diff --git "a/ablation_v4_results/ablation_v4_mpnn.json" "b/ablation_v4_results/ablation_v4_mpnn.json" new file mode 100644--- /dev/null +++ "b/ablation_v4_results/ablation_v4_mpnn.json" @@ -0,0 +1,12113 @@ +{ + "variant": "mpnn", + "config": { + "name": "MPNN", + "model_type": "mpnn", + "aggregation": "sum", + "edge_norm": false, + "edge_augment": false, + "train_domains": [ + "diffusion", + "advection" + ], + "epochs": 1000, + "matrices_per_epoch": 16, + "num_layers": 8, + "embed_dim": 16, + "hidden_dim": 32, + "num_context_pairs": 5, + "training_grid_sizes": [ + 16, + 24, + 32 + ], + "eval_grid_sizes": [ + 16, + 24, + 32, + 48, + 64 + ], + "batch_size": 128, + "learning_rate": 0.001, + "gmres_restart": 30, + "gmres_max_iters": 300, + "gmres_rtol": 1e-06, + "num_test_matrices": 50, + "seeds": [ + 42, + 123, + 456, + 789, + 1337 + ], + "eval_domains": [ + "diffusion", + "advection", + "graph_laplacian" + ] + }, + "seeds": [ + { + "seed": 42, + "models": [ + { + "name": "No Preconditioner", + "param_count": 0, + "train_time": 0.0, + "train_history": [], + "best_loss": null, + "best_epoch": null, + "eval": { + "diffusion_16": { + "iterations": [ + 92, + 92, + 89, + 70, + 80, + 86, + 97, + 94, + 87, + 102, + 99, + 79, + 90, + 102, + 87, + 85, + 85, + 117, + 96, + 84, + 79, + 83, + 82, + 85, + 72, + 82, + 88, + 85, + 84, + 87, + 79, + 90, + 94, + 96, + 103, + 86, + 85, + 93, + 120, + 73, + 75, + 94, + 67, + 90, + 69, + 85, + 99, + 72, + 77, + 88 + ], + "converged": [ + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 8.849466608178487e-07, + 9.038157360916802e-07, + 9.831751473519103e-07, + 9.842022519533538e-07, + 9.232250361971954e-07, + 9.002261828778202e-07, + 9.9813588356472e-07, + 9.170099375220525e-07, + 9.265688578811523e-07, + 9.146902867227488e-07, + 9.505956099760592e-07, + 9.181001926961287e-07, + 9.58149083752407e-07, + 9.117652475283652e-07, + 9.219373199635413e-07, + 8.751072682992054e-07, + 9.551646274943965e-07, + 9.771465702551275e-07, + 9.7281864384397e-07, + 9.992570297644205e-07, + 9.045304062608205e-07, + 9.475831643560432e-07, + 9.210528513060686e-07, + 9.766666673515225e-07, + 8.596233047722296e-07, + 9.382540061165044e-07, + 9.76266907644767e-07, + 9.923978776479618e-07, + 9.205848099073365e-07, + 8.356487961880503e-07, + 9.890016734894256e-07, + 8.946018926454138e-07, + 9.1356517336525e-07, + 9.872635207177978e-07, + 9.462878589061932e-07, + 9.472505027105415e-07, + 9.08992835409336e-07, + 9.241868163353711e-07, + 9.974144806451077e-07, + 7.745399911052034e-07, + 9.822184752306027e-07, + 8.831538500216185e-07, + 9.362275258935101e-07, + 9.655818043504687e-07, + 9.075506859276581e-07, + 8.613473143148737e-07, + 9.843657326104486e-07, + 9.522806746350867e-07, + 9.177558487662283e-07, + 9.592506251799735e-07 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 0.6309310680007911, + 0.642047449000529, + 0.6341067600005772, + 0.41156994700031646, + 0.5450725800001237, + 0.5871184220013674, + 0.688080717000048, + 0.7110265320006874, + 0.5757138669996493, + 0.7002829229986673, + 0.6639481719994365, + 0.5113400930003991, + 0.6807347300000401, + 0.7246981799999048, + 0.6541616340000473, + 0.8509287280012359, + 0.8827236689994606, + 1.255123757000547, + 0.7466038050006318, + 0.5907686009995814, + 0.5410491150014423, + 0.5937546530003601, + 0.5949560960016242, + 0.5524340970005142, + 0.48208331800015003, + 0.5802682289995573, + 0.6254045740006404, + 0.6276946479993057, + 0.5728068509997684, + 0.6436686329998338, + 0.5051741499992204, + 0.689117083000383, + 0.6708302269998967, + 0.6626920329999848, + 0.8344054410008539, + 0.8673408630002086, + 0.8048960870000883, + 0.9957508289990074, + 0.996074339000188, + 0.5060189760006324, + 0.4813767329997063, + 0.6928308790011215, + 0.4865697100012767, + 0.6333552750002127, + 0.47016421599983005, + 0.5656350650006061, + 0.7032012119998399, + 0.4754435029990418, + 0.48210648099848186, + 0.6039112689995818 + ], + "output_norm_ratios": [] + }, + "diffusion_24": { + "iterations": [ + 137, + 141, + 122, + 127, + 172, + 161, + 103, + 123, + 146, + 136, + 154, + 155, + 134, + 127, + 135, + 166, + 155, + 143, + 123, + 146, + 138, + 139, + 144, + 158, + 118, + 162, + 130, + 121, + 135, + 137, + 134, + 140, + 206, + 107, + 134, + 125, + 132, + 123, + 140, + 156, + 117, + 157, + 135, + 135, + 146, + 137, + 131, + 129, + 139, + 153 + ], + "converged": [ + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 9.544699185647606e-07, + 9.587760189134982e-07, + 9.331194249118201e-07, + 8.987310911056011e-07, + 9.569743007590225e-07, + 9.587001850582422e-07, + 8.937690010941312e-07, + 9.428459537290264e-07, + 9.663232300607155e-07, + 9.189592854168718e-07, + 9.758391652249088e-07, + 9.629947532099374e-07, + 8.935495125494931e-07, + 9.613718559476673e-07, + 9.59517894940616e-07, + 9.424429006301574e-07, + 9.468678541412646e-07, + 9.565570754670376e-07, + 9.516499292535886e-07, + 9.605463623671881e-07, + 9.624713553908928e-07, + 9.35991390131557e-07, + 9.645157770531545e-07, + 9.695084974775614e-07, + 9.716499844565535e-07, + 9.614341110780335e-07, + 9.511843022634717e-07, + 9.347356498185206e-07, + 9.952564848203143e-07, + 9.71672060316992e-07, + 9.71343486901874e-07, + 9.383308551412407e-07, + 9.874554705523514e-07, + 9.422247296854364e-07, + 9.25947803325315e-07, + 9.972116175838567e-07, + 9.360052246484835e-07, + 9.813527371882484e-07, + 9.543434766913437e-07, + 9.95432806675965e-07, + 9.262851824017934e-07, + 9.830222875631986e-07, + 9.403096961703958e-07, + 9.094173723846004e-07, + 9.865458967181696e-07, + 9.087473501387556e-07, + 9.091229260975543e-07, + 9.972543682398116e-07, + 9.448154105431053e-07, + 9.897309928081217e-07 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 1.0536820910001552, + 1.000003781000487, + 0.9235955080002896, + 1.1237500659990474, + 1.7624611100000038, + 1.4302674079990538, + 0.7360527319997345, + 0.8921293160001369, + 1.0969005189999734, + 0.9890068959994096, + 1.0792811409992282, + 1.1230352170005062, + 0.9844315810005355, + 0.8771230870006548, + 0.9189518250004767, + 1.5374167570007558, + 1.5033440299994254, + 1.4286219380010152, + 0.902997436998703, + 1.1062456499985274, + 1.0017213439987245, + 1.1045484169990232, + 1.0576781039999332, + 1.1564640659998986, + 0.8462230389995966, + 1.1834580819995608, + 0.9528553600011946, + 1.20742735299973, + 1.3035863290006091, + 1.380588603000433, + 1.0211062170001242, + 1.021207478001088, + 1.454146629999741, + 0.7331401809988165, + 0.9387389389994496, + 0.9200432719990204, + 0.9046429689988145, + 0.8520085709988052, + 1.0089975119990413, + 1.4543624530015222, + 1.1245681929995044, + 1.5734392720005417, + 0.9250199859998247, + 0.9511934450001718, + 1.0666105410000455, + 1.0005303829984769, + 0.8633526760004315, + 0.9220156440005667, + 1.0114183629993931, + 1.2129999890003091 + ], + "output_norm_ratios": [] + }, + "diffusion_32": { + "iterations": [ + 226, + 255, + 178, + 197, + 234, + 246, + 241, + 235, + 225, + 185, + 193, + 209, + 171, + 184, + 253, + 292, + 184, + 246, + 186, + 184, + 218, + 202, + 183, + 174, + 204, + 194, + 177, + 228, + 209, + 266, + 188, + 194, + 181, + 199, + 217, + 185, + 271, + 142, + 190, + 226, + 193, + 186, + 219, + 300, + 183, + 204, + 238, + 174, + 211, + 192 + ], + "converged": [ + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + false, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 9.509238585060975e-07, + 9.804556082977805e-07, + 9.278299122138735e-07, + 9.925427461448639e-07, + 9.858301045499623e-07, + 9.83732013168549e-07, + 9.863785218190011e-07, + 9.879729160698793e-07, + 9.770578113170973e-07, + 9.903121263707084e-07, + 9.23215248902649e-07, + 9.80339403616416e-07, + 9.38101242974112e-07, + 9.682420384775732e-07, + 9.69845553851214e-07, + 9.671426824923816e-07, + 9.242855485997784e-07, + 9.821196794783623e-07, + 9.5962846277391e-07, + 9.930834909302778e-07, + 9.461239316817652e-07, + 9.749725881375464e-07, + 9.911350255964222e-07, + 9.442335265798881e-07, + 9.397935731153459e-07, + 9.692160128208779e-07, + 9.60405281729227e-07, + 9.768611769018325e-07, + 9.78676156558373e-07, + 9.95219897027808e-07, + 9.37764464184337e-07, + 9.830988118561061e-07, + 9.783519524188514e-07, + 9.464097709507154e-07, + 9.781615772615721e-07, + 9.871735176339006e-07, + 9.891009599831183e-07, + 9.776491868791917e-07, + 9.746787598974872e-07, + 9.67083832132172e-07, + 9.671324114401248e-07, + 9.802268256184325e-07, + 9.551856290138135e-07, + 1.579759935793942e-06, + 9.793042680954916e-07, + 9.540002924185311e-07, + 9.741934866979418e-07, + 9.929807611109584e-07, + 9.912283842755438e-07, + 9.408735990853426e-07 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 1.6948971389992948, + 1.9097746499992354, + 1.3111633000007714, + 2.149652657999468, + 2.1593122619997303, + 1.8352618710014212, + 1.7471055419991899, + 1.9120483079987025, + 1.6569099270000152, + 1.383589414999733, + 1.9330480030002946, + 2.139194868001141, + 1.2899970400012535, + 1.440860762999364, + 1.8957402050000383, + 2.1662286520004272, + 1.373199511999701, + 1.9885861589991691, + 1.9199578679999831, + 1.8141957510015345, + 1.6185391290000553, + 1.463318113999776, + 1.3105539499993029, + 1.3440637000003335, + 1.6192948110001453, + 1.4190940640000917, + 1.7226382610006112, + 2.314079130999744, + 1.5392703540001094, + 1.9648859750013798, + 1.3601245530007873, + 1.4753953910003474, + 1.371272324000529, + 1.47752629200113, + 2.154439480000292, + 1.8951701019996108, + 2.1099396600002365, + 1.033327236000332, + 1.3949544959996274, + 1.7514068430009502, + 1.4094906020000053, + 1.3336834609999642, + 1.9475759569995716, + 2.957159199000671, + 1.2866745390001597, + 1.500234883000303, + 1.866931470000054, + 1.2234854989983432, + 1.4923265110010107, + 1.3786904589996993 + ], + "output_norm_ratios": [] + }, + "diffusion_48": { + "iterations": [ + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 294, + 300, + 300 + ], + "converged": [ + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + true, + false, + false + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 1.3854472130503531e-05, + 3.151994416594569e-05, + 8.84194855559533e-06, + 2.4825783353684386e-05, + 1.7357921024127584e-05, + 1.1972341616335178e-05, + 1.1392500423603892e-05, + 3.48239596499922e-06, + 5.995483441206114e-05, + 7.705356296735527e-06, + 1.1511282087871435e-05, + 0.0001685557868264237, + 4.176808570730504e-06, + 1.1903355850989998e-05, + 7.23588542186834e-05, + 9.211493157801205e-06, + 4.784817779346888e-06, + 2.9439216746055932e-05, + 1.0794759500647954e-05, + 9.407864726567066e-05, + 3.100227582940122e-06, + 1.257886709160684e-06, + 7.460275246354809e-06, + 7.358368697780394e-06, + 8.13088888195189e-06, + 1.7344789057880408e-05, + 4.42418574902606e-06, + 2.8449004774043142e-06, + 6.4740392004355995e-06, + 9.768345554104177e-06, + 1.0175339189872409e-05, + 3.646987444867763e-05, + 3.859695694392229e-05, + 2.9918148320932932e-05, + 6.655341464523835e-06, + 3.837960695886068e-05, + 2.539600248950996e-06, + 1.3040010410999403e-05, + 6.951318689145642e-06, + 0.00030606125367303104, + 7.299507856970886e-06, + 1.053955825727486e-05, + 8.155540506661418e-05, + 9.917395708127734e-06, + 6.824639858358961e-06, + 1.0444771356510019e-05, + 7.99034093250994e-06, + 9.848988210377003e-07, + 3.0201412851911496e-05, + 1.71873695688672e-05 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 2.26958372000081, + 2.2701626180005405, + 2.2054160669995326, + 2.181237480999698, + 3.1902613809998, + 2.373640145000536, + 2.3021379450001405, + 2.260985812999934, + 2.214874154999052, + 2.831264653999824, + 2.6664233669998794, + 2.2148948310004926, + 2.209519284000635, + 2.2092645020002237, + 2.384596623998732, + 3.222753186000773, + 2.217394969000452, + 2.181359706999501, + 2.262053778000336, + 2.2787382309998065, + 2.828222807000202, + 2.7595708789995115, + 2.1912056960009068, + 2.354176233999169, + 2.187110818000292, + 2.4928899530004855, + 3.051438593000057, + 2.2663484330005303, + 2.2814049999997223, + 2.366794589001074, + 2.257785776999299, + 3.001803443999961, + 2.4942989489991305, + 2.2235463969991542, + 2.2537172209995333, + 2.1935544309999386, + 2.427431682999668, + 2.8763931399989815, + 2.1647391080005036, + 2.2290185279998695, + 2.2140989209983672, + 2.172138828000243, + 2.854690430998744, + 2.5960625130010158, + 2.2314600530007738, + 2.2082297840006504, + 2.179051964998507, + 2.4383818410005915, + 2.954928220999136, + 2.116509835001125 + ], + "output_norm_ratios": [] + }, + "diffusion_64": { + "iterations": [ + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300 + ], + "converged": [ + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 0.0001366450213441476, + 0.00041978772902688684, + 0.0001732909012474272, + 5.769755323281471e-06, + 0.00016287973551992513, + 0.00024133228323891415, + 0.0005273600408512072, + 3.5328221636177535e-05, + 0.00010106612772413293, + 0.00016364961340765882, + 0.00040256947161018496, + 0.00010185230871511223, + 0.00017429128916917325, + 0.00039340954630889943, + 0.0003583087974773384, + 5.203024248725413e-05, + 0.0004760422171535279, + 0.00014262998919380355, + 0.00010091614806595295, + 0.00048010761313579297, + 0.00011808878156364075, + 0.00023929556419393822, + 0.0001236702849644425, + 0.00028100211064464376, + 0.0002514937242809076, + 0.00012433496556401032, + 0.0002985693234548136, + 0.0002333245829809952, + 1.0516273676199157e-05, + 0.0003371158978683571, + 0.0005251480168617193, + 0.00041553848595656965, + 0.00022724532028819264, + 0.0005271188330374732, + 0.00040524814012312944, + 0.00030486538132210576, + 0.0002290410293561841, + 0.00024826506742982866, + 0.00025679863574733404, + 0.00021829966102947156, + 0.0005332814059095293, + 0.0001453382699586066, + 6.7450431960017205e-06, + 0.00024237601999013437, + 0.0008237731808597504, + 7.582294558852601e-05, + 0.00033047052375050073, + 0.00011233169390249734, + 7.065526094940027e-05, + 7.783323602915091e-05 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 2.1695326370008843, + 2.2143940099995234, + 2.2261878789995535, + 2.856385600000067, + 2.497171437000361, + 2.1775674060008896, + 2.300806052999178, + 2.227116030000616, + 2.5173027029995865, + 2.943035806001717, + 2.1344860850003897, + 2.202444466000088, + 2.173487654999917, + 2.125452698999652, + 2.7186403249997966, + 2.7090328210015286, + 2.2145367289995193, + 2.1777995219999866, + 2.275094941000134, + 2.319959688999006, + 3.155228255998736, + 2.1353635550003673, + 2.2547483329999523, + 2.2600938649993623, + 2.1926264749999973, + 2.780702117999681, + 2.5502179820014135, + 2.247634225999718, + 2.1669694500014884, + 2.116877899999963, + 2.2468723120000504, + 3.187272925000798, + 2.1950721869998233, + 2.144380984000236, + 2.2045826059984392, + 2.2353245119993517, + 2.620846302001155, + 2.772884680000061, + 2.248607623998396, + 2.127049280999927, + 2.2237332679997053, + 2.2053545039998426, + 3.0709349019998626, + 2.3019666249983857, + 2.2236425900009635, + 2.271519881000131, + 2.1745410860003176, + 2.639201719999619, + 2.8123050760004844, + 2.20622287399965 + ], + "output_norm_ratios": [] + }, + "advection_16": { + "iterations": [ + 76, + 73, + 90, + 77, + 88, + 116, + 72, + 96, + 78, + 102, + 73, + 87, + 78, + 77, + 86, + 79, + 88, + 85, + 80, + 86, + 103, + 84, + 88, + 77, + 95, + 79, + 89, + 92, + 85, + 85, + 82, + 95, + 80, + 87, + 78, + 98, + 78, + 82, + 93, + 87, + 91, + 96, + 85, + 87, + 71, + 86, + 80, + 137, + 72, + 76 + ], + "converged": [ + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 9.718143321991784e-07, + 9.122055479574779e-07, + 9.370116020508474e-07, + 9.679335428137337e-07, + 9.436533993019255e-07, + 9.335422387289656e-07, + 9.299156054174642e-07, + 9.961707672694334e-07, + 9.455221448689774e-07, + 9.489205478787875e-07, + 8.583675743405242e-07, + 8.687082556379041e-07, + 9.32528098994054e-07, + 8.469289929623647e-07, + 9.156491826964039e-07, + 9.731322333951987e-07, + 8.940034276099769e-07, + 9.208607640816497e-07, + 9.07742782857586e-07, + 8.277243700099322e-07, + 9.709266788899639e-07, + 8.988018805846621e-07, + 9.440064040104704e-07, + 8.9872494444543e-07, + 9.073907566704926e-07, + 8.847302755940588e-07, + 8.719795036877706e-07, + 9.814427907244447e-07, + 9.443980161791432e-07, + 9.766665006733913e-07, + 9.140337968758862e-07, + 9.349277246420012e-07, + 9.902260658592955e-07, + 9.248944551584461e-07, + 9.054283062630651e-07, + 9.79643474565704e-07, + 9.434179746874839e-07, + 9.18191910545615e-07, + 9.511610254286776e-07, + 9.237646098262856e-07, + 8.841232404150961e-07, + 9.559823176701764e-07, + 8.972688115669871e-07, + 9.688353928794963e-07, + 8.457992468858255e-07, + 9.05240242252956e-07, + 9.608692680949125e-07, + 9.318427886528301e-07, + 9.616462511699961e-07, + 8.31713255676733e-07 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 0.518093303000569, + 0.48412289199950465, + 0.661700901999211, + 0.5235243099996296, + 0.6053230830002576, + 0.8299559489987587, + 0.48864042700006394, + 0.6632986039985553, + 0.5367128229991067, + 0.6684208210008364, + 0.46198816299875034, + 0.6565907750009501, + 0.6221884999995382, + 0.6956767899991974, + 0.8550350879995676, + 0.7404124100012268, + 0.8335487210006249, + 0.6253997170006187, + 0.5647126040003059, + 0.5770839180004259, + 0.7423578630005068, + 0.5661842360004812, + 0.613239132999297, + 0.5221895390004647, + 0.6513884760006476, + 0.546131241000694, + 0.5971633359986299, + 0.654088552999383, + 0.5853376549985114, + 0.5453768219995254, + 0.5370907680007804, + 0.6505606239988992, + 0.5995320259989967, + 0.8321060630005377, + 0.7768609859995195, + 0.9279985190005391, + 0.7867338980013301, + 0.5662340250000852, + 0.6560483020002721, + 0.5814114449985937, + 0.6717080860016722, + 0.619861117000255, + 0.5976412199997867, + 0.5788354590004019, + 0.4885057360006613, + 0.6123153600001388, + 0.5111788109988993, + 0.9344022979985311, + 0.4488176340000791, + 0.528091136000512 + ], + "output_norm_ratios": [] + }, + "advection_24": { + "iterations": [ + 136, + 134, + 135, + 132, + 147, + 156, + 117, + 140, + 141, + 159, + 131, + 138, + 163, + 162, + 138, + 124, + 141, + 150, + 145, + 166, + 144, + 142, + 146, + 150, + 148, + 123, + 124, + 139, + 150, + 110, + 137, + 151, + 136, + 185, + 132, + 129, + 137, + 144, + 154, + 159, + 156, + 151, + 149, + 131, + 151, + 159, + 109, + 146, + 144, + 140 + ], + "converged": [ + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 9.437356085028639e-07, + 9.421363524577145e-07, + 9.043839589617549e-07, + 9.252315795574487e-07, + 9.601219201722677e-07, + 9.935611570020508e-07, + 9.742203128624525e-07, + 9.85331571882182e-07, + 9.803229105608468e-07, + 9.911100675431261e-07, + 9.214691939008021e-07, + 9.218360827243469e-07, + 9.825998137876214e-07, + 9.56278090695707e-07, + 9.990079822128374e-07, + 9.693974318087603e-07, + 9.486303360471506e-07, + 9.650396235149125e-07, + 9.716856747684531e-07, + 9.128257031894614e-07, + 9.735687504296691e-07, + 9.827214834372433e-07, + 9.73033371267978e-07, + 9.787021252373499e-07, + 9.593040313252215e-07, + 9.88983350516275e-07, + 9.921580550165157e-07, + 9.872882249675288e-07, + 9.424780260930025e-07, + 9.167327279667823e-07, + 9.369988663751821e-07, + 9.64098138973436e-07, + 9.302330811569016e-07, + 9.618865391190452e-07, + 9.433437897845661e-07, + 9.236958999857104e-07, + 9.764224923990787e-07, + 9.351117183507452e-07, + 9.723588618767106e-07, + 9.480390462448927e-07, + 9.734938064205814e-07, + 9.953940045922743e-07, + 9.824487959177172e-07, + 9.585415969660046e-07, + 9.800244011192583e-07, + 9.512877685721629e-07, + 8.847064514916157e-07, + 9.674303074091307e-07, + 9.458332872001563e-07, + 9.142246842186444e-07 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 1.1088056139997207, + 1.2530985949997557, + 1.3670218700008263, + 0.9186366119993181, + 1.0178200890004518, + 1.1174786310002673, + 0.8102207940009976, + 1.001344729000266, + 0.9501111600002332, + 1.0897644899996521, + 0.8840450710013101, + 0.9483549960004893, + 1.1135354949983594, + 1.555588342000192, + 1.2947650180012715, + 0.9403844810003648, + 0.9473964759999944, + 1.0982990630000131, + 1.0725296210002853, + 1.1920585969983222, + 1.0120873039995786, + 1.015405918000397, + 1.0533919800000149, + 1.1067766659998597, + 1.2095615600010206, + 1.212292541998977, + 1.2431023589997494, + 1.1496378379997623, + 1.1350476509996952, + 0.803987313000107, + 0.9801323940009752, + 1.0981910369991965, + 0.9374814599996171, + 1.3104381859993737, + 0.8931050739993225, + 0.943891942000846, + 0.941819919999034, + 1.389168931000313, + 1.5664468840004702, + 1.2656241069998941, + 1.060589724998863, + 1.0302574800007278, + 1.0678982839999662, + 0.9124888999995164, + 1.035760331000347, + 1.1449528679986543, + 0.7485439569991286, + 1.0329548730005627, + 1.0116010649999225, + 1.3624095260001923 + ], + "output_norm_ratios": [] + }, + "advection_32": { + "iterations": [ + 272, + 229, + 222, + 230, + 237, + 180, + 269, + 224, + 187, + 232, + 218, + 215, + 190, + 221, + 184, + 202, + 229, + 253, + 207, + 240, + 202, + 161, + 224, + 214, + 156, + 220, + 204, + 234, + 207, + 209, + 186, + 212, + 166, + 217, + 219, + 264, + 215, + 205, + 220, + 174, + 232, + 226, + 208, + 180, + 267, + 196, + 244, + 172, + 208, + 231 + ], + "converged": [ + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 9.958797279677397e-07, + 9.990591101720724e-07, + 9.581449213648726e-07, + 9.672303530335022e-07, + 9.787708673453404e-07, + 9.499453212559806e-07, + 9.975618308690596e-07, + 9.634979157070442e-07, + 9.654664927271516e-07, + 9.672005336828114e-07, + 9.623478752430917e-07, + 9.780151701661417e-07, + 9.945605399256102e-07, + 9.79795487733634e-07, + 9.805094714992996e-07, + 9.89279397510592e-07, + 9.770700934283958e-07, + 9.826152059419185e-07, + 9.960579590985338e-07, + 9.735677987647252e-07, + 9.454376729413433e-07, + 9.880812548228956e-07, + 9.690893523589087e-07, + 9.922022878391267e-07, + 9.897771991825121e-07, + 9.951925259956054e-07, + 9.62176197151492e-07, + 9.968882116494094e-07, + 9.81071135964662e-07, + 9.975071846512368e-07, + 9.795361564876025e-07, + 9.733406584033958e-07, + 9.608101724786721e-07, + 9.887760224141278e-07, + 9.638999376050796e-07, + 9.769261819312608e-07, + 9.905776931465583e-07, + 9.783390807322794e-07, + 9.934809777457952e-07, + 9.913432087398352e-07, + 9.69543195247998e-07, + 9.984823150776678e-07, + 9.665153145748243e-07, + 9.668898354933913e-07, + 9.675113267575414e-07, + 9.601010319481957e-07, + 9.921077189756208e-07, + 9.931326733432371e-07, + 9.71739842824144e-07, + 9.727654576276057e-07 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 2.170548497000709, + 2.2298764690003736, + 1.8394685220009706, + 1.7172587200002454, + 1.7507213610006147, + 1.3502550780012825, + 1.9505875779996131, + 1.5080903319994832, + 1.741600692999782, + 2.2115100720002374, + 1.5530251519994636, + 1.5462249529991823, + 1.3326358329995855, + 1.5422267619997, + 1.3389418800015847, + 1.4224305860007007, + 2.0308406860003743, + 2.3725853789983375, + 1.4770750410007167, + 1.7511348619991622, + 1.4262043210001139, + 1.1536720229996718, + 1.6219794690005074, + 1.5461778870012495, + 1.3789610270014236, + 2.210448523001105, + 1.4759580820009433, + 1.7269122690013319, + 1.5151949970004353, + 1.5291312680001283, + 1.3204688419991726, + 1.5886349310003425, + 1.2572768489990267, + 2.116601587000332, + 1.7589922900006059, + 1.8503529520003212, + 1.4525080940002226, + 1.4756106949989771, + 1.5542475130005187, + 1.237679088000732, + 1.7605219449997094, + 2.267757534998964, + 1.624401000000944, + 1.3414775219989679, + 1.9046378030016058, + 1.4487801760005823, + 1.7763176270000258, + 1.2285827480009175, + 1.705302867001592, + 2.282564752000326 + ], + "output_norm_ratios": [] + }, + "advection_48": { + "iterations": [ + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300 + ], + "converged": [ + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 9.606632158540856e-06, + 1.824854453739814e-05, + 1.1722257895250752e-05, + 7.745117421806592e-06, + 1.447984588457328e-06, + 9.877818042262114e-06, + 2.2200560223053634e-05, + 5.386207049815389e-05, + 8.032851087307947e-05, + 4.83068685967078e-05, + 1.0698556978977972e-05, + 1.9405438238341444e-05, + 3.6218433438314975e-06, + 1.176222811488477e-05, + 4.2137378545763976e-05, + 4.985724535077392e-06, + 2.1314110846866733e-05, + 3.589883734704448e-05, + 2.7587648021307623e-05, + 3.891867209226718e-05, + 2.6566250211968874e-06, + 1.4968760838339665e-05, + 1.939519357218045e-05, + 1.5272499360814166e-05, + 3.3849417338401746e-05, + 9.8188875768611e-06, + 1.1758967644918342e-05, + 7.076933893263291e-06, + 8.63828869507428e-06, + 3.456166587717702e-05, + 7.206749802420773e-06, + 9.79841057849625e-06, + 2.6260030598924252e-05, + 2.192546087137719e-05, + 2.446560972584037e-05, + 2.4554692438809988e-05, + 0.00010921439782969647, + 1.710201003894254e-05, + 2.8546434044855668e-05, + 1.6372110925615886e-05, + 7.58044594222509e-05, + 3.85306112742662e-05, + 2.9722095384261075e-05, + 8.675899520779126e-06, + 4.2518161366894244e-06, + 9.117878688772542e-05, + 3.884105641919334e-05, + 7.5196579385882905e-06, + 3.26157771430911e-06, + 1.6259277916872979e-06 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 2.2251931719983986, + 2.2302098069994827, + 3.1527882579994184, + 2.299291239000013, + 2.2664313629993558, + 2.2057847479991324, + 2.1740052430013748, + 2.7087361289995897, + 2.674790186001701, + 2.2582050880009774, + 2.268415684999127, + 2.1964196899989474, + 2.2834197159991163, + 3.149684495998372, + 2.235308631001317, + 2.291805849001321, + 2.2037224039995635, + 2.187643245999425, + 2.6209090079992166, + 2.7383566469998186, + 2.2526812350006367, + 2.283237329998883, + 2.268365010000707, + 2.3391150740008015, + 3.1458365069993306, + 2.2254745720001665, + 2.1824756670011993, + 2.169284756999332, + 2.273095303999071, + 2.7775269689991546, + 2.628679514999021, + 2.2973922419987503, + 2.2749024370004918, + 2.2791173519999575, + 2.4008479669992084, + 2.945320290999007, + 2.2464328770001885, + 2.1741922450000857, + 2.19494588499947, + 2.2677077230000577, + 2.8285869709998224, + 2.5528908199994476, + 2.1807240350008215, + 2.19743122699947, + 2.2894656190001115, + 2.307605120999142, + 3.149333208999451, + 2.2283307629986666, + 2.2885215819987934, + 2.197574722000354 + ], + "output_norm_ratios": [] + }, + "advection_64": { + "iterations": [ + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300 + ], + "converged": [ + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 0.0006595299899435873, + 2.6379436632171394e-05, + 0.00014210088364708913, + 1.8412482398025537e-05, + 0.0005263991444558232, + 0.000127223553867124, + 0.0003198478289538816, + 0.0007744942654249026, + 0.0005222911910978883, + 1.5800018812432766e-05, + 0.0003005519812696422, + 0.00010767835956319249, + 0.0002152480576213952, + 0.00015420935752931392, + 9.942462403850002e-05, + 0.0002313874883394654, + 5.336311733760712e-05, + 2.1833762060793506e-05, + 6.561013650925888e-05, + 4.093569326370999e-05, + 0.0001161025936162115, + 8.00903401016909e-05, + 0.00011957320946048173, + 0.00020092284397656647, + 0.0006423984989522542, + 5.438555576944068e-05, + 0.0001262552456959843, + 0.00017467384302562384, + 0.00011352452705795763, + 7.420428139120921e-05, + 4.39637107845304e-05, + 0.00015474150917051588, + 0.00021386470717405854, + 0.0001978657112122713, + 0.00023899638628070748, + 0.00018159204476129242, + 0.0003411385903339678, + 0.00036040567750635755, + 0.00036643231958950295, + 0.000164432441999732, + 0.00020804834296003644, + 0.00024054677980105132, + 6.159883989118201e-05, + 8.089977728105096e-06, + 0.0007180265289332022, + 0.000511012680965732, + 8.181370668884438e-05, + 0.0006871352169152493, + 0.00018682058786117646, + 0.0004416856648004641 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 2.698348973000975, + 2.223733202999938, + 2.1981035140015592, + 2.1747174239990272, + 2.3165670199996384, + 3.0332664620000287, + 2.3104530069995235, + 2.2887795440001355, + 2.242439713998465, + 2.2174463820010715, + 2.5530950970005506, + 2.765090646000317, + 2.1551879109993024, + 2.250581214999329, + 2.109479320999526, + 2.213647309999942, + 2.909286771000552, + 2.5251855620008428, + 2.179375618999984, + 2.189156685999478, + 2.175984301000426, + 2.47962385000028, + 3.039978429000257, + 2.236059529999693, + 2.269733361999897, + 2.1554159890001756, + 2.24512726499961, + 2.9571627440000157, + 2.501371593998556, + 2.248695463000331, + 2.2389508910000586, + 2.2011695970013534, + 2.4508883229991625, + 2.878788093001276, + 2.1888518600007956, + 2.232962378000593, + 2.1789505289998488, + 2.24923776399919, + 2.8188893419992382, + 2.543080399000246, + 2.2345674240004882, + 2.1774810110000544, + 2.222205837999354, + 2.473822256999483, + 2.9193552269989596, + 2.1786185490000207, + 2.1860922209998535, + 2.292504357001235, + 2.215556781999112, + 2.826977080998404 + ], + "output_norm_ratios": [] + }, + "graph_laplacian_16": { + "iterations": [ + 15, + 15, + 13, + 15, + 15, + 16, + 14, + 15, + 16, + 15, + 15, + 15, + 14, + 15, + 15, + 15, + 15, + 13, + 15, + 15, + 15, + 15, + 16, + 14, + 16, + 14, + 15, + 15, + 14, + 14, + 14, + 15, + 15, + 15, + 14, + 15, + 15, + 16, + 14, + 16, + 15, + 14, + 13, + 13, + 15, + 15, + 12, + 15, + 14, + 13 + ], + "converged": [ + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 6.453485196816012e-07, + 8.063475388656881e-07, + 3.059211961452159e-07, + 5.917478079976073e-07, + 4.309358448730787e-07, + 5.076716761338638e-07, + 5.061026193271833e-07, + 7.756468745411865e-07, + 5.010324348931476e-07, + 5.505264194811978e-07, + 7.481778236825421e-07, + 4.6112364470593777e-07, + 9.351129189094019e-07, + 3.9991302668241093e-07, + 6.303065956859092e-07, + 3.923231106239795e-07, + 4.351735897196842e-07, + 6.437275957223996e-07, + 4.299033217716832e-07, + 9.310156893305854e-07, + 3.201508292945317e-07, + 9.303835995545249e-07, + 3.2419596783019254e-07, + 3.094311199384842e-07, + 4.516774840865542e-07, + 7.944840416105835e-07, + 3.644506765763192e-07, + 8.560536715503868e-07, + 4.1260815218351954e-07, + 6.717217069221615e-07, + 3.717468403133176e-07, + 4.833670047889586e-07, + 3.079133738210306e-07, + 4.479712053935133e-07, + 4.50646808893801e-07, + 5.827607116760607e-07, + 4.888693443754179e-07, + 3.949417545935857e-07, + 6.733411365265679e-07, + 4.385551588286863e-07, + 8.114640863726572e-07, + 8.731554518335042e-07, + 3.3621497120533397e-07, + 8.010559238767009e-07, + 6.657221308151047e-07, + 9.091312736106434e-07, + 8.079023750979906e-07, + 7.408169900656862e-07, + 6.119322382844901e-07, + 7.371368772115423e-07 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 0.06697732300017378, + 0.06764730100076122, + 0.04598570599955565, + 0.08561075999932655, + 0.07620587400015211, + 0.059052660000816104, + 0.06389377500090632, + 0.0707612460009841, + 0.07313123399944743, + 0.07074068099973374, + 0.06335926000065228, + 0.05871061399921018, + 0.0576579419994232, + 0.07723406700097257, + 0.06670189799842774, + 0.06659760299953632, + 0.062344640000446816, + 0.048110959000041476, + 0.06452766599977622, + 0.09235615599936864, + 0.061373934000584995, + 0.059034066000094754, + 0.07663098400007584, + 0.07107787200038729, + 0.07488858100077778, + 0.08643910700084234, + 0.06884954800079868, + 0.079625030999523, + 0.05979209299948707, + 0.05500635699900158, + 0.05954817200108664, + 0.07576260200039542, + 0.07877251200079627, + 0.06244212000092375, + 0.06509254500087991, + 0.06582544499906362, + 0.06900572099948477, + 0.07718138000018371, + 0.056943423000120674, + 0.07014257999981055, + 0.08877457800008415, + 0.06029329200100619, + 0.06094386599943391, + 0.05242284299856692, + 0.0618868969995674, + 0.0766702910004824, + 0.049160520000441466, + 0.06105504500010284, + 0.0755255340009171, + 0.0460728170000948 + ], + "output_norm_ratios": [] + }, + "graph_laplacian_24": { + "iterations": [ + 15, + 13, + 14, + 14, + 13, + 13, + 13, + 16, + 14, + 15, + 16, + 16, + 15, + 15, + 13, + 16, + 15, + 15, + 12, + 14, + 13, + 14, + 15, + 15, + 16, + 13, + 15, + 15, + 15, + 13, + 15, + 15, + 14, + 15, + 15, + 14, + 15, + 15, + 16, + 14, + 16, + 14, + 15, + 15, + 15, + 15, + 15, + 14, + 14, + 16 + ], + "converged": [ + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 9.685572424168298e-07, + 9.534477500258242e-07, + 7.446322493251304e-07, + 6.976711023712179e-07, + 9.892453949486002e-07, + 5.491142615560443e-07, + 6.348883752973584e-07, + 4.716922254169196e-07, + 3.752141687073385e-07, + 3.2854348597249175e-07, + 3.5078572602695866e-07, + 4.833972709475074e-07, + 7.039699159375219e-07, + 7.355020428553684e-07, + 5.667483333129983e-07, + 3.577899475716002e-07, + 5.667564274518597e-07, + 8.242625247248105e-07, + 5.681025871134767e-07, + 5.742548397632863e-07, + 2.906001613614028e-07, + 9.097534307217504e-07, + 8.994874458350741e-07, + 5.024292040382678e-07, + 5.159420756155439e-07, + 9.193664484064539e-07, + 7.264276383572151e-07, + 3.3586955421594017e-07, + 8.448934840667846e-07, + 4.81443488145944e-07, + 6.516678697540339e-07, + 4.831856926175933e-07, + 9.595036712446493e-07, + 5.683940284758194e-07, + 4.193462744599185e-07, + 7.172416378026506e-07, + 4.3844987091923733e-07, + 3.9547060674578245e-07, + 4.2849312733631756e-07, + 6.541113188011575e-07, + 5.572038507177135e-07, + 6.476697701951418e-07, + 5.488015207168084e-07, + 4.646311063997479e-07, + 9.60661250604674e-07, + 4.350354651294082e-07, + 3.786742336126309e-07, + 5.976025717019629e-07, + 7.322300316051575e-07, + 5.920623766815246e-07 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 0.08938796300026297, + 0.08822812600010366, + 0.09065257700058282, + 0.081679561000783, + 0.08274520499981008, + 0.07749256100032653, + 0.07644874900142895, + 0.10291906399834261, + 0.09502388700093434, + 0.07848953999928199, + 0.1004965380016074, + 0.1029657330000191, + 0.0896779949998745, + 0.08420373399894743, + 0.07327167899893539, + 0.12521137700059626, + 0.11800934099846927, + 0.11427052900035051, + 0.07278012099959597, + 0.08846186400114675, + 0.11800358299842628, + 0.10009443599847145, + 0.128309719999379, + 0.11027952900076343, + 0.09248979299991333, + 0.040138411000953056, + 0.09178495999913139, + 0.06466989399996237, + 0.07913948199893639, + 0.059013745998527156, + 0.05972893499892962, + 0.07586699999956181, + 0.06826256199929048, + 0.0909869829993113, + 0.06525407200024347, + 0.05278085600002669, + 0.08379470199906791, + 0.06165393400078756, + 0.06604229500044312, + 0.06198628400125017, + 0.09839520700006688, + 0.07022955000138609, + 0.07179331600127625, + 0.07265630500114639, + 0.0776613020007062, + 0.06231576999925892, + 0.09152164999977686, + 0.06992467300005956, + 0.05929014999856008, + 0.0847561209993728 + ], + "output_norm_ratios": [] + }, + "graph_laplacian_32": { + "iterations": [ + 14, + 15, + 15, + 15, + 14, + 13, + 16, + 15, + 13, + 15, + 13, + 14, + 14, + 15, + 15, + 14, + 14, + 14, + 12, + 16, + 15, + 15, + 15, + 15, + 16, + 14, + 14, + 15, + 14, + 15, + 13, + 15, + 15, + 15, + 14, + 13, + 13, + 15, + 15, + 14, + 15, + 14, + 15, + 15, + 15, + 13, + 15, + 15, + 15, + 14 + ], + "converged": [ + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 5.639665490284418e-07, + 3.1125341409717896e-07, + 4.979931516629534e-07, + 4.6234742550705397e-07, + 3.7886484483133694e-07, + 6.222206581128675e-07, + 4.817097031077225e-07, + 4.053637205038045e-07, + 7.361105449941111e-07, + 7.005321177558042e-07, + 3.309218409626273e-07, + 7.242135918292446e-07, + 8.411630927005288e-07, + 8.580059510367425e-07, + 3.788173057958908e-07, + 9.152837297381461e-07, + 2.601636042447545e-07, + 3.96497703274806e-07, + 4.837571770226861e-07, + 5.795722359847424e-07, + 9.241847136174708e-07, + 4.331562352472973e-07, + 4.3411822057852544e-07, + 5.723542193126875e-07, + 5.361511179139874e-07, + 4.3207302800217884e-07, + 7.55673378574189e-07, + 5.611774901740796e-07, + 4.1318769705048096e-07, + 5.265230716436877e-07, + 5.42937187455063e-07, + 8.106185731703002e-07, + 3.772859452574615e-07, + 3.955540861391151e-07, + 6.014479203559437e-07, + 7.548495693811321e-07, + 4.272301994911782e-07, + 5.498549117745822e-07, + 6.717852027851726e-07, + 6.327638998718577e-07, + 9.238762268602287e-07, + 4.810858121509034e-07, + 4.893245165401034e-07, + 5.382210110077102e-07, + 9.22364543016745e-07, + 3.015198532449528e-07, + 8.723904690988921e-07, + 8.409117989898697e-07, + 6.629463668420215e-07, + 8.059900193919009e-07 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 0.08639384500020242, + 0.07048493100046471, + 0.0766898729998502, + 0.06993380200037791, + 0.07998258899897337, + 0.04699342300045828, + 0.09542455900009372, + 0.057534433999535395, + 0.05091555299986794, + 0.07301246400129457, + 0.05633893199956219, + 0.06772394200015697, + 0.07261112299966044, + 0.09577761899890902, + 0.06146469499981322, + 0.10040676800053916, + 0.05960036500073329, + 0.0715363540002727, + 0.04177841299861029, + 0.08082105600078648, + 0.06937560500045947, + 0.0647712270001648, + 0.0806220399990707, + 0.08900211699983629, + 0.08062654500099597, + 0.06617000899859704, + 0.07497741999941354, + 0.06437594700037153, + 0.056124672999430913, + 0.10880690399972082, + 0.06826881100096216, + 0.06250256699968304, + 0.0856176930010406, + 0.06439717400098743, + 0.052546770000844845, + 0.06605010400016909, + 0.05685510900002555, + 0.07240152200029115, + 0.12532469000143465, + 0.08093110000118031, + 0.092910954999752, + 0.10515170100006799, + 0.12085971499982406, + 0.0960835189998761, + 0.08799221600020246, + 0.073562485000366, + 0.09760961499887344, + 0.08223602500038396, + 0.09602472199912881, + 0.08214129499901901 + ], + "output_norm_ratios": [] + }, + "graph_laplacian_48": { + "iterations": [ + 15, + 14, + 15, + 13, + 14, + 15, + 16, + 15, + 15, + 13, + 15, + 14, + 14, + 13, + 14, + 14, + 14, + 14, + 14, + 15, + 14, + 15, + 14, + 14, + 12, + 15, + 15, + 15, + 13, + 15, + 14, + 15, + 14, + 14, + 15, + 14, + 15, + 14, + 15, + 14, + 13, + 14, + 15, + 14, + 12, + 13, + 15, + 12, + 13, + 14 + ], + "converged": [ + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 5.75782602346297e-07, + 7.021416979589977e-07, + 4.004324475714804e-07, + 3.236803702574098e-07, + 7.287679015807443e-07, + 3.453898709562086e-07, + 4.5291170573723867e-07, + 3.6508253656455786e-07, + 6.584914793718901e-07, + 9.969263905009098e-07, + 7.743346125416634e-07, + 4.6075405207081235e-07, + 9.925343910453046e-07, + 7.520465261680521e-07, + 7.042557061280799e-07, + 4.0362146228991843e-07, + 8.272026420258314e-07, + 5.160457320731689e-07, + 6.697198113736777e-07, + 4.0040271829401575e-07, + 6.41269831050093e-07, + 4.5238295930080185e-07, + 5.755729472661154e-07, + 5.044865657916293e-07, + 9.827663301376754e-07, + 6.794712507215882e-07, + 5.881066998860217e-07, + 6.411344015044372e-07, + 8.072582405522004e-07, + 7.474727959089767e-07, + 6.071144319615666e-07, + 5.815909989432128e-07, + 6.406124350626233e-07, + 7.08962055580993e-07, + 3.8150145616792964e-07, + 5.49685336443127e-07, + 6.262136832249233e-07, + 4.86537279969306e-07, + 5.10139336861855e-07, + 6.731872467848175e-07, + 6.72478724165684e-07, + 6.295586850216064e-07, + 5.695383507610954e-07, + 9.961449579468107e-07, + 5.857774688768741e-07, + 7.115302207455089e-07, + 4.4663520937729946e-07, + 4.97500229650269e-07, + 2.7171949626846024e-07, + 4.993435000921728e-07 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 0.061628662999282824, + 0.07772492499861983, + 0.05431492100251489, + 0.062149112000042805, + 0.08520810099798837, + 0.0975020920013776, + 0.08929388099932112, + 0.07215660400106572, + 0.0861933330015745, + 0.04766693599958671, + 0.05810837399985758, + 0.059659091999492375, + 0.0649517179990653, + 0.048202529000263894, + 0.07052214899886167, + 0.07476379299987457, + 0.053740395000204444, + 0.05467637800029479, + 0.07120812799985288, + 0.07773534200168797, + 0.10828720599965891, + 0.07610486199700972, + 0.06497219900120399, + 0.06104094799957238, + 0.06406854099986958, + 0.08066391800093697, + 0.07104491499922005, + 0.06692432300042128, + 0.06108769200000097, + 0.07229113400171627, + 0.06240299599812715, + 0.07541795400175033, + 0.07378259699908085, + 0.056359917998634046, + 0.09538438500021584, + 0.07554864299891051, + 0.06866155799798435, + 0.05859367400262272, + 0.08008951600277214, + 0.060723008999048034, + 0.06181363400173723, + 0.07000400100150728, + 0.06639335599902552, + 0.05870500300079584, + 0.04011892800190253, + 0.06084852699859766, + 0.08362916400074027, + 0.05378445099995588, + 0.06234186399888131, + 0.0642871109994303 + ], + "output_norm_ratios": [] + }, + "graph_laplacian_64": { + "iterations": [ + 13, + 15, + 15, + 15, + 14, + 15, + 11, + 15, + 14, + 14, + 15, + 15, + 13, + 15, + 16, + 14, + 15, + 14, + 14, + 13, + 12, + 15, + 15, + 14, + 13, + 13, + 16, + 13, + 12, + 13, + 13, + 14, + 15, + 15, + 14, + 12, + 14, + 13, + 14, + 14, + 14, + 13, + 14, + 14, + 13, + 14, + 14, + 13, + 15, + 15 + ], + "converged": [ + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 9.143303449321515e-07, + 6.395899512171788e-07, + 7.676830044780108e-07, + 4.1412505425968884e-07, + 6.358319014449181e-07, + 8.588795489224464e-07, + 6.807366394052386e-07, + 4.7246865997203616e-07, + 4.02847453778561e-07, + 7.024812138471397e-07, + 6.23115857365115e-07, + 6.809557396931026e-07, + 7.847180327789624e-07, + 4.021301302685496e-07, + 3.932447307543083e-07, + 7.027816310206955e-07, + 7.727219907663402e-07, + 7.181231044008859e-07, + 6.714566389692024e-07, + 3.1243897900453693e-07, + 7.374907191424175e-07, + 4.428219551202401e-07, + 5.182219639966537e-07, + 9.169181944594187e-07, + 9.390348757906263e-07, + 3.7572164868701993e-07, + 4.039081728398161e-07, + 8.668029453637514e-07, + 8.763910035842387e-07, + 3.319118579941246e-07, + 7.364343140507393e-07, + 9.065571249310246e-07, + 6.1460193452689e-07, + 5.096994483046753e-07, + 6.80378206604966e-07, + 7.554853846646904e-07, + 7.423311804647193e-07, + 7.913150539412331e-07, + 3.1733666374552523e-07, + 4.1061612301216035e-07, + 3.6629862155109527e-07, + 8.966308970781747e-07, + 8.114279143543767e-07, + 4.102952215115457e-07, + 6.105372069699232e-07, + 7.82802299956654e-07, + 7.139975757268157e-07, + 3.135084366807461e-07, + 5.936721436468854e-07, + 6.02426788433767e-07 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 0.07606860400119331, + 0.08855260799828102, + 0.0853681590015185, + 0.08857616399836843, + 0.07260196300194366, + 0.09329311699912068, + 0.07061582899768837, + 0.11388141199859092, + 0.08386043200152926, + 0.07950326199716073, + 0.08381755000300473, + 0.11872950799806858, + 0.08373637800104916, + 0.1012041380017763, + 0.13675502200203482, + 0.10346265800035326, + 0.06664126599935116, + 0.05924878799851285, + 0.07143515099960496, + 0.053651643997000065, + 0.06101344899798278, + 0.07174335799936671, + 0.0621530040007201, + 0.0623389779975696, + 0.06407539499923587, + 0.057794246000412386, + 0.09262012600083835, + 0.05343374199946993, + 0.04712836199905723, + 0.0475043110018305, + 0.06519534399922122, + 0.06449357500241604, + 0.0805628029993386, + 0.06438783600242459, + 0.05085011500341352, + 0.06614913900193642, + 0.05950467000002391, + 0.0554501970000274, + 0.06432971399772214, + 0.058158783001999836, + 0.054572021999774734, + 0.05033419300161768, + 0.055039381000824505, + 0.051654585000505904, + 0.06083607899927301, + 0.05855717800295679, + 0.07207835900044302, + 0.07359018799979822, + 0.06989625999995042, + 0.07322559200110845 + ], + "output_norm_ratios": [] + } + } + }, + { + "name": "Jacobi", + "param_count": 0, + "train_time": 0.0, + "train_history": [], + "best_loss": null, + "best_epoch": null, + "eval": { + "diffusion_16": { + "iterations": [ + 60, + 59, + 63, + 61, + 60, + 60, + 60, + 73, + 59, + 64, + 65, + 67, + 52, + 64, + 66, + 57, + 63, + 76, + 62, + 57, + 64, + 68, + 65, + 64, + 59, + 63, + 57, + 66, + 65, + 58, + 63, + 64, + 64, + 63, + 72, + 58, + 67, + 66, + 73, + 65, + 66, + 69, + 59, + 64, + 58, + 60, + 62, + 59, + 62, + 63 + ], + "converged": [ + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 6.708087056156708e-07, + 8.465346642056083e-07, + 8.153396518224927e-07, + 9.56538750122392e-07, + 9.395300106666676e-07, + 8.597030650544497e-07, + 8.414893775889283e-07, + 9.456357859313334e-07, + 8.934342399704001e-07, + 8.745752521002488e-07, + 8.319318985914743e-07, + 8.311591854393603e-07, + 9.138452434974226e-07, + 9.359629541969526e-07, + 7.840423403509742e-07, + 9.05997687993306e-07, + 8.005286913954178e-07, + 9.850331115899587e-07, + 9.987194780191872e-07, + 7.402039988368571e-07, + 8.933180466349121e-07, + 9.096472036387135e-07, + 7.775313980144254e-07, + 9.76999057267262e-07, + 9.789375721610366e-07, + 9.542793928881982e-07, + 9.859474051257982e-07, + 7.743853237603085e-07, + 8.710664930047283e-07, + 9.517623443256831e-07, + 8.908199770099592e-07, + 9.674541413699436e-07, + 8.949319953654445e-07, + 8.732202948182601e-07, + 9.015577156967966e-07, + 9.795418450174831e-07, + 9.761913149385656e-07, + 9.892311774130763e-07, + 9.771212852332817e-07, + 7.67122454510306e-07, + 8.577457335808811e-07, + 9.734599923316441e-07, + 7.660751997512525e-07, + 9.73713975354029e-07, + 8.982218427033723e-07, + 8.761419291553662e-07, + 8.863785286353747e-07, + 9.271404074247394e-07, + 7.934103367333988e-07, + 8.091612246879517e-07 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 0.4316623859995161, + 0.4518934989991976, + 0.46407439899849123, + 0.4970137140007864, + 0.43957787299950724, + 0.4579364759993041, + 0.45693625599960797, + 0.7329880549987138, + 0.5682650239996292, + 0.6231799699999101, + 0.6064444429994182, + 0.7251277350005694, + 0.3615053749999788, + 0.41646769599901745, + 0.4441651359993557, + 0.44490766700073436, + 0.4725649220017658, + 0.5230436750007357, + 0.4378107769989583, + 0.3994506540002476, + 0.4760092779997649, + 0.41397705000053975, + 0.4895147489987721, + 0.4614126660017064, + 0.42773587299961946, + 0.46852642700105207, + 0.3984469110000646, + 0.5254781490002642, + 0.47176405800018983, + 0.42302751100032765, + 0.4659221109995997, + 0.47809163099918806, + 0.49559354499979236, + 0.5507716219999566, + 0.6958870540001953, + 0.6285785780000879, + 0.6345416519998253, + 0.640957884999807, + 0.6933549670011416, + 0.4976337589996547, + 0.4238908799998171, + 0.47228806899875053, + 0.4348750110002584, + 0.5248044850013684, + 0.42868206999992253, + 0.45080272700033674, + 0.4803601149997121, + 0.4663516159998835, + 0.4410265779988549, + 0.4460015000004205 + ], + "output_norm_ratios": [ + 6.967227637905316, + 7.10027753411477, + 6.4400567728062175, + 7.081447799316392, + 5.874671075724635, + 11.563352146892008, + 6.560023517055922, + 8.895654654141131, + 11.975848969395374, + 11.448280453013211, + 8.207268970319255, + 8.489541561168405, + 7.671626909539859, + 8.305099219125841, + 7.024519287929774, + 9.253752038767955, + 7.608342366124599, + 12.078196176975975, + 7.347508935296049, + 9.305806618307075, + 6.0837517219055925, + 7.277983457590531, + 7.512671467491361, + 5.629792203297014, + 4.7533909496693125, + 4.22981740215172, + 6.7459664203458445, + 7.676653739708354, + 6.13913004679981, + 6.504802869093137, + 9.365393799771649, + 5.169124183356564, + 8.114147863649332, + 12.549743928778385, + 14.582015878556835, + 9.23834013052269, + 6.509665368220364, + 7.47783123220339, + 9.038186333486884, + 9.40571855568934, + 6.888820243475793, + 9.303453815418724, + 6.678022111580343, + 7.97773827102028, + 6.245628836137066, + 7.8358247763457385, + 14.65426359982364, + 5.804618134821111, + 9.890803050144179, + 7.366868311617709 + ] + }, + "diffusion_24": { + "iterations": [ + 107, + 102, + 90, + 85, + 104, + 120, + 96, + 106, + 77, + 96, + 98, + 117, + 86, + 86, + 88, + 116, + 106, + 106, + 107, + 83, + 108, + 104, + 116, + 89, + 93, + 94, + 95, + 109, + 114, + 88, + 85, + 103, + 125, + 90, + 97, + 100, + 86, + 98, + 115, + 100, + 95, + 108, + 104, + 118, + 102, + 94, + 98, + 104, + 93, + 98 + ], + "converged": [ + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 9.501697865132222e-07, + 9.685828753786542e-07, + 9.712296120537103e-07, + 9.777959892397187e-07, + 9.099849157810618e-07, + 9.527324538859602e-07, + 9.397230171258985e-07, + 9.645750934262094e-07, + 9.688656301315734e-07, + 9.401428153958492e-07, + 9.974144310990905e-07, + 9.013611044949054e-07, + 9.115632145693658e-07, + 9.279744327212972e-07, + 9.463440561280153e-07, + 9.740388449777733e-07, + 8.956768495828546e-07, + 9.889183548465864e-07, + 9.664545743571749e-07, + 9.405415101910002e-07, + 9.228517035753113e-07, + 9.772402518603855e-07, + 9.419192106278994e-07, + 8.524890387248466e-07, + 9.434436717152893e-07, + 9.788354946962626e-07, + 9.146913765374172e-07, + 9.354338163843157e-07, + 9.275691266042271e-07, + 9.099230170364651e-07, + 9.26491690234139e-07, + 9.759316874411817e-07, + 9.786922196558249e-07, + 9.415560252780729e-07, + 9.596378893054994e-07, + 8.541471661801306e-07, + 9.469683243373322e-07, + 9.469846797452139e-07, + 9.535179867394463e-07, + 9.326419711048768e-07, + 9.402595091774319e-07, + 9.074277679990606e-07, + 9.266935075080868e-07, + 8.789584740649936e-07, + 9.231513239550372e-07, + 9.90260874762869e-07, + 9.516958950595354e-07, + 9.929716783821423e-07, + 9.354029977203842e-07, + 9.68080763950362e-07 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 0.7907033279989264, + 0.7627772739997454, + 0.8436414089992468, + 0.8922950980013411, + 1.0081508040002518, + 1.2457474959992396, + 0.7036526920001052, + 0.7607385909996083, + 0.5816928380008903, + 0.6668539729998884, + 0.6979656600015005, + 0.9180812169997807, + 0.5705500580006628, + 0.6320591340008832, + 0.7050109860010707, + 0.85229604900087, + 0.771857091000129, + 0.7852142449992243, + 0.7718321150005067, + 0.799302182998872, + 1.0576945480006543, + 1.0822598300001118, + 1.1007083149997925, + 0.6665807299996231, + 0.6481389439995837, + 0.6819849710009294, + 0.7253383510014828, + 0.803091312000106, + 0.8232438560007722, + 0.5984795360000135, + 0.6292434049992153, + 0.7743747999993502, + 0.8850512809985958, + 0.6630672909996065, + 0.7073794469997665, + 0.7123490930007392, + 0.9249073259998113, + 0.9701115779989777, + 1.2301343879989872, + 0.949842305999482, + 0.7456372830001783, + 0.7784795770003257, + 0.7727130570001464, + 0.8923073780006234, + 0.7484868510000524, + 0.6691341799996735, + 0.7259336229999462, + 0.7556692600010138, + 0.6493739329998789, + 0.7374620720001985 + ], + "output_norm_ratios": [ + 9.76589090990125, + 7.4432479753659, + 8.162999455070862, + 7.847160673476506, + 11.423652085904275, + 10.025735838576237, + 6.232990830570206, + 5.007107622077026, + 10.326950610859548, + 11.729635982020532, + 9.146672680602794, + 10.532377539631867, + 13.088334092653055, + 9.309611855011697, + 7.898857571638986, + 14.565589209168085, + 9.793482252784191, + 4.636983137694426, + 7.54594280317989, + 7.756685511339, + 9.335292998551532, + 9.271174378101323, + 8.798345382638693, + 8.319677122885366, + 7.757636422372387, + 11.01360980360764, + 4.8703022528085915, + 6.065726159960549, + 8.894407615719713, + 11.306932626333847, + 8.631742075409255, + 8.439507490092412, + 15.400856527017773, + 5.471188529039265, + 9.272785082161347, + 9.193507152987763, + 6.9274900923123655, + 8.044326818317652, + 4.58843574829277, + 9.568355289082664, + 7.154613806235157, + 11.358192308360813, + 6.547219558148808, + 13.44459455142369, + 10.59007189971037, + 9.130954097429845, + 9.823493864741836, + 7.651705299671155, + 15.11781266402745, + 7.3956830734540695 + ] + }, + "diffusion_32": { + "iterations": [ + 129, + 118, + 127, + 131, + 132, + 143, + 136, + 136, + 118, + 137, + 135, + 122, + 145, + 143, + 128, + 135, + 129, + 137, + 114, + 136, + 137, + 139, + 135, + 142, + 137, + 152, + 139, + 133, + 170, + 169, + 183, + 131, + 142, + 146, + 160, + 147, + 154, + 138, + 133, + 118, + 145, + 119, + 120, + 150, + 123, + 128, + 130, + 109, + 133, + 160 + ], + "converged": [ + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 9.517849306736912e-07, + 9.76450743334652e-07, + 9.347284533956831e-07, + 9.531470926246117e-07, + 9.66588220708983e-07, + 9.963090213463523e-07, + 9.859098078343737e-07, + 9.681439561309772e-07, + 9.8184020905672e-07, + 9.179072029626713e-07, + 9.953417450839282e-07, + 9.663080915715437e-07, + 9.637097305413406e-07, + 9.615892296841752e-07, + 9.831823791904982e-07, + 9.57645190414829e-07, + 9.844300190379911e-07, + 9.644836031561537e-07, + 9.95822493882966e-07, + 9.10312187802261e-07, + 9.365116093090341e-07, + 9.474211046115876e-07, + 9.533813139016586e-07, + 9.246252848219496e-07, + 9.78399039929858e-07, + 9.585945534962318e-07, + 9.543722072611943e-07, + 9.149345098814469e-07, + 9.555534031950686e-07, + 8.698239584435297e-07, + 9.335061810420696e-07, + 9.159340485845265e-07, + 9.983429013419518e-07, + 9.611745894992502e-07, + 9.377585295112028e-07, + 9.65724272182156e-07, + 9.719704179056168e-07, + 9.797803985652646e-07, + 9.553140815383484e-07, + 9.522108641282039e-07, + 9.613885343350845e-07, + 9.561388263933097e-07, + 9.112619133730419e-07, + 9.835946256534267e-07, + 9.73557730325566e-07, + 9.890575328700702e-07, + 9.773930925193746e-07, + 9.914967764881638e-07, + 9.427363868363468e-07, + 9.781966241837408e-07 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 1.2526930940002785, + 1.207736581998688, + 1.269749007999053, + 0.9846307150000939, + 1.0078668849982932, + 0.9498615949996747, + 1.0313525120000122, + 0.9673173770006542, + 0.9179868760002137, + 0.9625000310006726, + 0.9779472709997208, + 0.8975534709989006, + 1.047374944000694, + 1.4787329920000047, + 1.2919714559993736, + 1.242802782000581, + 0.9745823670000391, + 0.9870595849988604, + 0.8185433489998104, + 1.073075026000879, + 1.0332878610006446, + 0.9762889270004962, + 0.9364033229994675, + 1.0163205770004424, + 0.989869622999322, + 1.2724330250002822, + 1.364598666999882, + 1.3358813260001625, + 1.2153438159984944, + 1.2125140949992783, + 1.3898778809998475, + 0.922579209000105, + 1.025263122999604, + 1.0826591120003286, + 1.1475671700009116, + 1.094199932000265, + 1.3910709869996936, + 1.3200895090012637, + 1.403540695000629, + 0.9433180899995932, + 1.036358809000376, + 0.8997824350008159, + 0.9062108669986628, + 1.100398929000221, + 0.8947368610006379, + 0.9169925449987204, + 0.9347360680003476, + 0.8605794849991071, + 0.9241857650013117, + 1.59572867299903 + ], + "output_norm_ratios": [ + 9.245007081087838, + 10.420930645397226, + 9.218304781709755, + 5.357500330171955, + 10.446684555695965, + 10.766349994945466, + 11.480247080405457, + 12.17762426635762, + 8.002273573272623, + 11.08664669139037, + 6.62611533086512, + 12.861159001419555, + 6.117233143697796, + 8.503544345617472, + 12.482437812972513, + 14.003570735946337, + 6.501859851606862, + 10.778545460712966, + 6.810052782707888, + 9.502206489676409, + 8.258357729870145, + 6.796385169432162, + 7.548642943744241, + 8.370664808838379, + 13.685488094436897, + 9.353120158273333, + 6.368480489718611, + 7.548309734772438, + 6.451631873254017, + 11.981635649451905, + 6.657730584834446, + 7.269838641226336, + 8.028375212528346, + 10.082217781376865, + 8.425151492761055, + 6.896082492666248, + 17.305219927872347, + 5.533544499707085, + 10.296865723718424, + 12.951493197641565, + 8.100339824018615, + 6.732179517927381, + 19.913425058041177, + 12.071445263289515, + 11.303877429039774, + 7.286497603158904, + 12.702556514993343, + 8.716127436962388, + 12.34812587985495, + 8.643356345224815 + ] + }, + "diffusion_48": { + "iterations": [ + 285, + 224, + 233, + 211, + 230, + 262, + 203, + 212, + 220, + 205, + 200, + 290, + 231, + 207, + 294, + 198, + 215, + 257, + 251, + 187, + 221, + 234, + 204, + 240, + 229, + 226, + 199, + 218, + 229, + 224, + 203, + 205, + 247, + 283, + 217, + 247, + 218, + 206, + 229, + 225, + 192, + 230, + 231, + 267, + 242, + 235, + 215, + 182, + 244, + 256 + ], + "converged": [ + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 9.468050501692576e-07, + 9.535663763056784e-07, + 9.890188849743251e-07, + 9.808417293766557e-07, + 9.254862773191359e-07, + 9.94999425336237e-07, + 9.790582988390954e-07, + 9.996152207584533e-07, + 9.600503686722855e-07, + 9.965463030635716e-07, + 9.729495974958623e-07, + 9.912832539158614e-07, + 9.931584100657014e-07, + 9.352726990453705e-07, + 9.748691458387106e-07, + 9.438928894489017e-07, + 9.846995550354372e-07, + 9.722425300350275e-07, + 9.542150107878644e-07, + 9.151486530625436e-07, + 9.425719189655726e-07, + 9.615924767687077e-07, + 9.785476601942811e-07, + 9.632205017417022e-07, + 9.710309836366145e-07, + 9.773008061582657e-07, + 9.965706294492985e-07, + 9.6377010042751e-07, + 9.97990340463535e-07, + 9.819972838258574e-07, + 9.020078316844452e-07, + 9.641517839299883e-07, + 9.970619881226232e-07, + 9.692444479351408e-07, + 9.764963712106117e-07, + 9.63392336720883e-07, + 9.964396036037768e-07, + 9.634501306942175e-07, + 9.953585739884618e-07, + 9.813112340941838e-07, + 9.624229962150605e-07, + 9.637899616866222e-07, + 9.60710361856223e-07, + 9.898085543724494e-07, + 9.658347853949757e-07, + 9.705010433346468e-07, + 9.69539838646566e-07, + 9.799373415005335e-07, + 9.326814109865706e-07, + 9.71563885469943e-07 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 2.1534902830007923, + 1.6056845969997084, + 1.683389169000293, + 1.501474483000493, + 2.060610591001023, + 2.358637331000864, + 1.5137356560007902, + 1.5964251899986266, + 1.6736589609990915, + 1.5182815869993647, + 1.447382139000183, + 2.5222628299998178, + 2.2385794359997817, + 1.5270500570004515, + 2.1044043739984772, + 1.412466368999958, + 1.5628655239997897, + 1.8422485290011537, + 2.1588820939996367, + 1.8910341110004083, + 1.693827760998829, + 1.6434107980003319, + 1.5319121039992751, + 1.6728577349986153, + 1.676363921000302, + 1.6777985480002826, + 1.8967779630002042, + 2.0936672529987845, + 1.72654002300078, + 1.651811537998583, + 1.4741751500005194, + 1.4765595230001054, + 1.8250406719998864, + 2.352642912999727, + 2.268048934000035, + 1.8746169149999332, + 1.573822313999699, + 1.5277323379996233, + 1.6815489270011312, + 1.6472222249994957, + 1.3846684680011094, + 2.137879170000815, + 2.15484587300125, + 1.9082872710005176, + 1.7550670200016611, + 1.6383803810003883, + 1.603866539999217, + 1.3440821709991724, + 2.1640704830006143, + 2.3199609620005504 + ], + "output_norm_ratios": [ + 13.791299800531329, + 9.877155674437123, + 10.365126566611922, + 10.597671810274248, + 10.198342611766762, + 10.713316955492258, + 10.077119721194931, + 7.398960677104313, + 12.516525820271507, + 9.295259659734809, + 11.84275642229812, + 13.49932545659748, + 7.859882027803666, + 9.700101700707865, + 6.311424705143364, + 10.66015230724396, + 12.655028839861599, + 10.09070821754657, + 5.674572162302369, + 13.173320963126887, + 6.194515334667959, + 8.238732763419229, + 16.328984278418616, + 8.743551937145456, + 9.782512592827606, + 8.041758204586452, + 6.958080594331388, + 11.060602534161447, + 8.837647565941241, + 10.74626859362496, + 8.845404291178207, + 12.58843636210563, + 10.510716146021633, + 10.62409140426333, + 10.983190280898299, + 12.867342485491776, + 11.5407851503084, + 10.434300398483506, + 10.322092171627794, + 12.43192210970838, + 10.129115382654147, + 10.119299602149667, + 10.606207227116485, + 7.61870974402955, + 12.663502459394985, + 6.088093880584576, + 13.575947821269974, + 8.787585704780065, + 7.634285581306088, + 8.571918780243804 + ] + }, + "diffusion_64": { + "iterations": [ + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 288, + 300, + 278, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 248, + 300, + 300, + 292, + 259, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 298, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 295, + 300, + 300, + 300 + ], + "converged": [ + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + true, + false, + true, + false, + false, + false, + true, + false, + false, + true, + true, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + true, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + true, + false, + false, + false, + true, + false, + false, + false + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 7.295290300771852e-06, + 7.252795964780817e-06, + 2.3755149248288087e-05, + 1.2925362781774265e-06, + 1.588677981492911e-05, + 8.932687342117921e-06, + 9.87498814495194e-07, + 1.8961144408624013e-06, + 9.68516497518139e-07, + 1.4770300899779324e-06, + 1.4007432891912807e-05, + 4.061310928876794e-06, + 9.564107496240867e-07, + 2.0132274616929314e-05, + 7.819931105547257e-06, + 9.37333483397283e-07, + 9.874092326361934e-07, + 1.0480239847861957e-05, + 8.768126455629478e-06, + 6.185952518670073e-06, + 1.6184139987998695e-06, + 2.616548094611876e-06, + 5.32525897452337e-06, + 1.825223896073355e-05, + 1.0152735392178355e-05, + 1.4036307711416926e-06, + 3.0544334809360797e-06, + 9.962388518455054e-07, + 1.2261621160876834e-06, + 2.224350651066431e-05, + 1.344664299887792e-05, + 3.937122261259651e-05, + 2.180573050574504e-06, + 2.60682272940275e-06, + 1.6198633798970968e-05, + 7.2536285874298226e-06, + 2.597946405795183e-06, + 8.519803253942452e-06, + 6.449517567937904e-06, + 4.0169809963810385e-06, + 6.720815678977886e-06, + 1.421596342006875e-06, + 9.59105412633265e-07, + 3.989686508676625e-06, + 5.498955981072249e-06, + 3.2068157069241942e-06, + 9.999973109407306e-07, + 2.6347911804863023e-06, + 1.8521290632127246e-06, + 3.345960986194464e-06 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 2.2994227630006208, + 2.181267203999596, + 2.08496120000018, + 2.928604009999617, + 2.4172063919995708, + 2.2361815250005748, + 1.9661261770015699, + 2.213436373998775, + 2.0960946889990737, + 3.1552518799999234, + 2.188872837999952, + 2.2260922440000286, + 1.751519207000456, + 2.1944119520012464, + 2.540920543999164, + 2.712992579999991, + 1.8833179879984527, + 2.2407546049998928, + 2.179359783000109, + 2.189421062999827, + 2.8475215300004493, + 2.5753900179988705, + 2.1917223279997415, + 2.2128337390004162, + 2.2049804630005383, + 2.31763908999892, + 3.1156523730005574, + 2.1755844460003573, + 2.165058365000732, + 2.2006255260002945, + 2.2618140960003075, + 2.708702052999797, + 2.6406212739984767, + 2.1535844859990902, + 2.145267279000109, + 2.280043143999137, + 2.338737084999593, + 3.1419641360007518, + 2.1894875199996022, + 2.224232728000061, + 2.26398455799972, + 2.138668195999344, + 2.718884928999614, + 2.6658297869998933, + 2.18884848900052, + 2.201736508999602, + 2.1601473029986664, + 2.2155336260002514, + 3.2958383509994746, + 2.131256184000449 + ], + "output_norm_ratios": [ + 10.501857854959544, + 12.077572505687346, + 6.409999853809439, + 7.531232318299778, + 8.001431216464635, + 10.750520124894331, + 11.160927070442197, + 9.725624686617302, + 12.236874292501335, + 10.489011059336043, + 8.906769503435546, + 5.070229403068458, + 12.826521125593898, + 14.083552571681059, + 11.77938492147393, + 9.846723923881655, + 14.717424378650318, + 8.641907034684078, + 7.074261324463813, + 11.01459752959797, + 10.359655405857314, + 15.367553179738517, + 7.180905734132778, + 10.415213919797605, + 13.005482804672386, + 10.56982422361067, + 14.126010361003646, + 10.711276459782813, + 6.097940699218328, + 12.35664954349768, + 13.897023914927823, + 8.480973641670028, + 15.109311258904569, + 11.079892247882123, + 10.993523990667919, + 10.134546054177356, + 15.411119167241118, + 7.568300049517873, + 10.819960725845094, + 11.754225127893786, + 14.389098765002515, + 10.96757884390982, + 5.817013728551479, + 10.748532092936015, + 12.737349811727906, + 8.290240735562975, + 15.519773128360205, + 12.147555058431301, + 18.84690174267057, + 9.192539080051201 + ] + }, + "advection_16": { + "iterations": [ + 58, + 56, + 64, + 64, + 62, + 63, + 60, + 64, + 64, + 58, + 63, + 64, + 58, + 65, + 60, + 61, + 68, + 61, + 62, + 61, + 63, + 59, + 61, + 65, + 65, + 66, + 60, + 64, + 64, + 62, + 62, + 69, + 67, + 67, + 59, + 65, + 61, + 64, + 66, + 64, + 60, + 67, + 63, + 62, + 59, + 62, + 66, + 97, + 60, + 58 + ], + "converged": [ + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 9.747805160943353e-07, + 8.589612591641845e-07, + 9.84311523830725e-07, + 6.960103764180435e-07, + 8.900772344180331e-07, + 7.848827589133337e-07, + 8.782433344857955e-07, + 9.166989162287348e-07, + 8.120759460864274e-07, + 9.172392020493132e-07, + 9.396270584729626e-07, + 9.183931911281383e-07, + 9.81569121648975e-07, + 7.572728129138714e-07, + 8.593318840700279e-07, + 9.165348802296945e-07, + 9.012947232075914e-07, + 8.280172330295364e-07, + 9.191513003607558e-07, + 9.986806844149963e-07, + 7.871968915938522e-07, + 8.443424249867973e-07, + 9.884557847638912e-07, + 8.769568607353158e-07, + 9.246208023535894e-07, + 9.962263804179143e-07, + 7.45218673310969e-07, + 9.011613743585008e-07, + 9.26904003456654e-07, + 8.495074889318459e-07, + 9.501551530477564e-07, + 9.569607300336123e-07, + 8.879552256636383e-07, + 8.74867492509068e-07, + 7.964230126731124e-07, + 9.405642334908502e-07, + 9.408092743088308e-07, + 9.248049881639733e-07, + 9.836358395303374e-07, + 8.772672464866195e-07, + 7.843105859716264e-07, + 9.66720469979227e-07, + 9.56381407492424e-07, + 9.187238899130315e-07, + 8.893315603232309e-07, + 8.526483909357243e-07, + 9.490963855350434e-07, + 9.798978683104135e-07, + 8.904336021005978e-07, + 7.83941030938223e-07 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 0.39583804499852704, + 0.4341703769987362, + 0.42479324099986115, + 0.45580791999964276, + 0.44038007400013157, + 0.6251317259993812, + 0.5992801819993474, + 0.6693117060003715, + 0.6137426839995896, + 0.6063718019995576, + 0.5968000320008287, + 0.4857565889997204, + 0.40680295300080616, + 0.4596914220001054, + 0.42945610800052236, + 0.3977480249996006, + 0.48149708500022825, + 0.41207493000001705, + 0.4264280059996963, + 0.41835823800101934, + 0.47821622300034505, + 0.4178700360007497, + 0.4056796859986207, + 0.4398210859999381, + 0.46115350699983537, + 0.48718484199889645, + 0.41145117899941397, + 0.4040055389996269, + 0.44741139600046154, + 0.4718036819995177, + 0.4658456599991041, + 0.4643252730002132, + 0.5613975809992553, + 0.6509558390007442, + 0.5849342080000497, + 0.6029470350003976, + 0.669017108000844, + 0.6594124040002498, + 0.49341572299999825, + 0.4820999319999828, + 0.43051424699842755, + 0.46630789400114736, + 0.4601812370001426, + 0.43147808399953647, + 0.39987709900015034, + 0.44025911900098436, + 0.4857555799990223, + 0.668620672000543, + 0.4287910009988991, + 0.42884930500076734 + ], + "output_norm_ratios": [ + 6.4759235390879635, + 7.050078585624961, + 10.230128205047123, + 10.458480418515382, + 8.529318201007172, + 21.135656768215444, + 7.077799734770263, + 10.954668559109482, + 6.941508020848393, + 12.41959106299626, + 6.12056593347812, + 7.1685644045917964, + 7.548066854826598, + 7.8102019447830795, + 6.9841757207455935, + 5.726744549106467, + 7.7776336286117544, + 8.115201371167098, + 7.762755579466631, + 7.524980461490008, + 10.678244958391645, + 7.383531045517014, + 4.680088390496937, + 6.03317125270962, + 6.121127741457319, + 8.547494555923166, + 8.368051372177792, + 9.346588819157784, + 7.294586637850362, + 9.12194485543305, + 10.01658013078006, + 13.208971166234587, + 8.879350742006253, + 6.472914478089822, + 14.316905772475668, + 8.807652010675957, + 9.23807538171132, + 6.702472416988411, + 7.597974926954049, + 6.906843896888243, + 12.444627646584676, + 16.245864427294993, + 7.348860171894624, + 7.7827797532679766, + 7.384955259746656, + 8.90212597986889, + 6.948035346546398, + 11.767145750989382, + 4.596313993975691, + 5.765013702671163 + ] + }, + "advection_24": { + "iterations": [ + 121, + 81, + 103, + 112, + 86, + 115, + 104, + 118, + 102, + 98, + 111, + 86, + 102, + 129, + 102, + 100, + 97, + 94, + 86, + 106, + 120, + 85, + 112, + 105, + 85, + 118, + 110, + 83, + 102, + 106, + 119, + 85, + 117, + 102, + 110, + 110, + 76, + 85, + 119, + 119, + 96, + 94, + 96, + 112, + 100, + 94, + 96, + 90, + 97, + 97 + ], + "converged": [ + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 9.053510776709886e-07, + 9.69770350802769e-07, + 8.968645116735367e-07, + 9.851215369664518e-07, + 9.817700987635678e-07, + 9.550062302312814e-07, + 9.414667834058235e-07, + 8.915902955234817e-07, + 9.274074881063806e-07, + 9.257704707072754e-07, + 9.605106128935987e-07, + 9.785171313273556e-07, + 8.366077879805575e-07, + 9.553225224987685e-07, + 9.328129516467429e-07, + 8.390308938731497e-07, + 9.327845701447541e-07, + 8.811245435803433e-07, + 9.66954875791938e-07, + 9.744457703901046e-07, + 8.859670746838381e-07, + 8.798802087397128e-07, + 9.319902997906739e-07, + 8.836287563224386e-07, + 8.886526491295116e-07, + 9.953036934959412e-07, + 9.198096489630791e-07, + 9.93761126357333e-07, + 9.783683605483488e-07, + 9.757409104086811e-07, + 9.251220741276488e-07, + 9.811291984450536e-07, + 8.905923621540658e-07, + 9.481421575739329e-07, + 9.509712644578228e-07, + 9.991262211565264e-07, + 9.482844505397205e-07, + 8.724576832314922e-07, + 8.959588872297806e-07, + 9.534974761571315e-07, + 9.639071742933893e-07, + 9.614743317554564e-07, + 9.288849164623494e-07, + 9.421417299682168e-07, + 9.59107334541504e-07, + 9.75543278506301e-07, + 9.887947757464638e-07, + 9.69645557027328e-07, + 9.500240829354157e-07, + 9.841260420092012e-07 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 1.2172418370009837, + 0.7989892599998711, + 0.6999285340007191, + 0.7693328410005051, + 0.6131863619993965, + 0.8513061100002233, + 0.7345058549999521, + 0.8786752760006493, + 0.7199064300002647, + 0.6395805629999813, + 0.752566241999375, + 0.5863226729998132, + 0.7210525650007185, + 0.9178888639999059, + 0.687919547999627, + 0.8803484420004679, + 0.9741967860009026, + 0.9860121399997297, + 0.838584296998306, + 0.7125187560013728, + 0.9242260829996667, + 0.6357695730002888, + 0.813968135000323, + 0.7100475909992383, + 0.5861325259993464, + 0.8284297270001844, + 0.7378133229995001, + 0.5454155000006722, + 0.6883116969984258, + 0.7243312850005168, + 0.8568871389998094, + 0.5858343119998608, + 1.0232316120000178, + 0.9099458870005037, + 1.0529261869996844, + 0.9426979469990329, + 0.5178082459988218, + 0.5694116560007387, + 0.8767647719996603, + 0.8440639959990222, + 0.6526881629997661, + 0.6411350709986436, + 0.6757511999985581, + 0.7651343170000473, + 0.7304933659997914, + 0.6102714810003818, + 0.6362533399988024, + 0.6449219730002369, + 0.6480732880008873, + 0.661400278999281 + ], + "output_norm_ratios": [ + 12.863410722498006, + 6.749977165190325, + 8.990481141702233, + 7.008994326146989, + 6.699714431666602, + 10.481130826819255, + 7.60006702637575, + 8.954268353898614, + 8.338243720332208, + 10.55818830969443, + 9.733536923992094, + 13.863720294277345, + 12.057761182730427, + 9.35545938994341, + 10.478360172520189, + 8.188625263337151, + 8.632060578455206, + 11.206548649053946, + 15.198431258743511, + 12.423962035525296, + 7.371353604330475, + 6.073351291613152, + 10.311008796527409, + 12.741379559412795, + 10.188334098554733, + 9.818452768178819, + 3.827898471759428, + 7.321435384664707, + 12.65835025798246, + 7.407230093795075, + 7.3604670934216445, + 6.8518524967092755, + 7.576143031774765, + 12.538085102457135, + 6.672170803191296, + 9.20401009677562, + 8.91129636865925, + 11.038736198251893, + 7.856220516030114, + 11.77571716490705, + 15.672793499201012, + 8.93307067703183, + 8.808856625127637, + 7.831605236890044, + 9.17176692816013, + 11.071083267037165, + 7.73413098249488, + 10.601320056196535, + 9.806346916509142, + 9.732652779662711 + ] + }, + "advection_32": { + "iterations": [ + 123, + 159, + 116, + 120, + 151, + 160, + 132, + 152, + 143, + 126, + 135, + 112, + 142, + 123, + 146, + 127, + 121, + 131, + 128, + 129, + 136, + 144, + 140, + 148, + 134, + 160, + 142, + 120, + 122, + 166, + 137, + 140, + 136, + 117, + 130, + 161, + 141, + 128, + 131, + 132, + 121, + 136, + 148, + 151, + 161, + 160, + 153, + 140, + 125, + 143 + ], + "converged": [ + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 9.564376342622215e-07, + 9.264832177066614e-07, + 8.931818302633677e-07, + 8.709088875282803e-07, + 9.919435726274912e-07, + 9.174821975800079e-07, + 9.956759638662174e-07, + 9.535528494477154e-07, + 9.7711666816962e-07, + 9.78455577909511e-07, + 9.88862497920881e-07, + 9.71562982350827e-07, + 9.226603023922492e-07, + 9.357165502358356e-07, + 9.716257626638473e-07, + 9.292753008325284e-07, + 9.935337496500898e-07, + 9.438689202154298e-07, + 8.874531723870958e-07, + 9.765495128453367e-07, + 9.828483795185476e-07, + 9.996047063687188e-07, + 9.798116139135115e-07, + 9.733844178609376e-07, + 9.709298941138718e-07, + 9.845675213690727e-07, + 9.684204399441989e-07, + 8.559407542090664e-07, + 9.600635362251231e-07, + 9.647224122771331e-07, + 9.561135371279813e-07, + 9.729330896107013e-07, + 9.663179342608667e-07, + 8.911961052293028e-07, + 9.200132120071254e-07, + 9.300866230730043e-07, + 9.371892842957929e-07, + 9.140889450328458e-07, + 9.272681751707775e-07, + 9.311795987280017e-07, + 9.139642576184463e-07, + 9.667204266806947e-07, + 9.401491422646504e-07, + 9.71753701187276e-07, + 9.83660474464885e-07, + 9.58004331455201e-07, + 9.525344328192789e-07, + 9.692030158736677e-07, + 9.925659044930503e-07, + 9.864173163490567e-07 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 1.0005704809991585, + 1.0890901980001217, + 0.839478431000316, + 0.8898649299990211, + 1.1020732960005262, + 1.1111260739999125, + 0.8885627310010022, + 1.1493125390006753, + 1.0195540660006372, + 0.8648173929996119, + 1.2694914229996357, + 1.0485010989996226, + 1.4355651109999599, + 0.9741762119992927, + 1.085254771000109, + 0.9422787479998078, + 0.8905648339987238, + 0.8571557920004125, + 0.9467812729999423, + 0.8664614539993636, + 0.9493573769996146, + 1.0194291150000936, + 0.9459014069998375, + 1.4128071190007176, + 1.2610998359996302, + 1.3569697069997346, + 1.0465765610006201, + 0.8791822069997579, + 0.8993375270001707, + 1.22595014000035, + 0.9666876589999447, + 0.989379040998756, + 0.9406323000002885, + 0.8709881639988453, + 0.9291449550000834, + 1.491774076999718, + 1.4146564490001765, + 1.2357922629998939, + 0.9199251790014387, + 0.9099923250014399, + 0.9103989830000501, + 0.9540056770001684, + 1.0793242300005659, + 1.1286532430003717, + 1.1182971269990958, + 1.1175815040005546, + 1.1358726620001107, + 1.3488285430012183, + 1.1667467249990295, + 1.3680610290011828 + ], + "output_norm_ratios": [ + 8.598106370356764, + 8.59419805414639, + 8.010659516379848, + 10.88298214579223, + 8.179757463016717, + 9.140140527824045, + 14.523993783735795, + 10.987600912837935, + 12.126976519811322, + 8.690660398173963, + 12.478267878621843, + 6.5695736252466155, + 10.203994120031638, + 8.709400463226055, + 8.44668388095633, + 9.783644017997073, + 8.046120864059121, + 12.438666758936154, + 9.40710190041781, + 11.986373678708286, + 9.955606466144806, + 6.609462475887277, + 10.448818943244698, + 12.321998030016225, + 8.5241026806424, + 11.156798825849538, + 8.961499671394735, + 9.085382844056506, + 8.096047215115815, + 8.447764385107332, + 4.52908829253338, + 11.71345938335588, + 8.384667889368231, + 7.046773782804806, + 6.514712179075287, + 8.469765123976872, + 9.813070819162666, + 6.585575318963789, + 12.608466557380417, + 6.939492743893966, + 10.548909102560577, + 12.067045389217752, + 9.851657377131172, + 4.5334432550451496, + 15.928172829635349, + 7.348897086068952, + 9.532997715597222, + 8.164837757147401, + 10.267312977075566, + 7.598192891542616 + ] + }, + "advection_48": { + "iterations": [ + 218, + 233, + 251, + 213, + 229, + 258, + 235, + 228, + 283, + 242, + 229, + 222, + 206, + 231, + 224, + 203, + 233, + 259, + 218, + 221, + 213, + 232, + 266, + 269, + 226, + 195, + 252, + 227, + 227, + 236, + 225, + 271, + 232, + 206, + 244, + 215, + 230, + 224, + 235, + 227, + 225, + 285, + 269, + 191, + 229, + 265, + 291, + 236, + 256, + 183 + ], + "converged": [ + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 9.995230474201694e-07, + 9.593544269187507e-07, + 9.575672976641098e-07, + 9.740633107891273e-07, + 9.658633520818795e-07, + 9.944445501934473e-07, + 9.417974034022571e-07, + 9.76085380367191e-07, + 9.831538916829177e-07, + 9.912075414881505e-07, + 9.867025113527722e-07, + 9.640606514589948e-07, + 9.943792277299288e-07, + 9.707196110884463e-07, + 9.806574747640276e-07, + 9.701268852043122e-07, + 9.702734241610203e-07, + 9.67065141541913e-07, + 9.593202094366383e-07, + 9.881067467099517e-07, + 9.446159774423596e-07, + 9.581164417137485e-07, + 9.641120753520134e-07, + 9.87829670122999e-07, + 9.788332648525914e-07, + 9.576874936088882e-07, + 9.644051516671536e-07, + 9.664869784040584e-07, + 9.857877158188316e-07, + 9.743555200850272e-07, + 9.640856579345359e-07, + 9.876768068623467e-07, + 9.371523736280758e-07, + 9.419546959507179e-07, + 9.490131128575924e-07, + 9.690785482529173e-07, + 9.829028304142095e-07, + 9.702141305727921e-07, + 9.424370286484825e-07, + 9.774427166983989e-07, + 9.92151305060812e-07, + 9.98539953895712e-07, + 9.784876445075378e-07, + 9.795799675868875e-07, + 9.986453394641316e-07, + 9.621974654818373e-07, + 9.858544412012296e-07, + 9.59237104395814e-07, + 9.957758271529457e-07, + 9.7974634235141e-07 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 1.5739063340006396, + 1.8055854009999166, + 2.649969248001071, + 1.6210272250009439, + 1.7242675020006573, + 1.9498271299999033, + 1.7783329619996948, + 1.6851377780003531, + 2.2990871029996924, + 2.5542859350007348, + 1.6608538380005484, + 1.678232852000292, + 1.538746161000745, + 1.7422147899997071, + 1.6164974500006792, + 1.4798777609994431, + 2.2653879469999083, + 2.274549146000936, + 1.5385908409989497, + 1.5824687629992695, + 1.6220256610013166, + 1.7370767270003853, + 1.898289630000363, + 2.624016963998656, + 1.9928305979992729, + 1.3926084539998556, + 1.7621842240005208, + 1.7026511520016356, + 1.6973037150000891, + 1.713372015999994, + 2.0378462320004473, + 2.6173012259987445, + 1.7371817429993825, + 1.505175591000807, + 1.7372248740011855, + 1.6022969160003413, + 1.6527126239998324, + 1.8817584909993457, + 2.419768342999305, + 1.6574149700009002, + 1.6074340570012282, + 2.062657449998369, + 1.9707514389992866, + 1.3259271530005208, + 1.8360033150001982, + 2.6847684730000765, + 2.1858416860013676, + 1.7232880920000753, + 1.8652769210002589, + 1.3142287339996983 + ], + "output_norm_ratios": [ + 10.410625660575418, + 9.49313440453166, + 12.032145103000241, + 8.642493239122876, + 11.165864248379712, + 6.748519230952676, + 8.835650422526827, + 11.37643825152966, + 9.532098172529373, + 11.278007128697086, + 13.082029498028017, + 10.417321395588827, + 6.617115950626036, + 6.438483731404221, + 11.67271951679782, + 13.946225634588686, + 12.193915253246047, + 14.50874380144865, + 10.71752630607674, + 11.460487851914992, + 9.913844023736047, + 10.844014625162115, + 11.284572798279658, + 8.452665200549283, + 11.932224503189731, + 10.900297954405103, + 8.232596768722026, + 5.869809473796619, + 7.577672794095408, + 12.936044644354409, + 6.262825206832749, + 6.079315396015311, + 8.502093289683751, + 11.339089069717712, + 12.638679013366435, + 10.742424316255025, + 12.330467559746774, + 8.472650132593829, + 9.055064410205777, + 7.019735294287101, + 14.894735123234517, + 10.904981417998536, + 10.678193048707058, + 12.594165218452279, + 10.96472395460945, + 12.490557742250141, + 8.423301253658137, + 9.83403883912467, + 6.5443648195463355, + 8.451067791745682 + ] + }, + "advection_64": { + "iterations": [ + 300, + 283, + 300, + 300, + 299, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 268, + 297, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 286, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 291, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 288, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 297, + 280, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300 + ], + "converged": [ + false, + true, + false, + false, + true, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + true, + true, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + true, + false, + false, + false, + false, + true, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + true, + false, + false, + false, + true, + true, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 5.87704720368968e-05, + 9.816898074012813e-07, + 1.8033213404164587e-05, + 3.77428315310301e-06, + 9.83077021716576e-07, + 2.57741358518024e-06, + 2.2494699798429107e-06, + 2.548430223041407e-05, + 1.2067482884391586e-05, + 1.1008572385320314e-06, + 4.0696233678365294e-06, + 5.877531401554387e-06, + 1.8539222918240682e-06, + 4.691697492720024e-06, + 7.2912245461491215e-06, + 1.5571308963638838e-06, + 9.98558471970204e-07, + 9.989834419369962e-07, + 6.764080716745917e-06, + 3.04274198851638e-06, + 8.831387009508944e-06, + 1.4171647534753391e-06, + 3.4226604987576315e-06, + 1.0585765125488496e-05, + 2.1507393789426332e-05, + 9.821035119848467e-07, + 8.300482090076054e-06, + 9.32856018702386e-06, + 1.313603722083154e-06, + 2.9012593343304256e-06, + 9.343029469006801e-07, + 1.0362771876685046e-05, + 1.4152392148350318e-05, + 3.6950142512973186e-06, + 5.859250480269441e-06, + 2.253744216975214e-06, + 2.10158477308037e-05, + 2.3687401713000225e-05, + 1.0184573986574732e-05, + 9.386015213280533e-07, + 8.563541875655618e-06, + 2.079413433227851e-06, + 4.118499044302465e-06, + 9.933321741686937e-07, + 9.961536402644662e-07, + 2.1189988714672756e-05, + 1.7579750683478937e-06, + 8.663648629679706e-06, + 3.164036917951509e-06, + 1.0599877776449699e-06 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 2.473374891000276, + 2.0775728369990247, + 2.1713655250005104, + 2.176520482998967, + 2.3497946620009316, + 3.0522172559994942, + 2.2054995050002617, + 2.1729659299999184, + 2.177621270999225, + 2.244028699999035, + 2.7922183810005663, + 2.5762084100006177, + 2.298662339000657, + 2.1709536559992557, + 2.288504608999574, + 2.35883766599909, + 2.8216448849998415, + 2.249593892998746, + 2.2115437379998184, + 2.253617517000748, + 2.1208760809986416, + 2.595591790999606, + 2.7909495059993787, + 2.1656498209995334, + 2.242552223999155, + 2.0915499519996956, + 2.2301914359995862, + 3.143759639999189, + 2.2220382380000956, + 2.1863812589999725, + 2.1820244700011244, + 2.159321713999816, + 2.627097095000863, + 2.72696188700138, + 2.182714489999853, + 2.2349545220004075, + 2.1777196920011193, + 2.2215505999993184, + 2.948700122000446, + 2.3073147859995515, + 2.2011669910007186, + 2.211620097999912, + 2.2724150140002166, + 2.5284197510009108, + 2.62234952900144, + 2.147400703999665, + 2.2478408759998274, + 2.1172478560001764, + 2.1911976730007154, + 2.7402739449989895 + ], + "output_norm_ratios": [ + 13.601066443109016, + 8.019832160991143, + 8.587323175950482, + 8.180032330843115, + 14.144823260386536, + 10.093516333856536, + 9.244287166851954, + 8.154996321496897, + 13.290944645730013, + 6.25619745000032, + 14.673708497981693, + 10.067767237895067, + 10.259310785274824, + 10.211900869328499, + 9.794247739573077, + 9.22680170160957, + 7.553597128188192, + 12.886437236862529, + 6.201920950889964, + 9.53702136515861, + 6.333544513241663, + 10.041421539459767, + 7.859675972144003, + 7.512474884372458, + 17.732176045767343, + 8.5331582409281, + 8.197146441101774, + 6.406457869223618, + 7.954503832929341, + 6.203084156023575, + 9.342420701232792, + 9.840722709116076, + 11.069454976287156, + 9.567048388766663, + 5.9199275452358915, + 6.851461611572613, + 10.987790597699364, + 11.368216635844963, + 11.854910401104538, + 13.044380360503194, + 9.367654699439237, + 6.649537231404174, + 7.990847942317811, + 6.948596918790937, + 15.754247312114575, + 10.907315935486489, + 14.056753221531707, + 11.467054980321759, + 11.33074737565364, + 15.398210799741438 + ] + }, + "graph_laplacian_16": { + "iterations": [ + 9, + 9, + 8, + 9, + 9, + 9, + 8, + 9, + 10, + 10, + 9, + 9, + 9, + 8, + 9, + 9, + 10, + 8, + 8, + 9, + 9, + 9, + 9, + 9, + 9, + 8, + 9, + 9, + 8, + 8, + 8, + 9, + 9, + 9, + 9, + 9, + 9, + 9, + 8, + 10, + 9, + 8, + 8, + 8, + 9, + 8, + 8, + 10, + 8, + 9 + ], + "converged": [ + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 5.377685164584674e-07, + 2.301182136494341e-07, + 2.984360708126067e-07, + 2.1512837965469216e-07, + 2.8214735784000063e-07, + 5.116943549870128e-07, + 6.604785846720594e-07, + 2.42592589547535e-07, + 1.863600091674489e-07, + 3.025552099463992e-07, + 3.6083806444441295e-07, + 5.961820778463861e-07, + 1.5816639539519057e-07, + 7.934993840560297e-07, + 7.062827169542363e-07, + 1.7237516075629172e-07, + 2.0872048243623322e-07, + 2.791696665097553e-07, + 7.839145557357774e-07, + 3.3277603104402607e-07, + 1.4944957284701843e-07, + 2.908938205139132e-07, + 3.67408250826752e-07, + 5.525372912174818e-07, + 4.873737598691286e-07, + 7.110590904176539e-07, + 1.9398252267710325e-07, + 1.857370352528187e-07, + 4.2585886991702736e-07, + 3.492337669346066e-07, + 6.517560379321762e-07, + 1.7220980322553454e-07, + 2.4178336777902925e-07, + 9.19749096252199e-07, + 1.57420066336947e-07, + 3.875317852245451e-07, + 5.634606541307048e-07, + 2.2036592727755015e-07, + 7.58217218329837e-07, + 1.889366895214381e-07, + 5.167254936109848e-07, + 5.927810584430275e-07, + 6.636356651953355e-07, + 8.460769551900619e-07, + 5.777166482976181e-07, + 9.959754729231016e-07, + 2.5988320312951615e-07, + 3.010977224911398e-07, + 6.295032094783501e-07, + 2.554627502218639e-07 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 0.03001215400036017, + 0.03067062199988868, + 0.03689239399864164, + 0.045725531001153286, + 0.03289415799918061, + 0.032376252000176464, + 0.02418437500091386, + 0.03179039600036049, + 0.031847788999584736, + 0.0412983099995472, + 0.030636441999376984, + 0.03019627899993793, + 0.029287307001141016, + 0.042775833999257884, + 0.029167173999667284, + 0.03481364400067832, + 0.04515602699939336, + 0.02631480600030045, + 0.028067444000043906, + 0.041399493000426446, + 0.048607851000269875, + 0.03742659099953016, + 0.03308912100146699, + 0.034496878999561886, + 0.028955063000466907, + 0.03877552999983891, + 0.030675318999783485, + 0.0405936750012188, + 0.030169461000696174, + 0.028193539999847417, + 0.03216605399938999, + 0.02869612600079563, + 0.03565032099868404, + 0.036414510001122835, + 0.02752851900004316, + 0.03641657699881762, + 0.02870520999931614, + 0.026447088999702828, + 0.02640050799891469, + 0.031574583999827155, + 0.02857229099936376, + 0.03772878800009494, + 0.018763074000162305, + 0.023879463000412215, + 0.04829445600080362, + 0.032527985000342596, + 0.039230066000527586, + 0.03804304199911712, + 0.03183275599985791, + 0.030718553000042448 + ], + "output_norm_ratios": [ + 5.965548891101584, + 5.751434314459404, + 7.013698760573074, + 6.122355279808049, + 6.394025596804693, + 5.9166580817054655, + 6.35954499156301, + 5.427891286823746, + 5.897816527032925, + 6.24133172128693, + 6.272685565473715, + 6.719451901604052, + 6.197427228377375, + 6.281298130063733, + 6.617485394877096, + 6.492207729368868, + 6.51403696454753, + 6.809237851087415, + 5.769278016068994, + 6.067576150604664, + 6.427134849486308, + 5.935542587791268, + 5.8563119457259045, + 6.864485918032651, + 5.44289182409805, + 5.976808711113702, + 5.969365631978481, + 5.574494881603508, + 6.42782288477748, + 6.442767625803784, + 6.725261456121116, + 5.575160981240418, + 6.515745533931685, + 6.445165623707055, + 6.625064500904639, + 6.023390580771717, + 6.636636233198084, + 5.832703451432679, + 6.34276211387995, + 5.811103880743263, + 6.830655298139637, + 6.267902105195693, + 7.346876482469129, + 7.522680208649542, + 5.946726107501392, + 5.658053982463798, + 7.243547762541155, + 6.349399249506951, + 5.876611249352459, + 7.118205331800455 + ] + }, + "graph_laplacian_24": { + "iterations": [ + 8, + 7, + 7, + 8, + 8, + 7, + 8, + 8, + 8, + 8, + 8, + 8, + 8, + 8, + 8, + 8, + 8, + 8, + 8, + 8, + 8, + 8, + 8, + 8, + 8, + 8, + 8, + 8, + 8, + 7, + 8, + 7, + 9, + 8, + 8, + 8, + 8, + 8, + 8, + 8, + 9, + 8, + 8, + 7, + 8, + 8, + 8, + 8, + 7, + 8 + ], + "converged": [ + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 1.9306782632528545e-07, + 7.468980738358653e-07, + 6.424422459844e-07, + 4.715350252433552e-07, + 9.001908105901751e-07, + 4.4973215999556805e-07, + 5.116575949377172e-07, + 2.3235706015501936e-07, + 5.107291264084633e-07, + 1.4479935859111282e-07, + 7.206300631283758e-07, + 7.026830552303208e-07, + 1.725738760214023e-07, + 2.794521046458712e-07, + 1.8297234018519533e-07, + 2.755319753438975e-07, + 5.08341893031907e-07, + 1.9379021793388022e-07, + 1.4215480635669116e-07, + 4.837558037568209e-07, + 2.0274645327389995e-07, + 2.80630659026218e-07, + 7.760278051241268e-07, + 1.4438772670332565e-07, + 5.254104855877765e-07, + 1.3892068243008293e-07, + 2.523290965029227e-07, + 1.1402582880692857e-07, + 1.3624958945630275e-07, + 2.7754960964417645e-07, + 4.423535986240014e-07, + 7.738479400116317e-07, + 2.1792471523284423e-07, + 2.6286361467959676e-07, + 2.7183496795305626e-07, + 5.456362929517983e-07, + 4.2230840930694285e-07, + 7.114108288556057e-07, + 1.963518398480311e-07, + 3.039207902422754e-07, + 1.6859220807212802e-07, + 1.2780548112281737e-07, + 1.0634203876117509e-07, + 7.70421734004244e-07, + 4.0393457560558193e-07, + 2.3751402947983248e-07, + 1.6384291040893307e-07, + 2.3678808915787423e-07, + 8.556976988362126e-07, + 5.264725172295487e-07 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 0.04011397300018871, + 0.028005566000501858, + 0.033928049000678584, + 0.02825669499907235, + 0.031879484000455705, + 0.02224121700055548, + 0.03589514200029953, + 0.030895848000000115, + 0.03744272500080115, + 0.030569710999770905, + 0.038557981000849395, + 0.04599840199989558, + 0.030675486001200625, + 0.03217773100004706, + 0.02788956299991696, + 0.030731494998690323, + 0.02796665300047607, + 0.037975901999743655, + 0.032233370999165345, + 0.03252332400006708, + 0.035940456999014714, + 0.026586930000121356, + 0.02813553200030583, + 0.03052796500014665, + 0.033746984001481906, + 0.023787608999555232, + 0.030201713998394553, + 0.02650283699949796, + 0.026980726999681792, + 0.022540130999914254, + 0.0226243910001358, + 0.02038438099953055, + 0.03174482499889564, + 0.030503752001095563, + 0.0264840110012301, + 0.0365405020002072, + 0.030786051998802577, + 0.020864504000201123, + 0.02913542799979041, + 0.023606344000654644, + 0.03550376900057017, + 0.030927324000003864, + 0.025491563999821665, + 0.026546253000560682, + 0.03710623500046495, + 0.053220067000438576, + 0.03706136499931745, + 0.03271141400000488, + 0.026905164999334374, + 0.03262041300149576 + ], + "output_norm_ratios": [ + 6.594525309574451, + 7.042571925276526, + 7.188761655548546, + 7.025016735910477, + 7.311817342538291, + 7.545147443079439, + 7.4187694061352785, + 6.551367651334649, + 7.301651593001639, + 6.86779386500015, + 6.63915542703322, + 6.9630695732911585, + 6.639800255655578, + 6.747110905105288, + 7.451869415761439, + 6.443321069240395, + 7.076173819597917, + 6.580951400190437, + 7.992957299237876, + 7.438615965422402, + 7.7450608980613795, + 7.274714586937151, + 6.921493123462432, + 6.747458710731496, + 6.934084684297661, + 7.4537169072047975, + 6.8185636100685745, + 6.983396437315353, + 6.797837105239007, + 7.749117797566755, + 6.766725114468179, + 6.9997349590096505, + 7.1319466326888525, + 6.580070450484773, + 6.855262969368614, + 6.95780740312664, + 7.081891518432447, + 7.1410084756240995, + 6.563502702823707, + 6.785036623389958, + 6.588630123175074, + 7.532628944704441, + 6.918397387761947, + 7.0025928241790085, + 6.717123756660969, + 6.810165502872375, + 7.048808874248767, + 6.9381046771357475, + 7.077595133465734, + 6.548959085650946 + ] + }, + "graph_laplacian_32": { + "iterations": [ + 7, + 7, + 7, + 7, + 7, + 8, + 8, + 8, + 7, + 7, + 7, + 7, + 7, + 8, + 7, + 8, + 7, + 8, + 7, + 8, + 7, + 7, + 8, + 8, + 7, + 7, + 8, + 7, + 7, + 8, + 7, + 8, + 8, + 7, + 7, + 7, + 7, + 8, + 7, + 8, + 7, + 7, + 8, + 7, + 8, + 7, + 8, + 7, + 7, + 8 + ], + "converged": [ + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 7.174527169918987e-07, + 4.0080244916644836e-07, + 2.3776186735275095e-07, + 4.93683464461009e-07, + 1.7499520164663988e-07, + 1.7087253730595504e-07, + 1.8935845073609094e-07, + 3.0542505963618334e-07, + 3.303201244460856e-07, + 8.083010804865635e-07, + 5.338372531749661e-07, + 7.411858419071924e-07, + 7.05925644468834e-07, + 2.7015383134216483e-07, + 7.291435906137368e-07, + 2.838892980183215e-07, + 7.02945517017811e-07, + 2.0738896732911708e-07, + 4.054905973177455e-07, + 2.586720378761632e-07, + 2.1203974301775956e-07, + 7.092705970607127e-07, + 3.7646290931719165e-07, + 4.0779853925403686e-07, + 8.943937863462205e-07, + 9.36262153809721e-07, + 1.7100184251883788e-07, + 5.681781158519879e-07, + 3.094359412919527e-07, + 2.2376850144793097e-07, + 6.797272925094978e-07, + 1.3202534849426756e-07, + 2.0586164528638857e-07, + 3.9959436162710787e-07, + 4.317823356490574e-07, + 2.0748250241700324e-07, + 6.750208708827346e-07, + 6.816974005696024e-07, + 7.985560334961433e-07, + 1.345541067903499e-07, + 7.45975175011005e-07, + 9.53617661231862e-07, + 2.240688713603316e-07, + 5.458401670889821e-07, + 1.8135745529916757e-07, + 2.394630896537091e-07, + 1.2562717803500062e-07, + 9.606316633546783e-07, + 9.919182947347804e-07, + 1.403432845100861e-07 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 0.042254371001035906, + 0.02848877100041136, + 0.0429443410012027, + 0.032602846000372665, + 0.038153614001203096, + 0.05652193300011277, + 0.044823111000368954, + 0.050045060999764246, + 0.037854788000913686, + 0.03643900399947597, + 0.03821551800137968, + 0.04147777599973779, + 0.03693082499921729, + 0.05706762400041043, + 0.02741995200085512, + 0.034381261000817176, + 0.04672256099911465, + 0.039246512000318035, + 0.028660224001214374, + 0.03324616999998398, + 0.028456179999921005, + 0.041738297000847524, + 0.04579026899955352, + 0.050320034999458585, + 0.036606625999411335, + 0.03501848899941251, + 0.04800815500129829, + 0.026897735999227734, + 0.04194761200051289, + 0.04216758099937579, + 0.03465476400015177, + 0.04717268100102956, + 0.05086813200068718, + 0.02668149899909622, + 0.03946951199941395, + 0.042052053000588785, + 0.05182982500082289, + 0.05444252300003427, + 0.04661627499990573, + 0.05672403599965037, + 0.04780196800129488, + 0.04065322699898388, + 0.028640966000239132, + 0.02832319700064545, + 0.03294363200075168, + 0.024377427998842904, + 0.02897802900042734, + 0.030053982000026735, + 0.031783780999830924, + 0.03476768900145544 + ], + "output_norm_ratios": [ + 8.127245771761546, + 7.336527495750054, + 7.499251056400411, + 7.224721109874642, + 7.600422234510834, + 7.845596457160825, + 7.000631962904843, + 7.67890507945742, + 7.737127850546349, + 7.118573644520508, + 8.183926733025661, + 7.415817926044636, + 7.750683166822172, + 7.265370652183074, + 7.34881444641009, + 7.820253057738873, + 7.693614533072173, + 7.807336623846857, + 8.229298667185601, + 6.976087422103364, + 6.902879630651778, + 7.120424255366535, + 7.7049640544288165, + 7.63712074940126, + 7.072350698393358, + 7.7111360981658805, + 7.968021385044162, + 7.192111268780403, + 7.563483087033554, + 7.326345795766775, + 8.132493655285835, + 7.156487417854414, + 7.316085735670262, + 7.355200518589218, + 7.627173384685394, + 7.694115752087039, + 8.037828632899581, + 7.49337679885439, + 7.381980187872379, + 7.991637500931808, + 7.230533593838765, + 7.640679427071408, + 7.404558906724356, + 7.339058653540053, + 6.815986022323507, + 8.032012280509832, + 6.905059016485667, + 7.332179103715436, + 7.32545773698609, + 7.512153475359643 + ] + }, + "graph_laplacian_48": { + "iterations": [ + 7, + 7, + 7, + 6, + 7, + 7, + 7, + 7, + 7, + 7, + 7, + 7, + 7, + 6, + 7, + 6, + 7, + 7, + 7, + 7, + 7, + 7, + 7, + 6, + 6, + 7, + 7, + 7, + 7, + 7, + 6, + 7, + 7, + 7, + 7, + 7, + 7, + 7, + 7, + 7, + 7, + 7, + 8, + 7, + 6, + 6, + 7, + 7, + 7, + 7 + ], + "converged": [ + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 5.847076205728375e-07, + 4.6528655921225695e-07, + 8.724408190291979e-07, + 7.566898776594309e-07, + 4.924409236686605e-07, + 1.1516909777457386e-07, + 1.722154676298933e-07, + 1.0882843873280259e-07, + 4.4572772545472674e-07, + 1.3853583065367611e-07, + 1.8044170118321613e-07, + 1.430107584377335e-07, + 2.3243145157027025e-07, + 5.856705065319413e-07, + 1.010361493160256e-07, + 3.731700415053587e-07, + 3.034240031258696e-07, + 1.6953734505319557e-07, + 1.9474367744454556e-07, + 5.983316935044906e-07, + 5.793561558989618e-07, + 1.1272258433646896e-07, + 1.1084114149759027e-07, + 4.2068950832523027e-07, + 3.401532915111044e-07, + 1.4682424489911656e-07, + 3.6008251398068955e-07, + 2.294258550584332e-07, + 2.268559181546513e-07, + 2.0006869007750826e-07, + 9.486314455047577e-07, + 4.6987159357498086e-07, + 1.2324076966634093e-07, + 5.063866157756392e-07, + 1.4922810655692912e-07, + 1.4205589466717905e-07, + 1.2036421998446344e-07, + 1.5334031475208275e-07, + 8.826219406562761e-07, + 3.939444587157641e-07, + 1.2754967041994625e-07, + 1.1807402470829018e-07, + 1.8247761277887588e-07, + 2.080945410097336e-07, + 9.727323274627964e-07, + 6.603990511915261e-07, + 4.113603225263532e-07, + 1.2543623975474998e-07, + 1.095705036187429e-07, + 5.140090708081976e-07 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 0.02580541799761704, + 0.03470726200248464, + 0.030528490999131463, + 0.03693907300112187, + 0.028108886999689275, + 0.028193964997626608, + 0.019065915999817662, + 0.02262670900017838, + 0.03220743200290599, + 0.024211038999055745, + 0.03093637300116825, + 0.03627431800123304, + 0.028199239997775294, + 0.02207998000085354, + 0.02491622100205859, + 0.024386589997448027, + 0.028327118001470808, + 0.03234599600182264, + 0.026414407999254763, + 0.030172447000950342, + 0.02844865400038543, + 0.02628135499980999, + 0.03250347300127032, + 0.018512236001697602, + 0.019947786000557244, + 0.024786762998701306, + 0.020282170000427868, + 0.025972065999667393, + 0.03796563499781769, + 0.03308837100121309, + 0.040268013002787484, + 0.0402842609983054, + 0.0455769300024258, + 0.04451078900092398, + 0.03120156099976157, + 0.041179612002451904, + 0.04320358800032409, + 0.04494218599938904, + 0.04605436500060023, + 0.0444701519991213, + 0.03892084600011003, + 0.03319444899898372, + 0.03045391400155495, + 0.038759258000936825, + 0.027933754998230143, + 0.029777808998915134, + 0.040448682997521246, + 0.029065908998745726, + 0.02739091400144389, + 0.046337953997863224 + ], + "output_norm_ratios": [ + 7.773659072239888, + 8.206826454710052, + 8.140619017828751, + 8.55596549864146, + 8.254110113921064, + 7.9101708561061725, + 7.765406716719623, + 8.139170481095956, + 7.956190444443152, + 8.373290251346873, + 7.759531105865716, + 8.105252675326513, + 8.118639093690978, + 8.228513327951879, + 8.160187491518903, + 8.08572786334335, + 8.012130654009123, + 8.232502141743275, + 8.140592913394368, + 7.841063399202732, + 8.198006753090864, + 8.134340612905131, + 8.101105110208145, + 8.359940406153976, + 8.367327945379285, + 7.780549688321097, + 7.734156538046685, + 7.902614699798931, + 8.44736702911425, + 7.954051346297038, + 8.29572263958919, + 7.918235774539575, + 8.124232725406964, + 8.166432032361769, + 7.873935845816341, + 8.061638698895528, + 7.870072799125752, + 7.811181616081729, + 8.02106183963873, + 8.01028351203502, + 8.309780838593257, + 8.086870943707824, + 7.918106171058287, + 8.22024065505211, + 8.656592129999373, + 8.106938070670692, + 7.990708856283124, + 8.622307759915216, + 8.65423986065819, + 8.240325370900399 + ] + }, + "graph_laplacian_64": { + "iterations": [ + 6, + 7, + 7, + 6, + 6, + 7, + 6, + 6, + 6, + 6, + 6, + 7, + 6, + 6, + 7, + 6, + 6, + 7, + 6, + 6, + 6, + 6, + 6, + 7, + 6, + 6, + 6, + 6, + 6, + 6, + 6, + 6, + 6, + 7, + 6, + 6, + 7, + 6, + 7, + 6, + 6, + 6, + 6, + 6, + 6, + 7, + 7, + 6, + 6, + 7 + ], + "converged": [ + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 1.924460460829502e-07, + 1.1750258833131003e-07, + 1.4231089094568559e-07, + 4.7674621953063123e-07, + 3.202659163802941e-07, + 5.728395208908352e-07, + 1.6537206935954396e-07, + 8.718992441960589e-07, + 5.854735362652168e-07, + 1.9277547227906352e-07, + 7.378583665057165e-07, + 1.02162151095199e-07, + 5.840557779383368e-07, + 6.025210573537254e-07, + 9.191709956314042e-07, + 5.496715298234908e-07, + 6.719503353386785e-07, + 1.6196840405943712e-07, + 5.476042625637134e-07, + 9.947519022584524e-07, + 2.628591072399835e-07, + 8.641958246520033e-07, + 9.308803397750714e-07, + 2.2984873076046206e-07, + 1.5102686382426788e-07, + 8.76610647705534e-07, + 9.047253264768052e-07, + 1.9450517407134625e-07, + 3.373112771013968e-07, + 2.800372608115072e-07, + 4.2621431002054417e-07, + 8.087237797798037e-07, + 6.340718579329168e-07, + 4.3235438087519863e-07, + 5.318401600344081e-07, + 1.385623135715803e-07, + 1.6311998817949079e-07, + 1.5749474490016168e-07, + 1.3907815076881497e-07, + 3.661599368999595e-07, + 6.14340675342936e-07, + 1.605013266794352e-07, + 9.7980535352955e-07, + 8.653484254219154e-07, + 8.020839633120662e-07, + 2.488525415210679e-07, + 1.785854066234756e-07, + 1.7429110797853105e-07, + 4.651725802440559e-07, + 1.0653760788867985e-07 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 0.025839186000666814, + 0.02454306700019515, + 0.03040732299996307, + 0.022248089000640903, + 0.03827078999893274, + 0.03765614800067851, + 0.023886030998255592, + 0.024026815000979695, + 0.028146814001956955, + 0.022066145000280812, + 0.03447524900184362, + 0.025172399000439327, + 0.018632608000189066, + 0.018923937997897156, + 0.03382493499884731, + 0.022125650000816677, + 0.02080472799934796, + 0.016627504002826754, + 0.019971769997937372, + 0.018170397001085803, + 0.027726028001779923, + 0.02210642800127971, + 0.020203518000926124, + 0.022712770998623455, + 0.024727554999117274, + 0.022519251000630902, + 0.021010328997363104, + 0.030827378999674693, + 0.024410951999016106, + 0.02457834499728051, + 0.0163623610023933, + 0.03179385899784393, + 0.016744084998208564, + 0.02668630300104269, + 0.020156030001089675, + 0.020144178000919055, + 0.028301843998633558, + 0.017983916000957834, + 0.028733810999256093, + 0.025949921997380443, + 0.024161049997928785, + 0.02450506300010602, + 0.02225751999867498, + 0.022142959998745937, + 0.014100165000854759, + 0.029820957002812065, + 0.022313635003229138, + 0.02138188800017815, + 0.034958653999638045, + 0.023529826001322363 + ], + "output_norm_ratios": [ + 8.551872863714259, + 8.125432984041497, + 8.381288723441846, + 8.454590967655147, + 8.453580573445286, + 8.211451418959525, + 9.116892608408481, + 8.3153571248763, + 8.552823466140055, + 8.444465653541494, + 8.165693612431022, + 7.986373239413298, + 8.6389512819288, + 8.21994218253391, + 8.095085393060605, + 8.424759251991123, + 8.24189859219253, + 8.583892066423111, + 8.579296561919566, + 8.696891793426705, + 8.78054216798084, + 8.26425665090091, + 8.436141668922595, + 8.273212229969875, + 8.346366874250712, + 8.668104992855971, + 8.14063890780119, + 8.539127245938733, + 8.556740200462851, + 8.809334234104409, + 8.68552238108012, + 8.564715197922624, + 8.249551358575193, + 8.283301079605785, + 8.463051316209723, + 8.782959665163238, + 8.295298771191462, + 8.738757260340176, + 8.572367964363208, + 8.735881711970132, + 8.547097349793807, + 8.601023541759139, + 8.458309537551527, + 8.51280724756485, + 8.492814180048036, + 8.442633984079434, + 8.44459088524067, + 8.70873349001562, + 8.26701099842267, + 8.131379607419303 + ] + } + } + }, + { + "name": "MPNN", + "param_count": 15426, + "train_time": 1504.8357870560012, + "train_history": [ + 0.8222192674875259, + 0.8022483140230179, + 0.785399753600359, + 0.7708893418312073, + 0.7572821378707886, + 0.7446135804057121, + 0.7308456636965275, + 0.7209427170455456, + 0.7132380716502666, + 0.7036457173526287, + 0.6893597021698952, + 0.6805757321417332, + 0.6667784415185452, + 0.6599108502268791, + 0.6494069136679173, + 0.6380330547690392, + 0.6260509230196476, + 0.6281721852719784, + 0.6155192889273167, + 0.6059085987508297, + 0.6028941087424755, + 0.5858692787587643, + 0.5811121463775635, + 0.5739345513284206, + 0.574827253818512, + 0.5584471747279167, + 0.5545409917831421, + 0.5394380614161491, + 0.5367010347545147, + 0.536250825971365, + 0.5199535638093948, + 0.5139065738767385, + 0.5023137982934713, + 0.5022794269025326, + 0.4797850716859102, + 0.4887395054101944, + 0.47398668341338634, + 0.46847651340067387, + 0.44660712592303753, + 0.44799626246094704, + 0.4388910327106714, + 0.4434548635035753, + 0.4369080141186714, + 0.42320019379258156, + 0.41567190177738667, + 0.3991414662450552, + 0.3997696749866009, + 0.39274146780371666, + 0.3804628197103739, + 0.3770255371928215, + 0.3746047895401716, + 0.3625333961099386, + 0.35756942816078663, + 0.35722911916673183, + 0.3544914685189724, + 0.3478230442851782, + 0.33437950909137726, + 0.3319782018661499, + 0.3215584382414818, + 0.31928390078246593, + 0.31582510843873024, + 0.3099350091069937, + 0.3145537134259939, + 0.31249320320785046, + 0.30175030790269375, + 0.29428795725107193, + 0.28518320620059967, + 0.2825402729213238, + 0.28030863404273987, + 0.27616220712661743, + 0.26516524888575077, + 0.2764318808913231, + 0.27500588819384575, + 0.2725136447697878, + 0.2699749981984496, + 0.25792128778994083, + 0.25903413724154234, + 0.25180301163345575, + 0.24750392697751522, + 0.24869334790855646, + 0.2586101107299328, + 0.24836183059960604, + 0.24143532756716013, + 0.23892193473875523, + 0.2355172885581851, + 0.23672627191990614, + 0.22250495851039886, + 0.22011855244636536, + 0.22631028853356838, + 0.23247493896633387, + 0.2126941354945302, + 0.21241429820656776, + 0.20645960979163647, + 0.21128066442906857, + 0.21119203697890043, + 0.20813188795000315, + 0.21541339717805386, + 0.1938834749162197, + 0.19467468559741974, + 0.2065008506178856, + 0.20240608137100935, + 0.19191469252109528, + 0.19908920396119356, + 0.19219449535012245, + 0.19506243150681257, + 0.20208488404750824, + 0.18832585867494345, + 0.183503489010036, + 0.17939159646630287, + 0.17908943444490433, + 0.18347993306815624, + 0.1771675618365407, + 0.18486388213932514, + 0.17778506875038147, + 0.1883211638778448, + 0.1774648940190673, + 0.17334632854908705, + 0.18293078150600195, + 0.17202330939471722, + 0.1690577156841755, + 0.1698882719501853, + 0.1628308817744255, + 0.17144524306058884, + 0.1782838413491845, + 0.17617692984640598, + 0.1621468709781766, + 0.16855812724679708, + 0.16335873678326607, + 0.16170422919094563, + 0.16572174336761236, + 0.16824539471417665, + 0.16107607819139957, + 0.1621507303789258, + 0.17165271379053593, + 0.15952722821384668, + 0.16844746936112642, + 0.1576238665729761, + 0.15877465810626745, + 0.1545711336657405, + 0.16221268940716982, + 0.15635609161108732, + 0.1562679884955287, + 0.1523005748167634, + 0.15678816381841898, + 0.16050173342227936, + 0.1607038164511323, + 0.16023858729749918, + 0.1495382860302925, + 0.15241834986954927, + 0.15758458152413368, + 0.1526151280850172, + 0.15293406415730715, + 0.1509471731260419, + 0.16834965255111456, + 0.1529244240373373, + 0.15442676283419132, + 0.14669996034353971, + 0.16684805043041706, + 0.16045014932751656, + 0.1460251696407795, + 0.1535713216289878, + 0.14271612372249365, + 0.1645174128934741, + 0.15548387076705694, + 0.14210472349077463, + 0.1493128500878811, + 0.14524174761027098, + 0.16180400550365448, + 0.14912518486380577, + 0.1582199539989233, + 0.14544638711959124, + 0.14749186765402555, + 0.14333404321223497, + 0.15349521674215794, + 0.14591469150036573, + 0.15122463088482618, + 0.14407072123140097, + 0.1643684059381485, + 0.14847259316593409, + 0.14062644354999065, + 0.14425221271812916, + 0.14503327943384647, + 0.15234133414924145, + 0.1488666543737054, + 0.1457805074751377, + 0.14424660708755255, + 0.151646607555449, + 0.14082891959697008, + 0.15277078934013844, + 0.14592593908309937, + 0.15186718851327896, + 0.14951181504875422, + 0.13721443060785532, + 0.1455299872905016, + 0.14212167635560036, + 0.13683953415602446, + 0.13648652378469706, + 0.14497098047286272, + 0.13474943907931447, + 0.14491146011278033, + 0.14345152582973242, + 0.1419134009629488, + 0.14023606618866324, + 0.13796070124953985, + 0.15126132778823376, + 0.14326984994113445, + 0.144937333650887, + 0.14278441667556763, + 0.1475875824689865, + 0.1434206864796579, + 0.13870884152129292, + 0.14899587538093328, + 0.147541135083884, + 0.13708793371915817, + 0.14270151918753982, + 0.14296050928533077, + 0.14729619026184082, + 0.14325114246457815, + 0.1456736885011196, + 0.13644381379708648, + 0.1457548150792718, + 0.13944374350830913, + 0.13477571727707982, + 0.13949145143851638, + 0.14878121949732304, + 0.1412472827360034, + 0.14380835788324475, + 0.13151580514386296, + 0.13988599786534905, + 0.13487072195857763, + 0.13745669787749648, + 0.13585102884098887, + 0.13406423665583134, + 0.13737939344719052, + 0.1343643879517913, + 0.1328791631385684, + 0.13307572808116674, + 0.1388323800638318, + 0.13100745156407356, + 0.13344917492941022, + 0.13842013850808144, + 0.14002644130960107, + 0.1480988534167409, + 0.14594949129968882, + 0.1445249142125249, + 0.15918712969869375, + 0.1457719737663865, + 0.13639698596671224, + 0.13799033127725124, + 0.13659448036924005, + 0.14323629112914205, + 0.14889676170423627, + 0.13008646899834275, + 0.1322610811330378, + 0.1459856005385518, + 0.13647880731150508, + 0.13048451067879796, + 0.1418708865530789, + 0.13975662644952536, + 0.14865571353584528, + 0.1488426998257637, + 0.14214518293738365, + 0.13389265537261963, + 0.14539054036140442, + 0.13179328432306647, + 0.13616903545334935, + 0.13333435356616974, + 0.13791473535820842, + 0.13672107458114624, + 0.14136562263593078, + 0.13431778410449624, + 0.13365686032921076, + 0.13210805458948016, + 0.14378560846671462, + 0.13546996610239148, + 0.1280153589323163, + 0.13638005638495088, + 0.1477128155529499, + 0.1397946709766984, + 0.14168549934402108, + 0.1384690166451037, + 0.14091259706765413, + 0.13350574159994721, + 0.1284376853145659, + 0.13468846352770925, + 0.14282595459371805, + 0.13531496282666922, + 0.13395900884643197, + 0.12808191077783704, + 0.12713731173425913, + 0.12053857930004597, + 0.13565425155684352, + 0.12372160190716386, + 0.13105597300454974, + 0.14865460386499763, + 0.12809196207672358, + 0.13920494634658098, + 0.13400580501183867, + 0.12931938329711556, + 0.12811866868287325, + 0.12861747341230512, + 0.12461027503013611, + 0.1260393038392067, + 0.13069829810410738, + 0.1325773517601192, + 0.13417166890576482, + 0.14295210363343358, + 0.13419665303081274, + 0.13293955801054835, + 0.12935120472684503, + 0.13188304845243692, + 0.1332323681563139, + 0.13150134775787592, + 0.12497172225266695, + 0.13671137858182192, + 0.12752830469980836, + 0.12665652856230736, + 0.12997393496334553, + 0.1360920495353639, + 0.1327368593774736, + 0.12960634473711252, + 0.13610385404899716, + 0.11859995033591986, + 0.12756154499948025, + 0.12669335724785924, + 0.12134114932268858, + 0.13488255627453327, + 0.1324220192618668, + 0.13360243383795023, + 0.1306043448857963, + 0.12046756409108639, + 0.12975328508764505, + 0.12631483795121312, + 0.1238508801907301, + 0.1254491051658988, + 0.12325134733691812, + 0.1276082070544362, + 0.12961307540535927, + 0.1203029053285718, + 0.12031061900779605, + 0.12450918927788734, + 0.12820843793451786, + 0.13565944274887443, + 0.1306085865944624, + 0.13599174097180367, + 0.12379317311570048, + 0.13600375317037106, + 0.13628132082521915, + 0.12661721324548125, + 0.1208619736135006, + 0.12691504647955298, + 0.13222917262464762, + 0.1271150284446776, + 0.12033449951559305, + 0.12723328173160553, + 0.12441314896568656, + 0.12833426427096128, + 0.12306154938414693, + 0.11653568083420396, + 0.12429293151944876, + 0.12171761505305767, + 0.11853516800329089, + 0.12865133304148912, + 0.11537331435829401, + 0.12454622192308307, + 0.1301572280935943, + 0.12105582561343908, + 0.12421852629631758, + 0.11910535441711545, + 0.12480779131874442, + 0.12122324900701642, + 0.11897459393367171, + 0.12231890531256795, + 0.12436972977593541, + 0.12278506672009826, + 0.12605397356674075, + 0.11936095030978322, + 0.12267190404236317, + 0.12557120388373733, + 0.12602956406772137, + 0.13230113266035914, + 0.11907059466466308, + 0.12852039327844977, + 0.11911496752873063, + 0.12977532157674432, + 0.12796203047037125, + 0.11760214902460575, + 0.12442833930253983, + 0.11263494892045856, + 0.11529955919831991, + 0.11083711450919509, + 0.12100480543449521, + 0.11694699758663774, + 0.12485063960775733, + 0.1195503338240087, + 0.12137516029179096, + 0.1252887467853725, + 0.1299043302424252, + 0.13039902597665787, + 0.1186311412602663, + 0.13107757875695825, + 0.12268274463713169, + 0.11271380865946412, + 0.11580896843224764, + 0.1212987769395113, + 0.1296535567380488, + 0.11903415201231837, + 0.11907692393288016, + 0.11477827187627554, + 0.12351787323132157, + 0.10969124734401703, + 0.12050369987264276, + 0.11520074540749192, + 0.11197219183668494, + 0.11771611962467432, + 0.11679714033380151, + 0.12934494204819202, + 0.11411267844960093, + 0.12614680547267199, + 0.11281427880749106, + 0.11986694624647498, + 0.11986720468848944, + 0.12898731557652354, + 0.11911078402772546, + 0.12702778168022633, + 0.11603251565247774, + 0.1269685197621584, + 0.11167425662279129, + 0.13006531121209264, + 0.12951509142294526, + 0.12372750695794821, + 0.12100194953382015, + 0.1136569338850677, + 0.11975296074524522, + 0.12176019977778196, + 0.11339768767356873, + 0.1244922592304647, + 0.10772625403478742, + 0.10986040346324444, + 0.12015654379501939, + 0.12077671708539128, + 0.12505153566598892, + 0.11914991354569793, + 0.11494203004986048, + 0.12181897228583694, + 0.12930556200444698, + 0.11456535290926695, + 0.11360380798578262, + 0.12243652436882257, + 0.11005036672577262, + 0.13293860340490937, + 0.12170646479353309, + 0.12107955478131771, + 0.12486449535936117, + 0.11862899409607053, + 0.12152523314580321, + 0.11080187978222966, + 0.11419497989118099, + 0.11868024244904518, + 0.12171669816598296, + 0.10967948660254478, + 0.11677869781851768, + 0.12295479187741876, + 0.10912753734737635, + 0.13548160856589675, + 0.11180360103026032, + 0.13421792816370726, + 0.12135241273790598, + 0.11306971125304699, + 0.11812817258760333, + 0.1052872957661748, + 0.12701907940208912, + 0.11338095739483833, + 0.1262958445586264, + 0.11316352244466543, + 0.11596736777573824, + 0.12404543440788984, + 0.10697562340646982, + 0.1141065782867372, + 0.11172527587041259, + 0.12425919389352202, + 0.1215077773667872, + 0.11005650041624904, + 0.1256220657378435, + 0.11631766613572836, + 0.12077214615419507, + 0.1278599421493709, + 0.12000335846096277, + 0.11371088121086359, + 0.11978852888569236, + 0.11426253663375974, + 0.1126609337516129, + 0.12384762521833181, + 0.10754721704870462, + 0.1133484011515975, + 0.1121636494062841, + 0.11193350376561284, + 0.11727725248783827, + 0.11378732649609447, + 0.12425646837800741, + 0.11333418032154441, + 0.10888495622202754, + 0.10866889776661992, + 0.12489686254411936, + 0.12169590592384338, + 0.11628066934645176, + 0.1087639364413917, + 0.10893157310783863, + 0.12245470425114036, + 0.11740407114848495, + 0.10980174271389842, + 0.12399038299918175, + 0.1196211613714695, + 0.11414692783728242, + 0.11831600777804852, + 0.1173305488191545, + 0.1132545955479145, + 0.12020778050646186, + 0.1103137107565999, + 0.11172897322103381, + 0.12078855838626623, + 0.11073819734156132, + 0.11070482106879354, + 0.12133699143305421, + 0.11225512810051441, + 0.1198809053748846, + 0.11566954758018255, + 0.11664536641910672, + 0.12767384154722095, + 0.11016975017264485, + 0.10822283430024981, + 0.1158544416539371, + 0.12171392887830734, + 0.11117060761898756, + 0.11534348595887423, + 0.1166975200176239, + 0.11656307522207499, + 0.11068711336702108, + 0.12001409847289324, + 0.1034937622025609, + 0.11312022712081671, + 0.1147842057980597, + 0.12316064769402146, + 0.11124958144500852, + 0.12018597172573209, + 0.10959208477288485, + 0.1037068972364068, + 0.1225923802703619, + 0.1107993284240365, + 0.10466971294954419, + 0.10839008586481214, + 0.11486728582531214, + 0.11311797797679901, + 0.11369650671258569, + 0.12289276393130422, + 0.1100731729529798, + 0.11452446272596717, + 0.10883522452786565, + 0.11663975892588496, + 0.11455050017684698, + 0.10280598234385252, + 0.10755748441442847, + 0.1116825882345438, + 0.1198344910517335, + 0.1216606474481523, + 0.11895332532003522, + 0.10931953648105264, + 0.11033265292644501, + 0.10474656848236918, + 0.12811153195798397, + 0.1153065045364201, + 0.10464239865541458, + 0.11972310394048691, + 0.10756668727844954, + 0.10778252920135856, + 0.11397498706355691, + 0.11917151138186455, + 0.11547385528683662, + 0.11612737644463778, + 0.1062660408206284, + 0.11468643648549914, + 0.10452401777729392, + 0.1025899494998157, + 0.1037788325920701, + 0.11976135428994894, + 0.1296846098266542, + 0.11290780454874039, + 0.10620269039645791, + 0.10870355600491166, + 0.10558887664228678, + 0.11464335396885872, + 0.10866149887442589, + 0.11575175868347287, + 0.11329459305852652, + 0.11799022881314158, + 0.10248596593737602, + 0.11192962573841214, + 0.11157823260873556, + 0.10370491724461317, + 0.10381398489698768, + 0.11116447485983372, + 0.1080501233227551, + 0.10306511726230383, + 0.10483616963028908, + 0.11317054554820061, + 0.11025194264948368, + 0.10710304789245129, + 0.10806155717000365, + 0.1073706652969122, + 0.09867928083986044, + 0.10888521373271942, + 0.10042995400726795, + 0.10040122363716364, + 0.10953589156270027, + 0.10694928374141455, + 0.10362790012732148, + 0.10301473876461387, + 0.1031717169098556, + 0.11145062744617462, + 0.11323399003595114, + 0.10284453257918358, + 0.10519605223089457, + 0.11289473809301853, + 0.12084509991109371, + 0.10547360451892018, + 0.12078093830496073, + 0.10290497308596969, + 0.10643428098410368, + 0.10707903048023582, + 0.10738644795492291, + 0.10134685970842838, + 0.10683441581204534, + 0.11642514914274216, + 0.10906811710447073, + 0.10590427508577704, + 0.10554772661998868, + 0.10413244646042585, + 0.11015440849587321, + 0.10252539534121752, + 0.09931377740576863, + 0.10358934849500656, + 0.10290792025625706, + 0.10361051885411143, + 0.10186566598713398, + 0.09821728197857738, + 0.11561616137623787, + 0.12137844879180193, + 0.10323449829593301, + 0.11523491935804486, + 0.12453261436894536, + 0.11310669779777527, + 0.11412252625450492, + 0.1085133827291429, + 0.10222187545150518, + 0.10586719727143645, + 0.10139086004346609, + 0.11051873909309506, + 0.10186333488672972, + 0.09814416710287333, + 0.0998663054779172, + 0.10108443396165967, + 0.10595660097897053, + 0.10412291483953595, + 0.103140311781317, + 0.10067183338105679, + 0.10373957408592105, + 0.10383832547813654, + 0.10280857933685184, + 0.10204639658331871, + 0.10752894636243582, + 0.09842428425326943, + 0.10864787315949798, + 0.09979382576420903, + 0.10005956934764981, + 0.09675007546320558, + 0.10226126806810498, + 0.10367757035419345, + 0.09979386022314429, + 0.10518642934039235, + 0.09841199265792966, + 0.10929231252521276, + 0.09842620883136988, + 0.09835416963323951, + 0.10712556215003133, + 0.11067909514531493, + 0.10868362290784717, + 0.10815954906865954, + 0.10316379880532622, + 0.10336694028228521, + 0.1036896975710988, + 0.10263882856816053, + 0.10274551995098591, + 0.09846232505515218, + 0.09894799068570137, + 0.10480742808431387, + 0.10652302298694849, + 0.10125357564538717, + 0.10297025321051478, + 0.09825109178200364, + 0.09877169784158468, + 0.10471121547743678, + 0.09381878422573209, + 0.10297174658626318, + 0.09763706801459193, + 0.10273834131658077, + 0.10524562047794461, + 0.09820220386609435, + 0.09859982179477811, + 0.09738266561180353, + 0.09683849150314927, + 0.09694162802770734, + 0.10193144390359521, + 0.0984281343407929, + 0.09748972440138459, + 0.0972871407866478, + 0.10790367238223553, + 0.09266776870936155, + 0.09456645091995597, + 0.09771050792187452, + 0.10052121058106422, + 0.1022122367285192, + 0.10549240419641137, + 0.09981294255703688, + 0.09896602900698781, + 0.10339024057611823, + 0.09859781479462981, + 0.10256988788023591, + 0.09713227627798915, + 0.10778947919607162, + 0.11633788608014584, + 0.10886682523414493, + 0.10783463949337602, + 0.11853600293397903, + 0.10915336199104786, + 0.10649898834526539, + 0.11239175917580724, + 0.10707848658785224, + 0.10373052023351192, + 0.1097326916642487, + 0.10838780365884304, + 0.09927304508164525, + 0.09958817390725017, + 0.09488135762512684, + 0.09979386674240232, + 0.10149832675233483, + 0.09406122425571084, + 0.10877686366438866, + 0.11519669787958264, + 0.09901890298351645, + 0.09504700219258666, + 0.09779617795720696, + 0.09738055383786559, + 0.09794846130535007, + 0.09601491177454591, + 0.09758895821869373, + 0.09359634574502707, + 0.10176765685901046, + 0.09862278960645199, + 0.10084335785359144, + 0.10144846048206091, + 0.10481570707634091, + 0.09489258751273155, + 0.10354580823332071, + 0.12295328499749303, + 0.10755076305940747, + 0.10245038010179996, + 0.10020021116361022, + 0.10172212077304721, + 0.0983713292516768, + 0.10408610664308071, + 0.09768832987174392, + 0.09504338540136814, + 0.09909078711643815, + 0.1070460812188685, + 0.09459074027836323, + 0.0946970609948039, + 0.10313753597438335, + 0.09891787590458989, + 0.10116108134388924, + 0.10265982896089554, + 0.09383998950943351, + 0.10018219891935587, + 0.10110283689573407, + 0.09866275219246745, + 0.09424997167661786, + 0.09512544935569167, + 0.0960837877355516, + 0.09616329008713365, + 0.0965914442203939, + 0.10323083074763417, + 0.09477340104058385, + 0.09681569645181298, + 0.10114386631175876, + 0.09993518935516477, + 0.09898614510893822, + 0.09630171349272132, + 0.09256313042715192, + 0.0984373758547008, + 0.09645025478675961, + 0.09128946671262383, + 0.10334409354254603, + 0.10126751381903887, + 0.09309948515146971, + 0.09335337625816464, + 0.1000102674588561, + 0.09122539358213544, + 0.09927165880799294, + 0.10122876986861229, + 0.09608001122251153, + 0.09645769093185663, + 0.09562005521729589, + 0.09246784169226885, + 0.09064403222873807, + 0.09868582570925355, + 0.09497273759916425, + 0.10431475518271327, + 0.10186849581077695, + 0.0926617681980133, + 0.10044465120881796, + 0.11283755768090487, + 0.09551058802753687, + 0.10011938493698835, + 0.10555943753570318, + 0.0956180333159864, + 0.09448084980249405, + 0.09939342690631747, + 0.09772749431431293, + 0.09883692301809788, + 0.10176392877474427, + 0.09550199704244733, + 0.09950503520667553, + 0.11104709096252918, + 0.10178866656497121, + 0.09987613279372454, + 0.09910565847530961, + 0.09493890218436718, + 0.09186848951503634, + 0.09170936094596982, + 0.09379438403993845, + 0.08980611572042108, + 0.1011039069853723, + 0.09200764074921608, + 0.09411295270547271, + 0.09316874202340841, + 0.08957572700455785, + 0.09961993852630258, + 0.10011170944198966, + 0.09594263182953, + 0.09283410524949431, + 0.09594372706487775, + 0.09332213643938303, + 0.10019827168434858, + 0.09955319948494434, + 0.0935154277831316, + 0.09421004820615053, + 0.1021817266009748, + 0.09442281071096659, + 0.09491592738777399, + 0.09473255090415478, + 0.09393865521997213, + 0.09239985048770905, + 0.09828094486147165, + 0.09147400595247746, + 0.09741805214434862, + 0.09053871128708124, + 0.09326527873054147, + 0.09260819433256984, + 0.0953708360902965, + 0.09289056481793523, + 0.09399160323664546, + 0.08793286746367812, + 0.09177717845886946, + 0.09311742894351482, + 0.09069950506091118, + 0.08899368112906814, + 0.09140671417117119, + 0.08728171791881323, + 0.0946354572661221, + 0.09013733826577663, + 0.09913708968088031, + 0.09284232556819916, + 0.09439388010650873, + 0.08815816044807434, + 0.09024188574403524, + 0.0886821886524558, + 0.08828871510922909, + 0.09158680494874716, + 0.08994869142770767, + 0.08702044608071446, + 0.08831466175615788, + 0.09436140675097704, + 0.08924024552106857, + 0.09360016649588943, + 0.0927204699255526, + 0.09125114558264613, + 0.09839270310476422, + 0.10366573184728622, + 0.08783575473353267, + 0.10485562728717923, + 0.10456847306340933, + 0.09589188359677792, + 0.09292864194139838, + 0.09507320169359446, + 0.08963240077719092, + 0.09766984963789582, + 0.10006162524223328, + 0.08976237988099456, + 0.09661335591226816, + 0.10369246965274215, + 0.0918745119124651, + 0.09350878885015845, + 0.09771493915468454, + 0.09397084917873144, + 0.09214442875236273, + 0.10135312983766198, + 0.09252361534163356, + 0.09052379475906491, + 0.09665936417877674, + 0.088601169642061, + 0.09921923372894526, + 0.10134472697973251, + 0.09699719352647662, + 0.09296363918110728, + 0.10207046568393707, + 0.09117563394829631, + 0.09387828689068556, + 0.09608576260507107, + 0.09268047148361802, + 0.09427049430087209, + 0.08981574745848775, + 0.09478741372004151, + 0.09393709572032094, + 0.09652113961055875, + 0.09285607561469078, + 0.09133070055395365, + 0.09906006371602416, + 0.09480642154812813, + 0.09676234610378742, + 0.10031305020675063, + 0.09147788072004914, + 0.09406357491388917, + 0.09813245013356209, + 0.09203511942178011, + 0.09758320963010192, + 0.0980461286380887, + 0.10269544972106814, + 0.08975074347108603, + 0.09544243337586522, + 0.10444677993655205, + 0.10175528703257442, + 0.09329885616898537, + 0.09518331754952669, + 0.09721372928470373, + 0.0907663106918335, + 0.09407031629234552, + 0.09132609516382217, + 0.09301172057166696, + 0.0944930324330926, + 0.09065300412476063, + 0.08904377417638898, + 0.09369406010955572, + 0.09324043849483132, + 0.0967624681070447, + 0.11229856172576547, + 0.10064367717131972, + 0.08997702458873391, + 0.09799320017918944, + 0.10184445045888424, + 0.096383863594383, + 0.09320830088108778, + 0.10006997734308243, + 0.10145615506917238, + 0.10017695324495435, + 0.10565315606072545, + 0.09352718107402325, + 0.1011579129844904, + 0.10217945137992501, + 0.0963423429057002, + 0.09331131028011441, + 0.09124302957206964, + 0.10113072954118252, + 0.09479283215478063, + 0.09175093984231353, + 0.09128808416426182, + 0.08934195106849074, + 0.091045793145895, + 0.09104316309094429, + 0.09489178191870451, + 0.09691222151741385, + 0.09063123119994998, + 0.09076013090088964, + 0.09618918178603053, + 0.09531038021668792, + 0.09279429260641336, + 0.08944111922755837, + 0.08892789063975215, + 0.08892261330038309, + 0.10072639072313905, + 0.09757563751190901, + 0.08963818987831473 + ], + "best_loss": 0.08702044608071446, + "best_epoch": 888, + "eval": { + "diffusion_16": { + "iterations": [ + 25, + 25, + 23, + 23, + 23, + 26, + 22, + 28, + 27, + 31, + 29, + 25, + 25, + 28, + 27, + 26, + 24, + 32, + 25, + 24, + 22, + 25, + 30, + 25, + 24, + 26, + 27, + 24, + 25, + 21, + 30, + 28, + 28, + 27, + 29, + 26, + 23, + 27, + 28, + 25, + 24, + 30, + 23, + 29, + 24, + 27, + 30, + 25, + 25, + 23 + ], + "converged": [ + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 8.486948573713518e-07, + 8.93215997827106e-07, + 9.696985486176863e-07, + 4.5881966809315784e-07, + 7.656368955409393e-07, + 9.438426036097072e-07, + 4.830693051285019e-07, + 7.755569678265706e-07, + 8.884811233555013e-07, + 9.352813577767679e-07, + 9.8856184781648e-07, + 6.222954231920986e-07, + 7.439651240051298e-07, + 6.237910871082804e-07, + 4.899837000114371e-07, + 8.520839412436516e-07, + 5.896020687957356e-07, + 9.107597383005436e-07, + 5.786063817414028e-07, + 9.890597261681034e-07, + 4.402239763062526e-07, + 8.292676372053424e-07, + 8.223974469706752e-07, + 9.75017122168882e-07, + 2.815240619666347e-07, + 6.189929598141138e-07, + 8.835827157638174e-07, + 6.438237782404391e-07, + 8.025906948463777e-07, + 7.430094527646321e-07, + 8.734876717637496e-07, + 5.168146240233767e-07, + 8.049980041242544e-07, + 6.245499247072549e-07, + 8.31713152432476e-07, + 7.23254270027718e-07, + 5.587948284948572e-07, + 5.43966932740307e-07, + 6.89724808018432e-07, + 5.374215338116037e-07, + 8.470030484423459e-07, + 6.768289028785412e-07, + 6.003673015053221e-07, + 9.214593556318978e-07, + 7.311867299095199e-07, + 5.799315586730314e-07, + 8.726764800045928e-07, + 4.799173963212683e-07, + 6.333207580513938e-07, + 9.179311132465985e-07 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 10.6114476620005, + 0.2859203059997526, + 0.22156016799999634, + 0.25686385200060613, + 0.2826669909991324, + 0.2827941980012838, + 0.23871207000047434, + 0.30062238999926194, + 0.3215141170003335, + 0.37840354399850185, + 0.32534661700083234, + 0.27875853200021083, + 0.2750052819992561, + 0.31496830800097086, + 0.28109027499885997, + 0.2889536479997332, + 0.2772334220007906, + 0.36091270100041584, + 0.29830553300053, + 0.2674691049996909, + 0.20895491299961577, + 0.27132035800059384, + 0.35733398999946075, + 0.3807427789997746, + 0.36154285300108313, + 0.4332425639986468, + 0.4269165069999872, + 0.3831798789997265, + 0.3989367060003133, + 0.3043141779999132, + 0.5969423200003803, + 0.36172078599884117, + 0.4183541560014419, + 0.3272613260014623, + 0.35317951800061564, + 0.2690197649990296, + 0.28602763199887704, + 0.30358693199923437, + 0.34069295299923397, + 0.3219731169992883, + 0.25162527700013015, + 0.35334252800021204, + 0.27884057499977644, + 0.3822287860002689, + 0.29508859400084475, + 0.34539399099958246, + 0.34087506200012285, + 0.2509260240003641, + 0.27538168099999893, + 0.3005740139997215 + ], + "output_norm_ratios": [ + 9.033767513334944, + 7.182642104453216, + 6.466201387490864, + 6.474520049601614, + 7.687332608253224, + 7.153372900719102, + 8.26834628616114, + 8.718200158211884, + 7.908899084024085, + 7.378146253948397, + 8.245848941196629, + 7.85908986748963, + 7.18150031797168, + 7.864032402620576, + 8.079582844991998, + 6.768204726466545, + 7.8755505754413795, + 9.43500105143357, + 7.937140616840248, + 8.045125105418995, + 7.973335838182101, + 7.75309315903232, + 7.064406050335856, + 5.851584598969348, + 7.1762552965066275, + 6.364061594169059, + 7.193102731540455, + 8.448943545386816, + 8.091491730428892, + 8.366975465431453, + 7.8362487417679025, + 8.341781639386456, + 8.220704230420933, + 9.685312923078829, + 8.209221134869564, + 10.207318727535126, + 9.790580274891669, + 7.987333423702473, + 7.474508284436007, + 7.353466013991529, + 8.057026239603742, + 8.522986271136181, + 7.358148624781238, + 8.722028287342255, + 9.390511813181483, + 6.223818127639319, + 7.839745279721733, + 6.707686699653315, + 8.110438886852778, + 7.741203345258802 + ] + }, + "diffusion_24": { + "iterations": [ + 36, + 35, + 34, + 41, + 38, + 40, + 31, + 35, + 38, + 55, + 34, + 40, + 49, + 35, + 35, + 42, + 33, + 43, + 39, + 36, + 40, + 38, + 42, + 37, + 37, + 37, + 37, + 39, + 37, + 41, + 34, + 38, + 46, + 33, + 37, + 37, + 33, + 40, + 41, + 39, + 42, + 38, + 41, + 54, + 46, + 42, + 43, + 36, + 43, + 41 + ], + "converged": [ + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 7.563654961635594e-07, + 7.650742308475508e-07, + 9.82992357917644e-07, + 8.973239651972792e-07, + 9.730346974306252e-07, + 9.918631175321822e-07, + 9.772468595050408e-07, + 9.851567643235913e-07, + 9.080819801337835e-07, + 9.577902394913797e-07, + 7.835079876990535e-07, + 9.987682980769308e-07, + 6.821629607994088e-07, + 6.699077535118607e-07, + 7.065547145193649e-07, + 7.926186807627861e-07, + 8.858690093316029e-07, + 9.64770498628356e-07, + 7.738663331639901e-07, + 8.198718576305714e-07, + 6.76240833817705e-07, + 5.914940567578735e-07, + 8.123444516356568e-07, + 9.968023041315893e-07, + 7.129096968385534e-07, + 8.215924650137302e-07, + 8.567716209730061e-07, + 7.663127328586069e-07, + 5.909677874063851e-07, + 7.477714174220039e-07, + 8.547253962962093e-07, + 8.828161892006104e-07, + 8.092980205138181e-07, + 8.654129955012021e-07, + 9.861467067418338e-07, + 8.102739804973845e-07, + 5.751588193837613e-07, + 7.075978841444156e-07, + 6.681252381805154e-07, + 8.609287642882863e-07, + 9.981706301048176e-07, + 7.667775763050793e-07, + 9.866715846139772e-07, + 9.212589968204003e-07, + 9.30667557243988e-07, + 9.80801970658018e-07, + 7.74176751097147e-07, + 7.754329619830699e-07, + 8.376623757161964e-07, + 9.528642854857944e-07 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 11.173268848999214, + 0.3707099969997216, + 0.414429372000086, + 0.45581819800099765, + 0.4766786210002465, + 0.4845208980004827, + 0.4061761140001181, + 0.42481790899910266, + 0.6359693719987263, + 0.8923643420002918, + 0.520444107000003, + 0.5943330299996887, + 0.7856660359993839, + 0.40955652899901906, + 0.4073208070003602, + 0.46189630000117177, + 0.38548184300088906, + 0.5292418539993378, + 0.5591383920000226, + 0.3827407429998857, + 0.4505366960001993, + 0.4315249290011707, + 0.4684047209993878, + 0.37955511300060607, + 0.3987614270008635, + 0.4147093120009231, + 0.429403636000643, + 0.4737264380000852, + 0.4166888809995726, + 0.45235501900060626, + 0.3741635890000907, + 0.43390835100035474, + 0.4779074710004352, + 0.4218747869999788, + 0.3854524130001664, + 0.521440389999043, + 0.6062703429997782, + 0.5979797659983888, + 0.6299955059985223, + 0.6431200259994512, + 0.6724061069999152, + 0.4437645830003021, + 0.44740660000024945, + 0.6307156069997291, + 0.487212013998942, + 0.48476724899956025, + 0.4667674870015617, + 0.4197052330000588, + 0.4787531910005782, + 0.4655002109993802 + ], + "output_norm_ratios": [ + 7.943116161609758, + 7.814721443399055, + 7.630800277019647, + 7.497930901576222, + 7.1906476729908695, + 7.512354869162121, + 7.556385667301902, + 7.125841641358508, + 8.790638274001445, + 7.97290556403829, + 8.557927098405045, + 8.089143642043489, + 7.691712325285212, + 8.359239101536701, + 8.285805858058476, + 8.651142707868495, + 7.037395160333981, + 6.41292968023281, + 7.680342254873862, + 8.399156293757882, + 7.56108657827493, + 8.667766065137055, + 7.894438718547055, + 7.954579516651025, + 6.883703544573475, + 9.38829243811839, + 6.806833378565719, + 7.088758791305413, + 8.543189572831864, + 7.746952220082368, + 7.8496726028821895, + 7.367094308363469, + 9.146110946888518, + 6.931308497240492, + 7.82344002494153, + 8.954872094906918, + 7.393769567420241, + 7.416854417707262, + 6.221658577331312, + 7.621752553209618, + 7.264923721383555, + 9.503544984548567, + 7.954207414626792, + 7.121388447323282, + 7.608628668210093, + 8.026055657682997, + 7.706930961923089, + 7.746635975723978, + 8.083907041812608, + 8.671154787697889 + ] + }, + "diffusion_32": { + "iterations": [ + 51, + 47, + 60, + 49, + 55, + 46, + 42, + 50, + 49, + 45, + 48, + 60, + 44, + 50, + 54, + 53, + 49, + 48, + 45, + 55, + 45, + 45, + 56, + 43, + 66, + 42, + 46, + 45, + 54, + 53, + 52, + 51, + 57, + 47, + 45, + 44, + 52, + 50, + 42, + 45, + 54, + 47, + 60, + 55, + 46, + 50, + 53, + 59, + 50, + 45 + ], + "converged": [ + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 8.800467697186909e-07, + 9.203958946286945e-07, + 8.857966479595532e-07, + 9.523892519776944e-07, + 8.110384727770864e-07, + 8.880994753362966e-07, + 8.603632638360321e-07, + 9.09735365298048e-07, + 7.585946168114156e-07, + 8.508798823431009e-07, + 8.948776901041599e-07, + 8.445038529048678e-07, + 9.729809500306996e-07, + 8.012421149485108e-07, + 7.6933880902786e-07, + 9.469939020084597e-07, + 9.152119414256873e-07, + 8.418309294419092e-07, + 9.965507707071932e-07, + 8.238009561789639e-07, + 9.287480819199251e-07, + 9.262939169547482e-07, + 8.446659227736376e-07, + 7.212682288595631e-07, + 9.872988597522991e-07, + 8.142269034792946e-07, + 8.513065580684797e-07, + 8.175485066786201e-07, + 9.643790011642642e-07, + 9.533425792641668e-07, + 8.346818158179811e-07, + 7.432621448659437e-07, + 7.353556341456044e-07, + 8.31142087088633e-07, + 9.215051116719232e-07, + 6.490163930430672e-07, + 8.307730022333724e-07, + 8.238591591389271e-07, + 9.288594340652001e-07, + 9.146866250841676e-07, + 8.075888477471752e-07, + 9.479631473525746e-07, + 8.783214612400472e-07, + 9.79250124315812e-07, + 8.947309389012014e-07, + 8.56261061198785e-07, + 7.839637689439081e-07, + 9.279594287960866e-07, + 7.236686152611756e-07, + 8.842188387980225e-07 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 10.23224622700036, + 0.4921216380007536, + 0.8141748779999034, + 0.7910521179983334, + 0.8772857459989609, + 0.714729981000346, + 0.6867601419999119, + 0.5648528049987362, + 0.5633945089994086, + 0.46461142499902053, + 0.5912353470012022, + 0.6970409259993176, + 0.4828222550004284, + 0.5294532909992995, + 0.6333032269994874, + 0.6037847410007089, + 0.5646296819995769, + 0.5794929720013897, + 0.45710151299863355, + 0.6185159399992699, + 0.49376533800023026, + 0.47376040000017383, + 0.6221148519998678, + 0.4813914480000676, + 1.0363164440004766, + 0.6459638050000649, + 0.7317249190000439, + 0.7298592189999908, + 0.8950860279983317, + 0.6103439239996078, + 0.5745204140002897, + 0.5590673219994642, + 0.6777350829997886, + 0.49753741700078535, + 0.5366261520011903, + 0.4612319249990833, + 0.6220411220001552, + 0.5718907570008014, + 0.46624453000003996, + 0.49677204200088454, + 0.5828103450003255, + 0.5519412070007093, + 0.7611875309994502, + 0.6704513089989632, + 0.5078748550004093, + 0.5863796889989317, + 0.9013387670001975, + 0.9983615529999952, + 0.7698403499998676, + 0.6569026910001412 + ], + "output_norm_ratios": [ + 8.153221607641129, + 9.032871321946994, + 6.745397320479365, + 6.9830848935693055, + 7.919356417346238, + 7.785544985642308, + 8.988329426062105, + 8.139523872881464, + 7.858263789137161, + 8.46171298342476, + 8.363503704232794, + 8.022166847444181, + 7.819841746623234, + 8.518629442367589, + 8.086946385612556, + 7.8912356956188345, + 7.416092329336339, + 8.794297751659926, + 7.143788620193645, + 7.543640853917275, + 9.622165800822556, + 7.901326825765355, + 7.522228195988066, + 7.592209259531872, + 8.470961293747832, + 6.905612217254221, + 8.34034088887678, + 8.336220813056412, + 7.772868624292322, + 8.552876713364817, + 7.668041862548303, + 7.642248524308117, + 8.751520897354503, + 7.285810469324432, + 7.877400982597582, + 7.0451647922141785, + 8.072005100930816, + 6.420174058630057, + 7.663623910570923, + 8.34410081047347, + 8.118235954744913, + 8.217704374560961, + 7.687665756035781, + 9.24664160903542, + 7.094599534724472, + 8.200574094781368, + 8.132233178042833, + 7.705186498836587, + 7.909217751651184, + 7.3549155756371665 + ] + }, + "diffusion_48": { + "iterations": [ + 69, + 68, + 67, + 68, + 68, + 70, + 66, + 61, + 76, + 78, + 66, + 77, + 73, + 64, + 77, + 62, + 62, + 70, + 68, + 73, + 66, + 59, + 63, + 72, + 63, + 73, + 69, + 62, + 71, + 60, + 69, + 74, + 75, + 69, + 59, + 67, + 80, + 61, + 66, + 72, + 58, + 63, + 69, + 66, + 64, + 73, + 62, + 58, + 67, + 72 + ], + "converged": [ + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 8.141602353567552e-07, + 9.956822921215714e-07, + 9.642197365775416e-07, + 7.334773688331952e-07, + 8.558908949358835e-07, + 8.671375554389319e-07, + 9.92492765193148e-07, + 9.153493221421653e-07, + 9.973194628639756e-07, + 7.395706804501054e-07, + 9.1040644526773e-07, + 9.681042626473251e-07, + 9.578675296598622e-07, + 8.768017876496976e-07, + 9.326182509903322e-07, + 9.671669966179423e-07, + 9.978100927980782e-07, + 9.416679195978749e-07, + 8.312854082471641e-07, + 8.716762877762356e-07, + 8.296264414389629e-07, + 9.739265412176516e-07, + 9.226712284307867e-07, + 9.508936604664939e-07, + 8.77030360666993e-07, + 9.854606014601098e-07, + 9.323825260265826e-07, + 9.65630369343105e-07, + 9.944515326491524e-07, + 8.996889120997013e-07, + 8.557932876155132e-07, + 8.541288908394844e-07, + 8.683029695142751e-07, + 9.897183331596807e-07, + 8.330423878175286e-07, + 8.607893978516127e-07, + 7.951816600166347e-07, + 9.915109786094707e-07, + 8.168758706278484e-07, + 8.805319227181341e-07, + 9.614992914983807e-07, + 9.936640785024073e-07, + 9.84067235886633e-07, + 8.179901149358511e-07, + 8.54476470622202e-07, + 8.770846448688091e-07, + 9.55921944062864e-07, + 7.375818132034615e-07, + 8.444951369398018e-07, + 9.309603413525403e-07 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 11.959534515999621, + 0.9856692729990755, + 0.747943562000728, + 0.8114642420005111, + 0.8534147490008763, + 0.8544404599997506, + 0.7351978410006268, + 0.7092892209984711, + 0.8771075310014567, + 0.8755051339994679, + 0.7453104229989549, + 0.8331160739999177, + 0.8010105320008734, + 0.8063033250000444, + 1.2668361609994463, + 0.9766252150002401, + 0.9590042430008907, + 0.7994447460005176, + 0.7697841729986976, + 0.828073057000438, + 0.7353671660002874, + 0.7981534470000042, + 0.7524870010001905, + 0.8204766540002311, + 0.755458035000629, + 0.8567984090004757, + 0.8145292910012358, + 0.7005566569987423, + 0.8446126399994682, + 1.0422187089989166, + 1.0880266709991702, + 1.1855939409997518, + 0.9745023920004314, + 0.8142505539999547, + 0.6578894319991377, + 0.8452871829995274, + 0.8900390689996129, + 0.7357180010003503, + 0.7872341279999091, + 0.8227796289993421, + 0.7669046949995391, + 0.7750426230013545, + 0.7893064689997118, + 0.7727548759994534, + 0.9765817379993678, + 1.1680305339996266, + 1.0195707509992644, + 0.8620341989990266, + 0.7495005750006385, + 0.8129242480008543 + ], + "output_norm_ratios": [ + 7.642095073272403, + 7.891341104817979, + 7.635409795039407, + 9.078100026515576, + 7.3319640675249405, + 7.951621041393458, + 7.8148450743027285, + 8.294060453203539, + 8.450375485970417, + 8.018909019330133, + 8.251291377445112, + 8.816143077649047, + 7.502249506003538, + 7.817089498928992, + 7.654209162920525, + 8.24111690810334, + 8.59290121384918, + 8.291459469217633, + 7.872395244439926, + 9.653932695552605, + 7.206565912637604, + 7.748209186398009, + 8.938193942763478, + 7.140839525693077, + 7.821064523744413, + 8.64548648456739, + 7.7587376512792625, + 7.566296842167752, + 8.207743089924092, + 8.043243023246355, + 8.40474913479909, + 9.449958456445534, + 8.368148300978184, + 8.65144740383868, + 8.333094227614254, + 7.781101188695362, + 7.849371596763889, + 8.205289087722832, + 8.09394715201832, + 10.841707943917323, + 8.225842150446427, + 8.68645968729801, + 8.581521071287957, + 7.632726734356928, + 8.07464118006104, + 7.3293926374297715, + 8.782653583914776, + 8.494684930197263, + 7.596276571369482, + 8.175968512241065 + ] + }, + "diffusion_64": { + "iterations": [ + 75, + 88, + 99, + 75, + 93, + 79, + 87, + 73, + 79, + 90, + 92, + 92, + 83, + 102, + 85, + 88, + 81, + 85, + 86, + 100, + 78, + 80, + 86, + 94, + 79, + 81, + 90, + 80, + 80, + 85, + 91, + 91, + 78, + 99, + 96, + 95, + 81, + 90, + 83, + 75, + 85, + 77, + 94, + 89, + 93, + 81, + 85, + 81, + 87, + 73 + ], + "converged": [ + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 9.420103127980876e-07, + 9.443358386046589e-07, + 9.869893171389752e-07, + 8.881811235631556e-07, + 8.935885003824715e-07, + 8.06783966601511e-07, + 9.66107360667793e-07, + 9.206584082813553e-07, + 9.235541425546377e-07, + 8.863797073166368e-07, + 9.659628739600168e-07, + 9.89507102603422e-07, + 9.325718557032315e-07, + 9.334601235524233e-07, + 9.871799789081744e-07, + 9.520632156849036e-07, + 8.235549423013128e-07, + 9.277968187161643e-07, + 7.817588286844034e-07, + 9.481684951968831e-07, + 8.928181858108096e-07, + 8.839822502739888e-07, + 9.561208320092303e-07, + 9.115126183496224e-07, + 9.285178981290878e-07, + 8.887388513519178e-07, + 9.110386993159319e-07, + 8.569581566329947e-07, + 9.644907256142968e-07, + 8.963105103186918e-07, + 9.98654801279377e-07, + 9.503171898450298e-07, + 8.077254754071683e-07, + 9.88475682529866e-07, + 9.814095351150571e-07, + 9.414805313931611e-07, + 8.955993024716932e-07, + 9.283024312583779e-07, + 9.376856456829699e-07, + 9.517642613187362e-07, + 9.653393356448106e-07, + 7.94046626455405e-07, + 9.312579590014194e-07, + 9.805549867224121e-07, + 9.905285054184663e-07, + 9.461975927410455e-07, + 9.880081686743762e-07, + 9.250445200796877e-07, + 8.784159532174236e-07, + 9.607216365651979e-07 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 11.266398408000896, + 1.0799909830002434, + 1.1404771319994325, + 0.8083155360000092, + 1.1162045860000944, + 0.9029697530004341, + 1.0014838299994153, + 0.8741218069990282, + 0.9295608140000695, + 1.1286603349999496, + 1.5209370009997656, + 1.4659513679998781, + 1.174101034999694, + 1.1919939590006834, + 1.1193128590002743, + 1.0547176280015265, + 0.9542319329993916, + 0.9645376700009365, + 1.049338128999807, + 1.1568003930005943, + 0.9107490429996687, + 0.9234820159999799, + 1.3861010119999264, + 1.546460139001283, + 1.0544810470000812, + 0.9856299170005514, + 1.0793942550008069, + 0.9491031239995209, + 0.9775794039996981, + 1.0062416809996648, + 1.0910215280000557, + 1.1614854729996296, + 0.9182024040001124, + 1.2398638409995328, + 1.5327354299988656, + 1.5252526730000682, + 0.9147490699997434, + 1.1475918969990744, + 0.9780971919990407, + 0.8570995979989675, + 1.0193682039989653, + 0.9893403410005703, + 1.1014728310001374, + 1.1017323569994915, + 1.1628655460008304, + 1.1941630050005188, + 1.3082031329995516, + 1.3312196470014896, + 1.016658632999679, + 0.8606922020007914 + ], + "output_norm_ratios": [ + 8.133717889478104, + 9.035702367402475, + 7.81785939088375, + 7.608922505090114, + 7.7206761965805395, + 8.91917602287055, + 8.206148218164179, + 8.096500225488636, + 8.000026999076882, + 7.676388553092994, + 8.276544804107772, + 7.25761766449208, + 8.793536624569427, + 8.865216592367572, + 8.148331501380552, + 7.786402515539979, + 9.407287140945002, + 7.4915381097006835, + 8.113976886687306, + 7.841173250783717, + 8.222484421454167, + 8.581058823608933, + 7.91185970035006, + 8.168244768331364, + 8.646053749170347, + 8.681927807392402, + 8.204932688974106, + 7.564243652421484, + 7.549230614711944, + 8.46677565046191, + 8.400572445064682, + 8.344279535499673, + 8.189874358355647, + 8.644481172264104, + 8.447990547854532, + 7.860656568005736, + 9.070771270279806, + 8.202554123469916, + 8.272380262841903, + 8.670726815363398, + 8.728231024497148, + 7.636435257150315, + 7.875686497239267, + 7.761941261773883, + 8.458292013611464, + 7.5382581553529375, + 8.769504037071101, + 7.634480198796965, + 8.808869576024074, + 8.290741328305257 + ] + }, + "advection_16": { + "iterations": [ + 28, + 23, + 27, + 29, + 25, + 43, + 24, + 27, + 27, + 29, + 25, + 25, + 23, + 25, + 26, + 24, + 27, + 26, + 25, + 29, + 34, + 27, + 27, + 22, + 25, + 24, + 24, + 27, + 30, + 26, + 28, + 43, + 26, + 24, + 30, + 29, + 31, + 28, + 26, + 24, + 27, + 36, + 26, + 25, + 25, + 29, + 24, + 28, + 21, + 23 + ], + "converged": [ + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 8.209137795332771e-07, + 8.966605774178087e-07, + 5.10856059410464e-07, + 7.338534918438198e-07, + 5.55900090442776e-07, + 9.090647523372913e-07, + 9.729576057817687e-07, + 9.471864270744134e-07, + 5.73441637099898e-07, + 6.984202733244691e-07, + 8.987961683685174e-07, + 6.607140188973051e-07, + 7.904235583969522e-07, + 9.718398947106435e-07, + 6.347026930051686e-07, + 8.670230195198631e-07, + 8.457796066368497e-07, + 8.540930911841551e-07, + 4.329371394066337e-07, + 7.211251467391805e-07, + 6.868478868474796e-07, + 4.170266562970001e-07, + 5.388194491050055e-07, + 5.510336577037423e-07, + 6.203164383124442e-07, + 9.769221747800683e-07, + 7.654268209186361e-07, + 8.286070207151892e-07, + 9.534499717190796e-07, + 9.324435803961877e-07, + 7.604702300704787e-07, + 9.455465715399794e-07, + 7.940630615120399e-07, + 8.261887378201916e-07, + 6.014324531901955e-07, + 6.897276572194682e-07, + 7.317053679533086e-07, + 3.9572724162575746e-07, + 4.841747310784408e-07, + 9.921290468428513e-07, + 6.461449437426299e-07, + 9.213614605805629e-07, + 6.871327408003604e-07, + 5.309140716136106e-07, + 8.241110445485048e-07, + 8.413832955347685e-07, + 9.212236661607354e-07, + 9.447343831942494e-07, + 4.088605437782224e-07, + 6.463428036487511e-07 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 0.307059692000621, + 0.23902664099841786, + 0.3154306850010471, + 0.36136654499932774, + 0.340769125999941, + 0.49802328599980683, + 0.23059219399874564, + 0.2848370649990102, + 0.31727777699961734, + 0.3319669499996962, + 0.2493062289995578, + 0.28668109600039315, + 0.24449457500122662, + 0.2866484389996913, + 0.4430708660001983, + 0.3452308099986112, + 0.45082015300067724, + 0.3734346999990521, + 0.34657156199864403, + 0.459251704000053, + 0.572841088000132, + 0.2920952729982673, + 0.29060670099897834, + 0.22437286999956996, + 0.26873501999943983, + 0.23112967799897888, + 0.26058980299967516, + 0.3149300860004587, + 0.33573932299987064, + 0.3077577200001542, + 0.3501299180006754, + 0.4708425659991917, + 0.24542780099909578, + 0.29117755299921555, + 0.3435675920009089, + 0.3278357279996271, + 0.3798754649997136, + 0.29773567499978526, + 0.3154866540007788, + 0.2516106779985421, + 0.32176337800046895, + 0.40522806199987826, + 0.30883873800121364, + 0.28321725699970557, + 0.27390575500066916, + 0.30731216899948777, + 0.28427443000146013, + 0.33814358600102423, + 0.2186777209990396, + 0.20981484500043734 + ], + "output_norm_ratios": [ + 8.371119179423625, + 6.946629257167693, + 7.885124596587599, + 8.303270979857682, + 8.511637893052075, + 8.949963951969362, + 6.834397252590822, + 8.38011901046117, + 8.013425359651809, + 8.779443391135052, + 8.92614806235341, + 8.664664217323587, + 6.209827344072311, + 8.265462543288688, + 7.007589091427539, + 7.127130095175546, + 6.735780596146041, + 8.712306353903992, + 8.36984506736134, + 7.4018879717542045, + 9.262480646821746, + 8.151994511248402, + 7.3686664123660055, + 9.129570855422457, + 8.931403521672191, + 6.756166993632592, + 7.735768583842991, + 7.53448727846583, + 7.639361764348934, + 7.701090357229493, + 8.001896518367921, + 7.998173808607803, + 6.809245772102109, + 8.546820301020608, + 7.724815052018713, + 8.162436705052528, + 9.22937973657488, + 6.861611962271894, + 9.642591729822987, + 6.924835321993974, + 7.1791827137225654, + 7.7652189275271395, + 7.9390606407436595, + 7.89345318118662, + 7.532050246188457, + 6.545740460895986, + 7.779737898035044, + 8.074329286100074, + 5.913192275700923, + 8.08957179490844 + ] + }, + "advection_24": { + "iterations": [ + 37, + 30, + 33, + 38, + 35, + 38, + 34, + 45, + 39, + 41, + 38, + 39, + 40, + 44, + 37, + 37, + 41, + 33, + 47, + 39, + 44, + 32, + 37, + 53, + 42, + 34, + 38, + 38, + 52, + 37, + 36, + 34, + 42, + 43, + 39, + 43, + 46, + 37, + 39, + 40, + 55, + 37, + 35, + 39, + 34, + 38, + 48, + 52, + 46, + 33 + ], + "converged": [ + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 7.417111361677174e-07, + 9.529016853459473e-07, + 7.134104869109106e-07, + 9.755319593077775e-07, + 9.8819325795298e-07, + 7.389758280134358e-07, + 9.111763359412488e-07, + 7.150631307452692e-07, + 9.595886750555618e-07, + 8.911301925391056e-07, + 8.967061461827521e-07, + 9.1477134781612e-07, + 8.174825106198177e-07, + 6.014760570298806e-07, + 9.668562788312057e-07, + 9.412570387466085e-07, + 8.312426094476706e-07, + 7.21673889802443e-07, + 7.112991774136147e-07, + 9.687905455270036e-07, + 8.083926678958825e-07, + 9.220740559367254e-07, + 9.796601848510656e-07, + 7.725356501332549e-07, + 7.623626459707957e-07, + 8.675066291481939e-07, + 6.252617665574213e-07, + 8.028931247157776e-07, + 9.298944285773959e-07, + 9.78821057754167e-07, + 6.119050925627636e-07, + 7.649672653234e-07, + 7.596545747103386e-07, + 9.349071340549753e-07, + 9.29047528577179e-07, + 6.7372342188447e-07, + 9.929585977217264e-07, + 9.144419469582146e-07, + 8.721592851226954e-07, + 9.163555488506327e-07, + 7.744225154191729e-07, + 9.452891301722594e-07, + 9.796382769294154e-07, + 7.850523321109124e-07, + 8.435036647499941e-07, + 8.710489807342896e-07, + 9.919920967138776e-07, + 7.737388263685258e-07, + 6.856444107865329e-07, + 9.063699105196561e-07 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 0.624685975999455, + 0.48293383100099163, + 0.5184124930001417, + 0.5023298680007429, + 0.5924937199997657, + 0.559270687001117, + 0.407556176000071, + 0.4611524539996026, + 0.41784869200091634, + 0.4308129620003456, + 0.407053556999017, + 0.4605381560013484, + 0.4645228820008924, + 0.49936342099863396, + 0.3603055419989687, + 0.42230242699952214, + 0.43380954100030067, + 0.42118057100014994, + 0.5158209929995792, + 0.43012253300003067, + 0.5007864109993534, + 0.3550304750006035, + 0.3925038119996316, + 0.5528438519995689, + 0.4490613319994736, + 0.38126247499894816, + 0.4016013370001019, + 0.37803183699907095, + 0.7809399299985671, + 0.5564169180015597, + 0.5324467890004598, + 0.5321448739996413, + 0.688362839000547, + 0.5294865710002341, + 0.3984949059995415, + 0.45831744899987825, + 0.44929982000030577, + 0.38945199199952185, + 0.4318183470004442, + 0.4405307519991766, + 0.6326208190002944, + 0.3943906149997929, + 0.4056142169993109, + 0.389126705000308, + 0.360591991999172, + 0.4238891960012552, + 0.5238519100003032, + 0.5945554789996095, + 0.499124877000213, + 0.39513854200049536 + ], + "output_norm_ratios": [ + 8.183134028897676, + 8.183939269111804, + 7.878341182641557, + 7.538675496470951, + 7.720998739243571, + 8.603236677682396, + 6.967496604033974, + 7.175155170440808, + 8.280890582548702, + 7.892892363525292, + 7.058951324157451, + 7.852777471800192, + 9.641062137390227, + 8.497831616077317, + 8.588238096441243, + 8.155477660535093, + 8.00234189393684, + 9.338498784315929, + 7.666876360044533, + 8.490259164143588, + 7.519332619287925, + 7.27122634633337, + 8.316158561629221, + 7.009652933430287, + 8.176764416731823, + 8.806026525685239, + 6.790890274680447, + 7.664232184020679, + 8.113523902029671, + 6.942973383702545, + 7.585673929187829, + 7.047058722289676, + 7.968768929889181, + 8.948070160779736, + 6.863820306377424, + 6.500276533733255, + 7.657681576896421, + 7.484683941156105, + 7.396673792375177, + 9.452023734902973, + 7.499294950369759, + 6.8001038430712475, + 8.177225974586133, + 7.340529288173346, + 8.197243074413716, + 8.041366688546063, + 8.433021627421974, + 7.71824942054348, + 7.370974558581988, + 7.38257587962999 + ] + }, + "advection_32": { + "iterations": [ + 52, + 53, + 45, + 54, + 49, + 49, + 49, + 47, + 59, + 53, + 52, + 49, + 48, + 52, + 49, + 67, + 51, + 53, + 46, + 46, + 46, + 52, + 50, + 48, + 44, + 48, + 45, + 52, + 45, + 47, + 57, + 47, + 46, + 44, + 46, + 52, + 57, + 59, + 47, + 62, + 47, + 48, + 48, + 58, + 50, + 44, + 45, + 50, + 47, + 40 + ], + "converged": [ + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 8.07285876681705e-07, + 8.379449152544989e-07, + 8.963916253425877e-07, + 9.788036893074024e-07, + 8.705050244945675e-07, + 9.30189886048446e-07, + 9.6384934734452e-07, + 9.649587267856098e-07, + 8.803212389853708e-07, + 9.508186778021147e-07, + 7.658689005119123e-07, + 8.31594559592082e-07, + 9.363427878108133e-07, + 6.478028735390954e-07, + 9.490682810333809e-07, + 8.58637256634666e-07, + 9.324727824488278e-07, + 9.106629961709185e-07, + 6.185247908154397e-07, + 8.441439225257215e-07, + 8.100536402614575e-07, + 9.60168343705393e-07, + 7.562268452365824e-07, + 9.489982508162567e-07, + 8.680915612354629e-07, + 8.454639875262449e-07, + 8.287483625485842e-07, + 9.269848370943161e-07, + 7.475660546541343e-07, + 7.378639210107403e-07, + 8.816620254987269e-07, + 8.498280955468438e-07, + 9.934446116946263e-07, + 8.540725416683631e-07, + 8.515472661528859e-07, + 8.268701458218866e-07, + 9.211319603835548e-07, + 9.584567090891307e-07, + 8.063697914213188e-07, + 7.312976983515057e-07, + 8.58637817028662e-07, + 8.147130411587419e-07, + 8.199782275911408e-07, + 7.927187369870592e-07, + 8.059596559240715e-07, + 7.149835763242553e-07, + 7.363942238618642e-07, + 7.31971292534327e-07, + 9.872239142245194e-07, + 8.747517392124124e-07 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 0.6121442959993146, + 0.5494854930002475, + 0.5101094159999775, + 0.6051153289990907, + 0.5450238450011966, + 0.5385605369992845, + 0.546863099998518, + 0.5212835500005895, + 0.6710273410008085, + 0.6007785169986164, + 0.5907490230001713, + 0.5565987709996989, + 0.5343500649996713, + 0.5924391909993574, + 0.5242864120009472, + 0.790878887000872, + 0.7313934569992853, + 0.7861245430012787, + 0.664213602000018, + 0.764319735000754, + 0.6295079669998813, + 0.6234630409999227, + 0.5836314179996407, + 0.501803077000659, + 0.5193933169994125, + 0.5494862169998669, + 0.5245277100002568, + 0.5645943370000168, + 0.49862227300036466, + 0.47444888500103843, + 0.7195168990001548, + 0.5184622540000419, + 0.5642862170006993, + 0.4901721810001618, + 0.5393236429990793, + 0.5973822399992059, + 0.6918997049997415, + 0.7660086150008283, + 0.7555387330012309, + 0.9658711579995725, + 0.7073208689998864, + 0.7238579339991702, + 0.558372841000164, + 0.6794554779989994, + 0.5735753720000503, + 0.4814214190009807, + 0.4817014009986451, + 0.5552189099998941, + 0.5109520349997183, + 0.4813908150008501 + ], + "output_norm_ratios": [ + 9.332133811318617, + 6.99198196958363, + 7.372042893166562, + 8.044427933459247, + 8.011406464558892, + 7.237053616719136, + 9.756577943126041, + 8.625215126301077, + 7.192773134647456, + 7.825848739477168, + 8.9818851961533, + 7.583732055684504, + 7.648912298794809, + 7.455359054016909, + 8.162481038735903, + 7.737905897173867, + 8.59342967500667, + 8.861631635694366, + 7.845864338739332, + 9.173438251778343, + 7.786790304769701, + 7.896319914918162, + 8.85361442261026, + 8.21174225524205, + 7.136505836715267, + 8.782263763944446, + 7.367729674447218, + 8.58971539013705, + 8.264497515449783, + 8.174574632253366, + 7.016318107563065, + 8.649967459120607, + 7.194506033646411, + 8.12963450932536, + 7.459497107399977, + 8.578362758438198, + 7.620238988626294, + 7.512886990821356, + 8.453661508612225, + 6.364144465578843, + 8.594425346375864, + 7.903375295186404, + 7.84350204786208, + 7.347524073796943, + 9.572678391340508, + 8.538635095771498, + 10.322928523361542, + 7.624348918265459, + 7.951565338000234, + 7.39392005876858 + ] + }, + "advection_48": { + "iterations": [ + 63, + 65, + 67, + 69, + 58, + 85, + 71, + 71, + 72, + 60, + 60, + 69, + 74, + 69, + 57, + 57, + 63, + 67, + 57, + 75, + 59, + 67, + 68, + 67, + 75, + 63, + 68, + 72, + 63, + 62, + 68, + 64, + 69, + 70, + 64, + 69, + 73, + 67, + 60, + 71, + 72, + 76, + 69, + 59, + 67, + 73, + 71, + 67, + 73, + 61 + ], + "converged": [ + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 9.598834957035537e-07, + 9.581123425153976e-07, + 9.643099476292722e-07, + 9.77205865848119e-07, + 9.548600358298908e-07, + 9.27811879511572e-07, + 8.738104838103263e-07, + 8.879634809196533e-07, + 9.575755748595397e-07, + 8.17222498497383e-07, + 8.899788575239791e-07, + 7.783655626610147e-07, + 9.213082783851531e-07, + 8.710383548814953e-07, + 8.850525805799863e-07, + 9.00874960240122e-07, + 9.836033492309526e-07, + 9.04840909457976e-07, + 9.240601327599201e-07, + 8.879899777079297e-07, + 8.503485311376341e-07, + 9.6361226985433e-07, + 8.941788595515788e-07, + 8.253898110455e-07, + 8.910320405363962e-07, + 8.949235634725091e-07, + 7.632949632591078e-07, + 8.899293092744196e-07, + 8.431135688735706e-07, + 9.72355462609186e-07, + 7.651593749422926e-07, + 9.278361133795452e-07, + 8.947085647778785e-07, + 9.52885420212108e-07, + 8.00568863949549e-07, + 9.834542525415836e-07, + 9.938088162622492e-07, + 9.646045067079854e-07, + 8.661495409940132e-07, + 9.979897758608562e-07, + 7.888863810026812e-07, + 8.501651137425746e-07, + 8.546985361735514e-07, + 9.187140002529508e-07, + 8.712128375156279e-07, + 8.192917199441647e-07, + 7.599440620236426e-07, + 9.962401130894499e-07, + 9.045118988750988e-07, + 9.118444174960746e-07 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 0.7409004000001005, + 0.7658876120003697, + 0.7371184809999249, + 0.8976666100006696, + 0.9759222220000083, + 1.3142297049998888, + 0.9586331640002754, + 0.819525775999864, + 0.8401348690003942, + 0.7000397350002459, + 0.6934600360000331, + 0.8552625660013291, + 0.8476645050013758, + 0.7989154089991644, + 0.6414768339982402, + 0.7171796830007224, + 0.7401515339988691, + 0.7670440319998306, + 0.6769937360004405, + 1.086654507998901, + 0.9865944360008143, + 1.160756629999014, + 0.9102005789991381, + 0.8140770069985592, + 0.8779065010003251, + 0.7320067990003736, + 0.752156484999432, + 0.8336527869996644, + 0.7854959399992367, + 0.7169811940002546, + 0.7607421310003701, + 0.7622661079985846, + 0.7967611509993731, + 0.7989949349994276, + 0.8145036100013385, + 1.1103635620002024, + 1.1194268650015147, + 1.0194382600002427, + 0.7135033879985713, + 0.8256951370003662, + 0.7602571079987683, + 0.8522614180001256, + 0.7555082460003177, + 0.6969129119988793, + 0.7419132019986137, + 0.8595099399990431, + 0.7893445970003086, + 0.7894769310005358, + 0.7657531949989789, + 0.7637309640012973 + ], + "output_norm_ratios": [ + 8.603693129846638, + 8.491312638093662, + 7.015031251153246, + 7.666948446043134, + 8.001380844457591, + 7.667898562812476, + 8.355940678395603, + 9.350122426067644, + 7.944390733591999, + 8.891670374298231, + 8.32021522634555, + 8.001132357414457, + 7.989088816028153, + 7.80843907709903, + 7.85569651537126, + 8.15587137551559, + 8.336611882852862, + 8.36992064871239, + 8.948805570467178, + 9.181541426711105, + 7.605424220493552, + 8.171212398321167, + 8.7024828324327, + 7.198786298873777, + 8.369967544712356, + 8.105120947256324, + 7.614022467906599, + 7.66375528773382, + 7.638927344099625, + 9.334856400613393, + 7.510583560255587, + 7.112773997542684, + 8.973817089603102, + 8.74340390939863, + 8.517000111463386, + 8.178988368841532, + 8.636216853994345, + 8.223391351210665, + 8.471835469427358, + 8.157684110776314, + 9.55887546309135, + 8.099203958761196, + 8.447931578920368, + 8.240656091631465, + 7.928245649399869, + 8.839288780584774, + 8.108721816692832, + 7.936691913181307, + 7.150649100381126, + 7.7153889779877245 + ] + }, + "advection_64": { + "iterations": [ + 87, + 76, + 83, + 82, + 83, + 79, + 88, + 99, + 94, + 78, + 85, + 104, + 89, + 83, + 86, + 90, + 84, + 84, + 96, + 76, + 93, + 81, + 82, + 98, + 96, + 85, + 77, + 87, + 91, + 82, + 86, + 82, + 85, + 88, + 101, + 87, + 98, + 85, + 80, + 78, + 85, + 88, + 78, + 73, + 105, + 99, + 80, + 106, + 78, + 89 + ], + "converged": [ + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true, + true + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 8.338534788067019e-07, + 8.882099397226568e-07, + 8.928777750579987e-07, + 8.855595196097267e-07, + 8.194799719651135e-07, + 9.731233590815112e-07, + 8.757255530536275e-07, + 9.617022514898074e-07, + 9.92685382363648e-07, + 9.80172148515342e-07, + 9.610117758800986e-07, + 8.831430051240232e-07, + 9.230486671679922e-07, + 9.459028967738809e-07, + 8.646761945375275e-07, + 8.27223412323708e-07, + 9.389040290188847e-07, + 9.588501470398632e-07, + 9.309304515610558e-07, + 8.951939855994418e-07, + 9.637280186001893e-07, + 9.674310605071062e-07, + 9.73910385349332e-07, + 9.330710392283193e-07, + 9.61895394623328e-07, + 9.427751719280633e-07, + 7.115948974375522e-07, + 8.786372753423518e-07, + 9.760931871630683e-07, + 9.666922764116037e-07, + 9.226194301061077e-07, + 8.8677324579447e-07, + 9.050022296567586e-07, + 9.65726756901237e-07, + 9.792953857725343e-07, + 9.578450615551874e-07, + 9.648731449755753e-07, + 9.488795432465361e-07, + 9.479144916608788e-07, + 9.245521266272371e-07, + 9.439169585342321e-07, + 9.569380822697264e-07, + 9.739260804361574e-07, + 8.566626649759106e-07, + 9.593896053403683e-07, + 8.754224255075543e-07, + 9.963012686561802e-07, + 9.272838491025286e-07, + 9.566354544943764e-07, + 9.82561063421679e-07 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 1.439033456999823, + 0.9142595880002773, + 0.986663484998644, + 1.0148136579991842, + 0.9539716220006085, + 0.869521763001103, + 1.0786624809989007, + 1.1648403439994581, + 1.0847679350008548, + 0.8969969760000822, + 1.164413501999661, + 1.653461146999689, + 1.4492621549998148, + 0.996740148999379, + 1.0128296180009784, + 1.0997751190006966, + 0.9937486689996149, + 1.0051693999994313, + 1.1497595259988884, + 0.8640189779998764, + 1.1925545440008136, + 0.9194877360005194, + 1.2569837119990552, + 1.5472673700005544, + 1.3820292860000336, + 1.0680361230006383, + 0.9459278979993542, + 1.0354734119991917, + 1.1059767170008854, + 0.9766906549994019, + 1.0011418020003475, + 0.9743181690009806, + 0.9725852899991878, + 1.1086746319997474, + 1.6415655979999428, + 1.4319227340001817, + 1.2162286490001861, + 1.0202826759996242, + 0.9709722790012165, + 0.9356643219998659, + 1.0438188429998263, + 1.0662218170000415, + 0.8976614969997172, + 0.8709886480010027, + 1.235365210000964, + 1.3279857309989893, + 1.216980440000043, + 1.7095823260006, + 0.9070850329990208, + 1.075118577999092 + ], + "output_norm_ratios": [ + 8.184201294561422, + 7.856078578950806, + 8.092588826023466, + 7.9226082912091496, + 9.053168596386554, + 8.619870438108443, + 8.151892277188798, + 8.566504519277958, + 8.860987648373904, + 7.870158429766467, + 8.676749455524211, + 7.9649058325862585, + 8.36181917418973, + 8.278392758077324, + 7.842537263043251, + 7.633956433749472, + 8.074545094802566, + 7.148686313270542, + 7.427229088249381, + 7.034559923901905, + 7.7129723976789, + 8.346411600804354, + 7.824378619863936, + 7.415485479016408, + 8.692541481131258, + 7.4112108331764865, + 7.147229192208304, + 7.787777498748814, + 7.713592447956435, + 7.487476958059152, + 9.046967484418879, + 7.912815031126087, + 7.626467739344252, + 8.364116732144398, + 8.490384555655371, + 7.79194651464591, + 8.210364733935302, + 7.62943298887058, + 8.545197337821419, + 8.607496130527675, + 8.1835496239308, + 7.89161593415199, + 7.6515574870633, + 7.639020641339293, + 8.920084019790192, + 8.425586093793488, + 8.50655962484384, + 8.388544058149934, + 8.323848749172909, + 8.727808684444494 + ] + }, + "graph_laplacian_16": { + "iterations": [ + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300 + ], + "converged": [ + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 0.8262291666401447, + 0.8206507151220693, + 0.8732283540000502, + 0.8334660571325075, + 0.8313201137331161, + 0.8429230720716847, + 0.8560932284134944, + 0.8545959752430475, + 0.862030239387834, + 0.46961229144739525, + 0.7787374768369247, + 0.7162452481473304, + 0.8714919963548051, + 0.8536357365423548, + 0.6505922866210423, + 0.8521820809237735, + 0.5915609419300504, + 0.8825812297632502, + 0.8343620716998763, + 0.845184897953552, + 0.8286467488808538, + 0.8671323079133865, + 0.8536107870816518, + 0.7199652239988898, + 0.8375488756870714, + 0.8691638492206961, + 0.869642418461107, + 0.8464796977225224, + 0.8847294539492307, + 0.8151453256391108, + 0.8361383793012327, + 0.8787408212294179, + 0.8263396595656894, + 0.6800233355109496, + 0.7985439634057284, + 0.7669182140386916, + 0.7095542150908448, + 0.8435284330707862, + 0.8662919418547795, + 0.8057997870893161, + 0.7641637337012037, + 0.816674766743325, + 0.8090492242411204, + 0.8605760650234544, + 0.8039928763459917, + 0.8307506538955037, + 0.8740377662542061, + 0.45301032893752535, + 0.8315689238332306, + 0.7499820986641058 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 3.742240469000535, + 4.044952993999686, + 3.3891062029997556, + 3.5252011729990045, + 4.477192413998637, + 3.416733354000826, + 3.5633743190010136, + 3.856891807001375, + 4.020276625000406, + 3.387407741000061, + 3.341579682999509, + 4.379804173999219, + 3.399037335000685, + 3.5136813250010164, + 3.578153401000236, + 4.086996246000126, + 3.447234561001096, + 3.524092689000099, + 4.52292384699831, + 3.4705408070003614, + 3.5500834080012282, + 3.6904131600003893, + 4.132574383000247, + 3.361012727000343, + 3.481451002999165, + 4.3714174680008, + 3.463663752001594, + 3.4784025419994578, + 3.4300062989987055, + 4.399978638000903, + 3.3832954350000364, + 3.483585736999885, + 4.17062007200002, + 3.7579364770008397, + 3.5025876500003505, + 3.420707080998909, + 4.28334049499972, + 3.4955449379995116, + 3.553454633000001, + 4.164366172000882, + 3.6949958539989893, + 3.570936164000159, + 3.5250387370015233, + 4.498203184000886, + 3.490837813998951, + 3.3276514550016145, + 3.996892477000074, + 3.8245496840008855, + 3.4662806280011864, + 3.490452838999772 + ], + "output_norm_ratios": [ + 19962.70848004259, + 111389.57748677145, + 697985.8993454463, + 132773.42446759896, + 14615.806939213804, + 3766.061430259993, + 50418.33838159134, + 57352.32200955697, + 7239.6864140500775, + 466.24896410876937, + 51247.426986552404, + 1805.397526218119, + 53063.76420358964, + 63809.75311951521, + 688.4381328756408, + 14860.865812564452, + 445.11700836644104, + 201955.6605345851, + 50680.07016925606, + 5542.976926621087, + 22158.340291488363, + 16679.79344043201, + 42888.58919726521, + 2302.6151889255175, + 55370.85162108213, + 134955.90643534207, + 19318.72133846948, + 127738.27020228723, + 460244.5619668195, + 1005070.5872566879, + 12584.934809642999, + 39405.724920040535, + 9976.241824546507, + 2486.0779178092503, + 149811.9506009843, + 16171.425264823985, + 771.3703914860115, + 32537.547243376313, + 81580.99408255723, + 3714.690136734329, + 1325.8730441228968, + 86974.46693236724, + 24450.435333647027, + 7377.745926561056, + 2478.827863193159, + 156517.56573839433, + 81623.17700296693, + 436.2286188807557, + 640796.7667225314, + 8192.207648195434 + ] + }, + "graph_laplacian_24": { + "iterations": [ + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300 + ], + "converged": [ + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 0.9404482277727658, + 0.9402649935975466, + 0.938419499380448, + 0.9331305954417761, + 0.8997906370684784, + 0.9288649421231099, + 0.8836314693802476, + 0.9399360884801848, + 0.9127291087340386, + 0.9506577631087091, + 0.9093151320754229, + 0.9229767887428334, + 0.9365166827765611, + 0.9168252316819532, + 0.9443514624110864, + 0.9388619772494396, + 0.9349878982921586, + 0.9353695128479351, + 0.9439866954652844, + 0.8909894466231941, + 0.9008530139489312, + 0.9429887998296739, + 0.9286273807712512, + 0.9156820285674742, + 0.9228180763354267, + 0.9340655740527892, + 0.9277998358779203, + 0.9473735103498436, + 0.9299936747691075, + 0.9436853238873708, + 0.9507920602281055, + 0.9453706338515271, + 0.9134567424772396, + 0.9407547566004325, + 0.9442471100767658, + 0.9268236764611848, + 0.9377324046926766, + 0.908164584141689, + 0.9366852991251468, + 0.929674812866788, + 0.9160758186138928, + 0.9379077429016224, + 0.9308935566360281, + 0.9360479342988147, + 0.9366659504392669, + 0.9319791985093955, + 0.9322952541251363, + 0.9386105881423313, + 0.9396043218667033, + 0.9179748010969452 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 3.560922323000341, + 3.7479037920002156, + 4.16210807599964, + 3.5166085680011747, + 3.570591780999166, + 4.544060961001378, + 3.379419982999025, + 3.3939710920003563, + 3.698987682999359, + 4.123987311000747, + 3.3493999719994463, + 3.3668199670009926, + 4.192553943001258, + 3.713320962999205, + 3.5702253479994397, + 3.5833743709990813, + 4.309656916999302, + 3.442529410000134, + 3.536633575999076, + 4.451843920000101, + 3.50547201000154, + 3.4739964950003923, + 3.774130542000421, + 4.185071019999668, + 3.5907168579997233, + 3.436808709999241, + 4.294496227001218, + 3.5958834729990485, + 3.4697919200007163, + 3.589562859999205, + 4.193667344999994, + 3.5254132699992624, + 3.523361166000541, + 4.405236185999456, + 3.496845867000957, + 3.472816823999892, + 3.6010555400007433, + 4.222548639998422, + 3.552289495999503, + 3.424177079999936, + 4.296100581001156, + 3.7146078850000777, + 3.4436211960000946, + 3.490777168000932, + 4.38186637400031, + 3.467118364000271, + 3.4899503060005372, + 4.361091729000691, + 3.827693609999187, + 3.397815140999228 + ], + "output_norm_ratios": [ + 1146341.2438715396, + 5888817.193053946, + 16796348.75372004, + 321058.83375878504, + 8282.896966377675, + 7614001.088013251, + 25275.929424568985, + 1998679.5366614305, + 59653.81155331227, + 2770133.991419863, + 16910.849420306153, + 136886.0203352243, + 2068311.8976261746, + 637925.085425562, + 130954.97797723021, + 3169029.1187889855, + 126147.01018457861, + 1910719.52008136, + 36677.497984876834, + 108546.34817767983, + 52414.704197007064, + 671445.3273850936, + 124229.27334374045, + 8266897.8194305925, + 209116.59496287143, + 286806.95874623186, + 559042.3455707447, + 3591680.2213808377, + 1665421.2776503218, + 10248171.998338366, + 111843.42679148808, + 16618776.276273323, + 6094.312564345778, + 683862.532677136, + 769908.203017912, + 33457.80193120655, + 63200.44193517935, + 74241.66082636587, + 2653792.3696138063, + 424928.4727364198, + 69035.27156409608, + 1431296.4042582111, + 3158034.2478914894, + 15678920.30253475, + 381255.73858382617, + 166290.32791602716, + 462776.8714132867, + 733439.5883065826, + 6623449.270634382, + 520037.9585289892 + ] + }, + "graph_laplacian_32": { + "iterations": [ + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300 + ], + "converged": [ + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 0.964193277671006, + 0.9667442303986363, + 0.9655005752906497, + 0.9607271282789601, + 0.9568060208800181, + 0.9558355529251782, + 0.9696752155552226, + 0.9551445485736709, + 0.9738900840677519, + 0.972071270122734, + 0.9747269613560623, + 0.9656982658985727, + 0.969326528073808, + 0.964299254646063, + 0.9680070036092648, + 0.9591396126624596, + 0.9611295600233699, + 0.9542495856067013, + 0.9733018244819602, + 0.9620705418702495, + 0.9727711602543164, + 0.9623011943273463, + 0.9552851116289546, + 0.9661763299440795, + 0.9774726022769186, + 0.9607102815593722, + 0.9564470565401869, + 0.9731383220614748, + 0.9734929499922574, + 0.9619569827830599, + 0.9708760970459017, + 0.970485344055501, + 0.9567757400671407, + 0.9681772841666542, + 0.9672908127009873, + 0.9654788135675161, + 0.9718603060503038, + 0.9563216335569554, + 0.9659864088680931, + 0.9718168582978205, + 0.9760278508622804, + 0.967081586295605, + 0.9658471778866148, + 0.951114928965144, + 0.982711531393844, + 0.9742513327261944, + 0.9689172445140412, + 0.966634217944713, + 0.9722591132363018, + 0.9663667828644382 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 3.484235185000216, + 3.5073748309987423, + 3.6985519000008935, + 4.194147917000009, + 3.473912002000361, + 3.5520303009998315, + 4.572326972000155, + 3.358548530000917, + 3.516228409998803, + 3.797462524000366, + 4.068112176999421, + 3.4243111060004594, + 3.5225124080006935, + 4.449600562000342, + 3.521119226999872, + 3.4432427039992035, + 3.79613201400025, + 4.049889789999725, + 3.5125878199996805, + 3.4759380699997564, + 4.597854699000891, + 3.4659408799998346, + 3.4940942319990427, + 3.8854478650009696, + 4.024703641000087, + 3.5432196500005375, + 3.3566263659995457, + 4.513149075000911, + 3.4468258840006456, + 3.6871141329993407, + 3.972183800999119, + 4.119868322000912, + 3.480070075000185, + 3.656171020000329, + 4.39863251099996, + 3.531486774998484, + 3.413215560998651, + 4.078082329000608, + 3.936496344000261, + 3.3815535960002308, + 3.594957945000715, + 4.509761334000359, + 3.523393949999445, + 3.50308226800189, + 4.066631768997468, + 3.8263938800009782, + 3.5394335739983944, + 3.684418609002023, + 4.654973909997352, + 3.603268933999061 + ], + "output_norm_ratios": [ + 316725.59230495756, + 36910427.592546016, + 8128583.232417397, + 7919865.274391657, + 206336073.87551147, + 233175.05986469865, + 2585437.7340133134, + 209699.3843114195, + 23231080.911850583, + 8279068.936671363, + 628233.0204528929, + 4706914.964277609, + 1692987.8302458115, + 355695.99099971226, + 917845.4736323281, + 205022.84444021655, + 460483.2957945241, + 233737.0581184602, + 1678239.380244637, + 1001487.481253596, + 5112152.146566451, + 10151830.971910251, + 27212.441576683697, + 89383.43899865549, + 3369641.8164827833, + 25276.378492032552, + 86808.0630559316, + 5844420.431428089, + 1951602.8070969735, + 593285.2220020386, + 678157.3355470096, + 6386132.9045420205, + 503700.74692064116, + 18901398.123990186, + 11192426.29668754, + 47208606.12995718, + 798516.909803685, + 9762.459545779711, + 3890654.186108653, + 234165.71024332702, + 4373895.541804395, + 1657202.654251327, + 489559.45262971526, + 5051738.648897159, + 1821174.8208846191, + 1310429.279442824, + 6112237.841007594, + 2546330.434716983, + 4994905.491659719, + 1457563.9451554422 + ] + }, + "graph_laplacian_48": { + "iterations": [ + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300 + ], + "converged": [ + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 0.9893291712458977, + 0.9877479145894806, + 0.9840850175134928, + 0.9876281105998729, + 0.9852307823463343, + 0.9861884238649814, + 0.9846044360937777, + 0.9897162105336453, + 0.9865114157440573, + 0.9893379633292476, + 0.9871220271750019, + 0.9833208067644177, + 0.9893306939575319, + 0.983658733584429, + 0.9886229117236083, + 0.9885595078272499, + 0.9909953681876765, + 0.9887378569883194, + 0.9836070757417079, + 0.9882809994755013, + 0.9802750370758336, + 0.9865263685120257, + 0.9871694459107165, + 0.9870467860598106, + 0.9887927408137541, + 0.989232877049316, + 0.9896077463123734, + 0.9874383847013949, + 0.9863750260546459, + 0.984216104292883, + 0.9874008089306089, + 0.9854585499086064, + 0.9888031641342149, + 0.9842268040553437, + 0.9911611042213813, + 0.986242124262845, + 0.9866363444998812, + 0.986953624999358, + 0.9890419371327698, + 0.9857183118640027, + 0.9865562874001564, + 0.9865314815252305, + 0.9813992955607348, + 0.987413964057416, + 0.9863800589336658, + 0.9832306707255308, + 0.9859574767671212, + 0.9820875547346704, + 0.9868667579452606, + 0.9851916496786468 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 4.2232483369989495, + 3.4504169690007984, + 3.5622415440011537, + 4.492941765998694, + 3.543569674999162, + 3.7784319029997278, + 4.2034351190013695, + 4.139218559001165, + 3.5503631470019172, + 3.6582650920026936, + 4.4358109409986355, + 3.60828793300243, + 3.6326802689982287, + 4.634792222001124, + 3.738402535000205, + 3.907568128001003, + 4.578880866996769, + 3.7465531950001605, + 3.550538568997581, + 3.844642269999895, + 4.2017310810006165, + 3.6559546110001975, + 3.7203616670012707, + 4.552798837998125, + 3.870830357001978, + 3.783514560000185, + 4.2922106420010095, + 3.832583198996872, + 3.622426263998932, + 3.909681319997617, + 4.2334787209983915, + 3.654363548001129, + 3.7179776249977294, + 4.440892450998945, + 3.820773873998405, + 3.7746025110027404, + 4.437568055000156, + 3.9281555189991195, + 3.3873679030002677, + 3.9371938510012114, + 4.170080389998475, + 3.668295218998537, + 3.5287429050003993, + 4.5940613390012, + 3.5003253770009906, + 3.709996871999465, + 4.075304791000235, + 3.898370389997581, + 3.543918619998294, + 3.463084813000023 + ], + "output_norm_ratios": [ + 2803818.35257887, + 270013.9552109524, + 119292.30123756442, + 77538013.0801808, + 971662.7012360503, + 486337276.34949934, + 121598292.86295958, + 75964451.00118357, + 9791222.165910091, + 22207989.88441179, + 117205250.44499929, + 126491827.08449894, + 8037825.751447192, + 288208176.45919055, + 38239743.04807752, + 496465159.64030105, + 2581738.04522008, + 28113600.467050202, + 6773844.411636968, + 913683.5786226158, + 206666.66162663497, + 132938683.55816524, + 139764324.17152238, + 2609555506.525858, + 610892138.0246795, + 115432654.49445893, + 17799477.93065627, + 60567744.33581147, + 3220220.5828052596, + 63135916.11078888, + 30495386.872541055, + 2582836.2755016545, + 61112225.18481471, + 988039.0657295001, + 102762303.095473, + 52543650.55684358, + 133040425.73862116, + 79828471.28117579, + 124599.07274969127, + 11853323.552400913, + 8425403.974485464, + 77994427.52114469, + 261232.18886285071, + 27612340.233330596, + 20006419.012057494, + 29901663.61459891, + 5355057.1037194235, + 4787808.079456648, + 11313019.420398813, + 856214.6692893034 + ] + }, + "graph_laplacian_64": { + "iterations": [ + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300, + 300 + ], + "converged": [ + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false, + false + ], + "final_residuals": [ + 0.9956974221358763, + 0.995369783747333, + 0.9921256922269579, + 0.9909976655344613, + 0.993236073755039, + 0.9885478414648013, + 0.9927491824124594, + 0.9921003375468811, + 0.9940278735486957, + 0.9938886748779334, + 0.9942213179380599, + 0.9913909449967521, + 0.9925416645138253, + 0.9904165682445273, + 0.9945606453213524, + 0.9936428964048878, + 0.9941199229306017, + 0.9921479276769232, + 0.9937081593797878, + 0.9905727105932813, + 0.9911566199099662, + 0.993243908507259, + 0.9915037406126104, + 0.9918606250669461, + 0.9914314271287646, + 0.9918909009468115, + 0.9915350078519294, + 0.9937257780097027, + 0.9934612127716791, + 0.9935002057948558, + 0.9927387387756083, + 0.9935614000116244, + 0.99384845236994, + 0.9922350219619364, + 0.9939948157079235, + 0.991890176478963, + 0.9941913025317074, + 0.9923515630163144, + 0.9937921977189276, + 0.9935582250143201, + 0.9927431325604854, + 0.9930315693639569, + 0.9926983740335302, + 0.9932250673180382, + 0.9926198828287253, + 0.9912745844033045, + 0.9889928333130149, + 0.992021555435017, + 0.9941812973247515, + 0.991700276894143 + ], + "solve_times": [ + 4.31699762000062, + 4.68606901000021, + 4.113326628001232, + 4.1842799939986435, + 4.785319439997693, + 3.9701426869978604, + 3.710536320999381, + 4.38498239099863, + 4.367912883997633, + 4.126826792999054, + 4.810511980998854, + 4.590189742997609, + 3.728889050998987, + 4.743137620997004, + 3.9150496749971353, + 4.215349403999426, + 4.046378314997128, + 4.111513699997886, + 3.8512844900033087, + 3.703132808001101, + 4.668768843999715, + 4.143568831001176, + 3.8087049900022976, + 4.555420104003133, + 4.412308828999812, + 3.519726074002392, + 4.998200819001795, + 4.314154337000218, + 4.189938356998027, + 4.644787369998085, + 3.8684601040004054, + 3.872753854997427, + 5.133258211000793, + 3.602614735998941, + 4.138064020000456, + 4.575456518999999, + 4.002042038999207, + 4.019108245996904, + 4.138851314000931, + 4.2005490839983395, + 3.9542365630004497, + 4.673390886000561, + 4.367386035999516, + 3.8267142299991974, + 4.393764989999909, + 4.2396261479989334, + 3.7266600650000328, + 4.316473447997851, + 5.027530593000847, + 4.225959508999949 + ], + "output_norm_ratios": [ + 1896735249.1054246, + 78347709.56485191, + 21541998.6582617, + 802153273.3673224, + 3636065022.297503, + 1005381.6449339583, + 822068666.7760688, + 516963024.98401576, + 98708923.77584048, + 1265275815.3163075, + 766564047.9121832, + 387762405.4735823, + 139275044.22561744, + 434720982.90546507, + 280266.1874327567, + 903958107.9341027, + 23765409.915761583, + 5819602.883100491, + 61949321.8148923, + 5947547.44313457, + 227331177.666331, + 121039318.44536144, + 102710219.68484016, + 660483.028004298, + 3494756115.6719036, + 36280016.36368469, + 757580179.7481656, + 8049783688.039175, + 2801766884.515192, + 1033593862.2982707, + 611073739.7511561, + 39533349.28697906, + 1187588296.0380704, + 1107189.1713396828, + 793461844.5428909, + 1149619425.008414, + 12687265.139901707, + 495839362.5380274, + 4316992.504663147, + 141351628.00336477, + 126368467.62457393, + 2800927091.5131426, + 149415079.91853827, + 102549651.58823025, + 147792781.95395267, + 13292727.287836665, + 1797859.4862175318, + 2583866278.167172, + 944540120.0644624, + 91469111.59458873 + ] + } + } + } + ] + } + ] +} \ No newline at end of file