, + 0.00016287973551991873, + 0.00024133228323894545, + 0.0005273600408513483, + 3.5328221644161844e-05, + 0.00010106612772437244, + 0.00016364961340688017, + 0.0004025694716101797, + 0.00010185230871535982, + 0.00017429128916907543, + 0.00039340954630974267, + 0.00035830879747736057, + 5.203024248729505e-05, + 0.00047604221714630905, + 0.00014262998919503873, + 0.00010091614806594344, + 0.0004801076131358269, + 0.00011808878156347178, + 0.0002392955641938405, + 0.0001236702849643458, + 0.00028100211064464376, + 0.00025149372428079467, + 0.00012433496556408665, + 0.0002985693234548136, + 0.00023332458298117202, + 1.0516273676183047e-05, + 0.00033711589787040154, + 0.0005251480168616104, + 0.00041553848595658695, + 0.0002272453202881932, + 0.000527118833037495, + 0.0004052481401231536, + 0.00030486538113189246, + 0.0002290410293562122, + 0.000248265067429827, + 0.00025679863574731523, + 0.00021829966112996656, + 0.0005332814059166341, + 0.00014533826995884755, + 6.745043195979862e-06, + 0.00024237601999027762, + 0.0008237731808597031, + 7.582294558843276e-05, + 0.0003304705237508404, + 0.00011233169390320609, + 7.065526095787672e-05, + 7.783323602913248e-05 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 1.5777522850003152, + 1.4999958540010994, + 1.2081567510012974, + 1.2042727469997772, + 1.2061956340003235, + 1.2521769710001536, + 1.2218207080004504, + 1.219207018999441, + 1.2089188089994423, + 1.4198985009988974, + 1.628362941000887, + 1.2055867109993414, + 1.2098439399997005, + 1.2237468870007433, + 1.2491629569994984, + 1.2082317940003122, + 1.2047329880006146, + 1.2097318950000044, + 1.2406084180001926, + 1.7517455060005886, + 1.292636959000447, + 1.2062626130009448, + 1.2080637339986424, + 1.2332184229999257, + 1.2043618349998724, + 1.201474875000713, + 1.2052550680000422, + 1.1990633530003834, + 1.5414708200005407, + 1.5358204459989793, + 1.2006401760008885, + 1.2311688059999142, + 1.2013746059983532, + 1.204451390000031, + 1.2066674870002316, + 1.2033476320011687, + 1.206395994999184, + 1.3525413240004127, + 1.7086249660005706, + 1.2263123889988492, + 1.2103348479995475, + 1.207961398000407, + 1.2068744199987123, + 1.219882448000135, + 1.2073261730001832, + 1.235377184999379, + 1.2096413420003955, + 1.6364858710003318, + 1.4572471479987144, + 1.2165512730007322 + ], + "output_norm_ratios": [] + }, + "advection_16": { + "iterations": [ + 76, + 73, + 90, + 77, + 88, + 116, + 72, + 96, + 78, + 102, + 73, + 87, + 78, + 77, + 86, + 79, + 88, + 85, + 80, + 86, + 103, + 84, + 88, + 77, + 95, + 79, + 89, + 92, + 85, + 85, + 82, + 95, + 80, + 87, + 78, + 98, + 78, + 82, + 93, + 87, + 91, + 96, + 85, + 87, + 71, + 86, + 80, + 137, + 72, + 76 + ], + "converged": [ + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 9.718143321991784e-07, + 9.122055479574779e-07, + 9.370116020508474e-07, + 9.679335428137337e-07, + 9.436533993019255e-07, + 9.335422387289656e-07, + 9.299156054174642e-07, + 9.961707672694334e-07, + 9.455221448689774e-07, + 9.489205478787875e-07, + 8.583675743405242e-07, + 8.687082556379041e-07, + 9.32528098994054e-07, + 8.469289929462211e-07, + 9.156491830641116e-07, + 9.731322334753098e-07, + 8.940034276099769e-07, + 9.208607640816497e-07, + 9.07742782857586e-07, + 8.277243700099322e-07, + 9.709266788899639e-07, + 8.988018805846621e-07, + 9.440064040104704e-07, + 8.987249444204913e-07, + 9.073907566704926e-07, + 8.847302757492251e-07, + 8.719795036877706e-07, + 9.814427907244447e-07, + 9.443980161791432e-07, + 9.766665006733913e-07, + 9.140337968758862e-07, + 9.349277246420012e-07, + 9.902260658592955e-07, + 9.248944551420339e-07, + 9.05428306366164e-07, + 9.79643474565704e-07, + 9.434179746874839e-07, + 9.181919105492288e-07, + 9.511610254286776e-07, + 9.237646098233018e-07, + 8.841232404150961e-07, + 9.559823176701764e-07, + 8.972688115669871e-07, + 9.688353928794963e-07, + 8.457992544550896e-07, + 9.05240242252956e-07, + 9.608692680949125e-07, + 9.318427886528301e-07, + 9.616462511699961e-07, + 8.31713255676733e-07 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 0.27162547100124357, + 0.2743322709993663, + 0.3445260700009385, + 0.28092032200038375, + 0.3461380159988039, + 0.4407247320013994, + 0.25742604300103267, + 0.541382983999938, + 0.3968238540001039, + 0.5224225649999426, + 0.40406725599859783, + 0.39443817299979855, + 0.28987975799827836, + 0.2835828829993261, + 0.32365947700054676, + 0.29717074200016214, + 0.3447631660001207, + 0.3185550380003406, + 0.2957151789996715, + 0.34135852599865757, + 0.3761844630007545, + 0.3080006340005639, + 0.3652259709997452, + 0.27745728499940014, + 0.35216846900038945, + 0.30124642299961124, + 0.33919190999949933, + 0.34686606299874256, + 0.332277237001108, + 0.3176222919992142, + 0.29554020400064474, + 0.369070857999759, + 0.29120674099976895, + 0.3271920709994447, + 0.2943189010002243, + 0.3670887619991845, + 0.27927796999938437, + 0.2969044439996651, + 0.3713241579989699, + 0.33028321800156846, + 0.34851687400077935, + 0.38083529499999713, + 0.4827579200009495, + 0.4720346169997356, + 0.34241329500036954, + 0.4986188399998355, + 0.37317544399957114, + 0.5072874889992818, + 0.280112354999801, + 0.2724250259998371 + ], + "output_norm_ratios": [] + }, + "advection_24": { + "iterations": [ + 136, + 134, + 135, + 132, + 147, + 156, + 117, + 140, + 141, + 159, + 131, + 138, + 163, + 162, + 138, + 124, + 141, + 150, + 145, + 166, + 144, + 142, + 146, + 150, + 148, + 123, + 124, + 139, + 150, + 110, + 137, + 151, + 136, + 185, + 132, + 129, + 137, + 144, + 154, + 159, + 156, + 151, + 149, + 131, + 151, + 159, + 109, + 146, + 144, + 140 + ], + "converged": [ + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 9.437356085028639e-07, + 9.421363524577145e-07, + 9.043839589617549e-07, + 9.252315795574487e-07, + 9.601219201722677e-07, + 9.935611570020508e-07, + 9.742203128624525e-07, + 9.85331571882182e-07, + 9.803229105608468e-07, + 9.911100675431261e-07, + 9.214691939008021e-07, + 9.218360827243469e-07, + 9.825998137876214e-07, + 9.56278090695707e-07, + 9.990079822128374e-07, + 9.693974318087603e-07, + 9.486303360471506e-07, + 9.650396235149125e-07, + 9.716856747684531e-07, + 9.128257031894614e-07, + 9.735687504296691e-07, + 9.827214834372433e-07, + 9.73033371267978e-07, + 9.787021252373499e-07, + 9.593040313252215e-07, + 9.88983350516275e-07, + 9.921580550165157e-07, + 9.872882249675288e-07, + 9.424780260930025e-07, + 9.167327279667823e-07, + 9.369988663751821e-07, + 9.64098138973436e-07, + 9.302330811569016e-07, + 9.618865391190452e-07, + 9.433437897845661e-07, + 9.236958999857104e-07, + 9.764224923990787e-07, + 9.351117183507452e-07, + 9.723588618767106e-07, + 9.480390462448927e-07, + 9.734938064205814e-07, + 9.953940045922743e-07, + 9.824487959177172e-07, + 9.585415969660046e-07, + 9.800244011192583e-07, + 9.512877685721629e-07, + 8.847064514916157e-07, + 9.674303074091307e-07, + 9.458332872001563e-07, + 9.142246842186444e-07 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 0.5297808699997404, + 0.5010904900009336, + 0.5192358950007474, + 0.49004437000075995, + 0.5808812840004975, + 0.5964422190008918, + 0.46508837200053676, + 0.5270524700008536, + 0.5484122890011349, + 0.595750943000894, + 0.5082826229991042, + 0.5123176540000713, + 0.7978591259998211, + 0.8467015040005208, + 0.7583347999989201, + 0.49506545000076585, + 0.5478372630004742, + 0.5840465559995209, + 0.5655581199989683, + 0.6275742029993125, + 0.556346024000959, + 0.5347596629999316, + 0.5724088349998055, + 0.586664935999579, + 0.5815300849990308, + 0.472080826999445, + 0.4825609130002704, + 0.5276320959983423, + 0.597562693999862, + 0.40704382699914277, + 0.524535303000448, + 0.5967774490000011, + 0.5051477830002113, + 0.9885301409995009, + 0.6991858609999326, + 0.6424704189994372, + 0.5289267289990676, + 0.5519846589995723, + 0.6064673430009861, + 0.6029044700007944, + 0.6115156679989013, + 0.6030009379992407, + 0.5834217700012232, + 0.49899021000055654, + 0.585708856000565, + 0.6165617879996717, + 0.40844942100011394, + 0.5825891510012298, + 0.5498817860006966, + 0.5391422380016593 + ], + "output_norm_ratios": [] + }, + "advection_32": { + "iterations": [ + 272, + 229, + 222, + 230, + 237, + 180, + 269, + 224, + 187, + 232, + 218, + 215, + 190, + 221, + 184, + 202, + 229, + 253, + 207, + 240, + 202, + 161, + 224, + 214, + 156, + 220, + 204, + 234, + 207, + 209, + 186, + 212, + 166, + 217, + 219, + 264, + 215, + 205, + 220, + 174, + 232, + 226, + 208, + 180, + 267, + 196, + 244, + 172, + 208, + 231 + ], + "converged": [ + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 9.958797279677397e-07, + 9.990591101720724e-07, + 9.581449213648726e-07, + 9.672304419965982e-07, + 9.787708673453404e-07, + 9.499453212715891e-07, + 9.975618308571544e-07, + 9.634979157070442e-07, + 9.654664927271516e-07, + 9.672005336828114e-07, + 9.623478752430917e-07, + 9.780151701661417e-07, + 9.945605399256102e-07, + 9.797954879050883e-07, + 9.805094714992996e-07, + 9.892793975102475e-07, + 9.770700934283958e-07, + 9.826152059419185e-07, + 9.960579590985338e-07, + 9.735677987647252e-07, + 9.454376729413433e-07, + 9.880812548228956e-07, + 9.690893523589087e-07, + 9.922022878391267e-07, + 9.897771991825121e-07, + 9.951925259956054e-07, + 9.62176197151492e-07, + 9.968882116494094e-07, + 9.81071135964662e-07, + 9.975071846512368e-07, + 9.795361564876025e-07, + 9.733406584033958e-07, + 9.608101724786721e-07, + 9.887760224141278e-07, + 9.638999376050796e-07, + 9.769261819312608e-07, + 9.905776931465583e-07, + 9.783390807322794e-07, + 9.934809777457952e-07, + 9.913432087398352e-07, + 9.69543195247998e-07, + 9.984823150776678e-07, + 9.665153145748243e-07, + 9.668898354933913e-07, + 9.675113267575414e-07, + 9.601010319481957e-07, + 9.921077189756208e-07, + 9.931326733432371e-07, + 9.71739842824144e-07, + 9.727654576276057e-07 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 1.1110434500005795, + 0.8956655980000505, + 0.8701973139995971, + 0.9027050709992182, + 0.9512702350002655, + 0.7285223589988163, + 1.076069714001278, + 0.8730516619998525, + 0.7388204700000642, + 0.9191127230005804, + 0.8685037250015739, + 1.2109875629994349, + 1.0271439699990879, + 0.8769386129988561, + 0.7418114020001667, + 0.7854558229992108, + 0.9127751390005869, + 1.0311692079994828, + 0.8460823719997279, + 0.9650806939989707, + 0.8043520779992832, + 0.6162725119993411, + 0.8796168669996405, + 0.8598743830007152, + 0.7216055990011228, + 1.2407300529994245, + 1.0133586459996877, + 0.9457537079997564, + 0.8314429700003529, + 0.8294135629985249, + 0.7408062439990317, + 0.8493497909985308, + 0.6477306350006984, + 0.8414430190005078, + 0.8822677910011407, + 1.071349421999912, + 0.8473322179997922, + 0.8116952910004329, + 1.1490325020004093, + 1.017356763000862, + 0.9446691979992465, + 0.8908322639999824, + 0.8171800199997961, + 0.7272999779997917, + 1.0721359749986732, + 0.7751659440000367, + 0.9702272369995626, + 0.6846521710012894, + 0.8151903170000878, + 0.9150654189998022 + ], + "output_norm_ratios": [] + }, + "advection_48": { + "iterations": [ + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300 + ], + "converged": [ + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 9.606632135123181e-06, + 1.824854453744625e-05, + 1.1722257895270381e-05, + 7.745117421818877e-06, + 1.447984588464005e-06, + 9.87781804238895e-06, + 2.2200560223008114e-05, + 5.386207049816329e-05, + 8.03285109223579e-05, + 4.83068685967078e-05, + 1.0698556979079335e-05, + 1.940543823835693e-05, + 3.6218433438178133e-06, + 1.1762228114839388e-05, + 4.213737855314541e-05, + 4.9857245350707714e-06, + 2.131411084686307e-05, + 3.589883734701959e-05, + 2.7587648021314752e-05, + 3.8918672082028575e-05, + 2.65662502116965e-06, + 1.4968759981375005e-05, + 1.9395193571493656e-05, + 1.5272499360795443e-05, + 3.384941733839893e-05, + 9.818887576873772e-06, + 1.1758967643017977e-05, + 7.076933893834376e-06, + 8.638288696760993e-06, + 3.456166587716393e-05, + 7.206749803440326e-06, + 9.798410578492884e-06, + 2.6260030599011825e-05, + 2.1925460871275622e-05, + 2.446560972121483e-05, + 2.455469242819624e-05, + 0.00010921439740517882, + 1.7102010042835287e-05, + 2.8546434044799703e-05, + 1.6372110923603085e-05, + 7.580445930149835e-05, + 3.85306112765607e-05, + 2.9722095384434652e-05, + 8.675899521046199e-06, + 4.251816136631591e-06, + 9.117878688774588e-05, + 3.884105641920167e-05, + 7.51965793900725e-06, + 3.261577714312373e-06, + 1.6259277916872979e-06 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 1.2031989290007914, + 1.2089175960009015, + 1.2161585080011719, + 1.2051919900004577, + 1.210784204000447, + 1.2083353990001342, + 1.2044229399998585, + 1.610213031000967, + 1.457624439999563, + 1.1997405709989835, + 1.2204520739996951, + 1.2139507950014377, + 1.2334982630000013, + 1.208108839000488, + 1.2122025410008064, + 1.211824157000592, + 1.4642144520003058, + 1.63875175999965, + 1.2546924079997552, + 1.2255521959996258, + 1.2093292640001891, + 1.2039320620006038, + 1.2077578309999808, + 1.2104942290006875, + 1.220766743999775, + 1.2657305669999914, + 1.7289535149993753, + 1.2735338399998, + 1.206895142000576, + 1.2070240060002106, + 1.2120549560004292, + 1.1997758199995587, + 1.229398712001057, + 1.2147553419999895, + 1.218352367000989, + 1.5662156130001677, + 1.5183448040006624, + 1.1988872219990299, + 1.2165783079999528, + 1.2286303199998656, + 1.2116839390000678, + 1.200779954000609, + 1.2317002050003794, + 1.2033326210002997, + 1.3885234300014417, + 1.666487808999591, + 1.2066922610010806, + 1.2149234710013843, + 1.2315903039998375, + 1.2109340480001265 + ], + "output_norm_ratios": [] + }, + "advection_64": { + "iterations": [ + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300 + ], + "converged": [ + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 0.0006595299899436543, + 2.6379436632169317e-05, + 0.0001421008836467388, + 1.841248239807525e-05, + 0.0005263991444558191, + 0.0001272235538672996, + 0.000319847828953924, + 0.0007744942654252965, + 0.0005222911910978571, + 1.5800018812427278e-05, + 0.00030055198126955647, + 0.00010767835956328418, + 0.0002152480576211545, + 0.00015420935752904092, + 9.942462403847705e-05, + 0.00023138748828293335, + 5.336311733762648e-05, + 2.183376148904994e-05, + 6.561013650922914e-05, + 4.093569326367203e-05, + 0.00011610259361626909, + 8.009034010154735e-05, + 0.00011957320946048879, + 0.00020092284397659046, + 0.0006423984989521854, + 5.438555576942904e-05, + 0.00012625524569598317, + 0.00017467384302564625, + 0.00011352452705790568, + 7.420428139133217e-05, + 4.396371078453212e-05, + 0.00015474150917175707, + 0.00021386470717518627, + 0.00019786571123251297, + 0.0002389963862807368, + 0.0001815920447613009, + 0.000341138590334168, + 0.00036040567750637853, + 0.00036643231958951455, + 0.00016443244200122978, + 0.00020804834296000012, + 0.00024054677980121761, + 6.159883989119385e-05, + 8.08997772812173e-06, + 0.0007180265289331985, + 0.0005110126809663597, + 8.181370668799988e-05, + 0.0006871352169151041, + 0.00018682058786317364, + 0.000441685664800375 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 1.2216255530001945, + 1.221788935999939, + 1.229152633999547, + 1.2008022669997445, + 1.196772670999053, + 1.2221692690000054, + 1.5692126100002497, + 1.5159593159987708, + 1.2058895619993564, + 1.2241244730012113, + 1.2148591369987116, + 1.216999508000299, + 1.2211539939999057, + 1.2059938619986497, + 1.1974381910004013, + 1.4193068380009208, + 1.6470042599994485, + 1.2099221460011904, + 1.2593921339994267, + 1.209702128000572, + 1.214696407001611, + 1.1969179540010373, + 1.2051781039990601, + 1.24651890199857, + 1.209070991999397, + 1.714991677999933, + 1.344355559998803, + 1.2384414239986654, + 1.21804177499871, + 1.2082243510012631, + 1.2126669589997618, + 1.2268425809998007, + 1.2466225590014801, + 1.232562142999086, + 1.565529225001228, + 1.5215232810005546, + 1.204402271001527, + 1.199749375000465, + 1.2073508989997208, + 1.2405430920007348, + 1.2170800820003933, + 1.2023225709999679, + 1.2112086039996939, + 1.399522308000087, + 1.6603303310002957, + 1.2005140439996467, + 1.2389225679999072, + 1.202714074001051, + 1.2157298199999786, + 1.2063634189998993 + ], + "output_norm_ratios": [] + }, + "graph_laplacian_16": { + "iterations": [ + 15, + 15, + 13, + 15, + 15, + 16, + 14, + 15, + 16, + 15, + 15, + 15, + 14, + 15, + 15, + 15, + 15, + 13, + 15, + 15, + 15, + 15, + 16, + 14, + 16, + 14, + 15, + 15, + 14, + 14, + 14, + 15, + 15, + 15, + 14, + 15, + 15, + 16, + 14, + 16, + 15, + 14, + 13, + 13, + 15, + 15, + 12, + 15, + 14, + 13 + ], + "converged": [ + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 6.453485196816012e-07, + 8.063475388656881e-07, + 3.059211961452159e-07, + 5.917478079976073e-07, + 4.309358448730787e-07, + 5.076716761338638e-07, + 5.061026193271833e-07, + 7.756468745411865e-07, + 5.010324348931476e-07, + 5.505264194811978e-07, + 7.481778236825421e-07, + 4.6112364470593777e-07, + 9.351129189094019e-07, + 3.9991302668241093e-07, + 6.303065956859092e-07, + 3.923231106239795e-07, + 4.351735897196842e-07, + 6.437275957223996e-07, + 4.299033217716832e-07, + 9.310156893305854e-07, + 3.201508292945317e-07, + 9.303835995545249e-07, + 3.2419596783019254e-07, + 3.094311199384842e-07, + 4.516774840865542e-07, + 7.944840416105835e-07, + 3.644506765763192e-07, + 8.560536715503868e-07, + 4.1260815218351954e-07, + 6.717217069221615e-07, + 3.717468403133176e-07, + 4.833670047889586e-07, + 3.079133738210306e-07, + 4.479712053935133e-07, + 4.50646808893801e-07, + 5.827607116760607e-07, + 4.888693443754179e-07, + 3.949417545935857e-07, + 6.733411365265679e-07, + 4.385551588286863e-07, + 8.114640863726572e-07, + 8.731554518335042e-07, + 3.3621497120533397e-07, + 8.010559238767009e-07, + 6.657221308151047e-07, + 9.091312736106434e-07, + 8.079023750979906e-07, + 7.408169900656862e-07, + 6.119322382844901e-07, + 7.371368772115423e-07 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 0.03758062999986578, + 0.03700499200022023, + 0.029690543999095098, + 0.03732923300049151, + 0.03695937000156846, + 0.040722226000070805, + 0.03616007900018303, + 0.038210940998396836, + 0.040743072000623215, + 0.036572039000020595, + 0.036811734000366414, + 0.03685632800079475, + 0.0333369309992122, + 0.03701714899943909, + 0.05018438100159983, + 0.0373135160007223, + 0.03794853100043838, + 0.030170507001457736, + 0.03698317000089446, + 0.03823082999952021, + 0.03782521399989491, + 0.03739297899846861, + 0.04097774200090498, + 0.033221030000277096, + 0.042633778999515926, + 0.03383858900087944, + 0.039851053999882424, + 0.03758829300022626, + 0.03432672599956277, + 0.03372241400029452, + 0.03347632299846737, + 0.03684208300001046, + 0.037555645998509135, + 0.04117423699972278, + 0.033416117999877315, + 0.037038247000964475, + 0.03728296299959766, + 0.04100975100118376, + 0.034065380999891204, + 0.04118745699997817, + 0.03827571800138685, + 0.03802126899972791, + 0.038926863999222405, + 0.031033967999974266, + 0.037733854000180145, + 0.037052613000923884, + 0.026671236999391112, + 0.03879346900066594, + 0.0334561660001782, + 0.02984762500091165 + ], + "output_norm_ratios": [] + }, + "graph_laplacian_24": { + "iterations": [ + 15, + 13, + 14, + 14, + 13, + 13, + 13, + 16, + 14, + 15, + 16, + 16, + 15, + 15, + 13, + 16, + 15, + 15, + 12, + 14, + 13, + 14, + 15, + 15, + 16, + 13, + 15, + 15, + 15, + 13, + 15, + 15, + 14, + 15, + 15, + 14, + 15, + 15, + 16, + 14, + 16, + 14, + 15, + 15, + 15, + 15, + 15, + 14, + 14, + 16 + ], + "converged": [ + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 9.685572424168298e-07, + 9.534477500258242e-07, + 7.446322493251304e-07, + 6.976711023712179e-07, + 9.892453949486002e-07, + 5.491142615560443e-07, + 6.348883752973584e-07, + 4.716922254169196e-07, + 3.752141687073385e-07, + 3.2854348597249175e-07, + 3.5078572602695866e-07, + 4.833972709475074e-07, + 7.039699159375219e-07, + 7.355020428553684e-07, + 5.667483333129983e-07, + 3.577899475716002e-07, + 5.667564274518597e-07, + 8.242625247248105e-07, + 5.681025871134767e-07, + 5.742548397632863e-07, + 2.906001613614028e-07, + 9.097534307217504e-07, + 8.994874458350741e-07, + 5.024292040382678e-07, + 5.159420756155439e-07, + 9.193664484064539e-07, + 7.264276383572151e-07, + 3.3586955421594017e-07, + 8.448934840667846e-07, + 4.81443488145944e-07, + 6.516678697540339e-07, + 4.831856926175933e-07, + 9.595036712446493e-07, + 5.683940284758194e-07, + 4.193462744599185e-07, + 7.172416378026506e-07, + 4.3844987091923733e-07, + 3.9547060674578245e-07, + 4.2849312733631756e-07, + 6.541113188011575e-07, + 5.572038507177135e-07, + 6.476697701951418e-07, + 5.488015207168084e-07, + 4.646311063997479e-07, + 9.60661250604674e-07, + 4.350354651294082e-07, + 3.786742336126309e-07, + 5.976025717019629e-07, + 7.322300316051575e-07, + 5.920623766815246e-07 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 0.039507040000898996, + 0.04225650600164954, + 0.034869200999310124, + 0.034861100000853185, + 0.031860308999966946, + 0.03285047699864663, + 0.03018584799974633, + 0.041941525998481666, + 0.03342144199996255, + 0.03809672300121747, + 0.04310895800153958, + 0.04170554600023024, + 0.03805177799949888, + 0.037957593998726225, + 0.03046972200172604, + 0.042345440000644885, + 0.03721992200007662, + 0.0381083900010708, + 0.026492342998608365, + 0.03338535399961984, + 0.031916672000079416, + 0.033324121999612544, + 0.03691312999944785, + 0.038251406000199495, + 0.041367047999301576, + 0.031210240000291378, + 0.03864226000041526, + 0.037976554998749634, + 0.03781860900016909, + 0.043436572999780765, + 0.03960657700008596, + 0.0389076629999181, + 0.03660725500049011, + 0.03816793300029531, + 0.03770207899833622, + 0.033134416000393685, + 0.037128730000404175, + 0.038255565999861574, + 0.041982717000792036, + 0.034674317999815685, + 0.041586579000068014, + 0.03324029199939105, + 0.03810174200043548, + 0.03805371899943566, + 0.03776306100007787, + 0.037853743000596296, + 0.03950251300011587, + 0.0352173990013398, + 0.03429374799998186, + 0.04198072999861324 + ], + "output_norm_ratios": [] + }, + "graph_laplacian_32": { + "iterations": [ + 14, + 15, + 15, + 15, + 14, + 13, + 16, + 15, + 13, + 15, + 13, + 14, + 14, + 15, + 15, + 14, + 14, + 14, + 12, + 16, + 15, + 15, + 15, + 15, + 16, + 14, + 14, + 15, + 14, + 15, + 13, + 15, + 15, + 15, + 14, + 13, + 13, + 15, + 15, + 14, + 15, + 14, + 15, + 15, + 15, + 13, + 15, + 15, + 15, + 14 + ], + "converged": [ + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 5.639665490284418e-07, + 3.1125341409717896e-07, + 4.979931516629534e-07, + 4.6234742550705397e-07, + 3.7886484483133694e-07, + 6.222206581128675e-07, + 4.817097031077225e-07, + 4.053637205038045e-07, + 7.361105449941111e-07, + 7.005321177558042e-07, + 3.309218409626273e-07, + 7.242135918292446e-07, + 8.411630927005288e-07, + 8.580059510367425e-07, + 3.788173057958908e-07, + 9.152837297381461e-07, + 2.601636042447545e-07, + 3.96497703274806e-07, + 4.837571770226861e-07, + 5.795722359847424e-07, + 9.241847136174708e-07, + 4.331562352472973e-07, + 4.3411822057852544e-07, + 5.723542193126875e-07, + 5.361511179139874e-07, + 4.3207302800217884e-07, + 7.55673378574189e-07, + 5.611774901740796e-07, + 4.1318769705048096e-07, + 5.265230716436877e-07, + 5.42937187455063e-07, + 8.106185731703002e-07, + 3.772859452574615e-07, + 3.955540861391151e-07, + 6.014479203559437e-07, + 7.548495693811321e-07, + 4.272301994911782e-07, + 5.498549117745822e-07, + 6.717852027851726e-07, + 6.327638998718577e-07, + 9.238762268602287e-07, + 4.810858121509034e-07, + 4.893245165401034e-07, + 5.382210110077102e-07, + 9.22364543016745e-07, + 3.015198532449528e-07, + 8.723904690988921e-07, + 8.409117989898697e-07, + 6.629463668420215e-07, + 8.059900193919009e-07 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 0.03478073499900347, + 0.038991530000203056, + 0.038257113001236576, + 0.038035830000808346, + 0.03427583300072001, + 0.03263485000024957, + 0.04196078399945691, + 0.038493726000524475, + 0.03101845800119918, + 0.03806835199975467, + 0.03076216900080908, + 0.03456738100067014, + 0.03753721700013557, + 0.03937753799982602, + 0.0473371269999916, + 0.049192142998435884, + 0.03427000699957716, + 0.03532025300046371, + 0.028588702998604276, + 0.04201963100058492, + 0.03825635100110958, + 0.03858634500102198, + 0.04140680599994084, + 0.0384928729999956, + 0.05658796799980337, + 0.03446375400017132, + 0.03441537899925606, + 0.038397273998270975, + 0.0342780920000223, + 0.038586069000302814, + 0.03152580899950408, + 0.040388798999629216, + 0.038705723998646135, + 0.038461051999547635, + 0.035227598000346916, + 0.03100585699939984, + 0.030898053999408148, + 0.03838173800068034, + 0.04029357399849687, + 0.03632730699973763, + 0.038487679999889224, + 0.03460984100092901, + 0.03869059200042102, + 0.03826450900123746, + 0.03918258299927402, + 0.032041479000326945, + 0.038188476999494014, + 0.03821016999972926, + 0.03821077000065998, + 0.03750066600150603 + ], + "output_norm_ratios": [] + }, + "graph_laplacian_48": { + "iterations": [ + 15, + 14, + 15, + 13, + 14, + 15, + 16, + 15, + 15, + 13, + 15, + 14, + 14, + 13, + 14, + 14, + 14, + 14, + 14, + 15, + 14, + 15, + 14, + 14, + 12, + 15, + 15, + 15, + 13, + 15, + 14, + 15, + 14, + 14, + 15, + 14, + 15, + 14, + 15, + 14, + 13, + 14, + 15, + 14, + 12, + 13, + 15, + 12, + 13, + 14 + ], + "converged": [ + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 5.75782602346297e-07, + 7.021416979589977e-07, + 4.004324475714804e-07, + 3.236803702574098e-07, + 7.287679015807443e-07, + 3.453898709562086e-07, + 4.5291170573723867e-07, + 3.6508253656455786e-07, + 6.584914793718901e-07, + 9.969263905009098e-07, + 7.743346125416634e-07, + 4.6075405207081235e-07, + 9.925343910453046e-07, + 7.520465261680521e-07, + 7.042557061280799e-07, + 4.0362146228991843e-07, + 8.272026420258314e-07, + 5.160457320731689e-07, + 6.697198113736777e-07, + 4.0040271829401575e-07, + 6.41269831050093e-07, + 4.5238295930080185e-07, + 5.755729472661154e-07, + 5.044865657916293e-07, + 9.827663301376754e-07, + 6.794712507215882e-07, + 5.881066998860217e-07, + 6.411344015044372e-07, + 8.072582405522004e-07, + 7.474727959089767e-07, + 6.071144319615666e-07, + 5.815909989432128e-07, + 6.406124350626233e-07, + 7.08962055580993e-07, + 3.8150145616792964e-07, + 5.49685336443127e-07, + 6.262136832249233e-07, + 4.86537279969306e-07, + 5.10139336861855e-07, + 6.731872467848175e-07, + 6.72478724165684e-07, + 6.295586850216064e-07, + 5.695383507610954e-07, + 9.961449579468107e-07, + 5.857774688768741e-07, + 7.115302207455089e-07, + 4.4663520937729946e-07, + 4.97500229650269e-07, + 2.7171949626846024e-07, + 4.993435000921728e-07 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 0.03850076599883323, + 0.03493762600010086, + 0.040078945999994176, + 0.03087412199965911, + 0.03443893500116246, + 0.03946315199937089, + 0.042479359999560984, + 0.038239210000028834, + 0.04154274800021085, + 0.031349403001513565, + 0.03804942600072536, + 0.03413118899879919, + 0.034419339999658405, + 0.031011539000246557, + 0.03554878300019482, + 0.049314431998936925, + 0.03484352499981469, + 0.03454451099969447, + 0.034797345999322715, + 0.03797241300162568, + 0.03473391999978048, + 0.03785950000019511, + 0.035863443999915035, + 0.0347451750003529, + 0.02739547099918127, + 0.038115490999189205, + 0.03813252699910663, + 0.03881453999929363, + 0.03096874599941657, + 0.0396525929991185, + 0.034150912000768585, + 0.038001180000719614, + 0.033999126999333384, + 0.03536357200027851, + 0.03819605799981218, + 0.03422271800081944, + 0.04181145199981984, + 0.03420083499986504, + 0.0380803959997138, + 0.03408281000156421, + 0.030464842000583303, + 0.03426231299999927, + 0.04101363600057084, + 0.03795132799859857, + 0.03818364099970495, + 0.0316392660006386, + 0.03904377599974396, + 0.027657164999254746, + 0.03131683500032523, + 0.0343393669991201 + ], + "output_norm_ratios": [] + }, + "graph_laplacian_64": { + "iterations": [ + 13, + 15, + 15, + 15, + 14, + 15, + 11, + 15, + 14, + 14, + 15, + 15, + 13, + 15, + 16, + 14, + 15, + 14, + 14, + 13, + 12, + 15, + 15, + 14, + 13, + 13, + 16, + 13, + 12, + 13, + 13, + 14, + 15, + 15, + 14, + 12, + 14, + 13, + 14, + 14, + 14, + 13, + 14, + 14, + 13, + 14, + 14, + 13, + 15, + 15 + ], + "converged": [ + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 9.143303449321515e-07, + 6.395899512171788e-07, + 7.676830044780108e-07, + 4.1412505425968884e-07, + 6.358319014449181e-07, + 8.588795489224464e-07, + 6.807366394052386e-07, + 4.7246865997203616e-07, + 4.02847453778561e-07, + 7.024812138471397e-07, + 6.23115857365115e-07, + 6.809557396931026e-07, + 7.847180327789624e-07, + 4.021301302685496e-07, + 3.932447307543083e-07, + 7.027816310206955e-07, + 7.727219907663402e-07, + 7.181231044008859e-07, + 6.714566389692024e-07, + 3.1243897900453693e-07, + 7.374907191424175e-07, + 4.428219551202401e-07, + 5.182219639966537e-07, + 9.169181944594187e-07, + 9.390348757906263e-07, + 3.7572164868701993e-07, + 4.039081728398161e-07, + 8.668029453637514e-07, + 8.763910035842387e-07, + 3.319118579941246e-07, + 7.364343140507393e-07, + 9.065571249310246e-07, + 6.1460193452689e-07, + 5.096994483046753e-07, + 6.80378206604966e-07, + 7.554853846646904e-07, + 7.423311804647193e-07, + 7.913150539412331e-07, + 3.1733666374552523e-07, + 4.1061612301216035e-07, + 3.6629862155109527e-07, + 8.966308970781747e-07, + 8.114279143543767e-07, + 4.102952215115457e-07, + 6.105372069699232e-07, + 7.82802299956654e-07, + 7.139975757268157e-07, + 3.135084366807461e-07, + 5.936721436468854e-07, + 6.02426788433767e-07 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 0.03136474500024633, + 0.03824828799952229, + 0.03836988499824656, + 0.03835018700010551, + 0.0345157219999237, + 0.03830398799982504, + 0.024482409999109223, + 0.038178630000402336, + 0.03475327100022696, + 0.03524309199929121, + 0.038385478999771294, + 0.03832740100006049, + 0.030670295000163605, + 0.03862481900068815, + 0.04244428600031824, + 0.036294393001298886, + 0.04026423599862028, + 0.036584820998541545, + 0.03471287400134315, + 0.03135337599997001, + 0.027636422999421484, + 0.03912815700095962, + 0.03833598399978655, + 0.049402181000914425, + 0.03140122100012377, + 0.03197064999949362, + 0.04303047299981699, + 0.031383192999783205, + 0.027773302999776206, + 0.03128031699998246, + 0.03100238899969554, + 0.035177617999579525, + 0.03938294600084191, + 0.037915730999884545, + 0.03428258200074197, + 0.027865979000125662, + 0.03466445699996257, + 0.031937641000695294, + 0.034982430001036846, + 0.034389986998576205, + 0.03410876099951565, + 0.031037528000524617, + 0.03444089600088773, + 0.03442023599927779, + 0.033731506000549416, + 0.03517780699985451, + 0.03526337200128182, + 0.03168610600005195, + 0.038235623000218766, + 0.038120733999676304 + ], + "output_norm_ratios": [] + } + } + }, + { + "name": "Jacobi", + "param_count": 0, + "train_time": 0.0, + "train_history": [], + "best_loss": null, + "best_epoch": null, + "eval": { + "diffusion_16": { + "iterations": [ + 60, + 59, + 63, + 61, + 60, + 60, + 60, + 73, + 59, + 64, + 65, + 67, + 52, + 64, + 66, + 57, + 63, + 76, + 62, + 57, + 64, + 68, + 65, + 64, + 59, + 63, + 57, + 66, + 65, + 58, + 63, + 64, + 64, + 63, + 72, + 58, + 67, + 66, + 73, + 65, + 66, + 69, + 59, + 64, + 58, + 60, + 62, + 59, + 62, + 63 + ], + "converged": [ + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 6.708087056156708e-07, + 8.465346642056083e-07, + 8.153396518224927e-07, + 9.56538750122392e-07, + 9.395300106666676e-07, + 8.597030650544497e-07, + 8.414893775889283e-07, + 9.456357859313334e-07, + 8.934342399704001e-07, + 8.745752521002488e-07, + 8.319318985914743e-07, + 8.311591854393603e-07, + 9.138452434974226e-07, + 9.359629541969526e-07, + 7.840423403509742e-07, + 9.05997687993306e-07, + 8.005286913954178e-07, + 9.850331115899587e-07, + 9.987194780191872e-07, + 7.402039988368571e-07, + 8.933180466349121e-07, + 9.096472036387135e-07, + 7.775313980144254e-07, + 9.76999057267262e-07, + 9.789375721610366e-07, + 9.542793928881982e-07, + 9.859474051257982e-07, + 7.743853237603085e-07, + 8.710664930047283e-07, + 9.517623443256831e-07, + 8.908199770099592e-07, + 9.674541413699436e-07, + 8.949319953654445e-07, + 8.732202948182601e-07, + 9.015577156967966e-07, + 9.795418450174831e-07, + 9.761913149385656e-07, + 9.892311774130763e-07, + 9.771212852332817e-07, + 7.67122454510306e-07, + 8.577457335808811e-07, + 9.734599923316441e-07, + 7.660751997512525e-07, + 9.73713975354029e-07, + 8.982218427033723e-07, + 8.761419291553662e-07, + 8.863785286353747e-07, + 9.271404074247394e-07, + 7.934103367333988e-07, + 8.091612246879517e-07 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 0.2382404370000586, + 0.2304471490006108, + 0.2407349550003346, + 0.24921425399952568, + 0.2341359720003311, + 0.24417244699998264, + 0.23676373199941736, + 0.27710632300022553, + 0.22520870799962722, + 0.24259434199939278, + 0.24131989800025622, + 0.26089147300081095, + 0.18705111700000998, + 0.24387051399935444, + 0.24247207999997045, + 0.21109189500020875, + 0.2509341510003651, + 0.27535553899997467, + 0.23680651700033195, + 0.21133764299975155, + 0.25463581400072144, + 0.24867641299988463, + 0.2402797240001746, + 0.23783712500062393, + 0.23904810499971063, + 0.2472058969997306, + 0.24415937599951576, + 0.2407873819993256, + 0.24088020399995003, + 0.31282674000067345, + 0.3380082620005851, + 0.331492337999407, + 0.3437757589999819, + 0.3394057250006881, + 0.43847157999971387, + 0.23626469999999244, + 0.24499266099974193, + 0.24046744399947784, + 0.26373440099996515, + 0.2564993089999916, + 0.24186910000025819, + 0.2504341409994595, + 0.23024367099969822, + 0.2570360139998229, + 0.22256539999943925, + 0.23397790099988924, + 0.23992445900057646, + 0.22885750899968116, + 0.24461822000012035, + 0.23588690500037046 + ], + "output_norm_ratios": [ + 6.967227637905316, + 7.10027753411477, + 6.4400567728062175, + 7.081447799316392, + 5.874671075724635, + 11.563352146892008, + 6.560023517055922, + 8.895654654141131, + 11.975848969395374, + 11.448280453013211, + 8.207268970319255, + 8.489541561168405, + 7.671626909539859, + 8.305099219125841, + 7.024519287929774, + 9.253752038767955, + 7.608342366124599, + 12.078196176975975, + 7.347508935296049, + 9.305806618307075, + 6.0837517219055925, + 7.277983457590531, + 7.512671467491361, + 5.629792203297014, + 4.7533909496693125, + 4.22981740215172, + 6.7459664203458445, + 7.676653739708354, + 6.13913004679981, + 6.504802869093137, + 9.365393799771649, + 5.169124183356564, + 8.114147863649332, + 12.549743928778385, + 14.582015878556835, + 9.23834013052269, + 6.509665368220364, + 7.47783123220339, + 9.038186333486884, + 9.40571855568934, + 6.888820243475793, + 9.303453815418724, + 6.678022111580343, + 7.97773827102028, + 6.245628836137066, + 7.8358247763457385, + 14.65426359982364, + 5.804618134821111, + 9.890803050144179, + 7.366868311617709 + ] + }, + "diffusion_24": { + "iterations": [ + 107, + 102, + 90, + 85, + 104, + 120, + 96, + 106, + 77, + 96, + 98, + 117, + 86, + 86, + 88, + 116, + 106, + 106, + 107, + 83, + 108, + 104, + 116, + 89, + 93, + 94, + 95, + 109, + 114, + 88, + 85, + 103, + 125, + 90, + 97, + 100, + 86, + 98, + 115, + 100, + 95, + 108, + 104, + 118, + 102, + 94, + 98, + 104, + 93, + 98 + ], + "converged": [ + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 9.501697865132222e-07, + 9.685828753786542e-07, + 9.712296120537103e-07, + 9.777959892397187e-07, + 9.099849157810618e-07, + 9.527324538859602e-07, + 9.397230171258985e-07, + 9.645750934262094e-07, + 9.688656301315734e-07, + 9.401428154044555e-07, + 9.974144310990905e-07, + 9.013611045024532e-07, + 9.115632145693658e-07, + 9.279744327232098e-07, + 9.463440561280153e-07, + 9.740388449777733e-07, + 8.956768495828546e-07, + 9.889183548465864e-07, + 9.664545743571749e-07, + 9.405415101910002e-07, + 9.228517035753113e-07, + 9.772402518603855e-07, + 9.419192106278994e-07, + 8.524890387248466e-07, + 9.434436717152893e-07, + 9.788354946962626e-07, + 9.146913765374172e-07, + 9.354338163843157e-07, + 9.275691266042271e-07, + 9.099230170364651e-07, + 9.26491690234139e-07, + 9.759316874411817e-07, + 9.786922196558249e-07, + 9.415560252780729e-07, + 9.596378893054994e-07, + 8.541471661801306e-07, + 9.469683243373322e-07, + 9.469846797452139e-07, + 9.535179867394463e-07, + 9.32641971122504e-07, + 9.402595091774319e-07, + 9.074277679990606e-07, + 9.266935075080868e-07, + 8.789584740649936e-07, + 9.231513239114836e-07, + 9.90260874762869e-07, + 9.516958950595354e-07, + 9.929716783821423e-07, + 9.354029977203842e-07, + 9.68080763950362e-07 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 0.4094641289993888, + 0.3823158129998774, + 0.35048656900107744, + 0.3292491490010434, + 0.5476792650006246, + 0.6533463550003944, + 0.5087331979993905, + 0.5479036050001014, + 0.2765391709999676, + 0.35732606100100384, + 0.3827732979989378, + 0.44473836299948744, + 0.33692467199944076, + 0.3274080440005491, + 0.334970586000054, + 0.4544281549988227, + 0.3953571299989562, + 0.3867577380005969, + 0.4399029310006881, + 0.32507408399942506, + 0.41662159300176427, + 0.38770689999910246, + 0.43690028300079575, + 0.3645636019991798, + 0.35629792700092366, + 0.3525833269995928, + 0.3707229110004846, + 0.4033987379989412, + 0.44978921599977184, + 0.3349935829992319, + 0.3209688120005012, + 0.4000875570000062, + 0.499912019000476, + 0.4150448589989537, + 0.5225255220011604, + 0.5155104170007689, + 0.46592599699943094, + 0.5088143009998021, + 0.4470760659987718, + 0.3688329179985885, + 0.3737369239988766, + 0.3951220210001338, + 0.3849151670001447, + 0.4643023170010565, + 0.3746651169985853, + 0.3710694279998279, + 0.36382577999938803, + 0.38125511600082973, + 0.3699569909986167, + 0.36159944100108987 + ], + "output_norm_ratios": [ + 9.76589090990125, + 7.4432479753659, + 8.162999455070862, + 7.847160673476506, + 11.423652085904275, + 10.025735838576237, + 6.232990830570206, + 5.007107622077026, + 10.326950610859548, + 11.729635982020532, + 9.146672680602794, + 10.532377539631867, + 13.088334092653055, + 9.309611855011697, + 7.898857571638986, + 14.565589209168085, + 9.793482252784191, + 4.636983137694426, + 7.54594280317989, + 7.756685511339, + 9.335292998551532, + 9.271174378101323, + 8.798345382638693, + 8.319677122885366, + 7.757636422372387, + 11.01360980360764, + 4.8703022528085915, + 6.065726159960549, + 8.894407615719713, + 11.306932626333847, + 8.631742075409255, + 8.439507490092412, + 15.400856527017773, + 5.471188529039265, + 9.272785082161347, + 9.193507152987763, + 6.9274900923123655, + 8.044326818317652, + 4.58843574829277, + 9.568355289082664, + 7.154613806235157, + 11.358192308360813, + 6.547219558148808, + 13.44459455142369, + 10.59007189971037, + 9.130954097429845, + 9.823493864741836, + 7.651705299671155, + 15.11781266402745, + 7.3956830734540695 + ] + }, + "diffusion_32": { + "iterations": [ + 129, + 118, + 127, + 131, + 132, + 143, + 136, + 136, + 118, + 137, + 135, + 122, + 145, + 143, + 128, + 135, + 129, + 137, + 114, + 136, + 137, + 139, + 135, + 142, + 137, + 152, + 139, + 133, + 170, + 169, + 183, + 131, + 142, + 146, + 160, + 147, + 154, + 138, + 133, + 118, + 145, + 119, + 120, + 150, + 123, + 128, + 130, + 109, + 133, + 160 + ], + "converged": [ + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 9.517849306736912e-07, + 9.76450743334652e-07, + 9.347284533956831e-07, + 9.531470926246117e-07, + 9.66588220708983e-07, + 9.963090213463523e-07, + 9.859098078343737e-07, + 9.681439561309772e-07, + 9.81840209053851e-07, + 9.179072029554439e-07, + 9.953417450712125e-07, + 9.663080915508331e-07, + 9.637097305413406e-07, + 9.615892296841752e-07, + 9.831823791345689e-07, + 9.57645190414829e-07, + 9.844300190379911e-07, + 9.644836031561537e-07, + 9.958224938831998e-07, + 9.10312187802261e-07, + 9.365116093090341e-07, + 9.474211046049241e-07, + 9.533813139005747e-07, + 9.246252848219496e-07, + 9.78399039929858e-07, + 9.585945534962318e-07, + 9.543722072611943e-07, + 9.149345098814469e-07, + 9.555534031950686e-07, + 8.698239584435297e-07, + 9.335061811623439e-07, + 9.159340485989339e-07, + 9.983429013021842e-07, + 9.611745894992502e-07, + 9.377585295112028e-07, + 9.65724272182156e-07, + 9.719704179056168e-07, + 9.797803985652646e-07, + 9.553140815383484e-07, + 9.522108641282039e-07, + 9.613885343350845e-07, + 9.561388263933097e-07, + 9.112619133730419e-07, + 9.835946256534267e-07, + 9.73557730325566e-07, + 9.890575328700702e-07, + 9.773930925193746e-07, + 9.914967764881638e-07, + 9.427363868363468e-07, + 9.781966241837408e-07 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 0.5021019310006523, + 0.47760850899976504, + 0.49100611799985927, + 0.5153446610001993, + 0.5073108619999402, + 0.6496289990009245, + 0.7512874290005129, + 0.7490372680003929, + 0.5859191149993421, + 0.5460193330000038, + 0.5319520409993856, + 0.4813614710001275, + 0.5807940569993661, + 0.5671985040007712, + 0.5002496189990779, + 0.525063451999813, + 0.4984408820000681, + 0.5305534849994729, + 0.4393223380011477, + 0.5183963660001609, + 0.540321184998902, + 0.5284623999996256, + 0.5275871059984638, + 0.5516875970006367, + 0.5209973840010207, + 0.6100234759996965, + 0.533488455999759, + 0.7066057239990187, + 0.9398744259997329, + 0.8689663049990486, + 0.7224823599990486, + 0.5167360439991171, + 0.5465183500000421, + 0.5860998579992156, + 0.6105421270003717, + 0.58679722800116, + 0.6470485400004691, + 0.5277056570012064, + 0.525499146000584, + 0.45880001700061257, + 0.5811985780001123, + 0.4650798999991821, + 0.492849162001221, + 0.5920465270010027, + 0.49740471000041, + 0.4879996810013836, + 0.5134539720002067, + 0.4615643850011111, + 0.7311872279988165, + 0.8941806559996621 + ], + "output_norm_ratios": [ + 9.245007081087838, + 10.420930645397226, + 9.218304781709755, + 5.357500330171955, + 10.446684555695965, + 10.766349994945466, + 11.480247080405457, + 12.17762426635762, + 8.002273573272623, + 11.08664669139037, + 6.62611533086512, + 12.861159001419555, + 6.117233143697796, + 8.503544345617472, + 12.482437812972513, + 14.003570735946337, + 6.501859851606862, + 10.778545460712966, + 6.810052782707888, + 9.502206489676409, + 8.258357729870145, + 6.796385169432162, + 7.548642943744241, + 8.370664808838379, + 13.685488094436897, + 9.353120158273333, + 6.368480489718611, + 7.548309734772438, + 6.451631873254017, + 11.981635649451905, + 6.657730584834446, + 7.269838641226336, + 8.028375212528346, + 10.082217781376865, + 8.425151492761055, + 6.896082492666248, + 17.305219927872347, + 5.533544499707085, + 10.296865723718424, + 12.951493197641565, + 8.100339824018615, + 6.732179517927381, + 19.913425058041177, + 12.071445263289515, + 11.303877429039774, + 7.286497603158904, + 12.702556514993343, + 8.716127436962388, + 12.34812587985495, + 8.643356345224815 + ] + }, + "diffusion_48": { + "iterations": [ + 285, + 224, + 233, + 211, + 230, + 262, + 203, + 212, + 220, + 205, + 200, + 290, + 231, + 207, + 294, + 198, + 215, + 257, + 251, + 187, + 221, + 234, + 204, + 240, + 229, + 226, + 199, + 218, + 229, + 224, + 203, + 205, + 247, + 283, + 217, + 247, + 218, + 206, + 229, + 225, + 192, + 230, + 231, + 267, + 242, + 235, + 215, + 182, + 244, + 256 + ], + "converged": [ + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 9.468050502199151e-07, + 9.535663763056784e-07, + 9.89018884997692e-07, + 9.808417293487218e-07, + 9.254862773073119e-07, + 9.949994253167123e-07, + 9.790582988847899e-07, + 9.996152207413316e-07, + 9.600503687411465e-07, + 9.965463030519232e-07, + 9.729495975119089e-07, + 9.912832538911221e-07, + 9.93158410048726e-07, + 9.352726990304269e-07, + 9.74869145669434e-07, + 9.438928894379118e-07, + 9.846995550904767e-07, + 9.722425299742427e-07, + 9.54215010723293e-07, + 9.151486530587044e-07, + 9.425719189873144e-07, + 9.615924767502023e-07, + 9.785476601853976e-07, + 9.632205018475144e-07, + 9.710309835964765e-07, + 9.77300806138883e-07, + 9.965706294611264e-07, + 9.637701004001171e-07, + 9.979903405002428e-07, + 9.819972838133952e-07, + 9.020078316742197e-07, + 9.64151783923574e-07, + 9.97061988141616e-07, + 9.692444479301175e-07, + 9.764963712201874e-07, + 9.633923367589336e-07, + 9.964396035753214e-07, + 9.634501306846996e-07, + 9.953585739234368e-07, + 9.813112340879433e-07, + 9.624229962430968e-07, + 9.637899616886032e-07, + 9.607103618115266e-07, + 9.89808554350096e-07, + 9.65834785408157e-07, + 9.70501043460974e-07, + 9.695398386358817e-07, + 9.799373414913477e-07, + 9.326814109511191e-07, + 9.715638854582216e-07 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 1.1290789880004013, + 0.8830719310008135, + 0.9284918470002594, + 0.8536231399993994, + 0.9124934620012937, + 1.0416067019996262, + 0.8071715480000421, + 0.8432255309999164, + 1.1431842089987185, + 1.1916566510008124, + 0.7819243200010533, + 1.1594091369988746, + 0.9171511170006852, + 0.8321205810007086, + 1.1725573260009696, + 0.7835148609992757, + 0.862570739000148, + 1.021739140000136, + 0.9933533530002023, + 0.7446479869995528, + 0.9665824410003552, + 1.326984667999568, + 0.9851252190001105, + 0.9746162480005296, + 0.903461605999837, + 0.8830166699990514, + 0.788922891000766, + 0.8951530969989108, + 0.9018533730013587, + 0.8976790480010095, + 0.816077655999834, + 0.8082899740002176, + 0.982938639999702, + 1.3723437959997682, + 1.2438368549992447, + 0.9875166889996763, + 0.8613436719988385, + 0.8117914499998733, + 0.9076711170000635, + 0.8847498129998712, + 0.7576800429997093, + 0.904640003998793, + 0.9203879899996537, + 1.0724773809997714, + 0.9732219990000885, + 0.9365778639985365, + 1.225385024001298, + 1.0004922640000586, + 0.9702080679999199, + 1.0073130180007865 + ], + "output_norm_ratios": [ + 13.791299800531329, + 9.877155674437123, + 10.365126566611922, + 10.597671810274248, + 10.19834261176676, + 10.713316955492258, + 10.077119721194931, + 7.398960677104313, + 12.516525820271507, + 9.295259659734809, + 11.84275642229812, + 13.49932545659748, + 7.859882027803666, + 9.700101700707865, + 6.311424705143364, + 10.66015230724396, + 12.655028839861599, + 10.09070821754657, + 5.674572162302369, + 13.173320963126887, + 6.194515334667959, + 8.238732763419229, + 16.328984278418616, + 8.743551937145456, + 9.782512592827606, + 8.041758204586452, + 6.9580805943313875, + 11.060602534161447, + 8.837647565941241, + 10.74626859362496, + 8.845404291178207, + 12.58843636210563, + 10.510716146021633, + 10.62409140426333, + 10.983190280898299, + 12.867342485491776, + 11.5407851503084, + 10.434300398483506, + 10.322092171627794, + 12.43192210970838, + 10.129115382654147, + 10.119299602149667, + 10.606207227116485, + 7.61870974402955, + 12.663502459394985, + 6.088093880584576, + 13.575947821269974, + 8.787585704780065, + 7.634285581306088, + 8.571918780243804 + ] + }, + "diffusion_64": { + "iterations": [ + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 288, + 300, + 278, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 248, + 300, + 300, + 292, + 259, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 298, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 295, + 300, + 300, + 300 + ], + "converged": [ + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + true, + false, + true, + false, + false, + false, + true, + false, + false, + true, + true, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + true, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + true, + false, + false, + false, + true, + false, + false, + false + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 7.295290300768497e-06, + 7.252795964937657e-06, + 2.3755149248276388e-05, + 1.2925362781439886e-06, + 1.5886779814830192e-05, + 8.932687342164337e-06, + 9.874988145547932e-07, + 1.8961144408703187e-06, + 9.68516497491947e-07, + 1.4770300899776787e-06, + 1.400743289201009e-05, + 4.061310928852981e-06, + 9.564107495984705e-07, + 2.0132274616865472e-05, + 7.819931105464509e-06, + 9.373334834130015e-07, + 9.874092326481821e-07, + 1.0480239847838855e-05, + 8.768126455647906e-06, + 6.18595251866626e-06, + 1.6184139987460003e-06, + 2.6165480945055995e-06, + 5.325258974459078e-06, + 1.825223896073355e-05, + 1.015273539218147e-05, + 1.403630771179842e-06, + 3.0544334809360797e-06, + 9.962388518239654e-07, + 1.2261621161382485e-06, + 2.2243506510654532e-05, + 1.3446642998934912e-05, + 3.9371222612701974e-05, + 2.180573050519229e-06, + 2.6068227294940107e-06, + 1.6198633798899502e-05, + 7.253628587261591e-06, + 2.597946405728911e-06, + 8.519803253897881e-06, + 6.449517567909209e-06, + 4.016980996337626e-06, + 6.720815678947344e-06, + 1.4215963420130936e-06, + 9.591054126643802e-07, + 3.989686508664752e-06, + 5.498955981008125e-06, + 3.206815706928853e-06, + 9.999973108645584e-07, + 2.634791180511865e-06, + 1.8521290631581329e-06, + 3.3459609862282135e-06 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 1.2187576039996202, + 1.2151507589987887, + 1.2337670899996738, + 1.2302638979999756, + 1.2152853819989105, + 1.2171133199990436, + 1.3903786989994842, + 1.6077568270011398, + 1.1036725530011608, + 1.206801820999317, + 1.2131415519997972, + 1.2019538929998816, + 0.9885081840002385, + 1.220493296001223, + 1.205842938999922, + 1.1754390740006784, + 1.3326334770008543, + 1.5342722130008042, + 1.2098216810009035, + 1.2095399089994316, + 1.2150341550004669, + 1.2104354890016111, + 1.2302503379996779, + 1.2241011940004682, + 1.2043255650005449, + 1.3547450120004214, + 1.7315312890004861, + 1.206875965999643, + 1.213765290000083, + 1.2088814659982745, + 1.212175758999365, + 1.2249233980001009, + 1.2056852229998185, + 1.2138812220000545, + 1.2113387970002805, + 1.636803647999841, + 1.4384891480003716, + 1.2106277359998785, + 1.2168197089995374, + 1.2232970010009012, + 1.21591407500091, + 1.2177715510006237, + 1.19760849100021, + 1.2117345060014486, + 1.5189332989994, + 1.5721045279988175, + 1.1803386219999084, + 1.2269444849989668, + 1.2070772320003016, + 1.2087403519999498 + ], + "output_norm_ratios": [ + 10.501857854959544, + 12.077572505687346, + 6.409999853809439, + 7.531232318299778, + 8.001431216464635, + 10.750520124894331, + 11.160927070442197, + 9.725624686617302, + 12.236874292501335, + 10.489011059336043, + 8.906769503435546, + 5.070229403068458, + 12.826521125593898, + 14.083552571681059, + 11.77938492147393, + 9.846723923881655, + 14.717424378650318, + 8.641907034684078, + 7.074261324463813, + 11.01459752959797, + 10.359655405857314, + 15.367553179738517, + 7.180905734132778, + 10.415213919797605, + 13.005482804672386, + 10.56982422361067, + 14.126010361003646, + 10.711276459782813, + 6.097940699218328, + 12.35664954349768, + 13.897023914927823, + 8.480973641670028, + 15.109311258904569, + 11.079892247882123, + 10.993523990667919, + 10.134546054177356, + 15.411119167241118, + 7.568300049517873, + 10.819960725845094, + 11.754225127893786, + 14.389098765002515, + 10.96757884390982, + 5.817013728551479, + 10.748532092936015, + 12.737349811727906, + 8.290240735562975, + 15.519773128360207, + 12.147555058431301, + 18.84690174267057, + 9.192539080051201 + ] + }, + "advection_16": { + "iterations": [ + 58, + 56, + 64, + 64, + 62, + 63, + 60, + 64, + 64, + 58, + 63, + 64, + 58, + 65, + 60, + 61, + 68, + 61, + 62, + 61, + 63, + 59, + 61, + 65, + 65, + 66, + 60, + 64, + 64, + 62, + 62, + 69, + 67, + 67, + 59, + 65, + 61, + 64, + 66, + 64, + 60, + 67, + 63, + 62, + 59, + 62, + 66, + 97, + 60, + 58 + ], + "converged": [ + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 9.747805160943353e-07, + 8.589612591641845e-07, + 9.84311523830725e-07, + 6.960103764180435e-07, + 8.900772344180331e-07, + 7.848827589133337e-07, + 8.782433344857955e-07, + 9.166989162287348e-07, + 8.120759460864274e-07, + 9.172392020493132e-07, + 9.396270584729626e-07, + 9.183931911281383e-07, + 9.81569121648975e-07, + 7.572728129044242e-07, + 8.593318840653774e-07, + 9.165348802512384e-07, + 9.012947232075914e-07, + 8.280172330295364e-07, + 9.191513003607558e-07, + 9.986806844149963e-07, + 7.871968915938522e-07, + 8.443424249867973e-07, + 9.884557847638912e-07, + 8.769568607340356e-07, + 9.246208023535894e-07, + 9.962263804294098e-07, + 7.45218673310969e-07, + 9.011613743585008e-07, + 9.26904003456654e-07, + 8.495074889318459e-07, + 9.501551530477564e-07, + 9.569607300336123e-07, + 8.879552256636383e-07, + 8.748674924822433e-07, + 7.964230126741289e-07, + 9.405642334908502e-07, + 9.408092743088308e-07, + 9.248049881615509e-07, + 9.836358395303374e-07, + 8.772672464881193e-07, + 7.843105859716264e-07, + 9.66720469979227e-07, + 9.56381407492424e-07, + 9.187238899130315e-07, + 8.893315603236225e-07, + 8.526483909357243e-07, + 9.490963855350434e-07, + 9.798978683104135e-07, + 8.904336021005978e-07, + 7.83941030938223e-07 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 0.2285347199995158, + 0.2082261239993386, + 0.2676788810003927, + 0.24137931000041135, + 0.23260153099909076, + 0.23479451300045184, + 0.2501547339998069, + 0.23749179399965215, + 0.23817865300043195, + 0.22106714800065674, + 0.24206447600045067, + 0.25462566600072023, + 0.21892598399972485, + 0.24163326300003973, + 0.23839864600086003, + 0.24869574399963312, + 0.2486231590009993, + 0.23310522099927766, + 0.23939080600030138, + 0.2521053939999547, + 0.2616144260009605, + 0.22836658599953807, + 0.2371189500008768, + 0.2554926129996602, + 0.23956184599956032, + 0.2412274790003721, + 0.23749135799880605, + 0.2414695400002529, + 0.25053453199871, + 0.23596951400031685, + 0.23503050799990888, + 0.25745586799894227, + 0.25809799099988595, + 0.24243322599977546, + 0.2254306489994633, + 0.24548946899994917, + 0.3250734939992981, + 0.33852555100020254, + 0.3389783330003411, + 0.34156391999931657, + 0.3330653089997213, + 0.39247399600026256, + 0.2612082489995373, + 0.2343820739988587, + 0.2265593619995343, + 0.2385877930009883, + 0.24196602200026973, + 0.3727752649992908, + 0.23775390799892193, + 0.22365483199973824 + ], + "output_norm_ratios": [ + 6.4759235390879635, + 7.050078585624961, + 10.230128205047123, + 10.458480418515382, + 8.529318201007172, + 21.135656768215444, + 7.077799734770263, + 10.954668559109482, + 6.941508020848393, + 12.41959106299626, + 6.12056593347812, + 7.1685644045917964, + 7.548066854826598, + 7.810201944783081, + 6.9841757207455935, + 5.726744549106467, + 7.7776336286117544, + 8.115201371167098, + 7.762755579466631, + 7.524980461490008, + 10.678244958391645, + 7.383531045517014, + 4.680088390496937, + 6.03317125270962, + 6.121127741457319, + 8.547494555923166, + 8.368051372177792, + 9.346588819157784, + 7.294586637850362, + 9.12194485543305, + 10.01658013078006, + 13.208971166234587, + 8.879350742006253, + 6.472914478089822, + 14.316905772475668, + 8.807652010675957, + 9.23807538171132, + 6.702472416988411, + 7.597974926954049, + 6.906843896888243, + 12.444627646584676, + 16.245864427294993, + 7.348860171894624, + 7.7827797532679766, + 7.384955259746656, + 8.90212597986889, + 6.948035346546398, + 11.767145750989382, + 4.596313993975691, + 5.765013702671163 + ] + }, + "advection_24": { + "iterations": [ + 121, + 81, + 103, + 112, + 86, + 115, + 104, + 118, + 102, + 98, + 111, + 86, + 102, + 129, + 102, + 100, + 97, + 94, + 86, + 106, + 120, + 85, + 112, + 105, + 85, + 118, + 110, + 83, + 102, + 106, + 119, + 85, + 117, + 102, + 110, + 110, + 76, + 85, + 119, + 119, + 96, + 94, + 96, + 112, + 100, + 94, + 96, + 90, + 97, + 97 + ], + "converged": [ + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 9.053510776709886e-07, + 9.69770350802769e-07, + 8.968645116735367e-07, + 9.851215369664518e-07, + 9.817700987635678e-07, + 9.550062302312814e-07, + 9.414667834058235e-07, + 8.915902955234817e-07, + 9.274074881063806e-07, + 9.257704707072754e-07, + 9.605106128935987e-07, + 9.785171313273556e-07, + 8.366077879805575e-07, + 9.553225224987685e-07, + 9.328129516467429e-07, + 8.390308938731497e-07, + 9.327845701447541e-07, + 8.811245435803433e-07, + 9.66954875791938e-07, + 9.744457703901046e-07, + 8.859670746838381e-07, + 8.798802087397128e-07, + 9.319902997906739e-07, + 8.836287563224386e-07, + 8.886526491295116e-07, + 9.953036934959412e-07, + 9.198096489630791e-07, + 9.93761126357333e-07, + 9.783683605483488e-07, + 9.757409104086811e-07, + 9.251220741276488e-07, + 9.811291984450536e-07, + 8.905923621540658e-07, + 9.481421575739329e-07, + 9.509712644578228e-07, + 9.991262211565264e-07, + 9.482844505397205e-07, + 8.724576832314922e-07, + 8.959588872297806e-07, + 9.534974761571315e-07, + 9.639071742933893e-07, + 9.614743317554564e-07, + 9.288849164623494e-07, + 9.421417299682168e-07, + 9.59107334541504e-07, + 9.75543278506301e-07, + 9.887947757464638e-07, + 9.69645557027328e-07, + 9.500240829354157e-07, + 9.841260420092012e-07 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 0.4742964699998993, + 0.31588693400044576, + 0.3871222609996039, + 0.42093927600035386, + 0.3794757169998775, + 0.6366548059995694, + 0.5439393579999887, + 0.7013216169998486, + 0.40050517300005595, + 0.3644972759993834, + 0.4307887169998139, + 0.3281574240008922, + 0.37841050299903145, + 0.5050054210005328, + 0.3760418990004837, + 0.38897904899931746, + 0.36469899999974587, + 0.3605111829983798, + 0.3411069060002774, + 0.3911383409995324, + 0.4723202400000446, + 0.33534771599988744, + 0.4242915940012608, + 0.4025897659994371, + 0.34644071699949563, + 0.4585360799992486, + 0.4241430149995722, + 0.31466027200076496, + 0.3788835189989186, + 0.4067914999995992, + 0.46454785599962634, + 0.3340491840008326, + 0.44917155599978287, + 0.48874070899910294, + 0.5735259020002559, + 0.5815626699986751, + 0.4320124580008269, + 0.3821814369985077, + 0.4765820859993255, + 0.4636773220008763, + 0.3753336459994898, + 0.35916655300025013, + 0.36337660899880575, + 0.43520541799989587, + 0.37467665999975, + 0.3589194169999246, + 0.37897871200038935, + 0.35152699899845175, + 0.3786068689987587, + 0.36698924400116084 + ], + "output_norm_ratios": [ + 12.863410722498006, + 6.749977165190325, + 8.990481141702233, + 7.008994326146989, + 6.699714431666602, + 10.481130826819255, + 7.60006702637575, + 8.954268353898614, + 8.338243720332208, + 10.55818830969443, + 9.733536923992094, + 13.863720294277345, + 12.057761182730427, + 9.35545938994341, + 10.478360172520189, + 8.188625263337151, + 8.632060578455206, + 11.206548649053946, + 15.198431258743511, + 12.423962035525296, + 7.371353604330475, + 6.073351291613152, + 10.311008796527409, + 12.741379559412795, + 10.188334098554733, + 9.818452768178819, + 3.827898471759428, + 7.321435384664707, + 12.65835025798246, + 7.407230093795075, + 7.3604670934216445, + 6.8518524967092755, + 7.576143031774765, + 12.538085102457135, + 6.672170803191296, + 9.20401009677562, + 8.91129636865925, + 11.038736198251893, + 7.856220516030114, + 11.77571716490705, + 15.672793499201012, + 8.93307067703183, + 8.808856625127637, + 7.831605236890044, + 9.17176692816013, + 11.071083267037165, + 7.73413098249488, + 10.601320056196535, + 9.806346916509142, + 9.732652779662711 + ] + }, + "advection_32": { + "iterations": [ + 123, + 159, + 116, + 120, + 151, + 160, + 132, + 152, + 143, + 126, + 135, + 112, + 142, + 123, + 146, + 127, + 121, + 131, + 128, + 129, + 136, + 144, + 140, + 148, + 134, + 160, + 142, + 120, + 122, + 166, + 137, + 140, + 136, + 117, + 130, + 161, + 141, + 128, + 131, + 132, + 121, + 136, + 148, + 151, + 161, + 160, + 153, + 140, + 125, + 143 + ], + "converged": [ + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 9.564376342622215e-07, + 9.264832177066614e-07, + 8.931818302633677e-07, + 8.70908887541123e-07, + 9.919435726274912e-07, + 9.174821975084867e-07, + 9.95675963833794e-07, + 9.535528494477154e-07, + 9.7711666816962e-07, + 9.78455577909511e-07, + 9.88862497920881e-07, + 9.71562982350827e-07, + 9.226603023922492e-07, + 9.357165502335231e-07, + 9.716257626638473e-07, + 9.29275300813107e-07, + 9.935337496500898e-07, + 9.438689202154298e-07, + 8.874531723870958e-07, + 9.765495128453367e-07, + 9.828483795185476e-07, + 9.996047063687188e-07, + 9.798116139135115e-07, + 9.733844178609376e-07, + 9.709298941138718e-07, + 9.845675213690727e-07, + 9.684204399441989e-07, + 8.559407542090664e-07, + 9.600635362251231e-07, + 9.647224122771331e-07, + 9.561135371279813e-07, + 9.729330896107013e-07, + 9.663179342608667e-07, + 8.911961052293028e-07, + 9.200132120071254e-07, + 9.300866230730043e-07, + 9.371892842957929e-07, + 9.140889450328458e-07, + 9.272681751707775e-07, + 9.311795987280017e-07, + 9.139642576184463e-07, + 9.667204266806947e-07, + 9.401491422646504e-07, + 9.71753701187276e-07, + 9.83660474464885e-07, + 9.58004331455201e-07, + 9.525344328192789e-07, + 9.692030158736677e-07, + 9.925659044930503e-07, + 9.864173163490567e-07 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 0.5022041110005375, + 0.6227814929989108, + 0.551935075000074, + 0.6979277659993386, + 0.8595312729994475, + 0.7215107459996943, + 0.5293876820014702, + 0.5990870589994302, + 0.5709200940000301, + 0.5219782580006722, + 0.5342486170011398, + 0.437197584000387, + 0.5774910189993534, + 0.5226346130002639, + 0.6065159400004632, + 0.5050893389998237, + 0.497085907998553, + 0.5071206340016943, + 0.5164609319999727, + 0.5120048389999283, + 0.5426784200008115, + 0.5806306949998543, + 0.5550798429994757, + 0.7022356640009093, + 0.719951619999847, + 0.9217260759996861, + 0.5905160349993821, + 0.5090047289995709, + 0.4950164540005062, + 0.6425469840014557, + 0.536156905000098, + 0.537191740999333, + 0.5369302060007612, + 0.4555701469998894, + 0.517949121998754, + 0.6165844450006261, + 0.5642614160005905, + 0.4921317190000991, + 0.5162078089997522, + 0.5131385439999576, + 0.4950522199997067, + 0.5201784810014942, + 0.5992321319990879, + 0.6112993550013925, + 0.7771594130008452, + 0.8650880229997711, + 0.863397855000585, + 0.5383497120001266, + 0.5013419689985312, + 0.5555610560004425 + ], + "output_norm_ratios": [ + 8.598106370356764, + 8.59419805414639, + 8.010659516379848, + 10.88298214579223, + 8.179757463016717, + 9.140140527824045, + 14.523993783735795, + 10.987600912837935, + 12.126976519811322, + 8.690660398173963, + 12.478267878621843, + 6.5695736252466155, + 10.203994120031638, + 8.709400463226055, + 8.44668388095633, + 9.783644017997073, + 8.046120864059121, + 12.438666758936154, + 9.40710190041781, + 11.986373678708286, + 9.955606466144806, + 6.609462475887277, + 10.448818943244698, + 12.321998030016225, + 8.5241026806424, + 11.156798825849538, + 8.961499671394735, + 9.085382844056506, + 8.096047215115815, + 8.447764385107332, + 4.52908829253338, + 11.71345938335588, + 8.384667889368231, + 7.046773782804806, + 6.514712179075287, + 8.469765123976872, + 9.813070819162666, + 6.585575318963789, + 12.608466557380417, + 6.939492743893966, + 10.548909102560577, + 12.067045389217752, + 9.851657377131172, + 4.5334432550451496, + 15.928172829635349, + 7.348897086068952, + 9.532997715597222, + 8.164837757147401, + 10.267312977075566, + 7.598192891542616 + ] + }, + "advection_48": { + "iterations": [ + 218, + 233, + 251, + 213, + 229, + 258, + 235, + 228, + 283, + 242, + 229, + 222, + 206, + 231, + 224, + 203, + 233, + 259, + 218, + 221, + 213, + 232, + 266, + 269, + 226, + 195, + 252, + 227, + 227, + 236, + 225, + 271, + 232, + 206, + 244, + 215, + 230, + 224, + 235, + 227, + 225, + 285, + 269, + 191, + 229, + 265, + 291, + 236, + 256, + 183 + ], + "converged": [ + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 9.995230473960497e-07, + 9.593544269020138e-07, + 9.575672976585338e-07, + 9.740633107223554e-07, + 9.65863352089761e-07, + 9.944445501181041e-07, + 9.41797403375325e-07, + 9.760853803626027e-07, + 9.831538916068446e-07, + 9.912075414881505e-07, + 9.867025113331452e-07, + 9.640606514216438e-07, + 9.943792277295585e-07, + 9.70719611055397e-07, + 9.806574748216672e-07, + 9.701268852120122e-07, + 9.702734241186767e-07, + 9.670651415275972e-07, + 9.593202094050304e-07, + 9.881067467001331e-07, + 9.446159774316705e-07, + 9.581164416900346e-07, + 9.641120753927299e-07, + 9.878296701170072e-07, + 9.788332649269346e-07, + 9.576874936420141e-07, + 9.644051517219122e-07, + 9.66486978422285e-07, + 9.85787715840087e-07, + 9.74355520110627e-07, + 9.640856579965192e-07, + 9.876768068980523e-07, + 9.371523736689411e-07, + 9.419546959807632e-07, + 9.490131128387961e-07, + 9.690785482841474e-07, + 9.829028302260577e-07, + 9.702141305896692e-07, + 9.424370286406402e-07, + 9.774427166787054e-07, + 9.921513050045258e-07, + 9.985399537930236e-07, + 9.784876445178038e-07, + 9.79579967584105e-07, + 9.986453395151124e-07, + 9.621974654766164e-07, + 9.858544411826408e-07, + 9.59237104426812e-07, + 9.957758271317176e-07, + 9.7974634235141e-07 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 0.870601231999899, + 0.9191336359999696, + 1.00383919900014, + 0.8592919900002016, + 0.9065623099995719, + 1.3020360819991765, + 1.3146797430017614, + 0.9079617469997174, + 1.132306163000976, + 0.9751460860006773, + 0.9085786730011023, + 0.8990547950015753, + 0.8364145750001626, + 0.9201348640017386, + 0.9077200370011269, + 0.8130538470013562, + 0.9285701799999515, + 1.25102679200063, + 1.2354042659990228, + 0.9088156030011305, + 0.8801328629997442, + 0.9250940639994951, + 1.0686982750012248, + 1.0851911929985363, + 0.9004935979992297, + 0.7579414819992962, + 1.0013895689990022, + 0.9103510719996848, + 0.8983120319990121, + 1.0572200050009997, + 1.2500870660005603, + 1.2575584499991237, + 0.9253808180001215, + 0.8286723319997691, + 0.9810121160007839, + 0.8564599099991028, + 0.9148029340012727, + 0.8924077940009738, + 0.933543783999994, + 0.8827018629999657, + 0.8979748699985066, + 1.189407621999635, + 1.5536707139999635, + 0.8858961799996905, + 0.9048928329993942, + 1.0633259500009444, + 1.1576375229997211, + 0.9513524640005926, + 1.0109089509987825, + 0.7160730350005906 + ], + "output_norm_ratios": [ + 10.410625660575418, + 9.49313440453166, + 12.032145103000241, + 8.642493239122876, + 11.165864248379712, + 6.748519230952676, + 8.835650422526827, + 11.37643825152966, + 9.532098172529373, + 11.278007128697086, + 13.082029498028017, + 10.417321395588827, + 6.617115950626036, + 6.438483731404221, + 11.67271951679782, + 13.946225634588686, + 12.193915253246047, + 14.50874380144865, + 10.71752630607674, + 11.460487851914992, + 9.913844023736047, + 10.844014625162115, + 11.284572798279658, + 8.452665200549283, + 11.932224503189731, + 10.900297954405103, + 8.232596768722026, + 5.869809473796619, + 7.577672794095408, + 12.936044644354409, + 6.262825206832749, + 6.079315396015311, + 8.502093289683751, + 11.339089069717712, + 12.638679013366435, + 10.742424316255025, + 12.330467559746774, + 8.472650132593829, + 9.055064410205777, + 7.019735294287101, + 14.894735123234517, + 10.904981417998536, + 10.678193048707058, + 12.594165218452279, + 10.96472395460945, + 12.490557742250141, + 8.423301253658137, + 9.83403883912467, + 6.5443648195463355, + 8.451067791745682 + ] + }, + "advection_64": { + "iterations": [ + 300, + 283, + 300, + 300, + 299, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 268, + 297, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 286, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 291, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 288, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 297, + 280, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300 + ], + "converged": [ + false, + true, + false, + false, + true, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + true, + true, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + true, + false, + false, + false, + false, + true, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + true, + false, + false, + false, + true, + true, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 5.877047203689404e-05, + 9.816898074334666e-07, + 1.8033213404176652e-05, + 3.7742831531049967e-06, + 9.830770217009519e-07, + 2.5774135852590063e-06, + 2.24946997981269e-06, + 2.5484302230271512e-05, + 1.2067482884506806e-05, + 1.1008572385211542e-06, + 4.069623367783046e-06, + 5.87753140156497e-06, + 1.853922292040513e-06, + 4.691697492612733e-06, + 7.291224546186831e-06, + 1.5571308964371333e-06, + 9.98558471933955e-07, + 9.989834419368373e-07, + 6.764080716748646e-06, + 3.0427419884956633e-06, + 8.831387009492318e-06, + 1.4171647534839952e-06, + 3.4226604987319812e-06, + 1.0585765125488242e-05, + 2.1507393789549156e-05, + 9.821035119837136e-07, + 8.30048209004717e-06, + 9.328560187014214e-06, + 1.3136037220368664e-06, + 2.9012593343152667e-06, + 9.343029469338979e-07, + 1.036277187673884e-05, + 1.4152392148287339e-05, + 3.6950142512648396e-06, + 5.8592504802477765e-06, + 2.2537442169980945e-06, + 2.1015847730874588e-05, + 2.3687401712988502e-05, + 1.0184573986580595e-05, + 9.386015213693007e-07, + 8.56354187567364e-06, + 2.079413433286925e-06, + 4.11849904435296e-06, + 9.93332174162696e-07, + 9.96153640339884e-07, + 2.1189988714776548e-05, + 1.7579750683797483e-06, + 8.66364862966464e-06, + 3.16403691787974e-06, + 1.0599877776403845e-06 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 1.2230629160003446, + 1.1164020069991238, + 1.210902578999594, + 1.6658646509986283, + 1.4062229219998699, + 1.2215664730010758, + 1.2132999419991393, + 1.2091508579997026, + 1.233217605000391, + 1.2176801189998514, + 1.2127961659989523, + 1.20615146900127, + 1.532969736999803, + 1.5636743400009436, + 1.2327072960015357, + 1.2069333500003268, + 1.078265537000334, + 1.1971122119994106, + 1.2007426820000546, + 1.2084836989997711, + 1.2660632799997984, + 1.2885322050005925, + 1.7272878349995153, + 1.2703341859996726, + 1.1998571650001395, + 1.141202308001084, + 1.2130047880000348, + 1.2265221950001433, + 1.2198514880001312, + 1.2232235859992215, + 1.1598392020005122, + 1.524600290998933, + 1.5463925439999002, + 1.2331456219999382, + 1.2246486080002796, + 1.239781424001194, + 1.2436977340003068, + 1.2244222760000412, + 1.2144579870000598, + 1.140753825999127, + 1.4054102250011056, + 1.688170863999403, + 1.2533432170002925, + 1.206775769998785, + 1.1211483980005141, + 1.2247046860011324, + 1.2641800470009912, + 1.2233386650004832, + 1.2125199450001674, + 1.2185882139983732 + ], + "output_norm_ratios": [ + 13.601066443109016, + 8.019832160991143, + 8.587323175950482, + 8.180032330843115, + 14.144823260386536, + 10.093516333856536, + 9.244287166851954, + 8.154996321496897, + 13.290944645730013, + 6.25619745000032, + 14.673708497981693, + 10.067767237895067, + 10.259310785274824, + 10.211900869328499, + 9.794247739573077, + 9.22680170160957, + 7.553597128188192, + 12.886437236862529, + 6.201920950889964, + 9.53702136515861, + 6.333544513241663, + 10.041421539459767, + 7.859675972144003, + 7.512474884372458, + 17.732176045767343, + 8.5331582409281, + 8.197146441101774, + 6.406457869223618, + 7.954503832929341, + 6.203084156023575, + 9.342420701232792, + 9.840722709116076, + 11.069454976287156, + 9.567048388766663, + 5.9199275452358915, + 6.851461611572613, + 10.987790597699364, + 11.368216635844963, + 11.854910401104538, + 13.044380360503194, + 9.367654699439237, + 6.649537231404174, + 7.990847942317811, + 6.948596918790937, + 15.754247312114575, + 10.907315935486489, + 14.056753221531707, + 11.467054980321759, + 11.33074737565364, + 15.398210799741438 + ] + }, + "graph_laplacian_16": { + "iterations": [ + 9, + 9, + 8, + 9, + 9, + 9, + 8, + 9, + 10, + 10, + 9, + 9, + 9, + 8, + 9, + 9, + 10, + 8, + 8, + 9, + 9, + 9, + 9, + 9, + 9, + 8, + 9, + 9, + 8, + 8, + 8, + 9, + 9, + 9, + 9, + 9, + 9, + 9, + 8, + 10, + 9, + 8, + 8, + 8, + 9, + 8, + 8, + 10, + 8, + 9 + ], + "converged": [ + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 5.377685164584674e-07, + 2.301182136494341e-07, + 2.984360708126067e-07, + 2.1512837965469216e-07, + 2.8214735784000063e-07, + 5.116943549870128e-07, + 6.604785846720594e-07, + 2.42592589547535e-07, + 1.863600091674489e-07, + 3.025552099463992e-07, + 3.6083806444441295e-07, + 5.961820778463861e-07, + 1.5816639539519057e-07, + 7.934993840560297e-07, + 7.062827169542363e-07, + 1.7237516075629172e-07, + 2.0872048243623322e-07, + 2.791696665097553e-07, + 7.839145557357774e-07, + 3.3277603104402607e-07, + 1.4944957284701843e-07, + 2.908938205139132e-07, + 3.67408250826752e-07, + 5.525372912174818e-07, + 4.873737598691286e-07, + 7.110590904176539e-07, + 1.9398252267710325e-07, + 1.857370352528187e-07, + 4.2585886991702736e-07, + 3.492337669346066e-07, + 6.517560379321762e-07, + 1.7220980322553454e-07, + 2.4178336777902925e-07, + 9.19749096252199e-07, + 1.57420066336947e-07, + 3.875317852245451e-07, + 5.634606541307048e-07, + 2.2036592727755015e-07, + 7.58217218329837e-07, + 1.889366895214381e-07, + 5.167254936109848e-07, + 5.927810584430275e-07, + 6.636356651953355e-07, + 8.460769551900619e-07, + 5.777166482976181e-07, + 9.959754729231016e-07, + 2.5988320312951615e-07, + 3.010977224911398e-07, + 6.295032094783501e-07, + 2.554627502218639e-07 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 0.019740851999813458, + 0.018592918999274843, + 0.015753690000565257, + 0.018260259999806294, + 0.01850676200047019, + 0.018531232999521308, + 0.01594135999948776, + 0.018294591000085347, + 0.02386018399920431, + 0.021719893000408774, + 0.02055317600024864, + 0.01844396700107609, + 0.018366731001151493, + 0.015708041000834783, + 0.018351716000324814, + 0.018363520001003053, + 0.021392586000729352, + 0.01576213699991058, + 0.015771022999615525, + 0.018607854999572737, + 0.018356635000600363, + 0.020707358999061398, + 0.02125175000037416, + 0.018408122999971965, + 0.018526444999224623, + 0.017299903998718946, + 0.01832811100030085, + 0.018301636000614963, + 0.015745402000902686, + 0.01570558300045377, + 0.01565486400068039, + 0.01871809699878213, + 0.021524367000893108, + 0.018957954000143218, + 0.018891637000706396, + 0.018756383000436472, + 0.018412306000755052, + 0.018453003000104218, + 0.015872938000029535, + 0.021092424998641945, + 0.028862737999588717, + 0.01832423199994082, + 0.016122312999868882, + 0.01591213199935737, + 0.018118009998943307, + 0.015858687000218197, + 0.0155810800006293, + 0.020920291999573237, + 0.016915443000470987, + 0.018551122999269865 + ], + "output_norm_ratios": [ + 5.965548891101584, + 5.751434314459404, + 7.013698760573074, + 6.122355279808049, + 6.394025596804693, + 5.9166580817054655, + 6.35954499156301, + 5.427891286823746, + 5.897816527032925, + 6.24133172128693, + 6.272685565473715, + 6.719451901604052, + 6.197427228377375, + 6.281298130063733, + 6.617485394877096, + 6.492207729368868, + 6.51403696454753, + 6.809237851087415, + 5.769278016068994, + 6.067576150604664, + 6.427134849486308, + 5.935542587791268, + 5.8563119457259045, + 6.864485918032651, + 5.44289182409805, + 5.976808711113702, + 5.969365631978481, + 5.574494881603508, + 6.42782288477748, + 6.442767625803784, + 6.725261456121116, + 5.575160981240418, + 6.515745533931685, + 6.445165623707055, + 6.625064500904639, + 6.023390580771717, + 6.636636233198084, + 5.832703451432679, + 6.34276211387995, + 5.811103880743263, + 6.830655298139637, + 6.267902105195693, + 7.346876482469129, + 7.522680208649542, + 5.946726107501392, + 5.658053982463798, + 7.243547762541155, + 6.349399249506951, + 5.876611249352459, + 7.118205331800455 + ] + }, + "graph_laplacian_24": { + "iterations": [ + 8, + 7, + 7, + 8, + 8, + 7, + 8, + 8, + 8, + 8, + 8, + 8, + 8, + 8, + 8, + 8, + 8, + 8, + 8, + 8, + 8, + 8, + 8, + 8, + 8, + 8, + 8, + 8, + 8, + 7, + 8, + 7, + 9, + 8, + 8, + 8, + 8, + 8, + 8, + 8, + 9, + 8, + 8, + 7, + 8, + 8, + 8, + 8, + 7, + 8 + ], + "converged": [ + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 1.9306782632528545e-07, + 7.468980738358653e-07, + 6.424422459844e-07, + 4.715350252433552e-07, + 9.001908105901751e-07, + 4.4973215999556805e-07, + 5.116575949377172e-07, + 2.3235706015501936e-07, + 5.107291264084633e-07, + 1.4479935859111282e-07, + 7.206300631283758e-07, + 7.026830552303208e-07, + 1.725738760214023e-07, + 2.794521046458712e-07, + 1.8297234018519533e-07, + 2.755319753438975e-07, + 5.08341893031907e-07, + 1.9379021793388022e-07, + 1.4215480635669116e-07, + 4.837558037568209e-07, + 2.0274645327389995e-07, + 2.80630659026218e-07, + 7.760278051241268e-07, + 1.4438772670332565e-07, + 5.254104855877765e-07, + 1.3892068243008293e-07, + 2.523290965029227e-07, + 1.1402582880692857e-07, + 1.3624958945630275e-07, + 2.7754960964417645e-07, + 4.423535986240014e-07, + 7.738479400116317e-07, + 2.1792471523284423e-07, + 2.6286361467959676e-07, + 2.7183496795305626e-07, + 5.456362929517983e-07, + 4.2230840930694285e-07, + 7.114108288556057e-07, + 1.963518398480311e-07, + 3.039207902422754e-07, + 1.6859220807212802e-07, + 1.2780548112281737e-07, + 1.0634203876117509e-07, + 7.70421734004244e-07, + 4.0393457560558193e-07, + 2.3751402947983248e-07, + 1.6384291040893307e-07, + 2.3678808915787423e-07, + 8.556976988362126e-07, + 5.264725172295487e-07 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 0.016799737000837922, + 0.014762165001229732, + 0.0139756970002054, + 0.015754783000375028, + 0.01678474000073038, + 0.014228624000679702, + 0.015957965999405133, + 0.016416955999375205, + 0.01623782999922696, + 0.016370006000215653, + 0.016112023999085068, + 0.016024312000809005, + 0.01844020200041996, + 0.01642419599920686, + 0.016227224999965983, + 0.02637505300117482, + 0.018897834999734187, + 0.016311866998876212, + 0.01573464900138788, + 0.019730121000975487, + 0.01599291999991692, + 0.015746977000162588, + 0.01582779900127207, + 0.016295157998683862, + 0.01580102799925953, + 0.015722514001026866, + 0.016244926000581472, + 0.016288845999952173, + 0.016584388999035582, + 0.013967868999316124, + 0.016271460001007654, + 0.013967009999760194, + 0.019076151998888236, + 0.01632651399995666, + 0.016898410000067088, + 0.01583617199867149, + 0.015768406999995932, + 0.015690160000303877, + 0.016286980999211664, + 0.016303048001645948, + 0.018547425999713596, + 0.015839380999750574, + 0.016677812000125414, + 0.014785056999244262, + 0.01651319499978854, + 0.01636961800068093, + 0.01640635699914128, + 0.016415438998592435, + 0.013948540999990655, + 0.016412307999416953 + ], + "output_norm_ratios": [ + 6.594525309574451, + 7.042571925276526, + 7.188761655548546, + 7.025016735910477, + 7.311817342538291, + 7.545147443079439, + 7.4187694061352785, + 6.551367651334649, + 7.301651593001639, + 6.86779386500015, + 6.63915542703322, + 6.9630695732911585, + 6.639800255655578, + 6.747110905105288, + 7.451869415761439, + 6.443321069240395, + 7.076173819597917, + 6.580951400190437, + 7.992957299237876, + 7.438615965422402, + 7.7450608980613795, + 7.274714586937151, + 6.921493123462432, + 6.747458710731496, + 6.934084684297661, + 7.4537169072047975, + 6.8185636100685745, + 6.983396437315353, + 6.797837105239007, + 7.749117797566755, + 6.766725114468179, + 6.9997349590096505, + 7.1319466326888525, + 6.580070450484773, + 6.855262969368614, + 6.95780740312664, + 7.081891518432447, + 7.1410084756240995, + 6.563502702823707, + 6.785036623389958, + 6.588630123175074, + 7.532628944704441, + 6.918397387761947, + 7.0025928241790085, + 6.717123756660969, + 6.810165502872375, + 7.048808874248767, + 6.9381046771357475, + 7.077595133465734, + 6.548959085650946 + ] + }, + "graph_laplacian_32": { + "iterations": [ + 7, + 7, + 7, + 7, + 7, + 8, + 8, + 8, + 7, + 7, + 7, + 7, + 7, + 8, + 7, + 8, + 7, + 8, + 7, + 8, + 7, + 7, + 8, + 8, + 7, + 7, + 8, + 7, + 7, + 8, + 7, + 8, + 8, + 7, + 7, + 7, + 7, + 8, + 7, + 8, + 7, + 7, + 8, + 7, + 8, + 7, + 8, + 7, + 7, + 8 + ], + "converged": [ + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 7.174527169918987e-07, + 4.0080244916644836e-07, + 2.3776186735275095e-07, + 4.93683464461009e-07, + 1.7499520164663988e-07, + 1.7087253730595504e-07, + 1.8935845073609094e-07, + 3.0542505963618334e-07, + 3.303201244460856e-07, + 8.083010804865635e-07, + 5.338372531749661e-07, + 7.411858419071924e-07, + 7.05925644468834e-07, + 2.7015383134216483e-07, + 7.291435906137368e-07, + 2.838892980183215e-07, + 7.02945517017811e-07, + 2.0738896732911708e-07, + 4.054905973177455e-07, + 2.586720378761632e-07, + 2.1203974301775956e-07, + 7.092705970607127e-07, + 3.7646290931719165e-07, + 4.0779853925403686e-07, + 8.943937863462205e-07, + 9.36262153809721e-07, + 1.7100184251883788e-07, + 5.681781158519879e-07, + 3.094359412919527e-07, + 2.2376850144793097e-07, + 6.797272925094978e-07, + 1.3202534849426756e-07, + 2.0586164528638857e-07, + 3.9959436162710787e-07, + 4.317823356490574e-07, + 2.0748250241700324e-07, + 6.750208708827346e-07, + 6.816974005696024e-07, + 7.985560334961433e-07, + 1.345541067903499e-07, + 7.45975175011005e-07, + 9.53617661231862e-07, + 2.240688713603316e-07, + 5.458401670889821e-07, + 1.8135745529916757e-07, + 2.394630896537091e-07, + 1.2562717803500062e-07, + 9.606316633546783e-07, + 9.919182947347804e-07, + 1.403432845100861e-07 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 0.015171431999988272, + 0.01426442699994368, + 0.014225655999325681, + 0.014526388000376755, + 0.014134970000668545, + 0.025834203999693273, + 0.01967890699961572, + 0.01658089499869675, + 0.014327569000670337, + 0.014257903001634986, + 0.01443141299932904, + 0.01396970900168526, + 0.016114076001031208, + 0.016730545999962487, + 0.014778596998439752, + 0.01686154799972428, + 0.014357868998558843, + 0.0164218690006237, + 0.013856981000571977, + 0.016326516000845004, + 0.01503539199984516, + 0.014417829999729292, + 0.016424692001237418, + 0.016355291001673322, + 0.014150037999570486, + 0.014502201000141213, + 0.0164888899998914, + 0.013926964998972835, + 0.013657813000463648, + 0.016137624999828404, + 0.013756013000602252, + 0.016128172999742674, + 0.016179186999579542, + 0.013970751000670134, + 0.013715144999878248, + 0.013773217999187182, + 0.013791978999506682, + 0.01969429000018863, + 0.014254155001253821, + 0.01626956799918844, + 0.014055431998713175, + 0.014155568000205676, + 0.016309341001033317, + 0.013667627999893739, + 0.016160133000084898, + 0.013673096000275109, + 0.01626540799952636, + 0.013675488000444602, + 0.013744531001066207, + 0.01629852099904383 + ], + "output_norm_ratios": [ + 8.127245771761546, + 7.336527495750054, + 7.499251056400411, + 7.224721109874642, + 7.600422234510834, + 7.845596457160825, + 7.000631962904843, + 7.67890507945742, + 7.737127850546349, + 7.118573644520508, + 8.183926733025661, + 7.415817926044636, + 7.750683166822172, + 7.265370652183074, + 7.34881444641009, + 7.820253057738873, + 7.693614533072173, + 7.807336623846857, + 8.229298667185601, + 6.976087422103364, + 6.902879630651778, + 7.120424255366535, + 7.7049640544288165, + 7.63712074940126, + 7.072350698393358, + 7.7111360981658805, + 7.968021385044162, + 7.192111268780403, + 7.563483087033554, + 7.326345795766775, + 8.132493655285835, + 7.156487417854414, + 7.316085735670262, + 7.355200518589218, + 7.627173384685394, + 7.694115752087039, + 8.037828632899581, + 7.49337679885439, + 7.381980187872379, + 7.991637500931808, + 7.230533593838765, + 7.640679427071408, + 7.404558906724356, + 7.339058653540053, + 6.815986022323507, + 8.032012280509832, + 6.905059016485667, + 7.332179103715436, + 7.32545773698609, + 7.512153475359643 + ] + }, + "graph_laplacian_48": { + "iterations": [ + 7, + 7, + 7, + 6, + 7, + 7, + 7, + 7, + 7, + 7, + 7, + 7, + 7, + 6, + 7, + 6, + 7, + 7, + 7, + 7, + 7, + 7, + 7, + 6, + 6, + 7, + 7, + 7, + 7, + 7, + 6, + 7, + 7, + 7, + 7, + 7, + 7, + 7, + 7, + 7, + 7, + 7, + 8, + 7, + 6, + 6, + 7, + 7, + 7, + 7 + ], + "converged": [ + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 5.847076205728375e-07, + 4.6528655921225695e-07, + 8.724408190291979e-07, + 7.566898776594309e-07, + 4.924409236686605e-07, + 1.1516909777457386e-07, + 1.722154676298933e-07, + 1.0882843873280259e-07, + 4.4572772545472674e-07, + 1.3853583065367611e-07, + 1.8044170118321613e-07, + 1.430107584377335e-07, + 2.3243145157027025e-07, + 5.856705065319413e-07, + 1.010361493160256e-07, + 3.731700415053587e-07, + 3.034240031258696e-07, + 1.6953734505319557e-07, + 1.9474367744454556e-07, + 5.983316935044906e-07, + 5.793561558989618e-07, + 1.1272258433646896e-07, + 1.1084114149759027e-07, + 4.2068950832523027e-07, + 3.401532915111044e-07, + 1.4682424489911656e-07, + 3.6008251398068955e-07, + 2.294258550584332e-07, + 2.268559181546513e-07, + 2.0006869007750826e-07, + 9.486314455047577e-07, + 4.6987159357498086e-07, + 1.2324076966634093e-07, + 5.063866157756392e-07, + 1.4922810655692912e-07, + 1.4205589466717905e-07, + 1.2036421998446344e-07, + 1.5334031475208275e-07, + 8.826219406562761e-07, + 3.939444587157641e-07, + 1.2754967041994625e-07, + 1.1807402470829018e-07, + 1.8247761277887588e-07, + 2.080945410097336e-07, + 9.727323274627964e-07, + 6.603990511915261e-07, + 4.113603225263532e-07, + 1.2543623975474998e-07, + 1.095705036187429e-07, + 5.140090708081976e-07 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 0.015169407000939827, + 0.014419295001061982, + 0.014919245999408304, + 0.012325002000579843, + 0.014198958000633866, + 0.01486443199974019, + 0.024633212000480853, + 0.02250745499986806, + 0.02350894999835873, + 0.022865590000947122, + 0.02373241299937945, + 0.02121856099984143, + 0.018979842001499492, + 0.018508672999814735, + 0.020583899000484962, + 0.015916037000351935, + 0.018775050000840565, + 0.023728059999484685, + 0.02334287499979837, + 0.02016608600024483, + 0.021939214999292744, + 0.020331804000306875, + 0.019099855999229476, + 0.01595876600003976, + 0.015783323999130516, + 0.018929935000414844, + 0.018880999999964843, + 0.02279781299876049, + 0.021323373999621253, + 0.018860107000364223, + 0.015658078000342357, + 0.01876223200088134, + 0.01911684399965452, + 0.01901858800010814, + 0.018985823000548407, + 0.01926632799950312, + 0.018890172001192695, + 0.019032795000384795, + 0.019075193000389845, + 0.020696784000392654, + 0.018849629999749595, + 0.021620970999720157, + 0.02583959399999003, + 0.020216364000589238, + 0.01660116399943945, + 0.017635135998716578, + 0.019756023999434547, + 0.018397868998363265, + 0.018232385000374052, + 0.01834159000100044 + ], + "output_norm_ratios": [ + 7.773659072239888, + 8.206826454710052, + 8.140619017828751, + 8.55596549864146, + 8.254110113921064, + 7.9101708561061725, + 7.765406716719623, + 8.139170481095956, + 7.956190444443152, + 8.373290251346873, + 7.759531105865716, + 8.105252675326513, + 8.118639093690978, + 8.228513327951879, + 8.160187491518903, + 8.08572786334335, + 8.012130654009123, + 8.232502141743275, + 8.140592913394368, + 7.841063399202732, + 8.198006753090864, + 8.134340612905131, + 8.101105110208145, + 8.359940406153976, + 8.367327945379285, + 7.780549688321097, + 7.734156538046685, + 7.902614699798931, + 8.44736702911425, + 7.954051346297038, + 8.29572263958919, + 7.918235774539575, + 8.124232725406964, + 8.166432032361769, + 7.873935845816341, + 8.061638698895528, + 7.870072799125752, + 7.811181616081729, + 8.02106183963873, + 8.01028351203502, + 8.309780838593257, + 8.086870943707824, + 7.918106171058287, + 8.22024065505211, + 8.656592129999373, + 8.106938070670692, + 7.990708856283124, + 8.622307759915216, + 8.65423986065819, + 8.240325370900399 + ] + }, + "graph_laplacian_64": { + "iterations": [ + 6, + 7, + 7, + 6, + 6, + 7, + 6, + 6, + 6, + 6, + 6, + 7, + 6, + 6, + 7, + 6, + 6, + 7, + 6, + 6, + 6, + 6, + 6, + 7, + 6, + 6, + 6, + 6, + 6, + 6, + 6, + 6, + 6, + 7, + 6, + 6, + 7, + 6, + 7, + 6, + 6, + 6, + 6, + 6, + 6, + 7, + 7, + 6, + 6, + 7 + ], + "converged": [ + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 1.924460460829502e-07, + 1.1750258833131003e-07, + 1.4231089094568559e-07, + 4.7674621953063123e-07, + 3.202659163802941e-07, + 5.728395208908352e-07, + 1.6537206935954396e-07, + 8.718992441960589e-07, + 5.854735362652168e-07, + 1.9277547227906352e-07, + 7.378583665057165e-07, + 1.02162151095199e-07, + 5.840557779383368e-07, + 6.025210573537254e-07, + 9.191709956314042e-07, + 5.496715298234908e-07, + 6.719503353386785e-07, + 1.6196840405943712e-07, + 5.476042625637134e-07, + 9.947519022584524e-07, + 2.628591072399835e-07, + 8.641958246520033e-07, + 9.308803397750714e-07, + 2.2984873076046206e-07, + 1.5102686382426788e-07, + 8.76610647705534e-07, + 9.047253264768052e-07, + 1.9450517407134625e-07, + 3.373112771013968e-07, + 2.800372608115072e-07, + 4.2621431002054417e-07, + 8.087237797798037e-07, + 6.340718579329168e-07, + 4.3235438087519863e-07, + 5.318401600344081e-07, + 1.385623135715803e-07, + 1.6311998817949079e-07, + 1.5749474490016168e-07, + 1.3907815076881497e-07, + 3.661599368999595e-07, + 6.14340675342936e-07, + 1.605013266794352e-07, + 9.7980535352955e-07, + 8.653484254219154e-07, + 8.020839633120662e-07, + 2.488525415210679e-07, + 1.785854066234756e-07, + 1.7429110797853105e-07, + 4.651725802440559e-07, + 1.0653760788867985e-07 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 0.012199096998301684, + 0.014344340001116507, + 0.015058775001307367, + 0.011772576999646844, + 0.011941412998567102, + 0.014215782000974286, + 0.011673973000142723, + 0.014883117999488604, + 0.019614785000158008, + 0.013035560001299018, + 0.012048062999383546, + 0.014203401000486338, + 0.012299744999836548, + 0.012878797000666964, + 0.016431737998573226, + 0.012070728998878621, + 0.01197568399948068, + 0.014313215999209206, + 0.011749096000130521, + 0.011991543000476668, + 0.011956657999689924, + 0.01181335500041314, + 0.011785267999584903, + 0.01406348399905255, + 0.01184456400005729, + 0.011690835999615956, + 0.011999095999271958, + 0.01190229699932388, + 0.011811030000899336, + 0.011656525999569567, + 0.01186422200044035, + 0.011688303000482847, + 0.012041817999488558, + 0.013877653000236023, + 0.011660808999295114, + 0.011770957999033271, + 0.014153520000036224, + 0.011651456999970833, + 0.013944024000011268, + 0.01168735999999626, + 0.01180558299893164, + 0.011814769999546115, + 0.011777675001212629, + 0.01375638900026388, + 0.012191453999548685, + 0.014170944999932544, + 0.014725108998391079, + 0.012286760998904356, + 0.012518564000856713, + 0.014152974001262919 + ], + "output_norm_ratios": [ + 8.551872863714259, + 8.125432984041497, + 8.381288723441846, + 8.454590967655147, + 8.453580573445286, + 8.211451418959525, + 9.116892608408481, + 8.3153571248763, + 8.552823466140055, + 8.444465653541494, + 8.165693612431022, + 7.986373239413298, + 8.6389512819288, + 8.21994218253391, + 8.095085393060605, + 8.424759251991123, + 8.24189859219253, + 8.583892066423111, + 8.579296561919566, + 8.696891793426705, + 8.78054216798084, + 8.26425665090091, + 8.436141668922595, + 8.273212229969875, + 8.346366874250712, + 8.668104992855971, + 8.14063890780119, + 8.539127245938733, + 8.556740200462851, + 8.809334234104409, + 8.68552238108012, + 8.564715197922624, + 8.249551358575193, + 8.283301079605785, + 8.463051316209723, + 8.782959665163238, + 8.295298771191462, + 8.738757260340176, + 8.572367964363208, + 8.735881711970132, + 8.547097349793807, + 8.601023541759139, + 8.458309537551527, + 8.51280724756485, + 8.492814180048036, + 8.442633984079434, + 8.44459088524067, + 8.70873349001562, + 8.26701099842267, + 8.131379607419303 + ] + } + } + }, + { + "name": "MPNN-augmented", + "param_count": 15682, + "train_time": 1212.5584732879997, + "train_history": [ + 0.8238545022904873, + 0.8005518913269043, + 0.789644155651331, + 0.7772381640970707, + 0.7643328420817852, + 0.7496975362300873, + 0.7324997186660767, + 0.7203593216836452, + 0.7109373435378075, + 0.7006226219236851, + 0.6860564798116684, + 0.6781475618481636, + 0.6659441217780113, + 0.6581768095493317, + 0.646979309618473, + 0.6368711069226265, + 0.6242312528192997, + 0.6263904459774494, + 0.6126406863331795, + 0.6028660200536251, + 0.5976470746099949, + 0.5793205089867115, + 0.5728182718157768, + 0.5645203553140163, + 0.5652323998510838, + 0.54537133872509, + 0.5422090850770473, + 0.5236317738890648, + 0.5188551265746355, + 0.5177458934485912, + 0.4980081059038639, + 0.4924792181700468, + 0.478588642552495, + 0.4794206004589796, + 0.45198123902082443, + 0.46531688421964645, + 0.44654736295342445, + 0.4422197137027979, + 0.4187480006366968, + 0.42008358240127563, + 0.41227806359529495, + 0.41791902855038643, + 0.41099816747009754, + 0.39678738079965115, + 0.39143845066428185, + 0.3741609398275614, + 0.3779080454260111, + 0.37160814739763737, + 0.36024571768939495, + 0.35952175222337246, + 0.35804624296724796, + 0.34860179759562016, + 0.3436332941055298, + 0.3468000665307045, + 0.3440609257668257, + 0.336285712197423, + 0.3228457048535347, + 0.3278208523988724, + 0.317880105227232, + 0.31243971176445484, + 0.3116586934775114, + 0.3085783887654543, + 0.3109311182051897, + 0.31426661647856236, + 0.30145980417728424, + 0.29498742893338203, + 0.2872417941689491, + 0.2842893674969673, + 0.28522974252700806, + 0.28165637142956257, + 0.27028523199260235, + 0.2812399994581938, + 0.2779337652027607, + 0.2787817660719156, + 0.27388247288763523, + 0.2667377023026347, + 0.2647029869258404, + 0.25415544491261244, + 0.2535470938310027, + 0.2507621441036463, + 0.2588480170816183, + 0.24946682807058096, + 0.2433517388999462, + 0.238264050334692, + 0.2360680866986513, + 0.2414856143295765, + 0.2234642757102847, + 0.22936100233346224, + 0.23538565170019865, + 0.2307150885462761, + 0.22166149877011776, + 0.22840620949864388, + 0.21784314885735512, + 0.21802253741770983, + 0.21861873380839825, + 0.21294151712208986, + 0.21262068580836058, + 0.20105930883437395, + 0.20074100699275732, + 0.20989808347076178, + 0.20897842943668365, + 0.20494697708636522, + 0.20809723623096943, + 0.1962440526112914, + 0.20223382208496332, + 0.20930179674178362, + 0.19169554766267538, + 0.19074914511293173, + 0.1882743313908577, + 0.18173594772815704, + 0.18984819948673248, + 0.18285904359072447, + 0.18431439623236656, + 0.17982959654182196, + 0.19649565871804953, + 0.18333454988896847, + 0.1788289975374937, + 0.1889766538515687, + 0.1715410454198718, + 0.17079574801027775, + 0.17316587641835213, + 0.16467739921063185, + 0.17307646293193102, + 0.1816451195627451, + 0.18027397245168686, + 0.16326614003628492, + 0.16970173176378012, + 0.16834978386759758, + 0.16165248677134514, + 0.17027579620480537, + 0.16910433117300272, + 0.1637199092656374, + 0.16037387028336525, + 0.17536357790231705, + 0.16147135570645332, + 0.17278588470071554, + 0.17381202708929777, + 0.16505384165793657, + 0.16862730216234922, + 0.19243698194622993, + 0.17166195157915354, + 0.1675389353185892, + 0.16676491033285856, + 0.17169388383626938, + 0.16881153639405966, + 0.16718903928995132, + 0.16812090389430523, + 0.15616552159190178, + 0.16131203807890415, + 0.1614442802965641, + 0.15673780534416437, + 0.16287686955183744, + 0.15353595465421677, + 0.16805526055395603, + 0.1612687660381198, + 0.15410476084798574, + 0.15324335545301437, + 0.17337669990956783, + 0.1609168704599142, + 0.15440052840858698, + 0.15698674973100424, + 0.15149708464741707, + 0.17223176639527082, + 0.15753591433167458, + 0.14834088273346424, + 0.1593695329502225, + 0.15524260979145765, + 0.16551134083420038, + 0.15905432309955359, + 0.17464418336749077, + 0.1553473174571991, + 0.1526404172182083, + 0.14769020304083824, + 0.15825880225747824, + 0.1502466108649969, + 0.15651472005993128, + 0.14823249354958534, + 0.16814874112606049, + 0.15237153973430395, + 0.14508733805269003, + 0.14769930951297283, + 0.147020579315722, + 0.1575208529829979, + 0.1542482255026698, + 0.14949975162744522, + 0.14822509791702032, + 0.1532833520323038, + 0.14749321900308132, + 0.15350185986608267, + 0.14979736600071192, + 0.15467614121735096, + 0.15527441445738077, + 0.14581781066954136, + 0.15537628903985023, + 0.1494903825223446, + 0.14452297147363424, + 0.14112125802785158, + 0.14780772477388382, + 0.1404134063050151, + 0.1512394193559885, + 0.14530898910015821, + 0.14582130778580904, + 0.14362021163105965, + 0.14225488435477018, + 0.15084875747561455, + 0.1445893943309784, + 0.14908221550285816, + 0.14462903514504433, + 0.15186472795903683, + 0.14676334476098418, + 0.14045572886243463, + 0.15109178004786372, + 0.15207473328337073, + 0.1391793740913272, + 0.14803113555535674, + 0.14976530615240335, + 0.15301143936812878, + 0.15468435175716877, + 0.15625604707747698, + 0.14813947211951017, + 0.15026771649718285, + 0.14382497407495975, + 0.14366216119378805, + 0.14948170818388462, + 0.16041504684835672, + 0.14428624883294106, + 0.15092441905289888, + 0.14098622649908066, + 0.15051499288529158, + 0.14290033373981714, + 0.13844231748953462, + 0.13675878150388598, + 0.14124185871332884, + 0.14168885629624128, + 0.13915192196145654, + 0.1385465357452631, + 0.1323448265902698, + 0.13598372507840395, + 0.13669670559465885, + 0.13424251601099968, + 0.14175696019083261, + 0.13831305084750056, + 0.14217465743422508, + 0.14926998736336827, + 0.13370960159227252, + 0.13732914300635457, + 0.13624784536659718, + 0.13673877250403166, + 0.12720233155414462, + 0.13161228923127055, + 0.14006424276158214, + 0.1424971646629274, + 0.12926031975075603, + 0.12847288977354765, + 0.13699481124058366, + 0.13493123836815357, + 0.1364759667776525, + 0.150499084033072, + 0.1441240436397493, + 0.15852370578795671, + 0.1661665914580226, + 0.15225521102547646, + 0.13357635168358684, + 0.14497250877320766, + 0.14168251026421785, + 0.14279927453026175, + 0.13354211673140526, + 0.14933737460523844, + 0.13402183912694454, + 0.14423039089888334, + 0.15479292906820774, + 0.1433987831696868, + 0.1310469969175756, + 0.15039426879957318, + 0.15121075604110956, + 0.14460730366408825, + 0.14121083030477166, + 0.14005338493734598, + 0.1391323613934219, + 0.14481324469670653, + 0.13734982581809163, + 0.1440126420930028, + 0.1281402399763465, + 0.13579165004193783, + 0.1481026727706194, + 0.14574071066454053, + 0.13742549810558558, + 0.13695624889805913, + 0.13426017621532083, + 0.1324552115984261, + 0.1252656038850546, + 0.14081754628568888, + 0.12856072559952736, + 0.13473836658522487, + 0.1540133310481906, + 0.12896151328459382, + 0.14358170656487346, + 0.13998768106102943, + 0.13450422696769238, + 0.13169188564643264, + 0.1337405676022172, + 0.1329401363618672, + 0.12794238841161132, + 0.13253774074837565, + 0.13613056065514684, + 0.13840638985857368, + 0.14972813008353114, + 0.1404267279431224, + 0.13662994652986526, + 0.13470505643635988, + 0.13851212291046977, + 0.1368753588758409, + 0.13471017125993967, + 0.1262901434674859, + 0.1382862189784646, + 0.1311381491832435, + 0.13069175649434328, + 0.13086762838065624, + 0.1357302782125771, + 0.13674592832103372, + 0.13274504011496902, + 0.1385520496405661, + 0.12328339228406549, + 0.13165018474683166, + 0.13132944330573082, + 0.12173201702535152, + 0.13505483698099852, + 0.13389390986412764, + 0.13491463661193848, + 0.13353650132194161, + 0.12608725670725107, + 0.13197632832452655, + 0.13573456462472677, + 0.1392596629448235, + 0.13116576988250017, + 0.13837809022516012, + 0.1622587200254202, + 0.15087371598929167, + 0.13398175640031695, + 0.13873950019478798, + 0.13618757063522935, + 0.13647071458399296, + 0.1501310346648097, + 0.13577764201909304, + 0.14385579619556665, + 0.13453192543238401, + 0.13820897974073887, + 0.1444647558964789, + 0.13652392104268074, + 0.12773281056433916, + 0.1371513162739575, + 0.13713456504046917, + 0.12727118888869882, + 0.12725128047168255, + 0.13178703747689724, + 0.13138923281803727, + 0.1314634382724762, + 0.13236565329134464, + 0.124959213193506, + 0.1378200203180313, + 0.14118282590061426, + 0.12626349087804556, + 0.14867689739912748, + 0.1576289664953947, + 0.15367675526067615, + 0.14176804525777698, + 0.13784760935232043, + 0.1562510277144611, + 0.1367728728801012, + 0.1363141043111682, + 0.14820428658276796, + 0.14481156039983034, + 0.12958627752959728, + 0.14373403321951628, + 0.16571770329028368, + 0.1652132123708725, + 0.13560251938179135, + 0.14598487736657262, + 0.175791391171515, + 0.1710088811814785, + 0.1508769365027547, + 0.1326784291304648, + 0.15574084408581257, + 0.1484983554109931, + 0.1381431631743908, + 0.13735046330839396, + 0.1541874399408698, + 0.15058932825922966, + 0.12259451812133193, + 0.14173278398811817, + 0.15805449988693, + 0.158828753978014, + 0.13365742983296514, + 0.1378516578115523, + 0.14680887293070555, + 0.14376861741766334, + 0.1323314057663083, + 0.15326311066746712, + 0.17054722364991903, + 0.1568532232195139, + 0.14333780528977513, + 0.13515067240223289, + 0.14074414828792214, + 0.13941363198682666, + 0.126218703109771, + 0.14697645511478186, + 0.15832751337438822, + 0.1561559047549963, + 0.12689217133447528, + 0.1380564090795815, + 0.14698317274451256, + 0.15051215374842286, + 0.12504018237814307, + 0.1323330458253622, + 0.14988815691322088, + 0.14158797590062022, + 0.1398714780807495, + 0.13073168601840734, + 0.15233630500733852, + 0.1381620205938816, + 0.1360505954362452, + 0.13454526383429766, + 0.14695565728470683, + 0.1427872753702104, + 0.14287260174751282, + 0.12760520866140723, + 0.14239409659057856, + 0.12805684050545096, + 0.13635984994471073, + 0.14179078955203295, + 0.13040280062705278, + 0.13041286123916507, + 0.11988339805975556, + 0.12216727109625936, + 0.13079096283763647, + 0.12149549461901188, + 0.13083896785974503, + 0.11480860412120819, + 0.11751210503280163, + 0.1275059562176466, + 0.12542780814692378, + 0.13091428438201547, + 0.12524725124239922, + 0.1213838579133153, + 0.12742294929921627, + 0.13409391650930047, + 0.1241919407621026, + 0.1196747263893485, + 0.13071674993261695, + 0.11913318606093526, + 0.14037094498053193, + 0.13025230495259166, + 0.12607157323509455, + 0.1315500121563673, + 0.12288056034594774, + 0.1258938810788095, + 0.11953614093363285, + 0.12162178801372647, + 0.12094019539654255, + 0.12457329407334328, + 0.11750279692932963, + 0.12446741992607713, + 0.12651443481445312, + 0.11093227844685316, + 0.14180405950173736, + 0.11947582149878144, + 0.13747017225250602, + 0.12727871583774686, + 0.11724361311644316, + 0.12098635453730822, + 0.11372041003778577, + 0.13313397951424122, + 0.11571175046265125, + 0.12710847379639745, + 0.12320408457890153, + 0.12397942831739783, + 0.12703478429466486, + 0.11103058978915215, + 0.12214367231354117, + 0.11842783773317933, + 0.12832775432616472, + 0.12619847152382135, + 0.11443743715062737, + 0.1285995370708406, + 0.12197238299995661, + 0.12741999654099345, + 0.13251088932156563, + 0.12410013284534216, + 0.11976205790415406, + 0.12525658681988716, + 0.11941213347017765, + 0.11625865334644914, + 0.13055676687508821, + 0.11314951023086905, + 0.11820925585925579, + 0.11864698538556695, + 0.11703965021297336, + 0.12123759975656867, + 0.11996843572705984, + 0.13102842401713133, + 0.12010182533413172, + 0.11389198154211044, + 0.11369514930993319, + 0.13136557303369045, + 0.12606785912066698, + 0.12084930017590523, + 0.1149984379298985, + 0.11465827142819762, + 0.12684545433148742, + 0.12230818066745996, + 0.11430889554321766, + 0.12806953769177198, + 0.12560728145763278, + 0.1215460728853941, + 0.12098507443442941, + 0.11946599325165153, + 0.11982380552217364, + 0.12614564038813114, + 0.1158769098110497, + 0.11826121900230646, + 0.12541563715785742, + 0.11422176891937852, + 0.1163413180038333, + 0.1286393953487277, + 0.11596140637993813, + 0.12278870306909084, + 0.11779543245211244, + 0.12321147508919239, + 0.13127788063138723, + 0.11348495353013277, + 0.11362249264493585, + 0.12156916782259941, + 0.1277273828163743, + 0.11798484111204743, + 0.11791351158171892, + 0.12075700843706727, + 0.12228745128959417, + 0.11650074739009142, + 0.12558790342882276, + 0.10863991547375917, + 0.11686612386256456, + 0.11715117935091257, + 0.1295785647816956, + 0.11709691490978003, + 0.12360824970528483, + 0.11335409758612514, + 0.10864912858232856, + 0.12775792134925723, + 0.11474347999319434, + 0.10965105658397079, + 0.11353069404140115, + 0.12026782566681504, + 0.11564290756359696, + 0.11781102186068892, + 0.13067661598324776, + 0.11476620985195041, + 0.11982405232265592, + 0.11279548238962889, + 0.12524214247241616, + 0.12104038195684552, + 0.10727714421227574, + 0.1101135490462184, + 0.11896593868732452, + 0.12905142595991492, + 0.12090554693713784, + 0.120515420101583, + 0.11683946242555976, + 0.11631950177252293, + 0.10792016936466098, + 0.13474616734310985, + 0.12047768151387572, + 0.10789387905970216, + 0.12515197787433863, + 0.111333800945431, + 0.11479671439155936, + 0.12184142647311091, + 0.12368970876559615, + 0.11816702876240015, + 0.1237596096470952, + 0.11365110194310546, + 0.11955611081793904, + 0.10775435296818614, + 0.10979443229734898, + 0.11078682309016585, + 0.12294073542580009, + 0.13581314962357283, + 0.11851804843172431, + 0.11133927432820201, + 0.11547575891017914, + 0.11200152290984988, + 0.1246019909158349, + 0.11456098640337586, + 0.12000435497611761, + 0.11991083715111017, + 0.12746721785515547, + 0.10937490779906511, + 0.1191952065564692, + 0.11658421671018004, + 0.11119817662984133, + 0.11194426938891411, + 0.12046027975156903, + 0.11511316942051053, + 0.10949138551950455, + 0.11217114422470331, + 0.11928617721423507, + 0.11541489278897643, + 0.10985562857240438, + 0.11349179642274976, + 0.11500271689146757, + 0.10664977552369237, + 0.11517987633123994, + 0.10738055082038045, + 0.1047961669974029, + 0.11781472293660045, + 0.11671444913372397, + 0.11614624503999949, + 0.10806060768663883, + 0.1148138870485127, + 0.11685374891385436, + 0.1239576325751841, + 0.11004016501829028, + 0.11740643437951803, + 0.11686361394822598, + 0.12503824662417173, + 0.1153783486224711, + 0.1224641464650631, + 0.10891820583492517, + 0.11156955361366272, + 0.11794225359335542, + 0.11699381843209267, + 0.10840688413009048, + 0.11327542876824737, + 0.12781250337138772, + 0.11874861968681216, + 0.11626149993389845, + 0.11663642479106784, + 0.11401949729770422, + 0.12357774656265974, + 0.11011328734457493, + 0.10136448359116912, + 0.11408995371311903, + 0.11363262822851539, + 0.11313452525064349, + 0.10727504873648286, + 0.11187621811404824, + 0.12414331268519163, + 0.12517347652465105, + 0.11596524016931653, + 0.12032839516177773, + 0.12534750252962112, + 0.1193509278818965, + 0.11982199735939503, + 0.1129598580300808, + 0.11015800014138222, + 0.11576527217403054, + 0.10599969932809472, + 0.12322339927777648, + 0.10684180306270719, + 0.10752081871032715, + 0.10659365309402347, + 0.11212731199339032, + 0.12152171926572919, + 0.12783389631658792, + 0.11706944042816758, + 0.12115071201696992, + 0.11285294312983751, + 0.10159768536686897, + 0.10851072985678911, + 0.11492279823869467, + 0.11643572896718979, + 0.11088274465873837, + 0.11637526378035545, + 0.10586264776065946, + 0.11523794522508979, + 0.10624465392902493, + 0.11504249507561326, + 0.11953531578183174, + 0.10296661872416735, + 0.10849065380170941, + 0.11343445163220167, + 0.13059675553813577, + 0.10047354409471154, + 0.1086424314416945, + 0.11553260358050466, + 0.11719092447310686, + 0.12307264562696218, + 0.1195954754948616, + 0.11862497590482235, + 0.11406558193266392, + 0.1130729652941227, + 0.11086769681423903, + 0.11782825365662575, + 0.10671193106099963, + 0.11105391569435596, + 0.11107545671984553, + 0.11576357576996088, + 0.10961302043870091, + 0.11912954552099109, + 0.11572727933526039, + 0.10854160226881504, + 0.12626813305541873, + 0.10705683566629887, + 0.11720807570964098, + 0.10760133154690266, + 0.11592482263222337, + 0.12113144621253014, + 0.11851477529853582, + 0.11722915340214968, + 0.10784083511680365, + 0.1084693125449121, + 0.11032911064103246, + 0.12966699386015534, + 0.1120735639706254, + 0.11297730915248394, + 0.1143320593982935, + 0.12746677454560995, + 0.10605227714404464, + 0.11143518285825849, + 0.10646199434995651, + 0.1256521218456328, + 0.1033984269015491, + 0.10521847568452358, + 0.11048277001827955, + 0.11317724641412497, + 0.11269298987463117, + 0.10255326796323061, + 0.11408056318759918, + 0.11312158033251762, + 0.11134194023907185, + 0.10202967841178179, + 0.11005682358518243, + 0.12092039966955781, + 0.11319740815088153, + 0.10679085040464997, + 0.112722372636199, + 0.11357988277450204, + 0.1060191304422915, + 0.10729471547529101, + 0.11610121000558138, + 0.1150486497208476, + 0.11552844289690256, + 0.10753438994288445, + 0.10547788627445698, + 0.10351967392489314, + 0.1081534274853766, + 0.10751703009009361, + 0.13396005611866713, + 0.10269834706559777, + 0.10093786753714085, + 0.10854843026027083, + 0.11732318205758929, + 0.11176161235198379, + 0.10786428535357118, + 0.11176781449466944, + 0.11220821412280202, + 0.10810838965699077, + 0.11014788690954447, + 0.10721451556310058, + 0.12519276281818748, + 0.12119868397712708, + 0.10792285669595003, + 0.10423202998936176, + 0.10088628949597478, + 0.12749696476384997, + 0.1102831712923944, + 0.11109427595511079, + 0.11299112671986222, + 0.11335684638470411, + 0.0997403678484261, + 0.11540193716064095, + 0.10546824708580971, + 0.11183201987296343, + 0.11686672596260905, + 0.11904084775596857, + 0.10729163186624646, + 0.0996129303239286, + 0.1154961958527565, + 0.11070466972887516, + 0.11374293174594641, + 0.11304072523489594, + 0.11197375040501356, + 0.11040505766868591, + 0.11352517083287239, + 0.11357552511617541, + 0.10457836976274848, + 0.11106852069497108, + 0.10027913236990571, + 0.10740504413843155, + 0.10482273437082767, + 0.11939440248534083, + 0.10914917383342981, + 0.10575699107721448, + 0.11702013202011585, + 0.11637652618810534, + 0.11663495749235153, + 0.11022054217755795, + 0.10745527129620314, + 0.10706442268565297, + 0.12050663586705923, + 0.10309836687520146, + 0.12362624751403928, + 0.11992414202541113, + 0.10492485295981169, + 0.11526512308046222, + 0.11844515707343817, + 0.10399106657132506, + 0.11283975746482611, + 0.10932724084705114, + 0.11380137037485838, + 0.11914519779384136, + 0.1230972339399159, + 0.1113724927417934, + 0.10791894653812051, + 0.11824207799509168, + 0.11532257124781609, + 0.1233738143928349, + 0.10769912367686629, + 0.10369211062788963, + 0.10318383434787393, + 0.12772487150505185, + 0.11090591549873352, + 0.11375180399045348, + 0.10906977392733097, + 0.11507811211049557, + 0.1111177415587008, + 0.1069291615858674, + 0.12967211985960603, + 0.10536222439259291, + 0.1118259890936315, + 0.11520335590466857, + 0.10685134399682283, + 0.10394685296341777, + 0.11380088608711958, + 0.11987080750986934, + 0.10951079707592726, + 0.10261104628443718, + 0.0979907214641571, + 0.09971285797655582, + 0.12039624946191907, + 0.10571394022554159, + 0.1146104191429913, + 0.09918039664626122, + 0.11002093320712447, + 0.10483832191675901, + 0.10250028828158975, + 0.11407895619049668, + 0.11309875408187509, + 0.11193013750016689, + 0.10953728528693318, + 0.10527007468044758, + 0.11071029491722584, + 0.11209165584295988, + 0.11612399714067578, + 0.10722417198121548, + 0.10904561961069703, + 0.1281563537195325, + 0.11064878990873694, + 0.097455486189574, + 0.10361223155632615, + 0.11469570035114884, + 0.10690349945798516, + 0.11671101348474622, + 0.11635333765298128, + 0.12331537855789065, + 0.10633305739611387, + 0.10342274000868201, + 0.11706076050177217, + 0.11351047130301595, + 0.11052740504965186, + 0.10981569532305002, + 0.10160039644688368, + 0.11394938547164202, + 0.1100336886011064, + 0.1108363252133131, + 0.09819908579811454, + 0.10718012182042003, + 0.10903911711648107, + 0.11805035267025232, + 0.10218528239056468, + 0.10439937189221382, + 0.10975351324304938, + 0.11172028025612235, + 0.10182384820654988, + 0.10550013510510325, + 0.10836507333442569, + 0.09887062571942806, + 0.11307071056216955, + 0.11149990977719426, + 0.10323632787913084, + 0.10231458628550172, + 0.11715161008760333, + 0.10466178553178906, + 0.11716488003730774, + 0.11152043379843235, + 0.10808772081509233, + 0.10419116821140051, + 0.11528913723304868, + 0.10157344629988074, + 0.11843277281150222, + 0.11761576123535633, + 0.10999591415748, + 0.1037014084868133, + 0.10366539610549808, + 0.10778697161003947, + 0.11169725563377142, + 0.10319886123761535, + 0.09765323903411627, + 0.11179552599787712, + 0.11625492898747325, + 0.10248328885063529, + 0.09162523737177253, + 0.10121402144432068, + 0.11455529788509011, + 0.10294820554554462, + 0.11156233167275786, + 0.10060549015179276, + 0.10360591625794768, + 0.10355600342154503, + 0.10410149628296494, + 0.11401561461389065, + 0.11022815015166998, + 0.11606087442487478, + 0.10524045117199421, + 0.11284562107175589, + 0.1052268953062594, + 0.1178188743069768, + 0.10843253182247281, + 0.10326438117772341, + 0.10624164110049605, + 0.09469477087259293, + 0.1074154102243483, + 0.10908787604421377, + 0.10207095183432102, + 0.09749847138300538, + 0.10660744272172451, + 0.10501375235617161, + 0.11168546741828322, + 0.09623511461541057, + 0.10509669128805399, + 0.11569525022059679, + 0.09708021022379398, + 0.10096764098852873, + 0.09788450691848993, + 0.11984078446403146, + 0.11656641773879528, + 0.1103464369662106, + 0.11356834135949612, + 0.12532829632982612, + 0.12338576884940267, + 0.10828278446570039, + 0.11713821813464165, + 0.10958391660824418, + 0.10991876479238272, + 0.1166590265929699, + 0.10784587543457747, + 0.10618649842217565, + 0.1139796213246882, + 0.10447240713983774, + 0.10715770395472646, + 0.10662311967462301, + 0.09608063334599137, + 0.10726051963865757, + 0.1069727810099721, + 0.12394744111225009, + 0.11393913859501481, + 0.10616436274722219, + 0.10286261374130845, + 0.111308085732162, + 0.10007859906181693, + 0.1183818718418479, + 0.10572969354689121, + 0.10263445088639855, + 0.10603932896628976, + 0.10399767523631454, + 0.10422149999067187, + 0.09939685091376305, + 0.11054648039862514, + 0.10330099752172828, + 0.10289601981639862, + 0.09281866066157818, + 0.10887322342023253, + 0.0975583060644567, + 0.10101553611457348, + 0.10734590142965317, + 0.09769544983282685, + 0.10574181005358696, + 0.10253860289230943, + 0.11020169779658318, + 0.12213066825643182, + 0.1121893422678113, + 0.10809832904487848, + 0.10735125280916691, + 0.10618139896541834, + 0.09443209366872907, + 0.10121678980067372, + 0.10243837255984545, + 0.10016941325739026, + 0.10149213299155235, + 0.0967611032538116, + 0.10206427285447717 + ], + "best_loss": 0.09162523737177253, + "best_epoch": 910, + "eval": { + "diffusion_16": { + "iterations": [ + 25, + 21, + 22, + 22, + 20, + 25, + 23, + 26, + 28, + 29, + 29, + 25, + 25, + 21, + 25, + 26, + 23, + 28, + 25, + 22, + 22, + 24, + 29, + 24, + 23, + 25, + 26, + 22, + 24, + 23, + 29, + 25, + 26, + 26, + 29, + 25, + 22, + 27, + 29, + 24, + 24, + 27, + 22, + 27, + 22, + 25, + 33, + 24, + 22, + 24 + ], + "converged": [ + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 6.297801493127153e-07, + 6.114508447721351e-07, + 7.73459498713476e-07, + 4.151121391275316e-07, + 7.085508425948959e-07, + 5.488070516403098e-07, + 8.406967996614807e-07, + 6.73456781817567e-07, + 4.5829045940183474e-07, + 9.742328041717682e-07, + 8.004936268176513e-07, + 9.277902298890028e-07, + 7.887713464117468e-07, + 6.652273857555601e-07, + 7.614416668827465e-07, + 5.928634540671088e-07, + 4.7013583804836986e-07, + 6.558127219500098e-07, + 8.85682875020829e-07, + 9.890489633377944e-07, + 5.258901863607681e-07, + 9.064473911166958e-07, + 6.175006912811439e-07, + 5.263970884629441e-07, + 7.570543853678096e-07, + 3.7075928582982205e-07, + 7.406469152346633e-07, + 7.830671990916732e-07, + 4.3895592976172493e-07, + 8.181042468776082e-07, + 6.479443232658402e-07, + 7.902520090520445e-07, + 6.8264256470282e-07, + 5.055463890568743e-07, + 5.455933256626556e-07, + 8.328478391376821e-07, + 6.454767442517219e-07, + 7.250277098844889e-07, + 5.055207132324545e-07, + 5.352666155904009e-07, + 7.289458855392536e-07, + 7.145542561971735e-07, + 8.130685186255378e-07, + 6.567434840191016e-07, + 9.268505334436774e-07, + 7.168526709687576e-07, + 8.222860560186065e-07, + 4.711229149729225e-07, + 8.075114094698642e-07, + 4.3882319905216804e-07 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 0.235800030000064, + 0.18551133300024958, + 0.2134043030000612, + 0.195690678999199, + 0.17499727599988546, + 0.23008392900010222, + 0.20689209600004688, + 0.2559199739998803, + 0.2626444990000891, + 0.2728447010003947, + 0.2744894369998292, + 0.23710531600045215, + 0.22831336400031432, + 0.186367221999717, + 0.22709910699995817, + 0.26063968500056944, + 0.21902282599967293, + 0.26700145100039663, + 0.22966101699967112, + 0.207159018999846, + 0.20226695100063807, + 0.21512466100011807, + 0.27471271099966543, + 0.21785369899953366, + 0.21668990299986035, + 0.22893052299968986, + 0.24335409899958904, + 0.2891449440003271, + 0.31664217700017616, + 0.2797537779997583, + 0.36855203899995104, + 0.3342750880001404, + 0.384062879999874, + 0.24447409000003972, + 0.2741109980006513, + 0.24437058700004854, + 0.20104985600028158, + 0.2558113069999308, + 0.2750085489997218, + 0.23076641300031042, + 0.21949517399934848, + 0.2566144520005764, + 0.19525609199990868, + 0.26297582299957867, + 0.19793816999936098, + 0.22987344100056362, + 0.3136966920001214, + 0.2303097260000868, + 0.19847157900039747, + 0.21662671099966246 + ], + "output_norm_ratios": [ + 9.09127512749193, + 8.072521358387013, + 6.779806197899197, + 6.791296828721196, + 7.626042247744615, + 7.4666737018485225, + 9.187008004643234, + 9.345620016594612, + 8.216582938760201, + 8.005623337072585, + 8.085099820503299, + 8.140696572714425, + 7.484262022515537, + 8.351303605354428, + 8.315019398151943, + 7.225900947321739, + 8.413757921667893, + 9.378378648598554, + 8.256615892046852, + 8.026511712769956, + 8.470425895830928, + 7.998870952829005, + 7.3991141080825615, + 6.643493660771947, + 7.760376063323143, + 6.728663799539756, + 7.651928458093557, + 8.513142646639203, + 8.690117156606988, + 8.434556504909258, + 8.263120401401224, + 8.792917219530892, + 8.479372368287526, + 9.793648716632953, + 8.457587224436312, + 10.18595598565678, + 10.24964815966561, + 8.147783263280346, + 7.666990704968348, + 7.693061420675069, + 8.567247310747982, + 8.469898654302577, + 7.781464603058844, + 8.811236104826753, + 9.935910532636921, + 6.479882160003971, + 8.092835161470909, + 7.198564589695778, + 8.322301523353941, + 8.000305641884191 + ] + }, + "diffusion_24": { + "iterations": [ + 38, + 32, + 32, + 38, + 37, + 37, + 27, + 31, + 36, + 46, + 36, + 37, + 40, + 34, + 31, + 39, + 36, + 33, + 35, + 32, + 35, + 35, + 40, + 36, + 34, + 38, + 30, + 36, + 36, + 40, + 30, + 37, + 44, + 31, + 35, + 37, + 30, + 38, + 31, + 40, + 37, + 40, + 42, + 57, + 40, + 36, + 43, + 36, + 38, + 36 + ], + "converged": [ + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 7.664633099013807e-07, + 8.889239685440483e-07, + 6.907625223484625e-07, + 8.128105028849317e-07, + 6.820753096226146e-07, + 9.128918403946211e-07, + 8.146805943274172e-07, + 6.400594154090392e-07, + 8.672543996465298e-07, + 7.357595050670695e-07, + 8.340837959256923e-07, + 9.487533910743645e-07, + 8.482398724574288e-07, + 7.631443066340601e-07, + 9.79513527877903e-07, + 9.985544700643716e-07, + 9.604750463950643e-07, + 6.787732770541805e-07, + 7.789323798839871e-07, + 8.258040246729825e-07, + 9.352033844400751e-07, + 8.668725704228489e-07, + 7.290069294759612e-07, + 9.031274307972418e-07, + 9.318846084156233e-07, + 9.963200398587447e-07, + 7.024876359860971e-07, + 9.720629827528689e-07, + 8.567178455208208e-07, + 8.775696152212393e-07, + 5.252509909082536e-07, + 9.646875465605062e-07, + 8.695180884787025e-07, + 7.881318774356147e-07, + 8.54324706748509e-07, + 8.39262070710386e-07, + 8.525544091700677e-07, + 7.55068103245308e-07, + 7.891315178821722e-07, + 5.938179821071899e-07, + 6.893630000586624e-07, + 7.133628292591869e-07, + 8.827241456330584e-07, + 9.68605511971136e-07, + 7.823087038991251e-07, + 6.028172801757165e-07, + 9.353840897433592e-07, + 7.961377714928971e-07, + 7.429206878696614e-07, + 8.211860979187682e-07 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 0.36069019800015667, + 0.31526415099870064, + 0.31402148899906024, + 0.35426948799977254, + 0.3534158349993959, + 0.3318045809992327, + 0.2513039099994785, + 0.3014606239994464, + 0.3572929310012114, + 0.43171915499988245, + 0.35399738700107264, + 0.34533116800048447, + 0.3643610049985, + 0.3322486580000259, + 0.2970424630002526, + 0.514540186000886, + 0.4611993819999043, + 0.41436595400045917, + 0.5137900489989988, + 0.3423288350004441, + 0.3316716209992592, + 0.3396476760008227, + 0.36937476899947796, + 0.33127215199965576, + 0.33014163300140353, + 0.35215009700004885, + 0.28753821600002993, + 0.3455520079987764, + 0.33889975099918956, + 0.3648237170000357, + 0.3037310229992727, + 0.3447906800010969, + 0.39876823399936256, + 0.31056313599947316, + 0.32949695400020573, + 0.34194861200012383, + 0.30176466099874233, + 0.36529638599859027, + 0.29643894500077295, + 0.38119146899953193, + 0.3469503310006985, + 0.36772433099940827, + 0.41327740799897583, + 0.5292688389999967, + 0.37976359499953105, + 0.33030836999932944, + 0.39349141100137786, + 0.5081876500007638, + 0.4688239639999665, + 0.4715924100000848 + ], + "output_norm_ratios": [ + 8.276515258153076, + 7.816337092176565, + 7.658416359328785, + 8.056355432257309, + 7.619965411756164, + 7.760004507173572, + 7.886844966644722, + 7.704566587056467, + 8.909606360543552, + 8.351410350033253, + 8.466191902756202, + 8.201094658615302, + 7.985200549390901, + 8.36161653929903, + 8.500067560328487, + 8.681413226710726, + 7.1271631975062135, + 7.0287109018554625, + 7.765286224917422, + 8.388038460464335, + 7.668441942988047, + 8.890474059206527, + 8.414213541234071, + 8.341896441826222, + 7.26634124359153, + 9.320095561216817, + 7.56554222134725, + 7.50975246370567, + 8.873656432145424, + 8.174828076486227, + 8.108611626564565, + 7.655666509710653, + 8.94557261793865, + 7.405348695011023, + 8.311303761696916, + 9.008408313144495, + 7.609721900993784, + 7.691341506906511, + 6.754116926313204, + 7.55515397063392, + 7.418503545873819, + 9.662108788428737, + 8.341564230211437, + 7.746492494263237, + 8.137665504736232, + 8.043673913048137, + 8.171940793930192, + 8.157538312382718, + 8.334436602209395, + 8.943437700576144 + ] + }, + "diffusion_32": { + "iterations": [ + 39, + 42, + 49, + 40, + 48, + 45, + 41, + 49, + 43, + 40, + 42, + 54, + 37, + 44, + 47, + 49, + 41, + 44, + 40, + 51, + 46, + 40, + 51, + 37, + 53, + 40, + 44, + 41, + 43, + 49, + 47, + 48, + 47, + 44, + 45, + 42, + 48, + 42, + 43, + 49, + 45, + 43, + 61, + 51, + 43, + 39, + 48, + 54, + 46, + 41 + ], + "converged": [ + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 6.688510236639432e-07, + 8.613913017131525e-07, + 9.281110141951619e-07, + 8.45112027939942e-07, + 8.729158318615233e-07, + 8.9706589127122e-07, + 8.055168646534009e-07, + 8.756817893047223e-07, + 7.917085950281584e-07, + 8.550495542528477e-07, + 8.345028408633234e-07, + 9.743944497713415e-07, + 9.897641984239876e-07, + 8.381181250408128e-07, + 9.475205358604157e-07, + 8.094540414736895e-07, + 9.479409283197755e-07, + 9.843303291389152e-07, + 9.699745923760187e-07, + 9.586428027528965e-07, + 8.503212561382425e-07, + 9.311086596919374e-07, + 8.528547952354901e-07, + 8.122818529685511e-07, + 7.93448381400938e-07, + 9.138562680849044e-07, + 9.017440334336868e-07, + 9.58399175731979e-07, + 8.81664678503568e-07, + 7.479845349540721e-07, + 8.884572286088329e-07, + 7.941284009005744e-07, + 7.711454764825046e-07, + 8.53061329770215e-07, + 6.77671959121372e-07, + 7.624616269228027e-07, + 9.997891035846648e-07, + 7.32923805066575e-07, + 8.651853098586836e-07, + 8.8139334161783e-07, + 7.826022422409711e-07, + 8.080188067133461e-07, + 9.712442923246972e-07, + 9.490978948982251e-07, + 9.240029055571182e-07, + 7.525737785607217e-07, + 8.614097763923356e-07, + 9.463361255213991e-07, + 8.665140865192429e-07, + 8.63502005461031e-07 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 0.4620227760005946, + 0.38930366999920807, + 0.4661920350008586, + 0.37355318399932, + 0.4580055429996719, + 0.4130631320003886, + 0.3783976819995587, + 0.4691492740003014, + 0.39246172300045146, + 0.3717996699997457, + 0.381138369000837, + 0.51838671799851, + 0.34894841899949824, + 0.4075653190011508, + 0.4456026659991039, + 0.45920255099917995, + 0.38363075199958985, + 0.3997805460003292, + 0.3688677419995656, + 0.4877706759998546, + 0.4221267970006011, + 0.3778076880007575, + 0.47774674900028913, + 0.3420123150008294, + 0.6897691169997415, + 0.49851011499958986, + 0.5809158779993595, + 0.5084418830010691, + 0.3889444150008785, + 0.4549442870011262, + 0.4486993689988594, + 0.44374153800163185, + 0.45098080299976573, + 0.4054534059996513, + 0.42250592799973674, + 0.3917717329986772, + 0.4432714249996934, + 0.4099850829989009, + 0.4005453449990455, + 0.46841156800110184, + 0.4092733150009735, + 0.39145987700067053, + 0.5978353440004867, + 0.4732754320011736, + 0.408510176001073, + 0.36072002300170425, + 0.46209555300083593, + 0.5044611620014621, + 0.44037593099892547, + 0.3715899359995092 + ], + "output_norm_ratios": [ + 8.352549051776808, + 9.030482736974234, + 7.249737762300865, + 7.303474357782205, + 8.124830132163419, + 8.159260490232361, + 8.94007138854966, + 8.640760174848104, + 8.008380161352937, + 8.649403178079833, + 8.66030200666482, + 8.396886999279896, + 8.134822797025995, + 8.45789396317345, + 8.343731324359863, + 7.997533209751683, + 7.702815234097724, + 8.80200716181174, + 7.517993149746103, + 7.732222326214876, + 9.776627675379908, + 8.256586287536653, + 7.847977244818383, + 8.0175688476675, + 8.662704831472777, + 7.151345504494643, + 8.491497524984787, + 8.649234623636357, + 8.048309453215898, + 8.70700658115474, + 7.920296509372494, + 7.800356192747111, + 9.153771125586568, + 7.528870894566394, + 8.123917130902262, + 7.5621480954027005, + 8.30261726953794, + 6.888266560158576, + 8.112616574025193, + 8.54924700939254, + 8.146878171020807, + 8.55054645829657, + 7.83401462367642, + 9.266864021714134, + 7.572299026009161, + 8.527400082543714, + 8.264062413563886, + 8.258178766860631, + 7.9575692426885745, + 7.720946146288837 + ] + }, + "diffusion_48": { + "iterations": [ + 60, + 63, + 58, + 59, + 59, + 58, + 57, + 54, + 67, + 66, + 58, + 62, + 57, + 57, + 61, + 58, + 57, + 60, + 59, + 64, + 54, + 51, + 58, + 58, + 55, + 60, + 58, + 58, + 69, + 54, + 62, + 63, + 67, + 61, + 56, + 63, + 75, + 58, + 55, + 71, + 57, + 59, + 59, + 59, + 57, + 59, + 59, + 51, + 64, + 64 + ], + "converged": [ + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 7.936376460267559e-07, + 9.210397229138479e-07, + 8.773689368151763e-07, + 8.067677237758616e-07, + 8.803295782406379e-07, + 9.805889745950267e-07, + 9.761411454404958e-07, + 9.225063887662544e-07, + 8.069768853238773e-07, + 9.380122557435788e-07, + 9.390420455300466e-07, + 9.07338609304941e-07, + 9.560114959988987e-07, + 9.464230497886208e-07, + 9.762079348068824e-07, + 9.185389076408512e-07, + 9.533813571262979e-07, + 8.664224454998524e-07, + 8.142343134800189e-07, + 8.827060902844222e-07, + 9.61481668429311e-07, + 8.071049311424157e-07, + 7.885612511642954e-07, + 9.749605071227058e-07, + 8.355483722809887e-07, + 9.070593251104581e-07, + 7.589187953134916e-07, + 8.194610739456066e-07, + 8.137604287849593e-07, + 7.569694176710698e-07, + 9.437579713382685e-07, + 9.664828606886455e-07, + 9.062188746695689e-07, + 9.987692126553665e-07, + 9.923729550882228e-07, + 9.892882987140804e-07, + 9.485823678337451e-07, + 8.498474261915899e-07, + 8.996656788160797e-07, + 9.7667065670453e-07, + 9.178072686670496e-07, + 9.739512012884209e-07, + 9.402791463406235e-07, + 9.968553920290976e-07, + 7.528432772705992e-07, + 8.585027396173523e-07, + 7.163475492715961e-07, + 9.890610305578176e-07, + 8.750982429475822e-07, + 9.25669469923995e-07 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 0.6043781999997009, + 0.6316787190007744, + 0.5677812199992331, + 0.5939501239990932, + 0.5827049509989592, + 0.6282071540008474, + 0.5978770080000686, + 0.5236519890004274, + 0.6515984460002073, + 0.6405578450012399, + 0.5727010850005172, + 0.6066377589995682, + 0.6134223520002706, + 0.8046704509997653, + 0.8533120230003988, + 0.658788430999266, + 0.5583745530002489, + 0.5938859369998681, + 0.5930631310002354, + 0.6240155010000308, + 0.5165313480010809, + 0.4895605539986718, + 0.5695128840015968, + 0.5743701709998277, + 0.5267514810002467, + 0.6007789839986799, + 0.5590224100014893, + 0.582037455000318, + 0.6714477280002029, + 0.5158804740003688, + 0.6117783589997998, + 0.5984559379994607, + 0.8179843520010763, + 0.8087008450002031, + 0.7776414790005219, + 0.613909143001365, + 0.7304082270002255, + 0.5626295500005654, + 0.5498144070006674, + 0.6927028720001545, + 0.5537103520000528, + 0.6006874220001919, + 0.5768898540009104, + 0.5838231220004673, + 0.5463317720004852, + 0.5832342930007144, + 0.5875696069997502, + 0.4695266549988446, + 0.6276789359999384, + 0.6060677649984427 + ], + "output_norm_ratios": [ + 8.035006545421796, + 8.243796930640528, + 8.068374801725108, + 9.267830326126372, + 7.786979958844142, + 8.288779379002634, + 8.084703095788495, + 8.520635152136192, + 8.564597002576305, + 8.266201615211497, + 8.352980525973285, + 9.114639399663691, + 7.9395325120910485, + 8.061551674811719, + 7.998571029648033, + 8.50871296871328, + 8.841184310679521, + 8.516914685936849, + 8.319785856140543, + 9.617946116858008, + 7.6181788320135055, + 8.159330267117902, + 9.227427062237673, + 7.693411330356518, + 8.150273332231032, + 8.827712361575205, + 8.070735768370342, + 7.855533617640523, + 8.604227910895327, + 8.3883403880016, + 8.73160084057992, + 9.547878599092861, + 8.65862324691125, + 8.791471809375077, + 8.51450905553617, + 8.150348522948418, + 8.194901760730286, + 8.301898956282052, + 8.167162377160828, + 10.758338835905594, + 8.494049967560908, + 8.733603857417261, + 8.940888924621634, + 7.983527720603145, + 8.24923236446812, + 7.755003511272209, + 8.880278010985503, + 8.75804913921439, + 8.035090009855512, + 8.567783496911309 + ] + }, + "diffusion_64": { + "iterations": [ + 71, + 79, + 84, + 68, + 72, + 78, + 75, + 67, + 71, + 80, + 79, + 70, + 74, + 79, + 79, + 79, + 82, + 72, + 74, + 88, + 69, + 75, + 74, + 72, + 72, + 73, + 81, + 75, + 70, + 79, + 86, + 88, + 76, + 79, + 79, + 77, + 76, + 79, + 72, + 76, + 80, + 73, + 58, + 81, + 88, + 69, + 75, + 73, + 80, + 68 + ], + "converged": [ + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 9.66419034417365e-07, + 9.755811991256342e-07, + 9.248564754227964e-07, + 8.918009227523627e-07, + 9.79085908165684e-07, + 8.845989268019301e-07, + 8.531052019453951e-07, + 9.235748782749931e-07, + 9.975636041719747e-07, + 9.566084882802395e-07, + 9.631440731367088e-07, + 8.851395738647436e-07, + 8.463832650742168e-07, + 9.747946250367113e-07, + 8.983498968325572e-07, + 7.933059907359107e-07, + 9.430026952991722e-07, + 8.420887936308561e-07, + 8.796542311391167e-07, + 9.032510493052816e-07, + 9.016912814932297e-07, + 9.574280560152346e-07, + 9.947016870438954e-07, + 9.168991547003044e-07, + 9.665751386675835e-07, + 8.394357553083002e-07, + 9.032935797532996e-07, + 8.663266948562881e-07, + 8.621014132081803e-07, + 9.166023243532426e-07, + 8.893385399009287e-07, + 9.197046770065724e-07, + 8.15759125801643e-07, + 9.907640071975909e-07, + 8.679659758324034e-07, + 9.417917869715794e-07, + 8.677296042878079e-07, + 8.549049185617228e-07, + 7.371957245838963e-07, + 8.571785874294001e-07, + 9.522428321070462e-07, + 9.934505220692727e-07, + 9.325750233791413e-07, + 9.677598009376646e-07, + 9.73954330887853e-07, + 9.559958743889337e-07, + 8.294126864711233e-07, + 8.390615340750501e-07, + 9.281095551487854e-07, + 8.909493157036908e-07 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 0.7150905520011293, + 0.7348877180011186, + 0.7927358799988724, + 0.6535127690003719, + 0.6699935759988875, + 0.7311921029995574, + 0.875892293999641, + 0.8547277149991714, + 0.9217643949996273, + 0.7516717179987609, + 0.7432369449998077, + 0.6605293120010174, + 0.6953011980003794, + 0.7542697050012066, + 0.749109671000042, + 0.7603586120003456, + 0.7746160060014518, + 0.6864301189998514, + 0.7002357460005442, + 0.8513051180016191, + 0.6526778010011185, + 0.7141686490012944, + 0.9239099570004328, + 0.9301994590005052, + 0.7915119659992342, + 0.6917835789990932, + 0.7774503900000127, + 0.7041310529984912, + 0.6574461829986831, + 0.7632470989992726, + 0.8370669899995846, + 0.8549304169991956, + 0.7058864150003501, + 0.8029748520002613, + 0.7712247010003921, + 0.7253686189997097, + 0.7056697759999224, + 0.9227776269999595, + 0.9216391659992951, + 0.9332330239994917, + 0.7725221460004832, + 0.6860629769998923, + 0.5612551309986884, + 0.7661938929995813, + 0.8379801270002645, + 0.6473019300010492, + 0.7128430409993598, + 0.6908429739996791, + 0.763854036000339, + 0.6499714479996328 + ], + "output_norm_ratios": [ + 8.426898588623418, + 9.163592928323972, + 8.332570979361016, + 8.045911389265964, + 8.07147265948382, + 9.009508006622713, + 8.358525552673488, + 8.364208676893844, + 8.2572230467891, + 8.12053260161613, + 8.513439803723532, + 7.6779760232142875, + 8.93887172237517, + 9.037934003051552, + 8.38027647836336, + 8.10793344126168, + 9.501985243606248, + 7.8597433513889605, + 8.356292240958778, + 8.221793905791433, + 8.408826246413845, + 8.757920036355383, + 8.186779754341327, + 8.268961364638653, + 8.926981109552061, + 8.832659821315277, + 8.597804968978213, + 7.815178323909529, + 7.998533187520727, + 8.610277859395838, + 8.612552676055582, + 8.735044528553198, + 8.42659103072096, + 8.809343210985306, + 8.683155106090085, + 8.155248960575602, + 9.228816773342418, + 8.468410396947064, + 8.350566242815443, + 8.89615218372143, + 8.9113117037753, + 7.890833815004797, + 8.146451045702776, + 8.274610061586804, + 8.656981625138132, + 7.931301246555517, + 8.886055210339633, + 7.958053975280805, + 8.962568541152296, + 8.442244749751184 + ] + }, + "advection_16": { + "iterations": [ + 25, + 23, + 26, + 25, + 25, + 45, + 22, + 29, + 26, + 27, + 24, + 25, + 21, + 25, + 23, + 23, + 26, + 24, + 24, + 25, + 30, + 24, + 25, + 24, + 24, + 21, + 24, + 27, + 28, + 26, + 28, + 34, + 26, + 24, + 28, + 25, + 29, + 27, + 25, + 24, + 28, + 40, + 25, + 22, + 22, + 27, + 23, + 28, + 19, + 21 + ], + "converged": [ + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 9.462298885207804e-07, + 8.642288106675569e-07, + 5.287708102455363e-07, + 6.068479275981437e-07, + 8.852869892366787e-07, + 8.367354194198049e-07, + 8.633083072014524e-07, + 5.253906791600385e-07, + 7.685191139523362e-07, + 9.074626031917601e-07, + 8.903996496213174e-07, + 5.670100162351794e-07, + 7.630216003558902e-07, + 7.660180397902875e-07, + 8.796592630943188e-07, + 4.4410715908232815e-07, + 5.559843149868259e-07, + 6.9809395793727e-07, + 7.176897855248784e-07, + 8.790611545224078e-07, + 7.512944521844932e-07, + 3.9773395147049524e-07, + 4.7122171258089104e-07, + 5.135196858530801e-07, + 6.23999702007597e-07, + 6.734103349230205e-07, + 9.39615653214318e-07, + 9.000864691778199e-07, + 9.377862786165821e-07, + 8.027057612771354e-07, + 9.609417794167443e-07, + 9.751875547553727e-07, + 5.312602400336995e-07, + 6.523873124941415e-07, + 9.831669021271009e-07, + 8.806752115316976e-07, + 8.530494211227548e-07, + 6.656613307676066e-07, + 9.55786517751167e-07, + 8.390693037836677e-07, + 6.622309451238474e-07, + 9.80337366888702e-07, + 9.365410162207067e-07, + 9.310960282088097e-07, + 9.668132641411081e-07, + 3.8876121006869987e-07, + 6.829368407472368e-07, + 8.919175380796653e-07, + 5.018286191050129e-07, + 6.69685273757472e-07 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 0.240236362998985, + 0.21119174500017834, + 0.24665861500034225, + 0.23526471900004253, + 0.2305671499998425, + 0.4236699809989659, + 0.2020348030000605, + 0.2779835309993359, + 0.2536216219996277, + 0.2536343149986351, + 0.2242653480006993, + 0.2332611870006076, + 0.18635815599918715, + 0.2454315900013171, + 0.2124879709990637, + 0.2085453879990382, + 0.2400520030005282, + 0.23115173100086395, + 0.21999861299991608, + 0.22891407499992056, + 0.29049527300048794, + 0.2315407470014179, + 0.2333142419993237, + 0.22189654000067094, + 0.22115005100022245, + 0.18474886500007415, + 0.2311047029998008, + 0.2571516210009577, + 0.2644200300001103, + 0.2400475579997874, + 0.27721273499992094, + 0.32283951200042793, + 0.3625427019997005, + 0.30165286299961735, + 0.3546597410004324, + 0.2996600509995915, + 0.42815046000032453, + 0.3375137689999974, + 0.22738012599984359, + 0.21632978200068465, + 0.29213653999977396, + 0.3680612509997445, + 0.23057831799997075, + 0.1968051909989299, + 0.21338800500052457, + 0.25578413599941996, + 0.206999571999404, + 0.2674365479997505, + 0.18226230700020096, + 0.18747061000067333 + ], + "output_norm_ratios": [ + 8.725760145792162, + 7.189458428388082, + 7.883747283207117, + 8.018596176706254, + 8.688746435390929, + 8.878952650648426, + 7.124396400443872, + 8.758551160501689, + 8.095249795742859, + 8.642904820316645, + 9.301696954106395, + 9.20557662912602, + 6.358950383127513, + 8.564806321984294, + 7.195622056618869, + 7.587377749036722, + 7.30217397081107, + 9.252466136353366, + 8.890081854771273, + 7.847067092042024, + 9.421638884821297, + 8.304357417288937, + 7.6115733435984785, + 9.63653859817991, + 9.247358490775179, + 6.7641861212107575, + 7.664398847814197, + 7.786282035415226, + 7.926065592666536, + 8.11438868156521, + 8.050531642337868, + 8.753743745498008, + 7.4901414122661105, + 8.659785597273356, + 8.210100576262477, + 8.325800088799996, + 9.498217686617501, + 7.322200033710649, + 9.999585555845597, + 6.947283747562913, + 7.873963470764842, + 7.668849824190371, + 8.195063452083382, + 7.859745132696724, + 8.052325092654984, + 7.483606561220108, + 8.266455001120134, + 8.410684532301518, + 6.0444949134400305, + 8.447747056737777 + ] + }, + "advection_24": { + "iterations": [ + 38, + 40, + 29, + 36, + 34, + 36, + 34, + 38, + 34, + 36, + 37, + 35, + 35, + 39, + 34, + 34, + 37, + 39, + 49, + 36, + 39, + 33, + 36, + 43, + 36, + 35, + 33, + 35, + 44, + 34, + 33, + 30, + 37, + 44, + 31, + 46, + 42, + 36, + 33, + 35, + 45, + 34, + 30, + 39, + 29, + 41, + 36, + 45, + 39, + 31 + ], + "converged": [ + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 7.818020210127192e-07, + 7.765371906095923e-07, + 7.671207220647226e-07, + 7.845494120043543e-07, + 8.270004571699681e-07, + 9.870823049165936e-07, + 9.772259139238142e-07, + 8.841172030220885e-07, + 9.101255536533166e-07, + 7.471766221099878e-07, + 6.426729779743107e-07, + 9.258590206451164e-07, + 9.17650422773212e-07, + 9.87009544119894e-07, + 8.708410388328478e-07, + 7.810444649225629e-07, + 8.60382475666212e-07, + 6.193770901786681e-07, + 7.640111787738992e-07, + 8.303885209619453e-07, + 7.739464051704633e-07, + 7.743426329511531e-07, + 6.877715900888586e-07, + 7.911775180751863e-07, + 6.573063304619095e-07, + 9.0856827845129e-07, + 6.050105930170505e-07, + 8.001773407765442e-07, + 8.145349557178633e-07, + 9.892905223893784e-07, + 9.266123456956535e-07, + 7.770327278100855e-07, + 9.857412785788288e-07, + 7.417803484224611e-07, + 9.172747325912309e-07, + 8.049732669699822e-07, + 8.99452012746587e-07, + 8.667602704696524e-07, + 8.549688603234427e-07, + 7.818214204654111e-07, + 8.664824878655356e-07, + 6.374651725233587e-07, + 9.98677717758434e-07, + 9.510874216140096e-07, + 8.36289613178904e-07, + 9.750474065069842e-07, + 8.678717095241422e-07, + 7.539184004456287e-07, + 8.493171584120082e-07, + 9.309992583992596e-07 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 0.3527097930000309, + 0.37836310000056983, + 0.2796106919995509, + 0.33548036299907835, + 0.3315938449995883, + 0.336701627000366, + 0.3164991980011109, + 0.361449182000797, + 0.3207118949994765, + 0.32841685799940024, + 0.35001821399964683, + 0.32970628700059024, + 0.32562035900082265, + 0.37281540900039545, + 0.35092798200093966, + 0.47233361399958085, + 0.4674577509995288, + 0.49220898499879695, + 0.6250965340004768, + 0.32797582000057446, + 0.368457087999559, + 0.3097225839992461, + 0.33500691399967764, + 0.407413061000625, + 0.3320959020002192, + 0.32574922000094375, + 0.3249673720001738, + 0.32829770100033784, + 0.40546205200007535, + 0.3392283960001805, + 0.325273432999893, + 0.2871450860002369, + 0.3781957520004653, + 0.40172157199958747, + 0.3007611259999976, + 0.4315652859986585, + 0.38095691700073075, + 0.3360619819995918, + 0.3240437490003387, + 0.3273485019999498, + 0.4132556940003269, + 0.32999896999899647, + 0.3174055280014727, + 0.36453564499970526, + 0.289125133998823, + 0.37330099499922653, + 0.36473261900027865, + 0.5924750290014345, + 0.474607725000169, + 0.43269437799972366 + ], + "output_norm_ratios": [ + 8.353931216356946, + 8.750794539052027, + 8.23598236025145, + 8.03743969915346, + 7.933709020154423, + 9.041784677770043, + 7.427119779836744, + 7.676048297621782, + 8.336811441975366, + 8.442279176179511, + 7.370352317248275, + 8.055353740405504, + 9.648008703600789, + 8.656900447778135, + 8.917653355865948, + 8.669742137412705, + 8.435201423248008, + 9.219795537055132, + 7.71816444649281, + 8.615810468103591, + 8.271940049311075, + 7.646107605003008, + 8.737632617108467, + 7.498765473469872, + 8.289332768119063, + 8.981115289486054, + 7.5443858728718, + 8.29711570818517, + 8.396485724087094, + 7.163642074472887, + 7.747162239150155, + 7.571914989258975, + 8.145741666275686, + 9.05948687611561, + 7.493820512628037, + 6.803861229824322, + 7.897096150144456, + 7.646148584692106, + 8.031233080885235, + 9.618658315352835, + 7.723993155792373, + 7.203056587885417, + 8.381187453626477, + 7.6005245842475215, + 8.510851262154647, + 8.34363180858879, + 8.800824671664717, + 7.931040614840555, + 7.803340042970133, + 7.607678791347305 + ] + }, + "advection_32": { + "iterations": [ + 47, + 48, + 45, + 53, + 44, + 43, + 46, + 46, + 51, + 46, + 49, + 44, + 44, + 46, + 43, + 52, + 46, + 50, + 43, + 43, + 44, + 45, + 46, + 46, + 41, + 46, + 35, + 46, + 42, + 45, + 49, + 44, + 44, + 42, + 43, + 45, + 52, + 51, + 48, + 53, + 45, + 45, + 42, + 53, + 46, + 42, + 44, + 48, + 46, + 37 + ], + "converged": [ + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 7.734838881415348e-07, + 8.355269158337147e-07, + 7.875047509869982e-07, + 7.457685390173766e-07, + 9.068175838387324e-07, + 9.724605130351087e-07, + 8.573992201834569e-07, + 8.167102461771433e-07, + 9.494968448113218e-07, + 9.553484838438415e-07, + 7.595576045658355e-07, + 8.745176344513312e-07, + 9.158165791367958e-07, + 9.904634160513306e-07, + 9.826133469980727e-07, + 8.240564257177671e-07, + 8.609734976965325e-07, + 9.688722596327379e-07, + 7.262970390102094e-07, + 7.771899220797885e-07, + 8.685173207019595e-07, + 8.865844635574374e-07, + 9.9270373522736e-07, + 8.002404223737526e-07, + 9.998127295504097e-07, + 8.310918959168358e-07, + 9.297267726787194e-07, + 8.450734428950913e-07, + 7.911534467758741e-07, + 9.185533761092941e-07, + 9.66470258637506e-07, + 7.961851462639695e-07, + 8.6739595590567e-07, + 7.78514951308849e-07, + 8.626217025933714e-07, + 8.890528619189102e-07, + 9.168153992361428e-07, + 9.418077348368547e-07, + 8.35647887707468e-07, + 8.95806847115662e-07, + 8.242557312091104e-07, + 7.615208246638452e-07, + 7.865465820734009e-07, + 6.248431430072504e-07, + 9.909049590142405e-07, + 6.450737725389866e-07, + 7.709139948961106e-07, + 8.623615878227773e-07, + 9.862400873582566e-07, + 8.217334272510747e-07 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 0.45366915199883806, + 0.4508035300004849, + 0.4288261469991994, + 0.5010831150011654, + 0.4227951840002788, + 0.39790709299995797, + 0.4270965720006643, + 0.44961427899943374, + 0.47382674400068936, + 0.4368669579998823, + 0.4493781180008227, + 0.41664487999878475, + 0.41034155799934524, + 0.42895968099946913, + 0.41247671699966304, + 0.4897192329990503, + 0.4380495770001289, + 0.47794605899980525, + 0.5359431380002206, + 0.5476485609997326, + 0.5656916490006552, + 0.5951284889997623, + 0.4386410679999244, + 0.4271396799995273, + 0.3948778600006335, + 0.43086592700092297, + 0.3292481600001338, + 0.43815657400045893, + 0.39308649400118156, + 0.44548398000006273, + 0.4563420569993468, + 0.40734207599962247, + 0.41817784500017297, + 0.391274132000035, + 0.41802919800102245, + 0.4205434880004759, + 0.49809737900068285, + 0.4833480649995181, + 0.4730485290001525, + 0.4972971930001222, + 0.4193464890013274, + 0.4251618279995455, + 0.38696771700051613, + 0.5052763189996767, + 0.5105415710004308, + 0.5546581220005464, + 0.531575437000356, + 0.691549480001413, + 0.4256359490009345, + 0.36227335600051447 + ], + "output_norm_ratios": [ + 9.441729326655153, + 7.297283300604302, + 7.782596410622534, + 8.341993195899635, + 8.133110772436279, + 7.6433793063211874, + 9.948459842927058, + 8.782500645262989, + 7.739915340260252, + 7.965022821904641, + 8.985940732328142, + 8.078331517160075, + 8.06087956780073, + 7.645262170375624, + 8.659721888739526, + 8.203815798425287, + 8.769381004474294, + 8.73398556328237, + 8.166076415710124, + 9.26468109240069, + 8.013624607571028, + 8.230802232918634, + 9.068507079406734, + 8.669349977925883, + 7.486655739046561, + 9.220423811690887, + 7.5635975707234815, + 8.731653049912204, + 8.392201694998606, + 8.347870618413667, + 7.365513695938852, + 8.852283756992318, + 7.427577425106951, + 8.419419072006955, + 7.69090676931156, + 9.017665950150086, + 8.100328954603828, + 7.9327369122077, + 8.882393485375097, + 6.818527283891561, + 8.630933420783103, + 8.28634516091077, + 8.010012634344587, + 7.815562859111485, + 9.555729663035049, + 8.720402614212333, + 10.161080231229795, + 7.804748819624763, + 8.43929566123778, + 7.7290574251358 + ] + }, + "advection_48": { + "iterations": [ + 54, + 58, + 59, + 67, + 53, + 74, + 57, + 63, + 62, + 55, + 56, + 62, + 54, + 59, + 55, + 51, + 58, + 64, + 56, + 63, + 54, + 58, + 64, + 60, + 65, + 55, + 62, + 58, + 59, + 60, + 58, + 60, + 59, + 62, + 60, + 60, + 63, + 60, + 53, + 60, + 67, + 67, + 59, + 55, + 56, + 65, + 66, + 58, + 63, + 53 + ], + "converged": [ + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 7.990951691853098e-07, + 9.710224901514615e-07, + 8.278634653688043e-07, + 9.612685105206785e-07, + 9.048433713377495e-07, + 8.890721453942502e-07, + 8.779845678402722e-07, + 9.867206164026249e-07, + 9.655523772761195e-07, + 8.131875773836546e-07, + 9.290692383275777e-07, + 9.49307544167041e-07, + 8.618285581854983e-07, + 8.001352038266517e-07, + 9.669072928007307e-07, + 9.646554781359567e-07, + 9.477860266839923e-07, + 8.86542612174016e-07, + 8.249107984813755e-07, + 9.50859516537179e-07, + 8.460071943467262e-07, + 9.688823274940787e-07, + 9.857923339867176e-07, + 9.00743051101258e-07, + 8.484711562402688e-07, + 8.893829335191742e-07, + 9.069409870646899e-07, + 8.598284195005449e-07, + 7.997482424193479e-07, + 8.646038281038682e-07, + 8.506828034820475e-07, + 8.344519703319412e-07, + 9.345404361228771e-07, + 9.177069015780738e-07, + 7.544145153839631e-07, + 8.092753332521134e-07, + 9.652587529434496e-07, + 8.338723843785577e-07, + 8.659962293103947e-07, + 9.956872628692733e-07, + 9.944461441140984e-07, + 9.283243765041418e-07, + 9.098002106280135e-07, + 9.935875516639423e-07, + 9.030247645144198e-07, + 7.71817046270175e-07, + 8.806368814826036e-07, + 7.972578984694189e-07, + 9.027047710316601e-07, + 9.37779461554751e-07 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 0.5291405030002352, + 0.5627798929999699, + 0.6057782879997831, + 0.6575093009996635, + 0.5021867539999221, + 0.7093005370006722, + 0.7899754400004895, + 0.8265234799982863, + 0.7459789980002824, + 0.5391589860009844, + 0.5375882099997398, + 0.6096356779999041, + 0.515134555998884, + 0.5841096839994862, + 0.5350588389992481, + 0.5022220949995244, + 0.5667297370000597, + 0.6406799549986317, + 0.5522389469988411, + 0.6183993330014346, + 0.5278806619990064, + 0.57455747899985, + 0.6269773960011662, + 0.5894029819992284, + 0.6402940090010816, + 0.6269873150013154, + 0.8222644699999364, + 0.8304155719997652, + 0.6005380549995607, + 0.5816799009990063, + 0.5819118879990128, + 0.5987499069997284, + 0.5778491350010881, + 0.6163044089989853, + 0.5881961340000998, + 0.6088537369996629, + 0.6223103339998488, + 0.589510779000193, + 0.5151933249999274, + 0.5854248400009965, + 0.6620359559983626, + 0.6384764829999767, + 0.5902614099995844, + 0.5359551300007297, + 0.6515371980003692, + 0.9058600799999112, + 0.9289178180006274, + 0.566592290000699, + 0.6135457799991855, + 0.5248451739989832 + ], + "output_norm_ratios": [ + 8.777026646226508, + 8.856777150375663, + 7.4501254953839275, + 8.2026719940429, + 8.232838645367465, + 8.115506179193956, + 8.63312331309514, + 9.410024451918826, + 8.307947857279963, + 9.143095764381998, + 8.5978601410973, + 8.190364093241346, + 8.283549971730261, + 8.196705401044916, + 8.19726895147574, + 8.21003697913377, + 8.506405009580796, + 8.542699213302779, + 8.90146903785486, + 9.273037469601418, + 8.000412834550298, + 8.317695229645317, + 8.95792889707061, + 7.501118085961021, + 8.63760641390902, + 8.596389441815422, + 8.01829223870698, + 8.15295383339298, + 7.867781316252657, + 9.376190901339209, + 7.870741762000291, + 7.454580663262006, + 8.900347759142822, + 8.96953903039365, + 8.559149249102829, + 8.491171186400017, + 9.011809678260914, + 8.374294269437643, + 8.702269289895606, + 8.316581976041137, + 9.513093034901523, + 8.34713340201448, + 8.665431242636716, + 8.295935101769942, + 8.112158956203997, + 9.097844946206978, + 8.17461101643777, + 8.279756095700854, + 7.585168530885827, + 8.092458566605881 + ] + }, + "advection_64": { + "iterations": [ + 81, + 65, + 73, + 71, + 77, + 72, + 79, + 78, + 84, + 58, + 74, + 81, + 75, + 74, + 79, + 80, + 67, + 78, + 72, + 68, + 76, + 73, + 76, + 79, + 88, + 74, + 69, + 73, + 75, + 74, + 74, + 75, + 80, + 76, + 76, + 75, + 84, + 80, + 80, + 73, + 73, + 73, + 64, + 63, + 92, + 85, + 74, + 99, + 72, + 83 + ], + "converged": [ + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 8.333260666156189e-07, + 8.474554988923322e-07, + 9.514672809111815e-07, + 8.54063896468019e-07, + 8.589210573460463e-07, + 9.11261045438924e-07, + 9.506136340695667e-07, + 9.02318798298615e-07, + 9.936098216329674e-07, + 9.721762255381995e-07, + 9.643713852000365e-07, + 9.049952836274041e-07, + 9.77786067539085e-07, + 8.48551598708291e-07, + 8.212908039138983e-07, + 9.498929709485448e-07, + 9.65949375161178e-07, + 9.097448356094681e-07, + 9.480097274769794e-07, + 9.378250411524039e-07, + 9.044085635532717e-07, + 8.51129147343343e-07, + 8.564968456488434e-07, + 8.877794667071877e-07, + 9.487098182709913e-07, + 8.155367277395694e-07, + 9.341013935677845e-07, + 8.977744984976123e-07, + 8.975322435049636e-07, + 8.933904617602815e-07, + 9.754154197980951e-07, + 9.959925791927182e-07, + 8.638312288273967e-07, + 8.954109617532604e-07, + 9.185904600780514e-07, + 9.21825599544848e-07, + 8.44370974635867e-07, + 8.299655624234701e-07, + 9.828412417457531e-07, + 8.332147836791044e-07, + 8.743863209052199e-07, + 9.88711369628713e-07, + 8.94096443937435e-07, + 9.053501731486546e-07, + 9.834123815330648e-07, + 8.635738213951564e-07, + 8.733139555138014e-07, + 9.38377218134015e-07, + 9.43315696981733e-07, + 8.846891428115828e-07 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 1.0698812900009216, + 0.888343098000405, + 0.7446491589998914, + 0.6776199850010016, + 0.7458302239992918, + 0.6908780440007831, + 0.7570697939991078, + 0.7297064569993381, + 0.8112457990009716, + 0.5739486379989103, + 0.6788582669996686, + 0.7770517119988654, + 0.7185779320006986, + 0.6865709539997624, + 0.764036804999705, + 0.8428036909990624, + 0.884984260001147, + 1.0362803059997532, + 0.6824134170001344, + 0.6709549200004403, + 0.7236125950003043, + 0.7026557350000076, + 0.7122403680004936, + 0.7622960030003014, + 0.8430001939996146, + 0.7048568869995506, + 0.6617905660004908, + 0.6884225220001099, + 0.7162850060012715, + 0.7165979530000186, + 0.7116162009988329, + 0.8131484449986601, + 1.017210457001056, + 0.9496752209997794, + 0.7116401710009086, + 0.7255745399997977, + 0.8200249490000715, + 0.7640896229986538, + 0.7545087400012562, + 0.6979709199986246, + 0.6958439310001268, + 0.6816960549986106, + 0.6162787190005474, + 0.6127268860000186, + 0.8802564439993148, + 0.828234528999019, + 0.7052201679998689, + 1.270261665000362, + 0.9614136809996126, + 0.8179332059989974 + ], + "output_norm_ratios": [ + 8.307018127752352, + 8.234108029135221, + 8.392319657469864, + 8.340854539237501, + 9.183888114175534, + 8.815730854463094, + 8.39937005742093, + 8.826688083031176, + 9.020285661813515, + 8.244976031519457, + 8.74939405823365, + 8.260631961909983, + 8.579998321957524, + 8.603232713452481, + 8.13192206003433, + 8.043334651375533, + 8.476704269922529, + 7.651892758135311, + 7.822040998513101, + 7.4572745450583335, + 8.088794891707428, + 8.739613643847441, + 8.165281683775305, + 7.873385070503041, + 8.807905720434604, + 7.649138440132862, + 7.439636733228338, + 8.075907588964656, + 8.05982155291797, + 7.874862481613828, + 9.209861879133436, + 8.17383151056728, + 7.935756385742639, + 8.602673716007423, + 8.768780490005364, + 8.11524110137069, + 8.593216491277833, + 7.99529580626536, + 8.69678491054262, + 8.79802332706773, + 8.301950120624483, + 8.300863591666946, + 8.015375318356593, + 8.04129051808501, + 9.150816569413305, + 8.601825958143296, + 8.763749474786483, + 8.623971694627855, + 8.555079615362478, + 8.839262188765948 + ] + }, + "graph_laplacian_16": { + "iterations": [ + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300 + ], + "converged": [ + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 0.8498916037645183, + 0.8157456290336993, + 0.8594825926509538, + 0.857548298925337, + 0.8582001885738428, + 0.8243609788319723, + 0.8354092727830674, + 0.8575633972620239, + 0.8794623384538071, + 0.7460166222895568, + 0.8563576464947801, + 0.8348093791909911, + 0.869595227532883, + 0.8592913182302628, + 0.7965281236663234, + 0.856367163485246, + 0.7139824425173384, + 0.8631796252530075, + 0.84136987271397, + 0.8460413664520743, + 0.8395948815021567, + 0.8692806128331304, + 0.8641292445207078, + 0.8474101342962176, + 0.8425781347020277, + 0.8846444993691663, + 0.880894434153311, + 0.8709145871159096, + 0.8838281152015024, + 0.8233426204916987, + 0.8382227195175325, + 0.8538084929485225, + 0.8649482866686465, + 0.8075787640091544, + 0.8090271622471135, + 0.8299509689523439, + 0.8404758805619701, + 0.8649572176059593, + 0.8736234128470651, + 0.8262199707294807, + 0.8152489442382377, + 0.8323738994477694, + 0.8850016655285016, + 0.8801038944532578, + 0.8157128289081595, + 0.8293705859792968, + 0.8722661698550682, + 0.551776341143077, + 0.8630105114741142, + 0.8350179199159569 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 2.900969395001084, + 2.957161428999825, + 3.5315395849993365, + 2.9771410769990325, + 2.886081214999649, + 2.958814445000826, + 3.465707679000843, + 2.8709435289983958, + 2.9214152730000933, + 3.195358737000788, + 3.2596496249989286, + 2.9099631760000193, + 2.982595150999259, + 3.2671808569994027, + 3.188927758999853, + 2.8944489900004555, + 2.896083091998662, + 3.3995137339989014, + 3.025658235999799, + 2.8811354789995676, + 2.8658770570000343, + 3.4656568680002238, + 2.986067653000646, + 2.957402328000171, + 2.9037382070000604, + 3.5147092589995736, + 2.9480820589997165, + 2.905548386999726, + 2.89395481199972, + 3.5403282919996855, + 2.8966462220014364, + 2.8878006560007634, + 2.856838867000988, + 3.559190904999923, + 2.865621905999433, + 2.9173208579995844, + 2.9045114290001948, + 3.559474076000697, + 2.939398636999613, + 2.9611211880001065, + 2.9099614419992577, + 3.585661742999946, + 2.8972408030003862, + 2.922135172999333, + 3.0719348000002356, + 3.3862613290002628, + 2.909603394999067, + 2.929097938000268, + 3.1616546450004535, + 3.2548882070004765 + ], + "output_norm_ratios": [ + 6110.538884172689, + 38590.085502441885, + 30387.951926760932, + 29607.971584966774, + 27243.88771864353, + 9451.147409997484, + 94930.58298521975, + 73182.93704279228, + 3353.900047055262, + 1708.3450723627016, + 11098.365922556428, + 5031.173965766167, + 53932.47372293776, + 72570.2119780152, + 2724.313876818185, + 19071.36009927336, + 1880.5811702226567, + 263777.28452471667, + 133778.0827769463, + 13885.834779614343, + 39839.719892264395, + 37489.93843958974, + 37688.09061894765, + 5097.758014940011, + 17418.32885301065, + 103166.17701346098, + 52512.046792264686, + 124029.4254981023, + 607895.0886488098, + 231517.6636025059, + 67317.63016222941, + 80615.29368524467, + 22252.030542242886, + 1473.3853138912746, + 15277.246543305419, + 24716.072808026474, + 1853.3765772427978, + 46066.26863188813, + 117688.9411372823, + 3005.8662254609862, + 3454.5004561349256, + 126594.50215358307, + 38729.75435322892, + 17560.215272285877, + 4639.428458442344, + 115881.64858423753, + 216177.35488826226, + 651.8972178743196, + 46236.91843082663, + 12321.602857836822 + ] + }, + "graph_laplacian_24": { + "iterations": [ + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300 + ], + "converged": [ + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 0.9400323193378495, + 0.9389198838928586, + 0.9445522948924805, + 0.939369305339622, + 0.9617630942461146, + 0.9348107534973531, + 0.9344146244899638, + 0.9387215650773055, + 0.9424955593972495, + 0.9507714741241851, + 0.9166556166173587, + 0.9400295149758751, + 0.9384540236751071, + 0.9258939287866158, + 0.9478019421472688, + 0.9349062650245052, + 0.9406456949920652, + 0.9366589777867356, + 0.9465368883872607, + 0.9202816894130841, + 0.9194768443238659, + 0.9492059091615089, + 0.93611747312621, + 0.9245692299728405, + 0.9229211256731724, + 0.9468827282285456, + 0.9462849413172213, + 0.9379456998799576, + 0.9397563007542152, + 0.9469270920148345, + 0.9630960080438926, + 0.9484690118850551, + 0.9330806082571279, + 0.9460070821995732, + 0.9399862011108128, + 0.950849774342898, + 0.923265513649956, + 0.9317190576600891, + 0.9305454451617123, + 0.9459590083610615, + 0.9235568764628513, + 0.9464617239583389, + 0.9273996290901536, + 0.935025645804765, + 0.9336319118837911, + 0.9429254834028791, + 0.9453707297529819, + 0.9460199551681654, + 0.9492325418921488, + 0.9237826797066769 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 2.9004522430004727, + 3.272180126999956, + 3.1651275630010787, + 2.88605750699935, + 2.905905112000255, + 3.3901207670005533, + 3.0284478229987144, + 2.9093800430000556, + 2.894238803000917, + 3.574384318999364, + 2.919162961999973, + 2.910871345000487, + 2.9315013220002584, + 3.561598837000929, + 2.9435899569998583, + 2.918493330000274, + 2.9207201750014065, + 3.6062172150013794, + 2.9193788330012467, + 2.9040864890012017, + 2.930090772000767, + 3.5612389289999555, + 2.9069424159988557, + 2.93417085100009, + 2.9150511370007735, + 3.524129997000273, + 2.919193274999998, + 2.9535776829998213, + 3.0689548129994364, + 3.3953454720012815, + 2.939417248000609, + 2.954926266998882, + 3.216640628999812, + 3.299149586000567, + 2.988876903998971, + 2.9642824879992986, + 3.402701426999556, + 3.058347326999865, + 2.9112978680004744, + 2.9438831099996605, + 3.5308579949996783, + 2.912062191999212, + 2.949269433000154, + 2.9282733800009737, + 3.547557631998643, + 2.9270451519987546, + 2.9713868639992143, + 2.908209629000339, + 3.532597932000499, + 2.944276180000088 + ], + "output_norm_ratios": [ + 1612476.0660389757, + 3943804.3838255396, + 5478987.4236683445, + 33142.69304982171, + 18012.456534335277, + 4696132.126165082, + 27280.0199104938, + 682704.5890596756, + 27979.985427714117, + 1485357.216412919, + 55837.36042979652, + 144480.35587208174, + 1557380.8653357804, + 604322.6599391992, + 333159.0120772157, + 1208490.9615973078, + 136345.11276955035, + 1750999.9371747347, + 228423.8314679205, + 12029.614297583674, + 128652.44167684905, + 71368.05942272939, + 161099.87917344822, + 1763673.287161892, + 76457.67264601881, + 503082.4104525533, + 575340.760470756, + 2891590.4086677586, + 1832053.4172523008, + 11207414.589327594, + 186356.8316445284, + 2068506.7322335665, + 6833.754461535695, + 535905.9163661092, + 493934.28839097463, + 65621.98309882918, + 140436.85669522776, + 15404.410468165777, + 1538165.2892263094, + 323404.32992202434, + 61758.05920450704, + 1072671.9913424433, + 3556393.6908465056, + 2042104.2808605502, + 336781.98448361683, + 402671.117792985, + 639261.5770136681, + 797611.8270831762, + 4276078.71125277, + 236303.82660025582 + ] + }, + "graph_laplacian_32": { + "iterations": [ + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300 + ], + "converged": [ + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 0.9667323745363422, + 0.9656418027135754, + 0.9621412855173853, + 0.9606137158508111, + 0.9524854621015404, + 0.9649678162559354, + 0.9667843236204544, + 0.9561010166844996, + 0.9708846993950583, + 0.9742657472771834, + 0.9778569680821814, + 0.968282516345384, + 0.9653446216866716, + 0.966229394152416, + 0.9706988399384797, + 0.9639453409948613, + 0.9645565434522998, + 0.9632688898889253, + 0.9713789155542283, + 0.9715662397821628, + 0.9707524807537377, + 0.963375474960482, + 0.9667224170581845, + 0.9757621853178123, + 0.9724974487508403, + 0.966107479942822, + 0.9583466893501205, + 0.9683356596787007, + 0.968480833819151, + 0.9694481295590714, + 0.9684774380827407, + 0.9716107479454318, + 0.9600194402111388, + 0.9654855027866625, + 0.9688583073040102, + 0.9587170017573673, + 0.969741993232328, + 0.9688968882070296, + 0.9695513629651291, + 0.9742497190103183, + 0.9738648907108696, + 0.9648430460716816, + 0.9725968711769089, + 0.9651964168091876, + 0.9790148739834948, + 0.9793600660159597, + 0.9713807084262641, + 0.9678255003087494, + 0.9738505872981844, + 0.9671285842754987 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 2.9720341249994817, + 3.592527381000764, + 3.0054320620001818, + 2.952721063998979, + 3.0965566859995306, + 3.474482732000979, + 2.974495475000367, + 2.9694646269999794, + 3.283977795001192, + 3.303812755999388, + 2.989266343000054, + 2.944581661999109, + 3.470439525999609, + 3.0485802489984053, + 2.9847027089999756, + 2.986597699999038, + 3.58326455399947, + 2.982305327999711, + 2.961680724998587, + 2.976074943999265, + 3.6152935390000493, + 2.9952343350014417, + 2.950506060000407, + 2.976969077000831, + 3.612187630000335, + 2.996913898999992, + 2.9594666450011573, + 3.16720040600012, + 3.4094144640002924, + 2.973254354999881, + 2.9551858579998225, + 3.3398683450013777, + 3.20273035199898, + 2.9633732350011996, + 2.9622799750013655, + 3.579608828000346, + 2.9609848630007036, + 2.9864447790005215, + 2.974874579000243, + 3.595826324000882, + 2.953844700001355, + 2.952823093999541, + 2.9786223970004357, + 3.617621245000919, + 2.9909532080000645, + 2.9438944670000637, + 3.079438456999924, + 3.563598689999708, + 2.9398971010014066, + 2.919906285000252 + ], + "output_norm_ratios": [ + 474451.8208877751, + 17787190.20368428, + 4581583.69417532, + 7403862.9796394035, + 53106357.277158864, + 206091.0105390563, + 821893.1001457883, + 65271.24166138512, + 9172172.085973913, + 4607126.332792356, + 667794.2166737347, + 3994984.9248962416, + 1053457.642201371, + 343243.04357178265, + 1987219.0876276698, + 150781.4729400984, + 1145512.930664708, + 177586.77662266587, + 1522519.59995482, + 763900.7219095136, + 2871163.927253322, + 6187375.416252382, + 45770.932821712326, + 73886.21334245565, + 2873351.4071962927, + 47464.950637942115, + 138077.93740916558, + 6453619.751523739, + 2233362.241806873, + 218748.96743004103, + 515163.1490355655, + 1003153.1300841465, + 470264.29501957295, + 15299598.412037445, + 4672000.06779876, + 38806528.0593769, + 266433.25395517086, + 32042.279536647857, + 2309365.7263700017, + 248857.6739178614, + 1393217.0010772992, + 1096550.712166518, + 465763.46656560956, + 3295114.1678998424, + 1614534.4246386401, + 3216581.08992831, + 2611290.2565496415, + 2292406.3650241317, + 1269021.706796447, + 798030.840901139 + ] + }, + "graph_laplacian_48": { + "iterations": [ + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300 + ], + "converged": [ + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 0.9891036545223113, + 0.9896028438733181, + 0.9862006649739932, + 0.9872794827875484, + 0.9875273804549652, + 0.9874732879406121, + 0.9835161452769617, + 0.9858763683319156, + 0.9856436292401392, + 0.9900356433139282, + 0.9887365140773456, + 0.9868164240290159, + 0.9898682973922428, + 0.9868071316634276, + 0.9887791172143823, + 0.9882004441959528, + 0.9901178198191899, + 0.9873862287509805, + 0.9854506230732366, + 0.9877371938794252, + 0.9838448032215213, + 0.9845547035827155, + 0.9861219553981931, + 0.9873960622380614, + 0.9900941519249767, + 0.988005741957621, + 0.9899771067292515, + 0.986352726191693, + 0.9861989909062379, + 0.9870116559168761, + 0.986253464762959, + 0.9871697677360273, + 0.9865468662782787, + 0.9894426353199449, + 0.9877345002530948, + 0.988660472856879, + 0.9870410098853803, + 0.9860660057343849, + 0.9912060512503562, + 0.9863048454338088, + 0.9867025790444425, + 0.9872767260605332, + 0.98342469747264, + 0.9878942477042927, + 0.9869869220230504, + 0.9833446501609786, + 0.9834465348139939, + 0.9797145655485917, + 0.9894539141220627, + 0.9866102673532368 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 3.3232919440015394, + 3.0086899620000622, + 2.9861430100008874, + 3.4421544409997296, + 3.111433879001197, + 3.0305107530002715, + 3.0026494080011616, + 3.5716420540011313, + 2.9749260549997416, + 2.996193924000181, + 2.9958212370002, + 3.606113646999802, + 2.975060486000075, + 2.9889126229991234, + 2.9324843260001217, + 3.6148922900010803, + 2.9920821569994587, + 2.9966924550008116, + 3.2246418300001096, + 3.364658023001539, + 2.9948777410008915, + 2.9474000730006082, + 3.3887096399994334, + 3.1621671309985686, + 2.996405294001306, + 2.98253897199902, + 3.5764163739986543, + 3.0143222989991045, + 3.019354370999281, + 3.011609162998866, + 3.694512639000095, + 3.020689978999144, + 2.9779802819994075, + 2.966869752001003, + 3.6272617419999733, + 2.977383801000542, + 3.003581237999242, + 3.2505320939999365, + 3.367878360000759, + 3.002000725000471, + 3.0080366649999633, + 3.460954287000277, + 3.131529384001624, + 2.992755709999983, + 3.0261066040002333, + 3.5878685179995955, + 3.0020546890009427, + 3.01370286600104, + 2.9786427529998036, + 3.623337676999654 + ], + "output_norm_ratios": [ + 1394354.1778121255, + 243017.81508248352, + 246939.32086124114, + 65964739.588003315, + 737779.1081834966, + 100169379.22475474, + 62755365.1402971, + 53668606.056691326, + 1703687.4715664058, + 13176720.62991706, + 62667016.957449, + 58339075.00036886, + 4559488.110256811, + 244961444.31035596, + 52042517.55503504, + 145555524.1344268, + 3067353.234542379, + 12779349.664957408, + 5300214.257025684, + 1228528.0439561936, + 369400.6511214263, + 61092084.24360384, + 65963411.1205159, + 807934032.0291967, + 472168482.6168781, + 67313583.12031184, + 8218043.163185638, + 13796203.997824833, + 2441243.090079998, + 17148496.493457552, + 10742130.016619947, + 2425552.822117758, + 36741673.05573622, + 730811.3612003177, + 67116054.98409952, + 36612309.939249486, + 65788926.477743365, + 35849122.130985335, + 170393.14665036736, + 1181895.1898654997, + 13252666.402158355, + 47641391.8786249, + 213534.00504907806, + 8368281.503039187, + 3425146.226883993, + 30994763.3591959, + 2045359.8985231507, + 4791722.753798671, + 7002223.099380754, + 693860.6146878973 + ] + }, + "graph_laplacian_64": { + "iterations": [ + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300 + ], + "converged": [ + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 0.9949354742284938, + 0.9937093063517695, + 0.991188820181991, + 0.9915945585518321, + 0.9924608057277066, + 0.9893536914919829, + 0.9917752246343935, + 0.9907220865087897, + 0.9932946253198456, + 0.9925390449488796, + 0.9906719473835284, + 0.9906173809788801, + 0.9929307844182457, + 0.9906793683757834, + 0.993987884620768, + 0.9940642579744395, + 0.9934136859335654, + 0.991410595694098, + 0.9935254431128956, + 0.9889138354375914, + 0.992323842776054, + 0.9920425052072877, + 0.9902826233028228, + 0.9901728113259699, + 0.9899016408469798, + 0.9913769803600972, + 0.9912720675292231, + 0.9934596882192764, + 0.9925056434556362, + 0.993743727680449, + 0.9931135258678511, + 0.9930045313235574, + 0.9924692494308599, + 0.9926409261671043, + 0.9925598273750377, + 0.9906013331297111, + 0.9935473888288541, + 0.9922266792360418, + 0.9946220765033672, + 0.9932068101308884, + 0.992296835443055, + 0.9931219491200679, + 0.9927042161064326, + 0.9919914680421104, + 0.9917633032920752, + 0.9908103937623902, + 0.9879250917813773, + 0.9904439547239113, + 0.9914632814944995, + 0.9908183437441782 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 3.0398685060008575, + 3.05497835999995, + 3.5180462969983637, + 2.9062112499996147, + 3.0164164709985926, + 3.23677203599982, + 3.314546806999715, + 2.9791480769999907, + 2.987493082999208, + 3.407671790999302, + 3.1128754900000786, + 3.00976898800036, + 2.9800775940002495, + 3.5948108689990477, + 2.922808057999646, + 2.9610076839999238, + 3.008229029999711, + 3.642688268000711, + 3.0002613730011944, + 2.958258857999681, + 2.9736432890003925, + 3.5853969880008663, + 2.989045743001043, + 2.9590548890009813, + 3.2478481190009916, + 3.368655658001444, + 3.0234239819983486, + 3.0322200749997137, + 3.410633814999528, + 3.150116397000602, + 2.9556230140005937, + 2.991450169998643, + 3.6012332210011664, + 2.9526841139995668, + 2.936132941998949, + 2.9556581699998787, + 3.5830268150002667, + 2.959823184000925, + 3.12423949299955, + 3.0185282889997325, + 3.6287775010005134, + 3.035354229999939, + 3.0974332639998465, + 3.219432438001604, + 3.3198621249994176, + 3.0152890289991774, + 3.0170430990001478, + 3.4106559379997634, + 3.174293142999886, + 2.988822250999874 + ], + "output_norm_ratios": [ + 1843610627.2356322, + 47056482.75994529, + 18824735.571713503, + 306303937.09469044, + 1087358318.4404683, + 194352.17240037335, + 161192124.58970258, + 48157567.50496847, + 66051364.747650914, + 218040231.7331103, + 260046018.40624267, + 95382097.0191624, + 93809969.57330829, + 224168993.74909586, + 257219.53109578375, + 222613484.00153205, + 8930904.876653008, + 2322002.221733782, + 62964049.8008259, + 6533340.419716786, + 240221272.58051965, + 86100223.85279363, + 31895467.728541587, + 635091.5094951284, + 408628612.91874045, + 1320027.9351783511, + 329872038.4438675, + 3324288869.864436, + 540578105.4395572, + 232813692.92438772, + 131918475.73301412, + 39621824.82867894, + 517864609.26875097, + 817841.5226817628, + 368280497.1404924, + 320644848.67232305, + 7792005.641112999, + 197853816.50824016, + 2646111.31867132, + 172454494.33064836, + 70028227.23951991, + 3261212926.5900626, + 16563904.550368764, + 38405119.04411171, + 25167464.45165206, + 2607379.7897162433, + 1033902.1156784556, + 1724448735.6527739, + 545109184.005919, + 45253551.323959164 + ] + } + } + } + ] + } + ] +} \ No newline at end of file